COMPREHENSIVE AGRARIAN REFORM PROGRAM (CARP): IS IT OVER?

Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Program; CARP; Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Law; RA 6657; RA 9700; Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Program Extension with Reforms; CARPER; LAD or Land Acquisition and Distribution; Notice of Coverage; Department of Agrarian Reform; Rights of Landowner; Land Tenancy; Agrarian Reform Beneficiary; Land Tenants; Agricultural Tenants; Retention Rights; Right of Retention; Compulsroy Acquisition; Agrarian Reform; Agrarian Reform Extension; LAD Free 2022; Reporma sa lupa; Agricultural land; Agricultural Land in Philippines; Agrarian Reform in Philippines
RA 9700
"SEC. 7. Priorities. - The DAR, in coordination with the Presidential Agrarian Reform Council (PARC) shall plan and program the final acquisition and distribution of all remaining unacquired and undistributed agricultural lands from the effectivity of this Act until June 30, 2014.”
“Section 21. Section 63 of Republic Act No. 6657, as amended, is hereby further amended to read as follows:
"SEC. 63. Funding Source. -
Provided, finally, That after the completion of the land acquisition and distribution component of the CARP, the yearly appropriation shall be allocated fully to support services, agrarian justice delivery and operational requirements of the DAR and the other CARP implementing agencies."
Section 30. Resolution of Case. - Any case and/or proceeding involving the implementation of the provisions of Republic Act No. 6657, as amended, which may remain pending on June 30, 2014 shall be allowed to proceed to its finality and be executed even beyond such date.
IRR
“The acquisition and distribution of agricultural lands under CARP shall be completed by June 30, 2014. However, the process of acquisition and distribution for landholdings which were issued with Notices of Coverage (NOCs) on or before June 30, 2014 shall continue even after June 30,2014 until the said lands have been awarded to qualified beneficiaries.”
IRR
1. Within thirty (30) calendar days from receipt of NOC or from its date of publication, the LO has:
1.1 The right to choose a retention area not exceeding five (5) hectares pursuant to Section 6 of R.A. No. 6657, as amended; and
1.2 The privilege to nominate child/ren who may qualify as preferred beneficiary/ies.
The landowner is likewise given the same thirty (30)-day prescribed period from receipt or date of publication of NOC, whichever is applicable, within which to protest coverage. Upon receipt of the protest of coverage by DAR, the LO is given another thirty (30) days to substantiate his/her protest and/or application for exemption or exclusion from CARP coverage. Failure to comply within the aforementioned 30-day reglementary periods shall be construed as a waiver or abandonment of the right to protest and/or to file for an application for exemption or exclusion from CARP coverage.
xxxxxx
6. For landholdings under compulsory acquisition (CA), the landowner shall choose his retained area within thirty (30) days from receipt of Notice of Coverage (NOC) or date of publication of NOC.
Failure to exercise the right to choose within the prescribed period shall constitute a waiver thereof. In which case the DAR, through the MARO, shall automatically choose for the landowner his/her retention area.
For landholdings under voluntary offer to sell (VOS), the landowner shall exercise his right of retention simultaneously at the time of the offer for sale of the subject landholding.
1987 Constitution
AGRARIAN AND NATURAL RESOURCES REFORM
Section 4. The State shall, by law, undertake an agrarian reform program founded on the right of farmers and regular farmworkers who are landless, to own directly or collectively the lands they till or, in the case of other farmworkers, to receive a just share of the fruits thereof. To this end, the State shall encourage and undertake the just distribution of all agricultural lands, subject to such priorities and reasonable retention limits as the Congress may prescribe, taking into account ecological, developmental, or equity considerations, and subject to the payment of just compensation. In determining retention limits, the State shall respect the right of small landowners. The State shall further provide incentives for voluntary land-sharing.“

[@emelitaampoloquio4208]

Maraming salamat po atty..napa ka informative po..salamat sa pagbahagi atty.GODBLESS AND MORE POWER

[@AandS1090]

Galing mo boss, ang linaw ng explenasyon

[@jajilavillano9339]

Thank you soooooo much atty

[@laagangkatabang]

Goodmorning atty. watching from Hongkong

[@samsontorres2125]

Maraming salamat po may na totonan ako

[@archingcolocz]

thanks po atty sa naturunan ko

[@filomenaalviar9311]

Thanks

[@reginadorado542]

Thank u,Atty..for sharing the knowledge,i' m learning a lot.❤️❤️❤️

[@jhanelrapada2782]

thanks sir

[@jonathanmacaraig651]

Very informative Atty.Salute!

