They Don't Talk Anymore?! | Hall & Oates - She's Gone | Vocal Coach Reacts & Analysis

[@BethRoars]

🎵 Book a Lesson with Beth email [e-mail] 📖 Get your signed copy of my album Fable here: www.bethroars.com/shop ☀ Find me on Spotify: open.spotify.com/artist/1W0He1MTuQoG0Yt2ccmhyL?si=b5qm82DmSRip8L4abe2-nw 🥁 Become a Patreon Supporter: www.patreon.com/bethroars

[@JoeCruz-hs2yt]

where did you get them funny looking head phones !

[@longhairscorpio3976]

got one for ya sweet thing by rufus and chaka kahn short but sweet!

[@lotusmanb3832]

Darryl Hall is criminally underrated as a vocalist, one of the greatest singers of the 20th century.

[@privateer0561]

No, he isn't. Not in the least. He is one half of the most successful musical duo ever! There's always somebody...

[@lotusmanb3832]

I agree.. there's always somebody who doesn't understand what vocalist means.

[@ScottBeamer]

@@privateer0561 and that somebody is you. What’s with the hate? Daryl Hall is a fantastic vocalist.

[@antoniocharo1724]

Sara's Smile is a MUST!!! 🤫😉👏🎸🎵😎

[@FionaEm]

John Oates wrote this song after he was stood up. Incredible harmonies. Never get sick of listening to them.

[@stevem-h3562]

See if you can find the New York Songwriters guild meeting where Jon plays this by himself with just an acoustic and the crowd join in. Its utterly gorgeous and dripping with feel.

[@MrCancer66]

@FionaEm I was an 80s high school baby and they were huge but that popularity in the 80s caused huge interest in their older stuff which was played on top radio stations because it renewed interest intheir talent.

[@smj7773]

they both wrote the song!

[@karenadams138]

I met Daryl around 1977, a few years after "Abandoned Luncheonette"was released...(the luncheonette was in my area too). ...My friend knew him very well so he came over to his home one day....There were 3 of us sitting around on the floor with Daryl just talking and having an everday conversation. He stayed and visited for a couple hours......He was so nice and I also remember how thin he was at that time too. Very nice time....He truly had a phenomenal voice!

[@岩﨑昭人-x9n]

Hello, Ms Roars. I'm Japanese. Thanks for your nice analysis of Hall & Oates' old good song. 1980s, they were very famous in Japan, especially young Japanese women liked them very much. My most favorite Hall & Oates' song is 'Wait for me'.

[@Grant_Ferstat]

Always been my favourite Hall & Oates song and proof of what great singers they both were and incredible writers.

[@JJ-db8jw]

Whenever I think "I need a drink", my mind always follows with "and a quick decision" because of this song.

[@StoneDigitalArtCanada]

Hall & Oates were possibly the most successful mainstream music duo of the late 70's/early 80's with dozens of hit songs to their name. You should definitely do a deep dive into their catalogue. You also owe it to yourself to go down the rabbit hole of "Live From Daryl's House" episodes where the who's who of artists visit Daryl Hall's Club in upstate NY and jam with his house band for a while...he's been doing that since 2007 and there are some amazing performances (check out Joe Walsh's visit in particular).

[@VoxTone2009]

Personally, I think Todd Rundgren and Daryl did the best session. At least singing wise. They challenged each other to take it up another notch.

[@TxVoodoo_]

I hope she gets LOTS of recs for Live from Daryl's House!

[@TxVoodoo_]

@@VoxTone2009 I still get chills watching that one.

[@edmason9359]

Live From Daryl's House * Tommy Shaw

[@shortaybrown]

“The duo reached the US Top 40 with 29 of their 33 singles charting on Billboard's Hot 100 between 1974 and 1991. PLUS 6 #1 Hits”

[@edilsonsouza1607]

I really liked this analysis, it's because it always brings us something different, I like it

[@quietwoodworking]

There are very good reasons why Hall and Oats are still the most successful duo of all time and this is my favorite of all their great songs.

[@sdzielinski]

A great song, a great band. It sounds as fresh today as it did nearly 50 years back!

[@raycewilliams3300]

I literally grew up listening to Hall & Oates. They are from the Philadelphia, Pa. area are were tabbed by DJs as "Blue Eyed Soul". They had hit after hit after hit. They later parted ways. Both are still in the music industry. Take care....

[@joer1678]

That was the Righteous Brothers

[@TxVoodoo_]

LOL, just saw this post, it's almost an echo of mine! I grew up in the Philly burbs as a teen in the 70s. SO good. I remember seeing them at the Tower Theater.

