Voices Of A Generation - Crosby, Stills & Nash, Still In Perfect Harmony

[@jennifercole6045]

Miss you David. The world isn’t the same without you❤️

[@ChenBen-y6n]

David is talking too much wherever he is

[@thelonelyghosts9004]

Wow. What a catalogue of music they gave us. RIP David

[@catmom1322]

I'm 69 & I have loved these guys for a very long time.

[@MikeHinshawNomadicTexan]

I'm 73 and right there with you. Actually met them all, after several years of being a fan, backstage in West Palm Beach at an open air concert. I will never forget it!

[@nanrachlin7891]

Concord CA 2006... absolutely incredible!!! The perfect harmonies, the whole package, a night to remember that I will never forget!!!

[@jeffreyjacobs390]

David is one of the most talented singer / songwriters I ever heard .....who was just a viper's temperament and egocentric curmudgeon .... his life nearly lost twice, his carelessness and hurtful assaults on others - Graham especially .... and finally more recently ran out of luck ...... and stage to grace and croon "All Along The Lee Shore" ..... All three herein phenomenal !!

[@CheyennefromTaos]

I saw CSNY at Winterland (a former ice skate rink converted to a light show concert hall) in San Francisco just after Neil joined. Everyone would bring a blanket, a snack, and a joint. We all lay down and watched the most amazing light shows while listening to the intro bands, waiting for CSNY to play. It got real quiet.... then this high pitched clear voice... "Be on my side baby 🎶 .... (Down by the River song) and I sat up completely melting inside. That was Neil and I had fallen deeply in love with his voice. I had been to Woodstock just before he joined CSN. To this day, I still love listening to their songs. AMAZINGLY BEAUTIFUL AND PROFOUND BLEND OF TALENT 💎💜💎

[@michaellewchuk8272]

CSNY was at woodstock together.

[@pbrucpaul]

I saw them on their Last Tour performance in '74 at the Oakland Coliseum California. They went right into "Love the one you're with" and really got that crowd going. Even with outside acoustics, they still sounded great!

[@dannyd1572]

Seen them and was in radio so I got to interview Graham. Great guy. Sincer..down to earth. Nice.

[@leftymadrid]

Wonderful, totally special voices, reminding us of great times of the past! :-)

[@sandmtnirishred]

These men truly changed the world

[@sandmtnirishred]

@@wallacecleaver4485 yeah, hard to believe in ways, but you're not in my seat😁

[@sandmtnirishred]

@@wallacecleaver4485 No. I was born on the Army Base in Nuremberg, Germany in 1972, since that's where my Daddy was stationed. He was discharged honorably in 1973, and Mom had divorced him and remarried by 1977. The Louvin Brothers, Alabama Band in country music are my cousins. Other musicians hail from this area. As do uneducated idjits that actually DID support Roy Moore for our Senate. I'm very good at BOOK LEARNING. I taught myself to read musicand play Chess by the time I was 6 years old. Sacred Heart Gospel and Hippie Folk/Southern rock.

[@sandmtnirishred]

@@wallacecleaver4485 I said you'd have to see it from MY seat. It's a line from a song they did.....

[@TheSaltydog07]

They should undo the damage.

[@bronzester]

Saw them in Rio de Janeiro, May, 2012. They're better than ever !!! Peace !

[@jane-mariegifford1156]

It's the sound of your voices we want----always

[@bartstarr100]

Stephen Stills and 2 harmonizers.

[@MikeHinshawNomadicTexan]

Stephen Stills has always been my favorite musician. I'm 73!

[@kevincoontz6417]

These three very talented men have made some of the best music , the best to me personally. Neil added to the group but they did awesome without him as well .

[@paulduffy8774]

i was glad to meet these guys in person me and crosby had a great talk about one of his albums the one with the three of them on the couch with the old house well they werent sitting right so they went back but the house was torn down sorry

[@joshuafuller9898]

Put 'em all in a room together today, and it would look like a bar fight in a retirement home. So much for putting the drama behind them.

