The Masters 8: A Lost Opportunity for Rivalry Revival

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

What Other Topics/pokemon should we tackle?? Maybe, the HISTORY OF SCEPTILE??

[@rayhayes7701]

Yes History of Sceptile

[@GhostBoyJames]

Sceptile or maybe the grass owl.

[@Mvfasalways]

Rundown of ashes best traveling companions

[@Cross576]

Yes please, give so respect to my boy septile

[@CoolNala]

Ash's Sceptile or Bayleef. Or Drew's or Maylene's Team.

[@auroraSLAP]

I was fully expecting Tobias to appear and get yoked in the first round 😂

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Would've been preferred to Alain lol

[@regulartime2325]

That would be funny and satisfying at the same time!

[@Yajjay833]

@@regulartime2325 yeah in anime once a character become old He genrally becomes weak too

[@Coy.Rug22]

I feel like ash would’ve gotten his revenge on Tobias

[@Pokeamoon]

Well he just got permanently banned in joining competitions for being a cheater 😂

[@moddy121]

I stand by Brandon should have been in the Masters 8. I mean, the guy owned all three original Regi's and was considered the strongest of all the Battle Frontier. Imagine Brandon vs Cynthia or Brandon vs Steven to decide who the best archaeologist is.

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

I'm still surprised he didn't catch the two new ones

[@Rob17Cotton]

Brandon no longer has his three regi's they where sealed away with regigigas in diamond & pearl but Brandon would still be competitive tho I believe

[@gushernandez25]

It feels weird not seeing Palmer or the rest of the Battle Frontier members.

[@TheECSH]

as we can see in the case of Paul, some trainers are strong, but they just choose not to participate in the tournament

[@Rob17Cotton]

@@TheECSH well Paul is going to become a gym leader but I think that's a little hollow for me, Paul is better than a gym leader for me I would of been happier if he was gonna to become a frontier brain

[@josephluna6771]

I think Roxy should've came back in journeys she's pretty strong holding her own in a 3v6 and giving her a toxtricity would've been perfect

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Roxy was so powerful that I'm still surprised she wasn't at the league

[@Cross576]

She is the only gym leader in the unova region I have respect for in the anime she was the hardest gym leader to bet no one could have beaten until ash came with 6 Pokémon even a type match up Roxie still nearly bet ash she earns my respect after that plus in the games she is a pain to go up against as the second gym leader to face of against

[@Coy.Rug22]

The battle between ash and Roxy was a good battle during the black and white days

[@Hrothotus6969]

Man imagine Leon Lance Cynthia Steven Tobias Alain Iris and Ash

[@InfamousCitySounds]

He had a cameo, but seeing a rematch with Ritchie would've been so amazing!

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

It'd be epic!

[@andrewxu3602]

Ash should've had that back in Johto.

[@shehbazameer-ip2lo]

Whatever ppl Say But Paul Will Always Use His Monster Electivire

[@articusramos808]

They would be a perfect group for another set of badges. Just this time for the elite trainers.

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

I'd love to see more of all of them

[@yessir916]

Paul. Ik he’s a gym leader, but like give him a mega aggron. No matter what people say, Paul will always be the best rival to me

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

I want mega garchomp now XD

[@CoolNala]

I would love to see a Harrison vs. Sawyer battle in the first round to get a Mega Blaziken vs. Mega Sceptile showdown. That would be even better. That would show how far Sawyer has come before facing Ash. Ash vs. Brandon 6-on-6 would be awesome, especially if Ash uses all his powerhouses. Drake could face Kukui, and Sabrina against Tobias.

[@domango2020]

I actually thought Tobias was going to come back since he only won with 2 pokemons imagine if he used all 6 Pokémon

[@patrickkh1245]

Im really happy with the masters 8 We got. Its so cool to see all the champions.

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

I like it as well, but always fun to speculate XD

[@patrickkh1245]

@Tr Uz she almost beat garchomp without using any gimmick

[@Popstalgia]

Brandon absolutely deserved to be included in the masters 8. The anime dedicated an entire season to the frontier brains, and then have rarely been mentioned again. With characters in both the games and anime, not including at least one is a major travesty.

