204: Ayesha's Conduct towards the Family of the Prophet (Ahlulbayt) | Our Prophet

This episode is from Chapter 8 of Our Prophet -- the most comprehensive life story (seerah) of Prophet Muhammad (s) by Sayed Mohammed Baqer Qazwini.
View the complete Chapter 8 (His Other Wives) here:
• Chapter 8: His Other W...
Links to previous Chapters:
Chapter 1 (Prelude):
• Chapter 1: Prelude | O...
Chapter 2 (Birth to Revelation):
• Chapter 2: Birth to Re...
Chapter 3 (The Mission Begins):
• Chapter 3: The Mission...
Chapter 4 (Struggles in Mecca):
• Chapter 4: Struggles i...
Chapter 5 (Road to Medina):
• Chapter 5: Road To Med...
Chapter 6 (Foundations of Islamic State):
• Chapter 6: Foundations...
Chapter 7 (Badr & Uhud):
• Chapter 7: Badr & Uhud...
Things you'll learn in this episode of Our Prophet:
00:00 - Ayesha's expression of happiness at the news of Imam Ali's death
04:42 - Ayesha's lack of remorse toward the people who were deviated
05:50 - Ayesha performs Sujood in rejoicing at Imam Ali's death
09:34 - Ayesha didn't attend Lady Fatima's funeral
11:05 - A conversation between Ayesha and Umm Salama
14:00 - Ayesha's hatred towards Imam Ali
15:21 - Ayesha's jealousy towards Lady Khadija
20:59 - Ayesha's enmity toward Imam Hasan
Join us in creating the most comprehensive life story (seerah) of Prophet Muhammad (s). Dedicate episodes in the memory of your loved ones by visiting
thaqlain.org/ourprophet.
#ProphetMuhammad #PropheticBiography #OurProphet
=============================================
► HELP US REACH 100K SUBSCRIBERS:
/ @thaqlain
► JOIN US AS KZbin MEMBER:
/ @thaqlain
► BECOME OUR PATRON:
thaqlain.org/support
► CONNECT ON WHATSAPP:
wa.link/hfcf0g
► FOLLOW US:
Facebook: / thaqlain
Instagram: / thaqlainmedia

[@Thaqlain]

Play your part in spreading the message of the Quran and Ahlulbayt by performing 3S: I) Share: Help us reach more hearts by sharing this content with your family and friends (especially those unaware of the School of Ahlulbayt). II) Subscribe: Connect with us on KZbin & Social Media Platforms (links in description). Or join our WhatsApp list by clicking on this link: wa.me/message/TAR3C325Z5LYO1 III) Support: Producing content like this is impossible without your support. Be our patron and pledge your monthly contribution at thaqlain.org/support

[@NeoLeo877]

Why did Ali killed Usman brutally

[@khizarabbas7689]

😂😂

[@muniraalqamar]

Thank you Thaqlain & Sayed Mohammed Baqer Qazwini ❤🖤 ⚘️

[@fidahusayn8691]

Congrats to all believers on the occasion of birth anniversary of Imam Ali(as)

[@zainabadu-gyamfi6371]

Ya Ali (AS) 🎉🎉🎉❤❤

[@fidahusayn8691]

@@zainabadu-gyamfi6371 ❤❤❤

[@drahmadmusa6995]

CONGRATULATIONS TO ALL OF US, ALLAH HAD THE MERCY UPON US TO BRING US AMIRUL MUUMIN AND HIS PROGENY AFTER THE PROPHET. ALLAH REWARD YOU ALL THE BEST OF THE REWARDS❤❤ FOR HAVING THE LOVE OF THE PROPHET(SAW) AND HIS SUCCESSOR ALI IBN ABI TALIB...CONGRATS

[@sonabarnes6670]

Astounding sabr on your part. May Allah bless you!