[@michaeloreilly2533]

@@TxVoodoo_no better venue than the Tower!

[@TxVoodoo_]

@@michaeloreilly2533 Ain't that the truth? Saw so many great acts there over the years. I moved away in the mid 90s, but I'm moving back soon!

[@raycewilliams3300]

@@joer1678 The Righteous Brothers were indeed the FIRST to be known as "Blue Eyed Soul" but the term is generic and was applied to many other white artists including Hall & Oates. Take care...

[@kroft6799]

Hard to believe that you weren't familiar with the most popular duo in popular music history.

[@Chr1sWaterous]

The BBC concentrates on playing UK artists, and a lot of folks across the pond have never heard many staples of American radio. I made friends with a middle-aged gal from Norwich and I was constantly shocked at what she hadn't heard.

[@aaronnichols8159]

Most popular? Not hardly

[@camannwordsmith]

It's not hard at all to believe someone hasn't heard of you've heard of. Also, while Hall & Oates were extremely successful here ("the most popular duo in music history" comes from the band's own website), they were far less successful in the UK. Still a massive hit over there, but far fewer singles and albums made the charts. I know it's hard to believe, but sometimes people have a different experience of the world than you do.

[@lawwdogg1digr]

@@aaronnichols8159 Milli Vanilli! Yes!

[@gordonschiff3621]

@@aaronnichols8159definitely top 10 though.

[@turnerdan53]

Try Live From Daryl's House where he does songs with different artists to show how quickly they do a song mix.

[@helgar791]

Depending on the day either "She's Gone" or "Sara Smile" is my favorite song by these guys. Today it's "She's Gone". Listen to the beautiful studio version of "Sara Smile".

[@tomkruze1304]

I Can't Go for That and Private Eyes are absolutely bangers, listen to those Hall & Oates songs

[@BryanAlaspa]

Man, several years ago Hall & Oates played a concert at a smallish nearby outdoor venue. It ended up being a perfect July night for my wife and I (she is the biggest Hall & Oates fan and got me to appreciate them). Nothing fancy, just amazingly great music and one of the best concerts I have ever seen. Sad to hear they have now had a serious falling out, but they are just two amazing musicians.

[@petestottsberry1133]

Love it!! I’m a bass player and you actually gave cred to the bassist…bravo!! 👏🏻👏🏻

[@r12e5p]

Daryl Hall’s mother was a vocal coach and taught him how to sing. His father had a choral background as well.

[@randomtruths3400]

Oates is rarely given his due, either as a singer or creative contributor... Always hoped to hear more songs with him singing lead.

[@Gurkmassa]

I totally agree! The song "Possession obsession" is my favorite Oates song. Have you heard it?

[@RabbiSteve]

Also agree. Deserves more attention. His rarer solo vocals with them are outstanding. And his solo work is also great.

[@lesliebeacom4567]

My favorite is “Had I known you better then” with John singing lead. A simple but sweet song ❤

[@michaeltlewis3481]

I love your thorough explanation of vocal techniques plus musical arrangement, too! It’s also fascinating to get your combination of ‘reaction’ and ‘analysis’ … just made sure to have my notifications set to ‘all’ because this was excellent, Beth! ❤

[@BethRoars]

Thank you Michael!

[@robert_bbiii]

Old Grey Whistle Test was a great live music show. Some great different takes on hit songs.

[@岩﨑昭人-x9n]

Yes, Old Grey Whistle Test was BBC's great music show. When I was a teenager, sometimes I liked to watch them on NHK's program in Japan. Of course, not live shows in Japan. My best favorite program was Blondie's live show. I was in love with young Debbie Hurry.

[@josiepkat]

Daryl Hall is just an insanely great singer. Look at some of his videos in the past 15 years from Live From Daryl’s House- here is a man who has never stoped playing and learning his entire life and you can see him getting even better when you thought I would be impossible for that to happen. They were the first concert I ever saw in 1982. I was so lucky to have them as the soundtrack of a good portion of my life.

[@Ocrilat]

It's adorable (and strangely satisfying) to see you enjoy this so much.

[@aekelly]

I love when a song delights Beth. She's so adorable to begin with, and her visual appreciation for songs that make you feel something is just charming. 💕

[@ronnykornfeld3941]

So great to see these guys properly appreciated. This was a live performance!! Nothing but hard work and huge talent. A golden musical era . Nothing like the easy road to autotune and backtracking hip hop fame. Daryl on tour now with Elvis Costello and John also in lower scale arenas with his own fine band. Daryl lost his high octave but still has the Philly soul going on. Hope they continue to inspire !!

