Why Pakistan Isn't a Modernized Rational Society? | Syed Muzammil's Lecture in Black Hole Islamabad

[@zunairazubair2268]

Recommended Books and Other Suggestions: The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism by Max Weber The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism by Naomi Klein An Era of Darkness: The British Empire in India by Shashi Tharoor Pakistan: A Hard Country by Anatol Lieven Social Contract Theory BCCI Scandal Mu'tazilah History The Civilization of the Renaissance in Italy by Jacob Burckhardt A History of the Pakistan Army: Wars and Insurrections by Brian Cloughley A Princely Affair by Yaqoob Khan Bangash Authors/Philosophers Discussed: Francis Fukuyama Yuval Noah Harari Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel Ayesha Jalal John Calvin Friedrich Nietzsche John Elia Voltaire Jean-Jacques Rousseau Marcus Aurelius Socrates Noam Chomsky Karl Hagen Other Topics: Monroe Doctrine Socialism with Chinese Characteristics The Montevideo Convention on the Rights and Duties of States Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons Case of Gulbuddin Hekmatyar Nehru’s Speech on the Opposition of Muslim League to Land Reform

[@YoYo-kw9bw]

..🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣.. ..n when reading all these books takes u no where..try leaving islam!!.. ..🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣..

[@MR.FlyingMonkey]

​​@@YoYo-kw9bwSaid by a Radi¢al illiterate Cow,🐒,🐘 worshipper 😂😂 Who has never Read These Books,

[@bambamkumarjha8120]

Your Islam told about women have half of the brain men have. Women gawahi will be considered half and men gawahi consider full. Madam you can't question your religion that itself destroyed your asking ability. 🙏

[@bambamkumarjha8120]

On this platform of blackhole will you condam Hamas act ?

[@zaidkhalid3743]

Thanks for highlighting these @zunairazubair2268

[@sujisauthentickitchen428]

I live in Australia being a Indian. I have a Pakistani neighbor, well educated couple holding a good jobs! But their mentality is to change Australia as a Islamic country. They don’t vote, they go to polling booth but they escape voting (they told me this) what sort of mentality is this? I really feel and appreciate your genuine views which can change the mentality of Pakistanis, which is need for your country

[@sps6]

Mentality of bastardness …they can’t digest that Islam is reason for poverty in Pakistan

[@dipusardar4436]

i never been in Australia or any country. as an Indian and basically from bengal i have seen radical mindset is increasing rapidly. They don't believe in any kind of democracy or else's religion or culture they just wait for majority.

[@bablugupta4589]

​@@dipusardar4436u are absolutely 👍,I am in bengal . Bharat ,the don't respect any religion . only muslim .

[@aumshanti2631]

Muslims never change they like stone age but wants all luxury of modern times

[@ishwarchand6582]

Muslim think they over human and all other things, it's their book

[@ronickroy]

Being INDIA, being Hindu & being 44years of age . First time I find out somebody from Pakistan, seems INTELLECTUAL & MEANINGFUL. please follow him . Your country needs this kind of mindset . Om namah shivay 😊

[@asad-kc8zf]

I am glad at age 44 you found some rational Pakistani. Some times we are blinded by the veils of prejudice and apathy. It’s ok to shun them once in a while and I am sure you will find more than one Pakistani who thinks on similar lines. 😊Peace

[@ASHOK251058]

But India is now on the foot step of Pakistan. Zia ul haq islamised Pakistan. Now, rss is hinduanising India. 😀😀😀

[@pratiga2]

Your country also needs this kind of mindset. At least we have one person.

[@MR.FlyingMonkey]

Shameless Hypocrisy of Indian Hindus in Comments :- They Show so much love and support to Pakistani liberal. But In india, they arrest Liberals using UAPA, call them anti-national, even use Abusive languages Like :- LIBERANDU, Leftists Dog, Angrez ki aulaad, Dharm vidrodhi.etc. Dhruv Rathee is one such example, Hindus give r@pe threats to his wife...Called him German shepherd. (Which means 🇩🇪 Kutta) Never Trust Hypocrite like these ! Their Opinion is always Biased against others.

[@MR.FlyingMonkey]

​​@@pratiga2 RSS and BJP bhakts will abuse and arrest if this person will go to India and Speak against Hindu radi¢alism😂. And So you will see their real Faces full of Hypocrisy. I know most hindus are hiding their real face in comments 😂...they show real face in the comments of Indian liberals...And Many call them Anti-national 😂. And use Abusiv€ language. I hope Syed Muzzamil knows this hypocrisy of Hindus.🤣

[@mohammadsajid8204]

Salute to you muzamil sir Really a realistic lecture I am from Kashmir India and now kashmiris here are realizing that India is far better than Pakistan

[@himmsingz]

In a Muslim majority environment, a dissenting Muslim needs lots of courage and intelligence to realize the uselessness of Islamic ideology wrt progressing in the contemporary world. Muzammil has both courage and intellect, as well as communication ability to convey his thoughts with ease.

[@MR.FlyingMonkey]

​Hindus saying this😂 No muslim in comments said anything bad against Hindutva or hindu. But shameless Worst creatures are spamming h@te against muslims everywhere ! Scum pagans ! Indeed

[@mahboobkhan3710]

You r a Hindu pretending to b a Muslim.If u r a Muslim from occupied Kashmir then u r right as u have to pamper India for ur survival.

[@tarunroychowdhury1619]

Islam is the main reason that you realised this so late.

[@tarunroychowdhury1619]

You have realised it so late because you follow Islamic dictates written in the Islamic books like Qur'an and Hadiths which were written 300 hundred years after the death of Muhammad who was a pedophile and a strong sex maniac who loved to lead a lavish sexist life by using the power of some brandish goons of Arabian desert who were Beduins having no house to live and no land to till.

