Wish - Nostalgia Critic

[@equusheart3344]

The thing with Wish is its painful to know what we could've had given all the concepts behind it. We could've had a magic filled romance with a powerful villain pair.

[@gengargamer5657]

As I’ve said before, this movie is like The Lorax

[@sebastianemond5313]

​@gengargamer5657 Especially with Disney's Analysts going- "Well, the chart says-"

[@dinoboy4662]

​@@sebastianemond5313 Everyone: I'm not asking the charts, I'm asking you

[@Stormdragon356]

​@@dinoboy4662but the chart says

[@somedude9450]

@@dinoboy4662…Well the chart says-

[@gamebawesome]

I still hate how “Watch out world, here I are.” Was a lyric and the writers gave it the thumbs up

[@jaycolus3893]

Howard Ashman turns in his grave.

[@traviswhitfield8045]

“Watch out world, here WE are.” USE YOUR BRAIN DISENY. SHIT!!!

[@mysticmind4563]

The worst part is that it's an easy fix. Just change it to "we are".

[@meganbaute4254]

It’s so bad

[@gmarquez2073]

To be fair, it wasn’t cool when Timbaland or Bebe Rexha did it either.

[@ShahroozSmith]

Imagine asking for the biggest, tastiest wedding cake you could ever hope for on your wedding day.. but all the cook gives out is a cake made of Tofu, no sweetening, no spice, just a block of tofu shaped to look like a cake. That's what this movie is.

[@jackmack4181]

It’s so soulless that undead necromancies and lich won’t go near it

[@godabandonedthistimeline]

That's an insult to tofu. It's more like a cardboard box shaped like a cake

[@sebastianemond5313]

14:32 - 14:53 😒🤦‍♂️How is Asha the hero again? She goes on about how no one person should be in charge of everyone's wishes, but she becomes exactly like Magnifico in the end, but less careful with who gets their wishes granted. What if she grants the wish of a total psychopath? Someone who wants to make a weapon of mass destruction, like the atom bomb? (From Pitch Meeting) Ryan George: "🤨No hypotheticals, please. 😅It's okay for her to do that *now* because Asha's the main character and Magnifico's the bad guy." 🙄😅🤷‍♂️Oh, I guess *you're right.*

[@615randomgoat7]

It would have been nice had she not became a fairy godmother, but they wanted the reference. Asha's thing was that not only should someone not be in charge of deciding who's wishes gets granted. She had a point saying, if he wasn't going to grant them, then he should return them for the people to try to achieve them, themselves. Basically he's taking their dreams away from them. At leas tin Asha's world, the people still have their own wishes and can seek after them themselves without hoping for their wish to be granted and having no idea what it is they wanted to do.

[@ZakaZ1996]

This is one film where every tidbit, bonus feature, and deleted scene from it made shout "Why isn't THIS the movie we got?"

[@crystal95405]

I know, right? we could have gotten a villain couple and a star boy how was the main love interest. But it seems like Disney is to afraid to take risks.

[@pascaleelliott63]

Script aside, just talking about the animation here. Imagine if this movie was animated similar to how Netflix's "Klaus" was animated. All entirely 2D, but shaded and scaled in a way that made the 2D animation look like it had a 3D dimension to it.

[@annika3265]

I've heard people saying we should be glad Disney at least tried something different but I hate that sentiment cause it's like we're supposed to be happy they gave us their bare minimum effort, my favorite video talking about the animation of this movie is from the channel No The Robot cause he's an actual animator and he goes over all the bad and even the good parts of this animation. It's really weird, when 3d began to dominate the market Disney scrambled to turn out more creative projects as an effort to stay relevant, we got movies like Atlantis, emperor's new groove, brother bear, Lilo and Stitch, but now when there more experimental movies coming out like the Spiderverse franchise and Klaus and even things like Mushka that was made by an actual ex-disney animator the best Disney themselves can do to compete with all that is Wish, it's so insulting when everyone else is working so hard and this is the best they can do.