[@richardmartin9565]

Always listen to Hall and Oates for the good memories.

[@DouglasFess]

Love your insight. I think the keyboard section was originally a sax solo which is even better. This song actually is typical of their catalo, not really a change. They are Philly Blues, the songs you cited of theirs are more ‘pop’ than most. Sara smile is a personal favorite and is why I named my girl that.

[@berniceanne4959]

Great reaction! These guys were 2 of my music heroes growing up and this song shows just why you can't improve on perfection ❤

[@MarkBtvd]

Thanks Beth! As always, pointing out details that I totally miss. My first time hearing this sung live, rather more intricate than what I remember the studio/radio-play version being. And always fun to watch musicians ply their craft.

[@catherinewelshons7537]

I saw them on their first tour in 1974. They were crazy talented.

[@batigo211]

This is by far one of the most sensual songs not only of this duo but of all the music that was made in the 80s, it is so exquisitely captivating that it makes you want to listen to it while you are making love. Hall & Oates certainly went far with this topic.

[@leeasbury7273]

I forgot this song existed til now. My mom or dad (divorced immediately) had this on vinyl. This and Linda Rondstadt....cant even...Linda is my favorite singer of all time.

[@AngelaLohmar]

Pure professionals as singers/songwriters and multi-instrustrumentalists! Saw them several times live in concert. I love your analysis of this Hall & Oates song! Thank you, Beth! And: Thank you for your reactions to other talented artists, such as Maneskin and Beth Hart! It is such a pleasure 😊 to see them performing live, too!

[@MeYou-nm5bd]

The keyboard solo is a replacement for a sax solo in the studio version.

[@saturnnet1627]

Studio version is best

[@JEmmertz]

I return to this song so often for oh so many reasons. On the face of it, it is simple, but there are layers to it and there is always something new to discover in it. Heard several different versions with Daryl duetting with Oates likes in this one, and other versions. They are all extremely satisfying. My ears approve!

[@seldomseensmith4684]

Without a doubt one of the best duo's ever and one of my favorite bands. Lyrics, harmonies, arraignments are always in the pocket. I love these guys!

[@BillWalker3rd]

Holy Smokes, BETH!!! Talk about taking these reaction vids to the next level!! Thanks for even getting into the technical terms and meanings, AND the instruments and their inner workings!! I love this performance and have seen it before. I usually would not “like” the interruptions, altho I totally get they are required to use the vids at all. BUT if ya gotta do interrupt, it’s so awesome you took the time to make it interesting and educational without becoming a lecture! Next Level for sure!! ❤❤❤

[@BethRoars]

Thanks Bill

[@douglasvega8738]

Great memories from the 80's when I was a young teenager living on my own in a new country and a new language. Thank you Beth!!!

[@TxVoodoo_]

Sound of my teens! I grew up in Philly in the 70s. Pure blue-eyed soul, influenced by the Philadelphia soul groups of the 60s and 70s. From my hometown! Please look at some of their other songs from this era, like Sara Smile. Also, the studio version of She's Gone has a very different, but wonderful vibe. Also, check out "Live From Daryl's House", which is on youtube. Many, many famous folk do a jam session with Daryl Hall, and there are some spine tingling moments in there! Like Todd Rundgren, among others.

[@waynedavenport6053]

The Bass player was definately the 'Unsung Hero' of this rendition!

[@spazzyklutz75]

The keyboard in question is a Minimoog synthesizer.

[@RhettAnderson]

Yeah you cn tell that it's a monosynth.

[@nigelsilverthorn9188]

Old Grey Whistle Test, sadly missed and the greatest launch pad in the UK for great artists (and I mean A-Z) as well as the greatest into to music lovers...all pre-internet of course and mostly truly live. Fantastic!

[@rediscoveringhistoryinc2020]

LOVE your facial reaction as it hit....one of THE best duos ever and their music is timeless!!

[@bbowjazz]

Daryl Hall was playing the basic accompaniment part on a Wurlitzer electric piano Beth. The solo was played on a Mini Moog synthesizer.

[@twofarg0ne763]

One of my favorite groups in the 70's.

[@ThePierce5144]

I love your music reactions and analysis! I love your ginger hair almost as much!

[@1Yh8HH]

One of the incredible music group of the incredible 80s

[@surfboarding5058]

Incredible 70s

[@1Yh8HH]

@@surfboarding5058 70s and 80s

[@bruceroberts2407]

Blue-eyed soul at its best!

