Vocal ANALYSIS of Ren featuring Chinchilla performing "Chalk Outlines"

I am incredibly impressed by Ren's storytelling and musicality, and it shows in this collaboration with Chinchilla exponentially. So what better way to enjoy a collab than with one of my own! This is the second time we filmed this with Will Ramos of Lorna Shore and Chris Liepe, as the first time a couple months ago had a corrupted file. So we're listening to it for the second time, and giving our pearls of wisdom of this amazing piece!
Join professional opera singer Elizabeth Zharoff, as she listens to Ren & Chinchilla performing "Chalk Outlines" for the second time.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Written and Performed by Ren, Chinchilla
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I definitely recommend watching the original video without interruptions. Here's the link: • Ren X Chinchilla - Cha...
Ren - / @renmakesmusic
Chinchilla - / @chinchilla_music
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WE HAVE MERCH! Check-out the full line-up here: thecharismaticmerch.com
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
🎧 Elizabeth’s favorite headphones 🎧 : imp.i114863.net/zayoEM
Music Gear Questions? 🎤 See my list of recommendations: imp.i114863.net/yRyGoV
WANT MY CHAIR? I don’t blame you…and here’s a link to make it even sweeter:
secretlab.co/?rfsn=4692958.b2...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
🎙️Podcast: thecharismaticvoice.com/podcast/
🌐Website: thecharismaticvoice.com
📸Instagram: / thecharismaticvoice
🧑‍🤝‍🧑Patreon: / thecharismaticvoice
📺Twitch: / thecharismaticvoice
📰Our FREE Newsletter: eepurl.com/gz7Z_z
-------------------------------------COURSES------------------------------------------
🎵MUSIC APPRECIATION COURSE🎵
Want to understand how to listen to and appreciate music more? My Music Appreciation course is now live. Take a look at thecharismaticvoice.com
🎶DEMYSTIFYING SINGING🎶
My intensive 7-week course on vocal foundations includes weekly group sessions and private lessons. Learn more at thecharismaticvoice.com.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Elizabeth Zharoff is an international opera singer and voice coach, with 3 degrees in voice, opera, and music production. She's performed in 18 languages throughout major venues in Europe, America, and Asia. Currently based somewhere between Los Angeles and Tucson, Arizona, Elizabeth spends her days researching voice, singing, teaching, writing music, and recording TONS. She also plays Diablo and Dungeons & Dragons.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
We have a sister channel: THE SINGING HOLE. Join us there to examine how ordinary creatures create extraordinary sounds. / @thesinginghole
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
Non-profit, educational, or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#ren #Reaction #TheCharismaticVoice
-------------

[@bravenewozzy]

Chinchilla rabbit hole incoming for Elizabeth....

[@jasonsmith6707]

Can't wait till she hears Fingers.

[@loris.6614]

oh I hope so!

[@annaspurlock439]

Yes!!!!!

[@Mhantrax]

Live Version

[@discordianapple2129]

Wouldn't that be a chinchilla hole?

[@SparkyReynolds]

Ren and Chinchillas "how to be me live" is the essence of perfect voices together....its about Rens friend Joe...happy birthday Joe! his b-day just passed on the 1st. Ren doesn't talk about him much but he did on his b-day... I never ugly cried as much as I did that day....

[@bobbycollins6783]

Yep. For me I think How to be me is even better. A better song with so much emotion. It breaks your heart💔.

[@Avellan20]

I concur

[@reactivereplays5666]

I REALLY want them to do that one... It is TRULY phenomenal! Out of this world harmonies and synchronicities! Btw, some music loses it's shock factor after the first listen so people do not want to watch. Ren gives me chills on most every song even after 50 listens.... They face each other in How To Be Me also!

[@kellie7180]

@@reactivereplays5666 Absolutely. His, and Chinchilla's songs continue to bring me joy and also continue get chills, and moves me no matter how many times I listen.

