This Bonney Theory Makes Too Much Sense

This Bonney Theory Makes Too Much Sense
This week's chapter of One Piece brings us some crazy revelations! Bonney has just managed to transform into Gear 5th / Sun God Nika Mode!! Does this mean that she will join the Straw Hats / Strawhats as the final nakama? Will Luffy extend the invitation?!
#Syv #Somnus #OnePiece
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
💀 Patreon | / syvnful
💀 Twitch | / syvduck
💀 Twitter | / syvnful
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
💀 Anime Discussions | / @syv
💀 Anime Theories | / @syvretcon
💀 Anime Spoilers | / @syvspoilers
💀 Gaming | / @syvduck
💀 Anime Reacts | / @somnusreacts
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
💀 Timestamps
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
💀 Sponsorship Inquiries | [e-mail]

[@Kalaki9996]

No ship in the world has enough storage space to store food for both Luffy and Bonney.

[@trafulgar]

If only caribou stuck around…

[@Emilstekcor]

Sanji can 1 vs 2 joyboy confirmed...

[@davontjones5705]

​@@trafulgar100%😂😂😂😂

[@Lonelupin]

It does if Karibou is around 🤣🤣

[@MrRourk]

This how Sanji dies. They overwork the poor dude.

[@VaultUnd3rground]

Nikas in Egghead -Jay D Legend

[@lando8849]

Hardest Quote by far

[@keeplearningwithGoodguy]

💥

[@PluuuumE]

"Why do yo- Why do you think the arc was called Nikas in egghead? Because Nikas was in Egghead!"

[@GOLDDRIVER-xq6el]

Lmaooo

[@Kadeem.C.]

What up my Nikas

[@XanderKaine]

She has the most important requirement to be a crew member a dream. And that dream is to see the world free

[@derrickmiles5240]

My take is that she's a kid, so she has time to find her real dream. The point of her character and devil fruit is to emphasize the limitless potential of youth. She can have any dream she wants at this point in her life. And the Straw Hats are the perfect crew to enable the most dreams possible. She could be a shipwright, a sniper, a navigator, an archeologist. Truly, all doors are open to her on the Straw Hat crew.

[@heaven_lydemon7571]

If she does join the crew, it would make Kuma protecting the Sunny for 2 years that much sweeter. 2 years protecting the ship his daughter would eventually be sailing. I could already cry.

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Yah that’s never going to happen….

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

I’m not coping if it’s not happening… 🤦‍♂️

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

I’m not coping if it’s not happening… 🤦‍♂️

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

I’m not coping if it’s not happening… 🤦‍♂️

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

I’m not coping if it’s not going to happen… 😕

[@xbeliefs4242]

Saturn when he sees Bonney in nika form: "I have made a grave mistake"

[@Dipto380]

Bonney is most probably Saturn's child Saturn did say wife number something (I really don't remember) referring to Ginny

[@theamirrexie2380]

Not bonney offscreening two vice admirals 😂😂

[@kerresft8745]

honestly, vice admirals are a joke

[@davontjones5705]

​@@kerresft8745She barely even uses any types of haki n still boding

[@almy-qy1lf]

Just a reminder that haki doesn't make ppl immune to annoying DF abilities.

[@yazid6024]

​@@almy-qy1lf you wrong only the good one with haki can like kaido n bigmom nullified law abilities

[@almy-qy1lf]

@@yazid6024 I'm not wrong at all, you're arguing out of exceptional cases. There's far more examples of DF working on haki users. Kaido and Big Mom were exceptions to the rule, and it was only due to the VAST gap in haki they had with Law. Even then, as soon as the DF users awakened their powers, Kidd was able to make BM magnetic with Assign, Law could cut through Big Mom with K-Room and Silenced her, and Luffy was able to make Kaido's body rubbery. So I repeat: haki doesn't make people immune to annoying DF abilities. It was a haki GAP that made that. Give Law the same haki strength as Kaido, and he'd be able to Shamble him around.

[@NotTheWEJ]

Did you Suuuuuper forget Franky had a crew too? 😭

[@denzel8827]

he literally said that in the video

[@rakhatthenut3815]

​@@denzel8827he said about jinbe and usopp only, or maybe I'm deaf

[@aruto3680]

bonney turning usopp into a giant would be sick

[@aleccampbell7707]

a GIANT coward - he already is

[@evilovesperry]

​@@aleccampbell7707no he's not. He's hands down the bravest member of the crew. You wouldn't have the moxi to stand up or even physically look at the things he's been through... or did you forget he's just a normal human with extreme anxiety...

[@heylookitsdavid]

Bonnie’s bounty is about to skyrocket, she can control all the pacifista over the marines, after they got rid of the 7 warlords system

[@di8085]

and imagine Blackbeard is gonna aiming Bonney now because her devil fruit is broken

[@sage5830]

Sanji and Zoro going back to hunting

[@aleccampbell7707]

@@di8085 Blackbeard doesn't sleep or dream

[@evilovesperry]

​@@di8085how.

