The Reason 5* Weapons Are A Scam In Genshin Impact

An Analysis about 5* Weapons In Genshin Impact. SUBSCRIBE
Business Mail: [e-mail]
Affiliated To Yomiholic
#genshinimpact

[@TheGenshinScientist]

Business Mail:[e-mail] Twitter: twitter.com/GenshinTgs Discord Link: discord.gg/2PuwsPMV3V

[@mohaveeal202]

Hi, I just wanted to tell you about information from reliable source. The Developers of Genshin will be replaced, from reliable source who predicted FTX Bitcoin Closing, that Mihoyo will follow FTX closing by 2025. There will be someone else who is gonna develop Genshin. This source has 99% true predictions of Apple iPhone and other tech companies. Have a lovely day.

[@mananmangaka7638]

I lost 3 time on raiden weapon and got 2 haran and 1 yoimia weapon😢😢😢

[@bloody4558]

Counterpoint, some characters should ALWAYS have their signature weapon ,personal damage and damage contribution aren't everything. Characters like Raiden for example literally have only two F2P alternatives that are worth using, and those alternatives are highly disputed between many polearm characters. Therefore Raiden is better served with her own Signature weapon. Because Raiden is more than just generating energy for your team and she'll have around or more than 250% ER in every build. So using Fav on her is an absolute waste, when you could give it to your Shenhe, or Yaoyao

[@rudranathchakraborty5665]

Just wanted top let you know that I like your content and had thought that I was subscribed for a while but now I checked it was not so I did the right thing and sorry for the late subscription

[@rudranathchakraborty5665]

@@christophermauro-barias7451 what do you mean?

[@COBRAMANTISDOTXXX]

Weapon drip is very important

[@SydonX3]

Navia without her signature isn't Navia.😎

[@passwordyeah729]

Juggling higher damage AND fashion impact is a very hard task.

[@junyaiwase]

@@SydonX3truly. I will get it next time tho. F2p

[@a-passerby]

​@@SydonX3 Overlord looks cute tho 😊, still I get ur point!

[@Seraph_op]

I gave it to Navia, no way I let her swing cardboard @@a-passerby

[@sebastianheck49]

I only pull on that scam banner when i want both weapons. And even then i can still get shafted by standard bs.

[@Lukz243]

I wish the weapon banner had separated featured 5-stars weapons so that it wouldn't be as much hassle as it is currently. :(

[@user-lk6wy8mz6w]

Yeah. Put the gacha in one banner and the weapons in the other 😂

[@Seraph_op]

So like Star Rail?

[@blastchaos4286]

Weapons should NOT be on gacha banners!!

[@fathanbaghiz2576]

​@@Seraph_opyes as f2p that can easy without spend all primo

[@Nephale]

@@Seraph_op Or pgr or other gachas.

[@pumbawins9652]

There's IMO 4 scenarios when pulling a 5 star weapon is worth it. 1. It's a very good generalist option for multiple characters you like. 2. It's a very good support weapon (like crane's echoing call, Nilou signature, Elegy) 3. Very good weapon for characters that do most of the team's damage output, like Scara or Neuvillette. 4. It's for a character you really like, so you just want to get the best for them.

[@Larkian]

I think Crane in this case it's more specific for Xianyun teams specifically since it's pretty difficult to really use it on any other character. In comparison Elegy or Key are still good in other characters so they also fall in the 1st category but I agree with your takes nonetheless.

[@pumbawins9652]

@@Larkian good point, I'm just having way too much fun turning everything into plunge DPS with Xianyun right now

[@Axterix13]

I think there's a 5th one as well, which is basically for Xinyan... it fixes a fundamental flaw with the character's kit. Admittedly, that kind of falls into category 4, but I do think it makes Redhorn a particularly interesting weapon. It is strong for Itto, fixes Xinyan up to be a proper 4 star DPS, and is also great for Noelle.

[@pumbawins9652]

@@Axterix13 a fellow Xinyan main I see, very based. Also have Redhorn for her, but serpent spine r5 is most of the times just slightly behind it (exept for plunges) if you can maintain the stacks. Although Redhorn also allows you to do Def sands at c6, which is a very small damage loss but big survivability increase

[@studiesinflux1304]

Yep, I pulled weapon banner for reason #1: It just happens I use a lot of bow characters, so I used 200 pulls on the Lyney + Yelan bows banner.

[@bleedinme1]

There’s so much room for improvement on banners too .. instead of just giving us 3 star weapons.. they could give us mora exp books weapon ascension material… there’s so much they can do which they will never do sadly .. they could even have a 4 star fragile resin card which u get on every 10 pull or 20 pull

[@froeloe]

This is a great suggestion. Unfortunately, Hoyoverse is allergic to great suggestions.

[@juanlife6255]

this would be awesome

[@handsomejack2201]

No gacha make such changes in the middle of its life, wish full thinking.

[@ixirion]

if they give you a green book instead of 3 star weapon it dont do much. if they increase and we get purple books that are 60 extra purple books per month for F2p. 60 purple books are 200 resin - mostly worthless. it is a bad suggestion cos it will destroy game economy balance. they will reduce the books from events/chests/ley lines to compensate cos the economy works if you lose resources and play/pay to get them

[@bleedinme1]

@@ixirion okay thank you for enlightening us with the games economic strategy… we need more smart people like you in this world and further..

[@roennyh1362]

Another thing I wanted to add regarding the 5 star weapons is how often they arent the best options just based on what artifacts you have available. I have SoH for HuTao but rarely use it on her because I have yet to roll a decent crit rate circlet. So the RNG of artifact farming can essentially stop a character from properly maximizing the increase their signature weapon offers because of overall stat balance.

[@aerohydra3849]

IMO vertical investment priority should generally focus on teamwide significant damage buffs first- things like Furina C1/C2, Nahida C2, etc.,. as their contribution to team dps is a consistent percent rather than dependent on damage distribution. Since no character does 100% of the team's damage, basically every personal damage increase gets diluted, and this is obviously a lot more apparent with most mixed distribution teams.

[@johns783]

jebus why did i read your post in TDS's accent...