[@bentevibekesandnes1218]

I' m 64 yro.... I love you all. And i " sub. Of you all... This is the best of this sentuary...... THIS IS THE NEW MUSIC OF 202- 2040... And yeah... Rens mom is a highly respected musick/ song teacher

[@luciferlafleur4534]

I'm always in awe of music people. They are talking about globble offsets and T7 bang-bangs and I'm sitting in the dirt smashing wild berries with a rock saying, "Pretty sing-song sound pretty. Me cry now. Uggh."

[@HampZZ]

Haha, yeah, some drinks in and im there with ya

[@jeffwilson3205]

Idea. They should do one of these with Ren so he can answer questions and comment in real time. 😬😬😬

[@andrejsandal2382]

I second that, they ought to reach out to Ren, I think they would all have such wonderful and unique chemistry too.

[@amandawilson890]

I think they should have ren on to listen to lorna shore 🤣

[@andrejsandal2382]

@@amandawilson890 I believe that Ren is a metalhead too, at the very least he listens to RATM and Slipknot ^^

[@Bluemoon_75]

I was thinking the same thing . I must say I’m mesmerized watching Will, his reactions are so raw and honest, and his face watching is full of love and appreciation for the art of REN.

[@laterreurrouge1917]

Great idea ! And maybe later on with Vessel as well

[@TheBeelzboss]

Will deserves ALL THE LOVE for taking time out to do these KZbin things. He's in a majorly successful band and is among the elite in his field and he comes in and asks nothing from anyone.

[@pippafinland]

I think Will's clean vocals with Ren would be amazing. Both of them are so amazing in conveying a message. ❤

[@stricklywicked1112]

Regardless of if you like metal music or not. If you don’t like this dude as a person there’s something wrong with you.

[@PeteAxeShields]

I concur 100%%. What a lovely humble presence Will has. His humanity shines so strongly. All three of these amazing people are completely void of ego and are so consumed by their art it is a beautiful thing to behold. 🙏

[@choklityum]

Ren is, to me, a voice for those of us with chronic, often debilitating, physical and mental health issues. This song really resonates, and I thought that Chinchilla's vocals added a beautiful dimension. Thank you, Elizabeth, Will, and Chris, for your insights and thoughts.

[@ElWray8]

Chinchilla is a spirit, draining energy from the lights so she can manifest and sing a haunting duet with Ren.

[@salishseamermaid]

That's exactly it!

[@Corvid76]

Well she failed to show up in Hi Ren and those lights flickered a whole hell of a lot more.

[@NilZed1]

New head canon

[@Delta_Sierra_]

Why you gotta blow minds like that

[@ladysarafireheart5400]

This was my thoughts as well. Like the character died probably of an overdose given some of the lyrics. So haunting

[@maximilian_ggdas]

Will Ramos reacting to Ren. That's the top 2 of my personal musical discoveries within the last 18 months in one video. Sweet!

[@5T5A5Z5]

I want to see Will's reaction to Hi Ren and the lyrical content in particular.

[@tommyvercruysse4149]

lol i was thinking the same :) I would also add "Des Rocs" to that :)

[@TheFlagnard2]

Ren is a genius and one of the greatest artists of the modern era. Also, I just want to draw attention how cool it is the Will and Elizabeth are literally at the forefront of scientific research behind harsh vocals. They are pioneering the study of a singing style that, until now, has gone unstudied. And we get to watch it all as it happens.

[@andrejsandal2382]

It's so cool, honestly. As a science enthusiast and a harsh vocalist myself, I can't get enough of this unholy trinity \m/

[@Oryyyt]

​​​@@andrejsandal2382can't get enough of these three either lol they're so wholesome and masters in each of their own Different fields. All the while they still keep learning and us also learning from and with them. It truly is wonderfful

[@wildearthling]

Yes 👏👏👏

[@sprucemaroose]

Artists spend so much time making the sound perfect Ren rocks up in a corridor with an electro acoustic, lapel mic and creates better sounding music than anyone

[@JW-qf2fx]

no - this took meticulous planning, and a LOT of mics with awesome sound management to get right... making something look simple is incredibly hard. Kudos

[@rockarola55]

​@@JW-qf2fxYes and no. Ren (and Chinchilla) used to busk, so they can both kick ass live. This video is 100% live in the room, there might be a few cuts, but it's not recorded in a studio

[@morecrayonsplzmcw4836]

She lightly dances around and above his notes in a hauntingly beautiful way. ❤

[@jessehelton9031]

Will Ramos entering the Ren rabbit hole! YES!

