This is Our Dream Cast For Mean Girls The Musical MOVIE!

Hello and welcome to our channel!
Today, we're putting together our dream cast for the "upcoming" mean girls musical movie adaptation and we and SO EXCITED for our cast list! It's SO FETCH! (yikes)
We're excited to hear who is actually cast in this movie adaptation. What do you guys thinks? Who would you cast in these roles?
We hope you enjoy this video!
- Sam & Ryan
We're Sam & Ryan! Samantha Fekete is a content creator who works full time at Hi5 Studios. Ryan McCartan is an actor who you may recognize as Diggie from Disney Channel's Liv and Maddie, JD from Heathers the Musical, Hans from Frozen on Broadway, and more! We create content to entertain and inform. Subscribe to take a deep dive into out content! If you subscribe, you officially become Daddy, a part of the best fan base out there.
Check out our Twitch Channel! Sunday's & Wednesdays! - / ryan_mccartan​​. .
Instagram: @samantha_fekete & @mccarya
Manager contact: [e-mail]

[@ellie6475]

Let’s be honest... we all know deep down that James Corden is going to play every single role

[@_..jolene.._]

I would pay to see that😭✋

[@anamariacarrenoparra7543]

That would be hilarious

[@hopper6094]

Yup. Lol

[@Player-nv5bd]

it’ll just be james cordon with a bunch of different wigs

[@danimiller9932]

I heard he’s playing Regina

[@kassie9473]

Renee's Regina was too short lived. I'm so happy you brought her back

[@agg304]

No hate, but I wasn’t a fan of Reneé. I felt like her riffs in Someone Gets Hurt were really unnecessary and they made the song flat. I really loved Taylor Louderman’s Regina and kind of wish we could bring her back! I was so sad when she left Broadway!

[@lolarose8973]

@@agg304 she would be too old for an on screen version

[@goldstarforkathyparr7720]

Hi I'm from the future. Prepare for happiness my friend

[@vivluns]

Hi guys. Someone from the future. I will have you know that QUEEN REGINA GEORGE WILL BE PLAYED BY MS. RENEE RAPP IN THE UPCOMING MEAN GIRLS THE MUSICAL MOVIE!!!

[@tanvinerurkar3787]

When y’all started talking about Cameron Dallas playing Aaron my heart literally dropped I’m like 😧 so glad you were kidding 😂

[@madeleinefleming7648]

IKR me to

[@roseivy2278]

OMG SAME

[@raccoonmotion5681]

Ik

[@FrostyFrickles]

Oh my god I was so confused for a second. I was like??? Didn’t everyone hate him. 😂

[@triplecs5022]

Me too! I was like 😳

[@rutheckhart5137]

Also an idea could be Amanda Seyfried as any of the adult women since she was the og Karen and she’s got a bunch of movie musicals under her belt now

[@frozen_blondy2076]

Maybe as reginas mom 😂

[@seacucumber679]

karen's mum. i know she's not a character but make it happen.

[@person954]

I totally agree

[@Totallyawesomemegagirl]

@@frozen_blondy2076 yea she could slay what’s wrong with me (reprise)

[@buduhanfamily2419]

sorry, i'm only accepting james corden as regina

[@sofia.eagles5678]

Nah he should just play all 3 of the plastics...

[@buduhanfamily2419]

@@sofia.eagles5678 imagine that... three james cordens rolling out on that table as the set washes pink...

[@rachelriddell1774]

I will have James Cordon as Cady and Regina and we all know he’s gonna be Elphaba, Galinda and the Wizard in Wicked too.

[@j.k5840]

You gotta be kidding…..😭😭

[@valenciahidalg0]

“there are plenty of roles for 30 year olds to play 30 year olds. how about kids play kids?” *the prom movie has left the chat*

[@jadesmyspiritanimal886]

Excuse me, Ariana DeBose was the best thing about The Prom movie!

[@fashionablechangeling1988]

That's a strange way to spell Andrew Rannells singing Love Thy Neighbour

[@jadesmyspiritanimal886]

@@fashionablechangeling1988 that's the tea, my friend. I actually loved him as well

[@_..jolene.._]

That’s one upside about The Phantom of the Opera (2004). A 16 year old played Christine😌

[@kowabungakelly]

@@fashionablechangeling1988 that was my favorite number in the film it’s so good

[@clarissalovesick]

When Sam said Liz gillies I just started screaming OMG YES SHE IS PERFECT I CANT BELIEVE SAM LOVED VICTORIOUS!!!!!