[@KanishQQuotes]

1947 we cannot live with hindus 1953 we cannot live with ahmedis 1971 we cannot live with Bengalis 1980s we cannot live with shia 1990s we cannot live with muhajirs 2000s we cannot live with pashtoons 2020s sabke sar tan se juda

[@successfulway-p8T]

1000 yrs Gazwa-e-world ke ghode se uss huzum ko Elite ne uternee nahi diyaa !!! Aur 200 saal nahi uternee denge ! Warnaa wadero, sardaroo ko kaam Dhandaa karnaa padengaa ! Unkaa kam hi inkaa khoon chusanaa hai !!! Ye madhumikkii hai Waderaa boss For next 300 yrs !!! Pickock / stroberry Revolution ,selfi se Lahor/ Rawalpindi GHQ ki pool nahi khulti ultaa majboot hori hai ,sabse bada vaderaa bohat shanaa hai , lagaa diyaa Naa thikanee ,tum Kasmir, Gazaa marnee jao!!! Tumari Bibi,beti, wadere ka bistar garam karanggee !!! Waderaa ka bacchaa giri ladki ke sath London me , drugh, party Sex aish karangaa !!! Wallaa Habibi Tumahari Katt thee ,wadere ki daulat me izafaa Hoti!!!

[@kannadatechkumar3663]

😂😂😂😂🎉

[@abhinashkumar3161]

Lol

[@MR.FlyingMonkey]

Shameless Hypocrisy of Indian Hindus in Comments :- They Show so much love and support to Pakistani liberal. But In india, they arrest Liberals using UAPA, call them anti-national, even use Abusive languages Like :- LIBERANDU, Leftists Dog, Angrez ki aulaad, Dharm vidrodhi.etc. Dhruv Rathee is one such example, Hindus give r@pe threats to his wife...Called him German shepherd. (Which means 🇩🇪 Kutta) Never Trust Hypocrite like these ! Their Opinion is always Biased against others.

[@orissa72]

Problems of Converts (particularly of South Asians). These converts suffer from inferiority complex so much so that they think they are Arabs and Arabs think their forefathers were defeated and converted and thus not equal.

[@a-pale-blue-dot9219]

“Countries that are defeated by their enemies often rebuild. But the countries that are destroyed from within-that's really the end of the line.” ― Stephen Kotkin

[@Bharatiya1998]

Nice name! I have Cassini pictures as wall paper on my phone.

[@dvg-007]

They implode..

[@juliuskullu3766]

😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊

[@MukeshPanicker]

BJP is doing the same thing with India.

[@Kang.31]

​@@MukeshPanicker with enemies of india......

[@manojdhyani2974]

A first Pakistan who admits faults in his society. Brave man. Salute to his conviction

[@TheKnowledgePoint2020]

❤

[@sampathkumar4255]

Yes

[@hithere2030]

Bro I am Indian too. Would you like to hear about the faults of Indian society ?

[@sadaapricot]

It’s sad that so many Indian like the fact that a Pakistani admits their society’s fault but when this is reversed, when an Indian admits Indian society’s faults they are boycotted, btw I am a proud Indian

[@hithere2030]

@@sadaapricot you are right. Some people must know that charity begins from home. Such people are more concerned about the situation in neighbours' s homes but don't pay heed on issues with what is going on in their own house.

[@MLanjekar]

I am a proud Indian. I love my country extremely. However I respect Syed Muzamil. He is great thinker. The audiance is also a good thinker.

[@arpanjolly]

what does being Indian or loving your country have to do with respecting someone?

[@Ali-ld6tg]

Nikal lindu 😛

[@vaishnavnegi9640]

​@arpanjolly not everyone deserves respect. So when you do respect someone, especially from a place where rationality and discernment are in dearth, people feel it important to point it out.

[@Viewer-gd6tk]

​​@@vaishnavnegi9640and sometime when you come from a place where disrespect is norm 😂

[@vaishnavnegi9640]

@@Viewer-gd6tk that too. Respect isn't cheap in south Asia.

[@utkarshsrivastav6693]

I am an Indian and generally a supporter of BJP but I like Syed Muzammil's Ideas a lot. We can learn a lot of from him. Pakistan need many Syed Muzammil. Thank you for enlightening us.

[@udayarekhapalepu6587]

Are you sure? He says" india se 1947 mein hum apni marzi se alag nahi hue hame dhakke marke nikal diya gaya tha " 🤦‍♀️

[@lanoklom9697]

@@udayarekhapalepu6587 which is true, thanks to Nehru. People keep blaming Jinnah, it was Nehru's baniya mentality and western style conspiring that broke India. He was just a British stooge serving his masters.

[@yhuckthoo6254]

@@lanoklom9697what u been smoking to believe that Muslims were pushed outa India? U call urself BJP supporter but act like a librandu NY talking like a Congressi chamcha who makes Muslims sound victims of Hindus

[@akhilchandra9980]

It is surprising that pakistan has intellectuals like syed muzammi and inspite of that Pakistan is going down.i am an indian and wish that his tribe of intellectual increases in Pakistan. This would help India too.

[@MR.FlyingMonkey]

Dear Sanghi, 100% of Hindoo subscribers of this channel are BJP supporters. And h@te indian liberals...but These same scums love Pakistani liberal so much 😂 Hypocrisy of 🚩 Oldest Kulture sarrr

[@ganeshsingh1260]

First Pakistani I have ever seen in my 60yrs of life who lectured in 100 percent impartial way and without any Jelebie. My dandwat pranaam to sayed sahib

[@i_profoundquotes]

“Courage doesn’t always roar. Sometimes, courage is the quiet voice at the end of the day saying, ‘I will try again tomorrow’.” - Mary Anne

[@naanigirls8202]

❤❤❤

[@mikaass-hg9nq]

@@naanigirls8202 00 00

[@mikaass-hg9nq]

0 0

[@mikaass-hg9nq]

L

[@mikaass-hg9nq]

L

[@VivekanandSawant]

This man has brutally exposed the political, social and religious dilemma that pakistan is facing right now. I really hope all the pakistanis take his message to heart because I believe he is speaking through his heart doing extensive and intensive research on these subjects. I hope for pakistan's sake that more person like him are given the rightful exposure they deserve. My salute to him and all the people here listening to him in the hall and on the KZbin.

