Vocal Coach reacts to Jinjer - Judgement & Punishment (Tatiana Shmayluk Live)

[@DataLupus]

It’s actually incredible how much you’ve learnt about this style of vocals compared to your Pisces reaction 😅

[@carlosp7994]

I'm waiting for someone to request Spiritbox for her. That girl can sing like whoa!

[@Deplorable_Garbage]

@@carlosp7994 ugh... octane has ran them into the damn ground.

[@DiskoKDiskoL]

She doesn't care and won't answer you

[@DataLupus]

@@DiskoKDiskoL you say this as if 1. I didn’t know she won’t answer 2. It hasn’t been 3 weeks since this comment was posted in the first place 3. It’s KZbin and literally everyone posts comments that the creator probably doesn’t even see but ok🤷🏻‍♂️

[@deadknightdistrict]

Lol

[@GeneralDecimate]

Beth Roars: I am learning to do false chords at the moment Me: *waiting ever impatiently for a demonstration video*

[@narcissus79]

There's a tiny one of her practising on Mary Z's insta..

[@schizomaru]

Roar

[@dnez1559]

Full Pisces cover lol

[@pauljeitler7678]

Haha look at our little Beth, starting to head bang away. We're slowly turning her into a metalhead! 😂 One of us One of us! \m/

[@KIRA-jk3xl]

She's always been inside, just hidden!

[@DestructionGlitter]

She's one of the most interesting voices in metal today. Her singing is different in every song, she's versatile and just well rounded as a singer. We love Tati!!

[@dwerggalago]

Tatiana is a totally insane vocalist. I mean: she can do pretty much anything and it will sound good.

[@1988Jay]

I've been a metal singer for almost 20 years, and I've never seen anyone explain the misconception of "pitches" in screams and growls as well as you do. All that and you are [new] to this extreme world. Very perceptive!

[@davidsimonds7963]

I urge you to continue with jinjer as you will discover Tatiana's vocal range goes far beyond this video.

[@nothingmusic42]

wait until she discovers Maria Brink, Taylor Momsen, Christina Scabbia, and Sharon den Adel....

[@dominikweber4305]

@@nothingmusic42 angela gossow too

[@brettpenning]

7:23 Beth, you don't need a sliver of her cool, you are cool and awesome!! From one ginger to another 🥰

[@skinflute]

I am a death metal vocalist for over 15 years and I not only use mouthshape but also tongue shape and placement. If I push it down and curl the sides I get an incredible low growl with some sort of metal rattling sound in it. Great video again. Love it

[@ivanjednobiegowiec7656]

That bring Alex Terrible in mind... Low, low as pits of hell themselves... Cheers! I.

[@schizomaru]

yaaaaas... when we will see Beth "Roaring" ? XD

[@Ugunark]

Oh my gawd, I would love to see this.

[@Ugunark]

*hear

[@Ugunark]

well, both

[@SempiternLOL]

00:10 you welcome :D

[@FanaticDrummer]

Oh you know if she learns shes gonna end up on a Townsend track.

[@rofyle]

In their new video for Home Back she goes way down deep into the false chord growls.

[@nigeldepledge3790]

Cool! I was wondering how she did that.

[@theopinson3851]

Yep...and jazzy clean vocals lol. Gotta love her.

[@mountainpeakcloud8442]

“Women can be angry”, Beth says in the happiness voice ever, lol. Beth is so cheery and positive all the time, I just can’t imagine her angry... or I just don’t want to imagine her angry, I think it would be shocking and scary.

[@schizomaru]

She would probably roar at you XD

[@enlightendbel]

She's a ginger with a Scottish accent, trust me, you do not want to see her angry.

[@cl8onj388]

Rumor has it she's a cereal killer.😉 Cheerios, Fruit Loops, Cap'n Crunch, you name it.

[@jamescurfman3284]

@@cl8onj388 Hm...this brings up a silly question for me... Do you think Beth likes Count Chocula? Franken-berry? Boo-berry? :)

[@johnkrstyen]

I think she would be absolutely adorable angry

[@EetYajKundorp]

Also, not sure if you’ve gotten the request yet but you really need to react to Spiritbox. Another phenomenal female fronted band. I’d recommend “Rule of Nines” or “Constance”, but that last one is a bit emotional.

