Ultimate GIRL SCOUT Cookie & Dupe Taste Test - 27 Boxes! -- ABC vs. Little Brownie Bakers

[@kristi2305]

I worked in a private label food manufacturing facility. At the lower end stores, your Dollar Trees, etc. you are gonna find they are the same basic cookie. Perhaps a few very minor tweaks to the recipe or sometimes no tweaks. The cookie is mixed and baked and the only thing changing is the film to wrap the cookies and/or the box (Basically, just the packaging is different). The more expensive ones, Great Value, Kroger, etc) you will find they are very much like the name brand. A team of food scientists spent time and money reverse-engineering the recipe after countless lab tests and taste tests. You will get higher quality chocolate/real chocolate (watch out for the phrase - chocolate-flavored - that means there is not enough actual chocolate to advertise it as a such) better vanilla, etc. The recipes may also have more tweaks to make them slightly more individualized for the customer without getting too far from the name brand flavor. They are basically the name brand without the price. Why are they cheaper? Because you are paying for the advertising for the name brand. Remember, someone has to pay the person who animates the elves. When was the last time you saw a commercial just for a Great Value cookie? Never! The cookie may make an appearance in a commercial for Wal-Mart but it is not a commercial for the cookie. Wal-Mart advertises its stores as a total entity.

[@iluvy00hx3]

Kristi Pavey interesting 🤔

[@skeetsmcgrew3282]

I find with breakfast cereal this is especially true. The only one I havnt found to be identical is Cinnamon Toast Crunch, name brand is much better. Otherwise the bagged kind is the same

[@kristi2305]

@@skeetsmcgrew3282 There are some items that are that way. Either the food scientist couldn't get a near-perfect emulation without specialized equipment or they couldn't determine a way to make it at a cost they can significantly reduce. Some name brand companies will take a loss on the manufacturing cost of an item because it is considered a brand draw. Like, customers like that product so much they buy other products by the same company based on that one item. The cost/benefit analysis keeps the costly item on the shelf.

[@DDios-ih9de]

Yes thats true with many many foods and cosmetics Loreal is exactly the same as Lamcomb except for pkgs and sometimes scent Otherwise SAME except Loreal is much cheaper

[@Minimojojoy]

Kristi Pavey That was awesome info, thank you!

[@Kristen242008]

My husband calls Girl Scouts his "dealers" LOL. He can't resist buying a box, or 4, of Thin Mints when he sees Girl Scouts......

[@roefane2258]

Kristen Long haha glad I’m not the only husband with some self control problems. He actually walked up to a stand of Girl Scouts and when they asked “how many boxes would you like sir?” He actually said “how many do you have?” The little Girl Scouts face was a bit confused.

[@mihawk508]

Kristen Long your husband and I are kindred spirits

[@tomrexer1]

And therefor I'm glad we don't have that here xD

[@Dreadtheday]

We tell ourselves it is a charity... More like supporting my sugar addiction lol

[@arieldanielle23]

I finally got to get a box of cookies last month and it was really sweet seeing them try to work out the change from my $20 bill while their moms were gently coaching them.

[@PinkiiDoesStuff]

My whole life my dad would stick Thin Mints in the freezer and I can’t eat them any other way. They’re so much better cold!

[@ksawler2]

I just heard about this and stuck them in the freezer! Haven't tried them yet but I'm pretty stoked

[@opaljade98]

My dad does the same thing!

[@probablyanoldgod320]

That's only way I eat them as well!

[@No-hg1op]

That's what we do as well! It was supposed to be a deterrent or make us forget but it just made them better

[@Naedlj]

I love dipping mine in hot coffee until it melts the chocolate coating off and gets into the cookie! Then you have a delicious treat and a dessert coffee :)

[@gabbyy__]

COOKIES TIME STAMPS (just in case you wonder about a specific cookie): ✰Thin Mints: 3:42 ✰Samoa/Caramel deLites: 8:47 ✰Do-si-dos/ Peanut Butter Sandwich: 13:14 ✰Tagalongs/Peanut Butter Patties 14:31 ✰Lemonades/Lemon Ups: 18:10 ✰Trefoils/Shortbread cookies: 20:48 ✰Girl Scout S’mores: 21:51 ✰Thanks-A-Lot/Toffee Tastic: 22:48 You are welcome! Also, Lemonades are MY FAVORITE!!

