Trans Woman and Lesbian React: Trans vs. Detrans Jubilee Common Ground Episode

[@baconsarny-geddon8298]

There was a time when "every major medical association" supported castrating gay men. The idea that medical concensus is unquestionable (esoecially on diagnoses like trans, which are 100% subjective, with NO empirical diagnosis criteria) is just insane.

[@SuperSarahbop]

There was a time doctors thought women got hysteria and the only cure for that was the doctor inappropriately touching her in a medical setting. Reality was men had no clue about female sexual satisfaction and even thought women don’t orgasm.

[@mmmddjsj4696]

Being trans is not subjective. Have you heard of the Reimer case?

[@QCCatPlanes]

​@@mmmddjsj4696 Exactly. The mind & the body are intrinsically linked - you can't have one without the other.

[@hadassah6085]

Yeah, they should be doing Exploratory Therapy instead of Affirmative Therapy. All the detrans people I’ve spoken to had trauma or dissociation, body dysmorphia or were just autistic and thought they didn’t fit in with their own gender, but just didn’t fit in because they were autistic. Or there’s people with internalized misogyny or confusion from puberty.. This is why exploratory therapy is important, to find why the Dysphoria is there, what the unconscious reasons are. The biggest one is SA and repulsion to body instead of repulsion to abuser.

[@KurenaiTenka]

And now they're back to castrating gay men again. 🫠

[@baconsarny-geddon8298]

Litetally NO drug is "totally revesable". And puberty- blockers are one of the LEAST "reversable" drugs you could name.

[@PossibleBat]

I was on cortisone/steroids from 18-25 because I have a genetic autoimmune disorder and I have osteoporosis because of it. These people don’t understand how LUCKY (but IDEAL) that is being born healthy. Medication is a drug and as almost everything on this planet is has a side a and a side b, pros and cons.

[@mmmddjsj4696]

Tell me you don’t understand how enzymes work without telling me you don’t understand how enzymes work. Many drugs use reversible inhibitors to impact enzymes within the body, which as the name suggests is reversible. The Mayo Clinic has great studies on how the puberty blockers are reversible and have relatively standard side effects which can be offset.

[@baconsarny-geddon8298]

@@mmmddjsj4696 I have an AMAZING deal on a slightly used bridge that is JUST PEEFECT for somebody like you... The most popular brand of puberty-blockers ('Lupron') has such bad side-effects, that decades before it's off-purpose use chemically stunting the normal, natural development of healthy children, in the name of "just a social construct" (and based on ZERO empirical evidence that the child has any medical issue, at all), back when it was a cancer drug for 200lb adults, not 90lb 10yo's, it almost got bamned, for it's astronomical rate of severe side-effects. In other applications, it's deliberately used FOR THE PURPOSE of chemically sterilizing people.

[@atyboony6941]

​@@baconsarny-geddon8298 you do know puberty blockers have been used on cis kids since the 80s right? For them to be able to live their puberty at the right time

[@baconsarny-geddon8298]

@@atyboony6941 Yes. They are used for precocious puberty, which is a condition BASED ON EVIDENCE that the child has a PHYSIOLOGICAL NEED for the drug... Which is different from giving it to kids in PERFECT PHYSICAL HEALTH, based on no evidence at all. They also give children open-heart surgery. So that makes it A-okay to slice open a kid's chest, when ALL EVIDENCE says they're perfectly healthy, right? Coz they do the surgery on OTHER kids (those with evidence-based heart problems), so that's TOTALLY THE SAME as doing it, based on no evidence at all, right? Do you even THINK about what you're saying? Or do you just parrot whatever you're told? Why is it so vital to make these children (superfically appear to) conform to gender stereotypes, anyway? What's wrong with just LETTING a little boy wear dresses, and play with dolls? Why can he only wear dresses and play with dolls AFTER you chemically mutililate him, and make this perfectly physically healthy child, is made drug-dependent, for life? You understand this ideology is actually ENFORCING the gender stereotypes that it pretends to "oppose", right?

[@saiyamoru]

I think the social media factor is a huge aspect of why we're seeing a spike, specifically in teenagers, of people who want to transition. When I was a teenager, I wouldn't wear skirts or 'girly' clothes because I hated my body, I cut off all my hair in middle/high school, I roleplayed as a guy online (complete with a named alter ego), and I was deeply depressed, self-harming, and suicidal. If online trans spaces had been something I'd known about, I would have been an active participant. If gender dysphoria had been a commonly seen diagnosis in the 2000's, I would have received it. It took me until I was in college to actually embrace the body I was born into and enjoy being a woman. Kids go through phases, but also kids crave acceptance. Trans-positive online communities give them a space that is incredibly accepting and affirming, and it provides a very simple explanation to feeling uncomfortable in their bodies or unaccepted by their irl communities.

