Trooper cross-examined at Karen Read murder trial

[@tammyslade1375]

That dude has absolutely no idea what he’s talking about! They need to go back and investigate every single case he has given his expertise in! 😂

[@brianstark1527]

How to say "I lied on my resume" without saying "I lied on my resume"

[@thewolf5444]

This is the worst "expert" I've ever seen.

[@DMiller912]

This is such a joke. A woman's life is on the line, and this is the prosecution's so-called expert witness! Unbelievable. He's clearly not qualified for this. #free Karen Read

[@ashleydavis5557]

Well said Pal x

[@lisadavie5282]

I love your awesome comment the truth is Energy and energy doesn't Lie ❤

[@ANC2002]

I don't think this dude is qualified to be a greeter at Wal-Mart 😂

[@nyccolm]

Trooper Paul is virtually incomprehensible and completely incredible

[@Really........]

This guy got Einstein and Newton rolling in their graves.

[@pistolpete8231]

😂😂😂

[@adelalmohammadi5695]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@michele1330]

I feel bad for him. Why would they put him in that position? I graduated from high school by the skin of my teeth and I may as well been the accident reconstruction guy! lol

[@pistolpete8231]

@@michele1330 you feel bad for someone who's willing to lie to put an innocent person in prison?

[@radybay9088]

@@michele1330he’s incompetent and his job is to help put people in prison. I feel sorry for all of the people in prison because of his incompetence.

[@catlipe802]

I am 1000% certain, with zero training, I could’ve analyzed the crash scene with more accuracy and “definitity” than trooper paul blart mall cop here 🤡🤡

[@DMiller912]

I know, right...I couldn't believe what I was hearing, LOL

[@DMiller912]

I know, right...I couldn't believe what I was hearing, LOL

[@angelabaird7135]

That was so frikn cringe worthy!

[@noreenmountain2994]

This explanation regarding how he got hit and how those scratches got on his arm was embarrassing. I don't know what happened but this is rediculous

[@MEMELIFEBABY]

The entire cross was cringe worthy.

[@LoLo-zr7bk]

@@MEMELIFEBABYBEYOND!

[@AmyMcLaughlin-xy3pe]

Seriously?

[@MEMELIFEBABY]

@@AmyMcLaughlin-xy3pe yeah, did you not watch it?

[@SendingFreedomTM]

@@AmyMcLaughlin-xy3pehaha yes don’t watch it it hurts 😂 besides all you need to see is the dog expert and two neutral unpaid FBI experts to determine the case. This went on for fucking months and all anyone needed to know Karen was innocent was the FBI experts. Fucking disgusting that the prosecution had they got any real experts they would have and probably did tell them it wasn’t Karen read. Probably why the one they got is so horrible because nobody else would dare look so retarded trying to prove something that is literally so far from possible that you can’t even make it seem feasible ever

[@golfinfool777]

3 times he’s told not to read from the report! Then the judge basically says to the prosecutor to dumb it down for him by asking simple questions.

[@tobydean7097]

And he is paid $130,000 to do this job??? My dog can do a better job!!!!!! 😂😂😂

[@debpratt4692]

No degrees and no certifications a total of 5 weeks over course of years with classes is this like a joke this is unbelievable I'm so glad transparency is becoming a real live entity and our generation because this is embarrassing for this whole department all of them should just resign

[@MEMELIFEBABY]

This dude is a court reporter’s nightmare.

[@michele1330]

It’s heart breaking to watch as a mom. This guy is a mess.

[@ilibili7489]

Sadly, he is Karen Reads worst nightmare given he was the « expert ». And maybe others innocents

[@shemp815]

"What's your theory? "It just did."

[@graysgigi]

😂😂😂😂

[@smokincivsmokinciv9201]

Hows sun set ? How does posi trac work? It just does

[@nyccolm]

Trooper has a lot of nerve to get cocky when he’s so incompetent

[@stephencamara2047]

My boy could of said “Kinematics is the study of tropical fish and how they walk on land” and the “Trooper” would of been like “ahhhhh that’s corwect”

[@angelabaird7135]

😂😅😂😅

[@natesanti]

This guy tried to testify as an expert and has no clue what he’s talking about🤣

[@MEMELIFEBABY]

He testified like he had a gun to his head. Duresstimony.