[@ednaayao9613]

Nice video

[@astorytotell7041]

Pwedeng malaman attorney kung saan ba galing ang 6 percent na yan na annual interest? Saan sya kukunin po? Sa kita ba per year? E paano pag wala pong kita at nakantiwangwang lang ang lupa ?

[@matusalemromero9868]

Gd pm po Sir,dito din po sa amin camarines sur,libmanan myron po napakalawak pang sakahan na hinde pa po na impliment iyang programang iyan paabot po sa main office sabi po nila my problema daw po pagkatagaltagal na po problemang iyang bakit hinde maaksiyonan ng office tnx po

[@beinspiredmixedmedia4569]

Atty. Gud eve po. Ask kulang po bakit may mga lupa na lagpas 5 hectares dito sa amin sa Negros. Mga hacienda peru hindi na cover ng CARP peru yung sa amin is na 12 hectares lng ay na e cover nang DAR. Ang sabi nila atty. Is exempted raw yung mga hacienda and lands belonging to corporations. Tama po ba ito atty.

[@felylife]

atty kmi po since 1960's p kmi dito sa lupang tinitirhan nmin at ang may ari po nito hindi ngpapakita sa amin hanggang ngayon . maka avail b kmi sa CARP?

[@rolandocardeno513]

Sir yung area may collective title na noong 2004 pa. Kaso untill now ay wala pa pong approved survey para ma subdived na. Pede paba ito?

[@ratzelenglaterra7878]

Atty, Please paki sagot po Paano po pag ang regional directors ay my approval na na ang aking ina ay qualified maging benificiary , ano po next ano po kailangan for Finality. Tnx

[@fernandoalbiso2285]

Gud pm, atty. Paano kong nag protest sila o nagpetition sila tapos ma deny sa kc huli na sila ung protest na isyo na ung titulo benificiary

[@JellenAutriz-sn7or]

Good day po. Ask ko lang po kung may kara patan pa rin ang may ari ng lupa na bawiin sa tenant ang lupang naiaward na ng DAR sa tenant?

[@felylife]

sana po makatanngap ako ng sagot mula sa iyo atty. thanks

[@abdulsalsalani257]

sir alm kopo hindi related sa topic ang tanung ko..mabebenta poba ng nanay ang land title,kung my tututol o hindi pipirma na anak

[@erniejacinto7803]

Yun bang homestead patent title covered by comprehensive agrarian reform program?

[@senarine3415]

Ano po ang connection or effects ng mga land reform laws sa land economics?

[@cesarjrdizon3628]

Pano po Kung may nabili portion na lupa,subalit ito ay tax declaration. Maari po ba ito ipa tittle ng nakabili?

[@JanneMalunhao]

Thank you po attry pano po kng bininta ng May ari ung lupa tpos May notice of coverrage n po ung tatay ko po cya po namamahala ng hda 17hctars for 45yrs pina alis po kmi ng bagong bumili kinaso kmi tpos Natalo po kmi kc nbinta n po pero ung lupa my NOC po n enject p rin kmi attry.

[@grasyagrasya2706]

Hi sir ask ko lang po kung paanu po kung naisangla ang lupa na naka CLOA ng 14 yrs... makukuha pa po ba ng heirs .patay n po kc ang naka name sa CLOA

[@Ruth-ct5sr]

Magandang araw po sa inyo attorney! Hihingi po ako ng kalinawagan po sa CLT ng ama ko na mula sa DAR kung saan ay finallow up namin ngunit sabi ay invalid na raw. Ito ay sa panahon pa ni Ferdinand E. Marcos,totoo bang invalid na ito?