[@JMunny]

Me too!!! such an underrated cookie. The troop in my area switched to the other bakers and lemon-ups are nowhere near as good in my opinion.

[@ClanImprobable]

You wonder, thank you!

I miss the Savannah Smile cookies from the Girl Scout cookies. It's a crunchy lemon drop shaped cookie with a coating/dusting of powdered sugar all over it. Yum!

[@PaigeA6741]

TEAPLEASE THESE WERE THE BEST!!!! They were my favorite. I want them to come back!!!

[@meaganwallwork5395]

Yes! I remember those they were so good. I miss the Mango Cremes those were really good too.

[@Loungemermaid]

Those were so so good

[@meganstright5586]

Ugh, those were my favorite! I've tried the new ones and they are good but not the same 😒😒 Bring back Savannah Smiles!

[@lost_girl.7]

I miss them too 😭 the new lemon cookies they have dont measure up to the Savannah Smiles

[@chipskylark172]

*In front of grocery store* Girl Scout- cookies!! Girl Scout cookies!! Emmy- oh yes I’ll take some Girl Scout-Great how many?? *Emmy backs up pick up truck to the table* Just fill er up I’ll tell you when

[@aliviaguynes1401]

Chip Skylark Lol that sounds like what Emmy would do.

[@ShineHatfield]

When I was a Girl Scout, in 5th grade, my troop had a guy come to our stand and buy an entire case of Samoas. We were super happy. This was back when the were $3.50

[@nodezsh]

@@ShineHatfield Samoas sounds like the kind that someone would just casually order the full display of. That and Thin Mints. But one does not just eat a whole box of mint flavored cookies in one sitting. Then again, caramel has a similar effect. What I'm saying is, that if Girl Scouts ever sold Thin Mints or Lemonades here in Chile, I'd take 20 each.I like lemon and orange candies particularly lemon-filled wafers, so I'm guessing I'd like the cookie as well. And I've had chocolate and mint filled biscuits before (Obsesión), so that'd be a no brainer.

[@Angel_Billy4-30-23]

Chip Skylark Hahaha, that's too funny because I can actually imagine Emmy doing that too, hahaha.

[@puppsmcgee74]

My daughter’s friend was selling GS cookies and we bought a buttload of them. When I was younger and lived in a different part of the state, our GS cookies were from Little Brownie Bakers. However, now our area is an ABC Bakery area, apparently. Samoas/Caramel deLites are my favorites but the Samoas taste better to me than the Caramel deLites. This whole video was fascinating to me. Thanks for tasting and analyzing all 8274875326785367 cookies for us! lol

[@ZaxorVonSkyler]

After hearing hello fresh so many times in a row it starts sounding like hella fresh.

[@JonniusAngelicus]

I actually wondered if that was the joke to begin with.

[@poppetangel]

I read that as Hella Jeff and now I'm nostalgic for Homestuck.

[@sammybabi]

I can never unhear it now 😆

[@BankruptMonkey]

Ever since I found out the cookies were different depending on where you live, I've wondered what the differences were. Thank you for testing it out!

[@PaigeA6741]

Out of The Hat I was the same! My home town area and where I live now use little brownie baker but my college town used ABC so it was fun to see the differences

[@cutetimesinfinity3368]

The Great Value brand Samoas and Thin Mints are delicious. Walmart did an excellent job with their knockoffs. And the price is insane.

[@groovygirl2408]

Yes they are so good.