[@Taratara-uc8pn]

Then hopefully the whole wonderland of Chinchilla will open up - FINGERS LIVE is a must and I think they all would love One Time ❤

[@craigcalder7264]

It’s my favourite performance of hers,so unique

[@iamlpinthe312]

It’s brilliant!!

[@tattoodude8946]

When talking about how soft Chinchilla comes in - you can hear her fingernails pass through her hair at 22:26. Chris actually points it out as the "sizzle" or hiss from the compression, but its her fingernails dragging through her hair! So raw!

[@mranster]

Oh, you people with your educated, talented ears! As deeply as I love this performance (it makes me cry every time,) you somehow made me hear it and appreciate it even more. Thank you!

[@madboydaz]

yeah every time

[@mjvdg4194]

The single release of this song has a moment from Chinchilla that breaks my heart on every listen. On "there's a pill for everything" she goes off pitch and 'squeaks' into the last word. So much emotion and storytelling in that single second!! I love it so much

[@panchomcsporran2083]

Rens videographer is a childhood friend Sam, most of Rens videos cost less than £1000, who needs million dollar videos when you have All the talent.

[@EnterCombie]

Rens songwriting is absolutely world class. ❤

[@bearinmind7298]

Ren is one of those artists that come along every few decades. Full control of emotion. Song writing. Story and making incredible video. Keep in mind he has no major production company or studio behind him. Ren is braking the modern mold.This track is a absolute timeless hit. He takes story telling back to the 18th century when u just let it go.

[@Corvid76]

As others have said, while Chalk Outlines is great, How To Be Me(live) is a much more impressive vocal harmonization between the two. Consider checking it out as well

[@Hellroxas]

I love when you collab together its soo comfy

[@JohnWilson-np3si]

At about 28:45 when Chris points out that it's like Ren's voice is leading Chinchilla's voice it made me think about how my late wife would've likely seen it. "Their voices are dancing." I believe she would've said something like that. She would've immediately seen a deeper connection between those two. She was a truly special lady who was able to find the soul in everything. God broke the mold when he made her. She was truly special.

[@marthastewwart]

What does late wife mean exactly? I don't think I've heard of that term. Does it mean like the most recent wife? Just curious is all

[@JohnWilson-np3si]

@@marthastewwart it means my wife who recently passed away.

[@CleoHarperReturns]

I love that you know exactly what she would say. Having internal conversations with a passed loved one is such a good way to keep them alive in your heart. She sounds like a really beautiful person -- I'm so glad she was in your life. Thanks for sharing her with us.💜

[@misspowers]

I think it’s sweet you knew her heart and mind so well. Sending my best 🖤🌻

[@Zairn12345]

Thanks for sharing, John. I tell my wife this on occasion; that I know what she would say in certain scenarios, so that if anything were to happen to her, I'd know what she would say. It makes mortality a bit easier.

[@xariexis]

I'm just insanely excited about how much Will is learning from doing these professional analyses, and how much that puts him ahead of the herd - ON TOP of his already insane natural talent. 🖤

[@VestigialLung]

It’s almost upsetting how good Ren is at everything he touches, absolutely brilliant musician.

[@matttiggerward6147]

This song just grows every time I hear it… it’s just beautiful and haunting, the balance between Ren and Chinchilla is just insane, the mutual respect they have for each other is screaming in this performance. The videography is genius too !

[@Ontaros1]

Absolutely looking forward to this. There's so much good energy in this trio and I can't wait to get this song through their lenses

[@salishseamermaid]

OHHHH I can't wait for Elizabeth to do Chinchilla's Fingers live!!!!

[@danschultz4870]

We should be getting collage credit for this class these three are so awesome could you imagine a semester of them? I would pay premium for an online course of their music appreciation.

[@danielgeberth81]

12:22 anyone?