[@scarlet12234]

I'll never understand how people could think it's not harmful for a child's development to stop their puberty. In the case of precocious puberty I get it, because that's happening when it isn't supposed to. But stopping a puberty that's happening right on track? They don't think that will have harmful effects on the brain at the very least even if they go off the blockers later? I mean I'm not a doctor and I'm not sure that any studies show this to be the case, but it seems logical to me to assume that it might have that kind of effect. If you stunt a child's development in other areas it can fuck them over for life even if you try to correct it later, and we do know this for sure.

[@Jasminestealth1]

The argument of what is "real" what is "wrong" for the same problem seems weird - a person who it can effect the rest of their lives - is same concept as early puberty - AKA - not ready

[@silentscreams3776]

I think Samantha Lux and Blair White should debate. They both claim to be trans, but definitely have different views.

[@Fuzz82]

I agree. They have different views. But Samatha is capable of a reasonable debate. Unlike some others who Blaire debated with.

[@str.nickxx]

​@@Fuzz82 I agree with you so much. She may have different view points but can deliver them in a very logical way.

[@MsJimmysgirl]

I love how the adults that never went on blockers and doesn't know or care about their devastating effects, think it's ok to use them. I also don't like the way the Trans attacked Lukas parents blaming them for her situation instead of the medical system.

[@SuperSarahbop]

Yeah particularly because Luka said the doctor emotionally manipulated her parents with untrue statements that not doing the surgery would make Luka self end.

[@BarbieThee]

They did blame the medical system 💀😂 Samantha lux literally told Lukas that it sounds like her doctor took advantage for her & feels sorry for what she went through & that’s the case alot doctors are just money hungry who will do any procedure just to get paid everyone in the community knows this

[@alicianieto2822]

If the parents had banned hom from transitioned and he had run away to be allowed they would have been blamed too, or if their ban had resulted in him not finding out that he was not trans and transitioning and regretting it later, or if he had turned out to be trans. Especially the mother let me tell u. Good old Freudian misoginy

[@taeyongscheeks]

8:11 the moment I listemed to him, what I got was that he is ok with puberty blockers and such but not actual surgeries. That you can start the process earlier but that the surgery later on, when they are adults. I am sorry I just stopped the video to write that.

[@tpara527]

They should provide a class in high school regarding the history of medicine. People like to point to support from the medical community as the standard of safety. The medical community also supported smoking and lobotomies.

[@SuperSarahbop]

Should be a class that goes over medically ideas that where thought to be true at the time , but where later on proven to be quackery. Thinks like hysteria and lobotomies.

[@1voiceCriesOut]

...and balked at the idea of washing hands after dealing w/diseased people then going to deliver babies

[@1voiceCriesOut]

7:52 imagine the trauma her children experienced when she decided she wanted to be their "father"...so much confusion I'm sure

[@rebeccaspratling2865]

Exactly! Like just call yourself birthing person if mother makes you disphoric. Father is the one who contributed sperm and didn't birth them.

[@DanielleStarry]

@@rebeccaspratling2865 Flame Monroe's kids call her "Mama Daddy" because they know their mother birthed them, and they know Flame Monroe is their biological father. She has a really unique perspective and outlook, pronouns are he/she/we lol

[@rebeccaspratling2865]

@@DanielleStarry I love that.

[@shadow.banned]

They victimblamed Luka and her parents. That was not kind at all. It was ugly and exactly what Luka was talking about with the community shunning people like a cult.

[@byeebitch]

They gaslighted her. Since she's not a benefit to trans people and also trans people can't benefit off of Luka. Hence why she received the rude attitude, hostile and aggressive approach from them, especially from Samantha and Arisce or whatever. Imagine saying 'you needed a second opinion' to someone's own opinion...

[@Robisquick]

It’s because their opinion is shaped by their fragile ego, which is super fragile for trans.

[@AmericanAmy]

I love me some shapeshifter he’s kind and patient member. Trying to learn he doesn’t get angry. He knows a lot of us don’t know and we’re trying to understand. I highly recommend his channel. Of course I recommend both of your channels to watch both of you also.