[@muaddib4329]

god Constance hit me like a brick wall. So good.

[@InventSlaminate]

The song is cool but the vocals aren’t anything to react on

[@plantdesigns7889]

Blessed Be is another good one in my opinion.

[@helenajay2946]

Beth: Who'd have thought, reggae and metal? Skindred: am i a joke to you

[@GlockGrippa]

This comment made me laugh way more than it should've hahaha

[@DarkestofTimes]

my thoughts exactly

[@jamescurfman3284]

Well, maybe she has not heard of them. What's a great song of theirs that you would recommend for Beth to react to and analyze?

[@DarkestofTimes]

@@jamescurfman3284 see that's a tough one because it would be more entertaining if it was a good live performance. Hard to find from their early material otherwise I'd say Babylon is a great song. That being said I think I'd say Ratrace is the best one to react to in terms of having a music video and all that good stuff.

[@jamescurfman3284]

@@DarkestofTimes Thank you! In another comment, somebody else also mentioned them along with a few songs. :)

[@tribaltalker1608]

Beth, I'm impressed that you are learning how to produce extreme vocals. Best of luck with that journey! Please keep us updated and release a demonstration video when you feel able.

[@TheDjentleman77]

Yay! 😀 I was hoping that you would watch this one. She is one of my favorite singers atm. Incredible range. 🤯 I really hope I get to witness their awesomeness live some day.

[@metalhead7004]

the most attractive reactionist reacting to the most attractive singer. life doesnt get better than that!!!!

[@hotplums9353]

would so love to hear your reaction to Spiritbox - Rule of Nines - Courtney LaPlante live one take performance...especially if you enjoy Jinjer

[@tetsuyakuroko7608]

Yes, second on this one! Courtney is amazing! The entire band is amazing tbh

[@TotalxTroll25k]

Totally agree. They are both such amazing bands. They have different but really cool sounding screams in their own way

[@maximus11400]

Tatiana runs circles around Courtney. I listened to 3 of their songs and just can't get into them. One thing I do know it you can't compare the two bands. Jinjer is much much better.

[@tetsuyakuroko7608]

@@maximus11400 if you can't compare the band's, then don't. I feel the same way about jinjer, I appreciate what they do, but just can't get into them. Just a matter of tast, not whom is better

[@speoples20]

I would add their new song Constance. It's an amazing song.

[@picax8398]

I was just thinking about suggesting you a song by them and the notification popped up! I think you'd be blown away by the song "home back" by jinjer

[@GalacticCenterOG]

The kicker is she did in 1 take. I mean it’s not like no one hasn’t ever done one of their own specific song vocals in 1 take before, but she sounded so incredible and even throughout the entire song. Thanks for reacting.

[@gastonmansilla8654]

They just launched a new video. Home Back, I would love to see your reaction on that one

[@heatherhanlon2799]

Always love to get a notification for this channel!

[@programaenvion-mvl-1310]

Beth saying "Women can be angry" melted my heart and made my day.

[@larrybinmtn709]

Don't underestimate your own cool Beth. Your openness to new things and your knowledge and quest to learn more are pretty cool to most of us.

[@jefffiore7869]

Your Pisces reaction will always be my favorite. This is another great reaction, with much more knowledgeable than before.

[@CyberBeep_kenshi]

She is just amazing

[@paulreeves5524]

If I'm feeling down I watch Beth because she's so sweet and positive. Watching her reactions to Tatiana is like extra icing on the cake 😃

[@MrHerodoto]

Loved this video. As man that knows some powerful women I really love to see when they get so strong in what they do. Thank you for it, Beth.

[@TheCarJesus]

Oh My.... Beth it was so satisfying to watch your body rock to this music, and embrace this vocal style. Tatiana is an amazing vocalist. Makes it look so easy. Please do more videos like this.

[@alexdrada]

Beth sos un Ángel, cada día te quiero mas!!! gracias por tomarte el tiempo de estudiar detenidamente y sin prejuicios algo que es nuevo para vos, y ademas tener la generosidad de explicarlo. Beth you are an Angel, every day I love you more !!! Thank you for taking the time to study carefully and without prejudice something that is new to you, and also for having the generosity to explain it.

