Why Are Commonwealth Soldiers So DUMB? (Full Analysis)

Install Raid for Free ✅ IOS/ANDROID/PC: clcr.me/ClashedPR and get a special starter pack with an Epic champion Kellan the Shrike 💥 Join a special Valentine’s Day-themed adventure ❤️ raidlovequest.plarium.com ❤️ with the Raid Love Quest to win some fantastic in-game and real life prizes 🎁
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
In today's video, I go over 3 potential theories as to why the troopers of the Commonwealth were so dumb. I adapted the theory from a Reddit post (I have unfortunately lost since), and if I find it again, I will make sure to credit them here in the description.
Thanks so much for watching :)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Raid: Shadow Legends “Raid Love Quest” Prize Promotion. Entry is Open to legal residents of THE 50 UNITED STATES AND THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA (EXCLUDING NEW YORK AND FLORIDA), who are 18 years or older. VOID WHERE PROHIBITED. Open only to NEW users with a valid Player ID that downloaded Raid: Shadow Legends and opened a Game Account after January 1st, 2023. To install Raid: Shadow Legends for Free, click here clcr.me/ClashedPR Downloading Raid: Shadow Legends is subject to Plarium Terms of Use [plarium.com/en/legal/terms-of...] and Privacy Policy (plarium.com/en/legal/privacy-... ). In-game purchases are available. NO PURCHASE NECESSARY TO ENTER OR TO WIN A PRIZE. A PURCHASE DOES NOT IMPROVE YOUR CHANCES OF WINNING A PRIZE. Prizes: in-game items or Amazon.com Gift Cards, in the value and number as described in the Promotion Official Rules raidlovequest.plarium.com . ONLY ONE ENTRY IS PERMITTED PER PERSON. Additional Terms may apply on Amazon.com Gift Cards as set forth here: amazon.com/gc-legal. Prizes will be rewarded randomly and subject to eligibility requirement set forth in the Promotion Official Rules. Promotion Period: February 14th at 00:01 - March 14th at 23:59. Sponsor: Plarium Global Ltd. Administrator: BRAME AG. Personal Data will be processed in accordance with the Privacy Notice raidlovequest.plarium.com

[@ClashedPR]

Install Raid for Free ✅ IOS/ANDROID/PC: clcr.me/ClashedPR and get a special starter pack with an Epic champion Kellan the Shrike 💥 Join a special Valentine’s Day-themed adventure ❤️ raidlovequest.plarium.com ❤️ with the Raid Love Quest to win some fantastic in-game and real life prizes 🎁

[@daddyshome275]

Dude congrats for your first ad . I think so

[@TBCL3cky]

I loved it

[@ClashedPR]

@@daddyshome275 yes it is, first time making money from this channel!

[@daddyshome275]

@@ClashedPR You deserved it . 👏 Congrats bro once again

[@laserx430]

Love the vid

[@anonymistubis]

I love how in the comics a soldier would prove that his armour is devour proof by going up to a horde and the armour would ACTUALLY protect him but in the tv show the soldiers would get devoured by zombies easily through their armour 🙄

[@dessirangelova2676]

Yeah movies always do stuff like this star wars has the exact same problem with stormtroopers

[@noahtylerpritchett2682]

@@dessirangelova2676 stormtroopers are Kickasses in video games. They're paper in plot armor scenes

[@noahtylerpritchett2682]

@@user-hy5hs2wk2i clone wars is great. Stormtroopers have as much Quality as clone troopers. In comics, books and video games anyway

[@WallNutBreaker524]

​@@noahtylerpritchett2682 thats what happens to pretty much any minion 🤦‍♂️

[@thepro3k_watches656]

@@dessirangelova2676actually they are really good with there shots, they where order to capture them not kill them

[@shanenonwolfe4109]

I wish they showed off how good the armor worked like in the comics where we see one commonwealth soldier walk through a herd with no problem and come out after saving Eugene or someone

[@keztannis6848]

Let's be honest, they won't. They'll be like the Stormtroopers where they're only really badass in the comics and and only becomes competent in the show if the plot demands it.