[@fadalerabrasool3563]

when I see shape he always geniunely looks sad the whole time reliving his experience and the mistakes he made. I feel so terrible for him

[@AmericanAmy]

@@fadalerabrasool3563 🙏❤️😢

[@MsJimmysgirl]

I wish that the liberal vs conservative transgender middle ground could have been as productive as the trans vs detrans episode was. It just seemed that as soon as the liberal's saw Blaire was there, they just wanted to tear her down with their constant attacks on her and her career. I saw her react to the video that Blossom, Alexander and Shawn made about the episode and the lies that were being said by Blossom was crazy.

[@Mishalace]

It is the Q part that is a huge issue. I feel like the Q is more personality and I shouldn't be forced to like their personal behaviors and choices. I support LGB, that can't be helped. I support everyday trans folk who are chill.

[@janinebrittanica4314]

The Q seems to be all about dismantling societal mores and being 'different'. When someone says they're queer, it could mean 100 different things. Most queer-identified people often seem to just be individuals with bizarre personal aesthetics or fetishes. I would really like someone to explain to me why the Q is recognized.

[@lizzeltired2155]

Most Qs are straight white women with colored hair (mostly blue). They are usually dating or married to men but say that bc they are Q they are not in a st8t relationship. What does Q even mean??? And lesbians (I am lesbian) are using Q instead of L now to be part of the group. Why are people ashamed to say they are L?

[@GrimrDirge]

Gay is a sexuality, trans is an identity, queer is an ideology. T may or may not be reasonably lumped in with sexualities, but Q has more to do with Gnosticism and Marxism and is parasitizing the others for political power

[@SuperSarahbop]

The Q is a political label it’s not an identity

[@queerplatypus9357]

@@janinebrittanica4314 Think I'll try. ^^ To me, 'Queer' or Q is a nice umbrella term/category that can encapsulate a lot of the non-heternormative identities that don't strictly fall along the lines of 'lesbian', 'gay', 'bi', or 'transgender'. (Examples: Aromanticism, Non-binary identities, Asexuality, Gender fluidity, Polyamory, and much more). Plus, queerness in non-western cultures (and languages) can't always be neatly equated/simplified to the categories of L,G,B, or T. Sometimes 'Queer' can help in translation of terms. (Or as a nice placeholder word). Also, for people who don't know exactly where they fall on the spectrum, are fluid in their identity or have multiple aspects (to their queerness), 'Queer' can be a simpler/better term to use (instead of listing a whole bunch of terms, yanno?) To reduce queerness to the idea of just being different for the sake of being different is shallow in my opinion. So much of the world's cultures revolves around gender (including gender roles & norms), love and sex. People are quick to denounce, reject or vilify those who don't follow the current norm. We shouldn't be made to fit into the small, rigid and currently accepted heteronormative categories . We deserve to be thought about (or at the very least, our existence acknowledged). This label helps in recognition of that. Hope this response wasn't too long! ^^'

[@stevieboyXI]

It occurs to me that there are a lot of sensible trans people out there but they are not being given a platform.

[@mortagon1451]

I'd argue that the majority of trans people are sensible. A lot of the activists aren't really trans. I don't consider "non-binary" to be trans either. To me someone who truly is trans is someone with gender dysphoria and not an identity you can just adapt because it's the popular flavor of the Month. It's making light of a serious mental health issue. I'm not trans, but I'm bipolar and we're seeing the same thing with other mental health problems, people are claiming to have them because it's trendy and victimhood is a great way to get attention and sympathy.

[@realMoMoPuFF]

Kids are just want to belong somewhere and they follow any trend, would do anything not to experience rejection and ridicule. Back in my days, we had nerds, rockers, punks etc. This changed to this.

[@jolie1206]

Hi Sara! As someone leaning more so on the democratic side of things, I really appreciate your viewpoints and videos. Although there may be some things I disagree with, your content keeps me open minded and allows people like me to understand the nuance of situations :)

[@faychel8383]

Shape did so good in this :)

[@arielle]

That face in the first ten seconds hahaha

[@SaraHigdon]

Haha!

[@rebeccaspratling2865]

Lmfao we all made the same face watching that bs that was said. 😂

[@GrimrDirge]

There are a LOT of recent studies which dispute the "life-saving" claims of the transgender lobby. I've tried posting them on KZbin comments but they get auto-removed.

[@GrimrDirge]

​@who's xtina I am at the airport but I will pull them from my Zotero library if I can. KZbin auto-deletes them, even when I pull the DOIs

[@simonw.1223]

​@@GrimrDirge hmmm how could you name it hmmm.

[@winxclubstellamusa]

Where are the studies from? Maybe we can look them up so your comments don’t get taken down this time.

[@lizzeltired2155]

I love your channel. You are so sensible. We need more trans like you to speak up.