[@papalolobueno6125]

You're plenty cool enough on your own, Beth! Half a million of us come here for your expertise, so charismatically delivered. Sadly, few, if any of us, will approach that Beth/Tatiana level of cool! Ty

[@Duckyz.]

It makes me so happy to hear you’ve started to learn these techniques

[@christiancarter7563]

The band that really encouraged me to learn how to do harsh vocals. I’m 6 or so months in and doing pretty good. :)

[@louismarina7225]

I love how she is so relaxed doing all these incredible techniques she still has time to look down and smile at her cat :D

[@MikaTarkela]

I love how much you dig this one + you're like the cutest thing in the world!

[@genefidz2426]

Can I just say what a really genuine, beautiful soul you seem to have and your content is spot on girl, yours are the only vocal reacts i watch!!!! The original Pisces react is how I found your channel (love Jinjer & Tati) then stayed & Subbed coz you are 🔥 love your look & instantly I was crushing on u. not even gonna lie hehe. From this Kiwi ginger who watched a Scots ginger watch a Ukrainian Jinjer

[@eriknilsson2552]

After your 500k celebration I was waiting for you to watch this one! Great reaction

[@lukeprocopio3584]

Trust me Beth there’s at least 500k of us who think you’re awesome 🙂, never think you aren’t cool. We’re all individuals some of us have edginess, some of us are more reserved, but we’re all unique and that’s what makes life fun and beautiful, a wonderful adventure. “Rawr”.

[@pvilches06]

Wonderful reaction and commentary to such an awesome song!!! Tatiana never ceases to amaze and this is yet another example. I always love your videos Beth. ❤❤❤

[@arc6017]

Great stuff! Another good, enjoyable and insightful reaction (as always) to an amazing display of vocal skills from Tatiana. And this track is just superb! A brilliant composed blend of genres perfectly executed by Jinjer. Love it.

[@williampyatt3805]

I thought I heard this was a one take recording session for this song. She nailed it the first time out! Seems impressive to me.

[@onearthonelegion]

I love Beth. I love Jinjer. Thank you.

[@williamcody3415]

Beth, If you read the lyrics to this song, you will see how spot on your analysis was

[@CyberBeep_kenshi]

One of the best bands of the last years, and slowly gaining momentum. 🤘😎🤘

[@infernalsymphonytv2928]

Notice after the two verses when it goes into the middle 8 section with the extended section of screaming. How you visibly see her plant her footing so that her body is braced, grounding herself with good posture to enable her to tolerate to force of the sound coming out. Good growl/scream technique is as much about positioning and body posture as it is about throat relaxation and technique (much like other forms of singing)

[@rickleverette6963]

I definitely recommend Home Back, which they just released the video for yesterday, or Perennial (Live). In my opinion, those are the two most impressive performances Tatiana has done so far.

[@montv291]

So cool to see that after acknowledging in the Pisces video, that you were not familiar with the techniques she was using, you dove into it to learn more! I hope you do Perennial live at Wacken. It's my favorite!

[@baronofgreymatter14]

She is very adamant about her pronunciation. She works hard on her lyrics and she wants them clearly understood (paraphrased) ..Oh and you are cool Beth. Id have a beer with you any day!

[@jessaw8160]

Beth should react to On the Top live in Kiev. Stellar performance.

[@hoagsmash4188]

The unfairness of her limitless vocal ability, insane hotness and coolness.... Tati is EVERYTHING!

[@maaronsmith]

I've been waiting FOREVER for you to do more Jinjer videos! There's a TON more you should do by them. They just released a new video yesterday called "Home Back" you should definitely do this one. You haven't heard her go low until you hear this song and its got an awesome style switch up you would really like.

[@jessicacollins4042]

Great video, Thank you. I always learn something new from Beth :)

[@EetYajKundorp]

Always love your reviews, but these newest ones sound leveled up by 1000! So good! Both in terms of visual production and also professional/technical input.

[@Hemi_the_BlackSheep]

I love this. How you havent yet dont the official Jinjer - Teacher Teacher is boggling. by far their most impressive piece.

[@jonathanball8237]

Another Reggae-Metal fusion worth checking out is.... *Skindred -* _’Kill The Power’_

[@jamestalkington6306]

IMO, skindred's better tracks are nobody, rat race, state of emergency, and I forget but one other from earlier albums.