[@sandrabecht4489]

It is absurd that JO arm broke the taillight

[@MEMELIFEBABY]

@@sandrabecht4489 it’s honestly one of the most, if not the most, inane theories ever put forth in the history of theorizing.

[@MEMELIFEBABY]

@@sandrabecht4489 his arm would have compound fractured in three spots, if not shattered.

[@wendyrudokas]

Oh my god, right?! He kept doing weird stuff with his hands & at one point it looked like he talked into his cuff.. very bizarre.

[@MaryClareVideos]

One of the most bizarre testimonies I have ever seen. 😮

[@graysgigi]

From an “expert”

[@TheOldNewTeacher]

Agreed - so strange.

[@brandonnorris2898]

I was just following orders

[@Jmmw25]

This guy is over his head. Not sure why he’d want to say all of this and embarrass himself. He must owe proctor a favor

[@missstaceyarmes]

Why can’t this judge say “Overruled, answer the question” to the witness instead of “can you answer the question?” !?!?! If it’s not sustained then they need to ANSWER THE QUESTION! 😡 This is ridiculous.

[@lizcummings5985]

Agreed. She is the absolute worst Judge ever. She needs to be replaced

[@Nyabznsk]

You people hate everyone including yourselves that's why you project that hate that promotes harassment of innocent children onto everyone else...Jackson is a jack ass and has you all under his thumb with his false detailed narrative pointing fingers at everyone and there dog when the killer is right next to him smirking and turning her head back and forth like she's so interested in what's happening everytime the camera is on her...They know people like yourselves love reality TV though and got you right under there thumb to the point of leading you on witch Hunts against innocent children.. .All the charades that the Judge and Lally have gone through and put up with, I think they've done a damn good job...so keep staying lost in those weeds that your wizard Jackson got you lost in...Jackson don't have the burden of proof so he don't have to show Any Evidence for the false narrative he created...just photos from FB and videos that show men in a bar fighting that he tries to spin into showing how they are going to murder John...I don't know who is more ridiculous Him or you people...

[@Wesleyclarillos]

Auntie bev you make judges look bad. You are gonna go to fed jail after the fed investigation and they find out you rent your BEACH HOUSE TO THE MCABES/ALBERTS. 51:32

[@SabrinaD-sy5yw]

Absolutely! It’s like she’s treating them like children. So annoying.

[@KimVest]

Can he even read????

[@chadpukaite2905]

Why are us Tax payers. paying for this? I need a Refund!!!!!

[@tammyslade1375]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@logicandreason8090]

driving in reverse for 62 feet at 22 1/2 mph in the snow would require exceptional skill, concentration, and experience to not lose control of the vehicle entirely.

[@Beccaboo502]

All during a blizzard 😂 if so, get this girl in nascar

[@johnsmith-ug5tp]

Yep! And going with the state's assumption Karen did it in a fit of blind rage. Flooring the gas pedal she would have definitely lost control of the car. Oh yeah, and with no proof or evidence, They said, she was hammered drunk on top of it. ha

[@holdmyhalo6752]

I couldn’t do it sober in dry weather. That’s ridiculously fast

[@LeanneRigby-iy7nx]

Whenever I need a good laugh I just have to come back to this video. It only takes a few seconds before I’m rolling on the floor 😂

[@ANC2002]

Me too!!

[@heathermcallister4033]

Why would the victim stand and wait for karen to drive up sixty feet then reverse and back into him and not move...so unbelievable

[@aneelramharrack2178]

That was the on mind for the long while

[@facts-ps1fu]

Exactly, If he got out the car he would’ve immediately started walking towards the home

[@davidgibson646]

I've been asking myself that question

[@gdenny1748]

Making it up as he goes along! He said what he was TOLD to say….

[@coleengogerty3852]

No way John was hit like these people are claiming and thrown that far and have zero injuries from the neck down. His arm did not have injuries consistent with taking a direct hit by a vehicle. Just not possible ever. Period.

[@DiscoCatsMeow]

I'm in my 4th year of my criminology degree. I can definitively say that after the crime scence reconstruction classes I have had that this guy should not be investigating a lost dog -let alone a death.

[@LisaBush-qb2ic]

Alan Jackson is hilarious. Can’t wait to see him portrayed in a Netflix movie . I can play him well

[@MaryClareVideos]

Bill Hader 👍

[@LisaBush-qb2ic]

@@MaryClareVideos Gary Sinise?