[@scrapperk8399]

J. Wilde And I can get them year-round!

[@csmith2005]

Yes, I was gonna say exactly that. Blasphemous, I know, but I believe the Walmart thin mints are superior to the GS ones. They freeze better, and they're just better overall but I only have access to the Little Brownie Baker version of the thin mints so I could be biased. The ABC ones sound lovely.

[@kitschro]

I like their version of the Tagalongs, even though they have a chocolate cookie base

[@jennsutherland8608]

Have you ever tried the Dollar General brand ? They are delicious and under $2 a box and I know they have copies of the samoas and thin mints and the peanut butter ones and the lemon ones

[@SwtLvlyLucy169]

I always find myself rewatching emmy vids when I need to calm down and relax.

[@callioscope]

Luisa D Then you hit the jackpot today!

[@ivysweets]

Me too! Very relaxing videos of things that bring me joy...FOOD! 😁

[@kimaguirre3560]

same! 😊

[@niktaylor5631]

Luisa D currently having a mental break down and watching Emmy is always the first thing I do to calm myself down so it doesn’t escalate. Her videos really are therapeutic

[@SwtLvlyLucy169]

Nik Taylor Hey, Take a few deep breaths and close your eyes. Tell yourself you will be okay🙏🏼 I’ve been in your shoes and it passes okay.

[@Livlocalmartian]

Fruit loops and Fruity Pebbles are lemon lime cereals! I found this out when I got curious about the flavor of Captain Crunch Berries(which is strawberry FYI!). Listed in the ingredients of Fruit Loops and Fruity Pebbles, it has “citrus flavoring”.

[@skeetsmcgrew3282]

Emmy's kid: Mom can I have a cookie? Emmy: No! This is for science! Scoot!!

[@ouranhshc100]

Best comment here 😂 I'm over here cackling 🤭

[@arieldanielle23]

I absolutely believe that Emmy tells her boys to "scoot" lol

[@Janette_CH]

I went to the scouts when I was a child, but i come from Switzerland and here when we sold cookies we always made them ourselves, we also distributed self made bread on Sundays sometimes. It's interesting to see the differences of scouts in different countries. Also we only baked cookies once a year, around Christmas. We sold them on the market, we didn't go from house to house.

[@forest_green]

My daughter is a Spark (5-7 year old age group in Girl Guides of Canada) and I'm so proud of her. I don't think Girl Guide cookies are as good or as varied as Girl Scout cookies but I'm so happy to be a parent of a little girl continuing this long long tradition of a community of smart, strong girls.

[@Genna.K]

Imagine coming into the kitchen and your mom just taste test 27 boxes of cookies! 😁

[@gunfuego]

I'd be diabetic in .02 seconds....

[@Dreadtheday]

.....And Shes high on caramelized sugar and butter. Mom can I ha...... "You may have 1"

[@user1name1here]

dreadthedays says “1 from each box ok. Thanks mom” 😉

[@AneesaH.]

Girl Scouts: “This means war”

[@Cadenzal]

When I was a girlscout we sold from LBB, but I feel lucky to live in a place with ABC bakers because they have several vegan options! My favourites are the thanks-a-lots, though my local girlscout troupe told me theyre being discontinued this year 😔

[@Merbuggy1610]

I bought from a different troop this year. I wondered why my Samoas seemed different!!!

[@ellewelle8525]

When I was a kid, the thin mint cookie was a chocolate cookie with a white layer of mint on top, similar to York peppermint patty filling. The entire cookie was then covered in chocolate. The mint flavor was only in the white layer. You could actually lick the mint layer off the cookie! It was so good.

[@jacquipomeranski3508]

Those are the ones i remember too!

[@lmaree200886]

In Australia we have our own version of those made by Arnott's (the makers of Tim Tams). Dark chocolate, mint cream and a thin chocolate biscuit (not really called cookies here unless its choc chip).

[@Ari-ce7uj]

In a time of panic, Emmy’s voice really soothe and calms me :) Thank you for this lovely video!

[@danmccarthy4700]

You have the best job on the planet! Also, it was such a comfort to see the Girl Scouts selling outside the store I went to today, with all the craziness going on right now. I couldn't help but indulge in a few boxes.