[@arealconservative8712]

My brother-in-law's girlfriend told me that she loved this movie. Why? Because the lead character was biracial, and one of the main supporting characters was disabled. That's it. Aside from "some of the jokes were funny," that's all she had to say. That was apparently enough for a glowing recommendation.

[@zeldaprincessgirl100]

Let me guess, diversity is the only thing that mattered to her, screw the story, screw how the characters were written, screw the animation, screw everything. How shallow is she.

[@averagegamecritic]

For the diversity thing, like The Critic mentioned with Kim Possible: You make a character that’s something, not something that’s a character. You are supposed to make a character first otherwise their personality is entirely based on their group Nope. It’s a reference to keep buying Disney’s “wishes”

[@ARCtheCartoonMaster]

Whoa whoa whoa... *what?* Okay, first of all, Doug was talking about *female* characters. I don't care what your woke intersectional Gender Studies professor told you - being female is *not the same as being a minority group.* Just because the woke leftists say women are a minority group, doesn't mean they're right. Second, the whole point of us writing female characters as... you know, normal characters, is because we want to write them as *not* just some token minority group. We want to show that women make up roughly half the population like men do, so there's nothing special about being a woman, and they're just regular people like men are. *Men are a gender as well,* in case you didn't realise, and you'd be surprised how much gender discrimination men face from men and women alike. When we say we want well written female characters, we actually *mean* it - we don't also want to bring POC and LGBT characters into it, because then we're just writing women as a token minority group again, so we're just left with the same problem that we started with. It's really frustrating that woke politics have now become so influential that they're even influencing how the anti-woke people think, and when you ask the anti-woke people why *they* adhere to the "women = minority" mindset, the response the usually give is, "Well, it's what the woke people believe!" But like... they're supposed to be *anti* woke, so they should be *opposing* the woke mindset, rather than perpetuating it. We should be *debunking* the myth that women are a minority group. The fact that you took what Doug said about female characters, and applied it to minority groups, shows that you *completely* missed the point of what he was saying, and that unlike Doug, you just view women as another token minority group, even when they're actually written as normal characters. You know, despite that men are a gender as well, and that the "token boy" trope is present in works of fiction that have a female protagonist, such as _Punky Brewster_ and _Hilda,_ to name examples, which have a *white female* protagonist with a *token black* friend and a *token male* friend. Or, you know, like _Kim Possible,_ which has token black friends of *both* genders. It sucks that I have to spell it out for you, but here we are - being a girl isn't the same as being black. Maybe go out and actually *meet* women sometime - you'll see that they're just normal people like you and me, and not just some diversity group that the woke left loves to push onto us.

[@jamesdowman2023]

​@@ARCtheCartoonMasterwomp womp

[@mrcwillis6970]

Sad how the 100th anniversary for Disney was.. wish could have been so much better… Happy we at least we got the 100th anniversary short.

[@101superchao]

I just realized that during the 100th anniversary they did no do any tributes to Walt in anyway besides that small part in the short. There was no documentary's about him or merch as far as am aware of was being sold. This just proves that modern Disney hates it past history.

[@garrettbays6942]

Frankly, what little I saw of the short seemed to say, "Look how low we've brought ourselves." I am not complementing the short in that regard as well; it didn't look interesting to me at all.

[@sebastianemond5313]

​@@garrettbays6942 The short still has more heart and soul than Wish, especially with the group rendition of "When You *Wish* Upon A Star."

[@garrettbays6942]

@sebastianemond5313 now that just sounds cringy and corny. Added to that, I have never been a big fan of group singing of a notable song, and frankly "When You Wish Upon a Star" has lost its charm with the way Disney has had over-the-top arrangements of it, especially for their current film logo.

[@sebastianemond5313]

@garrettbays6942 I do agree with you that Disney has lost their way, writing to please focus groups as opposed to writing from the heart, and just shilling out products to sell us on under the misguided hope that 'cause it's from Disney, we'll fall for it. But I still believe in what the song instills in fans rather than which fans it represents, like many social and political groups debate on with media.

