Why Intel is Abandoning Hyperthreading - 40 GAMES TESTED P-Cores vs E-cores vs Hyperthreading

  Рет қаралды 11,911

DannyzReviews

DannyzReviews

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 208
@intelshill5099
@intelshill5099 3 күн бұрын
Removing hyperthreading from the design is very different from turning hyperthreading off. When you remove it from the design, it allows you to put everything else closer together and frees up that die space.
@quintrapnell3605
@quintrapnell3605 3 күн бұрын
Die space they’re wasting with Ai components.
@TamaraIsMeBecahse
@TamaraIsMeBecahse 3 күн бұрын
​@@quintrapnell3605of course, why wouldn't they
@LastExile1989
@LastExile1989 3 күн бұрын
​@@quintrapnell3605Facts this is the reason they are getting rid of it. To make way for TPM. It's kind of like the self sabotage of the auto industry to make EVs look more reliable. When will people realize they don't care about what the consumer wants it's about the plan for globalization. Aka you will own nothing and be happy.
@pedro.alcatra
@pedro.alcatra 3 күн бұрын
@@quintrapnell3605 Exactly. I would like to have more ral cores or then more Xe engines than any NPU. But they will figure it out anytime soon
@intelshill5099
@intelshill5099 2 күн бұрын
To push iGPUs much further, support for higher bandwidth memory will be needed.
@zodwraith5745
@zodwraith5745 3 күн бұрын
Hyperthreading hasn't really been necessary essentially since we hit 8 cores, and has given ever diminishing returns as core counts continued to rise. The 9700k was really no slower than the 9900k and it had hyperthreading fused off. Any difference between them can be 100% chalked up to their clock speed difference. But you need to keep in mind _removing_ HT all together will be more effective than just disabling it because you're removing a chunk of the pipeline effectively shortening it, which is _always_ beneficial. Honestly I hope Arrow Lake ends up being a home run for Intel. Not that IGAF about Intel, but they need a win after the beating the company and it's stock has taken the last couple years. Anyone that celebrates tens of thousands of people getting laid off needs to seriously check their fanboism and AMD is once again proving they're perfectly happy to increase prices the second they have no competition. Just look at Threadripper pricing.
@nempk1817
@nempk1817 3 күн бұрын
"Hyperthreading hasn't really been necessary" i wouldn't be sure of that.
@nichronos
@nichronos 3 күн бұрын
His benchmarks are all fcked, he seems to be most likely using 1440p and then is GPU bottlenecked in almost every game. So basically all benchmarks are invalid!
@zodwraith5745
@zodwraith5745 3 күн бұрын
@@nempk1817 There's a difference in "necessary" and "beneficial". As much as I love all my e cores when doing compression and compile workloads, if I could get 15% better single core performance on stubborn apps like emulators and sim games I'd happily sacrifice a few % in multi. E cores have made hyperthreading obsolete. Unless of course you're an AMD user. Then yeah, you need all the HT you can get cause you're slower core for core.
@zodwraith5745
@zodwraith5745 3 күн бұрын
@@nichronos That's inconsequential when he's got the same results we've seen for more than a few years. Moving to 1080p low would just make the results _more_ amplified, not less. There's a _reason_ many people suggest disabling HT. It rarely slows you down but in certain games it can be beneficial.
@nichronos
@nichronos 3 күн бұрын
@@zodwraith5745 Im doing 1080p ULTRA and i have between 20 to 80 FPS more in every single game he has shown here! Your entire argument is invalid and waste of time LMAO! P cores with HT and E disabled is about 15% faster in every game EXCEPT Shadow of the Tomb Raider where that games scales with more cores instead, resulting at 362 FPS stock and 340 Only P with HT. Rest of the games are ALL hard win for the P with HT no E.
@saiprasad8078
@saiprasad8078 3 күн бұрын
E cores are the new hyperthreading cores in case of Intel. I had guessed this move when Ecores came out.
@Jeboi96
@Jeboi96 3 күн бұрын
ppl forget that when HT is turned off you get extra room to overclock you cores with 200mhz. got mine from 5.6 to 5.8 ghz on a 14600kf.
@AGairsoft1
@AGairsoft1 3 күн бұрын
Good stuff but did it give you a measurable increase in FPS? If not it’s ok bc some overclock for the fun of it.
@Riyozsu
@Riyozsu 3 күн бұрын
Does it beat 7800x3d in gaming or 14700k in productivity?
@AdaaDK
@AdaaDK 3 күн бұрын
i would love to see this test on a 12600k or 13600k, to see if the lower core count there changes anything. manny more people prob has the I5´s over the I7´s anyhow.
@toddsimone7182
@toddsimone7182 3 күн бұрын
This proves how everything needs software control to park cores on an individual game basis. Intel Dynamic Tuning or APO comes to mind but is it even getting support anymore?
