Tubing Mascaras (9) - Review and Complete Try-On - Thrive, Tarte, KVD + 6 more

[@bobbithompson8256]

I'm a convert to the Thrive and so glad I switched. I have struggled with mascaras for decades and finally found (with your help) the thrive. Great video Kathrin

[@kasey8605]

More videos like this! Love it!

[@karenkalish-oh9ic]

I really like Two-Faced. It cleans with eye makeup remover really well. At 71, It thickens and lengthens very well.

[@cmgrad1624]

Such a good video. Thank you for doing the research!

[@kathrinmccarty6784]

Thanks so much, I loved trying them so much!

[@lisavega9860]

I started using the Thrive mascara many years ago when it was actually sold in stores at Ulta. I was bummed when Ulta stopped selling the brand but was glad I found it on the Thrive website. Like many, Thrive is my holy grail mascara. I use it with the Shu Uemura eyelash curler - my holy grail eyelash curler.

[@bluecobaltsteph2689]

You’ll have to do a part 2!!!! I really love the Elf and I actually thought it looked better on your eyes than a couple of the higher ones. Also tip for removal - use as hot/warm water as you can tolerate! It really matters!

[@kathrinmccarty6784]

I was kind of surprised by how a couple of them looked in the videos when I edited them but yes, some of it really came down to removal! I use pretty warm water, what my sensitive skin can handle. I will need a part 2 tho because people are suggesting others!

[@rags3901]

Yes…everyone is so different…I love Thrive, Blinc, and Tarte XL…Milani, I use over “regular” mascaras to finish everything off.

[@kathrinmccarty6784]

I wish I’d gotten he Tarte XL!

[@nrsjewlzshats6257]

Thank you so much! I greatly appreciate all of the great information!

[@kathrinmccarty6784]

You are very welcome! Glad you found it helpful!

[@amybrown814]

If I have a mascara brush I like I keep it and use it in other mascara I clean it of course

[@kathrinmccarty6784]

I wish I would do that….unfortunately….i know me…I won’t 🤣

[@faerie_waters]

I'm sold on tubing mascaras! This deep dive is awesome! I've tried the It Cosmetics, Blinc, Tarte, Eyeko, KVD (which, totally agree, doesn't behave like a tubing mascara). IC was my first, and still like, but it gets gummy in extreme heat - tested when I taught at a camp during a heat wave! My next favorite was Blinc (dry worked in its favor after the gummy experience) but the Tarte XL stole my heart! I need to try the OG Thrive and the Milani!

[@kathrinmccarty6784]

Ok, I’ve got to try the Tarte XL!

[@tinaparmer6545]

I love the Thrive and Tartlette. Lately I’ve been liking the Tartlette more and I have the Thrive on auto delivery 😳. I might try the Milani.

[@MARTHALGEORGE]

I agree on theThrive. Love it.

[@kathrinmccarty6784]

Love !❤️

[@lisaannwilner6408]

This was great! Thrive is my everyday go to. When I have and event - I use "Their Real Lengthing " and then take it off with a crow bar, Love you!

[@kathrinmccarty6784]

🤣Crow Bar🤣

[@elizabethmcenearney7860]

I’ve used a few including Thrive and Blinc but finally settled on Merit’s tubing mascara. I love that one, if you get a chance try that one.

[@kathrinmccarty6784]

Dang it, that’s the other one I wanted to try…I’m going over now to get it!

[@geridelaney3926]

I too went down the tubing mascara rabbit hole trying to find a less expensive mascara that I loved. Thrive is hands down my favorite. I had a similar experience with blinc. Too dry. Moral of the story, buy what I love.

[@kathrinmccarty6784]

For sure. I’d recommend trying the Milani if you can. It’s about half the price and pretty good!

[@lisag4588]

I should take a look at a tubing mascara since I suffer from watery allergy eyes pretty much year round now-a-days. I've been using waterproof formulas which are fine, but they are still a pain to remove. I might pick up a tube of the Thrive.