[@Kaysap]

@@di8085she doesn’t have a devil fruit

[@rj-nq4rp]

2 Nikas on Juneteenth was a crazy reveal

[@KirbyP_]

Nahh 💀

[@Rootz2000]

Ayoo

[@metalme2306]

That was garbage

[@camronk1356]

Yo that's wild af!!!! We love to see it. Give us all the nikas

[@BlessGodBro]

Cheek mills

[@cr21tor]

"AT LEAST" 10, BUT HE WILL HAVE 12 DISCIPLES

[@DonMhata]

since Oda played soccer in school i'd say 11

[@alia.m6404]

@@evilmonkey9196 watch it be the craziest foreshadowing

[@derrickmiles5240]

There are 3 strong pieces of supporting evidence for this that Oda hid in plain sight. 1.) Bonney would be the 11th straw hat and Oda drew her setting out on her journey eleven hundred chaptrers after Luffy. 2.) The final panel of the chapter "Luffy's Dream" is Bonney popping out of the warm water eddy. 3.) When Bonney, Luffy, Jinbe, and Chopper arrive on Egghead it's an overt reference to Star Wars. Chopper is Chewbacca, Jinbe is han, the pilot, and Luffy who was made into an old man, who then lectures Bonney as she uses the lightsaber, is Obi Wan. This makes Bonney, Luke. Edit: thanks @glarcier4398 for the correction

[@derrickmiles5240]

I'll add one more that I'm not as confident in, but still draws my attention. After Bonney uses the lightsaber, she uses 3 more weapons on Egghead. The first weapon is a pipe identical to Sabo's, against Vegapunk, as an act of revolution towards an adult authority figure who had wronged her, harkening back to the scenario at Sabo's home town, where the adults were rotten and Sabo revolted against them. The second weapon is a loose piece of cable she swung at Kizaru in defense of Vegapunk, after learning the truth, and realizing she had to hold on to what she has left. This is reminiscent of Luffy's revelation after losing Ace. After Bonney realized that her father was dead she began defending what she had left. The wobbly cable representing Luffy's arms IMO. The third weapon is a sword that she stabbed Saturn with, as she was filled with fiery vengance. She gave into her rage just as Ace did when he confronted Akainu. And of course, Ace was named after a sword. It's interesting that the weapon she is using all of a sudden, now that we are off the island, is a pistol. A reference to Luffy's first named attack possibly. Showing where her allegiance lies now that we're departing Egghead.

[@luqi5]

what do you mean by oda drew her setting out on her journey 1100 chapters after luffy ??

[@derrickmiles5240]

@@luqi5 In chapter 1 Luffy sets out on his journey. In chapter 1101 Bonney sets out on hers. There's an 1100 chapter difference.

[@glarcier4398]

uncle owen and aunt beru were killed when luke was 17 tho, no?

[@derrickmiles5240]

@@glarcier4398 it was 13 to my recollecting

[@ifantsaurells3014]

Its All Saint Jay D Fault Now There,s Two Nikas....

[@tayrock-ho3lq]

One piece meets 2 nikkas 😂😂

[@ShanksFreecss]

The stocks for bonney becoming a strawhat have gone up and I'm here for it Bonney for nakama

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Those stocks are a false trap and purely for show/hype…. And the minute this arc is over reality is coming crashing back down… Bonney is never going to be nakama that notion is pure delusion… She doesn’t even have a dream more less a feasible position to fill…more less has any real combat abilities for this late into the story… She wasn’t the main focus of the flashback that was kumas flash back and even at that it isn’t a proper straw hat like tragic backstory… And let’s not forget in the color spread of chapter 1103 it was YAMATO who was drawn with all the straw hats and not Bonney… And she knows luffys true dream through ace as well unlike Bonney… this is a jinbei 2.0 situation… The Bonney for nakama train is gonna come crashing down hard really fast….😕

[@shadowism1]

@@CrimsonKaiserx8I agree, she’s gonna die, not enough room for 2 nikas we’re overdue for an emotional death anyways

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Couldn’t agree more mate we really don’t need oda doing a lazy copy paste of something this late into the story that’s just bad writing…🫡

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

The fact that there is any Bonney for straw hat movement is utterly ridiculous…. You make it seem like it’s a given when it’s not even remotely close to a thing… Oda clearly has his mind set on other things or did we forget what happened back in wano… I’ll be sure to comment back here when Bonney joins the revs and or leaves next arc 😕

[@shadowism1]

@@evilmonkey9196 I said this somewhere else, what if Bonney’s fruit gets stolen by Blackbeard maybe this how he manifests this 3rd devil fruit zoan shit everyone’s been talking about

[@user-rk1xn9ei2v]

Once bonney asked kuma if nika would also make her free and right now because of luffy/nika she is able to use a distorted future where she is the most free.

[@arthurfleck4320]

Momo: a 28-year old that we thought was 8 Bonney: a 12-yeat old that we thought was 24

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Yeah that’s not weird at all after she was shown all sexualized the way she was…

[@IsmailKasapovic-lj5dj]

Wait bonney si 12?

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Yes her canonical she is 12

[@victorespisoler9117]

Momo was turned in one adult by a DF power.. For this mentally he is still a kid.

[@kualarompin589]

Zehahahaha, the fact that Blackbeard tried to make her his girlfriend after escaping Marinefold, I just can't. That a Tinder nightmare.