[@dropbarracuda]

I hoped you'd do this one... and then you go and drop a teaser for THREE professional musicians reacting to this beautiful peace?? I can't wait to hear what each of your inputs will be. THANK YOU for doing more Ren content, he genuinely deserves the attention and shine he's only now starting to receive. 🙏❤

[@Corvid76]

Is she a professional singer too? I've never heard her sing anything. Where can we hear it?

[@graceydez6199]

Its like the super-bowl of reactions. ❤

[@maryeckel9682]

​@@Corvid76she has a video reacting to herself singing in a vocal competition.

[@Voodoo_Actual]

Why is this trio the best thing to happen to reaction videos… ever… ? More please.

[@syanayde]

OMG, I am so happy you guys are doing this song!! It's unreal!

[@tylerspeiv2575]

Not sure what’s going on, but more Will and Elizabeth together can only be good things coming

[@sharoncarlisle9453]

I love this video so much!! Elizabeth, I'd love to see you interview Ren.

[@Jabadaw]

And let's not ignore the location selection. Chinchilla's final line underscores how the location not only make for a unique visual, but the natural reverb that Ren finds is always amazing. Much like the stairwell in Violet's Tale.

[@IratePuffin]

I’m surprised that Chris didn’t suggest y’all react to How To Be Me considering how excited he got during his reaction to it! 😂

[@kitwatson6035]

I hope that both Ren & Chinchilla see this. It would be such a trip to see 3 extremely talented singers in there own rights be amazed at your talents

[@jamesh2401]

Loved this group reaction! I really recommend you see Chinchilla's song "Fingers" performed live. It's phenomenal.

[@82gamerprincess31]

Something a lot of people don’t mention is how tallented Ren is at using a location as an instrument/effect. I am near positive that comes from his busking days singing outside or in tunnels where you really can play with how you sound. Violet is a great example when he sings up the spiral stairwell. Here he really digs into that loud reverb for power and softens to let it bounce around like a haunting echo.

[@syanayde]

This performance is so powerful, I get insane goosebumps every time I hear it, no matter HOW many times I hear it. Freaking incredible.

[@Ella-mj5vg]

I love Ren and Will Ramos

[@amandavanwyk5424]

I do too!

[@tyghe_bright]

Next, I strongly recommend Chinchilla Fingers -- the live version. It really shows her vocal technique and creativity, and has great shots of her face so you can see what she's doing!

[@tyghe_bright]

Also: To get more of Ren's vocal range, some of his busking... especially with Sam Tompkins, Earned it / Man's world / Falling

[@warmfuzzyfeeling]

I came here to say this - glad it's already been said! The official song video is super fun (especially when you know she makes her own hats!) but the live version is something else... she kinda makes me think of Kate Bush somehow.

[@rammilka]

You guys have to show Tale of Jenny and Screech, the masterpiece of storytelling, to Will

[@sharoncarlisle9453]

Yes!

[@nagyalex5310]

I concur!!

[@KCsFunHouse]

One of my favorite things Ren does with his music is getting across every emotion in such a genuine way. Nothing about his music feels forced.

[@r3dt3nnis]

Worlds colliding moment for me. Will Ramos repping a Ratio Beerworks hat, where I was the lead brewer the last few years. I started following this channel when I moved to Denver and am so thankful for the knowledge and introduction to new music. Will, thanks for introducing me to Sleep Token and if you actually went to Ratio I hope you had some good beer and a great time. Cheers!

[@Tonypurcell421]

At 16.31 chris goes into artists being good storytellers and straight away it made me think of will's work on the pain remains album that whole album is a story and as a hash vocalist will is also an amazing story teller that album in its entirety is an absolute masterpiece and will tells the story within it perfectly

[@melomaniac334]

This was wild for me as I was hoping Will would check out Ren sometime. It truly is awesome when the artists you love and listen to of various genres start listening to each other. Makes me insanely happy! Really like that y’all have joined forces and brought Will in on reactions sometimes. I am a huge fan and supporter of his and I know he is fascinated with all kinds of vocals - this is a great way to get his creative gears turning. I enjoy hearing his perspective and how he absorbs information from you, Elizabeth, and also Chris. Hope to see more of these!