[@Xavyeah1]

@@jamestalkington6306 SO much more good skindred song even in new albums (Big things, that's my jam, warning, ninja and my favourite song is roots rock riot). For me I enjoy them more in live than in album cuz they give so much energy to the crowd.

[@jamestalkington6306]

Agreed on roots rock, and ik, ninja is good, but I feel like their later albums feel like the label was rushing them.

[@jonathanball8237]

@@jamestalkington6306 I think we can all essentially agree they rock thou....

[@tolypochkin3205]

Finally you did another Jinjer reaction. Thank you!

[@David-yp9ou]

Finally! 😁 Great video as always Beth.

[@rael2099]

Yes, there are many women "growlers", I've listen to several but Tatjana is the one I like the most and shocked me the way she shook you, her tone and depth is outstanding, and she can sing as well with natural voice.

[@AgainstTheeWickedlyMusic]

I've been loving Spiritbox lately, I'd love to see you check out the one-take live performance of Rule of Nines. Another great combo of beautiful singing and screams! 🤘

[@tonyharmon8512]

A band for you to consider is Wishbone Ash and their song The King WIll Come from the album Argus. They are believed to be the first band to use a dual lead guitar and this prog album was released in 1972. I don't believe it has ever been remastered so you have the original compression to about 30 db of headroom but it is still a masterpiece.

[@fletcherrutland6293]

she definitely owns all the “cool”...damn her❤️❤️

[@chillasslofi]

awesome. I've been waiting for you to do more Jinjer.

[@stangriffinstan_the_alaska9668]

Home Back is amazing. The whole Jinjer library is epic. I'm always down for Jinjer. I'm making my rounds of all my reaction channels lol lots of work to do. Peace and happy holidays to you from Stan the Alaskan.

[@thomasegner6111]

You should react to “who is gonna be the one” Live. Tatiana goes super deep

[@timpalmer2216]

Damn you've really expanded your repertoire when it comes to these harsher vocals fam gg

[@rodolfosaumafuguet2471]

Amazing take, you are great and she is amazing! 💥🔥

[@simonecasadei3457]

i'm not a singer, but i played guitar, and my teacher taught me funk even though I've never played funk (i played metal), but he tough me it to learn the rhythmic component of the guitar, in particular the shuffle rhythm. in that moment I undertood that a musician have to learn different techniques, like a different color of a painter, because it enriches you and can push you to experiment. but the important thing is that you have to be a good musician, regardless of the style or technique used. Tatiana is all of this. she is an excellent singer, in any technique she tries. here he goes from ragge to metal to clean as if it were nothing.

[@vanlepthien6768]

I love your reactions - your reaction to "Pisces" was one of the first reactions I ever watched, and I keep coming back. You might want to listen to the studio version of "Retrospection" and the just dropped video for "Home Back", in that order. I would suggest having the lyrics up. Very different sides of the same coin.

[@cydrych]

She is such an intriguing human.

[@rionsummers5939]

You are very cool in your own way! Nice reaction and Happy Holidays!

[@fatmanvidz]

really wish I would've went see them when they came do a show down here

[@arthurolson9297]

Finally! Thank you for reacting to this! I second the suggestions for Spiritbox - Rule of Nines - Courtney LaPlante one take vocal.

[@BTAColorado]

I've watched a LOT of reactions to this version, many by vocal coaches. Yours is the only one I've watched 3 times now. Don't worry Beth, you have several slivers of Tatiana"s cool 😘

[@crazydale1000]

I saw JJinger in Oregon last year while visiting my son. I thought that she used an effect on her voice like a guitar distortion peddle. Nope. That's her

[@philipgroves4186]

Yup I saw her in Vancouver Canada at a grundy theater, it was awesome

[@uoabigaillevey]

The breathing issue with growling vocals is technically solveable by using another technique which you may know about (or may never have heard of?) ... it is 'inhaled vocals' where the vocals are continued while inhaling.. I have heard of this but never specifically seen it on video. I have zero information, however, if it is damaging to the vocal chords or not and I would definitely recommend finding out before using the technique.

[@clipkaiser]

Love to listen to your explanations even though I‘m not really interested in vocal theory. If you would explain maths I would like it. Great Job.

[@martinlopez1091]

Para mí... Tati es increíblemente hermosa y su voz es una mezcla de angel y demonio. Gracias por tu reacción!