[@krymsonkayharmony2529]

Assalaam A'laikum. CONGRATULATIONS to you Fam, on the birth anniversary of our beloved Imaam Ali a.s.❤️Awsome programs. I do have a little reauest though. The Sunni booms mentioned, is it possible to make mention of them in the description below please? If it's possible. Will appreciate it much for our research too. Keep up the good works and be safe😊🌹🍀🌷🌻☘

[@Thaqlain]

Alaykum Salaam. Congratulations to you to. InshaAllah we will be developing blog posts from these videos containing all references in full.

[@guiders14]

May Allah curse the enemy of Imam Ali as

[@rabiasaeed2206]

Jazakallah Allah Molana for stating the Facts of Islamic History from the pulpit. Bravo ! Specially from the Sunni School of Thoughts unity of Muslims is must for the Arrival of the last Son of Rasool Allah for the Establishment of kingdom of Peace for all Mankind.Equality and Justice for all. Educate the World 🌎 Islam is a Religion of Peace ☮️

[@abiabi9353]

Crazy people even they hear these enmity of aisha against Ahlulbayt, still praise aisha.

[@laughAFrame]

That's the Believers of Saqifa for you

[@moono9614]

When Allah swt brings our beloved Mother Aisha r.a right back on the day of judgement Infront of all creations remember you were part of those people who spread the false fitnah on her name 😢 😢 😢

[@laughAFrame]

@@moono9614 on the day of judgement a lot of Muslim that were killed in Jamal will stand up and tell ALLAH that Our so called MOTHER MOBILIZED us against someone about whom we had heard from Rasool Ullah that, HE(ALI) IS WITH TRUTH AND TRUTH IS WITH HIM, WHERE EVER HE GOES TURN THE TRUTH TOWARDS THAT DIRECTION.

[@laughAFrame]

@@moono9614 on the Day of judgement , The QURAN itself will stand against the so called MOTHERS OF BELIEVERS, AND WILL TELL ALLAH that the mothers of the believers added false verses in me, which you never revealed (the verse of breasfeediing an adult man) and then declared that the quran was eaten by a Sheep

[@laughAFrame]

@@moono9614 on the Day of Judgement Rasool Ullah s.a.w. himself will stand against Ayesha, and will tell Allah that she conspired behind his back which Surah Tehreem Mentions. And if you think we are making propaganda or false claims then Go Burn SURAH TEHREEM, NAOZUBILLAH AND BURN YOUR SAHIH BOOKS OF AHADEES THAT MENTION THESE THINGS

[@NP0451]

Mash'Allah. Thankyou.

[@dulalmiah6191]

Muslim loves Ali RA May Allah be pleased with him .

[@whyiamashia9497]