[@ixirion]

here is a dif viewpoint I have all 5 stars at C0 and 36 abyss with a 30-60 secs to spare. If I get Furina C2 or Nahida C2 it makes the game even easier for me so less fun... XDDD

[@BeavisVolg]

My team: Eula C0R1 Raiden C3R1 Furina C1 Mika C2 What im aiming for next: Furina C2 + weapon, Eula C6 and Mika C6. Once that team is ready then I'll work on a Navia team in the same fashion as I already have Navia C0R1 or if I manage to snatch a Shenhe then I'll build a team with her.

[@johns783]

@@BeavisVolg I'm aiming for a Eula c6 eventually, too. Let's hope the Mondstadt banner they release isn't a total pos and the only way to get her cons in the future.. Though my teams are Raiden C3R1, Diona, c6 Sara, and C0 Eula alongside C0 HuTao, Furina c2, Xq, and Cloud Retainer.

[@AkiraN19]

True. That's the logical approach and something I keep in mind But you also gotta consider that a lot of the times the kinds of people who pull for signatures aren't necessarily people who are trying to min/max everything. A lot of the times people will put a signature just because they really like that character or they want that character specifically to do more damage. So in that sense, the actual team DPS impact isn't as important. Since teams can already clear Abyss at C0R0, people really just want their favorite unit to do more personal damage

[@Indian_gay_boi]

i personally, only pull for weapons for characters I really like and want them to do more dmg, more often than not, their sig weapons look really good on them which is something I favour as well this is the exact reason why in hsr I always try to use the LC on a char with their face on it even if its a worse option for them unless I literally have no choice and the LC with their face on it is just a plain bad option

[@RagingPeanutButter]

Dude your channel is awesome. Quick intro outro. Informative explanation with no time wasted dancing around the topic, like streamers. Plus the info given, like from this video, is something even a veteran player like me could learn from.

[@Axterix13]

One thing worth noting about the Redhorn... it is good for Itto, but it also is great for Noelle and Xinyan. The latter especially. So it is a five star weapon... that also essentially gives you a new four star to play. That said, the biggest hindrance to five star weapons is the weapon banner system. It is just so full of fail, with two featured weapons, the five four star ones, the pain of getting refines for the weapon banner only four star ones, and so n. It, I'd say, is probably number 3 on my list of things Genshin needs to address. #1 being lack of an endgame/stuff to do when we have more time to play and #2 the amount of artifact RNG.

[@Marion_Impacto]

True. But why only Noelle and Xinyan? It's simply great claymore in general, for Diluc or Beidou as well. It's 5* crit weapon, so of course it's amazing. And yes, it's a great point that it 'gives you a new four star to play'. But again, it's not a specific case here. It's general value of good 5* weapons. They make weak characters relevant, your good characters - great, working well with your best characters, etc, they are easy fix for your builds, save you months of artifact farming and your mental health, they open hypercarry playstyle, cause you simply NEED a 5* weapon here to be competitive with other teams... Yup. And this video is terribly misleading, as it usually is with theorycrafters hyperfixated on DPS calculations that have little to do with reality. 5* weapons are totally worth it and underrated.

[@leedevee]

Really liked the way you systematically explained this topic. Hadn’t thought about a weapon’s value as in its contribution to the entire team’s damage. What would have been nice to mention is the the fact that a signature can make a character easier to build, mainly because of crit stats and sometime high atk or hp scaling to reach certain thresholds. Especially for newer players like me, who don’t have that good relics and struggle to maintain a good crit ratio without such a weapon. Yes there are some crit 4 stars like the BP weapons, but they’re not free either.

[@MereleFerele]

Tbh I just want 5 star weapons for characters whose best alternative is a 3 star. I love Tighnari, it just feels disrespectful to give him Slingshot, or Alhaitham Harbinger... even if it's not their sig they deserve something fancier, haha

[@alfredxsiv]

I don't have a single signature weapon in my account, for me it makes the game more fun using only "free to play" weapons since the end game is relatively not that hard especially if you're a veteran player. Though i do understand people pulling for the signature weapon just for the aesthetics, same reason why people buy the skins 😂

[@kurokenstein]

Spiral Abyss really hard for me, my damage really low, I just can barely got 26 star, and last Abyss I got 27 stars, even I already played this game about 3 months now, Idk why my damage is really low

[@shikharagarwal1169]

​@@kurokensteinit's just 3 months u ll get there by natlan, btw what team u use

[@chaosinfernoid9008]

​@@kurokenstein 3 months rooky number If you been playing casually. 💀 Don't worry mate it's normal. You can make a plathra of Teams that can go through IT pretty easily. Try your own teams even trust me.

[@TheStrongestBaka]

This tbh, I've never pulled on a weapon banner, have no fav swords and only one (garbage) 5 star weapon, I'm still 36 starring and have some primos to spare. F2P btw.

[@orfeasza]

Artifacts make the biggest difference. You can clear with 36 stars with godlike arts and 3star weapons.

[@GTsvetkovski]

Variety is the spice of life. I think there's no reason to pull for a weapon before you feel like you have enough characters to experiment with. My Main DPS units right now are Xiao, Diluc, Eula, Childe, Cyno, Neuvillette and Navia, all Floor 12 ready. After I get Kazuha, I may consider sniping Neuvi's signature, but he's hitting 45-50k per hit with Amber anyway, could just save for Natlan.

[@Nephale]

Early weapon banner pulls are not just for the signature but also the 4*. New players don't have access to many event weapons and an abundance of favonious but usually just a couple bells and flutes. The game doesn't shower you in billets either.

[@Larkian]

@@Nephaleit still takes a lot of time but I wonder how many billets they give through the upgrade "building" in each region or subregion like the Aranara Tree, Sacred Sakura Tree, Lumenstone upgrade, etc.

[@Nephale]

@@Larkian Not enough. I am a fairly new player and completed all of them. enough to r5 the inazuma sword and r1 bennetts sword but now i am kinda out of them. And not all craftable weapons are good. Craftable bows are just sad.

[@GTsvetkovski]

​@@NephaleMaybe you're right, I didn't consider that since I've gotten A LOT of fav weapons while going for characters (day 1 player, quit in 2.2 and returned in 3.8) and have R4 sword, R8 spear, R6 Bow and R6 Codex, don't think I've pulled more than 3 of them on weapon banner

[@bloody4558]

​@@Nephale Till this day the only good craftable bow is Liyue's, because that thing is essentially a 5-star stat stick such as Wolf's Gravestone

[@peoneer576]

Wonderful vid! It provides us very good perspective on 5 stars weapons. If I may give a suggestion tough, it would be great to implement timestamps on your vids. Thanks! Keep up the great work!