[@quitepossiblylucky]

You ladies are freaking awesome!

[@scottowens4162]

fun fact; matt walsh attempted to contact samantha lux for an interview for "what is a woman?". well naturally sam declined and after watching this i know why. it would be like a kindergartener trying to argue with a teacher. that and the fact matt blasted sam so hard in a video that sam still feels it lol.

[@mmmddjsj4696]

Matt also contacted CHILDREN, the man who claims trans people are praying on children also tried to prey on kids himself

[@scottowens4162]

i am guessing you are a child as well and dont understand he is looking at all this from a perspective of a father. sam is a predator who's only reach is children.

[@LucielStarz123]

@@mmmddjsj4696 Contacting children with the purpose of having an open dialogue with them regarding their life experience, Who definitely requires their parent consent, vastly different than dancing sexually in provocative/nude clothing in front of them you dimwit.

[@QCCatPlanes]

I don't see Matt as being a reasonable voice. Having said that however, some of the issues he presents are worth debating.

[@Crysalis-bd9so]

​@@QCCatPlanes I find him reasonable in the face of an unreasonable and immoral movement. He's certainly not for everyone though

[@ELLOUISEBOBBY]

Even Marcie Bowers says stop puberty at tanner stage 2... fertility and sexual development is screwed

[@tashacooper1753]

My sister is like that looking like a boy makes her feel safe

[@xyenyas]

I was the same because I hated being sexualized

[@winxclubstellamusa]

That’s internalized misogyny and trauma that she is disowning and escaping from! I know from experience that no one can run from themselves and their wounds forever, especially a wound like this.

[@Tiffaloni]

Children only know what you tell them. My toddler thinks he a tractor. It’s my job to tell him he’s not a tractor. He’s a human. He’s a little boy.

[@shifterofshape]

❤❤❤

[@legoshirocha]

If trans people were more logical and based like Sarah, Blaire, Buck and Marcus. They’d be way WAY more accepted by society. Thank you for the video ❤️🙏. New Subscriber 😎

[@SuperSarahbop]

If anyone did the inner work towards self acceptance they’d be more accepted by other people as your own feelings about yourself is the real gauge in how people will treat you.

[@nickname2935]

There are many of us. Usually noone notices us, as we are far to busy living a normal life, not involving ourselfs in politics. We really want to keep our medical issue privat and properly treated and that's that. The Q-People politicizing us in all the wrong way is detrimental to our integration into normal society. Either we let them talk, as if we'd agree, or we have to come out, contradict them and become political against our will.

[@raja.kohinoor]

Even Brianna ivy

[@zoozbuh]

You think Blaire White is “logical and based”? Wtf

[@legoshirocha]

@ lol it’s clearly you don’t watch her content it’s just so obvious you don’t 🤣

[@QCCatPlanes]

I'm excited for your collaboration on this reaction vid, ladies!👍 15:00 I love Shape Shifter's 👽🦎 collabs too - he's awesome!

[@via-anghelmagahum2586]

Social media also glorified medical transition, making it seem like it will solve everything and that’s it’s perfect rather than showing that it’s not.

[@AmericanAmy]

5:05 yeah, well leading scientist used to believe in eugenics they used to believe in lobotomies and shock treatment. Hell I think lobotomies and shock treatment still go on sometimes. They were wrong about the vaccine. It might’ve helped, but it sure didn’t prevent.

[@Robisquick]

The change from the stricter definition of the T in LGBT (aka Transsexual) to now include Non-binary has not only widened the gender spectrum but also widened the spectrum of how strongly and seriously one feels attachment to the gender they see themselves ass. Essentially the non-binary element has greatly dilluted the seriousness of transsexual experince to where now people are expected to take an alien-gender person (who switches genders every five minutes and has identities that aren't even a part of the binary or human existence who doesn't have dysphoria) as seriously and compassionately as a transexual person with deeply brutal gender dysphoria and life-long medicalization. I'm not discounting the likelihood that some non-binary trans people have had an equal degree of dysphoria and profound attachment to the gender they see themselves as. But there are quite obviously a shit load of non-binary trans who have almost no euphoria and a tenuous connection to the gender they like to be called. It's like shoving paranoid schizophrenics and over-imaginitive daydreamers under the same label where the overimaginative daydreamers claim that their mental disposition brings on the same degree of social struggle and oppression and deserves to be affirmed and garner equal sympathy. I think our sympathy and respect towards someones identity should be in proportion to how deeply they feel attached to that identity. Otherwise, a change in outfits will soon become an identity that people will think has deeper connotations.