[@ylyogesh]

I am from India and happy to see this happening in Pakistan. Black hole is very apt name. Sayed Muzammil is a ray of hope for Pakistan. Keep walking you have milesto go. All the best 👍

[@dharamewada6922]

We as Indians living in India are so lucky and fortunate that we are living in India , educated ,free and prosperous... One day every Indian will utter the same thing, it is not perfect, but an attempt is being made to improve..

[@raufshaikh2196]

Hamare yahan bhi dharam ko rajniti me mix kiya ja raha hai jo ki pakistan ki tarah disaster saabit ho sakta hai , lekin fir bhi ek cheez hamare yahan different hai ke hum modernization aur industrialization ko apna rahe hain

[@MR.FlyingMonkey]

​@@SmartGuy895aukaat dikhaa diya na andbhakt.😂 Ab congress ko blame kar do😂...kyuki Argument meh toh fas gaye....ab Hindutva ko khulke Support kar nahi sakte...kyuki Muzzamil ko support karte hai sarrr😂

[@thewitcher8658]

free? 😂😂😂

[@Logicalsane]

​@@BelugaTheSmartCatyour religion will ruin your country in the future.....

[@tangosierra4474]

​​​@@MR.FlyingMonkeyeasy bro....clashes between communities happens and it happens in every corner of world...... If you say him andhbakht then get ready to listen mullabhakt as well... Keep calm,take it easy.....try to react like literate,if you can... And one more thing...whether it's congress or bjp...all are the sinkers of same well... सब एक ही घड़े का पानी पीते है....कोई किसी का सगा नही है....everyone has their own interests

[@ideefixxe]

Proud Muslim from India. We are extremely lucky to be here!

[@monasharma2612]

But in india we will not vote for progress despite getting 35-40 of freebies. We will vote for those who help us in population jihad and illegal infiltration from Bangladesh and rohingyas. India is not progressing because 4-5 states where Muslims are 20% ,are poorest in india. Because 20% never vote for progress but to capture, control and own india permanently. Enemies within.

[@longerodds5077]

The day Hindus become minority in Hindustan, God forbid, Bharat will be turned to what Pakistan is facing today. 😊

[@Exmuslim_Anwar]

Any islamic country can never be modernised especially with respect to right to women and spirit of scientific enquiry in citizens, without giving away fundamentals of islam and ultimately coming out of fold of islam. Exmuslim movement Jindabad. 🎉🎉❤ Exmuslim Sahil and Adam seeker 👏🎉

[@allahuakbar965]

​@@Exmuslim_AnwarNowadays many Hindus and Christians are leaving Islam 🥲 Nightmare of ex Muslims 1) awaaz e haq 2) zaid Patel 3) mufti Yasir Nadeem Al wajidi 4) abuzar responds

[@munnabhaimbbs77735]

Exmuslim here

[@surindergupta2835]

I am Indian and have seen your many videos. I am really impressed by your knowledge and its presentation. Please contact muslim community here and spread your ideas to muslim in brothers in India.

[@Logical454]

I m from India.....and love❤ to listen this group talking very relevant and bitter truth of society . Especially related to Indian subcontinent. This will surely help free thinking ..

[@maximilian9454]

Syed Muzammil deserves to be either Prime Minister or Prime Minster 's chief advisor in Pakistan. I am equally impressed with the youth of Pakistan. There questioning clearly showcased their intellectual abilities. They deserve a leader like Syed Muzammil 👍

[@jeevan_ke_kisse]

There is no power to PM, so its better he Will become Army chief or advisor to Army chief.

[@maximilian9454]

@@jeevan_ke_kisse He is very much against the Army rule in Pakistan. He can not serve the institution which is detrimental to true democracy in Pakistan.

[@FaisalQureshi23]

Syed Muzammil is an Asset in our society. I think he is the only hope for us.

[@Seeker89]

Rarely have I come across a person as clear as Syed Muzammil in the political area in South-Asia. His analysis is sharp, dispassionate and, above all, honest. His understanding of Pakistan's history is absolutely clear. I will watch till end to know his conclusions.

[@Zeno_334]

syed muzamill is worthy of respect. but the fact remains that India has tens of thousands of citizens who not only understand and believe in rationalism and individual rights, but they practice them daily. let alone contemporary india, i urge you to research and study ancient indian philosophy, see for yourself the depth, sophistication, and complexity of thought.

[@Jitin_mishraa]

He is like a Little lamp in the dark that's why he looks diff in Pakistan! There are lakhs or i should say crores of intellectuals like these in India !

[@blastergoon4185]

@@Zeno_334 bs

[@Hari-th7bv]

😂😂 say Pakistan he is no where 1% of Indian geo political experts he is good in giving speeches but knowledge wise bus 10% hai aap logon ko pata nahi political knowledge kya hai jo todha bolta woh aapko best lagta hai

[@ThakurKunalSingh-wg5kp]

Right

[@mdazadalammdazadalam3204]

I am Indian from in Bihar. First time watching Pakistani video the black hole i am greatful good answers and questions.lage raho Indian sache logo sath kada hai phir wo Pakistani hi kyu na ho .best of luck 👍jai hind jai bharat 🇮🇳

[@Raj0221]

I am Indian and for the first time i have seen that kind of intellectual people still there in pakistan...