[@ghostviper8906]

Here's my version of if alot more previous characters battled in the world coronation series, Warning ⚠️ it is incredibly long: Masters Class: 1st Leon 2nd Cynthia 3rd Steven 4th Lance 5th Diantha 6th Alain 7th Iris 8th Ash Ultra Class: 9th Raihan 10th Brandon 11th Alder 12th Drasna 13th Kukui 15th Tobias 20th Hilbert (OC) 24th Malva 27th Volkner 29th Marnie 30th Bea 36th Astrid 39th Norman 42nd Virgil 45th Palmer 49th Olivia 52nd Koga 59th Flint 62nd Lucian 63rd Sawyer 69th Bruno 70th Guzma 71st Drake 75th Jimmy 79th Harrison 85th Tyson 88th Cilian 94th Clemont 96th Nate (OC) 99th Paul Great Class: 100th Trip 109th Remo 195th Kiawe 216th Wikstrom 233rd Hau 324th Claire 356th Wallace 421st Misty 466th Lorelei 487th Tierno 509th Kahili 538th Flannery 563rd Georgia 597th Caitlin 635th Agatha 664th Roxie 721st Luke 742nd Nessa 754th Stephan 812th Trevor 895th Kricketina 929th Rinto 958th Dozer 991st Tony 999th Ritchie Normal Class: 1001st Korrina 1024th Hayden 1250th Lt Surge 1508th Elesa 2109th Visquez 2216th Oluola 2592nd Lob 3017th Morrison 3200th Oliver 3771st Nando 4223rd Lucas (OC) 4408th Cameron 4977th Barry 5575th Gardenia 5866th Rosa (OC) 6700th Conway 6948th Bianca 7089th Acerola 8003rd Burgundy 8396th Faba 9999th Hiroki

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Very long indeed XD

[@ghostviper8906]

@@ProfessorAlexSilver it's called the "World" Coronation Series for a reason

[@martinsoto6146]

1:41 Personally I prefer Ash having a Mega Charizard Y due to Mega Charizard X being Alain’s ace

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

That'd be dope too, I just like X better haha

[@martinsoto6146]

@@ProfessorAlexSilver Tell that to the writers of Leon vs Alain

[@rayhayes7701]

Sabrina: If you take Giovanni out of the equation, Sabrina is probably the most powerful Kanto gym leader so I think so. Drake: He's never really lost. The only trainer who beat him was Ash so why not. Harrison: Maybe. It might be unnecessary but at the same time it could be done right. Brandon: It might be hard for him to return considering his job. However, Regielkei and Regidraco exists so...... Tobais: I don't really want to see him again. Sawyer: Yes. Plain and simple. Vergil: Yes also. That way he can add another Eeveeultion to his team and Chloe can see how that works. But don't evolve his Eevee. Professor Kukui: I wouldn't mind it.

[@jenniferdaniels701]

I wouldn't have thought about Harrison or Sawyer either, but even if they would have just run into each other and had a random battle somewhere in the woods would have been cool. Virgil wasn't really interested in competing. He just wanted to show how strong his team was and bring some attention to his family's kind of work. But going on a rescue mission in Unova, then having a one on one for fun later.... I feel like Tobias could have been part of a Crown Tundra arc, where you can catch mythicals and legendaries in the caves.

[@EmmanuelKai25]

Also would love to see Tobias again, his design matches Darkrai so well!

[@EmmanuelKai25]

And I also want to know more of his history

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

I did a video on his history, but there's still much left unknown

[@thefirespecialist9007]

Honestly, The World Coronation Series Masters Tournament should have been the Top 16 Trainers. Round 1 and 2, 3 on 3, Round 3 and 4, Full 6 on 6 Battles. The trainers: Ash, Leon, Alain, Lance, Iris, Cynthia, Virgle, Hop, Brandon, Steven, Ritchie, Guzma, Agatha, Drake (Orange Islands), Flint, and Siebold. Round 1: Ash vs Alain Round 2: Ash vs Flint Round 3: Ash vs Cynthia Round 4: Ash vs Leon Other interesting matches: Iris vs Lance (Round 2), Iris vs Virgle (Round 1) Hop vs Leon (Round 1), Ritchie vs Drake, Agatha vs Siebold, Steven vs Leon (Round 3).

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

That would have been dope!

[@gushernandez25]

Brandon, Palmer, Tobias, and N would have been great additions.

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

N would be very interesting

[@pun-inator6075]