[@SendingFreedomTM]

Maybe he’ll be IN the Netflix movie bro should be a movie star. Holy shit man when he said the “Well ‘YOU’ didn’t” (put the evidence there) was godamn savage man the judge had to say something because everyone mouths dropped haha

[@davidgibson646]

The guy that stared in the ozark jason Bateman should play Alan Jackson

[@LisaBush-qb2ic]

@@davidgibson646 no I like Jason Bateman a lot . Maybe the creepy investigator though.

[@SabrinaD-sy5yw]

I took physics in high school and thought I’d forgotten all of it but I even knew that physics was the greater area of study and he was asking about acceleration. What is this dude doing in this job?😂

[@kathleenmoran4270]

Who is sitting in jail because this guy was an “expert witness” and WHY???? Is every witness, expert or otherwise so HOSTILE!!!

[@michellesayers5346]

Lias are always hostile

[@19Marleymum]

Blame this on Lally for putting Mr. Associates Degree on the stand as an expert

[@wendyrudokas]

@@19Marleymum and it was probably from a correspondence school like the ones that advertised in tv guide or the Enquirer in the 80’s.

[@joseelafrance4807]

can you imagine prepping this witness and being like “Yes! he is perfect!!! WTF

[@SendingFreedomTM]

Well they needed someone who would actually take this case and argue for them. Any decent expert would look and say “that’s not only unlikely but that’s physically impossible that the car hit the guy and did that”. Whether they actually went through expert witnesses until they found one that was either dumb enough or brave enough to lie and play stupid we don’t know.

[@martayoung2492]

Has a degree in administration of justice. Doesn’t know what confirmation bias is. Terrifying.

[@lauramontgomery160]

The judge, a.k.a. aunt Deb shouldn’t allowed this in the trial so late without the defense knowing about it it’s a bunch of shit from PROCTOR

[@drea1976]

It's Aunt Bev... her first name is Beverly... but yeah, I absolutely agree with you.

[@drea1976]

It's Aunt Bev... her first name is Beverly... but, I agree with you 💯

[@SadAmerica1434]

Is the witness under the influence of a narcotic? He can’t speak with the numbness in his tongue. 😳😳

[@sashamulligan2993]

He’s nervous because he has no clue what he’s taking about

[@chrislotts4551]

It's not a good look when a "professional" can't answer a basic question like "who told you?" And the answer is "idk what you mean" 🤦‍♂️

[@marshapieroni6677]

And using the word "stuff" to describe anything

[@SendingFreedomTM]

@@marshapieroni6677He’s literally just trying to fool the jury hoping they are stupid enough to just believe him without questioning it. The police authority and trust are like the whole case given the real murders are also so sketch yet cop trust and authority is their game. Prosecution has to be retarded or knows he won’t ever get a full jury of guilty. He is either covering for himself to claim he really believed Karen was guilty but was just based on bias and/or they’re trying to delay the other people from getting investigated once Karen is cleared

[@aneelramharrack2178]

This is the frist time in a court caes so many witnesses suffet from lost of memory

[@judisullivan3047]

Hmmm.... just write up a report based on what your buddies tell ya !!! These cops believe this is justice .

[@rosecornu460]

This has to be the easiest case the defense has ever had. The prosecution should be embarrassed to bring this case forward.

[@Bri66ette]

Except here we are 7/22/24 go figure!

[@warriorforgod6044]

What a joke !!!!!!Unqualified is an understatement

[@Amber2024.]

WOW!!!! He’s no way an expert shame on you Judge for allowing that.

[@momsdiva71]

I believe I lost several brain cells listening to this trooper. I literally have second hand embarrassment for him. It is unbelievable that Attorney Lally didn't prepare him to testify. Even the fact that he trainec another trooper terrifies me. This is total incompetence and im curious how many other cases he assisted with for trials. I truly pray he does procreate. The world doesn't need another copy of him among us in society.

[@marshapieroni6677]

He should have had enough sense or balls to refuse to testify as an expert. I'm wondering if they just ran out of money for a real expert or if a real expert didn't come to the conclusion they wanted.

[@michelletaylor4211]

The crime scene talked to him!😂😅😂😅 Shame on him!