[@TheMattsem]

Still I don't think it has a place in a zombie apocalypse world look at it look like it come from Star Wars or Star Trek

[@Trace240]

Plate Armor Mobility kzbin.info/www/bejne/p6u3qHWHo85_icU

[@daddyshome275]

"Why commonwealth soldiers are dumb ? " Plot needs it .

[@altheuss]

They are NPCs

[@raypowerfulmc4551]

​@@altheuss fr

[@mrhammergaming2052]

@@altheuss they are stormtroopers

[@Nic-og2qq]

Reason I stopped watching after the lab was blown up at the end of season 2. Or season 1? I can't remember

[@sweatybeanz808]

​@@Nic-og2qq you should watch it all

[@MASTEROFEVIL]

In the comics they were actually more intimidating. But in this show they're basically stormtroopers

[@SpartanJoe193]

Agreed

[@liamphibia]

Exactly! They're Stormtrooper knock-offs, both appearance wise and personality wise.

[@Gabiman66]

Hell no stormtroopers are competent in star wars, we see them win multiple battles and kill enemies, unlike these guys

[@liamphibia]

@@Gabiman66 If we're talking comparisons, yes.

[@mr.e2239]

Honestly I will never understand why people don't use ARMOR against zombies or why writers act like it won't be effective. It's not like these zombies are carrying guns or even basic melee weapons, their only weapons are decaying teeth and finger nails. Hell even makeshift armor made out of cardboard and plastic would be effective.

[@therealgreg5653]

There is a new anime where a guy gets a special diving suit for shark tanks that is "bite proof" actually works haha

[@Qwty163]

In my opinion, The Walking Dead's Commonwealth soldiers could have been more interesting if they were divided into different tiers, such as red, yellow, and white soldiers. For instance, the red tier could feature a character like Mercer, while the yellow tier could include skilled survivors and ex-military personnel, alike to the Reapers but with slightly less skill. Finally, the white tier could consist of beginners. This approach could have made the Commonwealth soldiers more dynamic. Just imagine a scene where the IQ and teamwork of the yellows are on full display, giving our protagonists a hard time, followed by another scene where the whites are easily defeated by the group.

[@proceedproceed7494]

would yellow be obvious in a firefight

[@nikoscott145]

@@proceedproceed7494 Well they're already wearing white

[@griddenheimer]

@@proceedproceed7494 scavengers have almost ran out of ammo so idk who’d be shooting at them and they’re literally coloured bright red and white

[@brianachim2670]

How about a mostly black Commonwealth armor? That’d look sick.

[@Wall57k]

why does this say 15 yrs ago?

[@KatiesNippleTardis]

4. Never encountered walkers That’s what I felt when watching the commonwealth soldiers like they’d been living under a rock and hadn’t actually encountered walkers much like the prisoners in the prison arc

[@gametvon98]

bruh they have encounter just watch the video again

[@nfkhalifa7896]

​@@gametvon98 read the comment again

[@theboy6888]

Right, they’ve never had to deal with hordes because of their security precautions. They’ve only killed walkers in small groups.

[@regslime2411]

I bet they dont even have a shooting range for the soldiers. Thats why their aim is shit. I feel like the reason is because they're just handed a gun after knife fighting walkers immediaty after they do that

[@Mad_Skeletron]

@@regslime2411 they also don't have unlimited ammo, so they can't waste bullets for training

[@maskedninja6883]

I find it sad that the survivors can take down a militarized force

[@SwedishEmpire1700]

The Woke Force gotta survive ya know

[@mechanomics2649]

@@SwedishEmpire1700 God, shut up.

[@giftzwerg7345]

yea especialy head on, like its fine if they outsmart them on a bigger scale, but the fact that they can take them head on out numbered and out gunned just makes it meaning less

[@Dan_Edittz]

dumber than Commonwealth soldiers were the Terminus cannibals, the guys didn't even check their tasty Bob's leg, or even Carl in season 8 who instead of at least giving a dignified death Worthy for him they caused him to be bitten in such a silly way and in the fourth season he was cornered by 4 Walkers and was not injured💀

[@MyBrainGlows]

to be fair. This shows have to be set in another universe where people are not able to slowly walk away from a even slower walking enemy with an exposed and esay to eliminate weak spot.

