Why I LOVE The Last of Us | A Retrospective of Living

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks for watching guys! Make sure to vote on the poll I made on my community tab on what game you want to see next, and if the game isn't there leave a comment to see if other people want to see it! Edit: I just released a discord server that you can see on my community tab! Hope to see you there! P.S I try to read literally every comment if I can, so be sure to drop some opinions you have on the game and I'll hopefully be able to respond!

[@crusader2112]

Hey man, great surprise, for the next game are you going to finish Telltale Walking Dead Season 3?

[@magmalecreme]

@@crusader2112 I'm trying to diversify the games I do so looking at the poll it seems Until Dawn is gonna be the next video. After that I might do a shorter video on a game with less story, and then ill probably return to TWD

[@crusader2112]

@@magmalecreme Okay, no rush. I’m just wondering if you’re going review the other final two seasons. Peace ✌🏻 and keep up the great work.

[@magmalecreme]

@@crusader2112 i will for sure 100% make a video on the final season. I flipping love the final season, but the third seasons a bit more iffy so it might be a minute before I get to it lol. Thanks!

[@crusader2112]

@@magmalecreme Fair. ✌🏻

[@ryanharlowbass]

The cut from henrys suicide to the black screen and text sends shivers down my spine every time.

[@magmalecreme]

Me too homie, me too.

[@Lunabyes]

Same here. It's been years since I first watched that scene, and I've probably watched it in 25 different playthroughs, but it always makes me burst into tears. Both of them were so young. They deserved better :'(

[@magmalecreme]

@@Lunabyes I know, they survived for so long only for a random bite to end it for them.

[@dakotaeldridge7369]

I remember the first time I played the game, after the screen cut to black post Henry/Sam's death I had to set the controller down for five minutes and process what had just happened. I don't think any game has ever emotionally affected me like that.

[@AlphaQHard]

@@dakotaeldridge7369 Am I the only one who didnt care that much?

[@aleccadena9061]

When I first saw Sarah pass, I was 21 years old. It was such an emotional scene that of course I shed some tears. Now as a 28 year old father of a little girl, that scene makes me ball every time I see it. This series means so much to me in so many ways. My nickname for my daughter is baby girl and I’m always reminded everyday how much this game has impacted me. Thank you Joel, Sarah and Ellie.

[@ZacksRockingLifestyle]

Please don’t take this as me being rude, but I believe you mean “bawl” and not “ball.” Anyway, Sarah’s passing was such a well-done, tragic scene.

[@MadChatterYT]

I remember June 14th 2013 quite fondly. My brother told me there was a mix-up with his preorder and I'd have to wait for my birthday present next week. After everyone went to bed, he woke me up and told me he forgot to give me another gift. I was given a shoe box and guess what was inside, this amazing game. The opening scene hit even harder cuz it was my birthday

[@magmalecreme]

Thats super cool. I wish I played it near when it came out, I actually played it for the first time in March of this year.

[@cflo1386]

That's a good brother.

[@heezmagnif]

What a great brother

[@mrturner4620]

I wouldn’t say Joel necessarily “doomed” the world by saving Ellie. In the second game there’s a lot of evidence of incompetence from the fireflies showing they might’ve not even had the capabilities to create a cure to begin with. It’s very possible that if Joel let her die that a cure still would’ve not been created

[@magmalecreme]

Yeah and even if it was created it would probably just be used to control other people

[@twoohsimp1412]

the immunity that she had couldnt work on others so it wouldve just failed and she wouldve died anyways

[@magmalecreme]

@@twoohsimp1412 ig we have no way of knowing, either way im glad Joel saved her lol

[@cjvaye99]

at first I thought Joel was wrong but the more I thought about it...he probably did the right thing. Not just because of what you said but also ask yourself if humanity in this story is even worth saving? Lots of raiders, hunters, cannibals and all kinds of freaks. the world lost it's humanity so there is nothing to 'get back'. Besides the world here isn't as f*cked as in TWD for instance as there are still patches of safe cities quarantined and safe for the most part. then like you said even if they managed to make a cure how the hell would they get it out to everyone? Why do I feel like they'd keep the cure to themselves only give it to the elites take themselves somewhere safe and live happily ever after and just leave the rest of society in the apocalypse.