[@laurencarcaterra1743]

He combining the words definitely and definitively

[@tobydean7097]

😭😭😭

[@theresesink1057]

At last ,,,, a testimony that surpasses the ER “ physician” in stupidity ,,,, and ridiculous ineptness !!!!! What if this was your loved one ,,, and he was supposed to reconstruct in a professional, efficient , and truthful manner . How much trust could you place in his abilities and testimony ? Poor victim ! Not enough respect to correctly do an investigation,,, and then the disrespect of getting on the stand to lie and cover ineptness ,,, all to stay “ pals” with the police dept there ! Shame is the answer ,,, when Americans are allowed to look at and speak the truth . Shame !

[@DMiller912]

I agree 💯

[@EstherDoyle-i2u]

No degree?? That's weird. They couldn't get anyone in america with experience in that field

[@lauramontgomery160]

They wouldn’t want to lose their license or reputation, and/or certifications for a corrupt case

[@lauramontgomery160]

They wouldn’t want to lose their license or reputation, and/or certifications for a corrupt case

[@lauramontgomery160]

Trooper is lying. It’s so disgusting. Let’s have justice for John OKeefe.

[@sandrabecht4489]

Lally needed someone would testify utter nonsense

[@marshapieroni6677]

​@@sandrabecht4489surely they didn't plan for it to go this way. I wonder who decided, like yep, that sounds very complicated and he can explain it all! Pitiful, and I would love to see who ot was who made the decision. Maybe they didn't have the funds to get a real expert, or maybe a real expert wouldn't tell them what they wanted to hear

[@LARENLM]

Biggest question is why the state went with this trooper as their expert. Likely nobody qualified would testify to their ridiculous theory.

[@marshapieroni6677]

That's what I'm wondering. Either what you said or maybe they ran out of money?

[@LARENLM]

@@marshapieroni6677not a money issue - they hired TWO experts to defend Jen McCabe.

[@tobydean7097]

Defend Jen McCabe ???? For what????

[@LARENLM]

@@tobydean7097 her google search - they brought in two paid experts.

[@Ayan-ye2uj]

This whole thing is a joke .. I feel bad for Karen Read. I hope she wins the case

[@nop579]

Me too. I live in Mass and it’s so sad to see that these are the police who are supposed to be protecting us!! If she is found guilty this will be TERRIBLE!

[@nyccolm]

*what do you mean about scientific evidence*??? Considering his testimony it is not surprising that Trooper Paul does not know what that statement means

[@LoLo-zr7bk]

He is so dumb it’s insane that he holds this type of authority

[@hollyharris1874]

This judge is horrible!! Infuriating! A judge should never help a witness so much. (John spun & flew 30' because I was told that & b/c I say it - Paul).

[@Fockerized152]

So this guy says he was killed by getting hit by his arm? Come on...

[@sashamulligan2993]

This is so painful to watch. It makes me question who the state police use as their “expert” in accident reconstruction. It’s not like there are not tons to investigate on highways.

[@Starfish2145]

Witness needs to learn to E N U N C I A T E.

[@cleew8762]

He talks like he has marbles in his mouth.

[@spewgilist]

also needs to S T U D Y

[@Mr.Mister10-4]

He difinly needs to enunciate, but it is more likey he won’t 😂.

[@ashleydavis5557]

Trooper Paul is shaking, stuttering and his speech is very very fast x why????? Unbelievable

[@jimmydee2171]

"It just did "......lmao

[@jangojones8053]

He flew 35 ft fro. A side swipe😂

[@hollyharris1874]

And being 217 lbs struck at 25 mph (none of which we believe!)!

[@johnsmith-ug5tp]

haha

[@durango8882]

Seriously? Is this a prank expert?

[@debpratt4692]

they are ALL a JOKE!!!! WTH

[@emilymorgancreates]

"One of the possibilities..." ????? SIR you need ONE theory!! That's how this works.

[@PostalWorker14]

So Karen and John argued Isn’t that what couples do?

[@josiemiller6524]

“The he crime scene told me” is this guy for real????? I really hope the O’Keefe family realizes what REALLY happened to John. They can’t believe this BS. “So the car hit his elbow and he did a pirouette?” That had to be my favorite part!!!