[@thepro3k_watches656]

To be fair the director at the time when the actor for Carl was playing, he didn’t like the actor and wanted a way to get rid of him quickly

[@bryanemilius1606]

Really? What an ass!

[@joserios4409]

​@@thepro3k_watches656 A director getting rid of an actor just because he didn't like him just makes the show even more terrible.

[@dakotaheeren7468]

@@thepro3k_watches656 so he resorts to a cop out excuse? bad writing and a bad director. plenty of ways it could have been handled better.

[@xxxx5872]

the commonwealth was so goofy 😭. i honestly would’ve preferred if they just went full crm or variant walkers for the villains of the season

[@danielcarithers3345]

Nah that’s crazy. They’d never make the zombies the main threat of this zombie show.

[@xxxx5872]

@@danielcarithers3345 lmao

[@ClashedPR]

@@danielcarithers3345 😂❤

[@perkshaven]

@@danielcarithers3345 bruh i swear if it was up to yall TWD would literally just be 11 seasons of the protagonists fighting Walkers. nothing else, no human antagonists or anything

[@danielcarithers3345]

@@perkshaven Well then don’t make it a fucking zombie show then if the zombies are nothing more than overgrown mosquitoes that the main characters never have to worry about.

[@BlockImmigrants]

It’s the plot armor mostly They perform well against non-important characters and perform badly against important characters because the main characters need to be on the show further on. Also since they’re many in quantity, the writing makes them easy to kill. That’s my perspective

[@The.Frenchie]

But at least they know how to shoot unlike Stormtroopers

[@furiouspheonix2019]

Yeah so true 😂

[@BlastingXNP]

Disagree. The amount of times they would shoot at the main cast and miss every single shot was staggering.

[@XotiicYBA]

@@BlastingXNP plot armor

[@daddyshome275]

That's so true actually.

[@savageaches4519]

I mean probably cuz of ptsd/trauma/getting distracted The armor weighing them down Probably the commonwealth soldiers just messing around things they can not take it seriously cuz they be wearing armor when in reality should be more attentive and not underestimate the situation

[@TerranPlanetaryDefenseForce]

The goggles do not destroy your peripheral vision as much as you think. Armor is a good idea, but they went full Stormtrooper mode instead of properly designing it.

[@huntclanhunt9697]

Stormtrooper armor is great... Or was until Disney took over. Pre Disney the comics and books stated most Stormtroopers who get hit are wounded, not killed.

[@TerranPlanetaryDefenseForce]

@@huntclanhunt9697 That's not what I'm talking about. I'm talking about the fact that the armor is just a bunch of loose plastic plates instead of plenty flexible slash and stabproof materials. The armor does nothing because zombies just keep biting the neck and joints. Even if they were wearing actual lore correct Stormtrooper armor, we'd have to just assume that the black basesuits can resist cuts and punctures.

[@manjoring5944]

​@@TerranPlanetaryDefenseForceback the gambeson and chainmail medieval drip

[@TerranPlanetaryDefenseForce]

@@manjoring5944 100% High Drip Easy to make with some wire from Home Depot and Fabric from a Grandma Store.

[@coryfice1881]

@@huntclanhunt9697 "Stormtrooper armor is great" Literally cracks apart the moment a small rock hits them

[@Trxlyy]

Commonwealth soldiers in the comics were so much better than the show

[@perkshaven]

ehhh, they were way more competent and capable in the comics but thats about it

[@poncho9960]

@@perkshaven yeah, that's what "better" means

[@astartesfanboy5294]

@@perkshaven thats better

[@Varsus_]

Yes, but militarily in the series they were better equipped

[@abdulansari3666]

​@@perkshavenyou in the comments just to argue aint you?

[@THEDOYLER]

the common wealth made the walking dead feel a bit wonky and made it more of a govenor and a detective show had a kid

[@ess6608]

Last characters of TWD from TV and comics feels like they're from a comedy show... Princess and these stormtroopers

[@panspermiapancakes]

@@ess6608 To be fair, it seems like they toned down Princess going into season 11. Her clothes didn't make her stand out anymore, at least not like that pink fur jacket she had at any rate. They seemed to tone down her personality as well and made her slightly more "normal" as a functioning adult. I think they had intended on exploring mental health issues with her as a result of her traumatic past before the outbreak and her isolation during it. They mostly abandoned it though in season 11. She was still quirky, but also seemed more mature. They kind of made her a "voice of reason" in the final season.