[@kylev7128]

It’s been a while since I saw one of your videos. I really like that you’re adding informative tidbits to supplement it, great idea.

[@stephenreiner1523]

I met Darryl Hall in upstate NY where I grew up. That's was back in the 70's. I liked this song and so did a lot of other people.

[@alanjhargreaves]

When Hall & Oates came to Newcastle (Australia) in the early 80's, I had arguably one of the best seats in the Civic Theatre. 20-30 feet above the stage, sat in a chair that was gaffe taped to the flys with a purple follow spot that I had to keep trained on Jon Oates (have you any idea how hard it is to see a purple follow spot?). I was one up on my younger brother in that while we were both up there with follow spots, at least my chair had a seat belt.

[@barbarino2000]

Early Hall & Oates (pre-MTV) put out some awesome music.

[@icdogg2361]

Keyboard solo was on a Minimoog

[@BigTroyT]

Yes! Much as I love ya Beth, that's definitely no Whirley - it's a MiniMoog synthesizer that's playing the "sax solo" from the studio record.

[@carlwilson1772]

I enjoyed your analysis of this wonderful song. It has a particular resonance for me, which I shall relate shortly. I have to say that your appraisal has increased my enjoyment of this timeless classic many fold. Your description of how a Wurlitzer or a Fender Rhodes electric piano works is spot in. However, the instrument being played in that section of the piece is a Mini Moog analogue synthesiser. Why does this song resonate so strongly for me? In 2013 my wife gave birth to our beautiful baby girl Lily. She was born with a rare genetic defect and only lived for 2 months. With great support from the NHS we took her home and took care of her around the clock. My wife and I were determined to give her as much of a life as we could. Through the long dark watches of the night I read poetry to her, sections of novels - and played her music. Every track I would have wanted her to know and appreciate if she could have grown to be a woman. This was one of the prominent tracks. After Lily died, the lyrics became incredibly important and for me were no longer about a romantic break up. They were about the loss of my daughter. "She's gone, She's gone, Oh I, I've got to learn how to face it, Shes gone, Shes gone, Oh I, I'd pay the devil to replace her...

[@SK-lk3iu]

Glad you felt that a lot of this was improvised, you are correct! Some melody changes and riffing here. This was a great Live performance, but you might want to listen to the studio version as well, which is perfection. This is my favorite song by them!

[@alewis5081]

You go gurl, excellent analysis, and thanks for the Wurlitzer info!

[@matthewgoodA1206]

I was seemingly a fan of Hall & Oates as a kid; my mother’s said I knew some of their song titles. Quite a few years before I truly grasped music. And funny enough, but I never heard this tune until I was an adult. Now it’s my favorite track by them.

[@ianmason3040]

I love watching and listening to your reaction, when you hear songs for the first time - that I regrettably grew up with 😊

[@Tessiefaye]

Thank you so much for all your insights and explanations.

[@TheDivayenta]

Beth- Daryl Hall had a TV show from his home studio called Live From Daryl’s House about ten years ago. Old Daryl still has it!!! A different guest artist every week jamming with Daryl and his band. It’s phenomenal live music television. It’s an incredible rabbit hole. I recommend the episode with guest CEELO Green. It deserved a Grammy. “ I Can’t Go for That” and “ F*** You”.

[@petestottsberry1133]

You nailed it the end. It sounds improvised, but I can assure you, it was many hours of polishing, grinding work. Repetition and hard work pays off.

[@justitia257]

Beautiful song, gorgeous Beth

[@johnnydev9318]

This episode of TOGWT aired in '76 - the song released in '73 Classic H&O

[@carolmartin4413]

Great song and so glad John Oates' singing was highlighted...he really does have a great voice. Unfortunately their relationship is kaput now....but Live at Daryl's House is great on its own. Hopefully it will come back with new episodes. 🖐 Wisconsin...beer and summerfest coming soon!

[@roberthughes5880]

Just a side note Darryl is from Philly and John is from Montgomery County (Lansdale..just outside Philly) & my buddy Jim was a wrestler and told me his high-school still has a trophy that Oates got.

[@KennethSavage-nn2vv]

Blue eyed soul at its best. Great reaction and review. 👊🏻

[@paulransdell]

Hall and Oates is a huge, huge deep dive. So, so many good songs.

[@thorsden5562]

As a teen growing up in the 70's, I loved the music of Hall & Oates. The local radio station in Tarboro, NC played many of their tunes that were popular back then. Such a great musical duo with terrific voices.

[@artromano2419]

Fantastic reaction and I learned A LOT from it! Thank you Beth!!