[@tobydean7097]

💃🏻💃🏻💃🏻

[@SadAmerica1434]

The pirouette????😂😂😂😂😂😂❤

[@lisadavie5282]

Lock up the failed prosecutor Lock up the Judge and Lock up Trooper Paul. Saying. Words. Karen Read. NOT GUILTY 😂

[@themightygalactus8865]

RIP Massachusetts State Police credibility… WOW !!!

[@nyccolm]

Terrible terrible witness

[@momsdiva71]

That's a nice description of this witness. He is a total joke and embarrassment to true crime scene investigators who truly has the education, expertise and does a great job.

[@Mr.Mister10-4]

But he’s an expert, the best and brightest the state troopers have 😂 😂 😂

[@anaddictwithapen8537]

'What broader field is the subfield of kinematics a part of?' 'What is the term used to describe the rate of change of velocity?' My extent of knowledge in physics is a B grade in High School and I can not imagine not knowing the answer to those questions. In what world is that an expert?

[@Ayan-ye2uj]

He’s literally getting schooled 😂😂😂😂

[@mickcastillo615]

Tell me this trooper no longer walks in public after this debacle!

[@LadyLouise29]

Embarrassing on so many levels🙄😡😱

[@justmegaming1169]

He clearly said. HE CANNOT CALCULATE ANYTHING FROM THIS COLLISION!!!!!! Ummmm. How is this the EXPERT for the prosecution and how does the JUDGE except this guy as a QUALIFIED expert?????

[@TonyMosca]

My God !!! where does this fool come from ???????

[@tobydean7097]

No actual photos were taken at the scene????? No photos of the evidence???? 😮😮😮

[@sharonsmart5989]

This judge and expert witness is SHAMEFUL

[@etismith682]

Its important to find the motive why okeef was murdered if he was indeed murdered... Is it possible someone ordered his death ? Did the FBI tried to look into his work and what assigment he was given? Maybe he came across something that he shouldnt see..could someone knew he will be at the party and waited for him and struck him in the head?? There is so little known about the background and financials of all the troopers and their families ......what a tragedy.....

[@gdenny1748]

How did the dog bite him? Why no photos of the crime scene? Why all the guessing? Why get rid of cell phone? Why retire and sell your home? Why google searches how long to freeze? It goes on and on!

[@dianespafford5349]

I would vote not guilty sheerly because of the massive amount of reasonable doubt and CW had not come close to proving their case but I can't even begin to guess what happened. Some seriously fishy shit though

[@marshapieroni6677]

I just hope this man's testimony hasn't helped with the incarceration of other defendants. Anyone know if this is his first time to testify?

[@ANC2002]

I suspect that this officer and trooper proctor ingested a lot of paint chips as children. Between the two of them, there might be one brain cell bouncing back and forth😂

[@annabelshepherd4692]

😂😂😂

[@ashleydavis5557]

Even with Bev’s 4 million “Sustained “ rulings the defence have done beyond brilliantly how they kept their cool with Bev I have no idea! Free Karen! X

[@MichelleMastrullo]

I cannot believe all of the things she sustains!!!

[@annielane1843]

I see any cases he has been an expert witness being retried .

[@momsdiva71]

We can only pray that happens. However, I think they will have an excuse not to retry them. It seems as if these inept investigations have been covered up for more years than we can imagine.

[@sciencefirst7880]

What a joke... I want my tax money back!

[@MAMAlbertaGirl]

The Dunning-Kruger effect ~ if you are exceptionally stupid then you are too stupid to realize you are exceptionally stupid.

[@SendingFreedomTM]

Ah yes this guy is very “exceptional”! At least at some things such as being stupid haha

[@Jessica.Rachel]

I have never heard a law enforcement official testify like this before. He's nervous and clearly has an agenda to carry out.

[@martayoung2492]

I’m not sure he’s intelligent enough to formulate agendas 😅

[@wilfredjurassicyes]

So many of these "troopas" are going to be fired or jailed after this trial is over. I have no idea what's happening, but this is absolutely embarrassing. This guy is a car wreck expert? He doesn't even make sense and is obviously just trying to work with the state as apossed to offering his expert opinion to get karen red in jail. Some of that blue square nonsense.