@fullmoon5060
@fullmoon5060 3 күн бұрын
So Hyper-Threading are bad and more thread are good. Maybe a 16C no HT of P-core are the best instead of 8P/16T+16E?
@waferbarr
@waferbarr 3 күн бұрын
Surely not with arrow lake, those e cores will be fast and very space efficient
@nempk1817
@nempk1817 3 күн бұрын
If it was bad they would remove from the xeons too, they are removing only from the PC parts.
@bios9678
@bios9678 3 күн бұрын
Instead of all this fafo intel should just give us a non hybrid CPU. Nobody wants to test this shit. I’ll take a Monolithic 12p core CPU with no hyperthreading anyday over having e cores
@defectiveclone8450
@defectiveclone8450 4 күн бұрын
Gaming sure.. everything else.. not so much.. intel is desperate to save power and win the gaming crown. No body knows if they will.
@SterileNeutrino
@SterileNeutrino 3 күн бұрын
Isn't it more about being datacenter friendly (this matches getting rid of HT for "security reasons" as this is a problem on shared hardware). Gamers are not particularly concerned about power, are they (maybe in the EU where we are told that "switching off the rig saves money")
@godnamedtay
@godnamedtay 3 күн бұрын
Gaming crown is a win they desperately need
@quintrapnell3605
@quintrapnell3605 3 күн бұрын
lol they use the most power by a huge margin
@gametestinglab8861
@gametestinglab8861 3 күн бұрын
My I7 13700K locked at 5.6ghz on 1.375 V during gaming in Warzone consumes around 120 watts. Which is roughly as much as Ryzen 7700X. Given that AMD it’s at 4nm and Intel at 10 nm I don’t know how to call it. Shame for Intel that didn’t put correct boosting and voltage on the bios or shame for AMD by being better node performs similar to Intel. Or shame for both. As for “nobody knows how Intel will fix power issue” they getting a node shrinking next gen which means lower power consumption and removing hyper theradimg which also means lower power consumption. I can see the way. May be in your opinion those two factors doesn’t matter. Your choice. One question. That “way worse Intel power consumption” conclusion did you draw by testing both platforms yourself or by watching KZbin videos?
@Jasontvnd9
@Jasontvnd9 3 күн бұрын
​@gametestinglab8861 what on earth are you talking about? 7700X is on 5nm and 13700x is on 7nm which intel says is equivuilent to 4nm hence the Intel 4 process node. 7700X is not using 120w in call of duty it's using less than 80w. It's also irrespective because the 7800X3D will hammer your 13700X in nearly every game using less than 65w.
@nichronos
@nichronos 3 күн бұрын
You are between 20 to 80 FPS lower than me in every game! On what resolution are you benchmarking?
@nempk1817
@nempk1817 3 күн бұрын
I am curious too.
@SiliconSteak
@SiliconSteak 3 күн бұрын
Danny putting work with these tests. Appreciate your attention to detail brother
@godnamedtay
@godnamedtay 3 күн бұрын
Fr, love to see it
@Razzy_III
@Razzy_III 3 күн бұрын
HT being removed supposedly was/is a step towards a more flexible method of splitting tasks between cores (potentially even splitting P cores all the way down to 4 threads each). Supposedly we’re left with simply no HT on 15th gen because this method wouldn’t be ready in time and it wasn’t worth putting HT back in. Generally this has been referred to as “rentable units” the past few years but there’s a lot of pure speculation and we don’t have any details beyond rumors and a couple patents that have been found. Could also be breadcrumbs that exist entirely to throw off competition, or something that hit a brick wall and was ultimately cancelled some time ago.
@kristof6372
@kristof6372 3 күн бұрын
HT was a great solution in the dual and quad core times more then a decade ago. Now it's getting redundant for 6 cores and especially for +8 core designs.
@heickelrrx
@heickelrrx 3 күн бұрын
SMT is Ancient Tech, While it still have it use on Server, on consumer devices, Modern Smartphone already ditch that, Apple Sillicon do not support this as well, If Intel decided to kill off SMT, it's step to the right direction since the Consumer Hardware is moving away from that. SMT still acceptable of Workstation, but for consumer hardware, it's not longer necessary, Keeping SMT just because the Tech Community want to see 2x Thread as tradition is foolish, I hope AMD also can follow the same path, like having Zen 5 + Zen 5C on consumer platform. that way the scheduling can be streamlined on consumer OS
@totalermist
@totalermist 2 күн бұрын
SMT is still alive and well. heck, the Power10 ISA features 8-way SMT - that's 8 threads per core. But you are right in that most consumer hardware doesn't benefit from, especially if the underlying architecture isn't optimized for it (ARM doesn't have it and it's suboptimal on AMD64 in terms of efficiency).
