Thoha Khalsa I Ill-Fated Well I Mass Suicide By Sikh Women I Black Truth of the Partition of 1947

#partitionofindia #historyvlog #pakistan
Thoha Khalsa I Ill-Fated Well I Mass Suicide By Sikh Women I Black Truth of the Partition of 1947
Videography: Syed Shaz Gilani
Pak Rover
/ pakrover
Part #Jassar 1: I Bloodiest Railway Station of 1947 I Painful Memories-1 I When Sikhs Attacked Muslim Village
• Jassar I Bloodiest Rai...
Part # 2: Basantar Nala I Witness of 1947 Massacre I Mass Graves of Starvation Dead
• Basantar Nala I Witnes...
Thoha Khalsa I Ill-Fated Well I Mass Suicide By Sikh Women I Black Truth of the Partition of 1947
• Thoha Khalsa I Ill-Fat...
Thoha Khalsa is a village of Kahuta Region of District Rawalpindi in Pakistan. The village is located in the South East of Rawalpindi city at the distance of about 30 miles. The language used by its people is Pothohari dialect of Punjabi. The population is about 20,000 consisting Janjua Rajput, Ghakhar, and few others - all Muslims. Current inhabitants may not even know that it was a flourishing village of Sikhs before the partition of India (creation of Pakistan). The village was inhabited by wealthy Sikh families - Bindras, Duggals, Anands, and Chandhoks.
Sectarian violence erupts in Punjab as Muslim League announces partition and creation of Pakistan, a Muslim only nation carved out of India. Sikh leader Master Tara Singh declares opposition to the partition and tears the flag of Pakistan in Lahore. To the dismay of Sikhs and Punjabis, Indian leaders Gandhi and Nehru cave in to the demand of Pakistan.
On the evening of March 9, 1947, mobs from the tribal areas entered Thoha Khalsa and gave ultimatums to the Sikhs to convert. On that evening, the impact of their presence was negligible due to the lateness of the hour but the actual clashes started the next morning, when their numbers swelled to one thousand. The local helpless and poor Muslims who had earlier assured safety to the Sikhs, remained mute spectator when violence started due to their poverty, victimization, helplessness and lack of weapons.
After resisting for three days, the Sikhs hoisted white flags and negotiated truce with the Muslim mobs. Under the agreement, the mobs will loot their houses but will not burn them, kill men, or dishonor the women. The Sikhs collected Rs. 20,000 and gave to the mob leaders as demanded. They then abandoned their own houses and all gathered in the central Haveli of Sardar Gulab Singh. His mansion was huge with large boundary wall. Others took shelter in the "Dukh Bhanjani" Gurdwara located next to Gulab Singh's mansion.
From Gulab Singh's Haveli, they saw their houses being looted and burned for six days. After looting the houses, the Muslim mob turned to Gulab Singh's Haveli and surrounded it. Their intentions appeared menacing and it was clear that they do not intend to honor the terms of the truce.
But when defeat and dishonor was imminent, Sikh men started to prepare for the battle till death. While their men fought, the Sikh women started gathering near a well around the garden. When just women and children were left, Maan Kaur led all the women to a large well inside the Haveli. She recited "Japuji Sahib" the Sikh prayers and jumped inside the well. Over 93 Sikh women followed her and all committed mass suicide in order to save their honor.
On March 12, 1947 after long and heroic resistance, 200 Sikhs were killed. The women were asked to embrace Islam, but 93 of them, old and young, decided to escape dishonor by drowning themselves in a well, which they did. The Muslim invaders, aghast at this tragedy, fled from the place. A little later, the military arrived and rescued the survivors.
The news of the massacre at Thoha flashed on national newspapers. The Viceroy of India, Lord Mountbatten visited the village to assess the situation firsthand. He saw the loss of property and life at Thoha Khalsa and met with the survivors and heard their ordeal directly. Lady Mountbatten led the rescue and hospitalization of the victims.
Survivors reached the safety of refugee camps in Rawat, Kahuta and lived to tell their stories.
Follow us on:
Facebook:
/ ​. .
Twitter:
/ gilanilogs
Instagram:
/ zulfiqargil. .

[@sohrab9467]

Respect from the core of my heart . I didn’t know people like you still exist in Pakistan . If only ever just teacher was like you.

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thanks a lot for your appreciation. Stay blessed.

[@maanjutt162]

Rrrrdd .? V

[@soumyachaudhary8554]

Greetings from India🙏 Thank you for bringing this history and telling us the true story without being biased😇all the communities faced the aftermath of partition🥲🥲but people like you restore our faith in humanity🙂

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thanks and welcome ❤ There is no point in hiding something because only the truth remains alive. Be happy, stay safe.

[@aftabhussain6283]

ماشاالللہ !! گیلانی صاحب تاریخ کے دریچے کھولتے ھوۓ آج تک خاص طور پہ کسی مسلمان تجزیہ نگار نے اتنی اخلاقی جرات کا مظاہرہ نہی کیا جتنا آپ نے کیا ھے ۔ تاریخ کے دونوں رُخ دکھانے پہ آپ کی بے لوٹ کاوشوں کو سلام !! keep it up

[@zulfiqargilani]

حوصلہ افزائی کے لیے میں آپ کا شکر گزار ہوں

[@arshedkhan5143]

great.ending.words

[@miyalateef8899]

الله أكبر ماشاءاللہ جزاك الله سبحان الله الحمد لله استغفر الله بھت خوش ھیں أپکی ان کاوشوں پر ایک ھماری فرماٸیش پر ھو سک تو ایک ویلاگ کر دیں رحیم یار خان کے قریب ایک مقام ھے پتن منارا اسکا وزٹ اور تاریخ بتا دیں أپکے بھت شکر گزار ھونگے اللہ نگہبان

[@user-ml5lr5he8k]

U are Right , We agreed with ur comments

[@wasishah84]

i am from this region extremely saddened to hear about horrendous activities done in my region by muslim . i deeply apologize to my sikh brothers and feel ashamed.kudos to you for explaining these events in such a good manner and i appreciate your courage. keep up the good work.