[@SebasTian58323]

This could work much better as a story from Magnifico's point of view. He's a tragic hero corrupted by dark magic while trying to save his kingdom, forever trapped in a mirror, while a young woman runs the kingdom he built into the ground as she has no idea how to handle granting wishes. Eventually, she turns to him in the mirror for help, setting him up at the magic mirror. Asha starts to lose it from the pressure, turning evil herself and leaving the kingdom to marry into another one, taking the mirror with her-surprise prequel. The seven dwarves are the descendants of her friends, living in the woods after the kingdom fell to ruin. I know it's a bit fanfictiony, but it's better than what it was. I'd love to see that movie. And regarding "This is the Thanks I Get," I know it's supposed to be his villain song, but it plays out more like a frustrated and egocentric hero who's done nothing but give to his community and is taken advantage of. People only respect his ability to grant their wishes, not him as a person. It feels much more like a tragic hero pushed to dark magic than a villain. But this does remind me of a light novel series I read. In it, a goddess wanted to give humanity a paradise, so she did. She created a world without illness, hunger, poverty, or dangers. But no matter what she gave humanity, they wanted more. She realized that without strife, humanity can't recognize paradise. They need to struggle to be happy. So she came up with a cycle: humanity is threatened, a hero rises up, and it repeats. They enjoy peace until it's threatened again. Humanity eventually rises up against her, wanting free will. The protagonist recognizes the goddess's genuine intent to help but acknowledges her mistake due to lack of guidance. They could have done something similar here, where Magnifico goes down the wrong path to protect the kingdom, misunderstood by most citizens. Asha researches and realizes his intentions, using her power to heal him and joining forces to create a more compassionate rule.. And look at the state of the kingdom. Besides her one friend, everyone is happy, safe, signing and dancing, and willingly gave their wish to him because they thought it would be too hard to achieve themselves. He takes the wish, protects them, and the memories of what the wish was are erased so they're not stressing about it. The people know this. He's not hiding anything of what he's doing. Asha is just upset that her grandpa didn't get his wish, so she decides he's evil, and the movie does everything it can to try to prove her right, but it kinda fails in my opinion.

[@Hanmacx]

Reminds me of Maui from Moana, "I gave them everything, it was never enough"

[@SebasTian58323]

@@Hanmacx yeah, that's actually pretty accurate

[@matthewscorner2990]

Yes. I approve. Magnifico has much more potential as a tortured protagonist.

[@robbieking4070]

What's the light novel series?

[@SebasTian58323]

@@robbieking4070 a wild last boss appeared is the name

[@sonicboomers122]

"Mirrors, mirrors on the walls" is not a Snow White reference; it is a Sherk reference. You might be saying, "Wait! That is what the evil queen says in the movie, right?" No," Mirror mirror" is what Lord Farque said. It is a common Menedla effect. The line is magic mirror on the wall, not mirror mirror. They did not care.

[@FurKid_the_Gg_roo_99]

Damn.

[@malikpierre-louis3343]

This gets even funnier when you remeber that Shrek was a movie that was made to MOCK Disney and what it stood for, and now when trying to reference themsleves they actually reference a movie that was made out of spite against them and that is hilarious.

[@dragon345678]

Sometimes the universe throws you comedy gold. Like Nate saying that the Queen should’ve asked Magnifico “Okay whose dream did you kill this time?” Commercial: Febreeze

[@LeaveItToRemm]

I wish this movie would be attacked by the barracuda from the beginning of finding Nemo

[@RGDarx72]

I would of loved a House of Mouse for the 100th anniversary but after this I’m glad it was never a thought

[@mysticmind4563]

"It's the definition of a charts movie..." Charts guy: *Shudders* why do I feel needlessly offended? Even more so than usual.

[@sebastianemond5313]

27:57 - 28:02 😒Haha, get it? Because- (From Frozen) *Duke of Weselton.* (From Zootopia) Duke Weaselton: "It's *Weaselton!* Duke Weaselton!"