[@kathrinmccarty6784]

It might be perfect for you!

[@MsHardysgirl]

I have the loreal one double sided one. It's good for me but I have long eye lashes already.

[@kathrinmccarty6784]

I’m jealous! I’d love long eye lashes! My husbands are amazing and that always seems unfair…lol. He doesn’t even care 🤣

[@MsHardysgirl]

@kathrinmccarty6784 my brothers are even longer then mine.

[@cherylbleiler172]

I don't use mascara but I enjoyed your review.

[@luanneschonder787]

I’m with u, Thrive is the best!!! Great video, thank u. You’re so cute 😊

[@kathrinmccarty6784]

Thank you so much!!

[@janathompson1204]

Ive been using Ulta lash flash tubing mascara. I like it. It costs $11US. It doesn't create as much volume as regular mascara but it washes off so well. I haven't tried any other brands but I did have the bye bye panda eyes in my online cart. I guess I won't be buying it now! 😂

[@amybrown814]

Lil tip if you didn't know Warm your eyelash curler with the hairdryer Gives great lasting curl to your lashes

[@kathrinmccarty6784]

Well I’m trying that! Thanks!

[@Perfumenpages]

I usually love tubing mascara. I also strongly dislike the blinc. The kvd and tarte ones are also not my favourites. Thrive is still the best tubing and wander beauty mile high is the best regular mascara, for me.

[@amyparis5756]

I have four of the ones that you reviewed and I would have to say I like ‘blink’ & it’s wand. The ‘bye-bye panda eye’ was by far the worst for panda eyes!!

[@kathrinmccarty6784]

Makes me wonder if I should get another tube and try the Blinc again?

[@justkris1238]

Great video. I'm a long time ORIGINAL Blinc user (It was sold as "Kiss" at Sephora). Blinc actually has 4 different tubing mascaras available via thier site. I have tried 3 or the 4 and was only a fan of the original, which I still use. I have not tried the newest version which is the one you tried. Seeing the mixed Blinc reviews, I wonder if it's due to using different versions. Blinc website often runs deals like BOGO. Would be curious of your thoughts on the Original version.

[@Sandusko]

@kathrinmccarty do you know when FFF spoilers are coming out?

[@susieemabe]

I wanted to love the thrive cosmetics mascara, but i have extremely sensitive eyes, and thrive made my eyes burn. The only mascara I've tried that doesn't burn is the Tarte tubing mascara.

[@lisa-lisa-lisa]

I have no lashes and thrive works best for me too. I do think people's experience with mascara varies greatly with mascara and other people's recommendations dont mean as much as with some other types of products.

[@kathrinmccarty6784]

I agree, mascara can be so personal!!

[@Kerryjotx]

I must have the other Thrive one it’s one that we got in FFF box and I hate it

[@bluecobaltsteph2689]

Oh I wish you’d given each one more than 1-2 days to try!

[@kathrinmccarty6784]

Oh, I did. I heard when I made an offhand remark that made it sound d like that but I’d say most of them up I used at least 4-5 times. Some far more, just not the horrible ones to take off…that dang Bye Bye Panda 🐼 my nemesis….lol

[@bluecobaltsteph2689]

@@kathrinmccarty6784 😂😂😂 before I found the elf (and shelled out for thrive) that’s the one I used 😂💜

[@bluecobaltsteph2689]

For me personally I’m not convinced the thrive looks much better than elf, esp for the price but it comes in PURPLE!!

[@bluecobaltsteph2689]

First!!! So excited to see what you think !!

[@kathrinmccarty6784]

You're the best!

[@lisasmith7]

It defeats the purpose but.......................... I like tubing mascara over regular mascara. My last coat. Thrive bothers my eyes. For me it is the Tarte all the way. So far. 👀❌️⭕️

[@lisasmith7]

I am watching on the big sceen. Tell me everything. ❌️⭕️