[@zulfiqargilani]

This is called, high capacity. I appreciate your excuse. Thank you very much for liking and commenting. Stay blessed.

[@shaesta7897]

Don,t say sorry ,,, the advance version is been done now,, , ,,,in this modren world the muslim is killing muslim women and men in this region same as done in past 1947 .....but now the people wear uniform and took weapon in there hand and by law they hsve given permission to supress the movement of freedom .....say sorry first to pa

[@shaam7433]

salute for these women 😢😢😢😢 who choose death instead of disrespect ... mayri punjabi sisters ko slaaaam 🇵🇰

[@zulfiqargilani]

Pohnch gaya

[@shaam7433]

@@zulfiqargilani ?

[@anumzahra3948]

@@shaam7433 he said ap ka diya hwa salam phocnh gya Punjabi sisters ko

[@shaam7433]

@@anumzahra3948 how u & gilani logs know that ?🤔

[@zulfiqargilani]

Aap ka salam

[@sharma1976]

My grandparents migrated from a nearby village..."Rakh" (Bhura Hayal). And also, you are absolutely right, I was told the same thing by my grandparents that the rioters were outsiders and not from the areas around. In fact, one of the local Muslim residents helped my great grandfather escape.

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thats good

[@aqeelsurkhposh2818]

Do they left any thing written history after them about them

[@jamshedshaikh4619]

This is the most “intellectually daring”vlog from you sir. An eye opener for all of us. Thank you and congratulations for such quality work.

[@zulfiqargilani]

So nice of you. Thanks a lot for your appreciation,

[@zia989]

بہت ہی معلوماتی ویلاگ ہے۔ آپ کا انداز بیاں بہت ہی دل موہ لینے والا ہے۔ جزاک اللہ

[@zulfiqargilani]

بہت شکریہ آپ کا جناب

[@gurindersingh4655]

Thanks for sharing historical information and showing this place. 1947 was sad part of history of Punjab. You explained it very well.

[@zulfiqargilani]

It's my pleasure sir 😊

[@saqibbutt9926]

Gilani Sb...I want to add one incidence, My Great Grand Father name was Babe Bahadar he lives in Addra, near 22 No.Chungi. In 1984 5 sikhs came to meet my Grand father (Master Fazal), I asked who r these sikhs My G.Father told me that he is Harnam Singh. Than he said in 1947 Me & My father saved 2 Sikh families from murder very bravely. Harnam Singh was a kid he has 1 brother and 3 sisters.On death bed , his father told him to say thanks to Master Fazal for saving our life, honour and money. So when Harnam came to Punja Sahib , he visited our house as well to say thanks from his father side.

[@zulfiqargilani]

This is a sign of high quality. Glad you shared this story. Stay Safe. Please remember me whenever you feel free, it gives courage. Thank you very much sir.

[@user-or9tg2hb3p]

As a pakistani as a Muslim as a pothwari i am very sorry to my Sikh brothers and sisters for this massacre 😢

[@zulfiqargilani]

Yes, we have to be sorry for this

[@sukhdevsingh295]

It was was emperial powers to straight to divide and rule for which people of India and Pakistan are still suffering salaam bhai

[@ranbirsinghbeer8696]

Thanks for highlighting the truth and reality. This is the quality of a true muslim.

[@rajasajjad8009]

%%^31^%%%22222222​@@zulfiqargilani

[@nishigupta3336]

aapne sorry bola its very gud sir....aapme mein sach accept karne ki himmat hein sir...jo ho gya hein ab use bhul hi jaana chahiye...wo.daur aisa hi tha...aane wale samay mein aise hatyakand dobara naa ho ye ham sabko sochna chahiye warna har dharam ke massom log maare jate rahenge aur insaniyat ka khoon yoon hi hota rahega.. sabse jyada atyachaar to hinduon ne hi jhela hein shanti bani rahe usi mein sabki bhalayi hein india and pakistan apne past ko.bhulkar ab aage badhe...😢😢

[@majeedvlogs1245]

سبحان اللہ سر پہلے تو آپ کے انداز بیاں سے متاثر تھے لیکن اب آپکے حق گوئی کے بھی معترف ہو گئے ہیں دعا ہے کہ اللہ پاک اپنے محبوب آقائے دو جہاں رحمت للعالمین صلی اللہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم کے صدقے آپ کی حفاظت فرمائے آمین ثم آمین

[@zulfiqargilani]

بہت شکریہ جناب۔ اللہ تعالیٰ آپ کو بھی اپنی حفظ و امان میں رکھے۔

[@gurmeetverma8027]

Well said gilani sahab from 🇮🇳 india

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thank you so much dear

[@rosesareredvioletsareblue2012]

Very Balanced approach for narrating history. Very well done !

