Star Wars just caught stealing more fan work?

[@mattstorm360]

Star wars? Stealing fan work? I'm shocked.

[@the_cyberchill]

The company whos spokeswoman said they dont have an extenive history like marvel to pull from, then proceeded to copy small aspects of that previously ignored history rather then directly adapt it, and then the company stiffs the original authors on royalties? Shicked I say!

[@akumu9301]

​@@the_cyberchill🎯 LMFAO

[@MonkeyJedi99]

Claude Raines getting a lot of work these days.

[@femmefuntime]

Disney and stealing art go hand in hand

[@Warsie-Fan]

Yep, and for the FORCE AWAKENS they stole the idea from A NEW HOPE.

[@this.is.a.username]

@@Warsie-Fan pft the main character in TFA is a black guy that can't use the force, those movies are nothing alike.

[@Warsie-Fan]

@@this.is.a.username Hmmm,... both have a young adventurer on a desert planet, a mega weapon capable of destroying planets, and a droid that is carrying secret information. Oh your right, there nothing alike. 🤪

[@grimassassin9722]

@@this.is.a.usernamewe’re talking about the story dumbass. It’s essentially the exact same story as A new hope. With a couple changes which is pathetic. How do u not know this? It’s very widely known that the sequels are meant to be a copy of the og trilogy for nostalgia. No one is expecting them to use the exact same characters which would make it even more clear that it was

[@IrishDroid]

Yeah was just thinking Disney, not Star Wars haha.

[@Grayald]

Can't do their own art. Can't create a decent story. And they had the audacity to complain that they didn't have enough existing content to draw from. If only there was a massive, well established pool of existing content that they could have drawn from. Like... Something that expanded. On the universe. But I'm sure there's nothing like that.

[@tatotaytoman5934]

No no, they want to make their own story but not have to make it, OBVIOUSLY 😱😱😱

[@shadowslayer205]

Remember guys, they said they don't need source material!

[@G-Cole-01]

they cut out and fired everyone capable of doing competent work because those people knew how much their work was worth and the the Shareholders First model didn't like that

[@overlordmgcover2262]

Evil can not create.

[@Zygomatic_Bolt]

​@@overlordmgcover2262 it destroys or perverts

[@jamessquirrell1994]

Dam can Star Wars not do this for five minutes like seriously at this point just higher the fan artists

[@BigGuy-o9h]

*damn

[@STRAKAZulu]

*hire

[@Andi_G98]

Hire*

[@nicholasmerritt6376]

, .

[@jamessquirrell1994]

@@STRAKAZulu sorry I’m dyslexic

[@corntrooper8881]

You know you made it if Disney is stealing your fanart

[@tgiacin435]

Right lol. Though did these make it to official released?

[@JohnBachofer]

This isn't the first time they've stolen FractalSponge's work. I've seen a lot of games use his original ISD model.

[@nathanbeverley247]

Oh yeah, they steal his stuff ALL the time.

[@JohnBachofer]

@@nathanbeverley247 I feel like I recall at one point he started charging an insane premium for his models because of this. If that's true I can't say I blame him. I would too if I were in his boots.

[@IncredibleFolk1138]

Funny that they can steal art but refuse to steal decent stories.

[@Hello-bi1pm]

Fan artists aren't contractually obligated to get paid like authors

[@stubbornspaceman7201]

It’s because those stories are actually trying to tell good stories and not pander to the audience.

[@RizzenMurray]

​@@stubbornspaceman7201 Good stories should both relate to us and make us uncomfortable. Mainstream storytelling struggles to do both within the same narrative.

[@stubbornspaceman7201]

@@RizzenMurray I don’t think you understood what I meant when I said “pander to the audience”, but yeah agreed.

[@guybrushthreepwood362]

Honestly this is the thing that star wars does that actually angers me. I do not expect every piece of media from a long running franchise to be great (variance in quality is inevitable) or targeted at me specifically (there are other demos that might like something I do not) but theft from the fans is utterly unacceptable. If Disney likes a bit of fan work enough to use it PAY FOR IT and CREDIT THEM

[@masterdude9419]

Love the video, and LOVE the new Outro!!! I really wish they would just hire the artists that make these things instead of literally stealing art! Hell, at least ASK to do it for free, a lot of artists would do it for their name to be in the Credits of stuff! I hope that someone at Disney sees this happening, and actually cares.