All are Sunni sources When Ubaidullah Ibn Utbah mentioned to Ibn Abbas that Aisha said “In his death-illness the Prophet was brought to (Aisha’s) house while his shoulders were being supported by Fadhl Ibn Abbas and another person”, then Abdullah Ibn Abbas said: “Do you know who this ‘other man’ was?” Ibn Utbah replied: “No.” Then Ibn Abbas said: “He was Ali Ibn Abi Talib, but she is averse to name him in a good context.” The references for the above narration can be located in the following texts: Musannaf Abd Al Razzaq Vol 5. pg. 228 - 230 Musnad Ahmad bin Hanbal, Vol. 43 pg. 86 - 87 Tradition 25914 Al-Tabaqat al-Kabir, by Ibn Sa’ad, Vol 2, pg. 179 History of al-Tabari (Arabic), Vol. 1, pg. 1800-1801 History of al-Tabari (English) Vol. 9 pg. 169-170 Ansab al-Ashraf, by al-Baladhuri, Vol. 2, pg. 215 The margin writer of Musnad Ahmed bin Hanbal namely Shaykh Shoib al-Arnaut stated: “The chain is Sahih according to the standards of the two Sheikhs (Bukhari & Muslim)” Aisha hated Banu Hashim and Imam Ali (as) Allamah Abu Umar Ahmed bin Abd Rabbah records in Iqd al-Farid, Vol. 5 pg. 76-77: He (Ali) said: ‘Go to that woman and tell her to return to her house wherein Allah ordered her to remain’. He (Ibn Abbas) said: ‘Hence I went to her and asked permission to enter but she refused to grant it, hence I entered the house without permission and sat on a cushion. She (Aisha) said: ‘Oh ibn Abbas, by Allah I never saw someone like you! You entered our house without permission and sat on our cushion without our permission’. I said: ‘By Allah this is not your house, your only house is the one which Allah ordered you to stay at, but you didn’t obey. The commander of the believers orders you to return to your home land which you left’. She said: ‘May Allah’s mercy be upon the commander of believers who is Umar bin al-Khatab’. I said: ‘Yes, and this is Ali bin Abi Talib the commander of believers’. She said: ‘I refuse, I refuse……’. Then she said: ‘Alright, I will return, because I hate the city in which you (Bani Hashim) reside’. In Al Imama wal Siyasa, Vol. 1 pg. 66 we learn that: “Following Uthman’s murder Talha approached Aisha in Makka and said ‘Look they have made ‘Ali Khalifa. She said, What right does ‘Ali have to rule over our necks? I will not stay in Madina as long as ‘Ali is in power.” In Rauzatul Ahbab, Vol. 3 pg. 65, we read that: “After the Battle of Jamal, Ali approached Aisha and said: ‘You have treated me like an enemy’”. We also read in Rauzat ul Ahbab, Vol. 3 pg. 10 that: “Aisha was clouded by her hatred of Ali”. We read in Musnad Ibn Hanbal, Vol. 41 pg. 322 Hadith 24820: حدثنا عبد الله حدثني أبي ثنا أبو أحمد قال ثنا عبد الله بن حبيب عن حبيب بن أبي ثابت عن عطاء بن يسار قال : جاء رجل فوقع في علي وفي عمار رضي الله تعالى عنهما عند عائشة فقالت أما علي فلست قائلة لك فيه شيئا واما عمار فإني سمعت رسول الله صلى الله عليه و سلم يقول لا يخير بين أمرين الا اختار أرشدهما ‘A man came and spoke negatively of Ali and Ammar in the presence of Aisha to which Aisha said: ‘I shall not tell you anything about Ali but as for Ammar, I heard the Holy prophet say that if he is provided with two options, he opts for the better one’. The margin writer of Musnad Ahmed bin Hanbal namely Shaykh Shoib al-Arnaut stated: “The chain is Sahih as per the condition of Muslim”

[@AliAsghar-jl7tj]

Thank u for this comment

[@kumail17]

They claim Shias hate Prophet Muhammad sww wives. Was Aisha the only wife? We don't Sunnis talk much about Umm ul Momeneen Salma r.a, Umm ul Momeneen Khadija and other wives

[@ed92122]

May Allah protect you Sayed

[@AhsanAli-dl5if]

Thanks.

[@naqueevi]

Quick question, if Aisha refused to attend Bibi Fatima’s (AS) funeral, then does that mean her burial was known (and did not occur in the night)?

[@Thaqlain]

It did occur in the night. The rooms of the wives and that of Lady Fatima were next to one another. So it was natural of the wives to offer condolence.

[@HKHasty]

Makes me sad I’m 33 and I lived my whole life believing Sunni dogma 😢 اللهم صلي على محمد واله

[@rohlmayers1792]

Its not how you start, its how you end. God bless.

[@NeoLeo877]

Later you realise the total Shia and sunni stories are fake

[@yoursolosquad6283]

Brother always thank Allah (SWT) he saved you, God bless your pure soul 🌹

[@bellaasif2309]

Sir, where do you conduct these lectures I want to learn?

[@Thaqlain]

Al Hujjah Islamic Seminary

[@itgw4658]

@@Thaqlainis that a place or a website?