[@zoey5711]

SAME

[@wonderpotter2674]

SAMEEE

[@quinnhuang6515]

I WAS LIKE "IF THEY DON'T SAY LIZ GILLIES I'D TURN THIS VIDEO OFF" AND LIKE LIZ

[@evieanne06]

Just finished watching it for the first time(cause I was robbed of experiencing it in my childhood) and yeeesssssssssss!!!!!!!! 😍😍😍

[@linearellayae7652]

I was dying throughout that whole part. Feels like a crossover to me

[@juliarothstein]

Sam and Ryan after saying how great Cameron Dallas was: "obviously that was a lie!" Me: *deletes paragraph*

[@aubrieweaver2302]

I know nothing about him, what’s the tea?

[@dangosandlemons]

@@aubrieweaver2302 He agreed to playing Aaron in the musical and he was terrible at it :D

[@dangosandlemons]

or that's all I know LMAO

[@toxicsugarart2103]

DUDE Ariana as Karen is genius. Her role in Scream Queens was super airhead and sooo funny, she’d be amazing as Karen.

[@IHARumor]

Omg I totally forgot her role in Scream Queens! She was amazing as Chanel #2.

[@scott09146]

I was thinking it would be Heather Morris because she played Brittney in Glee but Ari is our queen so I’m ok with it.

[@valbea9958]

Plus wasn't she also in 13? So she has been in musicals before

[@j.k5840]

Plus we know she can be THAT popular girl, She showed it off in 13…

[@charliesimpson3879]

If it’s not Reneé as Regina then I don’t even know what I’ll do. She owns that role, and her vocals are something else

[@username1150]

i *agree*

[@FanOBarbaro]

@Madison and Leah Taylor won't do it. Erika henningson told me none of the obc wants to be in the remake because they are too old

[@andrewhamilton8158]

Ariana Grande? I mean she already played it in the thank u, next video and definitely has the vocals for it, and I think she has matured beyond the ditzy Cat Valentine character and needs to stop being typecast as such

[@ohblobby]

SHE IS. OMG. SO EXCITING.

[@AzurillStreep]

“I think they all sang” was such a deep cut and unexpected reference I choked 😂

[@kassie9473]

I've never been so honored to be called daddy

[@missraredoesstuff]

I love this list! The only change I would make is Sadie Sink as Cady! She's a broadway kid with a great voice She's 18 SHe's a natural redhead and STRANGER THINGS!!! I would love to see her on top of all your fabulous picks

[@tanseem5240]

I agree sm Olivia as Cady doesn’t feel right but I feel like Sadie sink would do the role justice

[@melly5162]

completely agree

[@kowabungakelly]

Omg I’d love to see this

[@missraredoesstuff]

@@kowabungakelly I HOPE it happens one day!

[@h3arts4kaykay]

omg yesss

[@julienlevesque5366]

Wait Karan Brar is a GENIUS pick! Edit: Also Joshua, Alex, and pretty much everyone else is top tier casting!

[@no.7988]

Also I think Gregory Diaz the forth would also be a good Kevin g (he was in in the heights btw)

[@savannahgrace111]

Sabrina Carpenter should be Cady. She only got to play her for two days, she has a great voice, and she's played sweet girl and bad girl equally well. Also, Jordan Fisher as Aaron anyone?