[@TheGenshinScientist]

There are vids where I want people to listen to the whole thing to get the point and not just jump from point to point, thats why no timestamps here

[@YungXin]

valid arguments but fashion impact, also personally i rather get weapons over constellations even if constellations give better returns since most of them dont change character playstyle just like weapons but weapons can be transfered and in someway change the way u build characters via stat allocation

[@soujiokita6062]

Yeah for example a weapon with high crit value for dps character can be less taxing when it comes to farming artifacts

[@snoobcat]

Some cons do change character playstyle though and the team building as well. Hu tao c1 for example, neuvilette c1 allows you to not run a shielding character making his gameplay very smooth and comfy, wriothesley c1 fixes all his problems etc. Whereas weapons are just bigger numbers. Transferrable sure but genshin is already way too easy at this point. Especially with furina bloating everyone's numbers. Using Furina c2 is like giving everyone on the team a 5* weapon lol.

[@YungXin]

@@snoobcat did u not read most, weapons let u build weird shit thanks to the extra stat like hypercarry dori, I find it more interactive to change my artifacts than wow more dmg bcs i slapped furina in every damn team I'm playing

[@snoobcat]

@@YungXin C2 furina allows anyone to be a hypercarry since she is the best damage buffer and is a staple in any hypercarry teams including dori without any 5* weapon. 5* weapons is also pretty restrictive actually since there are 5 different weapon types. If you only have homa for example, you can't make dori hypercarry. You would have to wish for 5 different weapon types, which may require you to wish 1000+ times compared to furina c2. And not to mention, some weapons just doesn't fit certain characters because some characters gain crit rate ascension and you can't give them jade cutter coz you will have too much crit rate. Some characters also have different playstyles that doesn't fit certain weapons, lyney's sig weapons buffs ca which is not compatible with yoimiya's playstyle. You can still use it but the weapon's potential will be wasted. Furina doesn't have any of this restriction.

[@YungXin]

@@snoobcat I am not putting furina in my double anemo thundering fury kazuha aggravate team, nor will she be in my random bullshit go Chevy overload team. she's good but she's just a character, I don't want her in every team even if it's more dmg. i rather get it from weapons and play whoever the hell i want. emphasis on the point that it does not change playstyle at all for most const, ik it's better but idc please re-read the original comment if u wanna argue that I should pour all my gems into a char idgaf abt

[@LD-yy6qt]

For me it's all about the crit on 5 star weapons. It makes it significantly easier to build characters when I have a crit weapon. The 4 star weapons with crit don't seem nearly as good except maybe serpent spine but that weapon also has an annoying effect if not run with Zhongli/strong shielder.

[@tommyhickin4669]

Especially for catalysts when even the 4 stars are things like widsith with 1 random buff active 1/3 of the time, which worsens if the character doesn’t need one of the passive buffs. If I get yae, kagura’s is defo on my radar, even if it’s on a future rerun. As someone who is sick of building characters and finds weapons easier to farm for, I’m entering a phase where I’m happier to pull for cons or weapons to improve my existing characters, but on the occasional new character I do want to get or for characters I want to rebuild when a new artifice set releases, weapons definitely appeal for their ease of building. Think nilou for the almost year in which key had the best HP scaling by miles - probably the best weapon I ever pulled and I still don’t regret saving for it alongside her first banner (although I would’ve picked nahida over it if I didn’t save enough for both)

[@losergamer04]

I pulled on 5* weapon banner when I needed the 4 and 5 star weapons so I can build more characters. I have every 4* and I enjoy them very much. I like swapping teams a lot so they are all decently built with their own builds. As such, I have very random smattering of 5* weapons. I haven’t pulled in a while because the event weapons have held me over.

[@maevethefox5912]

I'd played for a year and a half and still didn't have a Favonius Sword, so you'd better believe I pulled a bunch on the last weapon banner. Raiden and Yoimiya got their signatures, but more importantly I have an r5 and r3 Fav sword now xD

[@losergamer04]

@@maevethefox5912 That sums up my point better than I could. Pull on it when you have a specific use for each weapon.

[@aRandomXanobladeFan2596]

Hi! I loved your video and for your "tier list" of dmg contribution and sig weapon strength, how about doing an alignment chart instead? With for example one axis being the strength of the character's weapon and the other one being the character's damage contribution!

[@scrubcleangr4113]

Your thumbnail is crazy good tgs

[@usmanya5110]

5 star weapons are usually a hit or miss even the banners are scary cause you may get the weapon you don't want twice. let's not forget energy reqs with some of the units in this game when you consider the like i don't have Aqua but if i did i'm not giving it to my yelan since i'm scared if i can't get her burst back on time and if i have a 5 star weapon i'd rather use Elegy.

[@----x-----]

Do the same weapon ranking for 4 stars, past c6 the 5 weapons are one of the few ways to vertically invest in parties with 4 stars who cant get extra constellations

[@jeremiahbullfrog226]

I'm thankful for this insight, because I since I did finally get Raiden, I did also get very lucky with minimal pulls and got her polearm, since I'd like to use her as both a main and sub DPS as I see fit, and since I plan on using her so much, I wanted her to look good. I really don't like The Catch tbh, but I don't mind using it on someone else. And when I got Nahida this banner, I considered going for her weapon, but I opted to try for bird mom instead. I don't think I'll get her, but now I don't feel second thoughts on not going for Nahida's weapon. I only have three 5* weapons. Raiden's, Wolf's Gravestone, and the Sacred Winds book. I have a pretty nice selection of 4* and even 3* weapons to go with, so it's really fine.

[@hritwikranjan2198]

My account was gonna be forever bricked were it not for Navia being an attack scaler and being able to use one of my two Unforgeds. Hopefully the next one is useable on Pyro Archon.

[@GunNutsRNuts]

So Wriothesley’s best team being reverse melt (with Bennett, Nahida and Thoma), his signature is calc’ed to be 30% better than Lost Prayer. It depends on how much of a hypercarry role you will giving to your main DPS in order to justify the weapon investment. Weapons like EL on Raider are not a bad investment, they improve team damage by indirectly lowering teammate ER requirement allowing offensive stats to be more. It is not as easy a choice for supports compared to main DPs units.