[@sauce8148]

The show simply died when Rick disappeared...

[@THEDOYLER]

@@sauce8148 thats true when rick left there was a big hole in the middle

[@jeroenvanede]

I'd rather have plastic armor than no armor vs zombies. But the series has strange power level differance. Some times zombies rip people open as if there made of cake. Sometimes they can't bites because there is tape around a arm.

[@onewhotalks1943]

According to the zombie survival manual zombies are no stronger than the average human the only difference is that unlike humans zombies do not have pain nerve endings. So when a human would be come fatigued or felling hurt enough to force them to stop. A zombie with just continue with out stopping.

[@digitaal_boog]

@@onewhotalks1943humans have a limiter as well. It’s why under high stress or fear, you could get some skinny kid suddenly be able to lift weights that would impress a bodybuilder. Your muscles are so strong that they will rip themselves apart if the body doesn’t limit them. Walkers wouldn’t have such limiters, which may explain how they are able to bite through thick clothing and flesh easily, overpower a person despite being emaciated and seemingly frail, and how they managed to tear people apart when enough of them get a hold. They’re actually a lot stronger, at least when they have some muscle mass left, and can use all their muscle with no limit.

[@onewhotalks1943]

@@digitaal_boog The zombie survival guide by mat brooks covers this as well

[@MASTEROFEVIL]

Remember in season 4 when Glenn wore police riot armor and casually walked through a large group of them?

[@mindset2501]

Wow, I have never noticed that Jake Daniels and Green were those Commonwealth soldiers who were killed by Negan and Elijah.

[@ClashedPR]

Neither did I! It was confirmed on the wiki.

[@sagastudioss]

this is probably my favourite vid from you, you can really see the effort thats been put into your videos in the past couple months and your already at 1 mill congrats

[@zoknowmation451]

For real 🎉

[@ClashedPR]

Thank you so much man ♥♥

[@m_rkroblox2888]

At least they aren’t stormtrooper stupid, like they actually shoot the zombies. sometimes…

[@parkeranimations3671]

Loved how you put Scott gimpe as a threat

[@rency1803]

In the comic you have one soldier proving their armor is biteproof by walking into a group of zombie. Also just from the look we can already tell that the armor doesnt have any exposed part that let them get bitten easily. They just die cause plot need them to.

[@TY-PO]

Get ready for a small rant… Now, I don’t have much knowledge on the comics, but from what I saw, the Commonwealth were a legitimate threat that needed to be taken seriously. Their armor was very protective (they even criticized the crotch armor at one point). On top of that, they were functional soldiers that could be taken down without resorting to too much plot armor. What happened in the show?!

[@SobaOfPulaski]

In the comics a grand majority of them were active-duty and reservists as well as National Guard pre-apocalypse along with veterans. I think there are probably some veterans and soldiers, marines, airmen, and sailors who joined up post-apocalypse, but I doubt it would be too much as a grand majority of them died at the start and most units ended up sticking together as evidenced in Season 3, rather than joining any larger groups.

[@MASTEROFEVIL]

Are you talking about those army guys the governor killed?

[@SobaOfPulaski]

@@MASTEROFEVIL Yeah, the Georgia Army National Guard unit. Also, Robert Kirkman generally speaking is quite anti-military and it was one of the reasons why the military is portrayed as so incompetent [also because if they were, there would be no show].

[@aarons0z992]

@@SobaOfPulaski he could at least try to explain it a little better than just "plot"

[@SobaOfPulaski]

@@aarons0z992 I do not disagree in the slightest there 😔

[@aarons0z992]

@@SobaOfPulaski like the TOWL plot about operation cobalt being so difficult because of the fact that the national guard and army both had conflicting orders and generally coordination being a mess was a pretty good reason for their failure

[@deltasrage97yt]

The Commonwealth Stupidity Level: 40,000% Genius Level: 0%

[@ryanelliott71698]

There was plot armour in prior seasons, but the plot armour among the Commonwealth soldiers was bs. I just couldn’t take them as a threat

[@bearmusic4986]

7:40, to be fair it's a totally different scenario when your shooting at someone unarmed vs someone shooting back. Given that the soldiers never fought anything but walkers the stress lvl of being shot at in plastic body armor would overwhelm their senses causing them to point and shoot instead of aim.