[@Fraxxxi]

so on a scale from zero to yes, how are we feeling about "Ren X Chinchilla - Chalk Outlines (live) - one take vocal cover by Will Ramos X Elizabeth Zharoff"

[@BlackBryan94]

Holy crap that would be AWESOME

[@wolframvonstein7303]

On a scale from zero to yes? FCK YEAH, MFCKER!!! (Sorry, but to be far I AM hyped)

[@Oryyyt]

omg my YES. Take ALL of it!

[@glynnettleton9900]

Ooh yes please 🙏

[@archaeobard1]

I'm glad you posted this. It's one of my favourites, never failing to give me goosebumps and make me cry at the same time. So much emotion.

[@greenmonster4918]

I've watched around a hundred reaction videos since discovering Ren in February, and this is probably my favorite. The 3 of you compliment each other so well, & your enthusiasm is palpable.

[@slcncr]

What a *joy* to watch the three of you not only explaining professionally what is going on, but also at the same time let us see that *you* really enjoy what Ren is doing. The vibe, the admiration is great in this video. Thank you ! Edit: Yep, when Elizabeth gets the Goosebumps as soon as Chinchilla begins to sing. Same here. Always goosebumps. And when a voice, a style of singing can do that, it really touches your heart and soul on a level words can´t explain.

[@davidcarter5504]

I need more of this everyday!!!!! This collaboration is amazing. You all have an amazing well of knowledge when it comes to the vocal everything. Thank you for this.

[@ignoblesavage5559]

Will's having a tough time not (quietly) singing alone. It's pretty cute.

[@1over137]

15:50 Nailed it. The reason it is so emotional and so engaging is because it's real. It's not a pop song. It's not manufactured. Ren has a message and story (many) to tell. It's so refreshing... and deeply disturbing at the same time. In a good way. Something we should be disturbed by, reminded of and have our heart strings pulled with. Somethings shouldn't be ignored.

[@mldkenny]

Love your reactions and can't wait to see this one as it is without doubt one of my all time ( 50 years worth ) of favourite Duets!

[@davidberesford7009]

I have just watched this again. So much more relaxing this time around. Thanks again!

[@davids2676]

i hope ren see's this one day. this is 3 seriously professional singers just in awe at what he is doing. thats unreal to me

[@NotAMoralSaint]

I’ve been hoping you’d do this one next. Then I saw the line up on the thumbnail! OMG! This group reaction is going to be epic!

[@brettm41]

It is one of the greatest duets of all time, in my opinion. It's so powerful, and not just anyone can do it. Bravo, you guys in picky this song and artists 🎨 ❤❤

[@danielbeard7045]

I love how THE Will Ramos is speaking so highly of Ren's voice...Ren deserves every bit of attention he gets ❤

[@200shells]

Off subject but I want to tell Will that his latest song floored me! His clean vocals are incredible! Your talent is unimaginable.

[@janawham3296]

He's done more?! On his YT? Or his Patreon?

[@zachhenderson7982]

I was sooo hoping you'd do this one! Then on top of it, you bring those two with you! Going to be awesome

[@psychobetha]

two of my favorite artists i never thought would collide are Will and Ren. that it’s all 3 of you makes me so happy 😃

[@llchristensen77]

Same. I'm loving this! 🖤🖤

[@3dChris]

This collaboration between the three of them is just good for the soul. You all have very authentic child like smiles of excitement when listening, it's so much fun to watch. And each of you bring such different and complimentary insight. I hope to see more collab reviews like this. I was gonna play this in the background while I worked, but it had me glued to the screen, and smiling the whole time. Incredible dynamic. Thank you. Each of you.

[@nixpuk75]

That was excellent! Beautiful song, one of my favourites and a really interesting and fun breakdown of this glorious performance. Thanks 🙏❣

[@marcocrisari1901]

If they are going to make a harsh vocal duet happen I want to hear Will and Tati face to face. It would be something else.

[@heatherhobbit2931]

Exactly who I was thinking about, too! Elizabeth can make it happen!! 🤘🤘🤘

[@shell8481]

That is what I thought immediately as well!