[@zulfiqargilani]

Glad you liked it

[@raifarooq4096]

شاہ جی میں نے یہ تاریخ پڑھی ہے ۔لیہن اکثر لوگ اس بھیانک سچ کو ماننے کے لئے تیار نہیں ۔شاہ آپ کے اس سچ پہ آپ کو سلام پیش کرتا ہوں ۔ مسلمانوں کے ماتھے پہ لگا ایک بدنما داغ ہے ۔ اور آپ کو یہ بھی معلوم ہے کہ تھوہا خالصہ کے اس قتل کے بدلہ میں کتنے مسلمانوں کو جانیں قربان کرنا پڑیں ۔اور کتنی مسلمان بیٹیوں کی عصمت دری ہوئی ۔ بہرحال میں تو کم از کم آج تک اس تاریخ پہ شرمندہ ہوں ۔ شاہ جی آپ پہ فخر ہے

[@zulfiqargilani]

سر صرف شرمندہ نہیں، میں تو باقاعدہ رو دیا تھا۔ یہ بھی درست ہے کہ ہم مسلمان سچ برداشت نہیں کرتے۔ اس وی لاگ پر میں نے بہت گالیاں کھائیں۔ اپنے مسلمان بھائیوں سے۔ کسی نے مجھے ہندووں کی اولاد کہا تو کسی نے سکھ کا خون۔ میرے سید ہونے پر شبہ کیا گیا۔ اس کے بعد میں نے جسڑ ریلوے اسٹیشن اور بسنتر نالہ کے وی لاگ کیے اور انہیں دلائل سے جواب دیا جس پر اور گالیاں پڑیں۔ کبھی موقع ملے تو وہ وی لاگز بھی دیکھیے گا۔ تبصرے کا بہت شکریہ۔ خوش رہیں، سلامت رہیں۔ Jassar Railway Station Basantar Nala

[@asimzahoor3626]

گیلانی صاحب بہت ہی درد ناک واقع معاہدہ نہیں توڑنا چاہئیے تھا

[@zulfiqargilani]

نہایت تکلیف دہ واقعہ ہے یہ ہماری تاریخ کا

[@taraknathsingh918]

U changed by whole perspective toward the incident... Thanku sir. Love from India. I understood that nobody here or there is bad but politics.

[@zulfiqargilani]

You are absolutely right. People want to get together, but if that happens, where will politics go?

[@jasha9sandhu]

This genocidal incident by the then muslim leagis of the Punjab set in motion the bloodbath of 1947.

[@rajashahid8812]

Gailani Sb very exceptional historic vedio on this region, I have ever watched. I really appreciate your efforts. Narratoon given in Rawal Raj of Sajjad Azhar conflicts in some incidents like you have told that the first woman jumped in the well was a sikh servant whereas Sajjad says that she was Lajawanti wife of Gulab Singh. Will you please share references of info incorporated in this video.

[@baljeet-sandhusingh3369]

Thank you so much, GILANI SAHIB.

[@zulfiqargilani]

You are most welcome

[@ghulamfarooq6606]

گیلانی صاحب زبردست کاوش۔ تاریخی مکامات میں پہلی بار اتنی اچھی معلومات فراہم کرنے کا شکریہ۔

[@zulfiqargilani]

بہت شکریہ جناب

[@arshadhussainae2495]

گیلانی صاحب بہت بہترین تجزیہ excellent work

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thank you so much sir

[@waheedkhan8881]

For the first time ever since the partition you told the truth you are highly Appreciated

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thank you very much. There are so many which I will keep presenting from time to time.

[@VOLTRON999]

@@zulfiqargilani most of the stories are fake , the real culprits were non muslims who killed atleast a million moslims during migration , islam and me zindabad paindabad

[@VOLTRON999]

@@zulfiqargilani moslims nay is leyay attack keya kah non muslims nay jis bay dardi say moslims ka qatlay aaam keya tha woh app imagine bhe nahi kar saktay , thats why moslims also took revenge but in comparison moslims never harmed too much but non muslims martyred atleast more than a million people during partition would you like me to show you the statistics

[@sohailrehan2u]

It was really a very unfortunate event. During the era of partition in sub continent, it was Rawalpindi the very first city where the Hindu Muslims clashes erupted. However, later the hindues and Sikhs carried out organized massacre against Muslims throughout the India. The incident of Amratsar is worth mentioning in this context

[@amancheema9123]

@@sohailrehan2u it was tit for tat started happening to take revange from each others and peoples were forget totally humanity that time.

[@miralfatima]

I just came across your channel and loving all videos I've seen so far. Truly unbiased reporting in this vlog.

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thank you very much. This is a big compliment for me.

[@MK-qn5xo]

Came across your channel for the first time and immediately subscribed it as there are very few channels with seriouse contents. My appreciations to you. 1947 میں جو کچھ سرحد کے دونوں طرف ھوا ، انسانیت عرصے تک منہ چھپا کے روتی رھے گی۔ بلکل اسی طرح کا واقعہ سر ھند شریف میں پیش آیا تھا جب بہت سی مسلمان عورتوں نے آپنی عزتیں بچانے کے لیے کویں میں کود کر خودکشی کر لی تھی ۔ عطا الحق قاسمی صاحب نے اپنی کتاب ھند یاترا میں اس دردناک واقعہ کا تفصیلی ذکر کیا ہے ۔

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thanks a lot Dear sir. It's not only pleasure but also honor for me that you found it worthy to subscribe. جی سر یہ تباہی دونوں طرف سے نازل ہوئی تھی لیکن افسوس کی بات یہ ہے کہ ہم اپنی ہٹ دھرمی کے باعث آج بھی اپنی کسی غلطی کو تسلیم کرنے کے لیے تیار نہیں۔ اس وی لاگ پر مجھے گالیاں بھی سننے کو ملیں اور مجھے سکھوں کا بھائی تک بنا دیا گیا۔ میرے سید ہونے پر شک کیا گیا اور کہا گیا کہ اپنا ڈی این اے کراو، تم اندر سے ہندو یا سکھ ہو۔

[@MK-qn5xo]

@@zulfiqargilani what else were you expecting from an intolerant society? Don't be dishearten, keep separating facts from fiction. Seriouse minded people will always be with you. Best regards.

[@zulfiqargilani]

thank you very much for encouragement

[@munawarrafiq37]

Very informative video. Audio and video quality is excellent.

[@zulfiqargilani]

Much appreciated ۔۔۔

[@sukhdevsingh295]

Salute 🙏 it was imperial divide and rule. Such places should be developed as partition museums so that future generations can learn a lesson from the past salaam and sat sri akal🙏.