Firstly, I don't think Leon should be a part of the masters 8. As the reigning champ, he should be the final challenge for whoever wins the tournament. Personally, I think the master's 8 should be: Ash (Alola) - Obviously Brendon (Hoenn) - I would've loved a reintroduction for the two new regi's, maybe he could've beaten Paul in a rematch. Hence why Paul decided against competing in the world tournament. Cynthia (Sinnoh) - she has been shown to be one powerful trainer. (spoiler alert, I'm not putting Tobias here because in both Unova & Journey's, she was still Sinnoh's champ but league winners get to challenge the champion's league. If Tobias won, he'd be the champ, not her) Giovanni (Kanto) - he's been a gym leader & working in the shadows. With TR resources at his hand, I can see him being on champ level even if shrouded in mystery. He could also be a mostly unknown trainer, without his name being released prior to a big matchup Iris (Unova) - I liked what happened with her character in this series (my favorite part of Journey's actually). Diantha (Kalos) - same logic with Alain in why I'm not putting up Tobias. She is clearly the strongest rep Kalos has being a Grand Dutchess (presumably) & champion Drake (Orange Islands) - this would've made a cool call back for sure Lance - the champ of Kanto & Johto would've been a nice show off. Matchups: Round 1: Ash v Giovanni / Iris v Drake / Cynthia v Brendon / Lance v Diantha Round 2: Ash v Lance / Cynthia v Iris Round 3: Ash v Cynthia Champ match: Ash v Leon In round one, I tried to make some hype match ups. Imagine Ash's shock to find Giovanni being the last entry in the masters eight. A grudge match between Pikachu & Persian would also be nice to see. Iris would get to face Drake, since he's one of the first major obstacles Ash beat plus a Dragonite showdown would be awesome. Brendon & Cynthia is more just fan service since both are very well characters. While honestly, Lance & Diantha are more what's left but Lance could prove his mastery of the type by overcoming a mega fairy In round two, well Cynthia v Iris was the best non-Ash battle in the masters eight so we just need to do that. Ash v Lance would be a nostalgia trip like none other and fans of the original series would be great. Does the rest of the entries need explaining? I thought not.

[@frankaxe6700]

I didn't know who some of these guys were but It's nice to hear about MY BOY SAWYER!

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

I've done historys on Virgil's Team Eevee, Drake, Tobias, Kukui's Incineroar, Sawyer's Sceptile, & Sabrina, while Harrison was brought up in the Charizard video. Brandon is featured in my Torkoal, Bulbasaur, Squirtle, & Charizard videos if you need any refreshers :) They're all fun videos imo haha

[@zainmukadam5861]

Bro I love your content.been watching for 2 years

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Thanks Zain! You're an OG then :)

[@EmmanuelKai25]

Harrison was really cool too, wish they could bring him back someday, he has the most exciting Blaziken ive ever seen

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

I'd love to see more of his sneasel

[@neogotham2k39]

I hope Virgil has Sylveon since his Eevee defeat Druddigon (dragon type) at the Unova League. I like Eeveelutions!

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

If only Virgil could return!

[@priyanshugohel520]

There is mine theory which includes, ash winning the masters tournament and was hiked but then Tobias will come and beat him so he gives his title to him or alan or mr.dande and get away for more training, in this manner he'll win the league and still he can go over and over

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

That'd be a very interesting turn of events

[@LordRumshi]

My thoughts with those you chose Sabrina: an actual battle that could've happened between her & Ash plus seeing if she's no longer scary Drake: a nice throwback to the orange island league & chance to see a rematch Harrison: a chance for Ash to have a rematch after losing in the Johto league Brandon: a worthy competitor and chance to showcase some new Regi Pokémon Virgil: an actual battle to unfold between Ash and Virgil's team of evolved eevees Sawyer: a chance to see how far he has come since the Kalos league Kukui: an opportunity for Ash to use his Incineroar and reunite with his mentor Cynthia and her mega Garchomp would be a nice one to showcase in a future video

[@diyar728]

Would be epic to see Paul taking revenge on Brandon

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

That it would, I want to see it soo bad

[@Starmeistr]

HARRISON!!! THIS VIDEO IS A 10/10! (i'll pretend i didn't see the lance slander at the end tho)

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Glad to hear that XD

[@ShadowDinosaurNetworkTV]

It's coming to the point of us wondering Tobias even existed with how "off the grid" the dude is. XD

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Him and every other character the day Ash met 🤣

[@kaihiwatari3855]

Absolutely agree with you Prof. It's already saddening enough that these Hyper_Awesome Characters are not even mentioned in Journeys and let alone participate in the World Tournament. I can imagine how incredible it would've been when all the characters who've lost/tied/beaten Ash, see him climbing up the ladder/rankings and get motivated to take back revenge on him. Similarly vice versa for Ash too. Writers of Journeys have failed us fans a lot & making Alan loosing to Leon in such a terrible way was the FINAL NAIL IN THE COFFIN! Sabrina could've replaced Lance as Kanto's Champion instead of making him a double regional champ. Tobais could've beaten a strong champion like Iris or Diantha and swooped his way on to the Final 8. Kukui/Gladion/Paul/Brandon/Drake/Harrison/Sawyer could've shown why they are the some of the best brawlers out there. And most importantly ASH COULD'VE BROUGHT BACK HIS OLD MONS BACK! 😭 Im Heartbroken man. 💔

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

I suppose the happy medium would be a master's 16 :)

[@kaihiwatari3855]

@@ProfessorAlexSilver 😅 for sure! Strong Quarterfinals, Spectacular Semis and Grandest Final! 🎇

[@bigbaddwolf90]

Great list! Makes me want to battle!