[@TheGenshinScientist]

I don't believe thats his best team. To me it's Wrio Xiangling Bennett Furina. Pyro app is pretty consistent for melts there

[@GunNutsRNuts]

@@TheGenshinScientist I meant for his personal damage, other than perhaps his hypercarry team with Shenhe, Furina and Bennett. The Bennet/XL core will usually give more team damage which is when as you said a signature weapon on Wrio is less useful. The Pyro application is more consistent in the Nahida Thoma team because of Burning aura which stays consistent with long off field Pyro from Thoma. It is also more synergistic of a team because Thoma at C6 buffs Wrio NA and protects him from burning with a effective shield against pyro and Nahida gives EM.

[@DonKangolJones]

I have to laugh b/c pretty much any video about Genshin, in almost any subject, is a video about Furina now. I'm not mad. It's just pretty amazing how important of a character she is.

[@user-rm3itr40rnd]

She is universal buffer/subdd that doesn't force you to play circle impact. Even old characters as Eula, Xiao or Noelle became much more effective and comfortable to play in abyss conditions having Furina in team.

[@gamestory2834]

Weapons are transferable, that's enough to say that weapons are an over time more worthy investment than a character's constellation or even a character. Though long term weapons are also susceptible to more competition as well. That said, characters open up new gameplay, which weapons rarely ever do, meaning that characters are still probably king, but weapons might be better long term unless you plan to play the same team for years. However, that seems just miserable, unless it's an infusion or otherwise gameplay changing low con upgrade. I just know that the increase in damage from Oathsworn eye to Xianyun's signature was direct and insane. It was like 35% or so on the plunges.

[@johns783]

weapons, unlike new characters, don't require artifacts. that's enough for me to consider hyperinvesting in favs. Going all in on 2 teams, and when they're fully decked out I will consider making a 3rd. I"m absolutely all good with rocking the same few teams, due to how much I like certain characters vs the others.

[@zerddrez235]

5:22 You are basically going over all of my Mains 😂 Tbh, I‘m so glad Neuvillette will rerun with Kazuha (and Wanderer probably with Navia, fingers crossed). If I‘m lucky, I can get theor 2 weapons!

[@MojtaAS]

wanderer can now use flowing purity in a freeze team with furina so i'd say he can get away with a 4 star weapon neuvilette R1 and his constellations pretty much give the same damage increase/same stats so you can get away with proto amber assuming both use furina personally i think navia xiao and itto are the only ones who can benefit greatly from getting their R1 and one of them is a standard weapon you might have

[@martnsalah8941]

Which do you think is more valuable going for R1 itto or chirori ?

[@MojtaAS]

@@martnsalah8941 for the characters themselves itto without hesitation for other characters itto and chiori R1s are pretty good stat sticks if you want to pull on that upcoming banner its pretty good value imo and hopefully the 4 star weapons are good aswell

[@agiant5715]

Amazing video sir. I used to think only generalist 5* weapons were worth it to pull (my only limited one being mistsplitter), but now I realise I rarely equip it outside of ayaka teams anymore because the moderate TEAM DAMAGE (thanks again for your videos making me learn to take into account this concept btw) increase overall is overshadowed by other 4* choices QOL bonuses like fav sword ER generation.

[@agiant5715]

A point I would like to share is that if 5* weapons were the only way to fix problems with certain characters kits there may probably be a greater incentive to pull on the dreadful weapon banner but not only are Cons as you stated available, there are new characters that can do the same while also opening new gameplay mechanics and teams comps when you pull them. A recent personal example is my C0R0 hu tao, which was benched since ver 3 is now baller with furina giving her such a huge boost to the point of Fjords being only a bit weaker choice than her sig and xianyun changing the annoying jump cancel to a total dps increase making her c1 obsolete.

[@jacobwhittaker6241]

I just got the jade spear from the standard banner, should I use it or keep using the catch on my C1 Raiden?

[@mouradsofian1724]

is it still going to be worth pulling for key of khaj nisut for Nilou if i already have C2 Nahida.

[@loonastrawberry]

i only pull for 5* weapons ONLY when: 1. there are TWO useful for my account 5* weapons. if there's only one, i'm not gonna pull for this 2. there are weapons for characters i often use in abyss or universal weapons that are gonna be good for many characters (raiden's weapon for example)

[@beancake]

I sometimes do a 10 pull on the weapon banner for the 4* weapons. It's hard to get the favonius and sacrificial weapons otherwise. When I was close to full pity for a 5*, I pulled on the Ayato/Cyno weapon banner since both are useful on a lot of characters and ended up with Cyno's weapon. I don't have Cyno or Ayato but I'm able to put the spear on my Raiden or Xiangling, and it is definitely noticeable! I don't have the catch because I hate fishing. I think as long as you're looking for general weapons and don't care what you get, the weapon banner is fine. It's still dreadful odds and definitely would not try to get a signature for a specific character. It's nuts to me that you can even get a standard banner 5* weapon from the weapon banner for your pity.

[@treysmith9371]

I definitely think general team support weapons like elegy deserve to be higher on this list

[@thatguyFS6961]

thank u for this vid i was really wondering if i should pull for c1 neuvillete or his weapon and i think ill go for the weapon now

[@ninthfriend3347]

I would go for these weapons if the weapons aren't shared in a banner. Starting 1.4, Hsr has already ran separate lightcone banners with Topaz and Seele. This made me feel more confident on going for the sig lightcones I want since I don't have to worry about winning 50/50 after winning 75/25. There is no reason that Genshin's weapon banner remains shared for years. Even as a welkin/bp buyer, I would still not go for the weapon banners. Not feeling confident in getting the 5* star weapon I want because there's a chance that I can lose the 50/50 once or worst, twice...after winning the 75/25...

[@Kaiserker]

I pull when I want the drip for my mains. Xiao, Hu Tao, and Alhaitham all look amazing with their signatures. Saving for Furina C6, so I'll get her signature after as it'd be an upgrade to Festering at that point.

