The Most TWISTED Case You've Ever Heard | Documentary

[@abztractboxingandstuff8384]

I believe that if someone has already been convicted of violent sexual crimes against women and children, for the sake of the innocent and vulnerable in our society they should never be released again.

[@j4kgang921]

Yup...AGREE!!!

[@brittanycampbell2099]

Yesss, there’s absolutely no rehabilitation for SA, especially towards children. You will always be demonic, I’ll die on this hill.

[@HisgGalore]

🙌🏿👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿

[@BattleBladeWarrior]

I believe if they've been convicted of violent and sexual crimes, they should be put down. If nothing else, but for the safety of others. The needs of the many outweigh the few. And its not fair to put thousands of woman and children at risk everyday, just to give these violent criminals another chance

[@82Ispy]

Pedophiles deserve death panelty period!!!!

[@bobbierobinson6269]

These judges who let child predators off easy should be investigated. Nobody should give a person like this a 2nd chance.

[@aztecempire4206]

In all seriousness why do judges give these type of criminals light Sentences? Someone who's done a non violent crime can do more time in prison than those child molestors

[@Subawoo123]

@@aztecempire4206 because it never affects them or their families personally, they live in gated communities or with 24/7 protection. Have these types of criminals move next door to the judges that release them and watch how fast their sentences change.

[@SunshineCountryChickens]

@@Subawoo123 They protect their own, get it?

[@SunshineCountryChickens]

@@aztecempire4206 We keep telling you pedo monsters run the world but you refuse to believe it

[@dtw63]

I think the judges who let these criminals off easy should have them paroled to their house and be responsible for them and their actions.

[@erinbeitlich7310]

Her mother died of an overdose. Everything about this case is so so devastating. It could’ve been prevented if the people had locked him up when he was supposed to be.

[@truffles2721]

The parents were not very stable or responsible.

[@erikaxchristine]

Ugh how awful

[@gasmith7486]

@@truffles2721 Joseph Smith was one of Carlie’s mother’s druggie friends.

[@melissabrannam5268]

Oh no, However I know as a parent if my child died I would die with him. May they both RIP.

[@pooperscooper8791]

Drug addicted

[@teganlewis6091]

this is why i take my dog EVERYWHERE with me now, i have a giant bull mastiff who always protects me. A few years ago when i was 13 i was walking my dog and he was off the lead and i suppose the man didnt see him. He tried to grab me and pull me around the corner to where his car was parked with the boot open. My dog heard me scream and instantly ran over to protect me. He went for the man and scared him off. he saved my life, i love him with all my heart ❤️❤️

[@mackenzie5102]

Wow that’s crazy I’m so glad you weren’t hurt

[@michellestella7477]

@Basado Americano you realise that a world outside the US exists, right?!

[@rickmorgan1441]

dont let such a dog run loose in public

[@ping5258]

​@Basado Americano Not everyone is american 💀

[@ButterHeroBread]

​@Basado Americano Average Americans be like

[@tabbycat6458]

Convicted 13 times, there's something seriously wrong with the justice system in America.

[@chanelle7484]

It’s completely broken. This happens why too often. More often than what we hear.

[@MrThejoet75]

Thank your local Democrat judge or DA.

[@Adelicows]

And yet Europeans think Americans give prison sentences that are way too long.

[@Adelicows]

@@MrThejoet75 this was 2004. For ~YEARS~ prior, the president of the US was a Republican, the Florida governor was a Republican, most of the the Sarasota judges were Republican, and most of the justices of the Supreme Court were Republican. Blaming parties instead of people just makes you look uneducated and close minded.

[@JK-tt2um]

And here in the UK.

[@hannahxx17]

Can we talk about how AMAZAING her mother did on that phone call to 911. You can tell she's distraught but is holding it together to give very clear, detailed information based on all the last known information she had. Most people panic and freak out and cant concentrate on those details and can take longer to get help. Her mother, despite her obvious distress, fought through those emotions to do everything she could to help Carlie. That is a sign of strength that I don't think most people could ever have. What an incredible mother.

[@Tanyah-]

Sadly her mum passed away a few years ago 😢 Now reunited with Carlie 💕

[@pamelaann846]

Your right. I noticed the same thing. I don't know if I'd be able to hold it together like that.

[@Stephanie-ju6jw]

When I lost my oldest (who was 4 at the time in Walmart) I was an utter basket case they kept asking me what she was wearing and her hair colour and I couldn’t remember anything but she was beautiful and had curly hair 👩🏼‍🦱

[@Leyla7292]

@@Tanyah- OH no! Do u know why she died? Becuse she could not have been more than maximum 50 year, & that's way 2 soon 2 die 😔

[@Anthony.and.Bigsis]

Because thats what you always do in any situation for your children hold it together and be strong to do whats best for them.

[@kelseyrossi3648]

Carlie was my sisters best friend. I can't believe it's almost been 20 years😭 This was incredibly difficult to watch. Carlie's death destroyed their family and indelibly effected ours. Joseph P. Smith's death sentence being over-turned and reduced to life w/o possibility of parole, re-opened the old wounds. Joseph died recently in prison 👏 too humane for him, but glad none-the-less. The fact that he had daughter's of his own, is even more disturbing. Beautiful Carlie, We miss you. Allie misses you🥺💕 You didn't deserve this. You haven't been forgotten. The school still tends your garden, the church too. I kissed your pictured last night. We have kids now, they know you too. You are our angel. Rest in peace with momma. See you on the other side🙏💗😇

[@dominiquelarae4576]

❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@pamelaann846]

I remember this story on the news right when it happened. Absolutely horrible.And I can't believe it's been 20 years also. She would be a beautiful young woman right now. This dude is a monster.

[@parrotsandmore7446]

I remember watching this clip on the news 20yrs ago. I was hoping they found her alive. I’m sorry for your sisters loss.

[@gasmith7486]

Susan only cared about Susan and Smith was one of her druggie friends.

[@RainCloud848]

@@kelseyrossi3648 She is referring to the murderer being dead! Who cares about his sorry butt? I have no sympathy for criminals!

[@ImDhaBombLikeTikTik]

I really appreciate how you provided steps to avoid abduction. It really shows that you care for the safety of others and wouldn't want anything like this to happen to anyone. I'll definitely teach my child this, thank you very much.

[@hayleiwiddis6099]

fr my fav channel for vids like these

[@JHyde-tv3if]

I see some parents give me an odd look when I follow my kids every step in the park while they sit back and watch on their phone but like.. my kids are too young to teach prevention measures to and anyone could easily snatch them from the park. You are damn right ima be all over my kids' ass

[@uvaldestrongalways]

@@JHyde-tv3ifthey can GFT with those dirty looks.. id rather be on their ass than end up in a case like this …

[@JME1186]

@@JHyde-tv3iffacts. I couldn’t give less a shit what any other human being thinks of how close i monitor my daughter. She will have the freedom to live her life on her terms, but I’ll continue playing the sidelines and making sure she’s safe.

[@JOSEPH-vs2gc]

Not letting a 11 year old walk by herself for an hour and a half in a sketchy area seems like a bit of a no-brainer though. As horrible as this is, you can't help but question the parents. Or the step-dad who wanted drugs after the whole thing "blew over"

[@jannar1447]

I really appreciate how you paused the story to give some tips on how to avoid abduction. I started martial arts when I was around 11 and one of the first things they taught us was NEVER go to a secondary location with a stranger - fight with everything in you to keep it from happening. That lesson saved my life about 2 years later. I will be teaching my kids that when they're old enough. This case is so heartbreaking - it's terrifying as a woman and mother that there are monsters like this walking the same streets as us. Thank you for the great coverage of the case

[@sciencenotstigma9534]

Yes! I wish I had put my kids in martial arts. They’re ok, but I know it can help with bullying, too.

[@FatRescueSwimmer04]

This applies to all situations even when being Abducted abroad... Your best and maybe ONLY chance to escape is right away. So you def were taught well, although I highly highly recommend not relying on Martial Arts to save your life (Most of it isn't very useful in actual situations especially if your attacker is larger and stronger or even worse has a Knife/blunt object or even a Firearm) but a Handgun CAN. Glad it saved you in that one situation though!

[@icallmysugarcandy]

I was thinking the same thing. So important kids learn what to do if the situation ever arises. So glad to hear it saved you!

[@theoryofpersonality1420]

You don't have to wait. If they can walk they are old enough. I taught my child to yell as a baby if anyone tried to touch them that wasn't me. It saved her life one day. We were in a store and I had my hand on the cart and a man reached between the cart and me acting like he was going to reach for something on the shelf. He instead was going to take my child out of the cart. He touched her and she screamed. I shoved him back and screamed pedophile, security, help, security. When people looked I pointed and yelled he tried to steal my baby. He ran. Two other times someone has tried to take my child. We were stalked in a toys r us and again at a grocery store. When I was three a man tried to take me out of our car. Be ever watchful and vigilant. The more you pay attention the more you will see. May God keep you and yours safe.