[@stevebeltran9179]

In the game there are firefly logs that the player can find that shows that ellie was not the first immune person the fireflies had and despite trying to create a cure they were unable to create one

[@brandonclarke436]

“Even if you think what Joel is doing is wrong, you don’t get a say in the matter.” I know this is about part 1 but I can’t help but feel how relevant this line is to part 2

[@magmalecreme]

Poor Joel lol

[@noahalderman5774]

this is by far one of the best reviews for this masterpiece of a game

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks!

[@duran4689]

I laughed when the missing battery from the truck was in the truck yal were looking a battery for 🤣🤣🤣funny as hell

[@magmalecreme]

@@duran4689 lol yeah

[@Lunarpreparedness]

I agree. I hope he makes one for Part 2. I could watch these reviews and cutscenes of TLOU like they’re movies

[@magmalecreme]

@@Lunarpreparedness i will in the future!

[@marteeee]

22:48 another amazing thing about this scene is that after speaking with Ellie, Joel looks down at his watch. It’s an amazing way to imply that Ellie reminds him of Sarah

[@magmalecreme]

Wow I didn't even notice that, super cool!

[@albertawheat6832]

I actually just returned to the game today and played through that scene...it was the first thought I had also....He was starting to see Ellie in a different light.

[@cflo1386]

I think it's a reminder for Joel not to get too emotionally attached to Ellie.

[@nf7089]

It's almost like you are playing a movie, rather than simply playing a game. The story line, the way they are able to portray emotions through their voice acting. The last of us games are truly masterpieces

[@magmalecreme]

Yup, I totally agree

[@loonar7960]

The way you phrased things at the part at the dam made me realize how well they subtly convey how much Joel and Tommy care for each other. When Tommy sees Joel with Ellie he realized that she's becoming like a daughter to him and he knows that losing another one will destroy him. So he agrees to take her. And then when Joel gets back with Tommy he realizes how much Tommy has built and doesn't want to take that from him. As different as they are they really do always have each other's backs.

[@magmalecreme]

Yeah totally, Joel doesn't want to ruin what tommy has and he also doesn't really want to lose ellie

[@angelaparicio5237]

There are many theories as to what really happened in this ending, but this is my interpretation: Joel does end up lying to Ellie. Many wonder if Ellie did believe Joel, but I believe that Ellie didn't believe him. You can see it in the emotions she portrays when Joel says "I swear." She looks almost sad, yet she accepts the answer he gave her. She still feels that survivor's guilt that Magma says, but she chooses to live with it. She knows that Joel is hiding the truth from her, but she makes the choice to live that lie, up until TLOU2, where she can't continue living that lie anymore. At this moment, however, she chooses to "believe" the lie because she has finally found someone that will not abandon her the way others have in her past. She found someone that truly loves her and wants to continue feeling that.

[@magmalecreme]

Idk if she actually doesn't believe him, I think that she believes him but is skeptical if that's the full truth, which is why she investigates in the second game.

[@PanicSurfer1133]

Really enjoyed your TWD videos, glad you’re covering this one. I can’t get enough TLOU video essays haha

[@magmalecreme]

Lol definitely can't, its a great game

[@magmalecreme]

@A1Stranger1Unkown same thats why I decided to make some lol

[@anaionescu8913]

Same

[@scottstots7238]

Agreed I watch all these kinds of videos and lore related stuff, I wish there was even more like in depth stuff in regards to the world and characters

[@magmalecreme]

@@scottstots7238 yep!

[@Endgame_01]

I've played through this game maybe 5 times and that Sam and Henry scene still always gets me

[@magmalecreme]

Same ;(

[@yanchi8780]

I keep saying, Joel did what he did in the hospital only because of the way Fireflies treated him and Ellie. If they would have give them time to speak and say goodbyes, maybe it would have ended differently. He did what anyone would do for the person you love. And I especially agree with the creator of this video about How Joel is soo cool, and the music being fucking amazing. I love TLOU 1 and 2. Excited for TLOU part 1 rebuilt for ps5

[@magmalecreme]

Tbh I don't think Joel would be willing to give up Ellie either way, but maybe Ellie could convince him or at least tell him it's not his choice to make. Also yes hype for part 1!

[@ironmilutin]

@@magmalecreme That's the thing. As much as Joel cares for her, that is not his decision to make. Ellie was the one who should have the final say, the fact both the fireflies and Joel deprived her of that choice really rubbed me the wrong way personally.

[@bourneco]

@@ironmilutin She's a child with survivor's guilt. I wouldn't say she could consent to the treatment either way.

