STAY ✔️ or GO ❌? Assessing Ruben Amorim's Man Utd Squad! | Saturday Social

► Subscribe to Sky Sports Premier League: bit.ly/Subscri...
► Watch Sky Sports: bit.ly/BuySkyS...
Smithy and Joe are joined by Spencer Owen and Mina Ibrahim this week on Saturday Social. With Ruben Amorim’s arrival at Manchester United imminent, we’ve tasked our guests with deciding which players should be retained by the new manager.
#football #SaturdaySocial #SkySports #PremierLeague #ManUtd
► Premier League highlights: bit.ly/PLHighl...
► MNF, FNF, SNF & Super Sunday analysis: bit.ly/SkyMatc...
► Gary Neville podcast: bit.ly/GaryNev...
► Saturday Social: bit.ly/SkySatu...
► Buy this season’s shirts: bit.ly/SkySpor...
More from Sky Sports on KZbin:
► Sky Sports: bit.ly/SkySport...
► Sky Sports Boxing: bit.ly/SSBoxingSub
► Sky Sports Cricket: bit.ly/Subscrib...
► Sky Sports Darts: bit.ly/SubSkyS...
► Sky Sports Football: bit.ly/SSFootba...
► Sky Sports F1: bit.ly/Subscrib...
► Sky Sports Golf: bit.ly/Subscri...
► Sky Sports News: bit.ly/SkySport...
► Sky Sports Retro: bit.ly/SkySport...
► Facebook: / skysportsfootball
► Instagram: / skysportsfootball
► TikTok: / skysportsfootball
► X: x.com/SkySportsPL
► Website: www.skysports.com
► To enquire about licensing Sky Sports content, you can find out more here: www.skysports....

[@kiriakoz]

I don't know Mina, but she had decent logical reasons for her decisions, which puts her ahead of about 80 - 90% of guests on here.

[@omarabdullah5928]

Hahaha so true

[@lexxihd5843]

Shes also pretty good to listen to. I didnt get bored at all.

[@adamgrimsley2900]

She thinks the transfers were thinking about having Amorim, crazy

[@jaygotgame1731]

@@adamgrimsley2900ehh to a degree that’s what the structure was put in place for, at least for the most part. It's not that the signings were for Amorim, but for any manager that was supposed to come in and replace ETH. They want to build a philosophy and an identity, which is seeming to be possession based football, or artificial transitions through the use of possession. The profiles of the signings they made were supposed to be an indication of that so she's not entirely wrong. They're trying to find managers that fit a philosophy so they don't have to make 7 first team signings for the manager to be able to "implement their style" like a structured club would.

[@adamgrimsley2900]

@@jaygotgame1731 babble

[@MinaFootball]

Thanks for having me guys. Had a great time with this discussion 👊🏾

[@natwillz333]

Go on, Mina! You smashed it 👊🏼 Big respect for your football insight since seeing you on United View. Keep it moving! ❤🤍🖤

[@ackee1200]

Great stuff today Mina. You really killed it with your takes. Well done 🎉

[@botondbolgar7449]

I wish they had more such smart and intelligent guests like you or Nieve, who actually know football and know what they’re talking about. Looking forward for your next appearance.

[@joshcable3517]

Good speaker, well thought out arguments, great guest!

[@Ian-pi3nd]

We're you got wrong is rashford and Bruno the rest your correct

[@jonnyhawkins7744]

Fair play Mina, havent heard of you before, but your reasons were wise and you speak very well. Invite her back SkySports!!

[@JimmySands-pd7xt]

Simp

[@enesazemi420]

Please don’t

[@elschnorro1742]

@@enesazemi420 Why?

[@dankdracula6089]

​@@JimmySands-pd7xtcant even appreciate a speaker nowadays

[@archstanton6102]

​@@JimmySands-pd7xt can't someone just appreciate another's point of view?

[@samgasson168]

I came to watch SoccerSocial and stayed for Mina. She maintained my interest in a topic that may have bored me. Keep her!! I want to hear more of her takes.