[@ulandaychristopher2644]

bonney doesnt ask luffy to recruit her but possibly luffy will recruit her because luffy see her as nakama

[@isiahgayle7359]

Also, Roger’s whitebeard’s and Shanks’ crew had a kid at one point on it

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Kids at this point are a pure liability and a stupid idea… this isn’t rogers crew we’re in the endgame of one piece we have no place for kids of all things…. 😕

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Again she’s a kid… she doesn’t have the insane abilities or special traits like big mom or oden… Her abilities are biologically engineered and that’s kinda sad… it’s not natural or even remotely worked towards just handed to her.. Calling her top 3 kids in the verse compared to those who came before and current is literally headcanon when she hasn’t shown that…😕

[@thedude-nf1uf]

You cooking with this theory. Imagine a chapter 1000 2.0 but theyre all in their 'prime' with a new design

[@WindLogia]

She also saved Zoro from the celestial dragon in Sabaody which with all of this new info is CRAZY

[@almy-qy1lf]

I can't wait for Bonney to turn Garp, Sengoku, and Rayleigh back to their prime in the last war.

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

That’s utterly ridiculous and completely defeats the point of having them out of their primes…

[@C_fx]

At this point luffy is a side character..

[@almy-qy1lf]

@@CrimsonKaiserx8 not at all. Bonney's been changing people's age the whole manga, and affecting people's dangerousness like that. There's no reason why she shouldn't use it to the heroes' advantage, in one particular instance. Especially against such odds as they might face in an eventual final war. If they have these legends among them, it would actually be a terrible waste not to boost them temporarily with the benefits of young age.

[@almy-qy1lf]

@@C_fx the story is about finding the One Piece. I don't recall that Bonney wants to do that.

[@C_fx]

@@almy-qy1lf if a side character is stronger than the mc.. what value does that mc has?

[@mrbubbles6468]

All the SH and Allies transform into Nikka Imu: After 900 years, finally, a fun fight

[@Rorshach47]

Okay I’m sold on this theory as soon as u mentioned her aging the strawhats, I now need to see that along with them utilizing luffy awakening and bouncing around during fights! Im not making it sound as good as my brain is making it look 😂

[@CharTurner6928]

Syv, All great points for Bonney to join the Straw Hats!...and Nami can get her "Mom" on.

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

She’s a kid and nami isn’t a mother to her in the slightest… she’s not even remotely close to joining based off of any thing said… Nothing said makes sense or is sound logically even for a manga based on what is canon….😕

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Copy paste comment at the end is rather telling at this rate… Also how does that color spread have anything to do with this I fail to see the connection… that’s not even been hinted at in the canon…

[@justinwho2542]

There’s no way Oda would water down Nika form by allowing her to grant that to everyone. I like the idea of her being a support and see the more likely application would be doing things like “Usopp, distorted future Brave warrior of the sea,” and Usopp becomes his bravest self. She would also do other feats like this, the problem is she could never do it to Zoro or Luffy…they need to overcome and become their dream, they would never let her fast forward them so she would only be useful to the bottom tier of the crew.

[@trendyprimawijaya314]

Luffy's SPACE manipulation + Bonney's TIME manipulation = General relativity theory manipulation to fight against Blackbeard's GRAVITY power

[@TerranceForde]

Also he would have 2 supernovas on his crew like kaido as well as tie in almost every supernova in the new world except urouge.

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Two supernovas are already on the crew with luffy and zoro we don’t need anymore that’s redundanct… We already know Yamato is coming back after she’s don’t touring wano sense 1103 color spread basically spoiled it… 😕

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

That line at the end again bloody hell you really have it out for anything I say… Also you literally copy pasted what I said without changing the context for a quick snap back clap back attempt that doesn’t prove ignorant more less anything…😕

[@thevladoking7712]

YOU DID IT AGAIN SYV THESE ARE THE VIDS WE WANT!

[@bp4_archive]

The only role left, is Bonney. She is the Shanks to Luffy's Roger.

[@bobmarley7621]

Jesus brother 4 vids in one day you are excited about this, i mean, i will continue to watch them all and I am happy about it

[@altruist9727]

Bonney has skills.. if you can remember. Ginny was an expert thief and wiretapper. I think bonney inherits her mother's skills as an expert thief and wiretapper, and bonney has skills in using weapons. And she was expert spy and covert ops. Like other female strawhats. Nami as a thief and Robin as an assassin, they are more focused on gathering info and covert ops.

[@Gehinomlezvuvim]

Even without a role,she s definitely upgrading the crew

[@courage1363]

@@Gehinomlezvuvim She is more fitting as a apprentice. Since thats role of a pirate crew.

[@brandonjohnson1983]

Yo Syv, why you making me choose between the chapter discussion & a Bonney theory on my way home from work, brother?

[@sisilotau2185]

Maybe what Saturn did regarding her fruit was make it so it came pre awakened so distorted future is her fruits awakened power and unlike others who had to grow with their fruit to awaken it, Bonney has been able to use the awakened ability right off the bat thanks to what Saturn did

[@marquishazelwood288]

Sye: This is the first cabin boy of the Straw Hats!!! Momo: “am I nothing to you…..”

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Momo has the body of a 28 year old adult now… and he’s shogun of wano what’s this cabin boy statement mean?!

[@evilovesperry]

​@@CrimsonKaiserx8the crew splits from time to time. But nobody is mopping that deck. They go to want with their dirty ships

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

…. That doesn’t make any sense…

[@ajingtherandomguy787]

Momo is now a Shogun, a Shogun cannot be a cabin boy...