[@MikeHinshawNomadicTexan]

This interview was in 2012. Now ten years later Crosby has passed away and he and Nash hadn't talked in years before his death. 😭

[@GeorgiesMom723]

I watched this to hear Stills. He couldn’t get a word in without interruption.

[@ginnybloomer5132]

To me Stephen Stills was the true talent

[@damiant2441]

Each one of them is an amazing talent alone but together they are once in a lifetime.

[@michaellewchuk8272]

@@ginnybloomer5132 they are all talented. Stephen controlled the studio though, that's for sure. The CSN sound is a byproduct of Stephen's drive and technical savvy.

[@MikeHinshawNomadicTexan]

​@@michaellewchuk8272not to mention his guitar playing!

[@writereducator]

In their 60s they are positive and full of gratitude.

[@aundreadalrymple714]

70's

[@writereducator]

@@aundreadalrymple714 Check the date--10 years ago!

[@dggydddy59]

@@writereducator they were all born in the early 1940's.

[@ericgarrett9155]

@@writereducator This was 2012. Crosby born Aug. 1941 he's 71. Nash born Feb. 1942, he's 70. Stills born Jan. 45, he's 67.

[@claudermiller]

I saw this tour. I felt privileged.

[@ceejay1794]

Love that Croz gives credit to McCartney for inspiration. He’s a solid fan of The Beatles, check out the press interview in Pasadena (I think) 1966. Croz was there

[@oppothumbs1]

It John was their inspiration, then they would be able to write as well as Neil.

[@michaelrose3101]

@John Brown Seriously John and after dirt diving McCartney has just gone to Number 1 with his latest McCartney 3.

[@markzappasodi]

It was the Beatles second to last press conference in Los Angeles.

[@swingmanu]

their analyse about Lennon and Neil Young, "the hard edge", is so right!

[@oppothumbs1]

THEY ARE RIGHT BUT NEIL YOUNG IS UP THERE WITH DYLAN AND BETTER TAHN ANY OF THESE WRITERS (what has Crosby written - 4 decent or good songs and a one line from 8 miles hight. THESE GUYS ARE WRONG ABOUT PAUL BEING A BETTER SONGWRITER or having better melodies THAN JOHN. Best Beatle songs: Happy just to dance with you John A day in the life john I need you Harrison If I needed Someone Harrison That boy John I’ll Follow the Sun Paul Eleanor Rigby Paul I'm only sleeping John not a second time John she said he said John I feel fine John I am the walrus John ticket to ride John Penny lane Paul She’s Leaving Home Paul Eleanor Rigby Paul no reply John please please me John and your bird can sing John you've got to hide your love away John in my life John all my loving Paul all you need is love John two of us Paul you're gonna lose that girl John you can't do that John hard days night John bad to me John anytime at all John Daytripper John glass onion John Girl John Hey Jude, Let it be are not good songs and long winded

[@michaelrose3101]

@@oppothumbs1 gee you left out plenty of even better songs by all of John Paul and George while still The Beatles

[@Gazpacho8]

I love how they have the nerve to ask them about Neil after he totally ditched Stephen on the BS tour with like 30 dates to go. Leaving him holding all the mess.

[@buddysteele7624]

They had all made up since then over and over

[@MikeHinshawNomadicTexan]

The group is so much better when Young is not with them! Interesting comment on them getting along, but this was 2012, ten years ago before Crosby and Nash decided not to talk to each other! Stills is my favorite musician of all time! That man is magical when he wants to be! Wow Stephen just gave a shout out for Brandi Carlisle. I can't agree more!

[@Illnevervoteblue]

Young was notorious for just getting up and leaving a tour

[@bobmarkowitz5457]

They are the best

[@govertvandelaar2504]

With ny

[@danielbrady2357]

Yeah, agree but three part harmonies in pop music was started by the Beatles followed by the Hollies which became a natural progression to CS&N.

[@michaelrose3101]

Basically spot on.

[@joshuafuller9898]

Now the Beatles invented three part harmony in pop music? Jesus. Ever heard of The Andrews Sisters? The Lettermen? Peter, Paul, and Mary? If I thought a bit, I could come up with more. All were the pop music of their time.