[@dianespafford5349]

So bad...their expert sounds like an amateur...so bad

[@jangojones8053]

That was a major bump before he started testifying. He can't stop that drip

[@michelebillingsley674]

Is Cannone writing notes related to the trial or is she journaling, making a grocery list, writing thank you cards, doing a crossword puzzle, etc?

[@debpratt4692]

**gulp..drink..gulp... drink...gulp.. drink** I swear halfway through he was out of liquid in his cup he just kept doing it because it was absolutely necessary to take a moment to himself and think what the hell am I going to say next these guys better be fired they are absolutely incapable of figuring out any resolution of an investigation without corruption involved and if someone does not see that including everybody leaving comments then you need to seriously take a hard look in the mirror

[@jimmydee2171]

Never backed the two cars up to each other....wtf. Really. That's the most important thing we are talking about about here...first thing I would do 40 years in auto body repair and licensed appraiser.

[@lorrainedimitrovski5698]

Why is this Trooper aloud to read his notes

[@Fockerized152]

I hope as he is trying to explain how this guy thinks it happens, he did all of this while holding onto his phone and glass but he was hit so hard it knocked him out of his shoe.

[@amandamaywood]

"what do you mean by scientific evidence?" ARE YOU KIDDING ME?!? This is unbelievably incompetent testimony. I'm shocked he even has an associates degree.

[@KimVest]

Sounds like he memorized all of this I bet that’s why he has no hair. He lost it all thinking. 😂😂😂😂😂

[@jamessinclair2584]

God forbid an actual objection is stated. I guess the state knows it’s going to automatically sustained so fuck it, why state a basis for objection.

[@adriennejames77]

Utter Incompetence

[@johnsmith-ug5tp]

"I dont know what else you want me to say." How bout....I resign.

[@martayoung2492]

Absolutely speechless.

[@Beccaboo502]

I can’t tell if this trooper is high, nervous or incompetent. His behavior is odd. I think the PD wasn’t expecting for this story to go as far as it did and they are too deep into to drop charges. Literally making fool of themselves. Did I hear they offered her a plea? Maybe they thought she would plea out. This is crazy

[@johnsmith-ug5tp]

In the private sector this nervous and creepy bleep with an obvious speech impediment, zero social/communication skills would have NEVER been hired in the first place! The only jobs he is qualified to do is low skilled and ZERO public interaction. He is the face of the public sector DEI hiring process.

[@shemp815]

"I put them into the THING,"....Very scientific

[@marshapieroni6677]

Right up there with "stuff"

[@tko3779]

58:36 is my OMG moment. There are several WTF is happening here.

[@SpaceFrawg]

Holy crap, what's the deal up there... It's a shaved head parade, are dudes not aloud to have hair??

[@annabelshepherd4692]

😂😂😂

[@traceewulff4018]

This judge is really getting on my nerves!

[@michele1330]

This guy was training someone????

[@momsdiva71]

That is an extremely frightening thought. How many troopers has he trained? How many people were convicted based on Trooper Paul's "expert" testimony? I know the CW didn't expect Alan Jackson to actually research the concepts of Physics, engine cycles,etc. Jackson lived this case for two years and met with experts. He didn't use a you tube video for analysis. This is totally embarrassing. An officer lost his life and needs justice. A woman's freedom and life are at stake. Trooper Paul will sadly be turned into a meme and this testimony will be forever on the internet.

[@MichelleMastrullo]

My jaw literally dropped

[@lorrainedimitrovski5698]

There was still no blood or skin on the car

[@ainesisland2]

His spoken English is really bad for someone who speaks it,it’s obvious when he mumbles some words he doesn’t pronounce them properly and lacks any understanding

[@jeremyschick3450]

40 hours police accident training vs 4 years deductive reasoning and logic-law school. Hypothetically key and ignition cycles are identical given the freezing weather….trying to act intelligent, confusing everybody by seeming knowing the difference/coalition by correcting Mr Alan Jackson when your questionably capable of counting your fingers. If you didn’t study for the test, you call in sick. 2 years he had to reconstruct that accident. I would’ve said John got hit with glass in his left hand, had a seizure, sliced his own arm up… bit it maybe & punched himself to death.

[@MEMELIFEBABY]

It’s the “I didn’t drop my beer phenomenon,”the reason why John O’keefe didn’t drop his cocktail when he was struck by Karen Read’s 6,000 pound SUV going in reverse. Duh.