[@DSlyde]

If I had a nickel for every time Disney stole fan art, I'd have enough to start paying the artists like they should have.

[@peachpanzer519]

@@DSlyde if I had a nickel for Everytime people cry about stuff ,I'd be a billionaire

[@alopeksintx2959]

Last time I was this early, Empire Strikes Back wasn't in theaters yet!

[@slothfulcobra]

I don't think anybody working on the movie knew what the movie was going to be at any stage of development. The sequel movies had extremely bad coordination and planning, even moreso towards the end

[@hogfry]

The director they hired wanted to make a mess on purpose he basically wants to make the most decisive movie he possibly can. It's his career goal. Then the _geniuses_ at Disney were like "bet! Here's the most iconic IP ever, rek it's shit bro"

[@karlthorsten9118]

If I created an original Star Wars character for RP in a Star Wars MMO, or Star Wars DnD, Disney instantly owns the character, 100% I didn't create the character, Disney did. That is how they think. Of course, it does belong to Disney, they own it all. BUT, the DESIGNER owns the design right, the concept. Disney can use it any way they want, but the designer owns the CREDIT of creation in itself. Disney didn't design it, the fan did. Credit for the design itself belongs to the designer alone. But Disney doesn't agree with this, and never will. If I create a cousin of Mickey Mouse, I will not get credit. Disney would sue me into a coffin just to to have sole credit. They do not believe in sharing anything in any way unless they have 100% control and ownership, including the credit of creating something.

[@armorclasshero2103]

Because that's how the law works.

[@Joruuscbaoth]

You are playing in their sandbox with your imagination. But its still their sand and their sandbox. You dont get to walk away from the sandbox with their sand and claim it was yours because you imagined it up. That isnt how ownership works at all.

[@peachpanzer519]

well said, its a shame that the internet is so full of all these babys, as we can see from all the posts in the comment section, fans dont own anything and have no rights , end of story

[@imperialhighcommand8535]

@@peachpanzer519 They have the ultimate right, which is whether or not to consume. The customer is the lifeblood of any business. They rely on us, not the other way around.

[@peachpanzer519]

@imperialhighcommand8535 true, then don't buy, sitting and shit posting does nothing but prove just how stupid people are, don't like something just don't buy and move along with your life , it's a pretty easy concept that people just don't understand

[@Jesus_Christ_For_Real]

To be honest, the fact that these posters were leaked 5 years after the movie released makes me hesitate to blame Disney for these. They were clearly not official releases

[@Rensune]

Stop saying "Star Wars" Say Disney Because it's them It's always them

[@Kurayamiblack]

Nah man, I'm pretty sure this has been going on since before Disney got Star Wars. Eck has some really old videos covering it. But it's been a while since he brought it up so I kinda thought they stopped. 😅

[@Galvars]

Yes, just whitewash LucasArts when they did that... muh only Disney do this!

[@JainaSoloB312]

The Force Unleashed trailer is probably still the most egregious example of SW fan art theft (also a Fractal Sponge star destroyer iirc) and that was wayyy before Disney

[@zachwilliams2597]

Can Disney just... NOT steal shit for 5 minutes?

[@jessehorn6180]

The Allegiance Class Star Destroyer better be canon Disney!

[@moffjendob6796]

Why? So we can see a plucky band of teenagers blow up a ship that's 2,200 meters long with a crew of sixty thousand with a kid-friendly gun and some button presses?

[@jessehorn6180]

@@moffjendob6796 Because they ruined Star Wars, and they better fix it!

[@moffjendob6796]

@@jessehorn6180 I hate to tell you this, but the folks who ruin things often can't fix them. And given the chance, they ruin it more.