[@Seraph_op]

If you don't get her weapon the sacrificial sword is her best alternative at c6 possibly even her best weapon

[@Kaiserker]

@@Seraph_op didn't know that. thanks!

[@AkiraN19]

Very good and insightful video. Even if I already knew about how team DPS breakdown affects the weapon value ...I will now proceed to ignore all of it and pull the signatures of my mains anyways. For the drip of course

[@ixirion]

if we however consider multiple signatures and good investment it can be ok cos if you increase a unit contributing 50% of the dmg by 20% it is 10% dmg increase. It can translate to 8-10 sec faster clear times. its very complicated matter. for example Childe can nuke for 400k Imo biggest strenghts for me is that most signatures make building crit stats easier and reduce artifact farming. some of the weapons add versatility in teams. ofc having the meta units is better but after a while a few 5 star weapons that you can slap on whatever char + mid artifacts is very convininent

[@seniorakxel]

I mean, I think some weapons are worth it because of the passive, beyond the high stats. I have several 5* weapons, but the only ones I looked for were Raiden's and Xianyun's. The rest of the weapons I got in low pity or in the permanent banner and managed to get some use from them like the polar star in Faruzan

[@trashbuilds8351]

THIS IS SO GOOD!!! And answers perfectly the issue of building a character to their optimum vs a team to their optimum - but with actual numbers I love that some 3*s and 4*s are so good they are close enough to 5* not to really need them - in that sense I appreciate this aspect of how they balance the game

[@yayie2235]

Not quite but I do understand where you're going for here. Some signiture weapons has its own passive that could somewhat elevate the troubles on the artifact side. Like ER regeneration from Xianyun's sig for example, so that you don't need to build too much ER and use those rolls on certain stats that's needed. Or The Key for Nilou's HP + EM will help you greatly on the artifact side.

[@bumerang6525]

TGS i have a question, in the clips you're showing in background while talking, is it your account or like editor (if you have editor ofc)

[@TheGenshinScientist]

I record all my clips and edit videos myself

[@shadibrahim1489]

Only ones iv gone for were on banners that I wanted both weapons on. Al haitham and kazuha banner I got 2 LoFi. Yelan banner I got Aqua Simulacra. Xianyun and Nahida banner I can use both weapons

[@tomekpiatek88]

The differenve can be higher than numbers show. In practice there are break points and team rotations. Often you can defeat an enemy in either one rotation or in two rotations. A speciffic weapon can make that difference. This means sometimes you are two times faster with BIS and that is 100% team damage increase.

[@TheGenshinScientist]

Yes but breakpoints are more of a speedrun thing. I agree that at high invest the smallest things can make a significant difference but this was more of a general view video

[@asafin100]

Five star weapons for DPS or subdps characters have the sole purpose of turning your build easier, since most of them will have crit dmg or rate as the substat and the passive normally contains bonus for the stat that character scales with (so it will give bonus HP, ATK , EM or even energy). So it really helps that you don’t have to spend months of your life farming to achieve 200% crit damage with 70% crit rate for example, which is what most people consider the ideal. But yeah, for characters that don’t deal damage I guess they are pretty useless. Like, I have Baizhu’s signature just because he is my favorite character but I know it makes 0 difference lol I wouldn’t recommend getting the signature just in 2 occasions, one if that character is a complete support without any type of damage dealing (so mostly Venti, Kokomi, Zhongli, Baizhu, Shenhe, Kazuha), the second is if you already have a 5 star weapon or a 4 star bis for that character. For example, if you have The Catch for your Raiden there’s absolutely no reason to pull for Engulfing Lightning And Albedo… poor guy doesn’t benefit from any five star weapon, so definitely don’t put a five star weapon on Him lol

[@Kasraken]

Interesting, I got a couple 5 star weapons (Raiden's, Yelan's, Navia's, and Homa without owning Hu Tao). But I also have one you didn't place on the list, Dehya's weapon? I know we can't get it anymore since she went to the standard banner but I knew that when she released so I got one copy of it and 2 constellations on her, yet I digress. @TheGenshinScientist What I am asking is where would her weapon fall on that Tier list? Anyway good video!

[@Honed-]

pulled wander wep for wander. i knew it was a pretty much a must pull for him, didnt feel bad for getting it since i got it in 20 pulls lol.

[@Fairy-Uvinq]

Then there's also that the higher dmg you do, the higher er you may need in some units because you kill too fast. Elegy is very good for yelan or fischl also. Xianyun on the other hand, for plunge dps its pretty much a sig for them

[@martnsalah8941]

I resonant with this, my alhaithem can't finish his combo 70% of the time even with nahida and fav on 130 ER

[@Fairy-Uvinq]

@@martnsalah8941 ya. On paper an r5 and c6 are a massive increase in dps sometimes but the er needs may increase significantly and thus reduce the maximun dps you can actually do too. Investment is deceptive, even something like the r5 of xianyun is more about balancing how fast you kill instead of eliminating the er needs per se even thou its such a monstrous wep. Its a dual edged sword really unless your character doesn't need er. My gaming, even with 51 er and c6 can struggle a bit because bosses rarely survive more than 1 to 2 Es for example

[@martnsalah8941]

@@Fairy-Uvinq same mine has 166 ER not even C6 and he still struggles with ER because he doesn't get to finish his rotation so sadly I am running fav with like 190 ER in open world just because it's pointless and legit less DPS to use a stronger wepaons

[@Fairy-Uvinq]

@@martnsalah8941 178 seems like a good spot but I need to test it around. What annoys me more is that ben and and furina seems kinda short on er. Specially bennet since he uses instructor and my furina is kinda monster artifact wise sigh

[@rukia6090]

Thank you for the video! It was really interesting

[@dewanegara8333]

Ah yes, let's embrace the favonius meta. Favonius for love, favpnius for live.

[@hazelmaple1842]

In regards to Wriothesley what other weapons would you recommend for him? I’m planning to pull for him but I don’t think I’ll have the savings for his signature so looking for suggestions

[@krummesblech]

The good thing about Rizzly is that there are many good alternatives and the difference from its Signature is not that big. Lost Prayer, Skyward Atlas, Widsith, Fontaine Craftable, Ballad (Event weapon)

[@hazelmaple1842]

Thanks for the tip!