[@AwesomeIan135]

I especially loved the tip they gave of creating a safe word, that can help give a child the ability to determine whether or not to trust a stranger. My brother and I set up a similar plan to avoid ur grandmother ever getting scammed by someone pretending to be one of us, except instead of a safe word she is supposed to ask us how our sister is doing (we have no sister). The idea being that my brother and I would point out that we don’t have a sister, while someone attempting to scam our grandmother would just go with it and say something along the lines of she’s doing well. I can’t think of a way to use that as a way to prevent abduction, but if someone can I’d love to hear it!

[@mikhalaa746]

The fact that he blames DRUGS is truly disgusting. He had evil intentions and was just waiting for the perfect victim.

[@mydogma7116]

Exactly great point... misinformation the person was a predator... death penalty too EZ...

[@dmreddragon6]

If something makes you feel violent, or excessively reckless, yet you still choose to do it. It is all on you.

[@FelineBlue]

@@dmreddragon6 absolutely. and drugs aren't going to suddenly make you want to do something like this. they just remove your inhibition and ability to stop yourself. the desire was already there.

[@J2982able]

@@FelineBlue In vito veritas, no? Hundred percent, the drugs and alcohol didn't make these slimeballs do anything they wouldn't have done already. Just made the little voice a lot quieter.

[@plops993]

Ya, my friends and I have experimented with just about every drug under the sun, never made any of us want to kidnap someone

[@MaryQueenOfDots]

I have three sons, the oldest two are 12 and 10. When they have their friends over, from the second the child walks into my home, I take full responsibility for that child, right up until I release them directly into their parental care, am I free of that responsibility. I’ve been told by several parents ‘to let them walk home, it’s up the rd.’ and I never do, either myself or my husband will get them home & this is exactly why.

[@guerreroviv]

bless u

[@nates.2844]

I know a builder who's the same. He tells the kids parents that while they're at his house he's going to treat them like his kids. Including not tolerating any BS

[@cindysemblante4411]

My children are now grown but I had the same rules for my children’s friends when they came to my house they were my responsibility. Your the kind of parent I would have been comfortable with over seeing my children

[@aliciaramos4747]

Thank you for caring for other kids that come to your home. My kids are grown but I always watched their friends while at my home. I always made sure they got home safe. I took care of them like my own. I always watched my kids well into their teens. I was a single mom and never had a boyfriend or even dated after my divorce. Sometimes things happen in the home or out so keep a close eye on your kids. The friends mom was wrong to let Carlie leave, she should have drove her home or called Carlie's mom before Carlie left. So heartbreaking.💔😢

[@sarahraymond5564]

@@aliciaramos4747 I was thinking the same thing when they were talking about teaching a 'safe word' to your children to prove its ok to leave with another person. Back when employers thought parental responsibilities ceased to exist while working ( I remember my mother being panicked her boss would flip if I had to call her at work for any reason) and before cell phones, a safe word was at least some form of verification but now if my child and I haven't spoken directly on the phone I didn't say it. The same goes with any adult responsible for my child. They say they're allowed to do something I haven't specifically approved with you beforehand you best be making a call to me to verify. An actual voice call too not a text. I would absolutely blame the friends parent if something happened to my child because they chose to believe my 11 year old had permission to leave and walk home by themself and allowed them to do so without confirming with me. I had my best friends two early teen girls living with me on and off for years before I even had a child of my own and I called her to verify everything those girls claimed she gave permission for them to do. If it was something I was uncomfortable with I still wouldn't allow it even if their Mom said they could because she wasn't there to be responsible for it, I was.

[@lmschultz2445]

He lived longer on death row than this poor little girl lived period. That is beyond ridiculous.

[@bennu547]

He murdered a child. He had a target on his back the second he stepped foot in that prison. You think that he had it easy in prison? Prison isn’t a hotel get away

[@lmschultz2445]

@@bennu547 I don't know how he had it in prison. I know a lot of serial killers have been better protected than I ever will be. Even if complete misery was an everyday occurrence, it still isn't good enough. Also- the number of heinous criminals that were released back into society because of our ridiculous justice system is staggering. That's my fear when these rabid humans are allowed to live. Until you've been a victim of a violent crime or someone you love has, your opinion is in a much different space. And I hope that never happens to you.

[@seattlevixen]

@bennu547 who gives a shit how he had it in prison? The worse the better, he still lived while she didn't

[@lmschultz2445]

@@seattlevixen Precisely

[@Carlos-vw7xk]

@@lmschultz2445Yes. The whole child rapist/killer gets play on social media and in movies, but how accurate is it. What is FACT is that he lived longer in prison for that crime than that sweet child lived in general.

[@Kaye794]

I can’t imagine how much fear this poor little girl was in during the final moments of her life, this is heartbreaking. My heart breaks for her and her family. RIP beautiful Carlie Brucia.

[@ImGreiving]

I can’t imagine how the parents felt knowing she was taken, let alone seeing how she was taken. It’s stuff like this that makes me scared of starting a family. And it’s irritating to see how selfish these gross people are. Like at least let them go. Anyways imma stop before I just make myself even more mad lol

[@droo3010]

Sad you can't imagine it .. even I can imagine how scared she was.

[@ImGreiving]

@@droo3010 congrats…? 🍪

[@BabcockCheng]

@@droo3010 p

[@jcdeton72]

@@ImGreiving Bro I feel you. The main reason I dont want to have kids is because how terrible this world is.

[@racheld23biscuitsmom42]

I remember this case so clearly, especially the video. The way he just led her away as though it was a normal interaction is bone chilling. In the news coverage I heard “Never allow yourself to be taken to the second location” for the first time and I’ve never forgotten it. I’m not the only one, shortly after this a young girl was almost abducted but, because she heard the same thing, she fought and screamed so the would-be abductor got scared off. They found him with horrifying tools that were meant for her. I have no doubt that Carlie and her tragic story saved at least one girl’s life.

[@kimlangston251]

I went to college for criminal justice and learned that and heard it Oprah again and that is imprinted in my memories forever.. NEVER EVER NO MATTER WHAT LET THEM TAKE YOU TO A SECOND LOCATION... ✝️🙏

[@johntaylor-lo8qx]

Fight with every ounce of energy you have. Claw eyes esp. Gr8 comment, 2nd location is a planned spot by the sickest people in our world. Why are these people allowed to exist, they are so sick they will never think like the rest of us. God Bless, our lives are so delicate and precious. This is heartbreaking. 11yrs old !!! Sick sick sick predators !!!!!

[@2tall4u_]

Bc satan rules this world, that is why sick people exist. Find Jesus Christ! He is the only way.

[@CONEHEADDK]

As somebody in some other comment section once wrote: "I was taught by my dad, to fight like hell. Bcz whatever they will do to you in public, is far less scary, than what they will do to you, if they get to be alone with you". Teach that to EVERYONE you care about.!!!

[@enishalihoward8119]

This is why parents need to instill fear in their children about strangers

[@lilianeoster982]

RIP to Carlie as well as her mother, Susan who sadly passed from a drug overdose in 2017. Carlie’s passing was just too much for her.

[@KenDignam]

I didn't no that,how very very sad,I hope they are together again 🙏

[@wcolautti]

This poor family. Oh my God. What a beautiful little girl. 😢Rest in peace Carlie and Susan.

[@burlykim132]

Omg that’s so sad. I get it though tbh. I can see how that pain would be too much.

[@vickiyeah]

It's absolutely infuriating to know a dangerous repeat offender can just be out roaming freely like this. RIP Carlie.

[@Slurpee99]

Why are they allowed to roam freely? Most murder or rape cases showed the perpetrators have criminal records. Did the law learned nothing?

[@iramsavir5631]

@@Slurpee99 No, nothing has changed. They treat sex crimes almost as misdemeanors. It's appalling! I think all those in the justice system must be corrupt and perverted! These human filth continue to breathe and walk the earth leaving a trail of destruction as they go. They hardly serve any prison time and are let out for good behavior.

[@herbthompson8937]

Thanks libs

[@nellywilliams2776]

@@herbthompson8937 the irony of your comment is that under conservatives rule, nothing is done to change laws that allow these people to walk free. They’re no better than liberals! Same coin, different sides. They’re all the same….

[@Emily-ho1mj]

exactly. this whole case couldve been prevented

[@SoCalJellybean]

Yes! For everyone watching, please remember this, just in case: do EVERYTHING possible to avoid being taken to a second location!! Your odds of survival drop drastically once that happens, but if it is absolutely unavoidable or unsuccessful, remember to leave your DNA all over that second location! Do whatever you can; spit, leave your blood, pull your hairs out, rub your clothing against a surface… even if you don’t survive, this could be the thing that allows detectives to catch the perpetrator. Be safe, guys! ♥️

[@jenniferneal8874]

This! & scratch the predator so you have his dna under your nails!!!!!