[@rebeccaburnell9319]

From my perspective as a person on disability for the past 19yrs for depression and anxiety, the lyric "great big smile" - 100% bitter. He's expressing the anger and the resentment and the despair that he's expected to somehow perform "being ok" in interactions (often enough, even your therapists suggest that you "fake it until you make it" in terms of trying to maintain your social relationships). There's a sense that even with people who are supposed to love you and support you it's not acceptable to be yourself, when you're not okay; they want you to smile and pretend to be ok because it's uncomfortable and inconvenient and to be with someone who you can't fix, who won't be "fixed" the next time you see them or the time after that or the time after that.

[@dianeshelton9592]

Absolutely right , I get so tired of making everyone around me feel ok about me not being ok at all. It’s many years since I have been ok for more than minutes at a time and I support those around me. It isn’t fair for me share my pain, but I would so love to have someone just acknowledge for once , I am not ok and let me be ok. Actually I don’t think I could let them ackowlege I am not ok it might break me.

[@bellarebelrose5896]

Truly enjoyed you- all’s analysis of this piece. You each brought your individual expertise, insights, and knowledge to the table to create a fascinating experience! I also enjoyed watching your individual expression of appreciation for these two fabulous artists. It was a pleasure to watch and learn, thank you for the new perspective. It absolutely added to my appreciation of this song (didn’t think that was possible cause I already found it incredible, but now even more!!). Thank you!

[@elenaorujev3494]

Love this song and love your reaction/analysis!

[@mikebonecutter1869]

This is a power trio we all needed, always look forward to seeing you 3 together. Ren is amazing and chinchilla is just as amazing. ❤

[@donald1379]

This has been one of my favorite reactions to Ren...you guys are amazing ...thank you

[@MissMeKate]

Fascinating to hear the different insights from you all, united by your passion for music. Wonderful!

[@missmarlajean]

This collab is great! Thank you for sharing your insights and knowledge! Truly, sounds that I've heard a million times before become new again when I am able to learn and hear things differently from your point of view!❤

[@gothempress]

Your enthusiasm as you wait for the music to kick in is infectious!

[@robmullins]

I couldn't help but notice at 33:30 when Chris talks about Ren "tripping up a bit" and Chinchilla being like, "I got this" ... see the still frame captured in the video. It seems to express that perfectly! Nice synchronicity. :)

[@Cat_theft_auto]

Like “I got us”, how they’re intertwined in the journey and helping or complementing each other.

[@allisonkarnoff5135]

LOVED the collab here! Excellent insight from all of you!

[@boomerooni21]

I loved that deep dive! I got to geek out on one of my current favorite songs with some incredible insights. Thanks for taking on that song!

[@stevenmeyer9674]

Not often mentioned is how generous Ren is when he always gives the spotlight to the others he collaborates with.

[@andrejsandal2382]

WILL REACTING TO REN, OH MY GOD, CHRISTMAS CAME EARLY!!!! Edit: I can SO relate to Chris' little emotional "outbursts" during some sections of the song, and just his child-like excitement, I've never seen anyone else react to great musical stuff like this, glad I'm not the only weirdo! 😅 I've said it before and I'll say it again, I LOVE his passion for music. All of them bring something cool to the table, but I can't help but relate to Chris the most.

[@dougel4709]

Amazing job team! It was so enjoyable and insightful to listen to this through three professional ears.

[@nightshade7240]

The course you put together is extraordinary. So much information and camaraderie and you guys are so engaging and having so much fun with it and that's really what makes it fun. It's like if the instructors are having fun and giving themselves permission to look and sound ridiculous then the students feel way more comfortable doing so.