[@vikkidonn]

Samantha is trash on so many levels and it’s actually sad that not many people if any are pointing out or calling out the fact that it almost every turn in several conversations, she singled out and almost attacked Luca and their experience has a B transitioned woman

[@HeartFallenstar]

So refreshing hearing your views I totally feel like I’m just the only person who sees the flaws of so many people now a days in the lgbt community it’s just annoying how you can’t even navigate anymore without just love what happened to the simple days anytime I hang with lgbt people now I feel I’ve nothing to talk about because I usually offend them It’s so fucked up lol

[@reapthewhirlwind4166]

They are always playing the victim so it shouldn't matter if you are offending them or not

[@HeartFallenstar]

That is true! On so many levels, it’s almost like they’re trying to remain relevant lol

[@markrussell3428]

I am actually very disappointed. I watched the full discussion and you skipped through the most painful contradictions. Essentially telling Luka your not trans and your parents failed you for letting the "professionals" remove your breasts. Of course 2 minutes earlier you hear a trans advocate suggest just the opposite, "children have the answer we need to follow them". WHY did you skip that?

[@Erika.D84]

I' m a trans woman. I just finally came to accept myself, alone. At 39. I WISH someone saw me and helped me 25 + years ago before i had to go trough puberty.

[@darcichambers6184]

I feel for the detransitioners, especially feeling like there is no group to call home or have a safe place. I had the same experience in college when I came out as Bisexual. I went to the LGBT club meetings and just felt ostracized, and I was constantly asked to prove I was Lesbian enough to be included in the group. It is time for the LGBT community to recognize that it has a problem with acceptance. 20 years ago, they only wanted gays and lesbians. Now it feels like they only want transgenders and their allies.

[@ohlookitssarah]

Thanks for reviewing it I stopped watching at puberty blockers are reversible and safe.... I can't do much but I can show my values by leaving and not giving my time. But it wasn't much better debate than I imagined it would go. You're right it's hard to disregard people when they're right in front of you.. sad to see people having have the people in front of them to realize that... hopefully realize that

[@LVThN_von_Ach]

We need a D in the LGBTQ, if you even want to keep using that acronym.

[@DankrumStar]

I think part of the issue is we can’t define trans anymore. It used to be black and white, gender dysphoria or not. Tom boys and tom girls are a thing. Some 12 year old girl who likes cars and trucks doesn’t mean she’s trans

[@newfoundland042961]

Me as a post menopausal woman discussing HRT therapy from a doctor. Doctor: "Oh no that is far too risky we don't want to expose you blood clots, stroke, breast cancer etc we want you around for a long long time!" Doctor to trans gender females: "Ya you'll have to take it for life, up to you."

[@ItsSimplyAless]

No hate to Samantha but it felt like she was being condescending at times, for example around 12:15

[@hadassah6085]

I get frustrated when people say puberty blockers are reversible too. If a boy goes on blockers and misses puberty, he will NEVER orgasm because he never went through puberty. I also feel for Shapeshifter who had gender reassignment surgery and now is detrans and on testosterone, but has no outlet for their new healthy level of libido, which is a level of frustration that is hard to imagine how bad that feels. Male sex drive with no male parts.

[@alwaysrunning234]

Priests also live without orgasms. He'll live.

[@gimygaming8655]

@runrunrun OK but why would you want to do that on Purpose to healthy children

[@hadassah6085]

@@alwaysrunning234 your argument is comparing a priests free will choice as an adult, to a child robbed of being an adult that is ever able to have basic sexual function or pleasure. To think this is acceptable or fair comparison is beyond abusive.

[@lameducklol]

@@alwaysrunning234this is an insane take

[@nighttree2]

Big fan of Arielle, but new to your content. I have only watched a few of your video's, but glad to see another voice (especially a Tran's voice) speaking out against the Identity politics we find ourselves entangled in....following ;)

[@cklein4532]

Just wanna let you know, you inspire me Sara, you beautiful person you!

[@damianlafreaux2873]

As a trans man who is actually trans I would have stepped forward on the first question

[@jeannesgm7564]

The transitioners spat in Luka's face hard

[@joecollas9942]

I don't know, it seems like a lot of their answers to the other questions contradict the first question.

[@legolasofmirkwood]

Love you two ❤️

[@ivkafox369]

I love you two together.