[@zulfiqargilani]

Sat Sri Akal bro, your suggestion is very good but who will do it?

[@sukhdevsingh295]

@@zulfiqargilani I think Pakistan sikh gurdwaras management committee can do it easily.

[@sukhdevsingh295]

Brother please start a series of historical sikh shrines in Pakistan based on the gurdwaras which are closed since partition.salaam and sat sri akal​@@zulfiqargilani

[@salmanali3201]

Bohot dard nak video. I am feeling sad for the sikhs, who lost their lives and homeland without any reason.

[@zulfiqargilani]

Yes it was heart-wrenching

[@shoukatalisoomro7056]

goood comment bhaijaan for sisters 8/11/22 🌻⭐🌼

[@lalaland1069]

it wasn't their home they occupied it after ranjit singh attacked and captured Punjab

[@amancheema9123]

@lala land they were son of this soil. They didn't convert to invaders religions .

[@muhammadafzal496]

I agree with you

[@abdulmujeebkhan7268]

ماشاءاللہ بہت تاریخی معلومات دی گیلانی صاحب اپنے ۔ الله آپکو جزائے خیر سے نوازے آمین واقعی زیاد تیاں دونوں طرف سے ہوئ ہیں۔

[@zulfiqargilani]

بہت شکریہ جناب۔ تالی کبھی ایک ہاتھ سے نہیں بجتی۔ جہاں جس کا زور چلا، اس نے مارا۔

[@samsudden66]

buhut shukriya I am a history buff myself and like to visit places, quite a few of your Vlogs are of places i have been , but this was a new one, really eye opening.

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thanks a lot

[@tahirwaseemchaudhry]

ماشااللّہ گیلانی صاحب آپ ہم کو واپس تاریخ میں اس خاص وقت اور مقام تک لے جاتے ہیں جب وہ تاریخ بن رہی تھی خوش رہیں صحتمند اور اللہ پاک کی بے حساب رحمتوں کی آپ پر بارش برستی رہے تاریخ کے ایک ادنیٰ طالب علم کی حیثیت سے آپکے تمام وی لاگ ہمارے لیے اور آنے والی نسلوں کے لیے قیمتی سرمایہ ہین❤❤❤

[@zulfiqargilani]

اللہ آپ کو جزائے خیر دے اور آپ کی دعاوں کو تاثیر بخشے۔ میں آپ کا بے حد شکر گزار ہوں

[@iqbalmohammed51im]

Very sad.. Prayers for the sisters... Who have committed suicide... Cruel world...

[@zulfiqargilani]

yes, it was very sad. With you in prayers.

[@rubinalatifpoetry1141]

Beshak very sad

[@zulfiqargilani]

@@rubinalatifpoetry1141 Yes, it is

[@harmitbharaj7598]

Very sad indeed - sadly - the alternative - was rape - or forced marriage etc - women perhaps knew it too - not saying - the accesses - were one sided.

[@muhammadsuleman9328]

One side stories in Delhi basti nazamdin mah hazart khuja nazamdin mah ek talaab hy wahan Muslim woman NY apni izat save ki thi Delhi KY muslimano KY Sath zulam hova tha 👍

[@murtazashah6046]

Good v logue by Gilani Sahib! I am interested in such historical videos. Quite informative and a lesson for us all.

[@zulfiqargilani]

Your words are so encouraging for me. Thank you very much.

[@nailabushra1139]

بہت ہی اعلی وی لاگ ہے۔۔ایک ویران تاریخی جگہ دیکھ کر عجیب سا احساس ہوا۔۔ اب ایسی بھری پری آبادیاں ہیں کہ ایسی جگہیں خال خال ہی نظر آتی ہین۔۔

[@zulfiqargilani]

کل کی آبادیاں آج کی ویرانیاں ہیں۔ ذرا سوچیں کہ ہم نے آج جو کچھ آباد کر رکھا ہے، آنے والی صدیوں میں یہ ہوں گی بھی یا نہیں۔

[@binayshukla7706]

Gilani sab I salute u for fair talk. No matter whoever is killed, hindu Or dikh, it's any way human blood. Let's teach our generation the lessons of humanity.

[@zulfiqargilani]

Humanity always comes before religion, so I prefer that. Whether the oppression is on a Muslim, Hindu, Christian or Sikh, he is a human being first and we should raise our voice for him.

[@aqibali7450]

Hamain mazhab ka naam per juda kr dya warna sb bhai bhai thy.... As per blood relation

[@malikmudassar2620]

P

[@islamicziyarat8203]

اَلسَلامُ عَلَيْكُم وَرَحْمَةُ اَللهِ وَبَرَكاتُهُ‎ اے دوست میں آپ سے بالکل متفق ہوں آپکی ہر بات سچ اور حق ہے ۔ اسلام سچاٸ کا مذہب ہے۔ منافقت اور جھوٹ کا نہیں بیشک تاریخ کو مسخ کر کے پیش کیا گیا ہے اور کیا گیا تھا

[@zulfiqargilani]

وعلیکم السلام جناب آپ کا کہنا سو فیصد درست ہے

[@azmatkhan-uk2sm]

Sad story

[@khaqanbabar5614]

Very nice subscription Gilani Sb. You have explained the whole history in a very logical way. You are absolutely Right to say.. you have said very Right. Totally agree with you.

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thank you so much sir 🙂

[@21hunaid]

Assalam O Aliakum Brother, sir you are doing great work, and giving very informative Sir your talking style and presentation is superb wel done and congratulations

[@zulfiqargilani]

Wa Alekum us Salam So nice of you sir. May Allah bless you.

[@humeraahsen1346]

My father is eye witness of these females dead bodies after migration he saw this well full of dead bodies the words he explains I can't express ... but the way they emigrated and lost their families and belonging haven't any substitutes

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thanks to Allah that I got another witness. The incident was truly heart-wrenching and could hardly be regretted.