[@ethandouro4334]

Allahume Sale Ale Mohamad Vale Ale Mohamad Selamun Aleykum great standing and may Allah compensate your efforts, JazakAllah khayr. Greetings from Brazil 🇧🇷 Btw, can you ask for adding english, arabic and spanish/portuguese subtitles in the video, please? Looking forward to watch all of the lectures

[@Thaqlain]

Alaykum Salaam. We are working hard towards adding English subtitles. The volunteers of Bilal Subtitling Initiative have completed 100 episodes of the series already.

[@ethandouro4334]

@@Thaqlain Allahuma barik feek

[@commercialandresidentialpl7337]

Selam our Brazilian brother from your Bosnian brother.

[@yoursolosquad6283]

I seriously cannot understand how our Sunni brothers and sisters hear these narrations in their own books of aisha and still praise her, like what is there left for her to do for you to understand?! Does she need to kill the prophet for you to understand she is a disbeliever?! Wake up and dont be like the Quran says:, Deaf, dumb, blind, so they do not understand | صمٌ بكمٌ عميٌ فهم لا يعقلون

[@liahnatashah5145]

Because of Ignorance .that s it

[@maisamnazim4247]

By the way, according to some narrations from sunni and shia sources, Aisha was also involved in prophet's assassination.

[@SS-yo4qk]

It's shocking. I can only think of her as monafiq.

[@abdulvahid9043]

These people excited and parished, we will not be questioned about their deeds nor they will be questioned about our deeds We will be questioned about whom we followed, whom Allah teala and His messenger did appoint to follow to achieve eternal mercy instead of eternal punishment Obey Allah and His messenger and Amirs among you Allah has the right to choose and they don't have the right to choose

[@Thaqlain]

Salaam Alaykum. This episode is part of a series where we have examined all the wives of the Prophet and the lessons we can learn from them. We will urge you to watch it completely before reaching conclusion. 🙂 kzbin.info/aero/PLOXzVYnjThorUIEtu2YYLNRMq6CBgUOu3 The episode in question, too, is connected to other episodes trying to answer the reliability of Ummul Momineen Ayesha as a narrator of hadith and Sunnah.

[@habibanathani3747]

As she is wife of holy prophet Ali A.S is her son in law forget he being successer

[@fadelalkarbalai9766]

I am first to comment 😁

[@krymsonkayharmony2529]

Lol, very well☺

[@ethandouro4334]

allahuma barik feek akhi

[@SHIA12.A]

Good

[@shettimaumar9235]

Aisha is also Ahl Bayt if you don't know Quran surah Ahzaab 33 : 33

[@Thaqlain]

Ayesha herself will differ because there are clear narrations from the Prophet that only Ahlal Kisa are Ahlulbayt. There is a narration from Ayesha herself in Tafsir al-Kashaaf.

[@nomairshahzad7960]

Is it possible that we can indicate Lady Khadija (as) was the favourite wife of the Prophet Muhammad (SAW). As he remained completely monogamous to her during her lifetime despite having the ability to marry multiple wives (as would be normal for a man of his status), as we know that all wives a Muslim man takes must be treated justly and equally, and he would be unable to do that with any other woman next to Lady Khadija (as)?.

[@Thaqlain]

She was indeed the most beloved wife of the Prophet and the one praised by Allah in the Quran. We have covered her life in episodes 21 onward in this series.

[@shamstameez]

Why quote Hadith from history works? You know very well that Sunnis have a Hadith tradition. They don’t take Hadith from history books.

[@Thaqlain]

The previous episodes explores hadith from hadith books too. But history books are considered equally important in developing corpus of any Islamic school.

[@muhammadhamza5467]

@@Thaqlain no they are not most of the historic world , don't need to be supported by chain of narrations ,and is influence by socio political conditions ,,. Plus author of the work is kind of authority In it ,, where hadees is scrutinize by mean of ilm ur rijal, science of hadees and so on...