[@alikatplans8634]

The most important thing that I learned from my bestie, the girl scout, was that LBB uses the same peanut butter as Reese's in their Tagalongs. Which are my FAVORITE

[@timhutchinson8485]

Dr. Emmy, Cookieologist.

[@nadynemotherofcatz]

Try putting Thin Mints in the freezer, amazing!

[@annalgam]

My favorite thin mint dupe is the Back to Nature Fudge Mint Cookies. I find that the cookie is crunchier which I prefer over the Girl Scouts thin mints I can find in my area.

[@jayaitch88]

Of course you made a spreadsheet! You’re so dedicated Emmy. This is one of the many MANY reasons we love you so much 💕

[@ashleyk1604]

Both companies provided cookies to my troop over the years. I grew up on Little Brownie Bakers, but my last few years were ABC. I love them all!

[@jenniferliu7586]

Emmy is the only channel that doesn’t overreact to corona virus.

[@LurkingSpider420]

Right? I’m literally terrified as it’s even closer to my area and this channel calms me down so much 👏

[@LurkingSpider420]

Right? I’m literally terrified as it’s even closer to my area and this channel calms me down so much 👏

[@matthewanderson1916]

crèmepie im in georgia and my school is closed for at least a week

[@breel4769]

Daniel Mapache I live in Seattle 🤣🤣🤣 hows that for close 😂

[@jenniferliu7586]

crèmepie I’m actually from the east west, but my college is closed.

[@nathanhittle9457]

My favs are: 1. Peanut Butter Patties 2. Thin Mints 3. Lemonades

[@CanDoo321]

I am a longtime fan, thank you for the years of entertainment.

[@chinchillahats4907]

Thank you for all you teach us Emmy💕 I found your channel a few years back. I was the video where you talked about century eggs and how they are and prepared. I learned so much from that video. I’m so happy that you teach people about food, why people ate/eat them, and what the food means to them. So thank you 😊

[@lindeyc]

I bought a box of lemon ups this year and didn’t realize they were different from lemonades. I was so disappointed once I realized it because the lemonade icing is so perfect in the lemonades

[@aronraposa]

The world is ending and it’s making me anxious, however, emmy can literally calm me down wtf haha

[@shuou2794]

What do you mean the world's ending

[@onceever3097]

Don't worry as long as you have more than like three antibodies you're fine

[@gneepgnarp]

@@shuou2794 cuz of coronavirus

[@RGABodyBag]

It’s not even anywhere near as bad as Influenza. Last year 20,000 people died just in the USA from the FLU. The media is just blowing it out of proportion to try to cause panic.

[@Dlwr47]

Don't feed into the mass mentality and hysteria. Obtain the scientific facts, put it into perspective and think for yourself. The media always sensationalises things to make it worse than it is :)

[@Government_Username]

This channel deserves an Emmy Award 👩‍🍳🏆

[@BreakfastGolden]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@lynnwilhoite6194]

Now, that is just cute! 😁

[@ambarsantacruz7791]

I love videos like this Emmy! trying the same product but for different brands

[@OriginalAcefanatic]

As far as I’m concerned, there is NEVER enough mint flavor in things that are mint flavored. I LOVE MINT!!!!

[@meowrchl97]

YES ME TOO!!!

[@devodavis6747]

I *can't* be the only person watching that's thinking *"WHERE'S THE MILK??* All these delicious 🍪 🍪 🍪 and you had to eat 'em dry? Ouch!

[@Moona1966]

I was thinking more along the lines of a nice, hot cup of coffee! Would have gone a long way to calming her poor tummy, as well.

[@kyivstuff]

Tea! Only a nice big cup of green tea would suit!

[@the_real_littlepinkhousefly]

Emmy is lactose intolerant. Milk is not a good idea for her.

[@AbsolutelyAmel]

yes please reshoot but with milk

[@the_real_littlepinkhousefly]

@@AbsolutelyAmel Milk makes Emmy sick.