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Thanks! Time to get to it haha

[@wonderlady5835]

my thoughts for the other 8 champions 1 Tobias 2 Harrison 3 Jon Dickson 4 Virgil 5 Tyson 6 Paul 7 Kalos Queen Aria 8 Ritchie and the following 8 Coordinators 1 Zoey 2 Gladion 3 Cameron 4 Alder 5 Kukui 6 Drake 7 Robert 8 Sawyer the Alpha 8 Masters 1 Roxy 2 Wallace 3 Sabrina 4 Solidad 5 Brandon 6 Hop 7 Dr Abby 8 Misty

[@ryebur7625]

Brandon vs Tobias would be amazing

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Brandon all the way!

[@PEEshooter-pr3sq]

Tobias would win if 3 regis goes down. Brandon needs to catch new regis in order to make it fair.

[@PaperCutVictim]

Sabrina I never thought about, but hard agree on everyone else. It woulda been really cool to have these trainers included and either expand Masters 8 to a 16 trainer tournament, or they really shoulda been faced somewhere in the Ultra Class. I know they all had the option to not participate (Paul for example would definitely have been Ultra caliber, if not Master, but he didn't participate), but still.

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Sabrina always seemed unbeatable to me so I'd love to see her in a real battle

[@patrickkh1245]

Ash could battle all the previous tournament winners. Ash, John Dickson, Tyson, Virgil, Sawyer, Drake, Kukui or Gladion and Tobias. They all represent a different a region. I really like This idea. I really want Brandon, the paldea champion and Paul to be in the masters 8 too though. Another masters 8 could be Ash, sawyer, Kukui, Tobias, Brandon, the paldea champion, Paul and Noland. Maby Alder, Ritchie, Gladion, Mustard and Wallace since they have been champions.

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

John dickson has always been a character of interest for me

[@mauriziobernotti9171]

Not featuring any Frontier brain in the coronation series was a huge missed opportunity

[@lulukomadori9651]

It didn't even had to be Champion 8, Journey could of been the biggest fan service for each anime but it just didn't felt like much. Also rip Galar, they really done it dirty

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

A lot of the throwaway characters in the normal class could have been Ash's old rivals or at least characters of the day

[@andrewxu3602]

@@ProfessorAlexSilver I wonder if the writer didn't commit to having Journeys feature so many character returns and continuity references until the second half of its run. It would've been cool to have the continuity-fest nature of Journeys begin from the very start: constantly bringing back characters of the day for WCS battles, and constantly having Ash use his reserves throughout the entire series.

[@Yajjay833]

After watching nostalgia return Those days when dragonite was almost invincible and only pokemon who can use multiple type attacks The original dragon too

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Once Paul beat one with his honchkrow it was all downhill haha

[@ShadowRose759]

I feel like Sabrina should show as a contester for Ash, with 20 years in the making she could have more then what we've seen her had along with a proper battle

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

I'd love to see Mega Alakazam on her team

[@joek6820]

All great trainers to add!! I always said it should have been a top 16!

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

That would have been sick!

[@Rob17Cotton]

I'd say with Tobias not being mentioned or being in the masters 8 maybe it's that he couldn't defeat Cynthia after beating the elite four

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Definitely implies that

[@HAMMOS75]

we don't know if he could have challenged the elite four or Cynthia,we don't know what his Goal was,can't u think that his goal is probably to defeat mewtwo or something like that

[@tomkarate1]

That would have been some very nice storytelling; having Drake make it to the masters 8 using only his Dragonite. PS. I am disappointed that Ash did not visit the Orange Islands in Journeys

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

I would love for the orange Islands to get more love in the future it's my favorite saga

[@deshawnedwards6412]

4:44 It's said that Alain lost to Leon still scarred the Professor till this day.

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

XD hahaha

[@muhammadamrimohdrashidi8107]

Imagine if these 8 trainers did compete with the top 8 and we'd have a Masters 16.

[@Yajjay833]

Cool

[@gamerookie09]

I think a Master's 16 would be a good idea. You have two trainers from each region. Kanto-- Brandon & Sabrina Johto- Lance & Clair? Hoenn- Steven & Wallace Sinnoh- Cynthia & Paul Unova- Iris & Alder Kalos- Diantha & Alain Sun & Moon- Ash & Kukui Galar- Leon & Raihan

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

The only problem is that it might have been super rushed like the eight has been

[@Tom-dn6zy]

Tobias>paul

[@gamerookie09]

@@ProfessorAlexSilver In my version, the arc is fully fleshed out.