[@SteveCarrDrivesAPrius]

As they brag about their eternal friendship, here we are in 2018 and they will never speak to each other again.

[@RoyFive]

but that's happened before.

[@lastnamefirst4035]

Now into 2020

[@BlueEyes-gp8lg]

They were already fighting behind the scenes when they did this interview. Nash was just doing his public relations thing. The slow-motion car wreck took another three years (December 2015) to finally screech to a halt.

[@ashleyburns6752]

Although the digital era has arguably contributed to the death of artistic and meaningful music, it has also allowed kids to go on KZbin and ignore the crimes against humanity you hear on the radio and instead listen to all the greats of the 60s/70s. I was lucky and heard Hendrix when I was 13 (21 now).

[@michaelrose3101]

Good on you Ashley hope you have continued with your great attitude 6 years on.

[@technodroog]

sounds like someone judges the entire generation on music based on a cursory listen on mainstream radio. There was plenty of cheese and blandness in the 60s/70s, too.

[@michaelgraham9774]

@@technodroog This

[@poettree52]

Yes, it's annoying that Neil is brought up here. That tour wasn't the only one he quit during their partnership. Stephen has said that Neil left a lot of people connected with that tour out of work last summer too. He says he's "not mad" at Neil. What a forgiving guy! I think I would not be so generous.

[@MikeHinshawNomadicTexan]

Exactly. Young walked out on Buffalo Springfield with 30 venues left on the tour. I am not Young's biggest fan! Stills is my favorite musician and has been for decades!

[@RoyFive]

Nice of you to cut Stills off at 2:08, lady. Way to go. YEEESH.

[@MikeHinshawNomadicTexan]

Typical interviewers!

[@pippipster6767]

This interview was only just the right side of awkward

[@davidsghost4993]

Nice!

[@solaroberto7435]

Love

[@yvescourtois6434]

Oh i love you!

[@donreed]

"Dirty Ol' Charlie Rose, brought to you by BARF!"

[@BlueEyes-gp8lg]

Known in the industry as the "Crusty Paw" for his inability to keep his hands off of young female co-workers.

[@donreed]

@@BlueEyes-gp8lg And the Dirty Old Bastard got away with 99% of it before he was FINALLY fired.

[@lastnamefirst4035]

@@BlueEyes-gp8lg eww hard for me to watch him now creepy

[@scillyautomatic]

AND YOUNG!

[@lastnamefirst4035]

"Everything is good" not for long fellas, meaning soon after this they won't be speaking to one another

[@michaelrose3101]

They weren't at your time of comment for quite some time because of Crosby.

[@lastnamefirst4035]

@@michaelrose3101 Happy New Year to u. It just turned 2021 in Az

[@michaelrose3101]

@@lastnamefirst4035 Happy New Year to you Sammy it's now nearly 9pm New Year's day here in Victoria Australia and still quite warm. Although it's Winter in America guessing it's still pretty warm where you are. All the best for 2021

[@MikeHinshawNomadicTexan]

​@@michaelrose3101and Crosby had issues with several groups. I talked with Roger McGuinn after a concert in 1969 in Ft Worth, along with Chris Hillman. Roger said the reason he was no longer with the Byrds because of his drugs and inability to get along with the band.

[@michaelrose3101]

​@MikeHinshawNomadicTexan No doubt. I spoke to Hillman in 2012 and I mentioned to him Stills and Nash signed a record cover for me,but David no chance.

[@CheesyCola1]

Nash about McCartney: "The kids good"

[@malvavisco10]

Cheesy Cola *kid's

[@tosinoparinde9563]

I like Gerham Nash

[@damagedangel08]

Now we don't know where this CD is, it went away!!

[@BlueEyes-gp8lg]

If this was the kind of promotion it got, then no wonder it disappeared so fast.

[@rickkaylor8554]

Too bad this band is dead. Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young is definitely dead. Crosby burned all the bridges. So sad and a true loss for all music lovers.

[@jamescoughlan8193]

Wish Graham would let the others speak

[@dosemeter]

Well.....shizit.....If I have to be the first to post, I will! CSN, baby...betta recognize...