[@jordangoodman3507]

I really likw this too...honestly also kinda like oliva as gretchen better

[@MissLaurenLipstick]

YES TO BOTH OMG

[@hopper6094]

Jordan is actually playing Aaron tho. Lol

[@aleshatran]

Yes I agree

[@frozen_blondy2076]

Jordan yes omg yes

[@oliviacalvillo9284]

Tell my why I KNEW you were going to say Josh AND Olivia before it even happened. HAHAHHAHA I LOVE IT

[@RJ-pk3ns]

maybe because it was in the thumbnail perhaps? (this is a joke btw)

[@_..jolene.._]

@@RJ-pk3ns that’s what I was gonna say (but not a joke) but then I saw you said it first😂

[@oliviacalvillo9284]

@@_..jolene.._ I clicked on the video right went it went live so I didn’t see the thumbnail

[@abbaliciouz7208]

The one dislike is from Bailey getting told that shes dramatic

[@taliabernstein5600]

Omg if Olivia played Cady after Sabrina played cady for like 2 nights on Broadway before Covid😂😂☕️

[@krau2880]

Oh god that would be hilarious

[@saonnideleon]

Deja vu xd

[@_..jolene.._]

Why would that even matter

[@taliabernstein5600]

@@_..jolene.._ cos of the whole josh Olivia Sabrina drama

[@triplecs5022]

Omg! I didn’t think about that

[@anasofia-vw7ih]

the only two people who wont cast james corden in a musical movie I bow down to you

[@sophier8613]

Besides the West Side Story casting directors lol

[@anasofia-vw7ih]

@@sophier8613 RIGHT OMG...i expect nothing less from mr speilberg

[@_..jolene.._]

He wouldn’t be suitable for Mean Girls anyways.. if he were to be cast he’d need to have songs and a decent part. In Mean Girls the only males that have decent parts are Arron and Damien and since Corden can’t pass as a teen it wouldn’t work.

[@anasofia-vw7ih]

@@_..jolene.._haha agreed

[@anasofia-vw7ih]

@@_..jolene.._ it was also like a joke LOLOLOL

[@janinev.5974]

a star on the rise madison reyes but ppl aren't ready to talk about julie and the phantoms yet 😌 (yes it's directed towards teens but it's a hella good show and the music and drama is spectacular)

[@carlay.1045]

aaaahghhhh yess!! love madi reyes she is criminally underrated

[@girlnamedchris]

Yes! She immediately came to mind for Cady as well.

[@reginahay4998]

Yes she’s so talented.

[@reginahay4998]

I’d love to see savannah lee May as Karen

[@KalleighNorval]

YES THIS

[@edisonthethird]

Karan Brar is a GENIUS casting choice.

[@jaylajackson4935]

the way Cameron Dallas is the joke of Mean Girls on bway is hysterical😭😂

[@jiyagir01]

Karan and alex were just INCREDIBLE DECISIONS

[@constanza4256]

ikr they would be incredible for those roles!

[@_..jolene.._]

Mine: Reneé Rapp as Regina and the rest are the og cast. Although I love Taylor Louderman, Reneé is my fave.

[@username1150]

saaaaaaammmmeeeeee ✨✨✨✨✨

[@rainbowandre9580]

Yes Erika Henningsen is a Queen

[@samanthagonzalez6413]

This list is so incredible and I would cry if this is how they cast it. However, with how accurate to age you were casting a lot of the characters I don’t feel that Arianna, Liz, and Alex (even though they are fantastic and I love them so so so so so much) will play to that same age when surrounded by people who are actually 18 to early twenties.

[@dreamingofthemoon]

Yes that's what I thought too

[@cats7414]

“We wanna cast age appropriate people” *proceeds to cast older actors😭* LOVE the list but the age variety would just be tooooo funny

[@lolarose8973]

@@cats7414 it would be another dear evan hansen situation 😭

[@ellew.7638]

The second you said Joshua as Aaron, I knew Cady was going to be Olivia. I honestly think they would both be amazing in these roles and would attract so many viewers!

[@mariejoris2052]

Okay but hear me out. She was in the original Mean Girls movie. She’s been in several movie musicals and we know for a fact that she can sing. Mrs. George needs to be able to sing (please don’t cut "What’s Wrong With Me (Reprise)" out. . . . . AMANDA SEYFRIED! It just makes so much sense to me that she’d go from Karen to Mrs. George who are two (very different) airheads. Plus she’s a really good singer. I just want it to happen so bad!