[@deshawnedwards6412]

Maybe you should do an Part 2-ter video, as you said there are plenty of other trainers in the anime that could've also been included in the Masters 8. Ritchie, Clair, Morrison, Tyson, Nando, Conway, Barry, Trip, Skyla, Elesa, Olympia, Wulfric, Gladion, Hau, Hala, Acerola, Olivia, ect. Just to name an few other trainers that could have been mentioned. And maybe you could also some Ash's other Friends from past seasons, Misty, Brock, Tracey, Cilan, Clemont, Lana, Kiawe, Sophocles.

[@immortallegacy100]

I pretty much agree with all the above, except I'm gonna add Casey from the Johto saga. I wish she'd been the trainer with Meganium that challenged Ash and Pikachu earlier in Journeys. Ash battling the Beedrill he caught for Casey would've been fun. Ash helping Brandon catch the two new Regis from Galar only to battle them later would've been cool. Perhaps a double battle with Pikachu and Dragonite teaming up? Tobias being Ash's last challenge before entering the Masters 8 would've been very fitting. I also miss Sakura from the Johto Saga (and Chronicles) she was a really interesting character in my opinion, appearing in no less than three episodes throughout Johto, and seeing her again would've been really cool. Perhaps she went on to win a league since then. Agatha deserves a special mention since Ash has battled her before, and she could've helped teach Gengar a few things. Overall, I love returning characters, but I REALLY wish we got to see some of Ash's reserves make an appearance and perhaps evolve after all these years. I'll forever be a fan of Kingler, but Snorlax, Heracross, and others deserve some love as well. That's partially what made the Battle Frontier saga so great, as well as the Sinnoh League (minus the battle with Tobias where Ash kinda scraped the barrel lol).

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

I always thought it was strange that Casey didn't appear at the league

[@sumirsookdeo9443]

Hopefully? Lol I enjoy watching your videos, great work! It's well put together.

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Thanks!!

[@josephward1071]

Well for those 8 Pokemon Characters no doubt their teams would be awesome (Sabrina) Alakazam(Kadabra most likely evolved) Gengar(Haunter most likely evolved) Girafarig Metagross Espeon Gardevoir (Drake) Venusaur Dragonite Ditto Gengar Steelix(Onix most likely evolved) Electivire(Electabuzz most likely evolved) (Harrison) Blaziken Steelix Kecleon Hypno Houndoom Weavile(Sneasel most likely evolved) (Brandon) Regirock Registeel Regice Dusknoir(Dusclops most likely evolved) Ninjask Solrock (Tobias) Darkrai Latios Groudon(most likely) Entei(most likely) Charizard(most likely) Zoroark(most likely) (Virgil) Umbreon Flareon Espeon Jolteon Glaceon Slyveon(if possible) (Sawyer) Sceptile Slaking Salamence Aegislash Clawitzer Slurpuff (Kuikui) Inceroar Venusaur Emploleon Braviary Lucario Kommo-o(if Tapu Koko didn't interrupt)

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Great lineups!

[@josephward1071]

@@ProfessorAlexSilver Thanks

[@JarlQboyq]

The best reason I can give is it requires trainers to travel around and appear for battles no matter the location. Probably doesn't show on the anime since Ash just happened to be nearby them all so they could've all been entered and not fought enough.

[@eliassmeke3991]

Hey 👋 Professor I had this idea 💡 for a story about Mairin, when you planned to do the history video of Mairin I want to text what happened to Mairin from the anime when she runs in the forest 🌳 and a pack of Houndour attacked and chased her.

[@yamiemi1521]

Even though I don’t like Tyson I think it be a cool idea to have a Dynamax Meowth battle against Ash’s Dynamax Pikachu since they got their own unique forms.

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

That'd be awesome. Hope ash wins this time lol

[@vagabond4576]

I would have liked AJ to come back. He was a undefeated gym trainer that was all about harsh training and making his pokemon train under conditions that were a weakness to them. Even Gary during his smug days couldnt beat AJ.

[@HAMMOS75]

How dyk gary couldn't have beaten AJ

[@Hydra111-v6r]

You know what i really like your backround

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Thanks, me too XD

[@patrickkh1245]

Ok, here is the true 10 strongest trainers in my opinion in order. Ash, Leon, Cynthia, Tobias, Brandon, raihan, Diantha, steven, lance, kukui.