[@Repentance79]

@@jenniferneal8874 but then if it's a very twisted predator, they would cut off your fingers or whole hands to avoid that!

[@Repentance79]

@@jenniferneal8874 I think the best way is their hair if they have some...grab and pull as many as you can from root and they'll be all over the ground. They wouldn't have time to stop and collect their hairs piece by piece lol!

[@Sangwoo_oncrack]

@@Repentance79 This reminds me of that one case of an African American child whose body was discovered in a cave. Some teenagers went there to do drugs and happened upon her body which was decapitated and her limbs were cut off. She still hasn't been identified and is still known as Jane Doe. Its a very old case. Also reminds me of another South Korean case where construction workers found the body of a teenager in their construction site. I don't remember if her head was decapitated too but i do remember that the killer had sliced her hands off. She was identified by her name tag that students wear and her uniform and bag. They never caught her killer or recovered her hands. Its so scary to think about it.

[@tatertot4208]

Make sure to leave your DNA all over anywhere you've been. Or any evidence like pieces of clothing, earrings, necklace, anything

[@sirxanthor]

This horror happens all to often. Six years ago I was smoking a cigarette leaning against a tree with my daughter only six feet from me trying out her new skate shoes when a car slowed down behind her and passenger door opened as a guy made to grab her. I yelled run, which she did right back into the store as I put a rock in their rear windshield. Driver took off almost leaving his friend behind. No plates and never caught. It's one of those things that many think won't ever happen to them till it does. I drilled my kids on what never to do, even more so after that day.

[@alex_Skye]

So sorry that happened to your daughter and that you had to experience that! I know you might hear that often but truly, thank you for sharing your story, you are heard!

[@CyberusSuper]

You let the guy get away? Worthless lifeform. Be more thorough next time.

[@Lola-AreaCode212]

Omg. Where do you live? Where did this happen?

[@sirxanthor]

@@Lola-AreaCode212 California, border of Millbrae and Burlingame. Not a bad area, or at least not back then it wasn't. Not even the first incident either. From my understanding, with all the train upgrading, a ramp was moved so cars that got off came from bad areas, and would rob nearby homes and take off. Add kidnapping attempts, they could grab and be on the freeway in moments. Can't be done now, as they closed off that road and you basically have to pass a smaller PD, to access those stores and blocks now.

[@chickenmeal8910]

dont smoke

[@sophthekittie]

The death penalty should be reserved for child predators, rapists and serial killers. And should be available everywhere. Those people shouldn’t be allowed to either walk free or waste our tax payer dollars while they’re alive behind bars.

[@0Onyx13]

I agree with the premises of having harder punishment for those people, but imo death penalty is too easy. We don't know what's after life, maybe nothing, in which case they'd just stop suffering. Good old medieval torture devices should be reinstated for some individuals.

[@SueJohnson2024]

Right!? It should just be automatic! We are way too lenient to murderers: cold blooded murderers get to live their life after taking one. I’ll never understand it….😢

[@Pathfinder-qp1he]

honestly I don't think those types of criminals deserve something easy like the death penalty. they should continue to live the rest of their life slowly rotting in prison, getting off easy especially with a lethal injection seems way too unfair

[@robshane6634]

He was on death row for years and years, but sadly was overturn to life in prison. My father was friends with Joe Smith

[@rickmorgan1441]

rapists? bit harsh if he was being lead on ? what if she lied?

[@lovelight6973]

I took a self defense years ago from a police department. We practiced scenarios. One thing that they taught us was how predators can paralyze and weaken victims with intense verbal commands and threats. Surprisingly, even though we were practicing scenarios, it was actually scary and it did catch you off guard. But the more we were exposed to it, it help to lessen the fear. They found in past cases victims were terrified and paralyzed by a predator using using foul language, threats and aggressive intimidation etc. Watching the footage it looks like Smith did that. She was just blindsided by it. I hate that people like Smith can breathe air on earth. I know he's gone now but he got what 16-17 years to live longer than Carlie. We need stronger laws for sex crimes perpetrators committing against men, women and especially children!!!

[@KF-vo2yl]

Thank you for including men as potential victims of s3x crimes.

[@JJ-hr7dd]

I believe that shock can do that. People freeze in a threat. If only she screamed and shouted although it looks quiet around there.

[@MissHannah2036]

@@JJ-hr7dd Yes, it looks like she is walking through a vacant Lot or something. Maybe everyone would have been inside watching the Superbowl. Poor child only 11 would definitely be more compliant.

[@norran3830]

What's the damn point putting CCTV that can't even get a clear video footage. For God sake get a high quality CCTV !!! I don't think it will cost a lot more!! Geeeezzz......

[@lovelight6973]

yes absolutely. We're just barely touching the topic and possiblity in the media.

[@JICEL07122009]

Thank you for covering this story! Carlie lived only a few houses away from me. I was 10 at the time. People still leave flowers outside of her house, even after her family moved. McIntosh Middle made a memorial for carlie the day they announced her death and its still there today. I would pass it everyday at school. My best friend was good friends with carlie. Eventhough I didn't know her personally, this hit too close to home for me. my parents still live in the same house to date and driving by her house is heartbreaking still today. This story shocked the city of Sarasota, and has served to advise young kids in the area, including mine, her memory lives on. Her family fought hard for the death penalty but in the end carlies heartbroken mom died 4 years before that monster. It was also suspected that Joseph might've already claimed a victim in bradenton (tara Reilly-case remains unsolved) only 4 years before killing carlie. Heartbreaking :'(

[@jenwuzhere2305]

I went to school with Tara from kindergarten all the way to 12th grade💔it really broke my heart when she got killed and I know it was him💯

[@springsogourne]

Thank you for sharing this information.

[@mitradastafkan9803]

😭

[@RainCloud848]

❤

[@jaidenkersey3481]

I go to Macintosh and her memorial is still there and very pretty

[@DuckHouse1]

I always told my kids, "if someone tells you to do what they say or they'll hurt you: *don't* do what they say, because they're *going* to hurt you."

[@DKF_oli]

I was the same age as her, in the same town when this happened. I’ll definitely never forget her name, her disappearance was talked about constantly and we weren’t allowed to go anywhere by ourselves pretty much ever again. He’s a monster, just disgusting, he doesn’t even deserve to rest in peace.

[@Beccastyles_]

Seeing so many baby teeth still in her xrays just broke me. Eleven years old. She didn't even get a chance. I'm heart broken for her parents and family especially her poor mother.

[@allyb8010]

Don't pity her mother. What this faled to mention was Susan was the one woth a drug problem before and after Carlie who had no problem selling her daughters ashes for 50 bucks, selling all her daughters furniture shortly after her death, and leaving ashes behind at a drug house. Really shitty to make Steve look like he had the drug issue.

[@maryhalverson5713]

@@allyb8010 Drug use indicates illness and this mother neither caused or deserved this.

[@allyb8010]

@@maryhalverson5713 There's way more that people don't know. I lived next door and was over almost every day. Trust me you'd be sick knowing how Susan was with her.

[@annieapple8985]

True true facts

[@TheFriendlyPsychopath]

A chance for what, to be a thot?

[@TheDarkHorseRides]

As a brother of 3 sisters and a father of 2 daughters, its a crying shame that we live in a world that a 14 yr old girl and in some cases grown women can’t even walk a mile down the road by themselves in broad day light w/o the possibility of being kidnapped, raped, tortured and killed because of evil men amongst us. Btw, I guarantee you those men killed him in prison for what he did. Convict Justice!

[@firenze5555]

Poor Carlie was only 11 years old. Just a little girl. She didn't have a chance against that fiend.

[@madwhitehare3635]

Bollocks to ‘convict justice’. As though they are shining examples of humanity.

[@tinak.356]

YES, I heard that all child killers get killed or beat up really bad. Scott Peterson who killed his son Conner, has been someones Bi__CH.. YESH!!!!!

[@jplxlabelle1681]

He was strangled with a piece of clothing. Fitting end if only he’d been brutally assaulted aswell

[@deborahgonzalezknight168]

So many evil men and growing daily.

[@sandramayes8679]

To continue the story, Carlie's mother was so distraught, she got on drugs , became a hooker, and overdosed a few years later. This man ruined so many lives! Just horrible! He had daughter of his own too, what a creep!

[@jordonlittle4474]

She was on drugs before Carlie went missing.

[@Mr.Sr.Jr.]

Way to not smear her character for your own amusement... You are a gossiping c u nt Sandra Mayes. May they RIP.

[@Plumeria808]

So sad

[@paulcarpenter7844]

He had 3 daughters sick bastard this guy

[@sandramayes8679]

I forgot the s in daughter. Yeah, he had 3 daughters of his own, how could he do this to someone else's daughter? Just blows my mind...

[@mackenziekarsonovich1073]

I remember when this happened. My parents showed me the footage and used it to teach me about stranger danger. They told me if somebody ever tried this with me to scream and cry as loud as I could. It scared the shit out of me.