@Sheerwinter
@Sheerwinter 3 күн бұрын
Instead lf having a 8 core ultra 3 205 (4p+4e) I would rather have a 6p core 6t (no hyperthreading). 🗿It feels alright i guess.
@xdi1733
@xdi1733 3 күн бұрын
Danny you're a champ bro. I remember asking for this exact video compare e cores vs hyperthreading directly and with them both off. Fantastic video and the one on showing these configurations. I already shared this on the forums because it's a good test that deserves exposure.
@Lemard77
@Lemard77 3 күн бұрын
Really interesting results, looks like the 8P/8T + 16E variant shouldn't have any problems in multithreaded games at least. It would be interesting to see how a simulated arrow lake "i5" would fare, so taking the 14900K and reducing it to 6P/6T + 8 E cores enabled, or even 4 E cores for the cheaper variants. I know it's a lot of extra work to run the benchmarks so I would understand if you feel like not doing it.
@Patrick73787
@Patrick73787 3 күн бұрын
Using a 14900K to simulate an Ultra 5 245K wouldn't be a fair comparison as the 14900K has more L3 cache than the 14600K, which is the one he should use instead as it will have similar L3 cache size to the 245K.
@teskript4605
@teskript4605 3 күн бұрын
thanks for this amazing test! must have been an insane amount of work.
@GFClocked
@GFClocked 3 күн бұрын
I hope it's good, just for competition. But even if it is, the intel brand has lost credibility in general, and now with oxidation-gate and how they handled it.. They really need to say EXPLICITLY that they will take care of you if there's an issue AND confirm platform support for 4-5 years. Otherwise i don't see them gaining mind share. Me and all my friends are laughing at intel, they're a laughing stock these days. They will need to do a lot of work to turn this around.
@JCashBeatz
@JCashBeatz 17 сағат бұрын
not everybody uses cpus fo gaming.intel will always have market share for creative users.
@h428schannel
@h428schannel 3 күн бұрын
The decision to remove HT was made because of the tradeoff that the higher performance of the E core made it possible to allocate the area saved by removing HT to the E core without compromising area efficiency, and its primary purpose is power savings. The improvement in gaming due to HT-off only occurs when two heavily loaded threads cohabit on a single core. There are only a limited number of titles where that happens. Since Intel Core since the 12th generation has been optimized by Thread Director to use as little HT as possible, there shouldn't be much difference between Arrow lake and Alder lake (that's what makes HT one of the reasons for the decision to remove it, which was explained in the Computex 2024 keynote). There are still some games where disabling HT/SMT can improve performance, but most only happen before 11th generation and on some of Ryzen APU.
@techwandoUS
@techwandoUS Күн бұрын
Really good video Danny. Loving the deep dives.
@PAIN-ot4cj
@PAIN-ot4cj 3 күн бұрын
good Freaking Video danny and I havent even watched pass the intro, I myself keep HT off as it allows a higher all core oc 59p on my 14900k and a higher head room for ram OC 8200
@VioletGOKU
@VioletGOKU 3 күн бұрын
Thanks for your hard work and putting the results together. Definitely gives us an idea as to why Intel went with the strategy. With scheduling optimizations that they spoke about, it should be even better across the board. With that said, E-cores make sense for laptop CPUs like Lunar Lake for maximizing battery life, but for desktop CPUs I wish Intel focused on optimized P-core only configs
@jackywong079
@jackywong079 3 күн бұрын
Nice hard work. Tried on my 12900K with undervolt and now disable HT works even better which less shuttering and less power draw. The power consumption much lower than HT enabled only draws above 100W at full load, anf it should be like this. Very nice tweak for gaming. I agree your point of view which the CPU should works right out of the box without any such a lot tuning by user.
@NBWDOUGHBOY
@NBWDOUGHBOY 3 күн бұрын
Great video Danny. Pretty interesting test. I too am looking forward to seeing how the new intel cpus will perform on a new process node. If the rumors of the arrow e cores being as powerful as the Raptor lake p cores, Thats a whole lot of performance on tap. We'll see how it goes tho.
@AJDOLDCHANNELARCHIVE
@AJDOLDCHANNELARCHIVE 2 күн бұрын
Arrow Lake is going to be very interesting... there are strange leaked benchmarks that are showing the new Skymont E-cores have the same IPC as the P-cores... that'll be very impressive if it turns out correct. Not long to go before the official announcement (rumoured 10th of October).
@RedVisor1
@RedVisor1 3 күн бұрын
This inspired me to look up videos for disabling SMT on AMD CPUs (I have a 5800x3D). The results from Tech Yes City look promising, although he tested a much smaller sample of games. I'm tempted to give this a try 😉
@prem3548
@prem3548 3 күн бұрын
As long as they improve all core workloads by like 30% over 14900k and use less than 200w, they will be fine. If anyone thinks it unrealistic, that is basically what AMD did going from Zen 3 to Zen 4.