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Nice changeup :)

[@luke_oso5124]

I thought of this and it sounded really cool. What if Ash had a mega stone for his Gengar and even though he can gigantimax him but if he could dynamax him he can mega evolve him and use a z move if he had a ghost or dark type z crystal. The idea is good.

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

I'd prefer a mega stone but I suppose they can only show so much of each

[@Jack-by8lb]

I think that if Pokemon was willing to go all out, they could've added Giovanni as a wild card into the Masters Eight. We know he's a very strong trainer, and back in Unova he was able to defeat Ash with little effort. So seeing a full battle between Ash and Giovanni in the Masters Eight could've been one of the best battles in the entierty of Journeys in my opinion. Also, for video ideas, if you were planning to do more Elite Four teams, I would like to see videos possibly on other friends of Ash, like if Clemont or Brock were Elite Four members.

[@langadube9611]

Truth he told that would be a bad idea unless the anime is willing to make Leon lose to him which is something they wouldn't do given how much hype he has. Ash can't battle him in the first round, and then there's Cynthia in the second.

[@peightonspeth6857]

The Champions were good to put in the masters 8 with Ash but I think the last one shouldn't have been Alain especially with his quick takedown. Tobias would of been a better one to put in there or even a member of the elite four. Virgil too would of been a good one if he had a battle with Ash

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Definitely a better option

[@peightonspeth6857]

@@ProfessorAlexSilver thoughts on how Diantha vs Leon battle went?

[@SerenitySpiderMonkey]

Ritchie Katie Lara Otoshi Anabel Gizelle Kiawe Lana honorable mentions: AJ, Asunta, Jennette, Mandi, Pete, Miki, and Melissa

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Nice list!

[@luke_oso5124]

Also Professor? I just realized this too. That Paul’s Ursaring used Hyper Beam in only 2 episodes. One when attacking ash and his friends and when saving Chimchar from Team Rocket.

[@row4509]

If Tobias had been in the masters, we would’ve rioted. Anybody, but that dude. 😊

[@RescueSquadCulp]

Ash vs Erika in the Masters 8 would be great to see of an official match

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

That'd be fun!

[@EspyJuju]

I would have loved for Ritchie to show up and get to have a rematch using Pokemon Ash himself owns. Charizard vs Charizard, Pikachu vs. Pikachu, etc. Great video!

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

That'd be sick! Maybe Swellow too :)

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Or Tyranitar VS Dragonite

[@EspyJuju]

@@ProfessorAlexSilver I'm pretty confident Ash's Swellow can take on anyone else's bird pokemon and win. Haha. And yes! Cruise vs Dragonite would be an amazing battle!

[@jaredlanglitz5651]

I have to agree with you in terms of Sabrina, Harrison, Virgil, and Kukui. It would give Eevee the opportunity to Gigantimax or become Sylveon, also Ash and Kukui’s Incineroar could duke it out once again. It would’ve been nice to see Paul in the masters eight to see how far he and Ash have come since the Sinnoh league.

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

I'm all for anything that gives more Team Eevee

[@wanderlustwarrior]

I'd love to see Sabrina again!

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Same here! She's one of my favorite characters

[@wanderlustwarrior]

@@ProfessorAlexSilver If she reappeared, her lightened mood would actually fit her redesign costume.

[@jrbtransport5405]

My 8 are: Gary, sawyer, Paul, kukui, tyson, branden, tobyes and kamren

[@HAMMOS75]

No way bro said Cameron

[@crimsonflareumbreon1290]

Tobias is actually the only person who beat a league without losing more than two pokemon cause ash is the only person we know that was able to beat his darkri

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

perhaps we'll learn leon/cynthia/steven did the same, some day

[@marcuselmore8369]

They didn’t want Tobias to GG everyone

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Good point haha

[@cursedsailor7473]

If Brandon would be in Master 8 his team would be Regirock, Regice, Registeel, Regieleki, Regidrago, and Regigigas. _Waaaaaay_ too OP.

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Wait till he fights Greninja :)

[@cursedsailor7473]

@@ProfessorAlexSilver Greninja solos the Narutoverse.

[@wiseguy1512]

@@ProfessorAlexSilver Wait till Regigigas reaches their fifth turn… I’m just saying that titan moved continents with his bare hands.

[@HAMMOS75]

Tobias has a chance to defeat that team

[@juliettek.9440]

I would have loved to see Virgil, his Eevee probably would have been a Sylveon by now. Very much like Sakura when her eevee evolved into an Espeon. Predictable but satisfying. It would also be interesting to see Ash take on another Sylveon. This time maybe with his Dragonite.