[@saltytexasranger6301]

I personally had a serious problem with how both the Commonwealth stormtroopers and the Alexandria survivors kept using full auto against the walkers...

[@Skeene60]

Same. I’m rewatching it, constantly saying “switch that shit to semi & put down accurate shots. It’s not hard, no wonder there’s barely ammo left”

[@weeblordgaming6062]

@@Skeene60they shouldn’t run out of ammo given that they are in America

[@overlord1676]

I think that resistant boots for crawling zombies, bracers for emergency situations and a miner helmet as a precaution for falling debris and flashlight holder would be all you need as armor against the zombies. Bare minimum protection for unexpected situations and accidents but also full mobility to escape

[@huntclanhunt9697]

I've worn a helmet with goggles not too dissimilar in shape to their for airsoft. It really doesn't limit your vision much unless the goggles fog over.

[@gamer0066]

You can really see the effort put into this video you're definitely my favourite youtuber at first I only watched your shorts but ever since I've discovered your videos I can't wait for new releases and also, CONGRATS on 1 MIL!!🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🥳🥳🥳

[@elliottgaal9774]

What a way to make a fearsome adversary into a comical level enemies. Their armor is actually good in the comics anyway. Polymer armor is lightweight (when compared to kevlar and trauma plates) and the goggles don't really obstruct as much you would think. They're like ski goggles. I would prefer to be in the armor personally as it means should I get swarmed, the zombies cannot get to me as easily. Thus increasing the time for my squad to save me.

[@Mr-dw5zq]

Dude you are such an underrated content creator! Congrats on your first sponsor, and reaching 1 Mil🎉🎉🎉

[@stevengroeneveld7406]

What I wonder most about is the distance between the Commonwealth and places like Alexandria and Oceanside. I mean they have been at Alexandria for a long time, how tf did they never see any troopers or hell, a city with walls and 50.000 people😂😂

[@shanenonwolfe4109]

Well our characters are in Virginia, specifically the Washington DC area and according to the show and comics the commonwealth looks like they are some where in eastern Ohio. So they are like around 300 miles away from one and another. And since cars aren’t really around anymore walking or going by horse would take a week or two of traveling

[@stevengroeneveld7406]

@@shanenonwolfe4109 ahhh ok makes more sense now. They travelled quite a lot then, knowing they started in Atlanta

[@Hurricanelive]

When a group is expendable it makes you not care about them, and there are no stakes. It's like GIjoe killing a bunch of robots, or in Star Wars killing a bunch of robots or killing a bunch of faceless storm troopers. It's merely the writing trope of faceless expendable minions to make another group look more powerful. It's the stormtrooper and red shirt fallacy, as long as you aren't in combat against plot armor or alone with the main characters you probably aren't in trouble, but heaven help you if you are, then you fall into that tropey memey gunna die zone.

[@Sumschmuck]

Commonwealth soldiers suffer stormtrooper syndrome, needing to be a threatening army in the plot, but also being useless enough to ensure that the main characters don't get gunned down or tossed in a concentration camp by act 2

[@timothybailey6281]

Fr

[@The_Purple_Duck87]

They're exactly like Storm Troopers bright white armor to stand out, when they're facing side characters and non important characters they're killing machines but as soon as plot armor kicks in they start to turn incompetent missing all their shots

[@NilsNone]

all gunbattles in TWD are kinda plotarmor heavy. even back in the prison they were landing headshot after headshot with guns that had makeshift silencers but when it comes to shoot at people suddenly they are the stromtroopers trying to shoot at Lea and Luke.... it has always been something I felt was offputting

[@BHendrikx]

Lance Hornsby said most of the soldiers were just “kids in their twenties”

[@sheeshsheesh5439]

Congrats on 1 mil!🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@kq3u]

congrats on 1M man you are growing so fast!