[@ed92122]

11:00 no comment

[@ab5680]

Sunnis in the comments coping after hearing the truth about their beloved Ayesha (la)

[@user-eh2pv4sc7h]

She was never beloeved. READ THE QURAN TO SEE WHAT ALLAH SAYS ABOUT HER.

[@moono9614]

If believing Muslims who still spread fitnah are unjust and are fine with speaking falseness about our beloved Mother Aisha r.a we will stand with her and her rights! And defend her, if the lord of the worlds defended her we must do the same as much as we possibly can and defend her too. Mat Allah guide you people ameen

[@HadithOfThaqlain]

Falseness? Did you watch the video? He literally used Sunni sources ONLY. This is ridiculous, may Allah destroy the enemies of the Prophet PBUH.

[@moono9614]

@@HadithOfThaqlain Yeah 🙄, Ameen, I was talking about the comments, they are so rude about our beloved Mother Aisha r.a

[@HadithOfThaqlain]

@@moono9614 Beloved mother? A mother who kills her own children? Have you forgotten about the Battle of Jamal?

[@moono9614]

@@HadithOfThaqlain OMG here we go again, she never started the battle of jamal! She was with 2 companions that chose to go out and find out who killed Uthman r.a and good on her for trying to bring justice for Uthman r.a . It is very true that her intention was to not go into war but rather to see who murdered Uthman r.a in a peaceful manner. And the hypocrite's attacked. It was not her fault, and actually you would be surprised how many people she is beloved to including the Prophet Muhammad saws himself.

[@moono9614]

@@HadithOfThaqlain That is why when Imam Ahmad ibn hamad who died 200 years after hijra of the battle of the camel was asked which side should be taken and he replied by quoting “that was a battle that Allah saved our swords from having to have blood so why don't we save our tongues from having sides. In other words Alhamdillah that was a battle we didn't have to pick our swords because we won't alive back then, I wasn't forced to choose sides so then why are you dragging my tongue in and making me force and give sides now let me be quite and that there is pure sunni ideology that we believe in. And Aisha r.a did not deeply hate Ali r.a they were both people who were righteous and had a misunderstanding, whatever happened, happened and life goes on. So let's all try to follow our Mother Aisha r.a intellect and respect her as she highly deserves ameen :)

[@shettimaumar9235]

Why are you using sunnah hadith to butress your false claims use Shia hadith instead you can't because there was no Shia during the time of prophets and no a single Sahaba was a Shia .

[@Thaqlain]

It seems you have missed the purpose of this episode. This episode is the part of a 400+ episode series exploring the life of the Prophet. From episode 198 to 205, we have explored why Ayesha bint Abi Bakr is a controversial figure to be considered as an authority for Sunnah of the Prophet.

[@jimmykahn5431]

The prophet will turn away from the Shia for spreading fake news.

[@Thaqlain]

We are here to correct if anything shared in this episode can be proven to be fake.

[@muhammadhamza5467]

@@Thaqlain bro why don't you debate with Muhammad hijjab, adnan rashid , ammar nakhswani etc , so that academics of sunni side could jude your argument ,being sunni I don't think what so ever you are referring to is present ...

[@ibrahimharith9878]

​@@muhammadhamza5467Wallahy what a sad life we fail to use our intellect when Allah has clearly said ,Only men of understanding and reasoning will see His signs

[@rehanagoogle3869]

Not true that she harts Ahul-Bay Alhe-salaam and Ayesha loved Maula Ali alaihis salam

[@Thaqlain]

Salaam Alaykum. That's what most of us have been told. But the truth as found in historical references and books of hadith is otherwise :)

[@ItachiAli1993]

Yeah and that's why Ayesha fought against Imam Ali because she loves him... 😂

[@itz_goku4u]

Why is this guy slandering ayesha so badly ..... with no authentic proof

[@Thaqlain]

We are there to provide any proof/references that are required :)

[@ronm7503]

What are you quoting man? Al-Aghani? There's thousands of scholars from the past, what you're stating, no Sunni scholar believes this. What are you going on about that, that we Sunnis actually believe this? You are digging in the crates and trying your best to find anything to revile and tarnish the image/reputation of Aisha, it's obvious.