[@smashcode10]

No joke, once i open the packets i would'nt be able to hold myself back especially the mints :/

[@giannasawyer7466]

smashcode we have knockoff ones at my job dollar tree n I try to nvr buy any bc I wanna eat the whole box

[@Maisygirl1974]

The Thin Mints are crack, I tell you. Even more so when kept in the freezer. We also put ice cream between two Thin Mint cookies for a yummy little minty ice cream sammich. Crack......

[@ohmbug10]

@@Maisygirl1974 And those evil little girls with their cute little toothless smiles selling people the only substance more addictive than crack... bwahaha...me walking away with 2 boxes of me precious...nom nom nom...evil evil little girls.😂

[@smashcode10]

@@giannasawyer7466 Haha, im from australia so i dont have any here, but Mint is by far my favourite Flavour. Similar ones and other types i've bought here and i have the same problem lol! They dont last long when i see them.

[@SamKosel]

Actually, if you need a girl scout fix, find your local office because they usually have them outside of the season. Support the girl scouts all year round! 😁 They don’t sell from the office during cookie season. I used to work across the street from our local office and my office would send me over to get the goods!!

[@andrewflashchannelgibbs5384]

Even Vector never bought that many Girl Scout cookies! 🤣

[@loriferlulu]

My favorites were the savannah smiles, but they were retired this year. I’m so sad! 😞

[@larrianncurtis8078]

@ A unforseen problem was with the name of that cookie. There is an "adult" "actress" with that name. The cookies were pretty good, though.

[@JennaiM]

That was my favorite cookie too 😔🥺

[@purplepuffs2095]

@@larrianncurtis8078 Who had the name first? If it was the cookie, they could bring all that up in court.

[@larrianncurtis8078]

@@purplepuffs2095 Sadly - I believe it was the porn-star. You can just look up "Savannah Smiles". There wasn't really a legal issue, though, the Girl Scouts don't want or need even a hint of that association.

[@KC-ud7ko]

Wow! I was a girl Scout way back in the day and my daughter was one a few years back and I never knew there were different makers of the cookies.

[@meaganwallwork5395]

I remember cookie season was my least favorite thing about girl scouts. Standing outside a store early on a Saturday morning at the end of winter. So cold and miserable. Please buy from Girl Scouts during cookie season not off brands they deserve it.

[@wormcowboy]

And if the kids don’t sell all the cookies you gotta pay out of pocket for all leftovers

[@Inamichan]

Thhiiiinnn mints 😭😭😭😍😍 The scouts around me do the little brownie bakers but now I want to try the ABC ones.

[@emmymade]

They're the best.

[@missmaurie1]

We have ABC but now I want the LBB s’mores cookie!

[@jabiebabie4563]

YOURE TELLING ME THE THANKS A LOT STILL EXISTS. I HAVENT HAD THOSE IN MY REGION FOR YEARS AND I WAS A GIRL SCOUT UNTIL I GRADUATED HIGH SCHOOL OMGKAKCJSJC I MISS THEM SO MUCH

[@cupcakexlindsay]

The lemonades are my favorite! I’ve had the lemon slice ones. Ugh SO GOOD. I didn’t know they had a dupe for those! I need to find them! What store sells those?

[@asiyah9]

Signature select is from Albertsons so any of these stores: Albertsons, Safeway, Vons, Jewel-Osco, Shaw's, Acme, Tom Thumb, Randalls, United Supermarkets, Pavilions, Star Market, Haggen and Carrs.

[@johnhannibalsmith1607]

Wow. I feel like I've been looking forward to this video for forever!!! It didn't disappoint. 👍😁

[@SachaDoesPortuguese]

The generics that seemed like it are probably indeed the exact same thing, just with different packaging! Outsourcing the product to a third-party producer is one of the ways they're able to save costs on generic goods, so a lot of the times factories will do a run for one brand and simply change the packaging/labeling for the same product for another brand immediately thereafter. If the info of where they're sourced from is available on the packaging (in Europe, you get at least the corporate location), you might find that the production company is the same!