[@evilovesperry]

@@ajingtherandomguy787 says who

[@Getbacktoworknika]

damn very good theory nice video hope she joins

[@user-em1xp5jb8w]

Shank's pijama has son and moon symbols, interesting...

[@mikev4154]

2 Syv videos today to bless my soul

[@Mugiwara555]

Lmao R.I.P strawhats fridge. 😂 I mean, I think all the strawhats would agree to take bonnie since they owe kuma. But I still want yamato to join later on

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Yamato is still joining this isn’t a debate. She was drawn with all the straw hats in 1103 color spread it’s basically spoiled….😕

[@Mugiwara555]

@CrimsonKaiserx8 yeah and some people even tattooed her on their body with the rest of the strawhats 🤣

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

I have the big photo of a girl from the subreddit who did that… Thankfully that is still coming true soon with her cover story and all the setup we got so it’s not all worthless in the end 🫡

[@migueldELLO]

I don't really see Yamato joining. Not unless she becomes a focal point in the story soon. She really didn't have a proper arc dedicated to her, so her joining would be out of place. She seems more likely to be a strong ally.

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Mate she’s literally setup to join just like jinbei did and all of that was already done in wano… She got more then enough setup she doesn’t need an entire arc dedicated to what’s already been done… She’s literally the focus of the cover story rn like what are we even talking about… it’s perfectly setup with everything we were told and all the blatant hints… She not an ally when she literally said in 1059 she still wants to join and sail with them, gets an open invitation, and literally gets drawn with all the straw hats in the cover of chapter 1103… What about ANY of that says strong ally when she literally said countless times she wants to join and knowns luffys true dream on top of that like please pay attention….😕

[@ynwa3573]

I love your background music!! The original Charlie

[@martinshelton9533]

Brook was captain after Yorky got ill!

[@alvdansen7172]

Nami already fill the role of writing a ships journal, it's confirmed that she have written a journal along her navigation and mapping since she joined the crew. That is how the WHOLE journey is written down and can be read. Yamato have no role other than strengh to add to the crew.

[@aleccampbell7707]

Nami's new goal drawing the map when the sea was 201M lower then it is currently

[@gaoaibai6243]

Yamato's role would be chronicler, not bookeeper. She would be more like a bard not a librarian so no, the role isn't taken just yet

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

THANK YOU SOMEONE WHO GETS IT! She was basically mean to be the logkeeper and or chronicler due to odens journal foreshadowing. It’s not irrational not say she’ll do like he did and keep a journal of the current history more less fill in the missing pages/information oden tore out. It’s literally all right there in her setup from wano!

[@JD_BigBLANKETS]

Damnit… no I want Bonney as a Strawhat more than Yamato 😢🎻

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Yamato is the only crew member joining… she’s basically setup to be just like jinbei like bruh….

[@irvinsanchez3405]

​@@CrimsonKaiserx8Yamato don't have a role in the Crew and she stayed in Wano to protect that country (she can't protect the country if she Joins the strawhats).

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

She’s basically been setup to be a hostorian/logkeeper/chronicler due to odens journal that’s not hard to see… Writing the history of the world on her own journal as a mirror of oden plus the last few pages were torn out so more reason for her to finish what oden left open… She only stayed in wano temporarily to protect them and or take her tour it’s basically a what happened with jinbei as it’s a delayed joining process… All the times she said she was going to leave and in 1059 she even said she still wanted to leave and sail with the straw hats… She got an open invite, knows luffys true dream and was drawn with all the straw hats in 1103 color spread… She has more reason and setup then any other character to join… she does owe wano or it’s people anything she’s sacrificing her dream and freedom rn tell she realizes her mistake and finally leaves… 😕

[@Dankargonaut]

I never thought of chopper as the “kid” of the crew even though he basically is but she’s perfect to be that role like shanks on Roger’s ship which I think was just cabin boy. Someone mentioned this as soon as we saw Bonnie was actually a kid and I totally agree.

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Cabin boy/ apprentice role has to be the stupidest idea for a role this late into the endgame of one piece… Wouldn’t rather bring a “kid” along instead of someone who’s more prepared for endgame fights and difficult struggles/ situations over a literal 12 year old liability… That makes no sense what so ever….😕

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Having a kid who has little to no value or experience for the sake of keeping with tradition for the endgame is utterly nonsensical…

[@Bocchi_the_Kok]

If bonnie joins then sanji is eventually going to end up in prison

[@CanaimaAtherton-nj7in]

Imagine all the cute mothering moments between Nami and Bonney, after seeing how she treats children, I imagine she’ll be very protective and also mothering towards her if she joins.

[@GourSmith]

This better be good, Syv.

[@GourSmith]

It was good.

[@christianbenavente6202]

I have a severe problem with the point made at 8:20. Im a huge advocate of bonnie joining the crew, tbh ill be dissatisfied if she doesnt. But her being able to immediately give the strawhats their best possible outcomes is a no for me. For one it completely and absolutely undermines their growth throughout the entire story. We know zoros and sanjis back stories and for that to immediately be washed away by the power of bonnie and not their own efforts would destroy the story. I think bonnie could provide a supplementary role to the crew but her main point should be for her to have a moment with the rest of the crew telling her its ok for her to be a child just as many of them had not been able too and for her to remain in her 12 yr old state and enjoy the high jinz with chopper Usopp and luffy. while being relieved of the burden of so much as a child just as ussopp, nami, franky, robin, sanji, and zoro had experienced. Let them be a child through bonnie.