[@bikramsingh3625]

Dear Muzammil, The Internet came now but I am watching Pakistani news and channels since 1990 when I was a kid. Right now I am based in Delhi NCR but I belongs to border of Samba sector of our J&K state. I grew up watching your serials Andhera Ujala, Nilaam Ghar, Guest house, Sona Chandni. My TV use to pick PTV on rotating antenna. My radio also use to pick Pakistani radio station and I grew up listening alom lohar, Ataullah Khan, Akram Rahi, Farida Khanum, etc. I have a certain kind of bond with Pakistan. My father belongs to Chhamb joria and we shifted to Jammu after 1971 war. Thanks to KZbin and internet that I use to listen and listening Pakistani anchors, news channels and analysts. This is for the first time that I am seeing a hope for Pakistan because of young people like you. You are a hope. You are the future. You a ray of new dawn. Your flow, knowledge, and courage at such a young age is really commendable. God bless you my dear young brother.

[@saltpepper7525]

Wow!! 🫡

[@asangha182]

Haanji, same here. Am from a border district of Punjab, and we grew up watching PTV. We loved its dramas, but were also exposed to state narrative via The News at 7.30 (Chishty Mujahid and Shaista Zaid), and Khabarnama at 9.00 pm. We used to wonder 'yeh kab hua', when there'd be news of a high number of casualties in J&K. Once, my brother had returned from Srinagar, but the same evening there was news that the entire valley had been under curfew for a month. Anyway.. Neelaam Ghar (later The Tariq Aziz Show) was a perennial favourite and so were the ones you mentioned. 'Oye Sonay' could be heard in our drawing rooms too. Good memories, brother..

[@kchandrakant50]

After seeing this great crowd for listening Mr. Syed Muzammil , as a Indian I am very happy that people especially younger generation is waking up. Wish to see prosperous Pakistan which is also good for India ,world & Pakistan itself.

[@moonlight-zn9ty]

❤‍🩹 thank u for wishing well for us. nice seeing kind and friendlier voices from india ,pakistan and where ever else them may come from. sending wellness to u guys too.

[@ameetmukherjee5265]

Need more and more people of this guy's intelligence in Pakistan for it's true development. Maybe there are, but not as vocal as this guy. Kudos to Syed Muzammil 👍

[@TheKnowledgePoint2020]

Lets pray for him life....es ko bardasht nahi kya jay ga.q kh ya such bolta hai.

[@skywlkinson2128]

This is the first Pakistani I have ever come across who worth listening simply because he is displaying such clarity of thought, intellectual integrity and deep insight into diverse issues and he is expressing his thoughts views in such rational and eloquent way.

[@abhimonster2194]

I can deeply understood this man.. As a philosophy student from BHU.. 🇮🇳. Pakistan needs such Jem

[@satishtg4784]

Ji pak has to reform from education not from madrasa type.better to close relegion base education ji.

[@MR.FlyingMonkey]

​@@satishtg4784 India is supaar pawaar sarrr ! Our opinion matters ! (Not in our home and school but in comment section) 😂😂😂

[@gtkgaming5595]

@@MR.FlyingMonkey jaa na laude kya bhok raha hai?

[@devvv7124]

Which department? Me form Economics department.

[@garrysingh697]

Finally i found someone pakistani who is serious about his country they need more people like him

[@ganapanda7125]

Mr Muzzamil, you deserve to be honoured to educate Pakistanies to build a new world order. I am a proud Indian, but found you to have very rational thinking to change the heart and mind of younger generation.

[@humanmorehuman3541]

First time I am hearing a constructive talk…..congrats to organizers, students, journalists, all females participants, and especially Mr speaker. I am from India from a state which is driven by power ideology, but even here these kind of debates and talk prevailed here from my childhood…..it’s really good to hear these talks…..please keep on educating and spreading… ❤❤❤❤❤

[@Guys_Love_Each_Other]

society should be driven by what?

[@rukhezaidi7345]

Muzzamil, thank God there are still some people like you in this country. You are the silver lining in these bleak times. May you have a long life and stay safe.

[@JunaidJamshaid889]

Wow, what a great session full of information. I am a graduate student of mass communication and I feel very fortunate to have such a great journalist or mass communication follower like you in my field. Well done Muzamil Keep it up. Love from Kamoke,Gujranwala

[@ariankhan8882]

Syed muzammel is a murtad munafiq even punjabi army general asim munir ka loyal chamcha 😅😅😅

[@prashantprakash3172]

I hope young Pakistanis like you will take a leaf from his book.

[@sujathaviswanathan7210]

Respect for this rare to see intellectual outpouring of knowledge from an even rarer breed of rational and logical thinking individual in Pakistan! As an Indian, it is extremely refreshing to hear such individuals exist in Pakistan! Hope he continues his work in enlightening people! He is a gem of his country! Lots of respect to such individuals from India!

[@MR.FlyingMonkey]

Like Dhruv rathee, Shyaam Meera Singh, Akash Banerjee. Isn't it bhakt bro ? Ya ab Side palat lega ?😂😂

[@kkjkashe1285]

بہت کوشش کی کہ میں اپ کی کسی ایک بات سے اختلاف کروں لیکن یہاں کوئی ایسی بات نہیں

[@explorerfoxy]

I am so proud of Muslims for still living in the 7th century and going towards Stone Age. Continue till you reach Stone Age.

[@mayankindian3750]

Already stone age me hai

[@Leonardo_dada_vinchi123]

Paleolithic Man 😂😂😂😂😂

[@AamirKhan-bh7bw]

Pagan spotted

[@explorerfoxy]

@AamirKhan-bh7bw Islamic devil spotted. And that too converted who has no respect.

[@darklight898]

​@@AamirKhan-bh7bwabdul spotted

[@tushardeshmukh5098]

I am From India, last week i randomly listen your lecture and now i am fan of you , i have almost listen all your lectures 🎉🎉

[@siddharthjoshi6811]

Be careful in being fan of people..

[@MR.FlyingMonkey]

​@@siddharthjoshi6811 Only be fan of Modi and RSS😂

[@mostlymysterious4814]

@@MR.FlyingMonkey yes , not islamic radical terrorist

[@MR.FlyingMonkey]

@@mostlymysterious4814 yes, But be a Fan of HINDU Radi¢al teππirosts.