[@aliciaboehm4007]

I was 1 grade below Carlie and went to the same school. This is terrifying and heartbreaking when it all happened. We created a beautiful butterfly garden in her honor off the side of the 6th grade wing. May she rest in peace

[@oopsiesss]

@Tech the stupidity youve displayed today is massive. 10/10

[@overmidnight]

@Tech what the heck are you talking about? She was wearing proper clothes for an 11 year old. Now you're blaming her?

[@oopsiesss]

@Tech if you believe that this gives anybody a right on her body then you're a sick bastard

[@adesanyaadejoke9103]

@Tech may God reward you according to this your comment, and except you don't have children will this thing you've said go unpunished. It irks me to see people with low thinking like you comment on a sad n heartbreaking event like this.

[@SportsBoss999]

That must have shaken you to the core. A little girl minding her own business. Makes me sick to my stomach.

[@shifajamaima7173]

Such a sad story. That beautiful young girl, full of life getting killed by that psychopath. Can't imagine the pain she went through and how scared she was. RIP Carly. Thanks EWU for this story. Love all your channels

[@J.C...]

My daughter would've been 10 yrs old this Sept. Instead, her mother decided that texting was more important than actually paying attention to the road while she was driving and she had a really bad wreck that caused the death of my only child. I couldn't imagine the terror that mother felt. My heart goes out to her. I know the pain of burying your child. I wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy.

[@idiotsimulator8055]

I'm so sorry for your loss.

[@Vuden13]

LOL

[@mrsmercury2565]

I am so sorry for the loss of your daughter. My son was murdered, I understand the pain of losing a child.

[@loobielou6965]

I'm so sorry for the loss of your daughter.

[@deltadawn9276]

I’m So sorry for your loss 😢💔

[@harmangarcharana]

I can’t understand how could the friend’s mother let Carlie walk back home alone? Any responsible person would call the kid’s parents to know if they can allow the child to walk back home alone by their selves. Carlie would’ve been alive had the mother of the friend called Carlie’s mother before letting her walk back alone.

[@Carlos-vw7xk]

Because parents don’t expect worst case scenarios. Joseph Smith is 100% responsible despite what circumstances you may know or may not know about.

[@ennardaway]

​@@Carlos-vw7xkthats literally the exact opposite of how good parents are they always think the worst things are going to happen for a good reason, so the parents of the child who was murdered would have every right to be furious with the mother of her friend

[@Riftweaver1981]

this was also close to 20 years ago. things were not quite as stupidly crazy as they are these days and walking home in a 'small' town by yourself wasnt exactly strange or as dangerous as it would be these days. yea the friends mom should have called ahead just to make sure it was ok, but in no way whatsoever was it her fault at all.

[@aref111]

you lack the sense of empathy to think like this. In my culture we feel even more responsible if that's not our kid, I bet you wont even feel same amount of responsibility as you would do for your own@@Riftweaver1981

[@frumbo7394]

​@pandaangry1267 Wrong

[@bearhugzfam649]

TEACH YOUR CHILDREN TO BE RUDE I cannot stress this enough, so many of us teach our kids that good children are polite and respectful to adults no matter what while still trying to teach them stranger danger and it will straight up get them killed! Teach your children that if they're not 100% certain that the adult is safe, they can and should "be rude" - refuse to go with them, don't do as they say, run away, and, if they're grabbed, kick, scream, shout, tell them to fuck off, bite, whatever it takes. Teach your children you will NEVER be angry with them if they're just trying to stay safe, and that no half-decent adult will have a problem with talking to their parents or letting them talk to their parents, and no safe adult will ever try and get them to keep a secret from their family. Criminals often target children who can't talk to their parents for exactly that reason - it's easy to isolate them, gain their trust, and lure them away with promises of something better. You cannot teach your kids that you'll wash their mouths out with soap if you catch them being rude then expect them to defend themselves.

[@gregtennessee8249]

Haha sounds like a trump supporter household haha

[@ilaria6984]

@@gregtennessee8249 what does it have to with being a Trump supporter? Are you high?

[@gregtennessee8249]

@@ilaria6984 just a daily reminder. No,not high. Today the FBI raided trump's Florida home hehehehe.

[@KTx0609]

@@gregtennessee8249 yea which is absurd that that’s their focus and they should be after Hilary , Biden and his son for wayyyy worse things that are actual serious crimes . FBI has gone to shambles. But, disgusting for even mentioning politics on this video . And to assume someone’s political views that have nothing to do with that at all? You sound like a disgusting human being just like your distorted disgusting political judgments and beliefs. 😩 hehehehe.🤮🤮🤮

[@slow.and.hot717]

I somewhat agree but I believe it depends on the age and character of the child. It's not that black and white (rude and polite). I was a very polite child, quiet, obedient...an introvert. But I was also very serious and not that trusting. In danger, I would probably understand the situation I was in, but would be too afraid to make a noise and would go along.... While my son is completely different from the way I was as a child and I am worried he would be even easier to kidnap. He is a loud, hyper, cheerful, trusting, extroverted kid. While I struggled to communicate with extended family and peers, my son has no problem reaching out to strangers on the street and starting a conversation. He is outspoken and sometimes rude, but only to people he's comfortable with (aka me), so I have to teach him to be respectful and polite, while also explaining not everyone is a good person. He's still little and we go everywhere together so there's still time to prepare for when he's older and able to walk outside alone. But yeah....a lot depends on the child alone.

[@dk1472]

How was a guy like this walking free when people are STILL in prison for weed and minor strike 3 offenses? I know it varies by state buy this is ridiculous. Our prison, healthcare, education, and CPS agencies are all broken and its sad our government doesn't put our taxes to better use.

[@VelvetAnnn]

I ask myself this EXACT question everytime i watch some shit like this. Like people i personally know have gotten 15+ years for drug charges an I've seen people who do disgusting acts against innocent children get less then that. It blows my mind I Will NEVER understand. 😢

[@lolazal1]

Prison slavery...

[@charlottetaylor4471]

It's because the elites are drug dealers and child abusers.

[@kennethmoore8088]

Well said 100 true the system is totally wrong men like this should never be released there is no cure for these people they are total evil

[@BS10258]

He's dead now and burning in hell

[@beeeeeeeee7951]

I love how you always have “prevention methods” on every video that needs one 💚

[@renaymatthews6929]

That is exactly why I requested for them to do this story. This kind of thing happens way too much these days. I knew they would do this story right. I love this channel because it is not just here to talk about something as that happened. It teaches and informs.

[@tatum3d]

When my daughter was little she hid in the house for fun. We couldn’t find her for a couple of mins & those couple of minutes were the worst fear I’ve ever experienced . I had this terrible pain in my stomach & felt sick so my heart goes out to this mother. I can’t imagine how you would cope

[@MissyR2538]

Seeing that monster grab this little 11YR OLD girl like that made me so mad!!! I've seen hundreds of these cases over the yrs but for some reason, seeing him aggressively grab her as she's minding her business just boils my blood. 13 PRIOR ASSAULTS?! And he was let out to walk the streets?! From now on when a monster like this is let out and commits another assault, the judge who allowed him out ought to have to go to jail too. Maybe then they'd be a little more stern on who they let go. Ridiculous! May Carlie rest in paradise.🙏😢

[@cosmicreef5858]

I agree.

[@sierrabakara8383]

I have waited so long for someone to do this story. Thank you. I was at her house waiting for her to come home that day. The responsibilities she was referring to, was more or less acting as her little brothers mother. She did more cooking and cleaning and caring around that house than anyone, but she would have never left her little brother willingly. She was too pure of a soul to be on this earth.

[@dws84]

There’s an ep. of See no Evil about it.

[@hotmessmissy]

RIP carlie. The justice system failed her. Had they kept that criminal behind bars he wouldn't have ha a chance to hurt her. I see no reason for people, more like monsters like him to have that freedom to go on about having access to innocent lives let alone children. Some people you cannot rehabilitate. He clearly had no conscience or accountability as he was blaming it on the drugs. Disgusting piec3 of shite he was

[@BlueButterfly7777]

@@dws84 I'm a true crime watcher but never heard of that show. What channel? This guy was disgusting piece of garbage. Weird that he died so young.

[@dws84]

@@BlueButterfly7777 I think it’s on ID, but there’s some uploads on KZbin of it - just search it and it’ll come up. The quality isn’t great due to hiding the video from copyright flags.

[@BlueButterfly7777]

@@dws84 Thank you, Danny.👍

[@jessicacashmore4267]

I went to school with her, and grew up one street over from where she was abducted. This was so devastating to our community when I was growing up. Absolutely heartbreaking.

[@niaboctruk138]

Oh you were right off Bee Ridge also?

[@jessicacashmore4267]

@@niaboctruk138 I was right by there, yes. Good ole bee ridge and Macintosh.

[@niaboctruk138]

@@jessicacashmore4267 I was Bee Ridge and Honore. This was crazy. We couldn't believe it when it happened.