[@MrMulatto76]

ahem....Usopp, Jinbei and Brook

[@kbdc]

watch the video before you comment 💀

[@MrMulatto76]

@@kbdc i did you see, brook is a former captain on luffys crew. He wasnt mentioned along with Usopp and jinbei. Perhaps you should watch it again 💀

[@kbdc]

@@MrMulatto76 yeah go watch it again LMAOO 💀

[@Emiliodelgado25]

you know interesting that you also said Rebecca because I was almost thinking that too but yeah, that wasn’t actually going to work out

[@hteekay]

Nah, Bonney's bounty gonna skyrocket since she can use Gear 5, there's no way those old bones in Marine would overlook her threat to them

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Fluky offscreen gags don’t equate to her being propped up as a threat… and even then she’s a cheap copy cat mimicking a better character and power… 😕

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Bonney being a literall rip off of a better character and ability is literally copy paste boredom in its purest form… You lose all sense of idenity and unique traits that made gear 5ths special… we don’t Eve. Know if she can do all those things… Pacifista are all either destroyed or offline rn… Threat or not she’s still a kid who’s only purpose at this point in the arc is to be a Nika cheerleader… I fail to see how that’s a credible threat Bais again has nothing to do with this if in the end non of this is going to lead anywhere and is just in the moment hype only to die off in a few weeks…😕

[@Fx_Qz]

9:57 if this really happens it will start a war 😂

[@MomoDuality]

paulie and brownbeard are wild stretches @00:14

[@ginnungagapabyss5639]

A lot of future what-ifs involving that fruit.

[@jalengibbs5403]

Bonny joining giving luffy pasi army would be insane

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

The fact vegapunk left all the pacifista in Bonneys control shows how stupid he really was… The fact a kid controls them is utterly ridiculous more less most of them are destroyed…and how should they reasonably travel around with them… That’s a massive inconvenience and a big attention grabbing problem…😕

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

What… Secondly you keep using those words bais and remove it’s rather becoming of this…😕

[@camronk1356]

This video is fucking awesome. I've always loved bonney. Her stocks go up every time she is in a chapter

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Bonney stocks are literal hype and pure headcanon. She’s a bratty and whiny character and Everytime she’s on screen it’s pure cringe… The sooner she’s gone out of this arc the better she’s an utter waste of important paneling space….😕

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

You keep coming back with this notion and assumption I’m mad and or bais when it’s never been the case… Bonney stocks are based on in the moment hype and fan base headcanon there is nothing in the arc that supports this for the depth and complexity needed for her to be a main character… You can believe all you want she will join but given in a few chapter when she’s either with the revs or on her way all of this will be folly on the end… I can give you about 45 reasons to be excited for Yamato to comeback and her to join if you want to listen sometime🫡

[@lindsrins]

Brook was also a former captain

[@peter-josephlamusitele6296]

True

[@BlitzedKip420]

Nice theory and all except it makes more sense for her to join the revs (like her parents) and since Luffy is only 1 more crew member down from his stated goal , where would Vivi go? She even more wanted than Bonney atm and doesn't have any other real options that make sense. There's tons of tiny litttle details that seem to certain outcomes, that have spawned innumerable theories that didn't come true - but narratively her joining revs and Vivi joing the SH makes way more sense. The vid was etertaining nonetheless, so good job on that :P

[@joshcusack422]

Makes sense. Luffy needs to pass the hat down to someone.

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

It’s makes no sense for luffy to pass down his hat… Once the series is over there will be nothing left to do or anyone to carry the will of Roger if the world is at peace…🤦‍♂️

[@sfxdlwsrs]

14:43 man I'm watching too many Parvision's videos. I'd thought you'd say "Italy", because of you know, pizza... and Mihawk's and Cavendish's and Vista's roman influence... 😅

[@kamikaze.33]

Hell yeah!!! I've been saying Bonney for Strawhat ever since the very beginning when we started her and Kuma's backstory! Don't get me wrong, I love Yamato, but I was always kind of against the idea of her joining the crew for various reasons. Not that I would've hated it if she did, but it didn't sit completely right with me... that said, it wouldn't sit right with me either if Bonney DID NOT join the crew either! I feel like we have a moral obligation to bring her aboard at this point lol

[@AlphaTech-at1219]

I think yes she can make the whole crew into sun god, Also in Other theory, the giant robot became more powerful when nika is around, Robot became much powerful when bonney became sun god

[@AceSolomon94]

Wow, the next Shanks... Neva thought of that.