@Riyozsu
@Riyozsu 3 күн бұрын
HT never matters for gaming anyway. 7800x3d proves that by beats 14900k with any combination. Just give ton of more cache. Intel wouldn't focus for disabling ht for gaming only. Probably they had to reduce tdp and thermals and more e cores will inflate their benchmark scores even more. But multicore performance will take huge hit.
@MLWJ1993
@MLWJ1993 3 күн бұрын
Not exactly true, depends on the game engine what sort of impact HT has. Some games will really drop the ball on 1% & 0.1% lows if you disable HT, others will run slightly better with HT off 😅
@PAIN-ot4cj
@PAIN-ot4cj Күн бұрын
7800X3D losses in a lot of games to a stock 14900k let alone a tuned with 8000 ram 14900k
@Superchad245
@Superchad245 2 күн бұрын
You forgot to test power usage with each configuration for different games
@greenslay4626
@greenslay4626 3 күн бұрын
Results are invalid for e cores disabled hyper threading enabled because of windows 11 not knowing how to schedule the threads with the e cores disabled. Re run the test on windows 10 and you’ll see that configuration coming out on top, and also when you disable the e cores the ring ratio automatically goes to 49 so you should raise the ring as well!
@greenslay4626
@greenslay4626 3 күн бұрын
Make sure to install windows 10 with e cores off as well
@mikebruzzone9570
@mikebruzzone9570 3 күн бұрын
mb
@greenslay4626
@greenslay4626 2 күн бұрын
@@mikebruzzone9570all good king
@gamebenchmarks9715
@gamebenchmarks9715 3 күн бұрын
I examined this for years on my channel. There is a bigger thing there to consider, not just FPS, but the frame to frame latency Removing HT is a big no-no for desktop use that actually loves HT But, in games HT OFF is the best boost you can give to yourself through use of Process Lasso Intel is likely hitting the limit of improvements that they want, so they are doing something gamers did for years, the issue is that desktop performance will suffer It is not an actual improvement, but it will improve stutters and frame to frame in games, but will it actually beat 14900k in desktop use (non-gaming) is a question
@cliche_AF
@cliche_AF 3 күн бұрын
The mw2 bench was probably so terrible because the worker render count would be wrong
@yonghominale8884
@yonghominale8884 Күн бұрын
Everybody must disable the E-cores. Not sure about SMT because the general consensus appears to be you need it. E-cores need to be shut down because they are putting stress on the Ring bus which lead to voltage spikes and latency. E-cores are useless for most people unless maybe you are streaming.
@R6ex
@R6ex 3 күн бұрын
ARL needs to beat X3D in gaming!
@noppanonlekhachinnabut7478
@noppanonlekhachinnabut7478 2 күн бұрын
I would like to see how much temperatures when running across test cases. So I can trade-off heat vs. performance.
@CrisIsBored
@CrisIsBored 3 күн бұрын
yeah i noticed that years ago, but i cannot be bothered to restart the pc and go into the bios every time i switch the game.
@Shuttterbugg
@Shuttterbugg 3 күн бұрын
Ya but for editing , photo and video cad.etc...those threads do alot..i dont just game
@Ray88G
@Ray88G 3 күн бұрын
It would be even better if they completely abandoned their current design of P and E and went full on P cores without F around . But I suppose that's what new 5th and 6th gen Xeon HEDT is for
@marxmaiale9981
@marxmaiale9981 22 сағат бұрын
What would the results be with P cores turned off and just running on the E Cores?
@impuls60
@impuls60 3 күн бұрын
Should have tested Battlefield and Pubg. I'd think you'd see about 40% less fps.
@rin_rin69
@rin_rin69 3 күн бұрын
Should do much. Threads aren't even split between Cores. That's why there is always only 1 or 2 cores that basically are used the most. So should it be exactly the same as comparing a hdd and a raid set.
@lolmao500
@lolmao500 2 күн бұрын
Intel : getting rid of hyperthreading saves power... lol. On AMD, hyperthreading uses like 0.25% more power in exchange for 30%+ gains.
@totalermist
@totalermist 2 күн бұрын
30%+ gains is nonsense. The *theoretical* limit is about 25%, so in practice it's 10% to maybe 20% at best.
@Frozoken
@Frozoken 17 сағат бұрын
you've gotta be braindead to think it uses that little power
@JuanGarcia-lh1gv
@JuanGarcia-lh1gv 3 күн бұрын
This really shows why Intel went with a hybrid design. If Intel released a 16 p-core beast, it would destroy AMD in both productivity and gaming, but the power usage would be insane. Especially if you turned on hyperthreading. Great video!