[@patrickfennell6372]

The big surprise of this video is Charlie stays dressed.

[@2Uahoj]

Why in the world do interviewers constantly ask the same stupid questions, "why do you keep doing it?" or, "if you were not doing music what would you be doing?" Would you ask this question to a banker, a doctor, a news moderator or a university professor? Or does it mean that they don't like what they are doing and want them to quit and do something else? What is the point??

[@MikeHinshawNomadicTexan]

Why also do they always keep interrupting them. That is infuriating when they ask a question and will not allow an answer!

[@fanmaxis3004]

was this beffore they fell out again?

[@BlueEyes-gp8lg]

Yep. This interview would never happen now.

[@MrCathyarnold]

@@BlueEyes-gp8lg yep stupid asses., gotta love em.

[@pmc1649]

I like the mappy thing in the background.

[@CooManTunes]

2:20 - Nash was WRONG. No good music rises to the top. Mainstream has been utterly destroyed for a decade now.

[@nataliabarker2321]

I love Crosby to me he’s still a cool dude, don’t know if I like Nash or not he’s seems a bit full of himself

[@123456pfloyd]

apparently Crosby is a bit more of a jerk out of the 4 of them (see Nash's interview "he tore the hear out of CSNY" as well as what Crosby had to say about Young's newest wife; a statement he'd late retract). *sidenote: I absolutely love Crosby!

[@nicholasroberts6441]

Sunshine Ray. Try finishing his biography. He's so far up himself but not averse to savaging those around him.Lent book out to friends to hear their take on it they agreed.

[@oppothumbs1]

Wrong. And not as much talent either.

[@laura.sefchik]

💫CSN 2012 Concert DVD Preview (2min,30sec) promo =>> kzbin.info/www/bejne/n5PQgX2sj5mLjbM 💫Crosby, Stills, & Nash join forces for their first live performance video in over 2 decades! Filmed during their 2012 tour, CSN 2012 includes many of the trio's classic hits, some new and unreleased songs, and a rare performance of "Suite: Judy Blue Eyes." The disc also includes 'A Conversation with David, Stephen and Graham,' plus interviews with their band and crew. 💫 Set list: "Carry On/Questions," "Marrakesh Express," "Long Time Gone," "Military Madness," "Southern Cross," "Lay Me Down," "Almost Gone," "Wasted On The Way," "Radio," "Bluebird," "Déjà Vu," "Wooden Ships," "Helplessly Hoping," "In Your Name," "Girl From The North Country," "As I Come of Age," "Guinnevere," "Johnny's Garden," "Learn to Live (So Begins the Task)," "Cathedral," "Our House," "Love the One You're With," "For What It's Worth," "Teach Your Children," and "Suite: Judy Blue Eyes."

[@ChrisLawton66]

Wonder how that harmony is holding up?

[@darius595]

What does Stills say at 4:57..." I like his songs" pointing at Nash and then what does he say pointing at Crosby?

[@gacela19722]

He just states that he prefers Crosby and Nash music.

[@MikeHinshawNomadicTexan]

He says, after listening several times that he likes Nash's songs and then likes Crosby's songs, but one of the interviewers interrupted him as they did several times!

[@kancho4]

Gord Goble, I don't understand people like you. Not only is your comment negative and lacking any purpose, it is an oxy moron. You say you have no interest in anything they have done , then why on earth do you waste your time looking at them on this site? These guys are musicians and visionaries, their talents and harmonies at the top. Please look at your life brother, I feel it may be lacking somewhere.

[@clivemoney4548]

re sword graham nash is a nice guy and far from tiresome

[@TheRiceowlex]

Damn Graham is talking reality with people who work for a mainstream media corp ? Wishful thinking..

[@dadduorp]

"Mainstream media" is the result of American capitalism and unfettered regulation AKA corporate monopolies. Other countries have publicly-funded media but everyone here in the states (at least, the right wingers) always cry "SOCIALISM! to that idea. You can't have it both ways.

[@cappystrano1]

Hey Charlie Rose, now there’s a guy that changed the world!