[@roseivy2278]

BAHAHAHA loved when ryan pulled the "i think they AlL sInG"

[@danielle-idontwantjustnumbers]

i’d love to see the people you mentioned but idk how Ariana Grande and Elizabeth Gilles are gonna work next to Olivia Rodrigo as the same age

[@erinmcn14]

I feel like it would make it even better

[@jordanottey4360]

Makeup they could make it work

[@callmeKitty]

me: * has a million things to do for school * also me: * watches 18 minutes of Sam and Ryan casting the Mean Girls movie *

[@hyotmess]

I totally agree producers should employ the community more but these movies always need some big names to attract attention so choosing Ariana and Liz makes so much sense, they dont work in musicals now but they were on broadway when they were young and are also really big musical fans (they were the ones that got me into this world lol) so if the producers do cast big names to attract attention I hope they cast people who respect and appreciate musical theatre like Ari and Liz do

[@whatwhatwhatidkwhatstuff]

Ariana and Liz did 13 The Musical when they were 15 ❤

[@keke9795]

wait- musical theatre is cool at schools cause it definitely ain't at my school i gotta keep my theater nerd self to myself or the monsters come at me

[@_..jolene.._]

Be proud of your theater nerd self😌 we stan a theater kid.

[@ianfer3076]

When they said who would be great instead of Barrett the first think I thought was "what about that girl that played Veronica in Heathers" lol

[@hyotmess]

I LITERALLY SCREAMED WHEN YOU SAID LIZ GILLIESSSS I thought of her but I thought you wouldnt say herrrr

[@PurpleBiscuit]

I mean... I think they all sing. SOMEBODY GET THIS MAN HE WILDIN

[@grandlordSpencer]

Thank you for bringing Renee back. The world needs to experience her talent!

[@grandlordSpencer]

Also what about Mr. Duvall? I personally would love someone like Eddie Murphy to come in and bring the laughs as a fun small appearance.

[@addykress9578]

Ryan’s “I think they all sang” was literally the best part

[@neamhu-m479]

the shade in casting Josh and then Olivia and not Sabrina - saw this coming ahah

[@bethanylavallee3709]

Same. Like give the girl the role she was cast in and only got 2 times to play for a month or longer run. Sabrina should be Cady

[@lolarose8973]

@@bethanylavallee3709 I personally didn't like her as cady and I dont think her voice was the right fit personally, I love sabrina by the way though

[@xaviersmith5930]

I honestly thought that the "drama for the tabloids" was that fact that Sabrina Carpenter was paying the role on Broadway after only getting like two days of being the character before COVID shut it down. I 100% forgot about the Joshua casting by that point in the video ahaha.

[@ratbian]

I actually feel like Elle McLemore would be a good choice for Karen, since she played a similar role in Heathers, and just overall seems like such a kind and likable person

[@anasofia-vw7ih]

ok i loved most of the casting! i just wish that you casted more people with the college/hs age :/ like barret, ariana, as much as I love her, liz gillies. love you both and loved this video!! also excited for your next twitch stream :)

[@TheVendettaMcQueen]

I’d love to see y’all tackle a Heathers Musical movie or a new RENT musical movie 👀

[@quinnhuang6515]

so olivia as cady in the movie opposite josh as aaron while sabrina's broadway run as cady lasted 2 shows.... interesting

[@Daniel-ed9gn]

Sam and Ryan: We’re trying to cast this age appropriately Also Sam and Ryan: *casts like four 27/28 year olds as high schoolers Not meant as hate but I just thought it was funny

[@ellasong1029]

Isn’t that the norm now tho

[@3lisiaa]

Watching this again after Renee’s been announced and it’s making me so hyped for this all over again!!!

[@Magical3750]

You guys were right about Renee Rapp doing the movie!!!! She will be and is phenomenal!

[@esheahen]

Can’t wait for y’all’s “In The Heights” reviewwwww!!

[@vivluns]

First thing that popped into my head when u guys said "Kevin G." "KARAN BRAR. GET THIS MAN UP HERE NOW."

[@ohblobby]

THE RENEE PART AGED WELL BECAUSE SHES PLAYING REGINA YAYYYYY

[@arianagucciardo8887]

does anyone else think that Kristen Chenoweth would be so good as Regina’s mom?