[@brynnstephens6404]

My favorite cookie had a 1-year run. Mango creams. They were excellent, Hawaii in a box.

[@harleydhm]

Connecticut is Little Brownie Baker's. As a former Girl Scout, Tagalongs are the best in my book

[@1laurelei1]

Came here to say just this about the Tagalongs. I ❤ PB and Chocolate.

[@StargazerDog]

I miss Savannah smiles!!

[@StargazerDog]

And the dulce de leche

[@UrbanHomesteadMomma]

Wow so many flavours! In Canada the Girl Guides only have 2 kinds of cookies... chocolate mint and chocolate/vanilla sandwiches cookies

[@MarisaCohenBeauty]

Me: *sees Girl Scout cookies* Little girl: “hello! Would you like to buy-“ Also me: JUST TAKE MY MONEY 💵

[@anaiduwhiteley]

Signature select is also the store brand Safeway/Albertsons too! I just bought those two days ago since I missed the Girl Scout sales due to the virus. Excited to try!!

[@davefsmith6040]

If I remember, Grasshoppers are Milk Chocolate while GS Cookies are Dark Chocolate.

[@kyivstuff]

Your voice is like a gentle intelligent fun brook. It’s so soothingly refreshing and warm.

[@cartiaking3377]

we don’t have girl scout cookies where i am, but i really want to try them :(

[@Bloodhoundfostermom]

Can you order them online?

[@JenniferMcMahonhawaii78]

You can buy them on Amazon.

[@cartiaking3377]

probably are online, but all out of stock

[@vibrantpixeIs]

you can find girl scout smart cookies direct ship links if you just search for them! i used this young lady's link a few days ago! (they are ABC bakery if you're curious) app.abcsmartcookies.com/#/shopify-landing/ceba6f75-d41f-4249-8a69-22f692571042 edit: you have to order by march 15th btw!

[@sborrelli7]

How sad 😢

[@ShineHatfield]

Growing up in New Hampshire, I was shocked when I learned that Girl Scouts was changing the name of the Samoas to Caramel DeLites, but I was confused when the box never changed. Now I know that NH supplies the Little Brownie Baker brand hahaha Funny how I grew up at 7 minute drive from Massachusetts, but still only encountered Samoas and Do-Si-Dos, rather than the other names. I live in San Francisco now and they sell Little Brownie Baker cookies, too.

[@alltheday]

The sound effects in these past few videos... I'm ⚰️

[@coolness06]

All the little voices!!! 🤣

[@appieclnnamon]

Im a keebler grasshoppers fanatic. They taste like thin mints tasted in the memories of my childhood! I do wish they were dark chocolate coated, but the texture and concentration of mintiness feels right. Current thin mints are weirdly soft and crumble like dust!

[@IonIsFalling7217]

You’re making me feel like I’ve been missing out in those ABC cookies my whole life. Everywhere I’ve lived (CO, KY, WA, AK, WY) they’ve been the LBB kinds!

[@BethRazz]

They're both Girl Scout brand cookies though? I was a lil confused about that.

[@BethRazz]

My area def has only had the LBB kind tho.

[@ambershaw374]

LBB are the best!! My daughter sells in Oregon so I'm biased lol but our S'mores omg! Especially if u heat them in the microwave

[@Kristen242008]

Wisconsin has the ABC cookies. If you're ever up here during cookie season, they are usually stationed outside of Walmart.

[@piesusan17]

I can't imagine a mintier thin mint.

[@TheHBSeamstress]

I love watching you tast things. 😊 You describe the taste so well.

[@shannajhullaby]

I've been waiting for this video after being teased for so long!

[@daniireland1985]

I just watched a great lady eat cookies for almost 30 minutes. How do you make half an hour of cookies so entertaining and scientific?? I want to say, what am i doing with my life, but that would hint that im ashamed. Im sooooooo not ashamed. Keep em coming emmy.