[@DavidOmaha1]

Im so glad you found this song! One of my favorites by this duo. Darryl Hall is right up there with George Michael and others as a GREAT male singer of the 20th century.

[@oscararzate7956]

Exelente cantante es un placer escucharlo tanto como tu reacción exelente las dos partes bien Beth 👏👏🍀🍀 mí H Prrj 💙💜

[@rhwinner]

Many people knew them as successful songwriters and performers. Which they were. But they were also talented singers, multi instrumentalists and producers. ✅

[@RabbiSteve]

Excellent, educational and entertaining reaction to a stone-cold classic. Looking forward to future reactions to H&O.

[@bobbelleci9995]

I can see why u like them. Big fan too 😁😎 BTW, speaking of fans, segue, how can you possibly hear them with all that GORGEOUS red hair in your way? No, seriously, i love your descriptions and you've added some nice graphics to your vid. Nice! 😎👍❤️

[@zlionsfan]

It isn't like this here, but in the '80s - as many folks did - Daryl Hall had epic hair! I remember wishing that I could get my hair to look like that ... I definitely had no idea how much time it probably took to get his hair to look that way, or I wouldn't have wished for it 😄 It's also interesting to see how this version differs from what I bet was the second release, the one I'm more accustomed to. Normally we get your reaction to a newer version of a song!

[@t0dd000]

Man. I forgot about this song. Classic.

[@planktonrecords]

Someone often grouped with Daryl vocal wise is Todd Rundgren. I really wish you would react to his song Hawking recorded live in Japan. Rundgren and a number of backing vocalists laying it down

[@timmiszkowski9222]

Their best work

[@alexharbison4411]

NIce reaction. Abandoned luncheonette is the album you want to do. Everything on side 1 is amazing. love the electric Oboe.

[@andrewkubat1506]

Hall & Oates live cover of "Me and Mrs Jones" us incredible.

[@RadioFreeAnarchy]

The beginning of this song reminds me of 10CCs I’m Not in Love

[@Gonegonegone977]

The entire album is great!

[@rickthreebears184]

For a personal treat, check out some of the guest artists on "Live at Daryl's Place". The guests are awesome and the atmosphere (they're playing in a small wooden house) is wonderful. I have way too many favorites to list, but a big fav is Grace Potter - "Things I never needed" PS I have a huge crush on her!

[@thespacealienssmogandgrog4283]

Awesome! H&O's best song, imo. Deep 70s.

[@herb601]

Interesting, I grew up about 35-40 miles from Daryl Hall and more interesting is that we share the same birthdate and same year. I have loved them both from the beginning. Nice review, Beth.

[@musashimiyamoto586]

You should listen to "Sara Smile" from a German show called Musikladen probably from the 70s. Hall's voice will knock you out cold.

[@brucecronin6396]

Love it, love you !!

[@oldprankster7606]

Just finished listening to Rick Beato's take on the top ten songs currently on Spotify (Two are by Taylor Swift). This song crushes all of them.

[@ManuelGuajardo-zd7hx]

Great reaction Beth from your new subscriber wintersun Alex USA. ❄️❄️❤️😆

[@BobandSharonClark]

Beth, I would love to hear your reaction to the Seekers, especially your thoughts on Judith Durham and her voice in the 1960's (The Carnival is Over, etc) and then in the 2013ish tours (any of their songs, but maybe "I am Australian"

[@timothyjohnart]

love your reactions

[@paulmorris8762]

the version of I Can't Go For That from Live From Daryl's House with CeLo Green is a must watch/listen

[@waynefinnicumbb7218]

Grew up listening to them. One of my favorites. Its a shame theyre havibg such a harsh break uo. First time I heard this arrangement of this song. Its an excellent take on one of tgeir classics.

[@kb62147]

Awesome analysis!

[@TracyLML1]

Different than the recording I am familiar with. Thanks for the interesting analysis!

[@summerof67]

One little difference between the live version and the studio version is that they don't finish the line "I better learn how to face it" because the word "it" overlaps with the next line "she's gone". In the studio version, they can overdub it.

[@x-rockfm92hd81]

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤💯FROM PHILADELPHIA BLUE EYED SOUL

[@ThePersistentRumor]

You're finally getting around to covering overlooked and obscure bands like Hall & Oates. Never mind that they were the most successful band of the 1980s. :-D

[@Nightrelic]

Overlooked and obscure? Hope you were kidding.

[@ThePersistentRumor]

@@Nightrelic Did you stop reading there? :-D

[@tonyhomant244]

Definitely one of their best imo.