[@AmericanAmy]

Seems to meet new medication’s that would help people better align mentally with it the way they look physically I don’t know. Seems like it would be worth a try.😊

[@ArseniyaBlackMetal]

I respect Sara Higdon. ❤❤❤

[@lawyerLoke]

I saw the whole jubilee vid, Ive watched a lot of samantha's videos but she did not come off as a great person in this video xP also, a lot of people seem to dig puberty blockers because they are safe and reversible, well what will they say when they realize that this is not the case? what then?

[@nicknickson3650]

then tons of girls will grow up with facial hair and a lot of boys will grow up with weak bones and micropenises.

[@AmeliaPetrella]

I still don't appreciate people using queer, maybe because I'm older, but it was not a nice word growing up and it doesn't feel "empowering" to take it back it just feels like people throwing around a gay slur. Anybody watch Sling blade.

[@winxclubstellamusa]

Queer is 100% an insult that has turned into being the name for a political identity, it has nothing to do with being a homosexual or bisexual. And what’s worse is that the word is extremely trendy, as is the gender cult, and these people fight tooth and nail against truth and historical and scientific facts, so it’s completely impossible for anyone to reason with them. They don’t care how they are harming the LGB because it is actually their objective to do so! In addition to harming women and children as well. The evidence is irrefutable at this point. Queer means worthless and deranged, which I think describes these extremely misogynistic pedos perfectly.

[@heroncolby2842]

​@@winxclubstellamusa 🤗 Right on point!.

[@winxclubstellamusa]

@@heroncolby2842 thank you 😊

[@heroncolby2842]

@@winxclubstellamusa But where's the comment Now?

[@winxclubstellamusa]

@@heroncolby2842 I can still see it, can you not?

[@MaxItUpwithMarta]

It is sad that there are two sides. Opinions should be respected. Shape is brilliant.

[@eduardomerino8098]

Love you Sara and Arielle. You two need to do a debate with Samantha Lux.

[@simonw.1223]

Who was Samantha Lux?

[@eduardomerino8098]

@@simonw.1223 Th curly haired girl that was acting all sassy and arrogant. I genuinely think she is a good person but the way she speaks, comes off as bitchy and arrogant sometimes.

[@gamzecarsamba6273]

Did you see the video where the good person Samantha defended Wi Spa perv* rt and laughed the women who are afraid of s* xual assault? Pinnacle of goodness!

[@simonw.1223]

@@eduardomerino8098 hmmm I am not sure about that. Like as southpark made the strong women competition episode and Samsntha said that will never happen.

[@eduardomerino8098]

@@simonw.1223 I’m not saying that she isn’t a leftist woke propagandist. But I think she has good intentions but trusts the woke mob too much. Do I disagree with her on a lot absolutely. But I can agree to disagree.

[@SolarStrikeMolecularDragon]

everyone can influence other people good or bad doesn't matter. I wasn't into hockey but as i hung around my friends over time i began to like watch and enjoy hockey. so if your an influencer or talk about certain things to other through videos etc. you need to take responsibility for how you effect others

[@robertocatrone715]

I absolutely love your videos for your straight forward honestly coupled with humor.

[@gmotz9689]

This is so on point. I feel this. It hurts. Thank you.

[@JetTech1992]

I would like to see how these people would react if the others couldn’t see each other

[@millsdeb1]

Thank you for caring about children.

[@promark5317]

See already has the Italian grandmother mustache lol

[@nachtrevi82]

Just tired of hearing this BS about suicides , where were all these kids attempting suicide 10-15-20 years ago? And I hate the condescending tone they're using against Luka , trying to gaslight her at every chance they had .

[@misfitm1457]

Yeah, suicide isn't something people would just do just because they don't get their way. There's hundreds of people unable to get any medical help who go through worse pain and they are just dealing with it

[@gimygaming8655]

@@misfitm1457 exactly.

[@Ashakat42]

I live in NWGA and in a different video you spoke about a bar that seemed lesbian owned. I would love to know where that was. My favorite club in Chattanooga, Images, closed down 2ish years ago and good places are hard to find around here.

[@NickyRikki]

I don't agree with the transgender ideology but I can respect anyone with this life style if they accept facts and women's privacy. Also anyone against this for children as a transsexual has my subscription.

[@juliavargas2870]

This should be watched at High School levels very educational

[@jkscout]

Why wasn't I invited? I wanna hang out in a cabin with y'all?! lol

[@Fee_V]

Sara at 14:13 mins. An excellent thought that requires further exploration.