[@vonneely1977]

Back in 2016 I was so disappointed by The Farce Awakens that I went home and wrote an entire SW fanfic novel (400 pages), which was finished in 2016. I handed out dozens of free copies to people, thinking nothing would come of it. Since then at least half a dozen ideas from that book have ended up in various official SW projects. Probably a coincidence, but still annoying.

[@Hello-bi1pm]

Like what?😮

[@stevemarsh8928]

Yes, please list some example cause I’m genuinely curious👀

[@WinterLady87]

What's the name of the fic, I'd love to read it

[@thecatfather857]

Is this fic available to read online?

[@peachpanzer519]

rember if u have an idea, hundreds of others on earth have the same idea or simialr

[@DoomGhost001]

The Dorsal is the upper surface, the lower surface is the Ventral.

[@mleadenham1]

Thank you!

[@DoomGhost001]

@mleadenham1 You're welcome. Couldn't work out what that guy meant in his comment when he said "Why does the Star Destroyer have it's guns on the upper surface and none on the Dorsal?" And I was like, "Wait a minute?!"🤔😂

[@gasad01374]

So they used a placeholder as an example for concept art that was never meant for release? What probably happened is one of their artists googled star destroyer to create an example image and just picked one while rapidly slamming out as many concepts as possible

[@ToonamiT0M]

They used a photo of a Palpatine action figure, for crying out loud. The laziness is strong with Disney.

[@Butterwinkle]

Remember, evil can never create. It can only steal and corrupt.

[@mm-yt8sf]

damn why can't they steal something to make a good movie, like an entire plot 🙂

[@Bayofthe91st]

And water is wet

[@_MaZTeR_]

Ah yes, the floor is made out of floor

[@TheCoolSithlord]

it would make more sense to use the allegiance class star destroyer as the xyston class cuz its more bulkier and has a big core

[@DoomGhost001]

Because if they had used the Allegiance-Class, they'd have to pay Fractal something for his design. The Xyston-Class was dumb.

[@cellianexurianity5021]

Leave it to disney to be scummy....

[@Warsie-Fan]

"You will never find a hive of more scum and villainy."

[@LakesideTrey]

I'm sure tons of fans would be hyped to have their works made official if Disney just asked permission and gave credit. For the other artists, how much would it really cost to pay them off for permission. In most cases it can't be THAT much especially when it's independent internet artists running around.

[@peachpanzer519]

wht should they ask, all u people screaming about thief, but when u stop and think, all these fan artists didn ask for permission, people who made money from starwars by using copy right material didnt ask for permission, but u ok with fans stealing, stop being so two faced

[@imperialhighcommand8535]

@@peachpanzer519 Fuck off. These fans were making this content long before Disney owned it. And guess what, they were credited before Disney took over. Have you heard of royalties being a thing, idiot?

[@phillyskyguy9535]

6:26 don't forget Kenobi. It's not as close up, but they use the 8 large guns on the sides of the bridge and the 3 smaller guns in the center front of the bridge

[@phillyskyguy9535]

But honestly. I forgot Kenobi

[@danicalifornia505]

5:57 #askEck #askEckhart Had Dooku bled his crystal or did he toss it away? How did hive mind species act towards individuals who broke away and had own not as controlled consciousness?

[@KuraMad2000]

It's funny, you can also tilt a star destroyer in case some idiots decide to do a cavalry charge across the top hull

[@TheOfficialFivervex]

like the Chimaera having a Class II antenna array, instead of a class I (The Crown on top of the Conning Tower)

[@Spartan_Tanner]

8:12 dang, first time I've noticed he had to change the music

[@LegendsLiterature]

He still kept it for the intro, luckily

[@loganw1232]

Disney needs major reforms

[@wildlifetails]

The trouble is if the whole 'look' is stolen from 'original' Star Wars designers then a lot of fan art is already infringing on that original work.

[@nathansheldahl]

You don’t see the big guns on Star Destroyers in live action outside rogue one but you do see them in animation like Rebels (Imperial) and Clone Wars (Venator).

[@TheFreelancer0839]

#AskEck been curious about your opinions on the sith emperor from the old republic and palpatine being super similar, do you believe that the sith emperor is a more evil dude than palpi? and do you think they would be able to absolutely stomp palpatine or not? also love the Eckpire as a term for your community.