[@callmepsycho3132]

People tend to ignore that the fireflies treated Joel like shit

[@cxndiibatz]

this game will never stop being so good, I can’t get tired of it no matter what

[@magmalecreme]

Same, its a masterpiece

[@Broccolidad140]

Tlou was littarly my childhood this game was my masterpiece I love this game to death I never experienced such a good story until I played this game

[@magmalecreme]

Honestly so true

[@BrandiG31]

Love this video!! The fact that people still make analysis videos about tlou after so long proves that it's a masterpiece 💖

[@magmalecreme]

It stands the test of time!

[@Zeegoku1007]

Bruh the remake release is just on it's way...people won't just be talking about it , they'll be buying it soon 😂

[@magmalecreme]

@@Zeegoku1007 yup lol, its coming back into the mainstream!

[@sonyavengeance]

16:22 Tess is a complete BADASS!! When I found out she was bitten it totally broke my heart

[@magmalecreme]

That's what I'm saying!

[@ChazMcClure]

Glad you played the old "remastered" version instead of the newer remake. As much as I loved the remake, it doesnt really keep the same art style that I loved so much. I remember playing this game on a CRT tv in the middle of the night and being completely immersed. Wish I could forget this game and replay it.

[@Hero_Of_Old]

Agree about the remastered

[@donovanumbra9704]

I feel as though the remastered version is head-and-shoulders above the original in every conceivable way. Especially the more detailed and dynamic face designs and expressions. The cutscenes come alive with so much more dimension from the upgraded visages alone.

[@magmalecreme]

Lol I'm with you on the art style, although I don't mind the realistic style either. The remake wasn't out when I made this video so I didn't have a choice anyways lol.

[@mrdavman13]

Marlene was not the equivalent of Ellie’s mom. She did not watch over Ellie ever besides the few weeks she was bitten. Joel has so much more connection, so much more time and blood sweat and tears gone into connecting, caring for, and loving Ellie. Joel is her guardian, Marlene is just some lady who knew her mom and met Ellie once.

[@magmalecreme]

I suppose you're right

[@PhenomRom]

Is that true though? Why was it so difficult for Marlene to let the doctors do the surgery then? Why was she saying “this is what Ellie would want”?

[@gustavoecheverria6955]

Something I love about this game it's the insane detail Joel has with his watch, in a lot of moments since the beginning of his travel with Ellie when he opens up, he always looks or touches his watch being the first time I think just before the capitol, when he ask Ellie about the view, and the last one at the end of the game, it's a detail a noticed recently, and just makes me think about all the details this game have

[@magmalecreme]

Yeah it's really in depth, naughty dog is always on their game for details

[@x.brookebennett]

At 1:05:34 when joel calls Ellie babygirl i CAN NOT help but cry, since it was his nickname for Sarah

[@NeverNotJune]

didnt realize you were the guy who made the Walking Dead videos and went to check if that guy (you) made a part 3 because I love those games. I saw a notif for this video and thought, "oh dope something to watch at work, TLOU is dope." I haven't watched yet, but i'm sure this video is a banger, much like the first two TWD videos. Def smart as well, because tons of TWD fans played TLOU. But please keep this up, your content is amazing and you'll find an audience for sure.

[@magmalecreme]

Lol yeah I figured a lot of twd fans would also like tlou, im glad you're enjoying the videos!

[@stackmanification]

At around 18:57, mentioning how Ellie points out Joel’s watch being broken- another thing to add here, is how, when Joel gets the watch at the beginning, he makes a joke about it being broken. This is some really good writing and foreshadowing of the relationship between the two moving forward. He joked about his watch being broken when he got it as a gift from his daughter, and now his future daughter-figure is making mention of the watch literally being broken. Pretty dope from the writers there

[@magmalecreme]

Bro they thought of everything

[@sevenesa.]

I always believed that he wouldn't give her a gun because he wants to let her be a kid. Even in this messed up world. Yes also the trust had to be there. But mostly as she would start killing, she would start to be consumed by guilt and breaking the barrier of taking lives. (what he did in the 20-year gap of losing Sara). >> last of us part 2. Eventually he accepted the fate that she needed a gun to survive after she helped him.

[@magmalecreme]

Hm interesting i never thought about it that way. That does make sense, he doesn't want a kid to have to kill people.