[@kittensdaddy3559]

New subscriber so I know I'm so late to this video. I doubt anyone will read it as I just subscribed today, but i can't support children getting medical procedures and the hormone treatments or blockers. I am 39 and am what you might call a butch lesbian. I grew up in residential facilities and i was told i had gender dysphoria and when i said no i don't they would talk to me acting like i wanted to be male and i was very defensive. I'm a female I'm happy that way, but had I caved in that Vermont facility, i might have really thought they were right and made mistakes. I felt very pressured and they would say oh you like girls oh you wear male clothes. I was an athletic person so they picked on that too! I am so glad i didn't change my body. I was stunned when non of the trans people sat down for the first question about medical treatment for minors.

[@armaniv6455]

If we went along with the whims and feelings of kids - I still thought I was straight up until 18!

[@Robisquick]

The problem with the cultural trend-fronting and politicization of gender dysphoria, is those who want to work as a psychiatrist to help kids with gender dysphoria will inevitably have a siginificant enough political stance that influences and likely informs the interactions and decisions they make when with their patients. The MOST important thing for a psychiatrist to do is to have as little emotional skin in the game as possible. Their goal is to be as objective and impartial as humanly possible, but with the social norms of self-identificaton and blind affirmation being prominent, it makes engaging with a patient a conflict of interest, not just on the politically possessed psychiatrists side, but also on the patients side who has a head full of leftist lgbtq activism in their heads. And both of these people are inevitably gonna steeer eachother towards the conclusion of diagnosing gender dysphoria. (UNLESS. YOU HAVE AN EXTREMELY CAREFUL AND PROFESSIONAL PSYCHIATRIST)

[@LJ-ln3js]

Thank you for advocating for children. Children's brains are not even fully developed. I support them socially transitioning because it is reversible and they can live that experience but have the option to go back to their gender if they choose. I do have a question... Alexander on Jubilee said Non Binary falls outside of Binary yet isn't Transgender/Transexual on its face or by its very nature, Binary? I don't understand putting them under the same umbrella and conflating the two if thats true. Just trying to understand as the issue of children is an important one and I support Transgender people. When I saw Jessica say on Jubilee that she doesn’t use the female restroom out of respect, I thought, I would share any restroom with her and all of you. I just want all women protected and men not abusing this issue. I saw the video of the spa and knowing young girls were there while in a state of undress at their most vulnerable horrified me.

[@legatobluesummers96]

And notice 2 of those topics everyone both transitioned and detransitioned pretty much saw eye 2 eye on. 1. People with gender dysphoria need therapy not surgery. 2. The LGBTQIA+ is as not as excepting as they claim to be.

[@Ashakat42]

The Durch protocol shouldn't even be considered. It had 55 participants and no control. It was just a beginning not the gold standard of care.

[@orangesnowflake3769]

Omg at 3:40, I had kind of had a similar thing happen to me and then I wanted to look different for a short while to look less attractive to men, I dressed a bit more masculine to try and get more respect from people and to not have men attracted to me sexually but for who I am as a person. I was never trans though and never claimed to be but a woman disguising my femininity

[@aquarius3524]

I'm sorry for what happened to you stay strong ❤

[@tomandjennacali1879]

THANK YOU

[@catherinemiss6360]

Great episode

[@jkscout]

I can't listen to these people lie anymore.

[@TheMoises1213]

I loved this as always. Samantha reacted to trans cons v Lib I think you should check it out

[@hadassah6085]

Unfortunately trans people often quickly dismiss and shut down detrans experience because it scares them.

[@priscillaspets]

You’re awesome! new sub(:

[@lesabri]

The actual surgery is not safe enough. It's ok to keep the parts we were born with while also being trans. Is that idea too wild?

[@nickname2935]

Most transsexuals do not get genital surgery for that very reason. It is incredibly dangerous and the outcome is often not worth it. I mean, you don't walk out that surgery with the opposite full functioning genitalia. You get something that looks approximately alike and hopefully has the bare minimum function.

[@heroncolby2842]

Honestly the entire idea of "tπans" is nonsensical. But this is something even more stupid, a person with gender dysphoria being okay with the genitals that literally define their gender. Like Make that make sense. Let's face it, what most of the so called "tπans" people Nowadays have it's actually autogynephilia. A kink and a obsession with being the opposite gender.

[@shadow.banned]

This audio is a bit wishywashy. Lots of cheap mics available.

[@winxclubstellamusa]

This was obviously an impromptu video. The video is still valuable and enjoyable to watch. The audio is a lot better on headphones.

[@thickfitsteph]

Sara higton is very smart

[@emmapeel8163]

👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 excellent!