[@TK-nj8xv]

Mina is what Rory thinks he is, actually has knowledge.

[@ps-ph7eb]

She’s saying simple stuff anyone who actually supports United would know.😂

[@48hoursfootball]

@@ps-ph7eb Sometimes its about how its said not what is said. She speaks with belief in whats shes saying. Not just flip flopping on opinions.

[@jackjohnson217]

I love to see the objective support for Mina on this video, being a woman with a headdress talking about football on SkySports not necessarily being the norm, gives me faith in modern football fans. Love to see the different perspectives of all fans, big up Mina for flexing her knowledge and all the people commenting showing encouragement.

[@mefninja]

You brought up her headdress. While everyone was just focused on her football opinions. Grownup. Move on. Stop focusing on how ppl look. It doesnt matter. And i know you werent being negative about it. But shes more than her appearance and her gender. Move on

[@Burgervfx]

For real. So many simps here.

[@Joey2701]

@@mefninja??? Why so negative this was a very positive comment

[@trevorfurusa3102]

@@mefninjaWhy are you triggered? The bloke said nothing wrong

[@mefninja]

@trevorfurusa3102 Not triggered just want to bring ppl back to normality. She's Mina. Not mina with the headdress.

[@kevink01639]

Mina speaks more sense than almost every guy that comes on this show 👏 she was excellent

[@DanielBlom-y4v]

Stop tryna be different, guys like lyes for example have way more ball knowledge

[@onefortheroad1]

How sexist are you!

[@Cee_H]

​@@DanielBlom-y4vnope

[@ytACC19]

She is there to tick the box

[@jme6036]

⁠@@DanielBlom-y4vLyes is part of the “almost” along with JLA and maybe one or two people. Every other guy is an idiot

[@ytki97]

Mina was so well spoken and knowledgeable, she was fantastic 👏

[@ytki97]

Came back to say Spence was also fantastic. Great guests 👏🔥

[@thehallstar4642]

Well spoken? Well spoken street talk maybe

[@slips.]

​@@thehallstar4642rather whatever that means than some posh bum who doesn't go to games

[@banchoviess]

@@thehallstar4642how?

[@danielkonradsson592]

@@thehallstar4642did not hear any street talk? Did you burn hotels with refugees inside them a couple of months ago?

[@joshfrankland3590]

If rashford wasn’t from England he wouldn’t have a chance. I’m sick of people saying rashford is good and needs another chance. He needs to go

[@omarpatterson2474]

Your stupid and can't be a real fan!!! 2 years ago, the world was comparing him to the world best!!! Now a person like you think you can call him out base on talent, he is not performing and that's because fools like you keep making banter out of the player which affected his confidence. He is will make you eat those words though.

[@ErgenJaeger]

Agreed but our wingers suck atm Garnacho Amad Antony isnt gonna get you anywhere nice

[@gregordrizzlewing7339]

Dudes have 7 managers. He’s the problem

[@joshfrankland3590]

@@ErgenJaeger I don’t agree at all sell Antony and rashford. I think garnacho and Amad could really work in this system. Garnacho seems to be our only bright spark this year maybe Onana

[@omarpatterson2474]

@gregordrizzlewing7339 weird all 7 of those managers would tell you how great of a person he is and a hard worker....shut up with your assumption. Just looking to be negative.

[@bobbyharrop8817]

Mina is a great addition to the show, sharing some great insight and reasoning - really good to listen to

[@tomtomtombossa]

Hire Mina permanently. She’s a star and her attention to detail is refreshing.

[@halldd]

Mina, you know your stuff , very impressive 👏

[@StevenWarren-k1c]

That's her job ffs

[@ronniedodge3299]

Mina getting her debut 🔥

[@natwillz333]

Yeees! 👏🏼🔥

[@mikenicky6731]

Knew mina had football knowledge when she was talking about mount and the press he can bring to the team💯 well done

[@farnaghtom]

Really well spoken, done the research and was ready. Mina is a great addition

[@ackee1200]

Mina really smashed it with her knowledgeable takes

[@prazackdylinzki2055]

Mina was great on this 👏

[@santhoshkumarraju2000]

Sky Sports should do a Saturday Social episode with Nieve and Mina at this point.