[@Playerone1287]

you're a muslim i am confused why did you migrate from their then

[@Playerone1287]

you're a muslim i am confused why did you migrate from their then

[@shakeelbakhsh1649]

Excellent, the loss of human and humanity was the actual loss of this sub contenent , may God bless and save our country Ameen .

[@zulfiqargilani]

You are absolutely right sir

[@scoregamer5423]

Masha Allah 💞 Aaj bohat khushi hui k koi to hai k jis ne sach bolne ka hosla kia...💞 Khush rahain

[@zulfiqargilani]

Bohat Shukriya janab. Yeh sach bolna banta tha warna zameer par bojh reh jata.

[@babaralibebrick2204]

Excellent vlog. I used to visit Choa Khalsa a lot. Is Thoa Khalsa same ad Choa Khalsa, or different pkaces?

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thanks for liking. Yes, Thoha Khalsa and Choha Khasla are different localities.

[@dr.pervezzamurradjanjua7752]

Gilani Sahib, thank you for this informative video and correction of history of this region. In this regard great work has been done by some authors like Dr. Ishriaq Ahmed in his book The Punjab Bloodied. In this context an important aspect is often ignored, why Muslims and Non-Muslims who were living peacefully long before partition of Subcontinent, became hostile to each other. Here colonial rule has played an important role by encouraging different extrimest views and showing inability to protect fundamental rights of the people which, in my opinion, must be emphasized.

[@zulfiqargilani]

I do not deny the divide and rule policy of the British and also agree that all this was a phase of colonial rule but I must say here that our leaders also did not take concrete steps to stop these riots. It is true that they could not go to every village or city and hold anyone's hand, but it is also a fact that on March 3, 1947, Master Tara Singh raised anti-Pakistan slogans and the very next day in Lahore and Amritsar, Muslims attacked non-Muslims. At that time, All India Muslim League was there, why did it not take any action, the result of which was that the series continued and the allocation was also erased as to who had taken the initiative.

[@rubinalatifpoetry1141]

Good job thanks

[@zulfiqargilani]

@@rubinalatifpoetry1141 You are most welcome

[@gurpritsingh9840]

Dr Ishtiaq Ahmed is my friend and I translated his classic work into Hindi and Punjabi.

[@ohboyohboy2034]

As a woman my heart broken

[@zulfiqargilani]

It is really heart broken

[@ranaawais-rl2cm]

aur yr bohat bari haqiqat hay sb se pehli train bhi hum muslim ne kati thi aur uskay baad sikhon ne eik ke badlay 3 train muslim se bhari hui kaati meri dadi humain sunaya krti thi vo bhi indian punjab se mifrate kr ke aai thi

[@user-cq8hw3ni7g]

​@@ranaawais-rl2cmshuruwat kyu ki . Kyu marte ho pehle

[@maliksadikhokher7998]

Ranaawais sb shroaat pakistanio ne nai ki hindo ne poori planning kr k dange shro krwaye thay

[@syedimadhaider6684]

Bless you. Truth must prevail.Thank you

[@zulfiqargilani]

You are very welcome sir

[@syedshawkethussainrizvi9503]

Being small minded and stubborn don’t change history what generations before us have done wrong is wrong we just have to admit it

[@zulfiqargilani]

Unfortunately, we refuse to even acknowledge this history without any solid argument.

[@kakoosheikh9934]

Being a Muslim its shameful for me when my non Muslims friends told me about this

[@zulfiqargilani]

Yes, you are right

[@quaidkamal7943]

One thing is ro ne noted that the women committed suicide due to fear. The Muslims didn't even touch them.

[@user-cq8hw3ni7g]

​@@quaidkamal7943😂😂 or rape ka kon bataega . Tabhi suicide kiya

[@MrAzamsamad]

Very nice history, I didn't know before.Thanks for uploading.

[@zulfiqargilani]

Glad you enjoyed it

[@karanjha7117]

Hats off to you for impartial analysis of macabre genocide of humanity . Your neutrality of describing the massacre is highly appreciable . God bless you

[@zulfiqargilani]

My pleasure. Thanks a lot for your appreciation and prayers. Stay blessed.

[@riffatsohail2621]

I also like to explore history events and you told us the most authantic history to viewers. My mother and her parents were also refugees from Dahli to Lahore, she told Sikh and Hindus first started brutally murdered Muslims. When Pakistani Muslims received the dead bodies of their beloved once, afterwards they start killing Hindus and Sikhs

[@zulfiqargilani]

Your parents may be right but the reverse is the case here according to the history. In 1947, the first train of refugees left Peshawar for Amritsar, carrying Hindus and Sikhs, but only dead bodies reached Amritsar. After that, no train could reach Pakistan safely from East Punjab. It was revenge for the exchange. But the confusion is still there that who started this bloodshed.

[@shahidhabibadvocate6946]

رفعت بہن. سچ یہ ہے کہ ہند مسلم فسادات کا آغاز آن علاقوں سے ہوا جو پاکستان کا حصہ بنے. سب سے پہلے راولپنڈی میں ہندوؤں اور سکھوں کی ٹرین پر حملہ ہوا قتل عام ہوا. پھر میانوالی میں یہی درندگی دوہرائ گئ مری میں سکھوں کی لاشوں کے ڈھیر لگائے گئے اور پھر پاکستان میں شامل ہونے والے پنجاب کا کے وہ دو اضلاع لاہور اور گجرات جہاں اکثریت ہندو اور سکھ آبادی کی تھی ان شہروں میں ہندوؤں اور سکھوں پر قیامت ڈھائ گئ. یہاں سے جب لاشوں سے بھری ٹریینیں دہلی امرتسر جالندھر گئیں تو پھر سکھوں اور ہندوؤں نے وہاں جوابی قتل عام کیا. کبھی بھارتی اتھلیٹ "ملکھا سنگھ" کے بارے میں پڑھیں جو ضلع مظفر گڑھ کے گاؤں فرید پور سے اپنے سے بڑے 7 بھائیوں کی لاشیں چھوڑ کر اکیلا نابالغ بچہ بھارت گیا. یہ ین کا نہیں انسانیت کا بٹوارہ تھا. میں مسلمان ہوں پاکستانی ہوں میرے بزرگ بھی ہندوستان سے ہجرت کرکے آئے تھے

[@shahidhabibadvocate6946]

@@zulfiqargilani درست فرمایا گیلانی صاحب

[@anirudhparashar5468]

@@zulfiqargilani hats off to you Sir, It need guts to accept the reality too.