[@andrewoldham3675]

I love both games. I feel The Last of Us Part II gets unfairly hated due to the fact that it went a direction that wasn't expected for the most part. If you really think about it, the second game is like The Godfather Part II or The Empire Strikes back to The Last of Us as The Godfather or Star Wars (A New Hope). It took a chance, got divisive reactions, but probably will get reassessed down the line for how brilliant it really was, just like The Godfather Part II and The Empire Strikes Back were. I actually wouldn't mind seeing a deep dive analysis of Part II from you. You have just earned yourself a subscriber in me.

[@magmalecreme]

I actually do like part 2 a lot. Most of the story part im actually ok with, though I probably would've left you know who alive a little longer. The issues I have with the game are other things like pacing & characters. Lol I probably should make a video on it because I feel like I would have a lot to talk about.

[@maxNYGuk]

I understand your point, but it wasn’t just the fact it went in a different direction, the execution of the story was sloppy in parts, and while I don’t hate Abby like some people do, her side of the story was really dry and lacked any direction. I think comparing the last of us 2 to Empire and the Godfather part 2 is bold. Both those stories at the very least had a consistent tone in comparison to the first and expanded on the first story, whereas the TLOU2 butchered the two central characters of the first game by making one extremely unlikeable and not even a logical extension of the character from the first game and we all know what happened to the other. I do agree that it’s unfairly hated, I think it suffered from the success of the first game tbh, but putting it in the same sentence of Empire and the Godfather part 2 is inflammatory if you ask me.

[@jinxedangel2]

I hope that it gets more love in the future because TLoU part 2 (as well as the DLC) actually solidified the series as one of my favorite video games/franchises. The writers cared about telling their story instead of focusing only on what made the audience happy, which I wish more people did. I always see people saying that there were flaws in the characters or how the story was told and I don't get it. Flawed characters shouldn't be bad, I felt that both Ellie and Abby were flawed but that was due to the world they live in breaking them and seeing their transition to realizing that revenge killing is never the way to peace will always be a story I look back on.

[@magmalecreme]

@@maxNYGuk fair

[@magmalecreme]

@@jinxedangel2 yeah honestly the story is good for me, I just have other problems like pacing and characters. For example, imo Jesse is super boring because he's just a likable dude so no conflict ever comes from him, compared to someone like Henry who caused the player to constantly think that he could possibly leave the group to save Sam. The only conflict that happened with Jesse was when he wanted to save Tommy instead of going after Abby but that's about it.

[@ventorane1678]

Fantastic, extremely detailed review. Summarised the story beautifully, enough information to get the big picture however not enough to know each little spitting fact. Matching with the soothing voice and calm atmosphere that you have created in the video to generally have a relaxing time. Keep up the amazing videos - Will definitely look out for much more of your work!

[@magmalecreme]

Thank you so much! I'm happy to hear that people think my voice is soothing lol.

[@jamesschulziii9098]

I have played it numerous times. It is my favorite thing to experience. I don't believe it can ever be topped.

[@magmalecreme]

I dont think it can either

[@mikaylah_elizabeth4883]

The Last Of Us and The Walking Dead has had such an impact on my life, how the gameplay and story telling can make you have a connection with these characters. I absolutely love you're retrospective videos, keep up the good work!! Also at 32:32 I love that scene with the music play over the radio, gives me goosebumps every time.

[@magmalecreme]

Yep, tlou and twd are basically my two favorite games. Also yeah the music is awesome, I wish I could've played it all but I didn't want the clip to be too long

[@soul9859]

never really realized how much tlou has made an impact on me. absolutely love this game, and your video! keep up the good work😊

[@magmalecreme]

Yep you don't realize it until you notice that you keep thinking about the game lol.

[@wiwwy]

I'm glad your video got recommended to me, love your channel already! i hope you get the recognition you deserve man. Keep up the good work

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks! Im glad it got recommended to you as well lol

[@chloecola71102]

i just love this game. part 2 is great and all but you can't beat where it started. the feeling is unmatched because no other game has made me so invested in any characters. great video man!

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks! And yes the characters and writing are so dang good

[@albertawheat6832]

This is a good game no doubt about it...One of my favourites..I just started a run through it again, today... Now on a side note One game that had an adverse effect on me was " The Last Guardian " The bond you form with Trico as the game gets going, was like bonding with a real live pet, A true adventure, in every sense of the phrase...If you haven't played it yet, I recommend giving it a try, a simplistic game with an epic feel to it . One of the most under rated games out there...Most reviews were not kind to it. Cheers and keep on gaming.

[@Eli_Combes]

Throughout this whole video I cried like 4 times. This is a perfect video.