[@Yojimbo16]

I remember last year, my sister took me to see the new Ninja Turtles movie for my birthday and she told me she had a thing with her husband where they would watch the trailers and they would give a thumbs up if they wanted to go see it, thumbs sideways if they want to rent it or thumbs down to skip it. When the Wish Trailer played, I gave it a thumbs down.

[@MovieFan1912]

That sounds like what Siskel and Ebert used to do.

[@jerecklacap8867]

It was supposed to be the origin of the star in "wish upon a star". What in the ever-living hell happened BTS?

[@rokkraljkolesa9317]

corporate that's what happened

[@robbieshaw1629]

Walt Disney Is turning in his grave after this movie came out say what you want about the man but back when he was running Disney it came out with a ton of good movies.

[@danielscott5673]

Wish: meh. Once Upon a Studio: yes.

[@deshawnedwards6412]

Best part of this movie was the ending, as in the End Credits. seriously, I got more entertainment out of the watching the credits than I did from the film itself, 100th years of Disney films that I could be watching instead of this. And that includes Strange World which at least had a story compared to this.

[@Vaguer_Weevil]

"Ya know what I like most about your stories? The sound it makes when it stops."

[@MovieFan1912]

@@Vaguer_WeevilStatler and Waldorf: Doh-hohohoho!

[@gengargamer5657]

This movie is basically a modern day equivalent of The Lorax 2012, in that it’s a movie that was supposed to be good based off the cut/beta content but was f*cked over hard by corporate meddling.

[@ARCtheCartoonMaster]

And what's more, this movie appears to be a commentary on the exact kind of capitalistic bureaucracy that ended up being its downfall, so... talk about a pyrrhic victory, proving Disney right by being a victim of Disney.

[@Gamertag3608]

True minus the so bad it's good aspect

[@gengargamer5657]

@@Gamertag3608 Yup

[@jamesmoyner7499]

Next week isn't Madame Web, instead it's The Land Before Time. However, Doug has said once Web has a physical media release he will be covering if.

[@dikastederook6380]

I honest'ly can't deny I'm excited for the Madame Web review

[@sebastianemond5313]

*Madame Web* *Available in I-MAX* Doug: "😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣I-MAAAAAAAX!! *hoarse laughing* *😅Don't* see this in I-MAX."

[@haydnberthold9489]

Whenever I get bored, I made two characters, a pitch writer and Mr. Hollywood. Basically, the pitch writer will give something good and creative while Mr. Hollywood changes it to be corporate. Whenever I think of this movie I just think of those two.

[@mikechicago6200]

Once Upon A Studio was way better then the entire movie....that was a good tribute for the 100th anniversary also RIP Burny Mattinson!

[@stevenl9794]

OH SNAP did not Expect this reaction but I am happy

[@chimelxatrindad1516]

I'm surprised he hasn't done aristocats yet.

[@leonardomaranhao2861]

Is nate ok? He looked like he wanted to fall asleep.

[@SuperMandibleclaw]

I swear that happens in more and more videos

[@phiferbb10tmjagP]

I noticed too It really looks he was almost falling out of the chair

[@narendramartosudarmo6112]

Doug's covering Madame Web in several hours, so get ready to be in the Amazon with someone when she was researching spiders right before she died.

[@OMSOFFICIALS]

Nick is my Spirit Animal. We even wear the same glasses.

[@horimo8920]

Awesome

[@Vaguer_Weevil]

Are you the reason his stuff goes missing?

[@OMSOFFICIALS]

@@Vaguer_Weevil No.... .....Maybe

[@teddystephens3054]

I love the fact that nate was falling asleep just from the review.

[@117Jorn]

If you wanted to do a perfect 100th Anniversary movie, I would've found some way to connect this all to Kingdom Hearts - perhaps make it the origin story to all the worlds being created from KH.

[@theotherjared9824]

Wish is so bad that it's become a passtime on the internet to rewrite its plot on the spot when talking about it.