[@m_rkroblox2888]

Tbh there was some bad writing, for example: when we see Magie and that small group meet the reapers, negan gets shot in the leg and never says or does anything about it. He doesn’t even limp or anything. So ye there was some bad writing.

[@perkshaven]

that part where Negan gets shot in the foot doesn't count as bad writing cuz he gets shot up at his leg.but then pulls out the arrow, and then we dont see him for a bit after that.

[@bendynamic2150]

From what I remember the armor is good unless the plot and moment in the story says it's trash. It's a mix of Bad writing and maybe Outdated Training. Bad Writing is the biggest.

[@crimsonshadow1649]

The scene where Carol and Darul were escaping with Hornsby in tow and the soldiers were shooting at them in a Corridor yet still somehow missed every damn shot had me LOLing so hard.

[@basedpirate]

Congratulations on 1M ‼️❤️✨

[@Memelord6999]

Congrats on 1 million love the videos keep it up

[@amytapess]

I remember I continued watching the show a little after season 9 came out, the only text I got was “since when did stormtroopers get added in?”

[@themagnificentorange672]

CONGRATS ON 1 MIL 🔥👑😩

[@Zinnywiththespinny]

u deserve all ur success keep up the good content, brother.

[@Movies_Spot]

Congratulations bro on 1million subs 🔥

[@The_Undead_Survivor]

Congrats on 1 Mill 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@Havox_Editz]

CONGRATS ON 1 MIL🎉

[@VikIsAwesomeLikeAlot]

CONGRATS ON 1 MIL !!!!!!

[@maxwellquipey1]

Funny fact: In the letter hacks that are shown at the end of each issue of the comic, in #174, the issue before the New World Order arc which formally introduced the commonwealth, the last letterer called the gaurds stormtrooperz based on the cover for #175, and the fact they have terrible aim in the show 💀💀💀

[@DaroXs2]

CONGRATS ON 1MIL

[@colmgoulding]

Congrats on 1m subs you deserve it your my fav TWD yt

[@greaterhalo0659]

Commonwealth soldier's in the comic's we're far superior to there TV portrayal.

[@MakiMadara]

Congrats on 1mill!!!

[@andgeekin]

Congratulations for 1 million subscribers and for you first sponsor on this channel!!!

[@yellowsausage7714]

They have to be, this show is a joke, it should be called The Walking Plot Armor. They have characters explaining their plan to the bad guys... man

[@MangosCinema]

Congrats on 1M bro

[@meliiina_4647]

I somehow noticed that the commonwealth's soldiers look like Star Wars soldiers and I can't unsee it.

[@choco.munchiez]

It's funny how their armor practically does absolutely nothing

[@nickholas2233]

Interesting that you just made this video right when I'm struggling to finish season 11. Been watching one episode every week and a half or so, a lot a things seem a bit ridiculous and you already pointed out a problem I've been having. The main characters emit an aura of stupidity and anyone against them is caught in it. Doesn't really feel like there are any stakes.

[@ClashedPR]

Exactly. The cast became so big yet the stakes become less higher. Really disappointing from Angela Kang to do that.

[@karlonka7455]

It’s amazing how "Hearts still beating" has become an integral part of every TWD video, love it

[@neofulcrum5013]

It’s important to remember these guys were more fit for anti-walker operations, not human v human battles. Although I’m hoping they’ll be better prepared against the CRM.

[@nevyanplamenov5409]

They are bad even against walkers lol. I know it's just dumb writing, in reality they will be a badass military

[@onewhotalks1943]