[@rosalindalay4499]

I don't like how everyone could of buried the hatchet n just had a good aura amongst friend s..at least Croz dud what he could..

[@johnwinger2240]

I waited and Nash seems happy as young is absent from the csn egg. Calls Neil dark lol

[@jamescoughlan8193]

Not fair it was crosby young had issues with not Nash, Nash and young are still buddies

[@ST-xg3gy]

What's Charlie up to these days?

[@dazg4299]

lol Painting collecting yeah thats how normal folk spend their time

[@LesRadley100]

verryyyy debatable

[@donreed]

This reminds me I gotta go check the NYT obits.

[@nancytreiman587]

Cream rises to the top and the grounds go to the bottom floor of the Universe or Galaxy. I'm into the Milky Way. They go one way, and I go the opposite.

[@garybrinker4522]

Are these guys making anything new? I know Neil Young is..

[@sdot5389]

No. Crosby is on the outs with both Nash and Young for years now.

[@davidp7178]

"Is all of that in the past now?" Sure until David trashed Neil's GF (Daryl Hannah). That ended any hope of a reunion or any friendship or anything other than distain toward David. They will never play together again.

[@bethcrumpton476]

Yes. Daryl Hannah. The woman for whom Neil left his wife of nearly forty years. Pegi. Who has since died.

[@dadduorp]

@@bethcrumpton476 Daryl Hannah. A real basket case.

[@ardalla535]

The questions were geared toward the general, which is to be expected on a show like this. So they didn't say anything surprising or even substantive. They might have said the music today is just crap. Many of the old artists such as Keith Richards will tell you flat out what they think: “There is no new rock ’n’ roll. It’s pointless. There’s great musicians and some great singers and stuff. Unfortunately, to me, in music, it’s been synthesised to death,” Richards harshly stated. “Once you start synthesising things, you’re not getting the real thing.” He then added, “I don’t want to go into a long discourse on what’s wrong with synthesisers and music these days, except to say they’re cheap and corny.” Instead, Nash just offers some trite statement about how there's always been good music and bad. Does he really believe that or is he just trying to alienate anyone?

[@elmerexpress]

PDowns: Here's a couple thoughts: The olders almost always trash the youngers. Hieroglyphs from Egypt tells that very same story. On the other hand - what would you think Mozart would have done with a synth? Talent seeks expression and finds it. It has to be heard and seen on its own terms, though...

[@frandanco6289]

These 2 news people are totally clueless about C,S,&N.... They did absolutely no work into at least learning about them before this interview...

[@Obiwannabe]

I loved Neil's last couple of albums, sorry david. As much as i love CSN they are still not trying to reinvent them selfs like neil does constantly.

[@PlainVidz]

I can't believe someone hasn't told Stephen how silly that goat beard looks on him

[@lifelong5425]

Amazing guys, talking or not....But the never ending sensation that Mt. Nash is all about himself never leaves me...Watched a Hollies doc recently, and it was back then that view arose. Watching this interview said it again.....Thank you for the music, but it would be so much better if he toned it down a bit....It was a group, not one person.

[@CapAnson12345]

If Stephen Stills shaved off that silly facial hair he'd pretty much look just like he did 50 years ago.. too bad his voice is shot.

[@ginnybloomer5132]

Not helped by the fact he's deaf

[@swingmanu]

As we say in France: never insult the future... And, to say things the simple way: "Neil is neil" and there's no way around it... Neil happens to be the only one who's actually still a star...

[@MikeHinshawNomadicTexan]

You have to be kidding. Stephen Stills is the best musician in the group and can sing great. Young is always leaving tours and people holding the bag. Like with 30 venues left on the Buffalo Springfield tour he just left, leaving the rest of the group to pick up the pieces. He has walked out on these guys several times also. His early music was great, but I cannot agree he's the best musician left.

[@chipblock2854]

Too bad that there is a 98% chance they will never again sing on a stage at all. CSN has died and that's that!

[@fanmaxis3004]

Hulk Hogan on left?