[@afanofstuff9123]

18:43 that's the point he's not a evil guy and his goal is a noble one so they have to suddenly make him a dumb asshole out of nowhere so the lead looks better. He literally has all the power in the world and what does he do he makes a perfect city no crime, no starvation, No suffering, no homeless, and each month someone basically gets their hearts desire come true. Like seriously there is no problem other than Steve down the road won't fly now but even Steve doesn't know that's what he wants He's happy living his life in paradise.

[@dikastederook6380]

Worst part of this is that I can't help but actually genuinely liking Magnifico. And none of it changes the fact it's still a bad movie.

[@Christopherbellfan203]

I’m still so pissed we didn’t get the original version of this movie. Like, Disney royally messed up.

[@jeuryrabassa4724]

As they mostly do. How Ironic.

[@sebastianemond5313]

Well, again, they probably saw how similar the premise was to Neil Gaiman's Stardust, with a romance between a human and a star humanoid. But hey, that wouldn't stop them from ripping off better source material that came before their "original ideas."

[@sykheincosmonaughty5628]

Half the characters in this film, main ones or otherwise, look like reused assets from shreks background character roster!

[@EternalStorm796]

funny thing, the villain wasn't a psycho. sure, he was vain on the inside but he was incredibly generous and was genuinely a thoughtful person. Asha was caught up in her feelings and selfishly ruined the guy's life. He didn't even want to use the book *due to it basically being the darkhold*

[@Jeremy_theGent]

Wow this might be the quickest reaction to an NC video yet.

[@autumbreeze1129]

Tamara: WAS there a horse in Wish? Malcolm: you gonna watch the movie to find ou-? Tamara: hell, no 😂 It's the quick deadpan "hell, no" that really makes that funny. Just 2 words, delivered in a way that perfectly explains Just how HORRIBLE an experience even knowing OF Wish is, let alone the personal torment you'd be putting yourself through by actually sitting down and watching it from beginning to end. With just TWO words.😂 I honestly think the fact I own Disney's first movie, Treasure Island, as well as the special 2 disc edition of Snow White, their first animated movie, on DVD is more justifiable as a celebration of 100 years of Disney than this nothing movie

[@kaylaadjekum6270]

Executive meddling is what Killed this Film

[@47ratsinahoodie]

Random but, why does Rosas have a dungeon??? If everyone's happy and presumably abiding by the rules, what need is there for a dungeon?

[@ARCtheCartoonMaster]

7:50 Total missed opportunity for "the family Mierdrigal".

[@7evenseas975]

I kept saying as I was watching the movie that The king was not even a bad guy. He was having a a terrible week or whenever, girl says some crazy shit, nostalgic critics points, and that the book was possessing him. And he gets unfairly sent to the dungeon when the wish granting star could easily free him. In conclusion of this yap talk This movie is worse then bad, it's nothing

[@insectostrich4407]

Hey, I’ve been meaning to ask you guys. What’s your overall opinion on Doug? Because he does make some mistakes in his reviews and there have been a few people attempting to debunk some of his videos. Me personally, I think he’s still a great person and a mostly good critic despite his flaws. Plus, he has owned up to his past mistakes. However, I want to hear your thoughts.

[@simsgirlgem]

The concept and original ideas were so much better than what we got 😞

[@pandaman9238]

Does anyone notice that the guy in blue looks like Miguel from road to el dorado 25:30

[@sebastianemond5313]

Miguel: "How's the um- How's the escape plan coming?"

[@creeperjo7]

I remember walking past the clearance isle in Walmart and seeing a shit ton of Wish merchandise in it Not even kids who like flashy bright colors wanted anything from this movie

[@wattsink2009]

29:42 This isn’t quite as bad as the end credits of Jem And The Holograms, but it’s close! 😤

[@SJ_RANKS]

You want this movie done right check out puss in boots the last wish it’s sad that this what they did for 100 years of Disney like Disney pioneered animated films and nowadays a lot of stupid people think animation is just for kids and that’s what the mindset was behind this movie “animation is just for kids who gives a sh🐬t” and i a lot of people have said this a hundred times ANIMATION IS NOT JUST FOR KIDS!!! Its for everyone Walt himself said it and now Disney are contradicting themselves by remaking movies in live action 😒 Edit: because autocorrect made are ate

[@MovieFan1912]

Brad Bird has been saying that for a long time.