[@albertoabesilla4165]

Two hectar po ang over tenyrs na kaya approve ang clearance sa dar at land bank at nalipat na tct ang problema naghahabol sa korte nakabili raw siya 150 sqm ang alam ko bawal yon may laban kaya sya pakisagot naman atty ty

[@user-hl2dq8xk8n]

Pwd pa po ba kaming mag habol,nabigyan po ng lupa ung mga taong walanh hirap sa lupa,kami pong mga anak na mtgal ng nkatira sa lupa ay walang nkuha..wala rin po g bhay ung bnigyan nila,

[@joshuap.baldevieso2686]

Hello, Atty. Yuung lupa po ng lolo and lola ko is naka VOS. After ning mamatay, yung Certificate of Land Owership Award is nasa tito ko po (anak ni lolo at lola). Pero nung namatay na yung tito ko, kinuha ng kanyang asawa yung CLOA. Ngayon po ay pinapaalis nila kami sa lupa at may ibedensya din ako na benenta nya ung CLOA. Ano po pwedi kong gawin? Salamat

[@mariviccasilis2305]

Atty good day po hindi pa po na award sa Amin ang cloa dahil wala daw budget ang land bank para sa comprehensive owner para mabayaran ang may ari.

[@annamoralesharina7831]

Atty panu ho walang noc 41 has na carp no just compensation din nabigay mana ko n po problema sa dar urdaneta

[@nenelozano3488]

tanong ko po attorney ang aming lupa ay nasakop ng CARP GAYONG more than 4 htrs lang sya pina cancel po namin ang OCT Dahil hindi naman sila ang Beneficiary

[@kylejanssinnierra8219]

Attorney good ev po bakit my mga my ari ng farm dto samin na nag mamay ari ng 20 hectare above title at isalang my ari pwede poba un sir.

[@nellygarcia2017]

sir pwde mag apply ng CARP kung walang one hectare ang iyong sinasaka

[@SaylaAriate]

Sir wha if the land area is only 7,309 hctr if is it cover by the low?.

[@RolitoLacaran]

Atty.tanong ko lang po.na cancel po ba Ang carp awarded

[@user-yg1vo7ic8x]

Atty. Good day po ang nanay namin po ay tenant yong kanyang lupa VOS po ini award po sa kanya 3hecs. 2002 pa po ngayon nagbabayad po kmi sa land bank ang kaso ang 1hec. lng po ang my record doon nagtaka po kmi ksi ang 2 hecs.wla pong record sa land bnk may ibinigay sa nanay ko na title 2hec pero sa anak ng may ari hindi namin alam na hindi pala senurender sa DAR ng may ari ang titulo original ngayon ang sabi sa amin ng DAR hindi na daw napasok sa data base ksi tapos n po ang program ng CARP. Hingi po kmi ng advice salamat po vicky gensan.

[@truthoflife1693]

Atty pwede po bilhin ang collective cloa?

[@joeydangcalan1190]

Sir tanong lng Po pwede bang ibinta ang Carp,??

[@raysfildsoyland682]

Sir paano po ba ang proseso ng LADIS at CAF? ung full detail po nia

[@lesmejr1221]

Sir Kung walang natanggap? Poydi pa mag apply,

[@laniepagliawan6063]

How about po yung housing law in the philippines atty? 😊

[@gilianverano7652]

Yong lupa namin po sa iloilo brgay san dres sitio apo kinukuha baka po matulugan u po kami

[@quezonjadulco6419]

How kung may title before the carp program then sinakop ng carp how is that

[@dennisjulia3621]

Good day po attorney tanung ko lng po meron akong pinsan na may ari ng lupa na Ang title ay CARP. Mag magmatured po sya this year August 2023 gusto nya pong ibenta at tanung po ng buyer Niya pwd bang I pa transfer comprehensive agrarian reform program to TCT title pag na bili daw po niya salamat po sa pag sagot God bless po❤