[@appletvashar7601]

Mina made some good points!

[@MohamedAmin-xi6vy]

Pure football knowledge, realistic view ,well prepared ,well spoken and beautiful lady. Best show in sky sport so far.

[@axyshabp11464]

Not even a united fan but seeing Mina on here talking about football and how well she spoke is incredible to see. Keep the girl power

[@javiismael1480]

Mina has more ball knowledge 👏

[@jacknorman8236]

Mina is one heck of a pundit by the way. Please invite her back! She’s great

[@teonesofle]

can we have more of mina please - so good to listen to someone who knows their team inside & out

[@them8k396]

Usually I fast forward these videos. Thoroughly enjoyed watching Mina’s analysis. Ball knowledge 💯

[@opioericalfred1555]

Rashford must go

[@chrisvalleqatsi]

Mina's a sharp as a tack - give her the clipboard - overall a great analysis & conversation. I'm a longtime Utd supporter who hasn't watched regularly for a while, and this a great way to get back up to speed with the 1st team. Spot-on with the breakdown. There's a solid third of the squad that just isn't doing it, and if EtH got the hook, they need to move on as well.

[@class2ck]

Mina is legit. Well spoken, excellent justification for the choices, and a true fan.

[@philippeh3904]

Mina speaks more facts than any of the clowns they’ve had on to represent Man United over the years 😂

[@maximus8633]

Just bring back Stunt Pegg please. Just her.

[@nelty0987654321]

Mina makes more sense than most guests that come on. Also doesn't just think of what she wants, but how Ruben and his system will be thinking about it

[@nerdimmunity7672]

This women is a proper football nerd you can tell she knows her stuff

[@_MJS_]

She is very good with her analysis, we need to see her more often.

[@francishughes1145]

Rashford first out the door complete waste of space

[@Lee19976]

Clueless

[@francishughes1145]

@Lee19976 I know you are

[@kingsleyotisi5675]

@@Lee19976Rashford is the definition of a consistently inconsistent player 😂😂😂

[@Lee19976]

@@kingsleyotisi5675 yeah because Man Utd been consistently great since Sir Alex left you nakka

[@MrMcfillmore]

Make Mina a regular on this show / SkySports! Great guest. Spoke so clearly with some great points. Really good knowledge

[@jimmycadaan222]

Mina been speaking nothing but facts, finally glad she’s on mainstream platforms.

[@jonprague]

Good analysis, more insight than Sherwood, Merse, Agbonlahor et al have ever provided.

[@robf4157]

She knows her stuff, good guest

[@_MJS_]

She convinced me with every decision with her informative analysis

[@JoshCollet]

Mina and Stuntpegg both setting such a great standard, and really proving why being female inclusive in punditry is a brilliant step forward

[@aramanon]

Mina is bloody smart, great at picking relevant stats. Too good for banter on the sofa shows

[@euandobbie6659]

Mina one of the best guests yet 🔥

[@samuelford]

Mina is the BEST pundit I've seen in ages! So well researched and in her points. Delivery was great. Definitely subscribing to her channel.

[@rjceo5025]

Didn’t know who Mina was before this but she speaks really well and is quite knowledgeable. Great cameo from her

[@arik1511]

Yo this Mina knows much, a real fan.

[@Micléinn]

Rashford would be the first thing I'd get rid of

[@soloyo3374]

please watch another sport how can you get rid of a world class player on there day when a new manager comes in maybe golf would be a good sport for you

[@russmanc]

@@soloyo3374 rashford world class 🤣

[@bigmitchtv3922]

​@@soloyo3374his day is 2 months every three years. Any manager relying on him is just wishing to get sacked!

[@mefninja]

​@soloyo3374 youd be hard pressed to find a manutd supporter who wants rashford to stay.