[@moonshineblues204]

Allll Gore Ryythm! 💙 Just a comment to pay for my entertainment 💙💙💙

[@Mayson1408]

so, no hate. but you really dont imidietly get help, atleast not in the netherlands, i dont know anything i america. but ive been on a waiting list for two years just to get the therapy to help me get through it, and a lot of trans kids, have suicidal thoughts.. i do too because i dont get help. Im better now, but ive seen the healthcare fail one of my friends aswel, i hope theyre in a better place now.

[@crystalkeara8868]

I’m hoping to move to N. Georgia. from Vermont.

[@ThinWhiteAxe]

okay so this is probably gonna sound weird but I just rememebred i dreamt about u last night, Sara 🤔

[@spalding1968]

Transitioning is false advertising . Everyone knows that nobody transitions at all . What’s actually happening is mimicry . A man can dress like a woman , act like woman and believe he is a woman but the fact is he is and always will be a man . His mental health is always awry because he knows the reality of his situation. And this is why there is such a push to coerce everyone into affirming transgender people to reinforce the falsehood that they can be something that they are not and can never be .

[@gimygaming8655]

Gender dysphoria is a serious illness but they will always keep their biology. Definitely recommend "the offensive tr@nny" because he doesn't deny that he is a woman, but lives is life as a man because of a mental illness. He also doesn't agree with "non binary"

[@Mauriceeeeeeeeeeee]

I want to make a church for ppl you want to detransiton, to join hands with me and see what God really can do🥹🙏🏼 it’ll be one on one praying, family and friendship, my fellow brothers and sisters❤️

[@jucehnn]

😅😅 America is doomed. 😴😴

[@hugostiglitz6823]

40%

[@heroncolby2842]

I think the term "tπans" it's fundamentally flawed. Because in order to validate it one has to subscribe to a idea that simply isn't real or true. So I don't acknowledge the "tπans" term at all any longer. Now what I do is, I referred to people with dysphoria as dysphoric individual's, To be as accurate and truthful as possible. In this case Sarah is by all metrics a Man with gender dysphoria. Not "tπans", he's still a Man. But he is dealing with a psychological disassociative condition that he hasn't overcome yet.

[@TenleyAtwood]

Just here to say Samantha is amazing and beautiful. So is her mom.

[@mmmddjsj4696]

Thank you!! These people don’t understand facts

[@aquarius3524]

So her supporting kids transition so amazing and beautiful

[@mmmddjsj4696]

@@aquarius3524 its healthcare so ya

[@TenleyAtwood]

@@aquarius3524 Damn right it is ✊🏳️‍⚧️💖

[@heroncolby2842]

Samantha is a human Male. So basically that would be a He*... 🤦

[@danshotguns4226]

The correct syntax and grammar to use is.."Erin and myself ". Not "me and Erin." You always put the other person 1st unless you are a complete narcissist. Which transgender people typically are ...you put the other person first.

[@Corion2121]

Shape Shifter’s little gay nervous laugh is so disturbing… 🤨

[@Wild_flower_415]

Your homophobia is disturbing

[@Corion2121]

@@Wild_flower_415 - can you define homophobia for the class? 😐

[@winxclubstellamusa]

That man is an extremely brave warrior for the truth who is putting in back breaking work in order to prevent people from making his same mistakes. He deserves all of the respect in the world. Don’t make fun of him.

[@winxclubstellamusa]

@@Corion2121 how you found a gay man’s nervous laugh to be “disturbing”. That is objectively homophobic.

[@Corion2121]

@@winxclubstellamusa - he did it to himself. That man has two Masters degrees. He was perfectly capable of making his own decisions. 😐

[@Robisquick]

This should be titled “A transsphobe (aka a person who is repulsed or otherwise afraid of trans) and a TERF (someone who doesn’t seek to include trans people in conservations of feminism) react to a Jubilee video.” In case you were wondering how utterly divisive , irrational, contradictory and exclusionary those type of terms are.

[@EmberFlames_Jag]

Lmao someone mad

[@aquarius3524]

You've been brainwashed by the cult of banning freedom of speech and journalism the cult that hates biology and scientific facts and only seek the scientific fake facts of pharmaceutical industry 😊

[@Robisquick]

@@EmberFlames_Jag Nah i'm just being detailed in pointing out the absurdity of calling the lesbian with several trans friends a "terf" and a trans person with several lgbt friends a "transphobe". Which millions of people believe both of them are, which is illogical.

[@EmberFlames_Jag]

@@Robisquick oh I think you were an angry woke person...

[@Robisquick]

@@EmberFlames_Jag Haha yeah definitely not my friend. I couldn't be woke if i tried. Cause it's wrong on so many fundamental levels.