[@aimeeaa599]

Why didnt the friends or friends parents not offer to take her home. She was 11. They should have phoned the parents of the girl first before letting the child walk out on her own.

[@serida6097]

@@aimeeaa599 That’s what I’m wondering. I feel truly sorry for them but I’ll never understand letting someone walk that distance, alone, at such a young age…

[@JaclynPoulton]

I took my two youngest children into a shop, while we were there, a rep from a sweet company came and asked the two if they wanted to try the new sweets, my son, grabbed his sister’s hand and screamed as loud as he could, I was behind them, I had taught them so well about stranger danger!! I can smile at the memory, only because I was there with them.

[@LindaBarham]

I personally also blame her friend's mother. The girl was eleven years old and she let her walk home for a walk that would take an hour and a half, wtf! When children are playing at your house you are responsible for them period! I don't care if she said she was allowed to walk or not, her safety would be my responsibility. I hope that mother thinks about the choice she made for everyday for the rest of her life and feels guilty. If it were my child I could never forgive her! 😡

[@iveneverseenahealthyvegan.9885]

Only one person is to blame.

[@rickmorgan1441]

bingo!

[@leticiarobin3054]

Yup exactly!! An hour and a half walk Is insane as well

[@voteforscience]

I’m sure she does think about it and feels horrible. Probably ever single day.

[@kimmurray9346]

Agreed! It’s her guilt to bare and I send no hate. I used to watch my friend’s kids walk across the back yard into their home.

[@JustJenRx]

I live in Cleveland, where Ariel Castro lived. He kidnapped 3 girls and kept them for over 10 years. Amanda Berry was one of his victims. I remember the DeJesus family stopping cars with her picture asking everyone and anyone if they’ve seen Gina. They stopped me at an intersection near the Castro house (of horrors). Those poor girls, Amanda, Michelle, and Gina endured abuse for over a decade before they were discovered. These types of people are PURE EVIL.

[@jimboramba]

I was born in Cleveland and have family there. My grandma who passed away lived really close to that house. She owned a bar called Lois' Place, I think on Sackett Avenue

[@strawberryshortcake8382]

Don’t worry. You can rest assured they will pay back 10 fold

[@irmabeltran6125]

And castro used to help them look for the girls. So evil

[@JohnH20111]

and Castro took the chickenshit way out & hung himself in prison

[@Cutiejuliya]

@@strawberryshortcake8382 it doesnt matter, it doesnt make up for being kept captive 10 years. No amount of "paying" removes such psychological trauma

[@SamanthaLeigh7]

I feel so bad for this girl and her family. As for the video giving advice on how to keep kids safe, my parents gave my brother and I a "password" when we were young. My dad instructed us that even if it was his best friend, (who we knew well and considered an uncle) if he didn't have the password, we weren't to go with him. I have now taught my kids the same and the password is the same that it was for us when we were young.

[@avaottaway5071]

My husband and I have a special knock for when we're at hotels or one of us pops out without a key. Always better to be safe than sorry!

[@SweetTooth8989]

And also, the safe word thing is a good trick in the event a stranger approaches a child but i would go as far as to say to NEVER accept a stranger saying they were sent by your parents. If you have decent parents, they would have told you ahead of hand and likely would not choose a total stranger but somebody the child is familiar with. Also if ever in doubt, kids have phones these days, so if the person truly is a good person, they will have no issue with you taking a couple minutes to call your parents to confirm.

[@copperheaddesigns672]

whats your passcode

[@truthhurts3524]

Whoa…I’m going to steal this idea for my kids, thank you!

[@M3ad45]

@@copperheaddesigns672 ??? Are you like Joseph

[@MegNotTheStallion]

Her mother died in 2017. A mothers grief is unimaginable. My mom died of alcoholism because my brother killed himself. My dad was murdered a few years after she died. I have been through the most horrible grief for many years but never will I understand the pain of a mother who has to bury their child.

[@hannahhh.versooo]

i hope you’re doing okay and may your brother, mom and dad rest in peace🕊️🕊️💗💗

[@nikrixxx6338]

This happened in my town and it was huge news. I remember being glued to the updates and driving all over in my 2003 Mitsubishi Eclipse trying to help find her. The morning after her body was found I saw they changed the sign outside her school to "We love you Carlie".. It really hit people hard and inspired them to teach their kids even more about stranger danger. Then social media came along and made it even easier for the depraved psychopathic assholes to get to our kids! Please monitor your kid's online usage and don't let them walk alone 💖

[@hectorherbert6585]

how's that 2003 Eclipse driving...??..good..??!!

[@gasmith7486]

Ya I live in SRQ too and Susan was a drug addict and narcissist. She made everything about her. Poor kid never had a chance. If this hadn’t happened, her mom’s lifestyle would have destroyed Carlie’s life anyway.

[@trinisniper7064]

@@hectorherbert6585 same thing I thought... Who cares?

[@jaidenkersey3481]

She went to my school

[@marcwilliams9824]

The question we all want answered is what color shirt were you wearing when driving said 2003 Mitsubishi Eclipse?

[@geeker6350]

The thought of the unimaginable terror and pain she endured in her final hours at the hands of a total stranger is heartbreaking.

[@J.C...]

Someone tried to abduct me from school when I was 5 yrs old. They called the office and had my full name and information and were trying to get permission to come get me from school. Luckily, the secretary in the office knew me personally and had a bad feeling so she didn't let it happen. Thank God for that woman. Mrs Bailey was her name. It still makes my heart race when I think about it and that was 35 years ago. I don't remember the actual event, only what my mom told me when I got older.

[@mymai5859]

Whoah... thank goodness for Mrs Bailey. Did you ever track down as an adult, who it was that knew your details enough to steal you from school?

[@belmum1689]

@@mymai5859 To 'try' to steal them from school, b/c they didn't get a chance to steal them, thankfully.

[@xancypillosi9497]

Who was this person who knew your whole government info. Had to be somebody who was familiar with your family

[@niah1978]

God Bless 🙏🏾💜, may God protect over you & your family Amen 🙏🏾💜

[@jadetasker6401]

Just read all your posts . Wow. You've had a really sad dramatic life . So sorry ..

[@Alexxx.98]

This was a very close friend of our family. Growing up we were always at each others house…I was young but I still remember. My grandpa helped build Carlie’s Garden and every March her life is still celebrated. We miss her dearly, I looked up to her like a big sister…😔 Fly high baby girl, you are so loved. I know you and your mama are looking down on us🫶🏻🕊️

[@elizabethcole3274]

I’m so sorry for everyone involved! So happy to hear she’s still celebrated! They’re def making sure you all are safe and keeping an eye on you & your fam! Much love! 💕

[@BonJoviGirl84]

I am a mother of 6 children and this is one of my absolute fears! While devastating and heartbreaking, I am going to show this to my children in hopes that God forbid they ever face this situation, they know what to do. This serves as a stark reminder that evil lurks everywhere.💔

[@thismomof5]

I always share these with my kids. Not to traumatize or scare them, but to make them aware of what’s actually out there. Me telling them isn’t always enough.

[@greatestever7623]

Teach your kids self defense aim for the balls and kick the shit outta of em then runnnn

[@Most_Trustworthy_Weasel]

Yes be very afraid and play the lottery as you have a better chance of winning then you do what your fearful of. Who knows YOU could even be the next kidnapper. I don't think you should trust anyone including yourself.

[@bathroomsinging8728]

My mother did this to me growing up and its made me a very afraid person. A grown adult who is terrified of even sleeping alone in her own home. I know your fear is real, and your intentions are good. But from my personal experience, this was not a good approach 🙈

[@thismomof5]

@@bathroomsinging8728 Not everyone reacts the same way. I’d rather arm my kids with the knowledge of monsters than send them out against them unawares. We always discuss the cases as well and how it could be handled. I don’t want them to be naive because the threat is very real. We’ve been followed on multiple occasions with ME with them, and they’ve told me of instances when they were alone. The world is a scary place sometimes. And while kids don’t need to see and know everything, I do think knowledge of some things is crucial for them to function safely in this environment. We don’t not talk to children about fires because of fear they’ll be scared. They’re shown the risks and dangers, then given advice on what to do if they are faced with it.

[@brettadams7507]

When do we as a society start putting overwhelming pressure on the justice system for releasing these scumbags back into society? Sick and tired of hearing about cases like this it is beyond infuriating.

[@MB-gl7fx]

Well said 👏 I second that, These vile scum deserve the firing squad not a second chance….

[@OverRule1]

This was in 2004. Kids are a lot safer now compared to back then

[@LadyAstarionAncunin]

The judges should be required to take the criminal into their home for years if they're going to do a light sentence, and if the criminal reoffends, the judge should be arrested and sentenced too. I'm tired of them enabling predators to escalate to m/urder.