[@matt27113]

@@soloyo3374 youre a world class egg if you think rashford is world class

[@OsmanDida]

Mina is a breath of fresh air we need to see her in sky sport studio in the weekends before and after games actually not just on Saturday social

[@Amazingnature13928]

Thanks Mina you give important reasons for your decision on the players.

[@joelmathew9637]

YES MINA!!!!!!! LOVE SEEING YOU DO BIG THINGS.....KEEP UP THE GREAT WORK!!!! GGMU

[@faraichando3792]

Wow Mina has that Ball Knowledge 🙌

[@mikenicky6731]

Mina has football knowledge 💯 I like the way you think

[@Mar.wanJaniol]

Definitely one of your top uploads so far!

[@lm-pireltd7863]

This lady acc knows what she’s on about. Very refreshing

[@juddahjames101]

Mina Coming With Knowledge! 👏🏾👏🏾

[@edhannis]

Get Mina on again!

[@Brainiac1209]

Rashford, Shaw, Mount, Casemiro they all must go

[@the_smartest_jimbo5277]

You need to see what happens to Casimiro under Amorim. I am not sure about Rashford he is inconsistent.

[@tkenyon1988]

Mina is an outstanding pundit

[@MrUmpalumpa99]

Can we stop saying Rashford needs another chance. He had his best year under Ten Hag and then his mate sancho got binned off so he decided to walk around the pitch for a season. He’s the biggest embarrassment of a player especially cause he’s manc born. Amorim relies on the whole team working together to press high which Rashford won’t do. Ten hag and radnick tried to do the same but found it impossible to implement their system with these players and I feel Amorim will be the same. He needs to be allowed to sack off players like Rashford shaw and maybe even Bruno if they don’t fit the cohesion of the team

[@embiqioused]

Well done Mina! You were bang on everything you said

[@rehang9890]

Mina talking about amortization of Casemiro's contract/valuation is more insightful than most of the waffle we hear from guests on Saturday Social

[@iantez]

Rashford is overrated and overpaid. He's 27 and you say he still has a future at the club. Too inconsistent. At best he only has one decent season, he's going to be the next lingardinho or dele alli

[@alexandrekambs6818]

Yip this has to be Rashford's last season @ Man U if he doesn't improve please put him out of his misery.

[@ItsBlackNexusGaming]

Mina has gone main stream. Fair play. Always spoke well on united view

[@matthewjohnson4194]

Mina’s ball knowledge is top tier 🔥

[@abymodayil]

This woman is the definition of football analyst. Detailed and to the point..

[@LonghornArmy]

Mina knows ball!! Been saying to start Amad since watching him in Sunderland, he's been outstanding.

[@samiirlopez3050]

BIG UP MINA 🇸🇴❤️❤️❤️ the drip is mad too 🔥👊🏾 Big up girl 4 reppin us 🇸🇴

[@naam697]

Mina first guest ever who’s not just trying to clip farm and just actually being sensible👍

[@SG-mj6kg]

Mina is class. No idea how I have not seen her before. Better than all the "lads". Shows how you have to be twice as good to get the same opportunities.

[@Brexitguyedits]

3:03 ‘shifting an entire shape from a back three to a back three’😭

[@BriannaMoore-h7l]

Every time I see a new video, I'm excited!

[@JayIgnition]

Recently subbed to Mina on YT. She does some great content and speaks sense.

[@gurustv3685]

That lady knows her stuff

[@summan41man]

Not really, average knowledge

[@joelwilson5775]

The way she knows her football it’s so amazing!!

[@giovanni9609]

This list is perfect fair play to mina 👏

[@yellopops]

rashford hunger is gone, he’ll do good for awhile but he won’t last long and then it’ll be a whole cycle again

[@simyk810]

Mina's performance in this episode was so impressive that I watched it multiple times! She definitely deserves her own show!

[@darthmaul408]

Back in 2019, when Ajax were a whisker away from making the champions league final, De Ligt was viewed as THE next big thing at centre back. Every time I watch him he looks composed and he definitely has something. I’m not sure why the moves to Juventus and Bayern Munich didn’t work out, but he’d fit perfectly into a back three.