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks so much!

[@collectiveleak]

Probably been beat to this point but Ellie knows how to pop a clutch because she was raised in quarantine zones and had military training, probably taught all sorts of things that may end up being essential, which probably includes how to drive and pop a clutch and how she kinda figures out how to siphon gas

[@magmalecreme]

Oh huh I didn't think about that, that would explain it

[@PuppetKingdom]

These are some of the best retrospectives I have ever watched. I just want to say thank you for these videos and I can’t wait to see more in the future!

[@magmalecreme]

Thank you for watching! I'm hyped for more as well just because I love seeing the response and how yall feel about the games.

[@Sabsterrrrr]

I remember playing this game back when it came out such and emotional rollercoaster I just played the second game recently and that’s was a masterpiece the last of us is one of the best franchises in my books

[@magmalecreme]

I totally agree with you

[@Cinnamoroll.cherry]

Your videos are really entertaining to watch!

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks!

[@spacegirl3144]

this is such a good video dude i absolutely loved it! also, regarding david, i think he was a vile person and had some sick interest in ellie. the way his people described ellie as "his pet", the way he held her down in the lodge, the way he spoke to her (especially when he got her down in the lodge), the violent way ellie took him out, and the aftermath of the whole situation; she realized what he really could of done to her and his true intentions and that was really traumatic. i understand that trauma to a certain extent so i see why she was acting the way she was; that stuff really gets to you and sometimes you shut down when in the process of healing. also, seeing you mention berleezy put a smile on my face :) once again great video!

[@magmalecreme]

Yeah I definitely think David was a creep. I'm glad that we get to see ellie recover a bit from the trauma after seeing the giraffes

[@tylercooper1551]

You left out the part in the house, after Joel and Tommy had to find her, where ellie opens up about him abandoning her. Such an amazing and emotional scene "Everyone I've ever loved has left me... everybody except you!

[@magmalecreme]

That is a banger moment!

[@arlequin241]

I'll never forget this intro to Last of us. Hit me right in the feels the first 20 mins

[@magmalecreme]

I know its so sad

[@KrazyVideoChick]

I love this game as well! I can watch other people's gameplays of this over and over and not get tired. Part 2 gets a lot of flack but I LOVE that one too. The character designs in part two was just breathtaking. Espcially Joel and Ellie. They looked so real it was kind of uncanny. LOL. I can't wait until the remastered version comes out (next month?) for part 1.

[@magmalecreme]

I do really like part 2. I have some small issues with it like pacing and some writing but graphically it really is on another level.

[@JADub87]

@@magmalecreme Do you plan to review Part 2?

[@magmalecreme]

@@JADub87 Eventually!

[@aaronvasseur6559]

It’s a remake not remaster

[@fleshparasite]

this is an amazing video essay. it shows perfectly its story and the main characters' perspectives and motives. literally the best tribute to TLOU i've seen so far.

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks so much! That is quite a title that I would love to hold, I really do love the game so I'm glad I can contribute something to it.

[@fleshparasite]

@@magmalecreme 🫶🫶🫶

[@melissagarrett9719]

I always thought Ellie knew how to pop a clutch because before getting bitten she was attending a military school. Driving would be a good skill to teach to people who will be joining the army one day.

[@magmalecreme]

Yeah I don't doubt it, I still wonder how many working cars are around though

[@Forthegaymerinyou]

“No matter how hard you try, you can’t escape your past.” It means so much more now thinking about part 2.

[@magmalecreme]

yikes fr

[@roc5291]

I remember playing this for the first time a few years ago on the PS4. Remembered when you are riding the horse into the college campus. I remember getting off of the horse and the very subtle music track called “Flutes and Pads”. For whatever reason, that just hit me so powerfully. I’ve never felt like I’ve really taken a journey with characters the way I had with Joel and Ellie. So many of these subtle moments throughout the game. When your first walk into the park and Tess dies and the sunlight coming through the trees. Ellie playing with Fireflies. So much attention to detail to these little moments that I’m sure many missed completely, but not me. Loved these beautiful moments in this masterpiece of a game.