[@justwag9750]

He had only committed stupid minor drug and fraud crimes until he did this unforgiveable act. He should have just been taken out and shot behind courthouse. But he was just one of the 10's of millions people on drug or other non violent probation in USA when he did it. The justice system is broke because we have things like mandatory sentencing of 10 and 20 years for a drug crime but a rapist can get out in 5. That was not the case here.. No red flags in the system about him being violent.

[@RainCloud848]

@@OverRule1 Well, they sure as hell don't act like it! Kids are NOT safer today! Do you read?

[@Chels_123]

This is why I’m absolutely against young kids walking anywhere alone, there are so many predators looking for young vulnerable kids. I myself have experienced a scary situation while picking my kids up from school, it’s a block away and a man in a van was following me and asking me if I wanted a ride while walking with my kids (I was able to dodge him & thankfully nothing happened) however, can you imagine a kid walking alone?!

[@Batya-Grace]

The video conveniently left out that she had been communicating online with what she thought was a teen boy. She wanted to walk home so she could meet up with the “boy.” It turned out to be a man. She didn’t deserve what happened, but the full story is not being told. Carly was deceived, groomed and manipulated online to meet up with this man.

[@krystalriley10]

Reminds me of the one movie Megan is missing

[@danielallen8702]

Glad you're safe!

[@KarlheinzDerZweite]

In our village, the kids walk home in groups.

[@RebeccaNelson-be7oq]

I remember this case So well when Nancy Grace covered it on Headline News. For some reason, the video of a man walking up, grabbing Carlie by the arm and walking away with her has haunted me all these years. 😢

[@brenmanock]

I lost my daughter five years ago to homicide. The pain never subsided. You just learn to live with it

[@rusty01738]

I am so sorry🙏❤️

[@DopamineDecor]

I'm so sorry.

[@Ka-lh1le]

Stay strong always 💕

[@shoultzada]

I'm so sorry for your terrible loss😭 my deepest sympathy to you and your family. I wish I could take your pain away that's in your heart and will no doubt always be with you. Take care and stay strong.

[@xancypillosi9497]

God Bless RIP

[@winterlynn9012]

Poor girl! I had never heard of this case till now, it's so scary the way he just walked off with her in broad daylight! In the early to mid 90s when I was between 9 through 11 years old, my family moved to a very quiet street where all the houses were higher and further up from the street, as they were built on a hill. The school bus would drop me pretty far from my house and I was the only kid who lived on the long winding street, the other kids lived right near the bus stop. I enjoyed the long walk home, it was so peaceful that I often was in no rush, but I knew my mom whom was at work would be worrying and calling the house to check if I was home yet. I remember i used to walk holding my house key jutting out between my fingers so that if someone stopped and tried to grab me, I could jab them in the eye with it,lol. I'd tense up everytime a car passed me a little too slowly. But the street wasn't where something happened. Our apartment was a rented basement apartment in the back of a large home, to get in I'd have to walk up a long steep driveway, go through a breezeway to the back of the house where our door was. It was creepy because the family upstairs was never home and the backyard was just miles of woods. One day as I passed through the breezeway I heard noises coming from the garage, I turned to see an unfamiliar man peeking at me through the glass window of the door leading to the garage, he opened it and said "Hey Come in here " in a slurred voice, I forgot all about my "key weapon", panicked and ran towards my apartment door wondering if I'd have time to unlock it and get in before he reached me? Should I run to the woods instead? I had seconds to decide as I could hear him stumbling behind me. It must have been my lucky day because I reached my door and it was already unlocked, turns out one of my older brothers had come home sick early from school and had never locked the door behind him, I slammed the door in the mans face and he started banging on it, I yelled for my brother to call the police. The banging stopped after a few minutes and we waited in fear till the police showed up. They found the man an hour later hiding and intoxicated in a tool shed. He had a knife on him and had been driving drunk, left his car somewhere in the neighborhood and the police believed he had just randomly picked our garage to hide in. Later i was told he had a record and had kidnapped and assaulted his niece a few years prior. My mom moved us out of there not long after. It was one of the scariest moments of my life at that point and as anyone can tell by the length and detail of this comment, it's something I still vividly remember despite the 30 years since it happened. I often think of how different the outcome might have been had my brother not been home and that door would have been locked.

[@dropdeadgreen9421]

I got goosebumps reading this. I m glad you are safe

[@winterlynn9012]

@@dropdeadgreen9421 Thank you

[@cindysell149]

Omg I can’t even imagine. Terrified just reading that & remembering myself at 10. I’m afraid I wouldn’t have had a lucid thought at all about how to escape that situation. So glad you’re safe.

[@winterlynn9012]

@@cindysell149 Thank you! And exactly, I still remember the sheer panic I felt. Adults had always taught me what to do in a situation like that, but it was shocking when it actually happened, I remember for a split second just standing there, frozen in fear, it was like my feet could not move.

[@erinhansen614]

Was your mom not home? This is so scary!

[@seandelap8587]

An innocent young girl with her whole life ahead of her snuffed out by a predator like that it makes you sick.

[@lisalane3291]

😱 😱 😱

[@toddcarney9140]

Thanks for the spoiler

[@chrissharma4088]

Well she should not have lied about being allowed to walk home and called her parents for a ride…😑🤷🏻

[@Babystrange14]

@@chrissharma4088 that’s victim blaming but thank you for your input. It’s not like it was the crazy sadistic killer it was the fact she walked home you’re right

[@abyssmom2692]

The fact that people then defend the guys is beyond me. You can tell the world is full of pampered nihilistic assholes that just want the innocent to hurt.

[@lauraw3338]

This abduction is so heart breaking. The horror that she must have experienced before her life was ended is a mothers worst nightmare. Rest In Peace young Carlie. I pray the family can one day find peace🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

[@novawallenda7848]

This happened in my town, it was absolutely horrific and so heartbreaking. When the guy that kidnapped her returned the station wagon he was borrowing from a friend it had scuff marks all over the roof the whole entire car was trashed you could tell a brutal attack happened inside of it. I was like 16 in this happened and I think about her everyday when I drive past her house or Evie's car wash. Rest in peace You beautiful angel 💕🥺

[@richardshiflett5181]

God isn't real

[@elenahale1922]

@Jebus Bhrist i feel like it’s way too similar but idkkk

[@YoursUntruly]

I’d love to know the name of the cops who were too lazy to do the right paperwork to get a warrant for his arrest.. he would have been in jail, and this wouldn’t have happened.

[@Nikkiqiao]

This could have been prevented, if the other girl’s mother just drove her home and dropped her off. She has a daughter herself. It’s only 1 mile. You gotta insist to take her home, or call the other mother to pick her up. Now tragedy has happened, I wonder whether both families ever spoke again. It’s not her fault, it’s the predator’s fault, and the law system failed us to let a dangerous man back out, but it is also her fault by letting a teenage girl walk home alone. ;-;

[@sheilae.9670]

Exactly!

[@user-ci4bh6cc5b]

I agree, a mile is a long ass walk especially on a Sunday evening when it’s mostly secluded and empty

[@viktorcheng2061]

Either her friends mother drive her or her parents picked her up. Super Bowl is not that important

[@Nikkiqiao]

@@user-ci4bh6cc5b especially the walk included passing by business, it’s not a walk within the community down the street. A mile takes less than 5 mins to drive?

[@Miinafied]

But even if they brought her home, this predator would've take another innocent girl like Carlie. I agree on what you say. You should always drop the kid home or wait until the parent Comes and pick her up. Still the predator being able to walk around freely is what could've prevented the entire situation also for other victims

[@celiamcknight1321]

This is why I don’t trust ANYONE with my kid. Her friends mom was responsible for her since she was under her care at the time and didn’t take care of her. This could have been prevented.

[@elsie3724]

Glad to hear he died. Was sad to look up this case and see Carlie’s mother has also died (actually before Joseph). Also big props to Joseph’s brother John who testified against him several times and seems to have continued to speak out against him. He also thinks Joseph killed another young girl who’s case was never solved.

[@trishatate327]

Knowing the outcome of this whole thing , it was WRONG to have discussed the stepfather in the manner in which he was. It was also unecessary to mention that little girl supposedly had confided that Carlie had expressed having issues at home. What was glossed over and never talked about , was the fact that the adult who had hosted Carlie in her home and been responsible for her , let an 11 year little girl leave her home with out having talked to the child's mother. So for every parent and future parent out there...if you are going to let your child stay some where. Be that parent that ENSURES the other parent/parents understand very clearly things like , my 11 year old is not allowed to walk home. Also if you are going to host a sleep over at your home , you are RESPONSIBLE for the welfare of the children you are hosting! Carlie's mommy lost her little girl, she doesn't deserve to placed under suspicion for even the moments she was , to make the telling of this tragedy have extra drama added.

[@timdunk7278]

Excellent points!

[@HK_Musician]

Yeah fair comment

[@umangagga]

This needs to be pinned. Brilliantly said!