[@mostlymysterious4814]

@@MR.FlyingMonkey 🤣🤣 that is your perception funded by foreign NGO and so called liberals

[@sudip2bose]

Very difficult to believe that such a logical person exists in Pakistan and he has such a big crowd to listen to him

[@shahreyarhussain5346]

We were a business-oriented family for three generations, and we never considered leaving Pakistan. However, the current circumstances make it impossible to conduct business in such a country. The amount of capital we are taking away from Pakistan has been built over three generations, and we don't have a long enough lifespan to witness any significant and illogical changes in the policies, especially when people there seem to take pride in their poverty. Muzamil stay blessed brother.

[@StopandAct]

Where did it all went wrong ?

[@Hanafimaslak-UK]

You may come back after what ever Israrel started in the world..because if war started then EU or gulf or USA will be not safe for muslims ...😂😂😂

[@Animesh16117]

​@@Hanafimaslak-UKThis shows how adamant ur thinking has become.

[@maheshA1316]

​@@Hanafimaslak-UK after going there, you guys are changing western culture to Pakistani culture. They accepted you...but what you guys are doing instead of supporting your own country.... supporting Palestinians....

[@prashantprakash3172]

​@@StopandActprioritising Kashmir over Pakistan and an unhealthy obsession with religion.

[@hewhoisbelovedofthegods]

The ammount of people in the room just shows Syed's growing popularity

[@mohinderkumar7298]

First, change in yourself. Second, change in your family. Third, change in your neighborhood. Last, change in society, university, polity, state.

[@ShivaYadav-uu7rl]

Im an Hindu right wing indian thats why i watch a quality content 😊 . This is difference between hindu and Muslims of indian subcontinent

[@amritraj41]

No. Hindu right wing watches Pakistani bashing their own country. Pakistani right wing watches indians bashing their own countries. Thats it.

[@damn738]

Tumne goro ki chaati h or chatwayi ukhada tumne kuch nhi sirf gulam bnaya desh ko aur jo thoda bhot kam kya h wo tum jese logo n kuch nhi kya sirf desh batwa diya 😂😂 ab bologe patel n btwaya to bc tum kya mrwa rhe the us time 😂😂😂

[@bijayagarwal9842]

"We the people " Is the first three word to remember for a democracy

[@anantgoel5947]

1 sane person in whole Pakistan. Kudos to him.

[@shwetaruhela2821]

from India, i could not resist to listen this whole lecture. very informative specially coming from book references. Also, i can understand what can be done for India as well. thank you!!!

[@SivaramanSrinivasan-f7w]

India is doing well. We can manage it further too.

[@ranjitsul8438]

I am Indian but really impressed by Syed Sir 💕💕💕💕💕💕

[@ChamLama1]

I am from Tawang. India 🇮🇳 love and respect

[@theknowledge2918]

Mujhe to yakeen hi nhi ho raha hai ki ye pakistan me baithke itni rational batein kar raha hai 😮😮great to see u well done 🙏🙏🇮🇳

[@damn738]

Not just Bat sunne Wale bhi h

[@prakash27502]

finally, somebody talking about solution and not just problems in pakistan. Respect from India.

[@prakash27502]

Bhai Syed, I wish you good health and long life. Because you really need good luck to survive in today's Pakistan. But keep doing what you are doing. Bol ke lab aazad hai tere...

[@moonlight-zn9ty]

❤‍🩹thanks!!@@prakash27502

[@mohibzafar4585]

Feel like people like him existed in India before Pakistan hence they have gone so far ahead. But the current regime in India might push it in the back decades cuz everything that’s happening in india right now seems very familiar to what we did to Pakistan in the 70s

[@a.r.d7287]

​@@mohibzafar4585dude I think you should study the current progress made by india under this government then comment .because previous governments were more corrupt .

[@mohibzafar4585]

@@a.r.d7287 you are absolutely correct. But tbh I don’t think it has much to do with the government maybe its the honey moon period of all the good work you guys did all this while as we reaping the rotten crops that sown in the 70s . Or maybe the current government is doing well economically as you said but the religious extremisms always comes to bite you in back side . unfortunately whatever your government is saying these days sound pretty familiar to us. “Hindu khatrey main hain” pretty sure if you ask some ignorant idiot from Pakistan he will tell you the exact same thing about Muslims. And it has doomed us. Hopefully your story turns out alot better and whatever you guys have achieved you deserve it. I think it has more to do with the people than the government. I work with alot of Indian(work ethic the no other) God bless 🫡❤️.

[@kirtybikramdas6124]

I’m an Indian but I bow before the intellectual analytical power of sir Syed Muzammil.

[@themyworld1793]

Super rational thinker of indian subcontinent.. Big fan of you sir from India

[@RajnishPandey-pj5lq]

Syed Muzammil, an intellectual immensely needed for Pakistan. May god bless him.

[@AnilSharma-hc6tf]

The crowd at your lecture shows the hope that right sense will prevail eventually.

[@kulbhushanraimadan1707]

Heartening to note that though a very small but a section of youth students in Pakistan is realising that Mullas and military are the root cause of poor development of Pakistan. The only solution seems to be that all of them be highly active on social media and vent their views with reasons. So that this small section one day grows to be a majority voter.

[@PoonamkanwarRathore-k3h]

Don't be foolish ... intellectual Muslims were the main reason for partition ..not the jahils ....so first think before speaking something

[@damn738]

Mullas who actually preached only but didn't follow what they preach they are real trouble makers ... afghanistan is under mullas and you believe it or not they will get better with time with the mullas it's the niyat of military and mullas problem with mullas of Pakistan is their root of being Punjabi this punjabiness is the main reason of being corrupt

[@surajeetpaul2008]

I am an Indian and not very much interested in Pakistan's politics but Syed Muzammil is indeed my Hero. I admire him a lot and always wait for his video. I watch his every video irrespective of its length. He taught me what is critical thinking and I will transfer the same to my kids. Love Love Love from India Sir, wish to meet you some day..❤❤❤

[@hasanazhar3839]

One of the brightest minds of this nation, a truly liberated thinker and courageous, articulate speaker! God bless you!