[@ZahidHussain-ft2py]

I have visited this site. Reportedly during 1947, this was the beginning of communal massacres in the indo-pak partition... Unfortunately.

[@zulfiqargilani]

Yes, unfortunately, this is an ugly fact.

[@nusratullahkhan4380]

True,"this was the beginning of communal massacre in the Indo-Pak partition.... precisely.

[@advmahboobhussain]

What is age 1947

[@mirghulambaloch262]

Very nice of you GILANI Sahab revealing the truth of fact Thank you.

[@zulfiqargilani]

You are most welcome sir

[@KAButt]

Masha Allah. Gilani Sahab, your Vlog came after a long time, so please keep loading very often. I think you remember me, I am Ahmed Butt originally from Rawalpindi currently in New York. Anyway I totally agree with you about our tailored history. Thanks for uncovering the truth. I like you Vlog and especially this one. Ahmed Butt New York, USA

[@zulfiqargilani]

How can I forget Ahmed Butt, New Yorker. Maybe you saw my vlog after a long time but I uploaded them regularly. You may watch my new log after every 4 days. This is fixed schedule, if there is no emergency. Thanks for watching, liking and commenting on video. Also grateful that you showed strong agreement with this "Black Truth" which I revealed in this vlog.

[@KAButt]

@@zulfiqargilani O.K. you may be right, I did not happen to see your Vlog because of a couple of reasons, one of them is I work and hardly get enough time, 2ndly I just see news about Imran Khan and that's it. But I will start watching from now on regularly but cannot promise to watch every Vlog. Anyway I wish you all the best and Pray I come to visit Pakistan soon then will meet with you in person In-Sha Allah.

[@b.mehmood5724]

Harsh facts. History takes revenge itself . Tribel areas could never get settled and their women are living one of the most miserable lives.

[@zulfiqargilani]

Agreed

[@amancheema9123]

It's revenge by Almighty.

[@onthego7029]

ye bc kabaili aj kuty k zndge jee ry han

[@arkykhan508]

Same fate the Sikhs and now the ppl of Punjab have been suffering ... So history took revenge from them as well ??

[@arkykhan508]

Very racist comments don't expect someone like you appreciating such racist remarks ...

[@zamirhasan1350]

انتہائی افسوس اس اقدام پر اور ان پر جن کی وجہ سے خواتین نے یہ قدم اٹھایا 😭

[@zulfiqargilani]

جی یہ افسوس ناک واقعہ تھا

[@kakoosheikh9934]

Ye wohi pathan thy j8nko Pakistan ki books me bht bhadr ghurt mnd likha jata hy

[@waseemhaydar]

❤❤❤❤❤ ماشاءاللہ بہت زبردست ویڈیو ہر ویڈیو کی طرح اللہ تعالی آپ کے علم میں اور زیادہ اضافہ کرے آمین Greetings from Italy and Pakistan ❤

[@zulfiqargilani]

بہت شکریہ جناب، خوش رہیں ہمیشہ

[@waseemhaydar]

@@zulfiqargilani You are welcome always 😘 Greetings from Italy

[@ahmednaveedzafar2257]

Sir I have watched your all Vlogs. You way to describe history is excellent. I wish to meet you some time. Keep it up please....May Allah Pak bless you.

[@zulfiqargilani]

So nice of you

[@MunawarHussain-cc1oc]

مسلمانوں کو شہید کیا گیا تھا نا کہ قتل کیا گیا تھا اور شروعات سکھوں نے کی تھی اور آپ کی باتوں سے سکھوں سے ہمدردی چھلکتی نظر آ رہی ہے Anyway nice n informative video........

[@rajamaqsoodkhan4190]

jinab is main hamdardi ki baat nhi hai sachai ki baat hai tareek ka koi mazab nhi hota aaj kal tu har cuntry main apni hi tarik banai jati hai

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thk kehtay aap

[@zulfiqargilani]

مہاجرین کی سب سے پہلی ٹرین ہندووں اور سکھوں کو لے کر پشاور سے امرتسر روانہ ہوئی تھی لیکن جب وہ امرتسر پہنچی تو اس میں صرف لاشیں تھیں۔ اس کے بعد جواب کے طور پر امرتسر سے جتنی ٹرینز لاہور آئیں ان میں بھی صرف لاشیں تھیں۔ یہ ادلے کا بدلہ تھا۔ مجھے آپ کی بات پر افسوس ہوا کہ ظلم بھی مسلمان کریں اور آپ ایک مسلمان پر یہ الزام لگائیں کہ آپ نے اسے ظلم کیوں کہا۔ یہ مناسب نہیں سرکار۔

[@MunawarHussain-cc1oc]

@@zulfiqargilani ان باتوں میں کتنی سچائی ہے اللّٰہ کریم بہتر جانتا ہے کیونکہ ہم اس وقت نہیں تھے اس قتل عام میں دماغ ہندو کا تھا اور فرنٹ پر سکھ تھے شاید آپ کو معلوم ہو۔۔۔۔۔ یہود و نصارٰی مسلمانوں کے کھلے دشمن ہیں