[@thismomof5]

Exactly! I could never and because I think about how I would want My children cared for. My kid’s friend is a tall boy, works out, etc. But he’s still only 17. He was going to drive home alone and “figure it out” and I asked my husband to let him follow in his car until he knew where he was. His parents were called when he was on his way so they know to be looking out. The next time we were together, we just all drove behind him in our car and walked him in. I can’t imagine even thinking to let a girl drive, let alone walk by herself. My kids are always told to make a scene and stay together. Just because they’re older now doesn’t mean anything. Abductions are real and far more common than we’d like to think. So I’ll gladly be labeled the paranoid or overprotective one.

[@trishatate327]

​@@thismomof5 Need more mama bears out there like you.

[@beauburrell3318]

Judges should be barred from ever practicing law again, that is downright sickening.

[@kimberlykidd2217]

My mom was always so worried about me as a kid, I was so trusting and friendly to strangers and she absolutely GRILLED the rules of avoiding abduction into me. -the use of a safe word -never get into unknown vehicles -be as loud as possible -run as fast as could be -and if all else fails fight and scratch with all your might if being forced into a vehicle (That one’s especially sad considering she knew if a kid is abducted they’ll likely be murdered, and she wanted the killer to be caught if it happened) These things can seriously save lives and it’s important to engrave in your children as sad as it is

[@hanchan254]

That 911 call kills me... You can tell her mom trying so hard to stay calm, but the fear and panic her voice is raw.

[@allyb8010]

Her mom was far from a woman worth feeling sorry for. So much people don't know about her and how Carlies home life was.

[@SuperZytoon]

I vividly remember this case. Seeing the actual abduction is something I will never get over. That poor, poor child must have been scared and panicked beyond description. I sincerely hope she found peace in Heaven.

[@recovering.with.rachel]

I live in a rural area and I was 10-11 at the time of this case. We lived close to a car wash I'd use as a shortcut myself and it chilled me to the bone and I really understood WHY my mom told me not to do that.

[@benhartart9487]

she was violently graped and killed so yeah shes at peace being no longer alive

[@mom2babygkaterad946]

I remember this so well. She was such a beautiful little girl. When the footage of her abduction aired on the local news, I was absolutely horrified & knew it would not end well. I hate predators, especially those who prey on children, the elderly & animals. Rest In Peace Carlie💔🥀🕊

[@genodedemon5109]

I'll never understand why super wealthy companies can't afford decent quality cameras. Imagine all the time you could save the police if the camera quality was at least okay.

[@Your20droid]

I know right? And yet, photographers of spaces is so clear but cameras here is so?? Garage???

[@LastlyMore]

It was 2004, that was best quality back than.

[@Alcoholpad]

I remember when everyone was accusing her of have been talking to him online and that she was ok going with him. Poor baby was so confused and in fight or flight mode. The fact he has 3 young daughters makes me even sicker that he may have done stuff to them before. Sick bastard !!!

[@j4kgang921]

He probably did. !! Didn't you hear in this clip how he was staying with someone else amd not at home with his wife and daughters BECAUSE HE WAS PROBABLY BEING INAPPROPRIATE!!

[@trishpipkins]

I'll never forget this one. My girls would compete in a music festival at a church in Sarasota every year in late winter. When they announced her body had been found at a church and named the road it was on I recognized it right away and my heart sank because I knew we would have to drive by it on the way to the festival. Just a couple of weeks after Carlie's body was found I was driving my girls down that same road. As we passed the church I saw a ton of balloons, flowers, stuffed animals and a sign that read "We love and miss you Carlie." It was horrible. And to watch the killer in this interview wanting to smoke and talk to his family makes my blood boil. Carlie's mother died from a heroine overdose in 2017. Just heartbreaking.

[@Subawoo123]

Wow that poor mother… and now the father is left without a daughter and a wife, sadly he’s probably not going to be any better off. This man never should have been free in the first place, RIP to all those affected.

[@trishpipkins]

@@Subawoo123 I know. The killer was a scum bag and should have been behind bars. How many times do we hear about cases like this?

[@j4kgang921]

Yea but He wanted to Talk to his family to confess to them!! So they Should've Let HIm!

[@Subawoo123]

@@trishpipkins far too many sadly…

[@ArliQuinn]

I was born in Bradenton and was in fourth grade when she disappeared. I remember my mom wouldn't let me out of the house for months and months because she and everyone else were terrified. We would drive past that same neighborhood, that same car wash, everyday to get me to school and at the time I didn't understand why I wasn't allowed to take the bus anymore or visit friends anymore... I'm 28 years old now with two twin daughters of my own and I still live in absolute terror that something like this could happen to them. Rest easy Carlie. You were such a light.

[@LiveFreeOrDie2A]

How is he confessing to murdering her and where he buried her to multiple family members over the phone while in jail, yet LE needed THEM to come forward and reveal what he confessed? Why aren’t they actively listening in to his conversations

[@hellekimery9537]

Never ever let a child walk home alone ever, not in this day and age! If she runs off, call her parents immediately and if possible, get in your car, and try to catch her. I have family members that age, and they are in no way ready to take responsibility for themselves! Just like this very scary case, in can happen in the blink of an eye!

[@SHEEPLESUCK]

@@RepentfollowJesus you're right about the dogs. Once a bond is made between a child and a puppy, when that puppy grows to adulthood, the dog will protect that child from harm with a vicious fervor. I've seen it firsthand many times. Even the smallest of breeds can be quite effective too.

[@ivandzaja6251]

I agree with that but for the USA,almost all of Europe and a lot of other parts of the world are really safe to walk around alone no matter how old you are,just wanted to chime in so we dont needlessly scare people if we dont have to

[@carnifaxx]

@@ivandzaja6251 I wanted to say the same thing... but still, living in Central Europe, I feel we are much less aware how easy it is to actually abduct a child (or even an adult), if someone decides to. Like in USA, when they know this is happening, they have mechanisms how to act quite quickly and surround the area etc., while in Europe, police would probably wait until it's too late. And the same with general public - if I read discussions about lost children, it's often much more about "how did they dare to leave, I would spank them once they are home" than real concern about their well-being. Which is sick.

[@auzieblo]

@@ivandzaja6251 safe? How do you know where is safe, and what place or town exactly is safe to walk alone? Do you know what's going on in other people's heads? Do you know where every sicko/psycho/paedophile/killer lives? No you don't. You're just being naive and it's your wishful thinking, nothing more. A tragedy or crime can take place in the most picturesque village or in the loveliest, quaint little town. You just don't know the time and place

[@truth4004]

@@ivandzaja6251 There's all kinds of rapists and pedos in Europe. Everywhere actually. Perverts abound. A false sense of security is a downfall. Doesnt germany even have legal animal rape?

[@junglejulia4699]

As a mom of a 17yr old girl this breaks my heart for the parents! 🥺😢 I can’t imagine! My daughter was missing for 2 hrs and I lost my mind, only to find out her cell died and she was almost at her best friends house walking alone, I walked everywhere screaming her name and took a cab to the friends house n me and the parent of her best friend went looking for her and finally found her! That whole time my heart was in pain! I can’t imagine how the parents must feel 😞 I’m so sorry for your loss❤️

[@azwavlogs]

@Donnell Okafor children never stop being children to their parents

[@azwavlogs]

@Donnell Okafor we have differing opinions and thats fine

[@samiyemane751]

It’s really sad what happened to this family . At 47-years-old, Susan Schorpen was found dead on April 10, 2017, in Polk County, Florida, from a heroin overdose. The County’s Medical Examiner’s Office conducted several toxicology tests to determine her official cause of death. As per a few reports, Susan’s life was filled with one devastating news after another. After Carlie’s murder, her brother passed away in a tragic car accident, Then, her father, who was suffering from Alzheimer’s disease, died. And as if all that wasn’t enough, Susan’s then 11-year-old son was gravely injured after being hit by a drunk driver.

[@tinaosborne6837]

That poor woman . Don't think I could've coped with all that trauma either

[@jabellatv3240]

My goodness i hope she is at peace with her family now 🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@MarK-nj8vr]

@@MizzTrinieFyre the stepfather had nothing to do with it. Why would you even say that?

[@kalnedlewil2897]

I would do ever I could to numb out until I passed

[@norafox4789]

Awful just awful...

[@iangrinols4370]

This happened in my home town. Her body was dumped behind a church literally 1000 feet down the road from my house at the time. Her memorial is still there to this day. Such a heartbreaking case

[@runnerchick123kf]

It just keeps happening. When I was in highschool I knew a girl named Chelsea who would have survived if the offenders probation officer checked on him and someone knew that he had been staying at his mom's which was near children. He was Totally off their radar and killed two girls It helped create Chelsea's law for others but wasn't worth it.

[@starstatusvillarreal3747]

Lol police can't stop crimes, they just arrest and haul them to jail AFTER THE CRIMES. Them stopping a crime before it happens is very low nunbers..

[@kalleemay1058]

Great channel. I have two little girls, this world is filled with sickos. Thank you for sharing these stories.