[@bluefirekid]

In the lower ranks, having Ash rematch the league rivals he never got to defeat would have been nice closures. Especially with how returns are being handled in JN. (In Harrison's case; assuming Alain is still in, I think they'd opt for Char Y for Ash to differentiate. Still don't think Tobias would have made it in because of him having Legends.) Same with Sabrina, would have been a nice match for Gengar.

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Most definitely, and all they would have needed was a brief flashback to remind viewers of the battle. It could be fun for New viewers as well as all of those characters had really cool aces

[@PkmnTrainerEmerald]

i agree Brandon and Virgil should have been here! Virgil proved to be powerful with his eeveelutions and Ash never battled each other. Brandon could have been so perfect given how he could have helped both Goh and Ash with this research on the regis! Still the biggest missed opportunity not to even mention him in Journeys not even when Paul returned.

[@zyquaviontroupe1720]

No Paul is crazy

[@Nothing-141]

I love pokemon journies. But they could add more Ash rivals into the tournament beside the our champions from from diff regions.

[@mellyjordan1199]

I don't see how any of them would've been the strongest trainers in the World....

[@patrickkh1245]

Another masters 8 could be Ash, sawyer, Kukui, Tobias, Brandon, Gladion, Paul and Noland. Maby Alder, Ritchie, the paldea champion, Mustard and Wallace since they have been champions.

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Gladion would be great!

[@timolee]

Misty should have been in masters since her goal is to be a water pokemon master. she was the first companion who had the goal of being a master along with ash. would be nice to have seen her pokemon level up and be hardcore and see her take on champions after training for so long as a gym leader and having traveled multiple regions. she was the first of ash's companions to battle a gym and enter a cup and even made it further than ash in the whirl cup. she would have been great in masters 8.

[@markpuga5351]

Hi professor, great video, I've been watching some of the hoenn episodes of pokemon on pokemon TV, and so maybe some more hoenn region pokemon like jesse's serviper or James cacnea could probably be some pokemon to be talked about in a future video.

[@Yajjay833]

Bro how to watch poke episodes on pokemon TV I mean to aces this

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

I'll be doing a huge Hoenn character very soon 😄

[@supercrazygamer00x68]

i expect them to be in the masters 8 in the previous year befor the one ash is in

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

That'd be dope!

[@sirenstrike4163]

I was hard rooting for Brandon to be a part of the Masters 8 before we learned who the final competitors were. I also thought it would have been fun to seen Benga from BW2 take Iris' spot, as we already saw her lose to Ash once - though maybe making her champion only to get outclassed by Benga almost immediately would have been too disrespectful

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

I was thinking that he was a shoe in before it was announced to be only champions

[@cornap1]

Early for this class

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Welcome!

[@langadube9611]

The Masters 8 tournament should've been the Masters 16. Round one would be 1v1, Round 2 3v3, Round 4 6v6 and the finals 6v6.

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

100% agreed

[@siddharthashwath3696]

I would have liked to see Paul also in the masters 8 uk, instead of mentorship to Ash. But anyways what can u expect it is journeys🤣

[@aldordz5768]

Even if not part of the 8 masters, I still would like them to return. Maybe their absence could be explained because of loosing to someone stronger offscreen or not been interest in the tournament like Paul?

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Brandon especially should have returned given the new regis in my opinion

[@aldordz5768]

@@ProfessorAlexSilver that could have been an interesting plot for an episode, but personally I’m satisfied with how we last saw him separating from his main Pokémons. Now will never know if Paul could have defeated him with the 3 Regis.

[@Dejimon11]

Honestly I feel like this entire tournament would have been a lot better if it focused on older characters coming back to see how strong they’ve gotten since their debut. It would have been great if somebody like Ritchie(who never got a proper rematch) and Casey had entered. Or even use it as an excuse to introduce game characters who only made cameos in movies like Brendan and Lucas.

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

I would have loved to see characters like samurai and AJ as well

[@elsarules2870]

Having not yet got caught up on Journeys, I do think that it would have been nice to see at least more rivals return, even if it was to challenge Ash before the Top 8. Or at the very least, tell us where some of them are ranked! If Tobias isn't in the upper Ultra Class at minimum, then is he even competing? What about the others? I could see Brandon not competing, but I would have loved to see/hear about a shake-up to Kanto's Elite Four, adding in Sabrina as Lance's regular challenger, in the same way that Lance and Leon are regular challengers!

[@srikanthreddy9905]

I really hope that the Pokemon company considers you as one the writers for the upcoming Pokemon series 😍😍 you have so many great ideas which can correctly channelised too . The latest Pokemon series have become so boring , no strategies , no seriousness i had a feeling to stop watching them 😥😥. keep continuing your good work sir😃😃😃

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Thanks! That would be a dream

[@NoPulseGames]

I hoped the masters 8 to be Leon, Tobias, Cynthia, Ash, Steven, Gladion, Alan and Brandon. Genuinely the strongest trainers in the anime's history, and would've led to some amazing battles. Gladion vs Leon, Ash and Alan getting a sequel (which should've happened tbh) and Cynthia vs Brandon all would've been amazing matches

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

I'd dig that!