[@abegaeldilaoo7948]

Pwd po ba mag ahente ang staf ng dar at rd bawal po ba un

[@bernabethYonting]

Hi po

[@user-qy2eh5tp3l]

Gandang umaga po mag sasaka po ako sa isang sasakahan sence 1972.ibenenta na 2006. Ang ng benta po ay kapatid ng tunay na may ari.na may power of atty. Po mula sa may ari.binigyan po alo ng kapirason lupa bilang kapaalit ng pag voluntary surrender. Kaoatid ko. Ang nakabili.gusto bawiin ang bigay sa akin may kasunduan kmi galin sa agrarian.puede po ba yon. Salamat po.

[@joselitogarduce840]

Effective ba o Hindi?kaya ito inilagay Ng goverment ..Hanggang Ngayon Wala man succesfull na mahihintulad Ng Taiwan .

[@cocomartin238]

Hello po atty. Bakit po need pa expiration ng 10 years para sa land acquisition and distribution? Ano po dahilan? Hindi po b pwedeng wala nalang expiration?

[@hijarahpolangi6407]

programs or projects shall have timeline

[@nicocanlas4691]

Good day! Sana po ay mapansin. My father and I are farming in a land for more than decades as tenant till he died just this year 2022. Until today, hindi pa din pa naaward ang lupa sa amin. And currently d na po namin alam kung sino ang registered land owner. And with some rumors naibenta na daw po to other person. Question ko po is possible po kaya na ito ay under na ng carp at hindi lang naaasikaso ng DAR? How could we know kung under na sya ng CARP since it seems some of the authorities are in silence? And, saan po namin pwedeng makita mga list ng mga land owners na nabigyan na ng Notice of acquisition thru CARP?

[@YourLawyer]

Puntahan nyo po ang opisina ng DAR sa inyong lugar.

[@manifesting5241]

Hello po attorney.magtanong ako tungkol sa new agrarian emancipation act.ano po ito?kasali po ba wala ng bayaran na amortization ang bagong o member pa lang ng agrarian reform beneficiary na nakalist ang pangalan kahit dindi pa nakatanggap ng CLOA kasi for validation pa nitong April 27 2023.

[@MaritesBanuelos]

Hi po atty.noog buhay pa ang aking ama cxa ay isang tenant ng lupa 13hec.more or less din hinate sa dalawang kapatid hindi nla nabigyan ang ama ko.din nagfile ang ama ko ng case.ngayon ngrequest ko ng certfied true copy sa r.o.d doon nalaman nmi nacover na sa carp noog july 4,2o14 paano nmin malaman how many sqr mter makuha nmin 6.6hectar ang nkalagay sa title sa my ari ng lupa

[@genalnieva]

when the earth is gone u cannot bring it back this creation of the ALMIGHTY rev. 20;11

[@rexkie694]

May Tanong lang ako Atty Yong lolo at Lola ko 1949 pa Sila Dito sa lupang sinasaka nila Sila Na Ang namutol sa mga punong kahoy at tinaniman nila nang mga niyog at namatay Na silang dalawa si mama ang pumalit sa kanila kasi dalawa lang Sila mama magkapatid at si mama ang matanda sa kanilang dalawa Tanong ko Atty kung Ito bay ebenta meron ba kaming makukuhang pera sa may ari pag ebenta nila ang lupa mga 6 hectar ang sinasaka namin dito sa bunawan davao city ang tagal Na Namin Dito Atty mahigit 73 years Na panahon pa sa mga lolo at Lola ko hanggang si mama Na Ang pumalit sa kanila sana masagot mo Ito Atty kung miron ba kaming makukuhang bayad pag ebenta Ito nang may ari mag hintay ako sa sagot mo Atty salamat

[@jhaybabe3439]

Tama Po ba Yung naka titulo na da name Ng tatay ko Nung pnahon pa ni Corazon Aquino,ay hinahabol pa,na pag binenta daw Namin e hati daw kami sa benta kahit na nakatitulo na sa pngalan Ng tatay ko?sna matulungan nyo Po kmi

[@reytosino6722]

Atty. Good day! Is RA 6657 applicable to privately owned agricultural land less than 1 hectare? After more than 10 years of failing to give the 'saka' and allowing illegal settlers in my agricultural lot, is the tenant eligible for any compensation once I sold my land?