[@Thaqlain]

It seems you have missed the purpose of this entire chapter :)

[@muhammadhamza5467]

Why don't this scholar debate with Muhammad hijjab , ammar nakhwani etc , if he really thing that he has get so much information, but you can fool only fools with this weak sources...

[@Thaqlain]

Please share proves that the sources provided are weak. We understand that the information is new for you but that doesn't mean it is inauthentic.

[@billybs9965]

I listened without judgement trying to understand your pov , but when you said "We doubt her repentance", I stopped watching. My belief is even of a human today - only Allah knows whats in their hearts, so only Allah can judge him/her, and you are talking of someone who is the wife of the prophet SAW. Sorry, my belief in Allah doesn't allow me continue!

[@mahmoodvisram1739]

I’d like to ask that if Allah SWT openly reprimands her in the qur’an and has left it open - he has not revealed any verses after to say that she was forgiven for her actions conspiring against the prophet SAW, isn’t that a good reason to doubt her repentance? Or would you go against the Quran?

[@Thaqlain]

We doubt her repentance due to the fact that she continued with the cause that required her repentance in the first place. As Sayed mentioned, we have nothing personal against her :)

[@billybs9965]

@@mahmoodvisram1739 Allah knows best. My Allah is most Merciful, always forgiving and loves us unconditionally.

[@billybs9965]

@@Thaqlain Did Allah give us the right to judge the repentance of another human?

[@Thaqlain]

Not at all. But that makes her a controversial figure to take the Sunnah of the Prophet from. And that's the whole point of this video.

[@allysoobratty7565]

Have to be careful about HADITHS ,many of them are not AUTHENTIC

[@Thaqlain]

Indeed. But when you have similar reports it means that the person is definitely controversial :)

[@allysoobratty7565]

@@Thaqlain There is no SHIA or SUNNI in Islam,we are all MUSLIM!!!!

[@Thaqlain]

Indeed. Where did we deny that?

[@zaheer3456]

This guy just spreads hatred in the name of Islam with his biased and closed mindset. May Allah swt guide and protect the ummah from such fitnah of dividing and feeling hatred among muslim brothers

[@Thaqlain]

Please share where is hatred in this episode?

[@nooriah78]

May Allah SWT bless our Mother Aisha. It is very sad people in her time and even after her death are spreading fitna on her name. Verses of Quran were sent down her honour. May Allah SWT raise her rank shower abordance blessing on her. The beloved wife of our beloved Prophet Muhammad PBUH.

[@badolgiringya5035]

Brother all the wives of Prophet Muhammad (saw) are called mothers of the believers (Quran chapter 33 verse 6) meaning they are our mothers and seems like this guy believes that too Aisha (RA) was in fact his (saw) wife. Then how come he slandering his own mother? Or is he not a believer? may Allah (SWT) guide us all and save us from the lies of deviant cults!

[@ethandouro4334]

may Allah curse the enemies of Ahl Bayt and give Aisha the worst of punishments.

[@badolgiringya5035]

@@ethandouro4334 Audubillah so basically you deny the Quran? How can any believer curse his own mother and still call himself a Muslim? May Allah SWT guide us all!

[@ethandouro4334]

@@badolgiringya5035 The quran itself told us to curse the munafiqs that attacked the prophet and angered Allah. Ayesha, laenatullahi alayhi, was NOT the mother of believers, she literally wanted more power to her father caliphate. Watch. The. Preceding. Videos.

[@badolgiringya5035]

@@ethandouro4334 The way youre slandering against one of our mothers (RA) and writing about Quran and Prophet (saw) it doesnt feel like you or your kind have anything better to add! Btw I know this speaker longer than you imagine so yeah I know all his tricks and fallacies he likes to spread among the sheep of your community! Fear Allah (swt) brother and come back to the straight path. May Allah SWT guide us all!