[@flacko24]

if the genshin banner changes to be like honkai then is going to be worth to invest the banner, I play genshin since day 1 and I only tried to get the missplitter because I have ayaka and also my beloved keqing so the value is 200% for me and now I can put the sword on chiori too

[@a-passerby]

For someone who has never pulled on weapon banner, been playing for 2 years now and have been clearing abyss 36* for so long, this is my view on this topic - I never pulled on weapon banner for 2 main reasons - 1) The game gives only so much primos per patch, plus getting the weapon u want can even take upto 210-220 fates, which is a lot for me to save for one weapon, which I could spend on 2-3 characters at worst of lucks... 2) I can peacefully clear abyss with time to spare with 4*star, some of which are not even R5 yet..... What's the point of spending 200 fates, just to clear the abyss, maybe 5-6 seconds faster? For a 5* weapon user, they might clear it stuff in 1-2 rotations, i do it in 2-3 rotations... We both clear the same abyss.... I love playing multiple teams, trying new stuff with multiple characters, for example, I don't have or want Xiao, still pulled for Xianyun, i want to try Diluc, I love Gaming's playstyle, i wanna try that, Raiden plunges? Alhaitham? Its a game to have fun right? Getting more characters to make some of my characters work, like Shenhe for my Ayaka, Ganyu or Yae or Arlecchino to try overloaded, I don't mind building new characters for that only takes one week or two of farming materials.... artifacts can be reused most of the time on multiple characters (+ 2 pc exist ), so - If someone gives me 200 wishes to spend on, rather than wasting them for one weapon, which maybe a 10-20% increase in dmg, I could just get 2 different characters who i can try different teams and reactions and have fun with! Yep, Farming is tough, but we all do it anyways, there is no need to have 250 CD on every dps in order to clear the abyss.... Even 150-180 is more than enough Also,the only reason I would ever pull a 5* weapon is when the game forces me to do that, like them saying, "U must have a 5* weapon to enter this domain, playing which u can get 1000+ primos or something", it may happen, maybe by implementing some new gamemode or even harder content, although very unlikely 😅 Drip is true, but that's not a huge concern for me though ( Too long i know, but i had so much to say too, i also don't expect anyone would read and reply to this either 😅 )

[@Xelluse]

Still, the real reason for me is 2), even if Signas would take 50 pulls to get, there is no real point to spend it on them, Genshin always pushed itself as a casual immersive adventure and even Abyss, which is literally only a DPS checker is not that hard and can be beaten with 3* weapons, the problem is Artifacts more, rather than weapon's "Stars", and even then, simply just learning mechanics of the game makes Abyss 12 9* not that hard with medium quality Stat Artifacts, so simply there is no real reason to waste a single wish on 5* weapons in Genshin, only if for "Fashion" for character player "simps" and this is a good thing, cos player can simply focus on pulling characters even if he is fully F2P and just ignore Weapon's banner and save for other characters.

[@a-passerby]

@@Xelluse Yep... exactly! 💯

[@user-rm3itr40rnd]

@@Xelluse There are many signature weapons those colors don't even fit its main character so they're not worth it even for fashion purpose. HoYo, weapon repaint option when?

[@Xelluse]

@@user-rm3itr40rnd Not many, and still worth, cos some may fit other characters, when I say Fashion, I do not mean only Signa of character on specifically that Character only.

[@bzkill]

I feel like childe's dmg contribution in international is more than 40% most of the time 6:38

[@user-ji7jf6kb5e]

yep on equal investment Childe actually does a bit more damage. But its so close to 50 50 so he is still gonna be on the same tier.

[@bzkill]

​@user-ji7jf6kb5e that's fair, but i'd personally place him a bit higher since his 4* options aren't great (outside of maybe viridescent hunt?)

[@fzhs7030]

In practice the frontload alone makes having a limited 5* weapon a huge increase over the best 4* (vhunt) so in Childe's case this wasn't really accurate.

[@mononymouslyjan8313]

will bookmark this video, need to use it whenever ppl are getting peer pressured to pull a signature :

[@raezal2883]

True I'm never again doing Gacha in weapon banner I only had 6 of 5 star weapon 2 from rate up banner and the rest is from loose my 5050 and also from standard banner

[@Nanogat]

the last time im pulling for a 5 star weapon is on yelan first banner. after a month playing yelan I decide to give her fav bow until now because its alot smother rotation comparing when she uses her signature. So I put yelan signature bow on fischl.

[@Cajun_Seasoning]

I go for weapons once i have everything else invested in and its a character I use all the time, and I'll only go for it if i'd be fine with getting either weapon on the banner. Basically I don't pull often on it. Early-mid game no one should be pulling for 5* weapons at all tbh, unless its for the 4*s.

[@Goremize]

I am amazed, so amazed that the weapon banner is somehow worse then it was 3 years ago. How is it that we still after 3 years only have one weapon banner and many weapons are just diluted on the standard banner. Why don't they run three back to back weapon banners with 6 different five star weapons and 3 different 4 star pools at once or something? Why is it the exact same compared to launch besides the Fate Epitome feature. or better yet, let us put a focus on the standard banner that if a weapon drops it drops the weapon you want there. I remember at launch all the weapons were pretty much good for all the characters. You got a Skyward blade/wolf blade? Congrats ALL your Claymore wielders got their Bis/2nd bis. Now you get one of these focus's and congrats, you might have some use maybe on the character its made for even though some older weapons are better for the character its made for. I quit this game for awhile before coming back on a new account. The pool is so bloated and the game has just had way to many unsustainable FOMO banners. A gacha game really can't live on FOMO forever. The Revenue this game used to bring in has plummeted and its the devs own fault for not doing anything about the many issues the game has. Why are four stars now rarer then five stars? If you want to focus on some of them you have to wait 8+months for it to be featured to be able to get dupes?...

[@skyzip4k171]

what about generalist weapons like mistsplitter, homa and jadecutter?