[@damagehasbeendone4814]

شاہ جی۔۔۔لاکھوں لوگ بے گھر ھوئے۔۔۔ٹرین بھری لاشوں کی ۔۔۔خواتین مسلمان آج بھی سکھو نے بزور بازو ان کو رکھا ھوا ھے اور اس کی شروعات سکھو اور ھندو نے کی تھی۔۔۔ بحرحال یہ تاریخ ھے جس کو بیان کرنا پڑتا ھے۔۔جیسے ھوا۔۔۔۔

[@ferozshah6305]

your direct and straight forward commemts corAgeous remarks jeo shahji

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thank you very much

[@84manjit]

Thanks Gilani sahib I was waiting for this vedio

[@zulfiqargilani]

You are most welcome 😊

[@rabiashaheen3323]

Thanks Bhai bht achi lgi video first time dekhe achi lgi like or subscribe b kr leya thank you ❤🇵🇰👍

[@zulfiqargilani]

Bohat shukriya aap ka

[@rabiashaheen3323]

@@zulfiqargilani shukriya tu Ap ka 🇵🇰❤

[@shaikhyamin2921]

Very honest and true part of history you narrated Keep it up Good luck God bless you

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thank you, I will in sha Allah

[@qwuipafhg]

AA , Gilani shab , hope you are doing well, as you mentioned in this vlog that it was tribals who involoved in this attack. Here who you mean exactly from the tribals?, I would appreciate if you could give us the reference of the book or articles where it written that the attacker were not local from Rawalpindi but outsider ?

[@zulfiqargilani]

Wa Alekum us Salam No need of any book sir, Thoha Khalsa is 40/45 km from Rawalpindi, go there and see everything with your own eyes. By the way, it is also mentioned in the history of Rawalpindi & Pothohar

[@sukhimehta183]

Great documentary!!!

[@zulfiqargilani]

Glad you enjoyed it

[@shaikhbadar2830]

Masha Allah Gillani SB!You are great. I salute you right from the core of my heart for your marvelous truth based research. Hats off 👍👍👍

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thank you very much for your appreciation

[@syedtaqi6122]

Shah sahib, Salam from another Syed brother to you. Thanks for a very sad chapter of tragic episode. Very sorry that it happened and how innocent women were forced to commit suicide, I wish that it had never happened and we owe an apology, just like several massacres of Muslim men & women took place in East Punjab, two wrongs don’t make right, it’s high time for acknowledging the wrongs and moving forward. For a first, we should respect the places of worship of Sikhs & Hindus which were left behind, preserve them and then launch an effort to find the Kins of folks who lived there before partition, and invite them to visit their ancestral lands and this needs to happen on both sides. Peace and love for all.

[@zulfiqargilani]

Kiss to Salam of Syed with my eyes You are right, but I don't think that we are mature enough to admit our mistakes. What happened in Thoha Khalsa is a shame for us as Muslims but we still insist that what Sikhs did was wrong while we are completely innocent. What should happen is to learn from the mistakes of the past, forget them and move forward, but this is not happening. We still contend and propagate that history is wrong, only that we are right. You probably have no idea that for making this video, I was abused in the comments, doubted that I am Syed, called brother of Hindus and Sikhs and even wrote that I am working on a special mission. How can I hope that my nation will come to the right path, forget the past and move towards new destinations? Just pray My Brother. Stay blessed..

[@syedtaqi6122]

@@zulfiqargilani Salam Shah sahib, and with Darood o Salam on our beloved Prophet (PBUH) and upon his AAL. It’s natural for us SYEDs to raise our voice against injustice and tyranny, weather it was Karbala or any injustice and wrongs done, against anyone, regardless of which religion they belong to. It’s very unfortunate that we build false narratives and expect the rest of the society to keep on following those falsehoods. I live in states and know lots of Sikhs and find them very honest, hardworking, and above all, very loyal. I believe in building bridges. Peace ☮️

[@muhammadrizwankhan8453]

بہت بہت خوب گیلانی صاحب۔ آپ نے دل خوش کر دیا۔ اتنا دلچسپ وی لوگ بنایا کہ پورا کا پورا مکمل انہماک سے دیکھا۔ ٹھیک کہا آپ نے ہماری تاریخ کو مسخ کیا گیا ہے۔ میرا بھی یہ ہی ماننا ہے کہ ظلم۔دونوں طرف سے ہوا۔ ایسا ممکن ہی نہیں کہ صرف ہندو یا سکھوں نے ہی مارا کاٹا ہو جب کہ صدیوں سے ساتھ رہنے والے تینوں مذاہب آخر کیسے ایک دوسرے کے دشمن ہو گئے؟

[@zulfiqargilani]

بہہت شکریہ کہ آپ نے میری بات کی تائید کی لیکن ان تینوں کو آپس میں باقاعدہ لڑوایا گیا اور یہ کارنامہ انگریز نے انجام دیا

[@lalaram6900]

You r appreciable. My heart is sobing to learn this incident. Very sad

[@zulfiqargilani]

Yes, it was really very sad

[@mrahmed6534]

Mashalah terrific shah g or team ko salam thank ❤

[@zulfiqargilani]

Your comment is my asset.

[@ismaildogar9398]

Really informatiry logs... .great work Gilani sab salute you....

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thank you very much

[@junaidtahir5597]

بہت اعلی جناب بہت ہی پروفیشل انداز سے آپ نے سارے واقعات بتائیں۔

[@zulfiqargilani]

بہت شکریہ آپ کا

[@junaidtahir5597]

@@zulfiqargilani You are welcome sir.