[@KaeMcSpadden]

The song At All Costs was originally going to be a love song, and would have worked much better if they went with the Star Boy idea.

[@octo-generaljones8691]

In just a few months of posting this, Deadpool and Wolverine (aka the mcu’s dying gasp) will be in theaters. After that, is there anything in the mcu that is worth looking into?

[@futuremovieactor]

I raised my hand to both of your opening questions Nate. Haha.

[@thecrimsondragon2379]

My hand has never felt a stronger urge to go to the ground than in the first 30 seconds of this video.

[@alibrennan5977]

If you really want to watch something made by Disney that actually tried to take risks in an awesome way, go watch The Owl House. Disney didn’t treat the show well but that’s a story for another day

[@sarahhiversoeur3759]

When I first saw the Wish trailer on YMS' twitch, Disney went out of their way to manipulate their audience by telling them that the people who worked on Wish are the same people who made Lion King, Sleeping Beauty, and Snow White. Everyone in the chat including YMS himself thought that it was flat out shameless of Disney for going out of their way and doing that to their manipulate their audience for the 100th anniversary movie.

[@noir-214]

Once upon a studio, did this better, and that was 8 minutes

[@anyathepanther7977]

*Wish* is the Prime Example of Disneys Downfall! "Look how we fell from Grace! We used to be creative and inspired lots of People to become creative themself! Now we are too afraid to stray from the lines so we wont lose Money. Which results in us losing money!"

[@alyssabullock6421]

I wish he dived into the concepts of the original movie. There was SO much potential and work done on the original draft, where the king and queen were EVIL already, therefore giving a way better reason for Asha to want more for her people instead of acting like they're all suffering for NO reason (because everyone is genuinely happy, they dont care about anything until Asha messed stuff up), and the Star was originally a magical, shape shifting boy who would become Asha's love interest. I've seen animatics and art, and the original idea for this film was already fleshed out to a great extent and looked SO much more intense and genuine and original. Disney messed up SO badly with this movie, and I desperately hope we get a miracle to have it be remade. Also Asha really did just screw up in this movie. One of the big gripes people have is Magnifico ISNT A BAD GUY. He starts off as an actually normal, sensible dude with reasons for what he does, but then Asha comes in and has the nerve to question his methods when she was COMPLETELY aware of how the entire system works for the wishes already and never complained before. After that Magnifico gets mad, and Asha, feeling offended and sad because her grandpa wont get his wish (as if his life wasn't already content and prosperous in a kingdom where they DONT EVEN HAVE TO PAY TO LIVE THERE, as Magnifico himself said), we get the random song "I Make This Wish" which is incredibly contradictive to the plot because Asha sings about wanting "more than this" and acting like the kingdom deserves better and that she's trying to discover herself or what ever, when up until this point, we literally have seen how HAPPY everyone is, and how satisfied Asha ALREADY was with her life. But oh no, now everything is suddenly awful and HAS to change because the king doesnt grant every wish, even though that's EXACTLY what everyone knew and willingly abided by. Asha's motivation makes no sense, is what i'm trying to say. In return, she causes a once GOOD king to lose his mind out of fear of the magic from the star that Asha's song summons (Because oh my god, how fortunate and privileged she must be to only need to SING in order to get a magical, wish granting God on her side) and he tries to snuff her out rightfully because she's literally planning to rob his entire purpose and what his kingdom represents. Also it's important to note that in this movie, Magnifico is a good husband. His wife loves him, he listens to her, she supports him... UNTIL he snaps and his wife INSTANTLY disowns him and acts like she never knew him and doesn't even consider trying to redeem him or help him out. She just instantly accepts that her long time husband and good king is a bad man, and she feels 0 remorse or sympathy when he gets locked up in the dungeon. It's messed up.

[@leephillips4402]

13:14 my spirit animal for the next four years.