[@redsky397]

I only got reborn, and now maybe I will get chioris weapon. Just because i don’t like the fact that hod needs the character to stay above 90% health. I use that for albedo but all it takes is one hit to be lower and then I can’t heal him back because I use him with bennet

[@thebrigade7684]

Yeah pretty agreeable there's not a way to prevent baits because a lot of people think cons and weapons do a lot for you problem starts when our only content that remotely requires these investments are only floor 12. Floor 12 has been the only combat endgame since 1.0 . Only thing changed is DPS checks for 36*. Let that sink in the game is close to 4 years old almost

[@jessicafuller5658]

My Liney is C1 with his signature bow cause its a gorgeous bow! Navia has one of the best looking weapons in the game so of coarse she needed it. And my Dragon king Mr. Neuvillette got his drip too. Sad i missed Furinas weapon but i will try on her rerun

[@jackzubo6028]

For me the main reason i pull for 5* weapons is to make building a character easier, that's why almoust all of my 5* weapons are the crit rate/crit damage weapons that are more universaly good. I also generally only pull on weapon banners where both 5* weapons are actually good/usefull for me.

[@naenae4953]

for me 5 star weapon only worth to pull if you have spare primo, like i have guaranteed on character banner with 10 pity but i have some 90 pull to spend in this month, yeah i think maybe just depending on the weapon and what character and team etc

[@pauljoseph3081]

For someone who lost to Homa 2 f*cking years already. I'm gonna pull for Neuv's weapon as it also comes with Kazuha's weapon. I'll trick HoYo that I want Neuv's weapon so that they'll give me Kazuha's wep lol

[@Eclin]

I’ll consider IF they change how the banner works, similar to HSR. Edit: and they are holy inconsistent, in both fashion and functionality. You get ugly ass sword for Nilou and mismatch colors like Ayaka and Yoimiya. Sometimes they are nearly useless like Kokomi’s donut or Baizhu’s donut, but sometimes they solve characters energy issue lol.

[@therosetheghost5637]

Crit weapons, specially the 44cv ones make artifact farming extremely easier tho. Unless you are a very old player or dump all your resin on artifacts (thus building less characters) it’s unlikely that they can be built in a comparable way, Yelan and Furina are good examples, in paper the signature weapon is not that big of a deal but if you get the signature weapon the good rolls on artifacts are now hp, er and crit instead of only crit. The whole concept of comparing weapons asumes that you will have the resin, time and interest to dump it all into 40 CV pieces, making some of the weapons that cover the cv need less desirable by comparison

[@soujiokita6062]

My artifact luck is very bad (ar60 acc)and the crit weapon is what makes up for it ..

[@NonMeta_]

5-star weapons usually make builds easier because it's usually fewer substats you have to farm for. Less resin spent in domains. PJC made building Furina easy because I didn't need to look for Crit Rate substats that much.

[@Axterix13]

@@NonMeta_ While that aspect is true, that doesn't necessarily mean HER weapon is worth pulling for. You can get a crit stat from other weapons as well. Like, say, the Jade Cutter, a much less niche weapon. But, well, that only matters if you move weapons around. If you don't, then the most important thing is that the other weapon on the banner is also one you want.

[@therosetheghost5637]

Yeah, not necessarily a signature but i mentioned the ones that have 88% crit dmg cuz that’s a lot of CV. The resin required to get a good build feels like a lot less compared to an attack weapon for example. I see value in signature weapons cuz it means I can spend my resin in something else and be happy with 30-40 cv pieces with other useful stats instead of exponentially increasing the time I need for a strong build looking for a 40+ cv.

[@Marion_Impacto]

THIS. And there is much more to consider. Value of weapons is about builds and account. NOT about DPS calculations, whole approach in the video is missed and terribly misleading. Good 5* weaspons make weak characters relevant, your good characters - great, working well with your best characters, etc, they are easy fix for your builds, save you months of artifact farming and your mental health, they open hypercarry playstyle, cause you simply NEED a 5* weapon here to be competitive with other teams. All of that means more FUN. I always see theorycrafters telling nonsense when considering value of 5* weapons. Truth is they are totally worth it and obviously more than cons. Other thing you also have to know how to use weapon banner. Here is where most players fail, fixating on signatures. While non-whales should simply accept true gacha experience - pull and be happy with what you get.

[@FranciscoJG]

I didn't really understand your reasoning for Itto. Aside from that, even in "hyper carries" I'm only comfortable to go for 5-star weapons if the dps increase over my available options is above 30% - that's why my Alhaitham still has HoD and my Neuvillette is going to keep the Sac Jade. The only weapons I wished for were Redhorn for Itto and Mistsplitter for Kaeya :)

[@user-iw2vf7pb7s]

Well if both of weapons in a banner are signatures or meaningfull upgrades to your favorites why not pull if you have primos? Its not that big of an upgrade usually but why not?

[@mulipe8009]

There are good points in this video, but there is another thing I should add: Some signature weapons may make the character stronger but also require farming for specific artifacts for a character and therefore make them harder to build. Take Raiden for example: Though her sig makes her powerful and has recharge, it requires her to have more crit rate, an electro goblet, and an energy recharge sands which is quite difficult to farm for. With The Catch, however, it doesn't require as much difficulty farming artifacts. You can get her an attack goblet which is WAY WAY WAY easier to find rather than an electro one as well as not having to get as much crit rate because The Catch provides that for ya. I can't say another example or my comment length is too long.😅

[@memshad]

Im ar60 with i think about 15 limited characters and only have 2 limited 5 star weapons and theyre both from the same banner, i just never pull on weapon banner since it never feels worth it compared to the fun of new characters with new playstyles

[@tracer4b]

I think what’s missing from this analysis is that certain 5* weapons are more versatile than others, so they can upgrade more characters. Aqua for example isn’t the biggest increase for Yelan since she’s a subdps and you can run Favonius. But its value lies more in that it’s good enough that any bow user can make use of it

[@unknownkw]

Venti's weapon is often considered to be the single most broken weapon it the game. At R5 it's like an additional Bennett that buffs the whole team from just a single weapon which is totally ridiculous. It even gives high amount of ER to make sure its ability is fired every rotation, although it limits the rotation length to be at least 20 seconds.

[@typicpoem8764]

For wanderer, do you recommend pulling cash flow over his own signature?