[@marissaann2302]

I literally agree with all of them! Also HSMTMTS season 2 is coming out in two days! Kinda perfect lol

[@annikaruelo1383]

I knew they were going to put Olivia as Cady as soon as they started describing who her lol. Also I love your cast

[@sashkapolly6724]

Lol, I knew that Ryan would place Barrett as Janis. And I also think that Renee is a perfect Regina. I even think about Sabrina as Cady, but I never see her perform so have no clue, if she's good or bad. And it would be so much better if they would place James as Cady's dad. A little cameo, but not too much

[@chile7954]

kristen chenoweth as reginas mom. i kinda see it.

[@cuzwhynot253]

Yesss

[@artbyL31]

When you mentioned the fact that “Cady” was a really big rising star with a great Vioce I said: it’s obviously Olivia

[@kailikesrocks1251]

LIZ AND ARIANA WERE ON BROADWAY WHEN THEY WERE KIDS!! THEY WERE IN THIRTEEN THE MUSICAL TOGETHER

[@jilliannixon305]

PLEASE do more of these videos I’m OBSESSED with them. Your choices are always SPOT ON. Love it.

[@sydneyholtzman906]

Omg, yessssss. U guys have the best insight on who should play what part. Love u guys 💓

[@andrearabaza7259]

Thank you Ryan for the wonderful Zoom chat this afternoon. It was a fun and informative discussion.

[@nesie.noodles6541]

this channel is so comforting and addicting to watch WHY HAVE YOU GUYS BEEN ALL MY LIFE YOU'RE BOTH SO GORGEOUS AND SMART HOW HAVE I ONLY DISCOVERED YOUR KZbin A FEW DAYS AGO??

[@mariasmakeupart7969]

For Janice I think I have also a really good idea, what about Sophia Anne Caruso, she played also a gothic character in Beetlejuice, she is 19, she can sing...

[@AudrieSaint]

Current official cast as of 12/11/22 Cady Heron- Angourie Rice (Betty from SpiderMan) Regina George- Renee Rapp🙌 Janis- Aulii Cravahlo (Moana) Damien- Jacqueline Spivey (A Strange Loop)

[@kiaraco3550]

Once again, I manifested a Mean Girls dream cast vid for the movie musical!!

[@13Nikie]

I kind of love this list! Even as you brought up a character, I thought of the actor you did. Even when I didn't your choice was great, an incredibly diverse cast and I would love to see it.

[@faithhernandez764]

JOSHUA BASSET AS ARON SAMUELS IS THE GREATEST THING ALONE I HAVE EVER SEEN ON THE INTERNET

[@ninavillar565]

This dream cast you guys made NEEDS TO HAPPEN, every single role is perfectly cast and now I need this to happen

[@linearellayae7652]

Also adding to the Liz Gillies part: In Ariana Grande´s music video for 7 rings, she was literally in the Mean Girls scene (as Cady but who cares) and she has said multiple times that she likes Mean Girls

[@delwinvanjaarsveld4422]

Obsessed with these choices!!

[@ellisquinne9777]

I really want Sabrina to play Cady in the movie cuz I feel so bad for her only getting two shows on Broadway

[@bethmx10]

yes agree 🥺

[@ellasong1029]

No thank u Olivia a would be soooo much better as cady maybe her as Karen tho

[@ellisquinne9777]

@@ellasong1029 do you really think those two are gonna be cast together?

[@ellasong1029]

@@ellisquinne9777 no I don’t but I’m just eating I don’t see Sabrina as a cady, I see Olivia more of a cady and then as a character sabrinas more like Karen not cady, not in the same show

[@jadexcarroll]

Can I just say: You put Olivia Rodrigo as Cady in this and Sabrina carpenter was supposed to be Cady on Broadway before the shutdown 🤭

[@avas.5016]

O my god!!!!! I am screaming so much watching this!!!!! Like Liz, RENEEEEE, Josh and Olivia! YESSSSSSS! That is exactly what I decided I wanted like 4 months ago!!!!! Ahhhh

[@siennamerco8543]

u seem familiar 🤨

[@avas.5016]

@@siennamerco8543 no u

[@flutesister9919]

I’ve been waiting for this video I’m so excited!

[@katiegriffin1511]

OMG I LITERALLY WAS THINKING KARAN BRAR FOR KEVIN G BEFORE YOU EVEN SAID IT. HE WAS THE FIRST PERSON TO COME TO MIND. I was like no way, they're not gonna pick him, BUT YOU DID AHH!! He's literally perfect for it!