[@fullygaza8909]

What’s so great about Rashford that he should always stay. He’s been through 6 different managers

[@mefninja]

But lindelof should go 😅

[@panosmoust777]

Good points but the players you kept was almost the starting line up and they have proved that they can't play like man united should play, maybe the manager was to blame because the certain play style he used to play but if man united want to compete for top 3 they have to make some breathtaking change. For example a striker who can actually score and contribute 20 goals per season, a consistent center back who can actually progress the ball, a minimum of one winger and I think if they can't keep down the ego of Bruno they have to find a replacement inthe summer of 2025

[@Quattro_Joe]

Rashford is absolutely shite. Any manager with his head screwed on would launch him out the door. Why would any club give you a big fee for Rashford. And stop comparing him to previous top Man U players he is nowhere near that level.

[@louis.walker11]

We’ve been waiting for de ligt to come good for 5 years

[@ahmedabdikadir8914]

I came because of the topic, I stayed because of MINA.

[@ConorSchiavone]

Soccer AM was cancelled for this 😂😂😂😂😂 wow

[@Luke-kj1rj]

Soccer am was 'propah bantah' type cringe

[@Dermot88886g]

United are huge, everyone's got an opinion

[@finfog4590]

I’m not a fan of this but Soccer AM was getting tired of

[@YA-hm5zy]

​@Dermot88886g it's football get over yourself

[@StayCoolNahSK]

This is better show

[@NotTelling-dv3et]

Mina is the only woman I've ever heard talking sense about men's football

[@firasat13]

Casemiro has got to stay for at least a year. He has won some biggest trophies out there. just for the experience alone and the leadership he brings, someone the younger players can look up to, he has got to stay. dont look at the psr for this one. all other shouts 100% agree with mina

[@greenlionantiques]

I believe Rúben Amorim will give a chance to the entire squad until the end of the season.

[@RaPmanTimur]

Maguire - best def of Man United, btw

[@archervall274]

The fifa playa has come a long way from being Mr Lethal Injection to Mr Sensible on SKY makes me proud to be an early sub.

[@TheRay8588]

Mina belongs on TV 👏🏾

[@JamalBinLaden-om2vo]

Very good agreed with most but I think eriksen, evans and casimero should stay

[@ronakjoshi5198]

Mina talks sense. Those who watch her on UV for example know she knows ball!

[@MeiteiKasubimacha]

100% agree with her

[@mrbcoolkid8623]

She knows BALL!

[@AshIsrael-s4i]

Man U has to really consider getting players from their youth league instead of buying, players they can groom, build up and the new manager can mold them

[@velilentantiso]

Good to see Mina! One of the best female football content creators out there!

[@JayTaylorXI]

Mina spoke super well on this. Good perspectives, didn’t have to be the loudest in the room and didn’t have to say controversial things just to try and make her appearance noteworthy. Great job, hope they have her back on.

[@JL-dd4gd]

The picks have been absolutely spot on. I must say and Idk if this will be a bad shout but I’d turn Zirzkee in to a CF/CAM, I feel like he’s decent at creating chances which he’s definitely a lot better at than scoring. With Sancho coming back next season, I reckon Amorim can make use of his abilities for sure. I say all we need is a proper LB & possibly a CM.

[@topizo4746]

Enjoyed that. Bring her back ASAP

[@christopherbrooks2755]

United need to buy Bastoni to sit in Amorim’s system in the left of the back 3 🔥

[@mandenguemoukoko6646]

Martinez/Shaw can comfortably do that job

[@christopherbrooks2755]

@ yeah probably, I just love watching how Bastoni operates in the hole between Di Marco/strikers at Inter, he’s a top quality operator! Would love to see him in Utds system under Amorim

[@SamueI12]

Why would he downgrade

[@taskforce47gaming-en8bt]

Just because you are British doesn't mean you always have to defend rashford he doesn't need to stay he needs to leave