You also have to take into account that they do not have the logistical abilities like a conventional army before the walkers roamed the earth. In conventional military you go to recruiting stations talk to a recruiter or several and have several appointments fill out paper work. Get a ship date for MEPS Military Entry Processing Station where you fill out more paper work your physical, mental evaluation, finalize and singe your military contract swear your oath and you get shipped out to basic that day or if you are in a delay entry program you wait any where for several months to a year before shipping out to basic training. If you fail at any point in this process you cant be rejected and try again later or you are PDQd perminatly disqualified meaning you can not try to enlist again. Not to mention a huge back ground check and several things you cant join like felonies. Basic training for argument sake lets us the USMC basic training which is three months and for non combat marines you got to a month of more advanced military training before you go to you job for school. Combat marines go to their job school like SOI or school of the infantry which is another three months for more advanced infantry training then you go to you duty station. In basic they do even more checks on your back ground and if anything comes up you did not tell them during MEPS you are done no Marines or any other branch for you I'm not going into the marine raider force recon as that is a different animal by itself. Are main focus here is what is the bare bones requirements to just get to the fleet as a basically trained marine. I know I am missing many many things here this is just really basic stuff I am covering here. Once you get to your first duty station is when you are actually in the USMC the same goes for other branches. With the common wealth they do not have the time to do all of what I have talked about above. No time to do a back ground check because the internet is gone and good luck trying to pull court records you just have to take people at their word in not all but most cases. In the beginning when they come to the common wealth they are taken into custody and are hounded with several days of interviews. No mater how well you think you are interviewing someone, people still manage to slip through the cracks. When we see Daryl and Rosita in basic training for the common wealth and all of the other recruits is that the numbers that they are replacing because that's how many soldiers died or deserted or injured. We do not now how many of the soldiers die in a month and they need to be replace and unfortunately you are pulling form a large portion of people that are not qualified or up to the task at hand. Murser probably got orders on high we have this many open slots that need to be filled fill them they all "pass". Forcing him to lower the standards. talk to any one in the military and when the standers are lowered quality suffers. I would not want to be Murcer or any of the officers in the commonwealth military from the show because you are given an impossible task with many people who are not qualified to do it and when you fail its all on you because the people on high could never admit that their standards and policies could be wrong. When the standards are lowed quality suffers

[@mote_vengador2832]

It's just so silly they made the whispers better than a hole group of survivors some with ex military experience the show it's a shit show at this point negan is keeping it alive and barely btw

[@outrider425]

@@onewhotalks1943bruh those guys are lacking basic common sense and you don’t need crazy amounts of training to deal with braindead corpses one can easily outwalk

[@chrisbelit1599]

god season 1-6 was such peak i miss it. especially season 1’s and 2’s writer 😩

[@atlg9949]

When I first saw them in the series, "Stormtroopers" came into my mind immediatly by how they looked. Well, wasn't expecting to see they were actually as dumb as a stormtrooper...

[@cobraazazrl6422]

They are literally the walking dead version of stormtroopers 💀

[@TheRealRickGrimes]

0:45 Look at this man trying to make money💀

[@ReinEngel]

3:59 I see what you did there (twice) and I love it.

[@invisible_editzzz]

Your at 1 million subs now congrats 🎉

[@jamesm2078]

After thinking they look like stormtroopers and got killed so easily, this video was like hearing myself ramble about them. 😂

[@alexanderdixon8217]

Congratulations on 1 million 🎉

[@logan-vq3dm]

well i feel like the armor makes sense since we have scene armor does protect you from walkers, like riot gear will protect you from them and the armor they have will protect them from bites but wont stop them from being ripped apart in a horde

[@MiguelTheWorldIsYours]

Yo congrats on 1M

[@wondeler322]

in the scene (the first that we met commonwealth) a soldier ask princess some questions, omg, anyone else noticed that he was a damn NPC, for example: Soldier-where are u from Princess-where are my friends Soldier-how old are you Princess didn't answer and the soldier asked a different question

[@demian_csomic_winters9484]

One idea for the episode was that they show both competence and incompetent soldiers, competent ones are actually trained for threats such as people that were accurate at shoot escapees, but show these competent soldiers maybe slightly different uniforms, was killed in a reasonable way for story, leaving the incompetent soldiers that missed everything for two minutes, the incompetent are basically just normal people not bothered to really to be trained, while competent ones actually knows what to do, for room clearing a few zombies seems fine for incompetent soldiers while competent ones handles other things such as hoards and other not so simple threats as walkers in smaller rooms.