@jx9737
@jx9737 3 күн бұрын
Lots of work for this one! Thanks!
@renerant
@renerant 3 күн бұрын
I guess you're also using extreme profile or whatever is the unlimited power option in bios?
@mnkydeth8189
@mnkydeth8189 3 күн бұрын
Not tested.... But I can vouch saying that if you disable HT and E-cores you can typically OC the p-cores a little higher. Direct die using liquid metal Iceman cooler water block. 12700kf HT enabled, e-cores disabled I can get 5.2ghz all core. 12700kf HT disabled, e-cores disabled I can get 5.4ghz all core. $175-200 CPU doing nearly as good as a 14900k in games. Maxes out a 4080 super that I own and a 7900xtx that I own.
@cks5148
@cks5148 3 күн бұрын
Why having hyperthreading with ecores ? Ecores is much more efficient than hyperthreading , no need to test that .
@Lunnyx
@Lunnyx 3 күн бұрын
Make the same with 3D render and how perform after effect or premiere pro, you will see why HT is important
@mikebruzzone9570
@mikebruzzone9570 3 күн бұрын
Adobe definitely compiled to add e-cores. mb
@drgoodness7
@drgoodness7 3 күн бұрын
love this video.. please the next time can u add THE FINALS ? thanks man :)
@marufulislam4311
@marufulislam4311 3 күн бұрын
Finally a unique content, good work @danny, love this analysis
@micaiahchapman1599
@micaiahchapman1599 3 күн бұрын
what about heat? I feel this would’ve been a really good benchmark to see which setup runs the best thermals at the cost of performance so on so forth .
@nempk1817
@nempk1817 3 күн бұрын
Isn't intel only disabling SMT on the consumer parts while the xeon's will still use/support it? And this hybrid arch is only used on consumers parts too while on server they are all ecores or pcores? While SMT is different for intel and AMD implementation, just disabling it on the software level will not change much. So those test only tell which games/engines benefits with/without it not even considering if the impact is not from the way the OS is using it since most games are not programed to see difference on SMT cores from real ones. The only real way to test this would be have the same core with and without the SMT implementation on hardware level.
@OVERKILL_PINBALL
@OVERKILL_PINBALL 3 күн бұрын
Crazy, but is it possible to disable all P-cores and only leave E-cores? What can they do all alone? Obviously for a test only.
@bios9678
@bios9678 3 күн бұрын
Lol yes disable the actual CPU power
@ryue5626
@ryue5626 3 күн бұрын
Can't wait to upgrade this year from my 11900k
@hdz77
@hdz77 3 күн бұрын
The Best configuration is called the 7800X3D.
@ProVishGaming
@ProVishGaming 3 күн бұрын
??? Not true at all. To fully realize the 7800x3d’s potential, you need a 4080 or 4090 atleast playing at 1080p. According to steam hardware survey, only 2% of people own those gpus. It makes 0 sense to spend $450 on a 7800x3d if 98% of the population has a worse gpu. I have a 13600k with a 4070ti. Thanks to comments like yours, I know someone that paired a 7800x3d with a 4060ti. Literally people don’t need more than a 7600x/12700k if they’re using a gpu like a 4070ti or lower and playing a resolution 1440p or higher.
@ProVishGaming
@ProVishGaming 3 күн бұрын
^We spent the same amount of money on our builds btw and obviously my build curbstomps his pc by 20-30% in games. Literally 0 sense to buy a 7800x3d.
@hdz77
@hdz77 3 күн бұрын
@ProVishGaming That's 100% fake News and misinformation, Hardware Unboxed proved in one of their latest video that a good CPU is 100% important for good performance even at 4K, and specially high to Ultra settings since the settings is what use more CPU resources then GPU, also a lot more games are coming out more CPU Heavy like Dragons Dogma 2 and Black Myth Wukong, so this info is made up by a bunch of ignorant people that don't know what the hell they are talking about and be like just trust me bro, with no data nor proof to back it up. The Best Configuration for Gaming for Called 3DVcache anything else is trash or misinformation.
@hdz77
@hdz77 3 күн бұрын
@ProVishGaming Your build is made up trash misinformation called, just trust me Bro 🤡🤡🤡, 7800X3D Trashes, demolished and absolutely destroys the 13 and 14900k with less power, less headeaches and no degradation, sit down fake News chump.
@ProVishGaming
@ProVishGaming 3 күн бұрын
@@hdz77 you are the one actually the providing misinformation. You provided 0 numbers so let me provide some numbers. Upon watching HUB’s 7800x3d vs 13900k at 1080p, 1440p, and 4K video, the 7800x3d was 5% faster at 1080p, 4% faster at 1440p, and 1% faster at 4K. All while USING A RTX 4090. Any worse GPU and results would have been identical. Please stop spewing misinformation like an idiot. You bring up fringe titles where AMD x3d gets a win, but games like the star wars game, hogwarts also favor intel heavily with double digit improvements. If you take the average like hub did in the video, it’s very minimal (5% at 1080p). Kindly never speak about issues you don’t know again.