[@girlnamedchris]

These choices are pretty perfect! I really loved the Liz and Alex mentions. I was surprised that I didn't hear Sabrina Carpenter's name in the mix with the tabloid drama conversation re: Joshua & Olivia, especially since she was cast as Cady for a split second. I wouldn't necessarily promote drama (especially between young women) and they've both since cleared the air but I think this could be a great hypothetical project to work on together -- Olivia as Cady and Sabrina as Regina. I also thought of Rachel Crow as Karen perhaps? I also think re: stars on the rise / new talent goes, I can see Madison Reyes as Cady or Janis.

[@simongonzalez7500]

“I think we all sing” the fact that Ryan worked with Victoria makes that even funnier 😂

[@nyla565]

I never watched Mean Girls, but from the way y'all described the characters, i think these people are great for this

[@_..jolene.._]

I highly recommend!! It’s so good. There are many bootlegs on here of it snd there is a movie (the movie isn’t musical though)

[@nyla565]

@@_..jolene.._ thanks, i will try to watch it before the musical movie adaption comes out

[@willwalker24601]

Plz plz make more of these! Some ideas that came to mind are The Color Purple or Miss Saigon 🤷🏼 (both “in the works”)

[@JackieWarner13]

I'm so happy there's so many movie musicals. I live in Australia so we only get a few musicals at a time. Been lucky enough to see 4 already this year which is crazy & then we have more later this year so I'm just so excited for this musical filled year.

[@kendallbeavers2052]

I wanted to say it so badly, it would be hilarious if u had Joshua as Aaron Olivia as cady but then had Sabrina as Regina😂😂 like the tea is kinda over but that whole thing was absolutely insane in the moment-

[@gracecooper6616]

i see nobody but barrett as janis and nobody but renee as regina

[@matthewkim3496]

love this channel!

[@catleslie3997]

I need one for Hamilition next! Or something like bring old to new., grease maybe?

[@goldstarforkathyparr7720]

Who's here after the casting was announced? Angourie Rice: Cady Heron Renee Rapp: Regina George Auli'i Cravalho: Janis Sarkisian Jaquel Spivey: Damian Hubbard

[@grayhawkins3205]

This is a top tier video!!!

[@ShabanonMusic]

“I was so hesitant putting Ariana in a movie musical” Oop this aged well 😂

[@ella9120]

This cast is SO SO prefect!!

[@starfrisco7163]

I was so on board with all of these, and then you said Alex Newell as Damien ... Mind. Blown. YES. Somebody make this happen!

[@sscares_0730]

This list makes so much sense it’a amazing

[@evieanne06]

Ok but...Liz playing Janis and Ari playing Karen is just...✨ahhhhhh✨ because that would be 3 projects together! First, they were in 13 the musical(plus that means they both have Broadway background) when they were teenagers. Then, they were the iconic duo in victorious that we all know and love. And if this were to happen, they’d be that cute and annoyed duo once again. My heart can’t take this!!!!!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@carlyscovers28]

This. This is GENIUS

[@athenarogers6829]

this video is gold

[@jaelyn2228]

There was not a single choice I was not aggressively bobbing my head along with. I would LOVE to see this

[@deborahherrera3928]

Tina Fey said she wants actual teenagers or teenagers ish look like for the movie. saying that i will love to see Sabrina and Renee in it!!

[@bethanylavallee3709]

Same!!

[@rooparker9224]

I can picture Zendaya doing the "NO! THEY'RE BOTH IN THE COSTUME" "And I never told anyone because I am such a good friend"

[@JoAnneHartSings]

I LOVE this cast list. Like, I really want this to happen now.

[@sarahelizabeth9690]

you guys scared the shit out of me talking about Cameron like that LMAOOO

[@jessellis7444]

You really got me there

[@sarahscott1361]

I swear if it’s James cordon I will revolt. We need to give Broadway stars the roles they do better than anyone else ever could!

[@katiegriffin1511]

I was also REALLY hoping you guys would say Joshua Bassett for Aaron when I saw him on the thumbnail and I'm sooo glad you did :)

[@charlietheis4048]

From the get-go I KNEW you were going to pick Olivia as Cady and I LOVE it, I wanna see it!!😍