[@seanj3667]

I think the casting for the sequel trilogy was spot on. All of the actors gave good performances given the pile of crap they had to work with.

[@armorclasshero2103]

Y'all do realize that fanart is technically IP theft right? Legally speaking.

[@Molfra]

Day thirty five of asking Eck my question: #AskEck Why do you think the pirates kept grogu, there was quite obviously a bounty on him considering all the hunters with tracking fobes and I doubt they wouldn't have known about it, so we're actually protecting him. My theory is that after he was saved after the purge, so senator or rebel group hired these pirates to protect him, but was eventually captured by the empire or forgot about grogu, (why he was never given to the new republic after the war), and the pirates not knowing he was a jedi just kept and raised him till mando showed up, killed them and stole their kid.

[@darkheartlost5826]

@AskEck- here’s a big one. If anyone can use the force, it just depends on how much you practice, and how gifted you are. Than why can’t force be replicated in a clone, if anyone can use the force? Isn’t that contradictory

[@ben501st]

Spoiler alert for the Bad Batch. They do.

[@Joruuscbaoth]

The Force is an energy field created by all living things. The concentration of midichlorians isnt uniform across all life forms. There can be trees with minimal m-counts, and there may be a Tree with substantially high M-Count. Just the same for people of all alien species. Some people got a lot, some people barely got anything. It would be my understanding that a baseline number wouldnt mean you could have Force Powers like what we see the Jedi or Sith have, but merely just exist within the living force and its energy field that binds and penetrates us all and binds the universe together. But a significant M-Count concentration would be how individuals are taken into the Jedi/Sith Order. Those with borderline concentrations would probably be the ones brought into the Guardians of the Whills, not made into Jedi but obviously taught the religious ways of the Jedi order.

[@thecatfather857]

I'd also like to take a second to mention how the 'Lusankya vs Reaper' piece was lazily turned into the 'Ravager' and 'Annihilator/Liberty's Misrule' pieces.

[@ewanmccaffrey3528]

You can see an ISD use its dorsal guns in Battlefront 2 during the campaign at the Fondor Shipyard, Moff Wraith’s Star Destroyer IIRC fires the octuple barrette turrets into an MC80 and it pretty much cripples it then and there.

[@caselleknoxiv589]

😮the fact that we have to question thief or not is saying something regarding Disney’s reputation.

[@Joruuscbaoth]

Its actually a version of misrepresenting what is happening with the way eckh is presenting this. Either by just being in error, misunderstanding how the legalities of how all this works, or otherwise, he runs the risk of getting this video flagged by the IP owners for the misrepresentation being put forth here. Could even be held liable for slander/libel/defamation by the way the entire video is presented and titled.

[@peachpanzer519]

its just for views, becuase this kind of vidoe is whats popualar, its just the sad sad state of the internet now

[@foxtrotx-ray5283]

I'm going to apologize in advance if I missed it, But I didn't see any corrections of the usage of the word "Dorsal" Dorsal would mean on the Top side. Like a dolphin's Dorsal Fin or Godzilla's Dorsal Plates The word you meant is VENTRAL. Means underside

[@P4Tri0t420]

3:42 Everytime dude.... :D

[@noahgibson4695]

Lucasfilm needs to just hire Fractalsponge and/or pay them for their designs. They're so unbelievably talented!

[@millenniumf1138]

I'm glad they didn't use this poster, because I would have gotten SUPER HYPED to see an Allegiance class on the poster, and seeing a Xyston instead would have been just awful. Well, moreso than it was.

[@thechroniclegamer4285]

wait wait wait.... Its unused poster..... so its a placeholder image........

[@baronjutter]

I'd love a really crunchy sim-like star wars fleet combat game with fractal sponge as a main ship/art designer.

[@millo7295]

Solution to this: Make your fan work diverse from Starwars art direction This is like the FNAF Help Wanted poster again, Scott should have sued for HIS CHARACTER being plagiarised by fan content because that image was so close to the original that it got onto an official poster for the game

[@kineuhansen8629]

Allegiance would be so cool to see on screen

[@PaulJohn01]

Emo Ren was pathetic as an antagonist !