[@magmalecreme]

So much detail packed into one game with an incredible soundtrack on the side. It truly is an incredible game

[@Lunabyes]

How in the actual FUCK do you only have 2.85k subs?! This video was amazing. It put into words the way I have felt about this game since it released. I truly believe the person I am today wouldn't exist without this game. I've played it at least 6 times, probably far more. I eventually stopped counting. Fucking fantastic video dude, just subbed. I'd love for you to review all seasons of the Walking Dead game, I know you've done an all-round retrospective of it, along with a s2 retrospective, but I'd really love to hear your thoughts on the later seasons of the game. I really enjoyed it up until the 3rd season, which is when everything kinda went to shit. It was still fun to play, but it just didn't feel the same. It felt like the later seasons were wearing the skin of the earlier seasons. It looked okay at first glance, but if you look at it any longer than 10 seconds you can tell its a blatant facade in order to make more money. I was SO disappointed in Telltale games when the last 2 seasons of the game came out, it had so much potential and they just WASTED IT. I look forward to seeing your reviews and retrospectives of other games. You've just earned a new, loyal sub. Great work dude

[@magmalecreme]

Thank you so much! I totally agree about s3, but s4 was really good imo.

[@VulpisSkull]

The last of us was a big part of my childhood, it's such a moving and growing experience on you. I wish there were/I know more games like this. Again, Thank you for the beautiful narrative.

[@magmalecreme]

Man once you find a game like tlou it gets you playing all kinds of games to try and get a similar experience lol. Thanks so much, im glad you enjoyed the vid!

[@tiredgrove]

Great video man! I found your channel via your TWD videos and I think I'm going to stay. Hope you do more zombie related games.

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks man! I am definitely going to diversify but I do tend to play zombie games lol

[@tiredgrove]

@@magmalecreme Glad to hear! I think you have the talent to do some great things.

[@magmalecreme]

@@tiredgrove thanks man means a lot

[@_Devil]

IMO, The Last of Us the TTG's The Walking Dead perfectly captured the greatness of the early 2010's for the zombie genre of video games, long before the market got oversaturated and long before both companies started to fall off the deep end (writing-wise). The soundtrack alone for both games fill me with immense senses of happiness and nostalgia, they remind me of fantastic times before...well...before the world became what it is now lol. Great video as well, Magma!

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks man! I totally agree with you, its crazy how much feeling just a soundtrack can cause.

[@Ryuk45]

People who use the Last of Us as a emotional hugbox and then cry about Part II are manchildren

[@krislynjagt3223]

Couple of corrections, love the video so far though!! ❤ - the quarantined cities are run by the military, not the government. Fireflies were established and are trying to get a government body implemented.

[@magmalecreme]

Ahhh ok. That does make sense. I guess I figured military = government, makes sense why the fireflies would be fighting for control of the people.

[@rosestar1324]

I think a cute little thing that's easy to miss is back in the toy store, after Sam puts down the toy, if you watch, you can see Ellie quickly pick up the toy when she thinks no one is looking. It's easy to miss cuz she waits until no one is looking at her.

[@humansadness3749]

i never realized how goofy the horse in tlou ran, naughty dog please do more studies on how horses walk and run i am begging 🙏

[@magmalecreme]

Omg you're right that run is goofy asf

[@kurt2552]

the for sure fixed that in part ii

[@MCoconut97]

Great Analysis man! Honestly one of the, if not best I've seen on this site. You are spot on! The Last of Us is a definitive masterpiece

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks! And yes it sure is!

[@spritzup2312]

What a phenomenal video for the game of a lifetime. Thank you for putting in this effort, I really hope you do the sequel as well.

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks so much!

[@riebub8812]

Your videos are great man. u gonna do the red dead series in the future? I think it would be really great for your style of video

[@magmalecreme]

It would be a huge project lol. Currently I'm just doing these in my free time and idk how a 50 hour game cut into a video would go. If I could find a way to make it not super long I totally would!

[@landonisia]

Dude, you are seriously underrated. I got reccomended this video because tbh I'm going through another tlou phase and I can't believe you don't have more subs! Seriously good stuff!

[@magmalecreme]

Thank you! Im the same way, eventually i just start watching a bunch of tlou or twd videos lol

[@chasef1077]

Joel couldn’t save Sarah but he was damn sure gonna save Ellie

[@magmalecreme]

Hell yeah!

[@ix.x.mmxxii5486]

Good work mate,it made me remember what i liked about this game and why it is special for me.I couldnt understand how 1 hour passed so freaking fast.

[@sirduck600]

The last of us part 1 and 2 are PEAK story telling and absolute Masterpieces. I will die on this hill

[@magmalecreme]

Yessire!