[@VioletJoy]

That poor, precious, young child. There aren't words. I can't even imagine the trauma she endured and the torture her parents go through knowing what happened to their baby girl. So incredibly disturbing.

[@mandu6665]

My sister, 10 at the time, came running into our home after returning from her friend's house. My sister was hysterical, screaming and had tears streaming down her face. Once she calmed down, she told my parents a man in a car tried to get her into the vehicle and even tried to grab her from her bike but she took off. All of this on a Sunday afternoon in a small quiet town of less than ten thousand people. It's so sad how vulnerable kids and women are in the world. Rest in peace, Carlie, society failed you. Rest in piss, Joseph.

[@humongousfungusamongus3871]

When I was 10, 11 & 12 years old I used to walk home from school through the Indian reservation in the middle of the desert instead of taking the bus. My mom used to cry & beg me not to walk alone from school, but I couldn't understand why. This was back in the 70's & when I hit 13 years old...I understood why it drove my mother crazy. I'm so very sorry mother for making you fear & worry for me. I'm sorry for ALL mothers.

[@j4kgang921]

I Take my kids to school myself

[@dOlli3cOutur3]

You failed to mention Carli’s mom died of a heroin overdose years after because she couldn’t handle the pain

[@premiumgambler2216]

Heroin a strange drug to just go and try and do because she couldn't live anymore

[@nancymetcalf715]

Heart breaking 💔.

[@sahtification]

She was heartbroken from the first moment No sign of any hope. Very sad :(

[@Eashlynne]

Wrong, she was an addict prior to carlies death and the reason for it. She even sold her daughters ashes for drugs. Not to mention the son she abandoned for drugs and left behind.

[@esval3054]

Oh, no. 💔

[@diane_alworth]

Thank you for bringing attention back to this young lady. May she never be forgotten.

[@robshane6634]

This happened in my hometown and I also knew Joe Smith. He actually gave me a ride when i was 15 years old to a friend's house and he made a commitment about ine of the young girls at my friend's house saying "I really love blondes" looking back now i wish I could have done something. I was just visiting last month and every time I go there I think about her..RIP ❤️

[@guillermo3564]

Damned shame that his friend, who knew Joseph had a desire to hurt women, didn't notify anyone. Maybe his family could have gotten him mental health assistance or notified authorities that he may be a danger to others. Honestly, at that point, who knows what could have been done, because you can't be arrested for just thinking of committing a crime. It just pisses me off to think that somehow this could have been prevented. RIP, Carlie.

[@SHEEPLESUCK]

All tragedies could've somehow been prevented.

[@kymo6343]

The way it could have been prevented was if someone did their job and filled out the paperwork that would have gotten that judge to throw that sack of crap in jail before he ever even got the opportunity to see Carlie.

[@thatgirlvee2]

@@kymo6343 ye

[@thatgirlvee2]

@@SHEEPLESUCK nah

[@sciencenotstigma9534]

Maybe they did try to get help.

[@yvettetorres6671]

I went to school with Carlie and she was so sweet. I remember this day like it was yesterday. I was in the choir that sang at her funeral. 😭

[@WendelltheSongwriter]

I was a barber in Manatee county at the time and the initial investigating officer was my client. This case it changed him. Changed a lot of us around here.

[@TinyGrandma]

My favorite true crime channels! You guys knock it out of the park every single time! Thanks for all the hard work! 👏👏👏

[@njjones6427]

Been with you guys for about a year and can honestly say you’re in my top 5 true crime content creators! Never stop ☺️

[@Worldboss246]

NJ Jones do u know any good crime channels

[@kimbamoon]

Just here to read the answer :)

[@scott6233]

Who are the others

[@samanthacuevas2248]

Yassss!!! I want to know the others too 🤔 😊

[@damlamorkoc2336]

+1

[@trudilou1]

Its an awful world we live in where a case when a beautiful 11 year old girl is raped and murdered....isnt even close to the "most twisted case Ive ever heard"😔

[@underarmbowlingincidentof1981]

yeah ... I pray each time I look at one of those videos that it cant get worse than Junko ... until now its never been that bad but .. its just a matter of time really

[@nikrixxx6338]

Wow.. your comment hit me hard bc it's so true! Terrifying world we are in

[@truth4004]

@@underarmbowlingincidentof1981 sorry but your name is making me laugh. lol

[@underarmbowlingincidentof1981]

@@truth4004 the Underarm Bowling Incident of 1981 is another one of those horrors I discovered on the internet ... not for the faint of heart

[@randyg.7940]

@@nikrixxx6338 agreed. It always has been. Just read the Bible where the Israelites would go killing stealing and raping the Virgins. Actually, times are alot better now.

[@ItsBobbyBlTCH]

“City of Sarasota sanitation site” is one heck of a sentence. My deepest condolences to the victim and her family. I can’t even imagine if this happened to my family. I would be filled with hatred, despair, deep sadness, and SO MUCH more. Why can’t people just live their life without damaging or ending another’s?

[@lexione14]

I was abducted when I was 15. I was pulled into a car after being jumped. I played along without the man and after several hours convinced him I'd be his girlfriend and to let me go. He let me out close to my house where my mother was frantic and called the police. He was convicted of several crimes. Just to think I could have easily been killed. I didn't know at the time to scream, fight, etc. This story is heartbreaking and I reach my kids and grandkids to fight, scream, bite, kick, anything to get away. I was lucky.

[@truth4004]

Not lucky, smart enough to read the guy. Good job.

[@melpomenesnightmare7291]

You may not of known to fight, but you were smart enough to know what he wanted to hear. Good on you, glad you’re safe.

[@mandyjay5265]

That story made me almost cry, I was abducted and raped and was trying to fight him off but after I and was scared of being killed so I acted like everything was okay after and said I wanted to see him again and do it again so he let me go in a discreet area … I’m happy you made it alive as well ❤️

[@d.e.p.5624]

I had the same experience 3 years ago but I was already 45. Much respect to you, for such a smart reaction at such a young age! Seriously.

[@lexione14]

@@d.e.p.5624 thanks. I'm so sorry that happened you. It really changed me. I gave my daughter pepper spray bc I'm so scared for her. It's sad hearing about so many abductions and murders. Our best chance is to get away in the very beginning or try to outsmart them.

[@emmerinman1331]

I remember when this happened. The footage was all over the news and it was one of the first times that surveillance cameras had caught something like this so clearly. It freaked a lot of people out to see something like this happen in real time, and especially to a child. I had a friend who was a child psychologist, I remember her watching it and yelling at the TV "Put your phone down! Oh god, look up! RUN!!" Carlie was distracted by her cell phone as she walked behind the carwash and didn't realize the guy was walking towards her till it was too late.

[@amberrau543]

That's what I thought too. I'm in Tampa and was in high school when this happened. It was kinda the beginning first her then Jessica . I had never heard of abductions like these happening and then they were just popping up.

[@ghost1fer]

@@amberrau543 jessica who? i’d like to look into the case as i’m from sota.

[@j4kgang921]

Why walk back there??

[@emmerinman1331]

@@j4kgang921 Because it was a shortcut. The car wash was part of a business complex, and it was quicker to cut through the complex instead of keeping to the main road.

[@ghost1fer]

@@j4kgang921 theres a neighborhood behind that evies, she was was likely leaving a house from that neighborhood and trying to cross to the sidewalk in front of the business.

[@elysabethpoodle6234]

My husband and I have always been over protective of our kids. They could have easily walked to school when they were in primary school but we still drove them every single day and I am so glad we did.

[@tinahamilton4085]

This is absolutely horrifying!! My love and prayers to all of her family and friends! 😭🙏 ❤️☮️

[@kristintassos2741]

I enjoy these shorter videos. Over an hour is hard for me to watch most times... Thanks for another awesome video!!!

[@kiefdemon1979]

How does one get out of prison on parole with 13 felony convictions on their record?

[@hazelhadley-britt6396]

These days they are arrested and released in certain states.

[@marylamb7031]

Now I see why people want to take the law into their own hands. Not saying it is right, just understand if and why they do it.

[@meghanhertzog2426]

I watched a few minutes with my 5 year old daughter. Sharing the tips was such a nice addition to this video! I made sure she paid complete attention and understood what to do in a situation like this. This is a mother's worst nightmare. 💔

[@alisamodin9032]

I just read that Carlie's mother died from a heroin overdose now too. This is just so sad!

[@renaymatthews6929]

Thank you so much for doing this. I requested this because this happened close to home and it shock this community. I thank you so much. People need to be aware of what to keep this from happening to their children. I truly appreciate you taking the time to make this video.

[@scruffwhor]

I appreciate the avoiding abduction tips. I frequently watch these horrifying stories to get ideas on what to watch out for in an attempt to protect and keep my own children safe. Such evil unthinkable things done to such a beautiful little girl. It's truly heart breaking to imagine what this child had gone through. What a life long nightmare for her loved ones! He shouldn't have had the chance!