[@wargeneralbonez]

#AskEck For some dumb unknown reason The Juggernaut isn't given a lot of screen time nor is it utilized well on screen even though it's an extremely awesome and useful vehicle so what's up with that? WHY EVEN ADD THIS VEHICLE TO STAR WARS WHEN THEY'RE NOT EVEN GONNA USE IT RIGHT!!!???

[@ben501st]

The short answer is to sell toys.

[@wargeneralbonez]

@ben501st But unlike TMNT, this is undeserved because the vehicle didn't get what it deserved.

[@ericfischer8295]

As far as I know, FractalSponge has never been a $ for his work by Disney

[@Joruuscbaoth]

Probably because Disney didnt own the IP yet when the subcontracted company that did hire them to provide artwork that included the ISD in question. They were paid way back then. long ago. They dont get paid twice for work they already sold them. The 3d render of the previously 2d only artwork still belongs to the IP owners. The artist just extra work fleshing out something they sold previously and no longer owned.

[@sergeipohkerova7211]

For me, Star Wars is Episode 1 through 6, with Rogue One and Clone Wars thrown in. Even Battle of Endor and Caravan of Courage. Old Expanded Universe only. Everyone can take Star Wars on their own terms just like Lord of the Rings or Terminator or anything else. I dismiss most Disney Star Wars as non canon. Oh well.

[@philipcohrs7498]

I agree with you. I have not watched most of the new stuff. I saw Solo and it sucked so bad I just quit. Same with Marvel and Lord Of the Rings.

[@Joruuscbaoth]

Every franchise that lives as long as this one has will have its greatness on display and eventually not be so great. When people complain that episodes 7-8-9 are the worst star wars films or claim book of boba fett is worst star wars tv show or just refuse to call them star wars, I enter into evidence: The Ewok movies, the Holiday Special, The Ewoks cartoon, Droids cartoon, etc.... and suddenly when faced with the ACTUAL worst star wars films and shows do most folk let up on the hatred of the newest trilogy or newest shows. The hardest part for most star wars fans is to allow anything new into their personal definition of "Star Wars" when for me the issue is people making personal definitions in the first place. Its all star wars, the good and the bad, the written books and the illustrated comics, the games, the RP tabletop RPGs, the card games, the minifigure games, the toy lines, the movie replicas, the 501st costuming community, all of it is. But no one has to subscribe to ALL of it lol. I was perfectly happy as a kid only knowing the 1-6 and the Thrawn Trilogy/Young Jedi knights series. having never even known about all the rest i listed above. I wasnt a big fan and still am not one, of the Clone Wars animated film. But I LOVE the show it spawned. Every single aspect of the show is wonderful and fleshes out and references and cannonizes so many things from legends. But I dont have to specify that the clone wars animated film isnt star wars to me. lol. Same for folk that dont consider star wars video games as star wars, not everyone is meant to subscribe to all things star wars. not all adults i know buy many of the toys for themselves lol. I know they exist, but theres just parts of the franchise that exist for certain folk and not for others. Take it or leave it mentality i suppose. Doing so just makes me think if you did that anywhere else, like "to me, McDonalds is Big Macs, Happy Meals, and QuarterPounders only, no Filet-o-Fish or McChickens, that isnt McDonalds to me." Just sounds absurd lol.

[@tgiacin435]

Part of me likes that they used fan material in official promotional materials, but there should be some kind of agreement, or position as a official ship designer for games, shows and movies

[@tonyhawkk--]

#AskEck Hey Eck, not really a lore question but did you ever play the old Star Wars Galaxies MMO? I think its one of the most forgotten/unmentioned Star Wars games out there.