[@suhaibhaider6440]

One lecture for 72 hoore. Plz

[@zhusayn982]

Stop creating dis unity in the Ummah

[@Thaqlain]

Salaam Alaykum. The unity of the Ummah is in following the path of the Prophet (s) through Quran and Prophet's progeny (Thaqalayn). There is no intention to create disunity here :)

[@badolgiringya5035]

Hey Thaqlain, be brave at least for once and dont delete this comment! Subhan Allah what a liar this man is! May Allah (swt) guide me, you and your followers! The person this misguided man is mentioning as a scholar was born 200 years later after mother Ayesha (RA) and was basically a writer, poet and musician NOT a SCHOLAR by far! In fact the very book this man calling as a book of hadith "kitab al aghani" literally means "book of songs"! He wrote songs and poetry in that book and this man is calling that as a book of hadith! And since when history are being accepted as facts in Islam? And why is he calling historians as scholars and their work as hadith? Do Shia people know what hadith means?? brothers and sisters, Fear Allah (swt) and dont lose your akhirah following lies from misguided people! May Allah (swt) forgives us all and grant us Jannah.

[@Thaqlain]

The narration (or hadith if we call it in Arabic) is not in Kitab al-Aghani; it is in Maqatil al-Talibiyyin. Abul Faraj is known for Kitab al-Aghani, an Arabic encyclopedia of songs and poetry. Also, Bukhari was born in the same century as Abul Faraj al-Isphahani. So should we disregard him too? Ibn Athir also mentions this. Should he be disregarded also? Lastly, we urge you to listen to the episodes preceding this one. It is a part of a series examining why in the School of Ahlulbayt, we don't take the Sunnah/Seerah of the Prophet from Ayesha even though she has quoted hundreds of hadith and why we consider her to be a controversial figure. So one has to listen to the entire thing on academic/objective grounds, and it is entirely okay to disagree with it.

[@badolgiringya5035]

@@Thaqlain Bro stop lying at least for once! Firstly Abul Faraj al-Isphahani was a shia but your speaker again and again calling him a sunni scholar who used to write poetry and songs Subhan Allah! Btw your speaker said many times these are historical books and in Islam historical books are not regarded as facts and part of our deen! If you guys take them then its a different discussion altogether! What does Imam Bukhari born in the same century has to do anything with Abul Faraj al-Isphahani? One was one of the best scholars in Islamic history and another was a poet, writer and musician! How are they alike? You dont take any sunnah of the Prophet Mohammad (saw) from mother Aisha Bint Abu Bakr (RA) but you are quoting unknown peoples books and calling their statements as hadith! are you waffling? Btw do you believe in Al Quran? if you do, do you know she is your and our mother like all the others wives of Prophet Mohammad (saw) as Allah (swt) clearly stated "The Prophet has a stronger affinity to the believers than they do themselves. And his wives are their mothers." (Quran chapter 33 verse 6) Brother stop misguiding people. In the day of judgment if Allah (swt) ask you why did you disrespect, humiliate wives of my dearest Prophet's(saw)? whats gonna be your answer? Fear Allah (swt) bro and dont lose your akhirah following lies from misguided people! May Allah (swt) forgive us all and grant us Jannah. P.S. Please use (saw) after prophet Mohammad (saw) name as much as you and your scholars like to use AS after Ali Ibn Abu Talib (RA)'s name.

[@ethandouro4334]

@@badolgiringya5035 you are dodging the point and creating new discussion, watch the videos preceding this video.

[@badolgiringya5035]

@@ethandouro4334 no ones dodging the point you dont have! just admit you dont have answers to my questions or to the blatant lies by the speaker!

[@ethandouro4334]

@@badolgiringya5035 Watch the preceding video, it has all the answer for your questions, why would I type out everything the other videos already told???