@BarryMcCokiner47
@BarryMcCokiner47 3 күн бұрын
Mw3 benchmark the same as the mw2 shown ?
@jabronilifestyle
@jabronilifestyle 3 күн бұрын
Nobody is gonna buy them and Intel is looking at enough lawsuits for bankruptcy soooooooo RIP
@MrDabadabadu
@MrDabadabadu 3 күн бұрын
Please learn to use microphone, you are heavily clipping, clearly to loud, you can hear P, B, T etc. clipping all the time.
@steezegod2768
@steezegod2768 3 күн бұрын
Danny, If you disable E cores, you raise ring ratio If you disable hyperthreading you get 100mhz faster, add In the actual data bud.
@Crossfire2003
@Crossfire2003 3 күн бұрын
Yeah. Keeping E-Cores on and Hyperthreading off seams like the best choice.
@stefandywersant6679
@stefandywersant6679 3 күн бұрын
Windows should be reinstalled after each change, it is known that os will produce problems when switching number of cores without clean install.
@alecs2244
@alecs2244 3 күн бұрын
Amazing work, but I would have included Windows 10 in the benchmarks. I know it would have doubled the time and effort, but I still think Windows 10 is king for gaming on both Intel and AMD. Thanks for the hard work!
@alphaomega154
@alphaomega154 3 күн бұрын
i think eventually they are heading to full all simple small E cores that in massive amount type of chip. with NO P cores. so they will have literally individual compute unit that coming in large amount but in simpler instruction and easy on power resources. and each can act as multi thread combined together or single individual threads. flexibility. but this approach will benefit for a very short generations. since the silicon semi conductor tech itself have reached its peak potential in its electrical design. they will not be able to keep selling things that eventually has no more gains.
@yonghominale8884
@yonghominale8884 Күн бұрын
You know you just described Threadripper
@mikebruzzone9570
@mikebruzzone9570 3 күн бұрын
Good applications report it would seem content providers did optimize for e-cores but whether they compiled for parallel SIMD operations you'd have to tell us Danny which is e-cores doing the matrix math, vectors, for some aspect of play back that likely can be seen in game play for a specific situation, drawing and shading that is not refresh of a scene but a change in the pixels to display some specific aspect within the e-cores capability. Or maybe its audio playback who knows but they do something what is it? mb
@mikebruzzone9570
@mikebruzzone9570 3 күн бұрын
Report definitively shows the simple (effective?) compile for 8 P cores. mb
@mikebruzzone9570
@mikebruzzone9570 3 күн бұрын
Maybe there just like a slug power plant adding to the main engine? I don't know but I am curious maybe you should query a few developers as a report topic. mb
@mikebruzzone9570
@mikebruzzone9570 3 күн бұрын
Disable HT interesting power optimization technique few others have mentioned that along my audit like framechasers and Scatter Bencher who I think got the optimizations down but don't recall they mentioned 'just disable HT'. mb
@Darksh1n
@Darksh1n 3 күн бұрын
Why is not Diablo 4 tested it's one of the most popular games out right now
@AgentHondaCivic
@AgentHondaCivic 3 күн бұрын
9800X3D Gonna DOMINATE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@PAIN-ot4cj
@PAIN-ot4cj Күн бұрын
It’s gonna be 5% faster than a 7800X3D
@livinglifeboosted1642
@livinglifeboosted1642 21 сағат бұрын
I’m gonna go as far as to say if Intel next generation CPS are a failure, the company is bankrupt or it’s gonna be brought up by somebody else and it will never be the same again also the problem is a lot of people have lost faith and trust in Intel I am one of and believe me when I say I don’t trust AMD much more either I believe the computer industry is in quite a lot of trouble at the moment and we’ll see this when the 50 series GPU has come from Nvidia and we have to pay an arm and a leg and both kidneys for them
@laggmonstret
@laggmonstret 3 күн бұрын
Ok so HT on and E-cores on is basicly the best for both gaming and productivity? Got it😂
@Met1900
@Met1900 3 күн бұрын
Good test but to profit from disabled HT is to not have it in the chip at all. Thats why i think arrow lake will be great for gaming.
@NetrunnerAT
@NetrunnerAT Күн бұрын
I think HT Story ist very old. Since HT exist, its depends on two factor. What Compiler is used and can the Taskmanager Deal with the Code Base. Most Programms are Not carefully optimised and act Strange. Linux is in this Point better. You can easy Switch shedular to handle HT or E-Core better, without Code optimisation.