[@obiwanshinobi87]

7:38 I feel that kind of mirrors real life... I live in Rotterdam which might not be the biggest city but when I travel to let's say my home country of Cape Verde I get the same feeling.. It's a tropical island chain off the coast of west africa.. and it sometimes feels dreamlike.. especially when you're up in the mountains away from civilization

[@hunterkuhs]

These videos just be too good

[@magmalecreme]

Omg so true

[@sashadelange5155]

This is one of the best TLOU video I’ve ever seen. The way you talk about it just made me love and appreciate the game even more. Please make a video of TLOU2 as well. Even if you love or don’t love it 🤙🏼

[@magmalecreme]

I actually do like tlou2 a lot, although I think its got some problems. Thanks so much!

[@kizzoet9830]

Definitely one of the best ps games

[@magmalecreme]

For sure!

[@VVVVV253]

I love these retrospective videos of yours, I'm eagerly waiting for the next one!

[@magmalecreme]

Thank you!

[@davidlevine7350]

Just finished a 3rd play through. Honestly, that was the only way I could truly understand the decisions made in TLOU2. Wtf was Ellie thinking letting Abby go? After playing this and really trying to understand how each character perceives their situation, it all comes together much more nicely. TLOU2 still got some major problems though. 8mo prego = savage warrior. Just realizing you maybe prego with morning sickness = almost got our main character killed. The best part, the 8mo prego chick is way later in the game ⁉️. I’ll stop this rant before it gets too far

[@magmalecreme]

Yep when you go back to the first game the second game makes a lot more sense

[@xoxpctxox]

Wow amazing, just amazing! had me engaged the whole time and it was so thoughtfully crafted I know everyone always says this but I can’t believe you don’t have more subscribers, just wanted to share my appreciation for this and to commend your talent

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks so much, it seriously means a lot!

[@uhuhuh1966]

Thank you so much for your hard work on this, I really hope you make a video for Part 2

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks, in the future!

[@chibivampiregirl]

you really are SO talented with these essays. can't wait to see more from you.

[@dookieseawolf6982]

This was a great video! Worth the wait I can't wait to see what the future has in store for the channel. Keep up the good work!

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks man, im glad it was the worth the wait

[@nathanborns2288]

I always thought Tess and Joel's relationship was a best friend's with benefits type thing.

[@magmalecreme]

Yeah it seems that way, the tv show kinda shows it off a bit more

[@kourioji]

This was a great video! The structure was great and you really put and explained everything perfectly! Thank you so much for your hard work, your video was super entertaining and interesting!

[@magmalecreme]

Thank you so much!

[@Corroded_Corpse]

I absolutely love your voice and tone! Very calming! Also, great analysis of this!

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks so much!

[@fastkat7]

I am saying this again, you found who you are on KZbin and I’m so happy for you. Keep up the great work and keep making these great videos.

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks man!

[@dooter7299]

Loved this video man can't wait for the next one!!

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks so much!

[@dooter7299]

@@magmalecreme no problem man. Hey and I have a little theory about the end of the game now I have played the second game buuuut I like to think the fireflies would have fucked up the cure. Because through the entire game the fireflies and getting wiped out by the military, the bandits and even the zombies. Also Joel took down their entire operation. now Joel is a badass but he's just one guy so I think the fireflies would have messed it up soooo I side with Joel 😂😂

[@magmalecreme]

@@dooter7299 yeah they probably would've botched it in some way

[@Seiza25]

I enjoy these long video essays so much

[@chamomilecujoh5464]

ahhhhaha love this video sm!!! great commentary, analyses, and i love your voice!! i feel like voices are very important in videos where you can only hear the person and not see them , and yours is really nice!!

[@chamomilecujoh5464]

yeah this video is everything i hoped for haha

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks this comment is super nice lol!

[@jvever4904]

Another fantastic video! You honestly deserve more subs for these detailed masterpieces.

[@magmalecreme]

Thank you so much!

[@listeningtothemoon]

I’ve been loving binging your videos, great job man! Hoping to see your take on the second part of TLOU soon

[@dylandaly7524]

Bro I'm so happy you're blowing up your comtents always been so underrated

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks so much!

[@QuestionableLifeChoices]

one of my favorite little parts of this game is the name at sam and henry's hideout, in one of the conference rooms, that is basically a slow motion breakdown of how the city fell to/became hunters: through scared democracy. horrifying

[@magmalecreme]

Hm i never really noticed, thats cool though

[@Liiisp]

keep it up. I stumbled upon this video by watching a lot of TLOU recently so this was a once in a life time chance to watch this.

