Interesting perspective

It’s clear Mr Herzog’s refused in his own analysis to work through and engage with the negative transference and his repressed rage against his own father. The Oedipal drama is so utterly unresolved!

Herzog talks about bad professionals. A good psychologist or psychoanalyst only helps you become aware of things, interpretation and explaining stuff does not help, but you have to know what is in front of you to make better decisions and judgements. Herzog has an ignorant view on the topic.

This is amazing

The assertion, that "Psychonanalysis tries to illuminate every corner of the house" is very misleading, and in fact omitting one of the greatest insights of psychonanalysis: That the house has corners, that can never be illuminated and these corners will affect you, even if you are not aware of it. To be more concrete: The unconscious will be there, whether you try to illuminate it or not. Or as Freud put it: "The ego is not master in its own house." And I for one think, it's far more helpful to at least try to figure out what has an effect on my behavior, than ignoring these forces.

Somethings are meantbto stay in the dark.stop anylazing and wanting reasons for everything .its unhealthy and vain

Hes right

wtf haha

I prefer the meds , instead of listening a lot of bs from an ordinary pathetic being

It's a instigate proposition. I will even refrain me of psychoanalyse from where his believe come from lol. I only will say that each of us are like directors of (the movie of) our life. Then I will ask: A good director don't know his crew n every component of his movie? 🎥 I doubt Werner like to do movies without knowing a lot of what's happening. But I like the discussion opened by his thoughts

I am sure they have not seriously read classic psychoanalytic bibliography. Also, there are a lot of anti heroes that have no counter proposals. The typical person resists to the teeth at a certain point in the psychoanalytic cure, and this is where people stop sometimes their analysis. You have to live the experience to believe it, empirically see the results on your way of being and the come the behaviours that were before impasses and full of anxiety. I salute you from México.

I didn't immediately like this but i grew on me really fast. The tuning sounds great and how she plays is great too, I really like how she ends the peice Its kinda bitter sweet.

Paul Rudd?

Happy 4th! 🫡🇺🇸

I think Herzog is responding in a highly provocative way to certain perceived abuses carried out by psychologists, but his statements are wildly hyperbolic and absurd. Are psychologists given too much power? In many cases yes, but there are many competing schools of psychological thought, some of them in direct contradiction with each other, so you can’t generalize. Herzog seems to be denying that mental illness exists or that, if it does, we can cure it by simply “treating each other with great care.” If you hate psychology, then that means you hate the study of the human mind. The goal should not be to abolish psychology/psychotherapy but to improve it and to use it in a way that impinges on human freedom and dignity as little as possible.

Born On The Fourth Of Jubayou

Food sex and money is all we crave.

'It's just a racket. For the jews!' (Livia Soprano)

nice to hear annies posh voice

Have you been to Louisiana Vingul?

Elon Musk has a smelly ass.

Paul Rudd method acting

Circumstantial like almost everything How can you say everyone enjoys their house, no one needs help, and the practise is irrelevant and terrible because of it. Pretty one sided statement if you ask me

Me after my therapist diagnosed me with 10 disorders :

they need to focus on the people not the numbers

the difference is most psychological people are not actually pychologists

We are born into a psyche. The infinite consciousness we are becomes contained by this virtual computer called mind, and organic computer called body. Psychoanalysis helps us decide from the inside out and vice versa, to unravel the layered processes contributing to our perceived pains that lead to maladaptive behavior.

Psychoanalysis is useful. I tend to think people are well off reading some psychoanalytic material and using it as a means of reflection. Beyond traditional psychoanalysis and its tendency to seek illumination and discovery, and beyond the identification and assimilation of the "shadow", one may discover a respect for and recognition of as yet unseen shadows, and the shadows of shadows, and the unknowable, unseeable, undetectable aspects of psyche. Also useful is the recognition that psychoanalysis is never "done". One is never fully or completely analyzed. We should dispense with notions that humans are perfectable and that a reasonable aim of psychoanalysis should consist of a linear progression with a definite end point in which someone is fixed or whole or in some way perfect.

The good thing about psychoanalysis is that it's for the people that find ir interesting. If you don't you can just ignore it. I find it fascinating and it helps me think about things in a much more interesting way than the other schools of thought today that wish to just reduce human beings to dopamine or animal behaviouralism.

Hes talking abt from a very narrow artistic conceptual perspective, without real empathy or understanding about when/how to employ it

I studied psychology and I can confirm that this is pseudo-science. Most of the psychology students I met had a lot of psychological issues themselves, especially the female ones. My advice: if you want to do something with your life, train in something like engineering and avoid anything 'social.'

"I swear, gentlemen, that to be too conscious is an illness" The Underground man, Notes from the Underground by Fyodor Dostoevsky

I sincerely don't understand why this movie isn't included among the best films by Kubrick as well as best movies ever made. It might never be as loved as A Clockwork Orange or The Shining since it's longer and brings forth less emotion, which would bore the average audience member. But film enthusiasts and critics at least have to give it the attention it deserves by acknowledging it as the undisputed masterpiece to which it should be referred if there's any justice in this world at all.

The bombings were horrendous, but i keep seeing death figures now of only 25,000-30,000. Are these accurate?

This is a really dumb or rather ignorant and arrogant opinion. In excess, without moderation and with some people looking to find excuses for their life...psychoanalysis and psychology can do harm. But it is also a science that has gone through many years of evolution and it absolutely helps find common denominators for human behavior and reasons for such behavior.

Wait so psychoanalytics is just uncovering child hood stuff? Does thst mean that CPTSD is based on psychoanalysis

Vakkert

Some of them are like this. Others not. There is no scientific evidence that some method is better than the other. Which means this is not about the method but healthy relationship that heals.

Herzog appears to love the darkness a bit too much.

Of course you don't point working lights to walls and corners at all times, you use them only until the problem is found and fixed, and then you decorate the room back to a habitable state.

This is coming from a guy who could clearly benefit from some therapy….

What did Kinski think about Psychoanalysts?

4yrs of psychoanalysis has shed light on many dark areas, other areas were lightened later for me. However it has also shown that my family and many friends were somewhat toxic. I’ve even become more solitary and detached as relationships don’t feed or support an unfortunate need for companionship.😢

Psychoanalysis is more a literary form than anything else.

I love his poetics about the illuminated house but honestly it just seems like a hill he wants to die on

I like his work, but this is just dumb. Guess he felt triggered by Jung.

One of the most powerful indicators of mental insanity is to deny the need for psychological mantainance. He urgently needs a psycho-therapy.

My husband's therapist recommended him a book that opened with an interesting statistic: "95% of therapy doesn't work." Looking at all my friends in therapy, all of whom are getting fatter and more addicted to pornography and video games (neither of which are inherently bad things, my brother and I have made both professionally), I can't reasonably argue against the statistic. From what I can tell, most people simply use therapists as a subscription-service-vent-friend, and then proceed to be more and more impulsive. It really sucks.

He has no ideia whatsoever of what he is talking about

I tell you what is wrong with psychoanalisis. greek 'psyche' is latin 'anima', english 'soul' The soul is like a robot, like a programable computer. it is like an animal that you can train. They tell us that we are the soul. But we are the spirit. They replace the recognition of the imperishable spirit with the image of the perishable soul.