@sdnnvs
@sdnnvs 3 күн бұрын
My 14900kf runs better with HT off + 8P + 8E (8E disabled) = 16T. Games are optimized for consoles, in other words, 16T. Better temps, better energy consumption...
@iLegionaire3755
@iLegionaire3755 3 күн бұрын
7800X3D has Simultaneous Multithreading (AMD's version of Hyperthreading) always enabled and sips power in full gaming workloads.
@eawblablatron9161
@eawblablatron9161 2 күн бұрын
intel needs to put its shit together. degrading cpus?
@michaelthompson9798
@michaelthompson9798 3 күн бұрын
Great review Danny 🤩🤯🥰💪and very informative! I’d love to see you do a comparison with AMD Ryzen …. Higher coded variants with Both non-3D vs 3D v-cache CPUs 🫡🙂‍↕👍
@MrHC1983
@MrHC1983 3 күн бұрын
Imagine owning an Intel 13th and 14th gen........... lol. Silly bugger.
@hralch1234
@hralch1234 3 күн бұрын
Thank you for this video! can you please add MSFS 2020?
@ceuser3555
@ceuser3555 2 күн бұрын
They should have abandoned hyper threading and the ecore nonsense.
@frankwong9486
@frankwong9486 3 күн бұрын
Intel : Get rid of HT in hardware design, saved transistor space and used those to make a better P core KZbinr: make video with a older generation and HT / ecore disabled for readers who claim HT disable have better performance Basically you dont need to make them a video , because they are Not the same thing
@Bass.Player
@Bass.Player 3 күн бұрын
You can not make up for the loss because in all cases hyper-threading will benefit performance. Arrow lake with lower clock speed and ditched HT is revealing, I don't expect much from this release except lower power draw and we see how a lower power design has worked out for AMD's Gen 5. Die shrink enables more transistors is a smaller space, but thinner dielectric material means more heat from leakage and dictates using lower voltage. A new architecture may circumvent some of this but a smaller die size won't. IMO. At this point pushing more 1's and 0's takes power and the binary system probably needs a change soon...✌
@bamboostick5
@bamboostick5 3 күн бұрын
Compare with 9700k pls
@carlosrieum1526
@carlosrieum1526 3 күн бұрын
it should be at least 12+12 cores
@jjlw2378
@jjlw2378 3 күн бұрын
Gotta Try 8p+8e HT off.
@Adel-sj4ue
@Adel-sj4ue 3 күн бұрын
What a great vedieo Thanks man
@gedeuchnixan3830
@gedeuchnixan3830 3 күн бұрын
I think both Intel and AMD have to do better, if you can´t really do the promised improvements without massive tinggeling get lost. Who the f*k wants to UNDERVOLT his out of box CPU only for it not overheating @Intel ? AMD isn´t doing better perfomance improvement wise nor on pricing after failing to deliver a propper upgrade nor does eithe have ANY OC headroom left the chips are almost all pretty much run to the limit out of the box no freaking difference. But why does anyone buy Intels crap right now and bothering with all those issues AMD doesn´t have? An explonation for that weird buying behavior would be nice so I can understand since it doesn´t make sense. Intel´s issues are always called "minor problems" but a normal user doesn´t want to deal with such b*tchy CPUs just like we now rejecting DEI in all entertainment: normal people don´t wanna deal with that oversensitivity!
@tacoterito22
@tacoterito22 4 күн бұрын
Would be great to test it on windows 10 also. Great video!! But i See a problem, it should not affect performance when you disable HT, the problem its that maybe with the thermal solution that you have its not enought so the turbo boost or the the cpu downclock to meet the VID requirement from the cpu, if you Custom liquid cool/delid you should not have this problem. And WTF is the result on MWII??? i have both, my 14900k OC to 5.9hz 7600Mt/s on the memory and thats not the result vs Ecore on and HT, you must be doing something wrong mate, there is no way in life that disable Ecores and HT lose you that dramatic FPS. Soz the bad english
@get-in-2-get-out774
@get-in-2-get-out774 3 күн бұрын
800 views / 100(+) Likes Good ratio !
@adriancojo6671
@adriancojo6671 3 күн бұрын
Any news on the Bartlett lga1700? I have a 12600k and i ll never buy a hybrid intel CPU ever again. I had to disable the e-core because of the stutterfest on my 4070Super.
@theanglerfish
@theanglerfish 3 күн бұрын
Huh? I don't have any issues but i'm on 12900KS i had 5800X on that i had a lot of stutters on i9 i had only one ¯⁠\⁠(⁠°⁠_⁠o⁠)⁠/⁠¯ 6000MT/s CL 30
@adriancojo6671
@adriancojo6671 3 күн бұрын
@@theanglerfish use Superposition Benchmark at 4k and u might see them.