[@Marinealver]

Disney needs to go BANKRUPT

[@phillyskyguy9535]

5:08 you see it in the Seadfast's hangar when Rey and Kylo start circling each other. And when they Dock Oochi's ship in the hangar

[@HalfPraetorian]

There is a scene in Rise of Skywalker that shows the turbolasers firing from outside, right after the Allegiant General says "use ion canons"

[@chrisreilly1290]

The other day Nerf released an image of their new Destiny gun. Someone pointed out to Bungie that Nerf copied their art, Nerf then fixed it. Why can't all companies fix it that fast

[@noname-bu1ux]

I actually like the sequels and the tv shows better than the last two prequels, but i have three major problems with disney star wars 1. This fuckery. The uncareful plagerism. 2. Taking the comics from Dark Horse and giving them back to Marvel. I domt wanna talk shit about the marvel artists, but the artists feel uninspired compared to DH artists. 3. The games. The prequels are my least favorite trilogy, especially before i watched Clone Wars. But that was the best time for star wars games. We had a solid run from 1997-2015 with epic games. There were a lot of duds, too, but they were easily ignorable through all the gold. I was never a huge fan of the KOTOR series, the Force Unleashed series or any of the games based on the movie itself. But that was fine considering i had the jedi outcast games, the star wars pod racing game, republic commando, battlefront 1, and 2, star wars bounty hunter, etc etc etc.

[@gundam2jimmy]

#AskEck I spoke to Timothy Zahn years ago with a question. "Instead of just using ships he comes across. If Thrawn could design his own big capital ship, what would it be like?" Timothy Zahn said the Imperial Star Destroyer is the biggest practical ship. What sort of ship would you come up with? And what do you think of mine? I designed this with render made by Simon Coles: kzbin.info/www/bejne/nJPFmnmnhN14b7c&ab_channel=gundam2jimmy

[@philipmetts8831]

Wait, I thought if you draw in a franchises design format, then the drawing belongs to the franchise not the artist. So what gives?

[@peachpanzer519]

just bunch of entitled alult children bitching agian, becuase thats all they know how to do, rember we in the age of bitching and trying to make everything look bad

[@rossh2386]

Time to crowdfund buying the Star Wars IP from Disney

[@Alexus1138]

The ECKPIRE? Eckhart, my allegiance is to the rECKpublic, to DEMOCRASSSEEEAAAHHHH

[@Joruuscbaoth]

Generation Tech is such a better channel and takes the time to be nuanced in its takes. It also doesnt misrepresent things in order to make ragebait/clickbait type videos like this.

[@Alexus1138]

@Joruuscbaoth they're both good and quite different content imo

[@0predaking0]

Please not the Titan!!

[@UnseenMenace]

Digging the chiptune outro :D

[@highlandoutsider]

#askeck whats your thoughts on ship combat in Battlestar Galactica? Im pretty sure you talked a lil about it in a old Vs video but it would be cool to hear your take on what they did well or didnt 👍

[@classicforreal]

Finalized Star Destroyer eh?

[@mleadenham1]

If they steal the design its canon!

[@connorgormly3236]

They should have used the allegiance star destroyer for they Xsyton anyways it would fit the size they were going for much better and looks amazing while still being very imperial

[@alex-b24]

Not gonna lie, I'm heavily missing the old outro music. Resonance for life my dude

[@Bounty_Hunter_brix]

#askeck: In season 6, episode 1 of swtcw, general tiplee says there are rumors of "an anti-clone virus, biological warfare." Is it possible that these rumors were about Dr. Hemlock's clone gas in the bad batch? We know Palpatine knew Hemlock and could have him working on it during the war for when the clones had served their purpose after the war?

[@JustPanda2305]

#AskEck Why did the First Order even think about building Starkiller Base specifically on Ilum, even though it was said that, "It is powered by the star to fire the weapon"?

[@Joruuscbaoth]

The kyber crystals arent the source of power in lightsabers nor the Death Stars nor Starkiller base. They are the focusing lenses are my understanding. The sun is merely the power supply used in the case of StarKiller base.

[@captiannemo1587]

If I had a nickel for each time this happened I’d probably have a dollar… no it’s not weird, it’s just embarrassing.