[@rowanrobinson]

This live version is incredible. The two of them are a perfect match and the lyrics hit so hard

[@LoW_CHeEesSse]

Ren is just so insanely amazing because very tiny little sound and kyric, matched with the guitat notes..its all telling a story, even his little ceack i feel is his emotions almost having a mental breakdown b4 trying again with a fake smile.. like he says. And he expands and outl8nes that fake smile part in his voice because his smile is just trying to push down his own emotions and put a sarcastic smile when hes truly suffering and his emotions conoletely MELD into one which is why his lyrics and kusic just hit that much different. Hes super authentic and he hits the soul.. and chinchillas voice truly conpliments it very well the way she comes in and then powerhits. Very cool

[@Ryan-31]

Really good insight by all of you like usual. Pointing out the raised background hiss by raising the soft quiet vocals in the mix by Chris was great.

[@bethscott4330]

Love seeing all three of you together!!! Great job.

[@defmonk0]

You all need to do the live version of How To Be Me. It's more of the same vein, and is absolutely heartbreaking.

[@200shells]

Ren, you're nothing but badass! Wish you nothing but #1 great health #2 incredible success! Nothing to discourage!

[@brandywrostad5657]

Just beautiful, was so hoping you guys would do this song❣️

[@forestduffe5576]

Love the Collab on this analysis! Great song!

[@jwarrior852]

Amazing that you 3 can sit and analyze a couple of new, independent, and not widely known artists! How many artists that are backed by industry would you do this for? Them going live and one take is genius! It wouldn't be talked about as much if it was studio. It wouldn't be special if the video was edited. They invite you in to experience their art❤ Beautiful

[@hobbsyboy]

The fact this was a live one shot makes the song resonate even more. So emotional and captivating. Oh and on a side note big respect for Lillith in the corner.

[@thegiantyeti1367]

Love hearing the three of you together with your different perspectives coming from different areas it makes for such a great breakdown and commentary. There were lots of moments in that song that you just think "well that's just amazing" but to hear it broken down as to why it sounds so good is a rare thing so thanks for being so diligent keep it up 😁

[@xx1CRU]

I love all 3 of y'all. I love the insight, the knowledge, the experience, also individual talent as vocalists. And I have no problem with pausing a decent amount... but y'all take it over the edge for me. I've tried so many times and I can't make it through an entire video. Maybe this just isn't for me, but I hate that it isn't because I really appreciate and respect your knowledge and insights. I wish y'all all the success in the world!! I have a great deal of respect for what you do. And for those that really enjoy the super, in depth(really deep), micro breakdowns I'm sure y'all are in heaven. I am just such a fan of Ren and especially thos song that I had to try again. ✌️❤️and respect to all 3 of y'all and your entire awesome community!!🫡

[@Odderetegg]

Another awesome REN joint is his live performance of Wade in the Water with his band, The Big Push. The vocals on that one are AMAZING. It really shows another side of REN .

[@ancltube]

Yes, it would be great to see a reaction/analysis of that one. It really shows what Ren can do with his voice.

[@Ella-mj5vg]

The Big Push - Wade in the water / Nina simone / Trouble so hard

[@Ella-mj5vg]

Yes, they really don't know how good Ren is yet.

[@bass021]

"Props to the audio production team". I think that might just be Ren.

[@anakein]

Lol yeah. He's like a one man army! :D Ren so inspires the solopreneur in me!

[@Lynds77]

Wow this was epic ❤❤❤ please please 🙏 do more reviews/ breakdowns / reactions with Chris and this awesome trio ❤❤❤ loved it

[@fresnokidsr]

This was a really interesting and cool video for me to watch. I love this song. It was fun to see how you guys kinda piggybacked off of each other to talk about what you were hearing in the song. Thanks for sharing this video with us. May y'all have a good one. Have fun take care I'm off to go check out that video now.

[@mattyball]

When you were talking about the human emotional elements in the voice I just call them imperfect perfections because that’s what they feel like , those are the feels that give you the goosebumps .

[@RockinRonnie111]

Ren is clearly an artistic genius. One of the things that I notice he often does is find these spaces where the acoustic resonance needs no digital enhancement on many of his live, one take videos.

[@natalie8698]

You three are delightful! Thank you for your thoughtful analysis.

[@AlanPritchard1977]

So glad you did this, i think i found this song 3rd into the Ren rabbit hole and it has quickly become my favorite song/performance i an long long while, i'm not even sure i can listen to it without goosebumps and a tear!