[@emmymade]

Yay!!! 🍪🍪🍪

[@GentleSnow22]

There's no girl cookies where I live. I was super excited to find some dupes at Walmart! I remembered your first video while choosing the flavor and Thin Mints is a total win for me!

[@csmith2005]

The Walmart thin mints in my opinion are better than the originals :s at least the LBB versions.

[@GentleSnow22]

@@csmith2005 For real? What a surprise! I don't have other brands to compare. I'll stick whit them!

[@carly5380]

Signature Select also has a Grasshopper dupe for Thin Mints although they’re much bigger. They’re very good (and vegan like Thin Mints)!

[@scrapperk8399]

Carly This is probably the “dupe” I’ve purchased the most! In fact, I haven’t purchased the GS version recently because the price is so high.

[@bittersweetinsanity]

In my kid's council cookies (ABC) are $4 per box and we offer $6 shipping on 5 to 12 packages! You gotta have our [superior] thin mints and lemonades!

[@alexgarza2165]

I’ve been WAITING for this video. Thank you!

[@alicerose512]

I've had a really bad week that's had me crying for hours but Emmy always makes me feel better.

[@emmymade]

I'm glad you're feeling better.

[@alicerose512]

Even better now!! Thank you so much

[@lynnwilhoite6194]

@@alicerose512 Well, this short comment thread brought tears to my eyes, it was so sweet.

[@alicerose512]

​@@lynnwilhoite6194 aw, thank you! Honestly I cried too- it made my day

[@SkiesTurnedGrey]

Ack! You missed the Lemon Coolers/Savannah Smiles again! They're lemon shortbread wedges dusted with confectioner's sugar, and I think there's lemon zest in them as well. So delicious! (Nevermind, they've been discontinued. Shame, they were the best...)

[@rtblaze7915]

That should never have been discontinued; sounds so good!

[@frogonmytoe2946]

“Studded with little rhombuses”. Emmy is the best. 💓

[@FirefliesInJars]

Pro tip from a previous Girl Scout camp counselor, the Thanks a lots are GREAT for making s’mores. We used them at camp all of the time.

[@lindeehopkins6439]

What the heck??? Closed caption said, " Good ass yes..."???? Made me lololololol

[@nicolefields5917]

Thanks to your gut for taking one for the team! I enjoyed watching this one!

[@scrapperk8399]

Finally! I’ve discovered that the only bad thing about following Emmy’s Instagram is that I become incredibly impatient for the teased content!!! 💕

[@melinaz3385]

Thank you for the cookie comparison! I love the coconut ones!

[@ZaxorVonSkyler]

23:00 Toffee-tastic is the only girl scout cookie I buy because it's the only gluten free one I like. Glad you like them too!

[@Homemademamas]

I’m learning so much! I want to try all of the comparisons!

[@roddob3389]

I just tried Do-Si-dos for the first time this Girl Scout season and I was surprised to find they are essentially expensive Nutter Butters. Lol! Also, Keebler's "Grasshoppers" are a fairly good Thin Mint replacement. Those cookies are also bigger in size than regular Thin Mints. EDIT: Ah, the grasshoppers!

[@DocCokie]

SO many cookies!! 🍪 Thanks Emmy! That was fun! ❤

[@pie46733]

Someone's local Troop must love them lol.

[@emi.lastname]

LOVE the Benton ones from ALDI! I’ve had them side by side with Caramel De-Lites and they are better!

[@andrewzimmernisgross]

Emmy, I can’t even tellllll you the disappointment I felt when I bit into one of those thin mint style cookies from The Dollar Tree. Cursed day. Also Shaw’s is Safeway/Von’s on the west coast, I’ve lived that signature select life 😂

[@cottonwoodbazaar941]

Thanks for sharing! Love your video's!

[@NeelTheSphynx]

So the knockoffs have decided that the ABC brand is the definitive cookie. Tagalongs will still forever be my favorite!