[@asad-kc8zf]

Pakistan doesn’t not necessarily need rational journalists but the journalists who speak the truth!

[@Nihan18]

Only a rationalist will have the courage to say the truth like muzzamil

[@asad-kc8zf]

@@Nihan18 Not necessarily, a lie can be based on twisted rationality.

[@Nihan18]

@@asad-kc8zf that's the dilemma no. Our truth is limited to our level of awareness and understanding. A rational thinker expands his/her horizons of knowledge which reveals a greater truth. So your statement is debatable in my perspective.

[@asad-kc8zf]

@@Nihan18 I am afraid truth is truth. Objective truth is like the sun ☀️, self evident. Don’t need any rational explanation.

[@Nihan18]

@@asad-kc8zf evidently not. There was a time when we believed that the sun revolves around the Earth. So I do believe until we expand our horizons of knowledge and critical thinking, we will be limited to our incomplete truths.

[@shubhamdhande2544]

He is gem of Pakistan.please preserve this guy at any cost

[@MR.FlyingMonkey]

What about Dhruv Rathee , Akash Banerjee ? Aren't they gem of India ? Or you call them Anti-national, German shepherd ?🤔🤔 Hindoos give r@pe threats to his wife. And Call him with words like "Librandus" Aur Pakistani liberal ko baap bana liya ? Intellectual ? Aur indian liberals ? Unko toh gaali dete ho !

[@UmairKhan-ht4ku]

Syed Muzammal consider Gilgit-Baltistan Azad Kashmir integal part of Pakistan 🇵🇰not so called POK

[@shubhamdhande2544]

@@MR.FlyingMonkey no I love them too they are honest and serving the nation, if I am praising someone that does not mean that I am demeaning someone. The video was about syed Muzzammil so i comment on him? So please before commenting on my comment just apply your knowledge and wisdom in what context iam talking

[@veganforlife4699]

That makes him a patriot, so be it@@UmairKhan-ht4ku

[@Jaibheemmusalmaan]

​@@MR.FlyingMonkeydhruv rati akash is not going what this anchor is doing. This anchor is trying to give good advice to pak whereas dhruv rati akash banargee is trying to save congrsss and leftist political groups in India to keep India under developed so that India will forever be dependent on the politicans for food.

[@sajjadmahsood8306]

Being a student of political sciences once in a lecture our sir said that , in order to get civilized , modernized or even to get that real freedom we have to sacrifice one of our generation.

[@GlobalIndian-df6gb]

What a crystal clear thought process..!! Syed Muzammil, there's indeed a lot to learn from you, not just for Pakistanis but for everyone.

[@tarlokkandola473]

Muzamill is a rare person , well educated , loves his country , but frustuated by actions of the society he lives in , i have grt respect for him and wish him well.

[@AkashChSahu]

Many such things that we Indian 🇮🇳 should learn from him . Great 🙏🙏

[@kalpanamoghe5367]

I am very happy to see, youth of Pakistan is thinking about past, Present and Future. All the very best. Keep it up 👍🏼 Ser tan se juda is very easy to say with out applying heads.

[@PramodDas-io4ig]

Sir, I am looking forward to seeing you a person who has changed the future of Pakistan.

[@imyogeshs]

One of the most sensible and learned men in Pakistan. Wish Pakistan speedy recovery.

[@prasantnayak3637]

Such sense of history and gift of articulation can come from true and humble disciple of knowledge. As an Indian, When I see such quality exchange and deliberation , my heart gets filled with hope that there would be a day when secular and modern Pakistan would be an equal partner to India growing and sharing success of development together. A secular and developed Pakistan would be a blessing for all Indians. Syed Saab Stay blessed. This world needs more free and fearless erudite scholars like you. 🙏

[@chatif17]

Good to hear. started following you recently. Hopefully things will start changing in Pakistan soon. We need collective effort to bring positive change.

[@nishithdave8184]

A rare and pleasant surprise from PAKISTAN ‼️ I am happy that I was TUMBLED* upon this KZbin channel 🎉👍🏽 👍🏽

[@watchiton4604]

Syed muzammil … 🙏🇮🇳 .. what a thought .. first time I found someone relevant to modern thoughts from Pakistan

[@mihirjoshi8934]

Matlab Laanat dekho Internet ki duniya mei aaj jab sabhi ke pocket mein internet hai tab sirf 1 banda khada hoke stand leraha hai Balochiyo ke liye Laanat hai laanat

[@archanashetty9208]

One of the best and engaging talk by a Pakistani! Truly enjoyed listening to him..Love from an Indian 🙏

[@TakaluKevin]

India appears to have successfully navigated the delicate balance between faith and science. One can observe this harmony when witnessing the esteemed scientists of ISRO engaging in traditional rituals before the launch of their rockets. In contrast, Pakistani society seems to struggle with reconciling these two aspects, leading to a state of confusion, contradiction and frustration..

[@Hari-th7bv]

Bro india or ancient Bharat is 100 times more advanced than current world science Pakistani don't know this we r getting back

[@dollartreeshark6786]

@@Hari-th7bvWhat nonsense.

[@dollartreeshark6786]

India did not navigate anything. India and Hindu by nature is always open spiritually and is not ideological by any stretch except for a tiny percentage. We have never opposed science in any form or fashion, as science is nothing but a concrete form of spirituality. What we know becomes concrete and what we do not know is handled spiritually.

[@harshapatil3497]

​@@dollartreeshark6786there is nothing wrong in Hari's statement.