[@magmalecreme]

Lol I'm glad you ended up finding it!

[@hi-qt5jd]

I love this video because of the production quality, soothing and calming voice but most importantly it is talking about one of my favorite games of all time. Thank you for making my night! Cheers

[@magmalecreme]

No problem, thank you for watching! Im glad you find my voice soothing, sometimes I think it gets too scratchy so I do a lot of retakes to make sure it sounds alright.

[@over_kill6666]

I really love your retrospectives you are so underrated and I love your twd vid too

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks so much!

[@sebas13576macx]

This video was spot on! I loved how you present the last of us as what is, a master piece of a game, I really liked your way of presenting the review while going through the whole game, not a general review of why you should play it. You're awesome, Ill subscribe to see your future reviews!

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks so much! I'm glad you like the long format, it always frustrates me when videos don't go in depth enough.

[@erika662]

and part 2 made me love these characters even more. which I didn't think was possible

[@magmalecreme]

Yep!

[@erinelaine8915]

This was a wonderful review, I really enjoyed your takes on things and I agreed with so much that you've had to say. I would love to see you cover the second game.

[@pallissardfamilyaccount3837]

Let's GOOOOOOOOOOOO, I have never played the last of us but IM SO EXCITED YOUR A GREAT KZbinR

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks homie! If you like the walking dead im sure you'll like them

[@jeremyward2238]

I wish I could experience this game for the first time again

[@magmalecreme]

Same :/

[@japa2305]

incredible video i would love to see you cover part 2 as well

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks! Probably in the future.

[@Phenriir]

One thing I’ve not seen about the Fireflies is the idea that they never deserved to make that cure because they didn’t earn it. They should’ve kept Joel in captivity, tied him up, or at least been able to kill him on the sight. They also acted way too quickly. They needed much more time than what they had given Ellie and Joel. Ellie first can’t even consent to being harvested for a cure nor did they acquire it from her. The Fireflies were lost souls, grabbing tight onto whatever pieces they had from when they were kids and young adults. It’s ironic that they want to go back to their PAST by taking away Ellie’s FUTURE.

[@magmalecreme]

Yeah their procedures definitely weren't ideal for what they were trying to accomplish

[@wuldntuliktonoptb6861]

Damn in here way b4 100k ur gonna blow up here soon my dude just keep doing what ur doin

[@magmalecreme]

Man 100k would be insane! Thanks so much!

[@sixfootnai]

love that you added that berleezy clip! it fit the mood perfectly!

[@magmalecreme]

That's what I'm saying!

[@sixfootnai]

@@magmalecreme keep up the great work! i’ll be watching for your videos!

[@callabarnes]

i just watched all three of your retrospective videos, and i just wanna let you know that they're amazing!! i thoroughly enjoyed watching them, and i'll definitely be looking forward to your future content :) keep it up 💪❤️

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks so much! That really means a lot that you watched all three of them!

[@Packend]

you did great on this video man! hopefully part 2 is already on your channel

[@magmalecreme]

Not yet

[@vampcloze]

Nice job man this is really high quality, keep it up

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks!

[@jathandiller]

Awsome stuff bro, cant wait for the next video!

[@magmalecreme]

Thank you!

[@michaelmontalvo7441]

this was a great & well put together video man, watching it makes me even more hyped for the last of us part 1

[@magmalecreme]

Only a week left!

[@monkeybeexd5359]

this was a great video and i watched it in one sitting, thank you and keep up the good work

[@magmalecreme]

Thanks so much!

[@KrazyVideoChick]

58:58.. I can't remember which book it was, but I was reading some book about a zombie apocalypse and the author mentioned how the people who mastered stealth were actually the ones who ended up being the long-term survivors, not the brutish-guns-a-blazing type of people. The latter actually got killed off pretty quick becuase of how noisey they were and lack of actual skills and foresight.

[@magmalecreme]

Yep sounds pretty accurate lol

[@LeeEverett1]

Please put your focus into doing these gaming retrospectives, I'm very confident your channel will make it if you do. Just the past 3 videos you've uploaded is proof of that with the views compared to previous content. I will watch your career with great interest.

[@magmalecreme]

Thank you for the wise words Lee Everett. In all seriousness though, that's the plan! I don't plan to do anymore gameplay videos, ill just stick to the reviews. I may do some streams in the future if there is interest in it because I have to play the game to get footage anyways.