[@Faust-Hell]

👀...Ppl who have a problem with Bonnie copying Luffy Gears transformations & others using her Devil Fruit... Catarina Devon: Hold my Wine sweetheart 💋 ❤

[@Shanked-em]

Yo guys it kinda makes sense, I always hated the whole Joyboy and Luffy being like some sort of destiny person, it always felt like it was kinda pushing away the main goal and plot of the story, it kinda felt like Luffy wanting to find the OP was being a bit side lined with Imu and the Gorosei stuff, to me luffy shouldn't be the one who liberates the world, his just a simple guy with a simple dream, to me he is not a hero, but someone who has a child like simple mind, and has his own sense of justice and morality that he fallows Bonney basically being Joygirl now is Big, think about it this could mean that Luffy is kinda like a Shanks to Bonney Plus this means that Luffy being Nika could not be what we think it means, meaning that Luffy is but also not the one who *(directly)* liberates the world but bonney is, and I know that yall are gonna say, Luffy is the Mc he has to be the one to do it, *NOPE* not necessarily, Law wants to find out the True meaning of D, which is a big dream for a side character to have, plus Luffy wants to be the king of the Pirate's, not save the world and be some kind of legendary hero, he doesn't even know who Nika is, on the other hand so far this whole Arc Bonney it is shown mostly in Kuma's backstory, we see how passionate and determined she was to find Nika and it's clear that she wants to be like him just look at some of her fighting moves, to cut it short this is only a guess, so don't argue with me, but I think that luffy job at being Nika is to bring Apon a new dawn and libate the world in the form of Bonney, but he still plays a big role in it, and Luffy can focus on BB and Shanks and fight to become Pirate King, the main plot of the story🤷🏽

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Not a single word you just said makes ANY sense on both a headcanon or logical level for the sake of an argument… 🤦‍♂️

[@Deadmanstune]

Roger Ended up finding 2 Kids who eventually inherited his technique and fighting style and the other his will to find treasure. I wonder who is the 2nd Kid who will join….if so

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Luffys not having a kid join this late in endgame… and what happens to rogers doesn’t = what happens to luffys crew… 🤦‍♂️

[@Deadmanstune]

@@CrimsonKaiserx8 everything roger has done is everything luffy has done as well. The only difference is being that instead of ending where roger stopped luffy will go further.

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

You keep saying the same thing without providing further context…

[@WillOfMyD]

I seriously wish this was true. I want Bonnie to join. Unfortunately, I think it would be Yamato. I don't like Yamato.

[@TysonTyler]

Bonney suits the strawhats so much

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

No she doesn’t bring a glorified companion character…😕

[@ComeFindOuts]

Oda might drop Bonney off in elbalf tbh, similarities to big mom and being able to transform into Nika , she might become a staple to Elbaf and join Luffy’s alliance instead . I’m 60/40 on this vs her joining the crew .

[@troysaxon8740]

StrawHats bounties are gonna skyrocket after egghead. No way the WG doesnt raise it post egghead especially for Bonney. Yes, Bonney for nakama

[@CC-ed9lf]

She can also make Momo his original age (temporarily) when they meet again.

[@Proboybsb]

I think that the reason is Luffy, not Bonney because if Luffy knows that Bonney wants to see Nika, luffy can literally imagine the Bonney was nika with him and just make it happen because gear5

[@Chibason]

Im torn because although it certainly seems like Bonney is being set up to be the next Nakama, which wouldnt be a bad fit, i dont really want to see her using Nika form for the rest of the manga

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

What setup for her to be a straw hat?! There’s no tragic proper backstory or a dream… She doesn’t have any unique powers just a cheap knockoff version of gear 5th which is a copy paste lazy effort in all honesty… She lacks proper haki and the combat experience to be a real endgame player nor a defined role on the crew… And that Nika form is obviously going to be temporary and not a permanent thing….😕

[@SlickSIoth]

Maybe it’s just me & my potential copium but I feel like the last member to join will still be Yamato. Given of her friendship with Ace, Ace telling her about Luffy & all that. Also the fact that she did agree to join, but later decided she wanted to explore Wano FIRST, like Oden had done. I’m holding out hope that after she gets done doing that, she will in fact join the SH at sea, just like Jimbe did. Also if that becomes reality Jesus Christ will the SH be cracked.

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

So all of what you just said is entirely correct mate. Nothing of what you said is wrong about her joining and for why and how. You understand she’s the only one and why she will. 🫡

[@joshuadebose2693]

Also had a thought that Saturn was able to give her those powers during the time the government had the gum gum fruit. Because how the government got their hands on it in the first place still hasn't been answered yet

[@koffge]

Bonny is only 7 years younger than Luffy. The age difference is not big enough for her to be his successor.

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Btw she’s still a 12 year old girl btw who’s been heavily sexualized in the past before we knew her real age so let that sink in…

[@koffge]

@@CrimsonKaiserx8 Maybe she is also a 1000 year old dragon and we don't know about it yet?

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Umm excuse me what does that mean… 😕

[@jasonforgeron]

Her awakening: being able to indefinitely change the ages of others

[@justinharvey8818]

Sai just found a big win. With that bounty, I'd bet money on bonnie joining.

[@BlitzedKip420]

You're going to lose money. There's only really one spot left and Vivi has nowhere else to go. It makes way more narrative sense for her to join the revs like her parents, despite all of his clever circumstantial evidence, and the fact it would yes be kind of fun. Though a tons of ppl gonna doisagree on that point, half the fanbase getting pissed off the manga is devolving into Nikepiece.