[@dollartreeshark6786]

@@harshapatil3497 I do not support hyperbole

[@parmykumar8592]

The poem of Dr.A. P. J. Abdul Kalam which was given at the European Parliament is worth watching, which is on here! 💚✌️💜

[@ashutoshkumar8052]

Outstanding speaker and well informed listeners with valid questions. Fan from India 🇮🇳.

[@BadAss_691]

This man- a shining sword of knowledge and rationality….

[@virendrasharma8251]

Can’t believe such persons exist in Pakistan and teaching modern theory. Thanks boy from your Indian counterpart ❤

[@aamiramin8485]

People like him are present in India as well , but they are dumb folded just because they know how harsh annbhakts are while listening to sach

[@Onlyscienceisgod]

Being an Indian, i pray this intellectual human of state like Pakistan lives long.... Impossible to find such rational creature that too in Pakistan. Hope Pakistan creates such thousands youths like him

[@babubhairathod]

Sir ,this audience and students can make Pakistan modern and successful as long as religion is kept at home .

[@sundeepjethani]

🙏 Such a pleasure,joy and hope to see young citizens of Pakistan eager to listen truth and willing to change for better.😊

[@manjitsaini06]

Delighted to listen this conversation. 👌 One of the most important and daring thing is to use our own brain. Rationality comes at individual level. Start on little things in our lives and always be polite and courteous. 😊

[@vkulin]

I am really impressed with your calmness, the ability to give references, and the composure you maintain. Pakistan really needs you.. Happy that you are heard there.

[@danishyounas9653]

This man bring tears in my eyes every time he spoke a word!! Amazing.

[@ashokjain5940]

I’m very impressed by the quality of participation of the youngsters in this discussion, something I haven’t seen in Pakistanis often. Muzammil has brought about this consciousness in them through his erudite analysis and forthright views. I wish well from India to these youngsters.

[@adilzain076]

Muzammil sir bohot acha lecture tha 👌 Greetings from India 🇮🇳

[@naveedakhtar8747]

Muzamal, Thanks a lot for being so humble and patient in Q/A session. Regards

[@MeGoanBeGoan]

The boy Nauhan Nawab's comment at 1:27:04 was epic. I also sincerely appreciate the open mind with which the Speaker and the audience conducted this discussion. It is an eye opener for both Indians and Pakistanis to develop a critical mindset. In that alone lies the possibility to succeed and bring equitable change in society.

[@ayshashahid2398]

Muzzamil you are doing great work , waking up youth to think rationally and critically

[@MR.FlyingMonkey]

Shameless Hypocrisy of Indian Hindus in Comments :- They Show so much love and support to Pakistani liberal. But In india, they arrest Liberals using UAPA, call them anti-national, even use Abusive languages Like :- LIBERANDU, Leftists Dog, Angrez ki aulaad, Dharm vidrodhi.etc. Dhruv Rathee is one such example, Hindus give r@pe threats to his wife...Called him German shepherd. (Which means 🇩🇪 Kutta) Never Trust Hypocrite like these ! Their Opinion is always Biased against others.

[@Kamrankhan34996]

A true rational thinker and political philosopher of pakistan.❤ love you sir

[@DevendraKumar-ze7cj]

Syed Muzammil , you are true human being and should be leader of 🇵🇰

[@naanigirls8202]

Thanks for uploading this, I missed this sitting , looking forward for more such amazing experience.

[@sheroykalyanwala9258]

Wonderfully articulated. Well balanced , logical views , down to earth, a face to the mirror lecture. Well done 👏

[@rakeshbhatnagar2986]

Mr Syed you are doing great work it’s very difficult ! 1960 till 1975 Pakistan was Modern country ! I think to much Islam and politics involved in every aspect . Public need to understand real meaning of education . I wish you success in your hard work and future .

[@vermasattu]

If Pakistan has great problems in their countries, then believe me, after watching this video specifically, i can say, Pakistan has great minds too. Happy to see these too many intellectual persons in Pakistan.

[@ratheeshjohn8646]

Great talk. Pakistan needs more people like Muzammil.

[@Aseelshoq556]

Listening to such beautiful thinking and lofty minded people as Syed Muzamil Hussain is just like working on a barren and rotten land to make it fertile and arable. When I listen to him, I feel like someone Giving strength, confidence and courage to my body and soul. Showing the way of light, knowledge and awareness to really rotten and barren thinking minds is a great work. May you live forever, Syed Muzamil. You are a beacon of light

[@naveensingh1016]

I have seen 3rd Pakistani , who is really good in understanding the situation. I wish there are more Pakistanis like you.

[@just_a_woman-h9s]

who are the other 2?

[@charurolvcharurolv9230]

Please name the other two…waise we all know there are many other ones

[@vikassonwane1846]

I think South India is the best example of Modernazation , They believe and carry their culture and they are also very modern in a financial way also in education

[@exoticindiaa]

They hate their own skin tone, are super entitled in terms of dating(both looks and dowry), Would spoonfeed you their culture and language, literally hate North Indians, Casteist par excellence and what not. Don’t live in this illusion that they are modern, they are far from it

[@jai6196]

Then why is conversion so rampant in South especially Andhra Pradesh,TN and Kerala getting Islamised?

[@amritraj41]

@@jai6196 Whats wrong if people prefer one comic over other ?? Religion is comics. You love Iron man. Fine I love Batman

[@AG-gv9cb]

@@jai6196 question was why north India is unsafe for women, if you have trouble reading

[@abhinavsharma1104]

​@@amritraj41First spread abrahmic cult religion then leftist propagate religion is comic .All intellectual mindset become centralised in some university .

[@manasbiswas2504]

This is the first time, I am listen and seeing a rational Pakistani! Great brother.