[@v-Lex-v]

Oh man, how could they? Yknow what? I really hope that they dont steal the, uh, Dreadnaught class Heavy cruiser that Fractalsponge made which definitly isnt the most beautiful fanon ship ive ever seen...and i most definitly hope they dont accidentally make it canon or something... Wink wink

[@NCC-72545A]

I have a legal program that allows me to build anything so I have built a number of star destroyer models in it, once there is small or smaller than the Introductor class all the way up to superstar destroyers, and on a few of them, I've mirrored the dorsal and inventoral hulls with the exception of a a ventral hanger. I got the idea from a few fan films that were in the form of a documentary of the empire that follows a carrier group and the large carrier Is star destroyer shape with its dorsal and ventral holes mirrored.

[@thetankcommander3838]

Hey Eck, WWII historian here. I ask you, please do not refer to the citadel and bridge of a battleship as “conning tower”. That term is used on submarines only. If you have questions about these things for future videos, please feel free to reach out, fine sir.

[@colewilson8050]

What happened to the outro music?

[@puppylova9546]

he has permission from the musician who wrote+owns the song he used to use, but there's a scummy company that buys the rights to use songs once then false copyright strikes everyone who has ever used that song on YT :/ he's explained it a few times if you look back in his videos if you want more details

[@puppylova9546]

tried linking video but it got caught in the auto moderation system, it's from 8 months ago and it's called "I'm being stolen from by the Orchard Music"

[@TheAstrologyZodiacball]

Star Wars is not stealing anything from anyone its the exact opposite

[@_MaZTeR_]

Even the whole Xyston ship design is just extremely lazy. Oh yay, let's copy-paste a model we already have made and slap some giant cannon at the bottom.

[@tristanskywalker1998]

I dont why people keep being shocked when this happens. Disney owns the IP. If you create something Star Wars, Disney owns it, not you. Even if it's not officially licensed work.

[@Web_2567]

Dorsal cannons are the worst enemy unit in Squadrons.

[@LordSiravant]

Disney LOVES stealing fan work for themselves.

[@reeceemms1643]

#askeck What is your opinion on Star wars Fanon and also do you think Star Wars should make an official What If series similar to that of Marvel's what if? If so what kind of stories would you like to see?

[@NayuzAqua]

This is how low we got? Man it's getting to say "I am an Star Wars fan".

[@jamesk1868]

Disney stole the Lion King story. Creater didn't care when it came out. Wish he did and sued them.

[@40kthrawn30]

If only Disney would steal story ideas from fans

[@DoomGhost001]

They stealing Fractal's stuff again?!🤔😂 This wouldn't be the first time. Wasn't it a similar situation that got him officially involved with The Essential Guide To Warfare? This is of course only bad if it's an official poster, and not just a fannon 'mockup', which is still not cool if they didn't get Fractal's permission.

[@ImaRush]

From the title, Star Wars has swayed so far that I don’t care. More Star Wars. MORE!

[@grayj7441]

Disney as Melkor Morgoth

[@doomslayer9138]

Much of the Canon is made up of ideas from the legends that, even though they are official products in the form of being licensed, were still made by fans, that even though they didn't make the most perfect stories you saw that they were stories made by fans for fans nowadays with few exceptions it seems made by haters for those who don't even care about franchise

[@peachpanzer519]

@@doomslayer9138 a true fan if not like something would just ignore and enjoy life, people that shit post are not fans just people who think they are entitled

[@doomslayer9138]

@@peachpanzer519 A fake fan accepts anything without questioning and even calls anyone who complains a fake fan. A real fan always demands the best and doesn't encourage companies to do shit.

[@peachpanzer519]

@doomslayer9138 actually a fan just won't spend money if not happy, and will not waste time posting like a little child having a melt down because they don't like something, fans act mature unlike 99 percent of the child's that post and think it makes s them cool to complain

[@ClnlBogey]

Do have to say digging the outro music.

[@ben501st]

Did FractalSponge come out and say Disney stole this? If not, this video makes a lot of assumptions and is just ragebait.

[@jeremyscungio16]

When did you change the outro music?

[@LairdErnst]

Nice music at the end of the video.

[@acarrillo8277]

The real tragedy is you believing they wouldn't.

[@Minty1337]

mimicry is the best form of flattery, they're admitting that random people on the internet do better than they can.