[@aoneal0603]

I think it’s important to note she bought the knock off in her local area which is the ABC area. I can attest that the knockoffs in my local stores are similar to LBB. I find that very Interesting.

[@GreyGaymer]

I have NEVER seen those Teal Toffee Tastic ones before, I love the idea of that!! My faves were an older Lemon one called "Lemon Chateaus" which was a sandwich cookie with Lemon Cream! Very nice! Then there were uh... Lemon Smiles as well?? Miss those. Thanks for sharing!!

[@leannemayor5755]

I have this question when I watch Emmy taste test. Clearly she can’t eat all the cookies before they go stale ,so my question is ,does she pressure seal them into bags so not to waste food or does she give the excess away to family and friends ? I’d love to know. I do love Emmy so no crappola in the comments please .i am just curious xo

[@paulagallant]

She share's stuff with her friend's, neighbour's etc. :)

[@tomrexer1]

Well,yes:3! She give them away to friends and family^-^ You could watch her Q&A for more info or better details 💜

[@leannemayor5755]

Thank you I just wondered

[@cmanlovespancakes]

She has two kids and a husband so I am sure they help out.

[@emmymade]

Like Paula said I share the leftovers from my videos with friends and neighbors, and this one was no different. Give thanks to break rooms. 🙏🏼

[@dvnrhillary]

That is a whole lot of GIRL SCOUT COOKIES!!!😀😯 The Peanut Butter cookies I would not eat because I am allergic to nuts and peanut butter🤮😖. All the rest of the the other cookies, however, I would have my turn to try them myself. And anyways, I LOVE CHOCOLATE!!!!😍😀

[@CadetteAlright]

Was in girl scouts all my life in the mid west and lemonades are my favorite cookie but LBB did them dirty, imo

[@Cat-xxxxx]

I grew up in Las Vegas and moved to Michigan when I was 21....Im now 38 and I spent my WHOLE life thinking "peanut butter pattys" was something I made up in my head because where I am located they are called "tagalongs" and taste COMPLETELY different. OOOOMMMGGGG......THANK YOU FOR SOLVING THIS RIDDLE! 🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂

[@jennamedlyn]

I just went to the grocery store; it did not take 41 minutes. It took me 2 hours! Lines are crazy because of the virus scare

[@Gingergent07]

You are a champ to do that many different flavors! My stomach would killlll me if I ate so many varieties of chocolate and lemon.

[@msgigglesbaby]

I knew something was off when I tasted the thin mints! This WHOLE TIME they're recipes were baked in two different bakery's!? I feel bamboozled,hoodwinked,betrayed, lied too, deceived, tricked,cheated,duped,fooled....😭😭😭

[@lynnwilhoite6194]

Lol, you've been had, you've been took! 😂

[@wally626v_m7]

Your special shirt, did moire a lot on my iPad 2, but does not on my new iPad Pro, technology for the win.

[@viktrois]

i’m upset bc samoa’s are my favorite and i’ve been wondering why caramel delites don’t smack like samoa’s do. turns out they sell caramel delites in my section of california but just 50 miles north they sell samoa’s 😭😭

[@janicewong7535]

Omg I’ve been waiting for this since you first showed us sneak peaks ❤️❤️❤️

[@yeyaCbrd]

EMMY AND EVERYONE WATCHING STAY SAFE !!!

[@Sqwirle]

We only have two varieties in Ontario Canada and they’re sold at different times of the year, fall and spring. We have the chocolate mint which I believe is made by Christie and a duo pack of an Oreo style in chocolate and vanilla. My granddaughters sell them and they go fast!

[@Roofgeese]

There's one you didn't get to try! There's a cookie in a dark blue bag that's a Gluten Free sea-salt caramel chocolate chip.

[@PorQpine09]

Ren Cullen theres a few she didnt try

[@caylawalsh843]

Also, Signature Select brand stuff sells at the Target I go to frequently. Buena Park, CA. My mom loves their items lol 😂