[@bartstarr100]

Everybody hates Crosby

[@robinjones6999]

how come Nash is really the only one who talks sense

[@ginnybloomer5132]

Because Crosby and Stills didn't get a word in. Nash monopolised this

[@josesouza1561]

Woodsckok 1969.Fantástico.souza SP.brasil.abc.

[@TheSaltydog07]

Geez. They hated each other. Like an old married couple.

[@jubeegrooves2]

...and at (6:15) she refers to Graham as Stephen. Ridiculous.

[@BlueEyes-gp8lg]

Typical network host idiot

[@raphaelkoster6099]

Stils and crosby need to start listening to eckart tolle

[@MikeHinshawNomadicTexan]

Have you heard Brandi Carlyle who Stills brought up? I just heard her with Willie Nelson in a Dolly Parton tribute. She is fantastic!

[@Braglemaster123]

She’s cute “‘

[@IwanttoliveinParis]

Stills' nose sounds like it's full of candy.

[@BlueEyes-gp8lg]

It used to be...frequently :)

[@sdot5389]

He’s nearly deaf, has been since childhood and getting worse with age.

[@robertpeck6916]

Like their music, hate their political veiws!!

[@dadduorp]

No one cares what you think.

[@jamesfitzgerald6636]

Stills sounds drunk!

[@thomasromano9321]

He's partially deaf due to years of playing at high volume.

[@lastnamefirst4035]

Probably was usually is according to him

[@MikeHinshawNomadicTexan]

He's partially deaf from all the loud music over the years. I am guessing he's probably very self-conscious about it and doesn't talk strong, because he's not able to truly hear himself. What is worse for me is the way the interviewers keep interrupting him.

[@plant1deep4u2]

I wanted Charlie Rose to shut up . . . I liked her question "What else do you like to do?" besides music . . . He ruined the interview and I ordinarily like him.

[@FSEVENMAN]

Graham Nash is an angry little man......

[@theart8039]

Graham Nash annoys me for some reason..he's a bit gobby

[@anglodutch8321]

Nash talks too much !

[@seanjockel43]

Not

[@vacancyforlife]

got to laugh at this.

[@rosalindalay4499]

Grahm smh..wt..

[@MrRhmccabe]

Thank God the Byrds kicked Crosby out of their band.

[@kai326]

Yeah and where are they now? I’m glad Gene got out while he could, rest his soul.

[@MikeHinshawNomadicTexan]

I was lucky enough to hear the Byrds play in Ft Worth Texas and my date and I walked around to the backstage door. It was open so we went in. McGuinn talked with us for about an hour and Chris Hillman for about 45 minutes. Both said they just couldn't handle Crosby's drug habits anymore. Probably one of their best decisions!

[@antoniobernetarrebola4153]

En español

[@uncatila]

These guis are left wing ballad singers

[@uncatila]

@John Brown Rejection Steven Stills stood school boy like Flowers in his hand With the gift of a guitar new made Martin brand Begging her to keep him Judy Blue eyes stared Steven went on stamering saying that he cared my now Steven that was nice said the hippy Qween We can be the best of friends I m not really mean Your not Gordon Lightfoot and I am not your bud Go on back to Croz and Nash Il never be your blood.

[@MA_808]

never heard of this boring trio before

[@markpatterson2764]

Graham Nash is the worlds most boring rock star.

[@BaahBen]

They stopped being able to sing years ago! They should be ashamed of themselves for taking money for their horrible voices.

[@mr.timebombman2230]

At least they actually sing. Can't say the same for all the pop artists that lip synch and people don't care, cause they still go and see them.

[@professormacdeezy]

Croaby's voice was awesome still 2000-17 or so. havent seen him since then but even last time i saw him he killed it. Nashs voice was still good too Stills voice has been pretty wiped put for awhile but hes a phenomenal musician

[@brunobarks6544]

Thanks for your valuable input.

[@millenniumcorp7334]

CSN was and still is... a great trio. Never liked when Neil joined them.....honestly.

[@robertwiesler381]

That's an interesting comment Exactly the opposite for me😊

[@MikeHinshawNomadicTexan]

Can't agree more. I also will never forget Young walking out on Buffalo Springfield with 30 venues left, leaving Stills to carry the tour.