[@deshawnedwards6412]

Is the Channel Awesome studio being painted? Cause most of these recent reviews have been taking place in Doug's home.

[@IAmInfinitus208]

They've been having ceiling issues to the point where further maintenance isn't working so they're planning to move to a new studio.

[@LeaveItToRemm]

Late last year early this year it was being repaired because it got hit by tornado and after all the repairs the ceiling was still messed up so they're looking for a whole new place.

[@KyleRosenthal-pf7gu]

28:40 Hail to all the beasts of England! Sorry that’s my favorite book ever

[@thesupershinymegagengar2034]

The Luma looking ahh star looks like it belongs in a Kirby game. Jokes aside, when I watched this movie, aside from the animation, I see where all the A.I. allegations came from.

[@cytromix9927]

A kingdom hearts movie would be a better 100th celebration than wish.

[@SonicXAmy121Gamer]

Wait a minute that’s actually a great idea! It does everything Wish wished it did. Acknowledge new and old Disney without feeling needlessly shoehorned in, a plot that while stupidly complicated as the series went on actually does have an end goal for the most part as to why the Disney worlds even exist so they could’ve made it a series of movies with the first one being a straight adaptation of the first game, and you actually give a shit about the worlds and characters. I mean could you imagine a big budget Disney 2D anime styled film for KH? I mean it’s not like the animation studio hasn’t wanted to explore and expand their talent. Hell Encanto in the art of book actually said that the staff originally wanted the art style of the movie to be a blend of traditional Disney Animation with that of Hayao Miyazaki work like Howl’s Moving Castle but it got canned early on most likely do to the higher ups saying no hence why the film looked more in line with the same art style they’ve been using since Frozen.

[@LegitMan335]

I saw Wish in theaters on my birthday last year, it was pretty good. *not a 100 years celebration Disney, but I would call it just fine*

[@GamingSaturnMoonManBoy]

My friend actually met Ariana DeBose once. She said she’s such a nice person

[@AllyStrikesBack]

Imagine if this movie was an animated musical based on Walt's life, that's what this movie should have been.

[@DodotheWishFanboy]

Man, I just love Wish! It’s now my favorite movie.

[@TheGenesisCrisis]

Luma? I was thinking Twink from paper mario 64, shows how old I am.

[@tfrowlett8752]

This is what happens when you underpay your writers

[@Random_Guy_20xx]

How is it that, SQUARE ENIX another studio made a better interconnected Disney story using iconic characters than F*CKIN DISNEY THEMSELVES. granted kingdom hearts kinda cheesy and confusing but its still an original story AND THEY EVEN USE THEIR OWN CHARACTERS AS WELL. modern disney can die in a pool of debt that they made. No one will care. Disneys magic drained out years ago.

[@charliecomer6001]

I will say this: if you take a shot everytime the reference another disney movie, itd be one hell of a drinking game

[@1805movie]

Funny enough, the original draft of this movie was actually a million times better.

[@justin-yx4jc]

100 YEARS LATER JUS TO HEAR LALA LA LA LA GOOD JOB IGRE

[@annika3265]

I think they could have fixed the problem of magnifico not being villainous enough and asha being too villainous for a protagonist by having magnifico use the wishes as the source of his power from the beggining, like that's why he collects the wishes in the first place, he lies to the people by saying that it's so difficult to grant wishes that he can only grant a few but the truth is that he destroy most of the wishes he gets to use as a magic source. And the people also need to feel the absence of their wish instead of carrying on like normal, they need to be yearning for something they don't know what it is, like they are aimless in life, you could have them all put up a facade of happiness for newcomers to the kingdom but in private the people are sad.

[@redvince5627]

I got a 2 year old at home who loves this movie so I watch it every damn day

[@danielsrandomchannel1472]

Please react to Robin Hood Nostalgia Critic

[@sierramccutchen3531]

The perfect reaction combo. 😂❤

[@EternalStorm796]

seriously, the ending just puts her into his place...