[@Brian_kj]

Waiting patiently the day that Beth will react to Courtney and Spirit Box. Since Jinjer already appeared in the channel a couple of times that day might be near. Finger cross. Oh, I love you Beth.

[@wally837]

Ginger likes Jinjer, go figure :) Seriously, good reaction. It is nice to see people expanding their horizons. I would like to recommend "Beggar's Dance". There is no official video for it, but it is on KZbin. Even if you decide not to make a video on it, I think you might enjoy it.

[@dougarnold7955]

Ah, she's back to the Jinjer...Sweet! 👍

[@miykaelp5284]

Ginger reacts to Jinjer ;) Love your videos ! Waiting for your future growl video..... Beth ROOOOOOARS!

[@sleeepwalk]

Great!!!! Should take a look at Yours an empty hope by Nightwish - Floor growls a lot here too... And Jinger is f..... awesome!

[@erlingkjrlien9629]

You must see Perennial live at Wacken. She’s amazing live

[@jesikats712]

that rawr at the beginning was cute lol. love the vocal breakdown. also yer very pretty ;)

[@BethRoars]

Rawr!

[@jasondelisle9128]

My first introduction to a woman screaming like that was Otep- Bloodpigs. Great band, you should react to them!

[@hb81]

7:50 Now there is again that beautiful moment when Beth almost loosing the fight :D Pisces had similar effect. Tati is GOOOOOOD!!

[@laurarestrepo100]

2:53 love how she gets in the mood again in 0.00001 secs

[@Marco-nu6dg]

Try Jinjer Perennial live at Wacken.

[@johnfish8208]

Please please more Jinjer 🤗👍👍 their new release Vortex would be awesome

[@Mike-wo3uy]

Beth talks about how she is really jealous of the lows, but I am reminded of when she was reacting to 'We own the night' and she missed Tillian's note because it was too high. Thanks for the effort put into these!

[@prmrdark]

Gracias por tus análisis, me encantan

[@stephenclark4114]

for metal and reggaes mix there is also Skindred

[@SPACEMunky47]

A song with an awesome mix of styles and intensity is stranger things by periphery. Worth a listen

[@danninielsen8876]

Gotta love that joyful and smiling face saying "Women can be angry" lol :D You are awesome

[@jayz9081]

I use to listen to a band that fused metal and swing together. That was over 20 years ago. Name of the band was Demonspeed

[@davguev]

Okay, I just listened to a song. I'm sold.

[@SoiledWig]

That sounds intriguing. The band that i know with the closest combo to that is Diablo Swing Orchestra.

[@davguev]

@@SoiledWig Indeed! That's what I thought as well.

[@jamescurfman3284]

Aw, come on, Beth! You ARE cool or I would not be subbed to your channel! You're AWESOME! And I know that you are awesome because you are actually trying to learn things that are out of your comfort zone (things that you had never even thought about before you started this channel)! It takes courage and willpower to stay with any training in order to get good at something. That's you, or you would not also be a vocal coach; you'd be just another couch potato (like me). You really have to give yourself some credit here. Happy New Year! Luv ya!

[@footnotedrummer]

I know that within this style of music, the vocals don't need to be super rich sounding all of the time. However... I'm amazed that she's laying down vocals for a major label release, using an AKG Perception 220 (maybe a 420?) microphone. Certainly, some people have been know to use cheaper (~$100) dynamic mics for major release (Shure SM57/58), but this is roughly a $100-$200 condenser mic. Typically quite a brittle microphone too (I have one). Many vocalists will use a Neumann U87 or a Telefunken U47 (both range between $3000 and $12000). This is a testament to good recording techniques and the fact that you don't need to spend ridiculous amounts of money on a high end microphone to get a good vocal take. Would her voice sound better on those high end mics??? Sure, but again... within this style of music... the richness or body that those high end mics would give her voice, would likely be lost in the mix anyway.

[@joshuamcclung3558]

Nice reaction...liked your pieces reaction as well

[@Rosannasfriend]

amazing. I love Tatiana.

[@Dismas444]

Beth; If you want to experience the first fusion of reggae and metal (or rather, ragga and thrash, called Thragga), check out the British band Skindred. Absolute bangers, every tune, but my favourites to start on would be either The Kids Are Right Now, Doom Riff or Warning.