[@warduxe]

only if you use furina with him and okay with getting juggled around or one shot

[@walter1824]

Zhongli: the most beautiful looks, weapon, artifact set of all time And the worst kit, weapon passive, and artifact passive of all time I think Albedo and Baizhu`s signatures aren`t that bad

[@CaptainObvious59]

I’m trying to get a flexible cr and cd weapon in each weapon category, so I can have pretty good options for every dps character

[@Starmonkey69]

I am actually thinking of doing the same thing. I even have a tier list for the weapons I can pull for in each category, bows : Polar star or aqua simulacra or thundering pulse catalysts : don't know. most of them are too niche. Maybe I'll will use widsith or lost prayer if I get it one day. swords : mistsplitter(this weapon is such a blessing, can be used on a dps, can be used on bennett.) polearms : staff of homa or staff of scarlet sands (primodial works too I guess) claymores : redhorn or wolf's gravestone(not crit but my god this thing gives so much attack)

[@CaptainObvious59]

@@Starmonkey69 haha i got almost the same list ! I got aqua simulacra, Kagura/lost prayers, mist splitter/jade cutter, homa/primordial jade, redhorn /wolf gravestone I just need a cr bow and claymore and it will be perfect

[@user-rm3itr40rnd]

@@Starmonkey69 Dehya's claymore is great too.

[@natonaa9681]

I've been playing genshin for 5 months and am now saving for nilou (im f2p). Im not a meta player and im almost certain that the characters i already have + nilou are gonna be enough on my account for now, so not wanting to pull anybody else. Im considering pulling for her signature, is it worth it?

[@kimakhiangte]

Yes, Nilou weapon is worth it as there's only 2 HP sword in the whole game, Nilou weapon and Xiphos. Since Nilou is heavily scaled on HP, it's worth the pull for her. Since Xiphos is almost always clubbed together om Nilou weapon banner, it's a viable alternative for her even if you loss for her sig too.

[@mrrobot4257]

dude if i have cracked artifacts i wouldnt pull for weopns but the states are needed if youe artifact not so good

[@Xelluse]

I always was pulling Signa weapons only to make them fit character's visual style and only for characters I actively like to play with and who I "simp" (in simple words).

[@ZatchQQ]

not worth pulling on support weapons like kazuha sword for exemple?

[@ugotmybeef]

Kazuha case, I'd argue getting er for the team from xiphos/fav is more useful to the team. Also ER might be harder to balance with freedom.

[@ZatchQQ]

@@ugotmybeef how much is enough er?

[@wiz_lime]

He says that signature weapon of Navia isn't good with bennett. That is now one of the reason why I like it.

[@ZoField]

How are you getting these damage figures?? the game doesnt have a feature where it tells you how much damage the character did, which i really wished it had... So in a team with double hydo, how are you able to tell who is doing the hydro damage? especially since they are all off field damage dealers and damage numbers are flying all over the place...

[@TheGenshinScientist]

I calculate the team dmg myself

[@FinalFinale]

So how valuable are support weapons like Elegy vs maindps ones?

[@qwertysysysyysysysyzz]

better value, homa vs r5 db on hutao is only a 3k-9k per CA increase in her best teams, while elegy would be 15k-30k per CA , freedom sworn would be at around 10k increase per CA aswell.

[@miggymigz9242]

The first time I reached pity in the weapon banner I got Yoi's weapon and I haven't pulled since.

[@IdeasAreBulletproof]

As a HSR Player. 4 Star/Some 4 star forgotten Haul and "5 Star Sim uni shop weapons" aren't that much lower then the 5 star signatures. Other then Jing Yuan's Before Dawn, on average the Best S5 4 star or Herta shop LC is about 80-85% of a Signature LC. The thing is about HSR though is the Lightcones of the Characters running (One inital and one Rerun) are separated and the pity is 70 instead of 80 and it is 75/25 instead of 240 pity fate system that's 33/67. Most Signature LCs aren't worth it to your average F2P player/Light Spender especially if one goes to 80/90 pity/loses their 50/50s, but the LC banner is WAY better in Hsr then Genshin Impact.

[@Hyuinn]

I pulled on engulfing Lightning because I like the weapon's design and also because I didn't want take my "The Catch" off Xiangling, my Raiden deserves better

[@arvidanseven862]

weapons worth pulling in my opinion: jade cutter, mistsplitter, eternal flow, aqua, homa, redhorn, scarlet sand, and beacon.

[@AzureDrag0n1]

I pulled for weapons if both were good like the legendary Elegy + Homa weapon banner. I do not recommend doing this in your first year of playing the game where having a variety of characters is far far more important than weapons.

[@glovs4188]

Foliar incision can be weaker than HoD for all i care. It still looks godamn good.

[@piloswinne]

Very much agree with the video and the tier list at the end

[@saokatedo8570]

The reason I pull for 5 star weapons is when They are mostly universal to be used by a lot of characters, and specially because they make easier to built characters (specially whit my luck in crit rolls😢)

[@generalalatusfallingin]

Best advice anyone has ever given me was to never wish on the weapon banners because they are such a scam. If you really like the character and want to simp for them, pulling for weapons is never recommended...unless there are favonius weapons

[@lostrefugee]

I mostly get 5* weapons for aesthetic. that too only for my fav characters.

[@bloody4558]

3:10 but that is the precise reason why I consider these characters to be overrated in the first place. They ultra charge one stat needlessly. When you could simply get the weapon and use another character with a more specific buff for same results. Without having to enslave your team to circle impact. Theorycrafters greatly underrate how bad it is to be forced to remain inside Bennett's burst. Not everyone enjoys being forced to bring shielders who contribute to nothing but stagger resistance. But has strict cooldowns and downtimes. I absolutely hate having to use Zhongli as a shielder, because his tower has its own duration and cool down, and it takes forever to fully cast compared to just using the skill. Geo would've been in a way better place if shielder characters didn't exist, or if they were made to buff shields created by Geo instead of having their own and making an entire element irrelevant.

[@Biohacker777]

But 5* weapons impact prestige status highly, while signature weapon increase aesthetic stats by 50~100%, depending on what player investing for, their account might have higher value on the market also their social status improve accordingly with how much drip their characters have

[@BloodyVeel]

Yes but actually no . Old players can clear abyss faster because they have high cons on old characters like Xq Xling Fishel Bennet . For my example I had Yelan and Furina before Xq . I have Ayaka Misspliter Shenshe Kazuha Ganyu And my Xling is c3 . And i have C2 raiden and my fishel is c1 . I am not ftp but in one year they were never on those banners that i wished .