[@mejestin]

i wanna be serial killer when i grow up ~ said nobody ever... but dont worry child, you'll have your chances in the army

[@triggerfairy4070]

So she just took Magnifico's place but still didnt grant everyones wish.

[@sidneyrester6100]

IT TAKES ACTUAL EFFORT TO BE THIS BAD how/

[@CaptainCat101]

It is incredible how much the ending amounts to nothing, at least from what I can observe from the review, I don't actually want to watch the movie

[@MicaAnneArts]

9:20 -Now that that’s been said, you guys are obligated to watch The Guy Who Didn’t Like Musicals by Team Starkid. xD

[@PaulW_ftPAULK]

Sweet shirt Nate, got the same one!

[@ZoanBlade90]

26:50 Bippity Boppity Boo this movie!

[@MovieFan1912]

That joke was better than any of the ones in this movie.

[@ZoanBlade90]

@@MovieFan1912 Thank you. It's not that hard, Disney.

[@abelmantor7557]

Such a bland mess for Disney's 100th anniversary.

[@SJ_RANKS]

Alan tudnyk was funnier in transformers 3

[@MasterBuilderDragon]

When it comes to this movie, the only thing I was looking forward to was this review.

[@themessenger1871]

8:49

[@johanstenfelt1206]

Hm, it’s a shame the a Movie like this turned out the way it did. I wonder if there could be a Sequel that fixes everything?

[@gojulas2009]

0:18 i say answer i never cared to see this movie. i was more enaged with enjoying watching godzilla minus one when it was in theatres, they were both release around the same time back in december. Godzilla minus one was a far better movie to watch in theatres back in december. Minus one managaed to make it to the oscars for best visual effects. Takashi yamazaki, the director of godzilla minus one held it down when handling the production crew, very on point than how hollywood does it. Toho released a video of takashi yamazki breaking down his role as a director and also a VFX in handling his production team on youtube. Not to mention minus one was made to also celebrate godzilla’s 70th aniversary and they nailed it quite well. Did you get to see godzilla minus one when it came out in thatres in december?

[@goosehzomsog]

Yes

[@equusheart3344]

Also, the demo version of At All Costs is SOOOOO much better than the version in the film.

[@Ra1d3n-np9lr]

Wow you guys are fast at making videos

[@afanofstuff9123]

I love the idea this is the prequel to Zootopia instead of it being a reference make it real because she single handedly with the first wish she grants killed all of the humans. Animals are equals but human all of a sudden realise meat is off the table they Rebel against Asha because she in one wish has taken away half the humans food supply and taken away their choices and ya know humans we love our freedom to choose so some human probably try eating a now sentient cow causing the animals to rebel causing a war that causes humans to die out. Showing Magnifico right wishes in the hands of ideots ruined everything.

[@memeseller9444]

Hey Nate you look.. *incredibly* tired. You good?

[@LegitMan335]

*thinks about buying a random Wish toy* 🤔

[@mannyegarica12]

Yeah I wish this movie never existed but my wish never came true 😮‍💨

[@IkeMastree]

And it never will, because I can guarantee my mind is far stronger than yours.

[@HardcoreLADFan1836]

I haven't seen Wish nor do I plan to but I've heard that it's basically just not a good movie and the plot and characters are so uninspired and generic that you would swear that it's AI generated and it shows that Disney hasn't made a good movie since Zootopia or Moana and have basically forgotten how to make an actual good movie and something with substance and actual personality. Not to mention that this is the movie they choose to use to commemorate the 100-year anniversary when they could have made a movie that is 10 times better and easily more enjoyable than this pile of crap then I'm starting to be convinced it' is AI generated and just made because Disney doesn't feel like trying anymore and what's even more sad is that this is the movie that they use to celebrate the 100-year anniversary and honestly it's heartbreaking to know that they could have made it a much better movie and turn this concept that actually is interesting into something really worthwhile but chose they chose to make a uninspired and generic pile of horse manure and something Disney is going to regret having made when they think back on why the late 2010s and 2020s was not a good period for them at all both animated and live action