[@aKenheart]

Land in excess of 5 hectars ang cover, kung less, hindi na.

[@shemdee]

So how do some businessmen have 100 hectares without being subject to carp?

[@N0noy1989]

Many ways. The usual is leasing. They just lease from many owners. Another is having dummy corporations to have 5 has each. And another is land conversion to something that's not agricultural, which is the usual for subdivisions. More often than not, like in some haciendas, DAR is just not doing their job.

[@gm2655]

Pag nakuha farmers lupa..ibenta nila agad para gawin mall

[@vstations]

Hello po Atty., tanong lang po. Kung lumampas ng 5 hectares ang agri land mo at hindi ka pa nabigyan ng NOC up to present, may chance pa bang ma-cover yan ng CARP in the future and pwede ko bang mabenta ang excess sa 5 hectares? Thanks po

[@aKenheart]

Yung bibili ang mamomroblema jan pag itratransfer na sa kanya yung lupa kasi need ng DAR clearance.

[@vstations]

@@aKenheartPero di ba po DAR clearance is needed sa Registry of Deeds sa pag process ng sale ng agricultural property? Hindi lang yan problema ng buyer kundi ng seller kasi hihingi ng aggregate lang holdings ng seller at makikitang sobra sa 5 hectares at sasabihin na hindi ka pwede magbenta ng excess kasi dapat ipasok yan sa CARP?

[@aKenheart]

@@vstations Yup problema nga ng seller at buyer yan pag excess 5 hectars . kaya ang ginagawa ng iba ay idinodonate sa mismo nilang kamaganak and the rest 5 hectars and below will be sold to other na hindi pa naawardan ng lupa under carp or wala pa talagang agri land. Or kung di naman apurahan yang pagbenta di hintayin nalang natin na maisabatas yung house bill 9955 ni Cong Salceda na nagtataas ng retention limit to 24 hectars.

[@vstations]

@@aKenheart Wow, hindi po ako aware na meron pala ng House Bill 9955... Pero di ba po meron pa nung House Bill 5507 na para atang phase 2 ng CARP and keeping that 5 hectare limit? So parang labanan na yan ng opposing house bills na ito kung alin ang magiging batas?

[@aKenheart]

@@vstations Yup ganyan nga po ang mangyayari kung maisabatas yang HB9955. Base kase sa isang pagaaral, although natutugunan ng CARP ang pagnanais ng gobyerno na mapagkalooban ng lupang sakahan ang mg Pilipinong walang sariling lupa, nagsasanhi naman ito ng pagbaba ng produksiyon sa ating agrikultura.

[@meloithefarmer2319]

Atty, good evening. Our problem po ay sinapawan ng CADT from NCIP ang lupang pinamamahagi ng DAR sa amin. Na award po sa Agrarian Reform Beneficiaries noon pang 1989.

[@victorivancastro4940]

Kawawang mga pilipino sobrang tagal kumilos ng gobyerno

[@sweetlife2823]

Thanks for very informative videos Matt anong Lang po ako about sa land transfer na matagal ng na award sa tatay ko since 1980 pa pero di nila na tapos I process Until now nasa min pa ang land transfer and until kami parin ang tenant, may point is under land transfer my parent shall pay 30 % of the produce for 15 years now is over 40 years na po may maadvise ba kayo what todo to legalised the land transfer !?

[@user-jd3ny5pt8p]

Hello Attorney, halimbawa po sa mother title dalawa ang beneficiaries pero kinalaunan sinubdivide ang title. Ang bilang po ba ng 10 years sa CLOA ay magsisimula kung kelan naaward ang mother title?