[@funkyreapercat5280]

Can you talk about Telltale TWD games someday? Please

[@UMCorian]

I am all about the Stormtrooper outfits - kind of amazed it took people *this* long to design "Walker Combat Armor". You see people 12 years into the apocalypse fighting in short sleeve shirts FFS. These Stormtrooper outfits just needed a few tweaks. First: Helmets are bad, your best weapon for offense and defense vs walkers is keen hearing and full visual perception (video touches on this - it's not that they're stupid, it's they can't hear or see anything in those). The walker you can see and hear is not a significant threat - it's the walker you can't that gets you every time. Clear or 1-sided Face shields and open ear head-gear is the way to go. Second: Surprising lack of variations - the Stormtrooper outfit (minus the helmet) is great for small, surgical operations that won't last long against a small to medium amount of dead - like raiding an infested building for supplies. For guard duty in relative safe zones, you'd want about half that armor covering key vital areas - but designed not to be cumbersome so it can be worn in heat for hours on end. Armpits, thighs and parts of the core unprotected for maximum heat loss. Hordes, you want to sacrifice even more protection - if you're in melee vs. a Horde, the only thing that'll keep you alive is being fast, quick on your feet to avoid being flanked and not tired. The armor fails at all of those. I'd just keep modified headgear, neck coverage, shoulder coverage and one arm covered (so you have the option to shove it into a zombie's mouth while you deal with it or another - similiar to padding used to fight of/train attack dogs). So, having the full stormtrooper set have velco components to allow easy stripping of key areas would make it much better. Some things it does right: White. This is a Walker Combat Suit. You want to be very visible to non-walkers so you don't get shot. The material - polymer is perfect - it's light, cheap, easy to create and will stop human bites and claws. That's what it's designed to do - anything more than that is pointless. If you need to defense vs. weapons, you're no longer fighting the dead and there should be a whole new outfit designed with that agenda in mind. And holy hell this got long. I promise I have a life.

[@ianjoshzapanta743]

3:35 like bruh this got me. Somehow i got convinced with this one clip

[@I.Am.Legally.theLORAX]

I love ur content soooo much thanks for lighting up my day dude

[@Peto_IL_DUCA03]

whats the song at the end of the video? i remember hearing it in a twd finale episode

[@chaoticwj1772]

Can you compare the Commonwealth armor to the armor/uniform used by the CRM?

[@random_evo_guy9120]

There a line from the channel Oversimplified that best describes the commonwealth soldiers camo, "spot the hidden soldier"

[@melonam]

it's the storm trooper argument all over again, they wear tons of armor it means they have limited sight lines, they get exhausted more quickly, and also you have you realize their training is quite limited from what we saw in this season

[@yeetingmobs1884]

bruh they got their armour from a starwars paintball arena and their goggles from a scuba diving centre and their scopes on their guns from wish

[@Unbeknownsttt]

video idea: How did Walkers become smarter? like in season 1,2 and 11 and fear the walking dead seasons 8 and further

[@Homophobic_racist_sexist]

Ain't no way these guys were the final villians army

[@AchillesofOblivion]

Congrats cookie on 1mil and the sponsor

[@AlSpohn]

ive watched u since 1k but i forgot i wasnt subbed😅

[@Buzzer_Bee]

How do u make thumbnails like that?

[@twd_thomass]

CONGRATS 1M WWW!

[@TWDgs]

I know

[@Pozy-]

1 mil LETS GOO

[@alexandertodorov6373]

Remember Star Wars? They just took the stormtroopers😅. I absolutely loved season 11(actually the whole universe). It was a little strange at times, but...😊

[@lukasmaxa8700]

one thing i can say from experience in airsoft when we shot a target moving in a straight line we hit all the time but if he target is armed you naturaly try to dodge the bullets ant take cover wich trow off youre aim so this is excuse to eliminate bad writing but that is just how i see it

[@goliathsaber2455]

I have to agree it’s a bit of the three as well they were trained to hand inclosed areas and a small amount of walkers and they just stand there not even looking around there surroundings , there armor was just useless and blocks most of there felid of view they also look very heavy or at least make it hard to run and climb and the writhing for them is bad

[@roi6075]

Very well explained, I agree with you with everything, seasons 1-8 are just something different than 9-11

[@86TheMedia]

I would have a chain mail suit shirt and pants underneath my clothes. That would work. I would want armor, because in a horde situation, it could save u. It's light enough too. Believe it or not.

[@liamphibia]

You must admit though that they absolutely NAILED Mercer from top to bottom. Dude look like he came RIGHT out of the comic book.