[@humanmorehuman3541]

I am almost at the end watching Mr speaker….you are very well educated and very good speaker…..you speak with clarity and with facts…once again keep on educating and spreading love…❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤…..mentioning it I am from India…

[@Haveagodday-w8m]

1:13:23 You hit the nail right on the spot sir. I have always wondered why we take pride in never invading any country /never being the first one to attack any country. It was very foolish indeed. My holy books teach me to do what is right whether it results in being violent or not. Yet, our leaders always like to play the victim card and blame it on the British, mughals. Yes, what they did was very wrong but, that doesn't excuse our inability to stand up and fight despite having the competence just because guest is God(atithi devo bhavah) . We always like to preach about non - violence but, its high time we learn from the example of other countries. Ps: This was such an insightful and eye opening lecture. I was so excited to see so many people actively engaging in conversation and i got to learn so many things. Thankyou soo much👏👏

[@avgdghhbhhygxs9684]

The fact of matter is we lacked competence. Europe went ahead miles from Indian subcontinent during the Renaissance. And if look back during period of PRC there were constant infighting among local rulers. They lacked strategic vision. Thus India always fought her wars on her land.

[@aatmaDipoBhava]

His lectures are treat. Often Indians watch and do course correction as well as honing of knowledge of comparitive national and international studies vis a vis History polity socialism Thinker and great writers, in works of Muzzamil. But the point which hit a nail for you is actually a "claimed" point coming from Echo Chamberism and we are also victims to our own format of moderate subversion by state. Someone from audience mentioned name of Abul Kalam Azad (first education minister as he did something miraculous being a muslim 😂) except handpicking a certain class of Historians who wrote Indian History. We are also victims of our flawed storytelling I mean when Chaing Kai Shek said Indians lack importance of History. He was already planning for Tibet expansion which Mao did later. Few atomic bombs in History tellings 1. Hephlographic m-m gene flowed fron India to German - humans are from last 2 million years ago and we never invaded because we knew what voilence was as Muzzamil said initially for svandavania, we had mythlogies of Mahabharath. But recently Aryan Invasion Theory is also debunkked and questionable. 2. Slavery comes from root word slav now before questioning the cult called Islam - Ashoka did genocide after conversion to Buddhism. Cholas were mighty raiders and did unspeakable crimes as columbus did. Cholas bought and sold slaves worldwide through their maritiime ships so lets not blame Islamic Muslims for slave trade only, Its was an expansion era of cholas occured due to the position of strength. So did Kalinga Invasion. We were not as peaceful as Bipan Chnadra Thapers Mridula mukherjis Irfan Habibs wrote. All Historians can not be free from conformational biases. Especially communist. 3. Non of Handpicked Historian wrote about 1st and 2nd crusade on India only the 3rd under Qasim is written, why and when Al Biruni wrote about Amogvarsha 10000 Elephant army drinking water from Indus? Was Hindus weak at that time, Nehru handpicked historians made sure to write 10000 years of non invasion its a lie. 4. Inward science of Spirituality - Alexander met a nude Aghori - both smiled one was a conqueror of physical lands world another was conqueror of metaphysical world. Their is no need to get star struck 😅 an Indian UPSC Ias teacher Avadh Ojha teaches this formulae of "Strong Weak conundrum", so does American saying of Good times weak men Hard times strong men corollary.... History Time Naratives all are as opaque and translucent as once India was entirely buddhist majority nation for 1000+ years after which Later vedic period game rise to Brahminical Hinduism causing creation of caste system and forever diacrimination of shudra, Brahmins used to take breast tax and banned Sanskrit learning to shudras.... there are almost every format of history available.

[@dinamaanchannel]

You have no idea what you are talking about. Indian ways of influence were beyond your meager intelligence to comprehend. Indian universities like Nalanda and Taxashila were doing the soft influence all throughout. If you understand influence just as military might, you are as confused as this non stop talking person. 😂😂

[@MyNewAge]

I think that the notion that we were non expansionist is not entirely true. However it is just that India itself is so big that the focus and energies of the rulers was always to expand in and around India rather than westward to Afghanistan or Iran. And by the time they would finish their rule they would have managed to conquer that much of territory in India which they did. Yes we didnt see the likes of Alexandar and Genghis Khan in our history. It is because of the fact that ours was not a tribal society where wars were the only focus day in and day out. It is comparable to a large corporate vs startup. The startups are ruthless in their expansion because that is the only thing they can afford to do. While corporates need to manage both inwards and outwards and their growth and expansion is not as fast. And to say that we lack the courage and killer instinct is discrediting the Rajputs, Marathas, Sikhs who have shown time and again that we can fight and kill as much as others. Just because our history happened to be of misfortunes doesn't mean that our DNA lacks courage and strength. We need to come out of this defeatist mindset and not let such false notions propagate. Ours is a great civilization and we have witnessed magnificent figures in our history that have exalted us to where we are.

[@MyNewAge]

@@Vishal- minor disagreement with you here. I agree that we do have the courage and grit to fight. But saying that the Muslim rulers couldn't convert entire population to Islam is because of that resistance is not true. The type of Islam that spread in Iran and Egypt was the extreme version of it that imposed severe penalties on non Muslim populace. The tyranny was such that they had to convert. The Islam that came to our country allowed non Muslims to co-exist though as a downgraded citizen. So we could still survive. Otherwise today we would have been sitting here gloryfying to MD. Bin Qasim and Ghaznavi 😐

[@brahm-ahamasmi]

The answer is just one word: Islam! Keep debating without knowing the root of problem. May be something good will come out of it

[@Ray-of-Hope720]

Simply brilliant discussion and analysis!!! World would have been a much better place if people like muzammil are heard!! Such people Are a common chord between india and Pakistan.

[@blastergoon4185]

Fun fact- both countries' populace abuse such thinkers

[@Anonymous-px9wk]

​​@@blastergoon4185yeah thats why one country is fastest growing major economy and another one bankrupt beggars

[@Anonymous-px9wk]

​@@blastergoon4185fun fact - Lower caste dalit wrote constitution of india, abdul kalam azad become education minister of india Such thinker become top leader in one country While other is ruled by Bootpolisher slaves of military boots