@marcinkarpiuk7797
@marcinkarpiuk7797 3 күн бұрын
go win 11 its better with working with ecores
@Ray88G
@Ray88G 2 күн бұрын
Best config is only p cores
@WinZard
@WinZard 3 күн бұрын
there e cores are there new hardware hyper threading.
@mokhtariabdelmadjid2977
@mokhtariabdelmadjid2977 3 күн бұрын
Even without it, Arrow Lake needs to be at least 10% better than AMD's X3D parts in terms of TDP, price, and efficiency for gamers to even consider it. After the disappointment of Intel’s 13th and 14th Gen, no one trusts Intel anymore. Desktop gaming for Intel is essentially dead, and its data center prospects are also diminishing. This leaves only the laptop market, which will soon face strong competition from Strix Halo. Intel will likely end up using TSMC for better stability and efficiency, marking the end of Intel's own foundries. All the government funding will have been wasted on poor decision-making by CEOs.
@Zeni-th.
@Zeni-th. 3 күн бұрын
? AWS and Intel recently announced a multimillion deal. Xeons on Intel 3 and pots of things in 18A 14A and 14AE. They invested millions in Ohio where the new fab is being constructed.
@BlindBison
@BlindBison 3 күн бұрын
Bump
@evanharris1629
@evanharris1629 3 күн бұрын
7/11/11 also if you have black hole cores anti star cores try disabling your trashiest,
@impuls60
@impuls60 3 күн бұрын
Rumours say they used the same ring solution and then you will have high latency to the ecores even though they are fast. So in 100fps (low fps games) having them ON will probably be best, but in 300fps+ having them OFF will yield highest 0.1%lows. Thats my prediction.
@henson2k
@henson2k 3 күн бұрын
So HT basically doesn't matter
@totalermist
@totalermist 2 күн бұрын
*for games
@Phil-D83
@Phil-D83 3 күн бұрын
Intel needs to fire top management and product management, and get the circus back into order.
@MGsubbie
@MGsubbie 3 күн бұрын
Biggest reason I'm excited for next-gen Intel is that this will probably cause AMD to release the 9800X3D.
@ivankintober7561
@ivankintober7561 3 күн бұрын
while getting destroyed in benchmark when arrow lake is surpassing every zen5 chip lately....
@MGsubbie
@MGsubbie 3 күн бұрын
@@ivankintober7561 Aren't those multithread benchmarks? They better be faster with the more cores. In gaming, single-thread is still king, and with the 7800X3D having like 20% greater ST, it seems like that might still be the gaming champion.
@Ray88G
@Ray88G 2 күн бұрын
Useless gamer fanboy video
@ofon2000
@ofon2000 4 күн бұрын
1st
@tacoterito22
@tacoterito22 4 күн бұрын
you where second :D
@AgentHondaCivic
@AgentHondaCivic 3 күн бұрын
NO SMT. =No PURCHASE
@leandrodrace
@leandrodrace 3 күн бұрын
07:10 excuse me? 108 fps = terrible 1% lows? I understand it`s like 50% behind but also I`m positive 100+ fps on 1% lows is far from terrible. I even dare to say the difference between 108 and 170 on 1% lows are impossible to notice.
Intel's Lunar Lake: Is this the end for Qualcomm?
18:13
Just Josh
Рет қаралды 43 М.
Новый уровень твоей сосиски
00:33
Кушать Хочу
Рет қаралды 4,6 МЛН
How To Get Married:   #short
00:22
Jin and Hattie
Рет қаралды 16 МЛН
The Most Hated Politician in America
37:15
big boss
Рет қаралды 806 М.
Intel Arrow Lake Cinebench 1T Leak | Nintendo Switch 2 Update
14:00
Moore's Law Is Dead
Рет қаралды 62 М.
The Newest X3D is an AM4 Chip? || Ryzen 7 5700X3D
8:44
The Savage Asian
Рет қаралды 8 М.
When Windows Picks Favorites...
29:40
Vex
Рет қаралды 197 М.
BlackRock: The Conspiracies You Don’t Know
15:13
More Perfect Union
Рет қаралды 1,4 МЛН
Why did we Abandon 4:3? | Nostalgia Nerd
16:40
Nostalgia Nerd
Рет қаралды 691 М.
Nvidia's New WORST RTX Graphics Card?
12:07
Dawid Does Tech Stuff
Рет қаралды 194 М.
NEVER install these programs on your PC... EVER!!!
19:26
JayzTwoCents
Рет қаралды 3,4 МЛН
The Father of AMD Zen: Origins of Ryzen Architecture
15:25
GN Extras
Рет қаралды 50 М.
AMD RX 8800XT a GIANT Leap for Mainstream Gamers! - The UDNA Strategy
16:15