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Then your about to lose all your money cause Yamato is joining… she’s already basically confirmed to be a jinbei 2.0… 😕

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Vivis not joining either that’s going to Yamato… She was already shown to be drawn with all the straw hats on chapter 1103 color spread… Oda already set her up and spoiled it with her being like how jinbei joined later… 😕

[@instinct1148]

Also one of the last things vegapunk said before he died was for them to protect Bonney

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

That’s not a dying wish nor is it anything remotely tying her to joining the crew… 😕

[@christianbenavente6202]

Also as a bonnie for crew stan, i cant omit the bonnie and kuma pacifita possibility. For one all she really wanted was to be with her dad again, over seeing sun god nika. And in the memory flashback kuma makes a clear point to state that the memories he gives vegapunk is just a copy and that his original memories will remain. So as long as the original kuma remains so does his original memories. I still think the kuma pasafista will gain his memory and sail the seas with bonnie allowing her to grow up with her father. To me her joining the crew or leaving with the kuma pasifista are the only two possible outcomes and anything else will disappoint me

[@joshuadebose2693]

Yooooooo could she possibly revert Brook back to human temporarily with her power??

[@BlitzedKip420]

No (I mean probably but) also that would be lame and ruin his schtick. It would be a nerf as well he wouldn't be able to glide across water, itd slow him down, and probably make him unable to use all his soul powers.

[@aleccampbell7707]

Bonney is no fun without limits, Oda has a balancing act ahead

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

What…

[@Snakestube]

If luffy gets bonnie he is the new Xebec

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

What does that even mean….😕

[@Snakestube]

…. Xebec had were the strongest pirate crew in One Piece history. With the addition of Bonnie and Yamato, Luffy can parallel that is a hard conclusion to come too?

[@lyradahlia3473]

I really like the idea of Bonney taking on different futures depending on which straw hat she could be with. For example a swordsman distorted future, a fishman distorted future, a sniper distorted future etc. While Nika future is ofc the strongest of them, her tapping into all of the strawhats situationally instead of just Luffy could come in handy. I also like the idea of her joining the grand fleet and collecting Pacifista as her crew! And her journey could consist of her essentially liberating her own father over and over again, finally taking him back from the world governments clutches. Heck she'd be an extremely valuable member of the Revolutionairy army as well if that's how they come back into the story to take care of Bonney on Kuma's behalf.

[@H_i1867]

Luffy bout to be the most weakest character here soon. No one can have anything unique to them now, its kind of stupid to me TBH. To be able to copy EVERYTHING just defeats the purpose of luffy grows when there is a person who can copy everything of his fruits powers. Even when people say "OH yeah she is not powerful than luffy because she lacks haki to fully use Nika" she is literally a child with many years to train up till that point, and till then she might have perfected the nika fruit even more so than Luffy has. She is toooooo broken they literally need to nerf her before luffy gets the ONE PIECE, because I am not going to feel right that there is a person on luffy ship that can steal the title of the pirate king.

[@H_i1867]

At this point Oda might as well give her every kind of haki as well. Because from what I can tell Haki is more easier to obtain than an Awaken of a Devil Fruit, because every person that has an awaken has unlock their haki. So that also defeats the point of giving luffy more haki to kinda balance out the Bonny Nika transformation.

[@H_i1867]

So the thing of saying haki is stronger than devil fruits wont work. because all we have to do is give bonnie a few years or even month and she will be luffy equal. I dont like that. But honestly that just me

[@ashmilla3]

Like naruto, Luffys other nika power is friendship. Luffys gives this power to his crew, jembei, Ussop, zoro, brook, Robin, Nami, chopper, Sanji, vivi, carrot, yamato, bonney and his brother sabo all thanks to ace for clogging his memory and make sabo go to Luffy

[@JazzyJinx]

I do like that it could be like a Chimchar situation as well. Blackbeard said that she was too weak to join his crew and so Luffy letting her join his would be a repudiation of that. Kind of like Ash and Paul.

[@repulzer]

I mean isnt Nami creating the Logs and co? I loved that fact actually, because Nami seems intelligent

[@elemomnialpha]

Yamato being a log keeper NEVER made sense because she hasn't experienced the majority of the journey and considering her upbringing I highly doubt she'd be better at it than Nami or Robin Oden's job was to read the Poneglyphs something Yamato CAN'T DO and even if she could that's already Robin's job

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Then clearly you don’t understand her character and what oda was portraying with her… She clearly takes after oden even in the fact his journal directly set her on a path to following in his footsteps… She’s clearly going to write her own logbook about the history of the world..plus it has zero relevance if she wasn’t there for the start… That information can always be written down later. It’s not about how you start it’s how you end it. She’s going to be there for the most important part of the story… That’s all that really matters… her upbringing has nothing to do it’s her love of oden and replicating his logbook but with her own account of the history of the world at this time… Also she doesn’t need to read ponaglyphs that’s robins job… your final statement makes no sense trying to force a comparison between her and oden in the wrong context as well as with Robin….😕

[@jay_officialtv4000]

WE NEED ROOKIE STRAWHATS I wanna see sum young guns 😂

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

We need EXPERIENCED AND PROPERLY TRAINED users on the crew when we’re in ENDGAME!😕

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Same thing yet again and you keep commenting after me trying to prove something I’m utterly perplexed… Bonney being a rookie only shows how inexperienced she is and what training compared to a vast amount of other characters to a literal 12 year old… Riding this Bonney hope in the moment really hard and it’s obvious how much we keep bumping heads at this rate…

[@AlphaTech-at1219]

"Final Crewmate can help luffy to became pirate king"

[@AintMeTU]

Did bro leave in a cough and edit in a black screen as it happened? Lmao

[@beardedmotu2007]

Oda open the gates …

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

NO! Oda already opened pandora box when he showed off her true age… 🤦‍♂️

[@HAZM31]

What if figarland is the one who actually impregnated Ginny? And Saturn only experimented on her. Kinda dark to think about but the whole kuma backstory is already dark tbh.