[@junaidtahir5597]

یہ جناب سردار پریتھ پال سنگھ ہیں سانحہ تھوہا خالصہ والے واقعے میں یہ بھی اس کنویں میں کودے تھے لیکن محفوظ رہے ان کا تفصیلی اور درد بھرا انٹرویو ۔۔۔ kzbin.info/www/bejne/hqOyfYqHrMhomZo

[@zulfiqargilani]

انہیں کسی نے اپنی پگڑی ڈال کر نکال لیا تھا شاید

[@ghulamrasoolmirza7368]

very informative video about partition. I am much pleased by this video and Gilani sb. Do more like this videos. Thanks

[@zulfiqargilani]

So nice of you sir

[@user-pn2ew8fe8i]

Very good video with honest and balanced translation of history.

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thank you very much

[@ranbirsinghbeer8696]

Thanks for sharing the facts.

[@khurram498]

wow ...great sir

[@zulfiqargilani]

So nice of you sir

[@asifmehmood5868]

Zabardast information Gilani sab

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thank you very much sir

[@mushtaqimam895]

آپ کی حقیقت بیانی کو سلام- جزاک اللہ خیرا

[@zulfiqargilani]

بہت مہربانی آپ کی

[@dr_sikandar_ali6597]

Excellent piece of history. I salute you for your real humanistic perspective. With love from Chawinda ❤

[@zulfiqargilani]

So nice of you. Chawinda is my maternal town and many of my childhood memories are associated with this town. Stay blessed.

[@inmyopinion3843]

Thanks for your independent way of talking From India

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thanks a lot for your appreciation. Lots of love from Pakistan.

[@alir665]

آپ کا بہت بہت شکریہ آپ نے ہمیں تاریخ اس پوشیدہ پہلو سے بھی آگاہ کیا یہ تاریخی ورثے ہیں جو ملکی معشیت کی بحالی میں بھی اہم کردار ادا کر سکتے ہیں اگر ان کو مناسب دیکھ بھال کے ساتھ بطقر سیاحت فروغ دیا جائے آپ کی اس کھوج اور محنت کو سلام

[@zulfiqargilani]

آپ کا بہت شکریہ سرکار۔ میری کوشش یہی ہوتی ہے کہ وہ تاریخ پیش کروں جو ہماری نظروں سے اوجھل ہے۔ میں نہایت غیر جانبدار ہو کر بات کرتا ہوں۔ آپ کے جذبات کی قدر کرتا ہوں اور گزارش کرتا ہوں کہ آئندہ بھی میری غلطیوں اور کوتاہیوں کی نشان دہی کرتے رہیے گا۔

[@shahid4771]

Very realistic approach towards history.

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thanks a lot sir

[@khalidahmed6875]

Zabardast sir ap ny bahut achi video banao ap ka thanks good information to history of 1947

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thank you very much sir

[@zohaibnazar4633]

I salute you sir. I have seen many of your videos but this video proves that you are not only a great person but also an honest journalist.

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thank you very much dear. Stay blessed.

[@syedshawkethussainrizvi9503]

Thank you for this sad facts and story of our past bloody history

[@zulfiqargilani]

You are most welcome

[@takerpk]

I like ur thoughts about history Shah G

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thank you very much

[@IjazKhan-er6fw]

Excellent keep it up. 👍

[@zulfiqargilani]

I will try my best

[@rosesareredvioletsareblue2012]

Bohat achee video , bohat achee baatein ki ,dil ko lagee ,humari history mein humari books mein sirf Musalmano pay zulm hua but such Jo app nay bataya woh meray buzrgoun nay bhee bataya bohat Shukria achee tarhan say history batana k liya takkay hum history say seekhein aur achchay musalman banay hats off to you

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thank you very much

[@AdilKhan-ot9ck]

AoA, Gillani sahib first time apka ye vlog dekha Aur yaqeen Manain dekh kar Aur sun kar kafi Acha laga k apne bari emaandari se review diya k galtiyaan dono tarf se hoi thi na k one sided, anyway keep it up and stay blessed 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@zulfiqargilani]

Wa Alekum us Salam Bohat Shukriya sarkar. Sach bola hai aur be khauf ho kar bola hai. Alhamdollilah. May Allah bless you too

[@KhatamAnNabiyeenLaws]

زبردست۔۔۔بات۔۔کی۔۔۔❤❤❤

[@zulfiqargilani]

بہت شکریہ

[@ifra1610]

Deep Respect and gratitude from India... Sad but true story😢.. Impartial description

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thanks and welcome dear ❤

[@munirkhan3840]

Good zabardast sir.

[@zulfiqargilani]

Bohat Shukriya

[@ziaiddinqureshi6681]

شاہ صاحب آپ کےمتواز ن تبصرےاورانداز تفہیم نے متاثرکیا آپ کی کوشش قابل قدر ھے

[@zulfiqargilani]

بہت شکریہ آپ کا

[@rahimullahmirza3849]

Very interesting

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thank you very much

[@zahoorahmad456]

Wonderful work bro thanks

[@zulfiqargilani]

So nice of you

[@jahangirzafar8105]

Gilani Sahib your comments are reality stay blessed

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thank you

[@shajivk7104]

So fascinating information brother, thnaku

[@zulfiqargilani]

Glad you enjoyed it

[@asyiakhatan5916]

ماشاءاللہ بہت اچھا لگا

[@zulfiqargilani]

بہت شکریہ۔ خوش رہیں، سلامت رہیں۔

[@shoukatalisoomro7056]

very gooood information about thoha khalsa historical places 🌼⭐🌻 08/11/22

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thanks for liking

[@saniarehman1013]

Great work keep it up your videos are very informative and interesting

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thank you very much

[@Dubai-Pak-Studio]

Beautiful vlogging..keep it up

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thank you so much 🙂

[@rizwanqamar1974]

Wonderful vlog. Thank You!

[@zulfiqargilani]

Glad you enjoyed it. Stay blessed.

[@jhonsmithsmith5883]

You are absolutely right Weldon for this vlogs and Thanks for this

[@zulfiqargilani]

Thank you very much