[@paolocalapatia6401]

MY Thoughts: There are already reps for each Region BUT… …Sabrina, Drake, Sawyer, & Conference Winners can be PWC Challengers Only one I MIGHT agree with is Brandon🔺 If I were to suggest one person for Masters8, MAYBE Karen of Johto Elite4 to give more Rep for Johto😈

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

I'm still waiting for Karen to make her debut

[@trinidadjthebarber7192]

Sawyer masters 8? Damn I must have spilled some crack in my oatmeal this morning

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Time to get a doctor then XD

[@trinidadjthebarber7192]

@@ProfessorAlexSilver 😂😂

[@ybyplays3133]

Giovani would be really awsome to see so he can figth Ash

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

I'd love that as well, hopefully ash obliterates him

[@jeopardy-alpha]

Got to agree for Sabrina and Brandon, Professor Silver. My beloved teacher! It would make me starstruck and extremely excited if Lisa Orbitz got back to voice Sabrina again. As she managed to do the same already for Korrina I think. But we totally need Brandon, Sabrina, along with other characters to come back in the anime for us, the fans at some point! 😄😄😄

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Good to hear that! They would have been dope :)

[@jeopardy-alpha]

@@ProfessorAlexSilver ikr Professor Silver, along with us needing the dark elite four of Johto in the anime. The delightful Karen who could have a opposite personality compared to Nanu. For once for us the fans. :)

[@ariohandoyo5973]

Yup is up to you prof, video on Sceptile would be great Treekcko is my favorite pokemon anyway.😎

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Very soon :-)

[@ariohandoyo5973]

@@ProfessorAlexSilver ok

[@Dueling101able]

Mega Sceptile until Leon’s Rillaboom started disrespecting everyone 😭

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

🤣🤣

[@qqqqqqqqqqqq121212]

I do kinda wish Pokémon Journeys established more trainers in the Coronation Series - other than just those fighting Ash. Would it have been a problem for Paul to show had was rank 14 or something, rather than giving a lame excuse for not competing? That said Journeys completely yadder yadder’d how the ranking system actually worked (Ash’s rank should have been fluctuating up-and-down as other trainers battled, especially during the normal and super rank) And how did Ash get to be the one battling Raihan for a place in the M8? Surely he wasn’t the only trainer to win 4 Ultra class battles? Perhaps it’s best they didn’t draw to much attention to it…

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

I was really surprised there weren't more returning characters for ash to battle

[@bubbletea_]

would’ve been hilarious to see tobias enter only to get disqualified for cheating because his pokémon were clearly haxed.

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

haha, that would be quite funny

[@kuitaranheatmorus9932]

Sabrina and Drake rivals for Ash would be my picks Also this video was just really great,and hope y'all have a great day

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Thank you! Have a good day too :)

[@kinghunter8247]

I have always thought that having the master 8 champions was one of the most obvious and boring decisions of this competition, sure it has a lot of logic, but it makes you wonder why so much mystery at the beginning, besides all the wasted opportunity by not including Old characters like Tobias or Kukui

[@garchompgamer1874]

I feel it would’ve been better if Ash faced Alain and Lance faced Steven

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

I wanted Ash to fight Alain & Lance to fight Iris. Steven VS Ash was actually on my wish list, but perhaps round 2 would have been better

[@montecristosmith2343]

Out of these I'd pick Brandon and Tobias. Esp Brandon since he only used 1 Regi per battle with Ash. Also wouldn't mind seeing Ash face Ritchie or even Jimmy. I'm down with Kukui being included but I would've loved to see him face Lance and get the win since Lance defeated him during his own journey.

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Lance vs masked royal would be sick!

[@bige81892]

I think Tyson and his meowth in boots should be on this list. I’d love to see pikachu get its revenge after it lost to meowth by a hair.

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

They're great too -- I used Brandon as the "Hoenn" stand-in but he was my 9th option

[@bige81892]

@@ProfessorAlexSilver I agree that between those two, it should go to Brandon

[@chinmaykulkarni7835]

You had me at Sabrina and Drake

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

Great minds think alike

[@sageblast3143]

What I didn't like was the Ash had to work all his way upto the master rank to square off against Champions : something he should have been able to do in his capacity as Champion of Alola

[@ProfessorAlexSilver]

I think the rest of them had to do the same so at least they're on even footing