[@lynxparaguariensis]

A timeline when Usopp was born divine.

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

No….

[@shayoko6]

it was a mistake for carrot to not join. having mink representation was a great direction and fir with the other theme of crew joining. east blue-normal humans grandline-devfil fruits and modified humans New world- non humans

[@Dreq458]

Hm. Never thought to distinguish them that way. I like it.

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

It was a mistake wasting 8 years pretending that carrot juice as even considered eligible to join… The minks don’t need representation outside of being tied to zou and wano otherwise their just another race of people and nothing more….😕 In the grand scheme their not even all that important… the race in the pirate kings crew has little to do with the overal narrative of the story…😕

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

8 years for a dead agenda for that rabbit… she’s was overhyped and vastly overrated… The mink neither are really anything special to write home about either… 😕

[@ederymikael4097]

@@CrimsonKaiserx8 A yamato fan who talks about overhyping and overating ; are you serious ? Carrot is way more deserving of becoming a strawhats than yamato . She basically was one of them during WCI ; They Laught cried and bonded together during that time ! It’s ok if you don’t like her but please Stop the disrespect thank you

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

It’s unironic that you blame me a yamato fan for overhyping and overreacting…. Compared to turning right around with that coming from a carrot fan… You ever stop to think carrot has had 8 years and almost 350 chapter worth of hype and expectations set out all while carrot fans talk her up to the moon?! She’s been in the story far long then Yamato and yet the small vocal minority of carrot fans are exactly what you think I am… They propped up and put this gloried side character on a pedestal who ended up failing into success in her current position off a cheap and failed revenge side plot… Don’t even think the two characters are anything alike when Yamato and what she has done for her is far more depth and of quality compared to carrot… It’s ironic cause everything people have said over the last 8 years for carrot is what happened for Yamato… If seen just about everything and anything from pure fanfics and Herculean leaps in mental gymnastics for excuses for carrot so please don’t make me laugh at the notion you still think she’s gonna join… And yeah btw she was barely on screen with them in wci so please try harder to show me somthing I haven’t already seen thank you… She was a prop and side character with barely any relevance outside of being a sulong hype man for the dukes later in wano… if she was going to do anything you say she would it already would have happened so nice try… Ship has come and gone and pretending anything else will happen means your late to the party cause I’ve seen it and done it… And lastly she’s a fiction character im allowed to hate if I want cause frankly after 8 years of constant screaming from the loudest of carrot fans I could care less cause the wind is blowing other way… talk all the smack and now you deserve to eat it…😕

[@Dankargonaut]

So what if she does that whole asta sharing his devil powers with everyone making everyone have those powers on the crew who’s in her presence. It’s so ironic that her and luffy are gonna beat some elder ass.

[@deraminator945]

Luffy unwillingly becomes a small child or very old as a drawback. Bonney willingly changes her age as she wants. Luffy consciously changes his body form to his wish. Bonney must to be able to imagine a future where her bodyshape is changed to change her bodyshape.

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

No one is asking or needs to have their ages altered to provide anything new or interesting…😕

[@DmccullochD]

The flower thing keeps getting referenced as an early hint but do they really mean anything? I dont think it does..

[@JBirdInfo]

Can you do a video on your thoughts on the 3 other gods of one piece (forest, rain and earth)

[@sphinxtan9158]

Bonney's dream is to travel around the world. Thousand Sunny is the dreamt ship.

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

Bonney doesn’t have a dream… the Sunny is not a ship she dreams about being on what do you even mean…. 😕

[@sphinxtan9158]

@@CrimsonKaiserx8 Bonney's dream is to travel around the world after 10 years old as Kuma promised her. She has been traveling, but she was looking for Kuma. And as a pirate, she is not free to go wherever she like. Thousand Sunny is the dreamt ship because it is the ship of Nika the Sun God, it signifies freedom. That is also part of Bonney dream as she dreams to be freed from the enslavement (unable to expose to the sun, and later hunting down by the world government). The last page of chapter 1118 actually signifies this, as Kuma recalls his promise to Ginny. And Bonney pirates might be as well as disbanded. Due to the fact that they were probably retired pirates before set sail again for Bonney. This points out that Bonney has no place to go except Nika's ship.

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

None of that you just said is anything outside of headcanon and pure fan speculation up tell now…

[@sphinxtan9158]

@@CrimsonKaiserx8 Nah. Bonney's dream and conditions were told in Kuma's memory recall. The only problem here is that Bonney never officially asked if she could join the crew. But who had ever wanted to join Luffy before they were asked to? Zoro was invited, Nami was invited, Sanji was invited, Chopper was invited, Brook was invited. Robin and Jinbei's conditions were special. The only two persons who voluntarily wanted to follow Luffy was Usopp and Franky. The reason Bonney would want to join Luffy is that he is Nika. And if Nami get to know about her condition (12 years old and without a proper team), she will want her to stay.

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

🤦‍♂️

[@nerderspree]

Nami takes care of the ship's logs btw

[@GhostLGNDClashRoyale]

Vivi is technically already a member

[@CrimsonKaiserx8]

And yet she’s not on the crew currently….

[@courage1363]

@@CrimsonKaiserx8 I agree since she is CURRENTLY on Morgan's news ship.