10 Darkest Moments REMOVED from the Films (Part 3) - Harry Potter Explained

[@HarryPotterTheory]

MORE LONG VIDEOS: kzbin.info/aero/PLB5djWCQq2_e0UCOmVbhRP8HkxetpzXUV Part 1: kzbin.info/www/bejne/f3LCiGWha7OIfJIsi=y7QzGMzymH6oHNDI Part 2: kzbin.info/www/bejne/aJ2yqn1prqyhqdUsi=1rpk4LAwQRrdm04Z

[@stevefontaine1335]

@HarryPotterTheory Lord Of The Rings Theory Channel.🙏🙏🙏

[@stevefontaine1335]

@HarryPotterTheory Lord Of The Rings Theory Channel.?🙏🙏🙏

[@cerboris521]

The whole battle in the Dept of Mysteries was much darker in the books. Most of the friends almost died and suffered horrible injuries.

[@katiemateyy]

Recently read it and totally agree. Ron with the brain tentacle scars, Ginnys ankle, Neville’s face, hermione hit with the curse. I think Luna was the only one actually okay?

[@TC-tl8ie]

Agreed. In the movies I knew they weren't going to kill off any kids. In the book I'm terrified for them, especially with the creepy setting of the Department of Mysteries.

[@earthstar7534]

​i just read the books. I really thoughtsome were going to be picked off. I stopped reading, read ahead, and then kept reading it to my daughter. Shes only 9. I was unpreparedfor the stakes to be so high.@@TC-tl8ie

[@imperialinquisition6006]

@@katiemateyyLuna got knocked across a room and was knocked out.

[@countluke2334]

I always read the book with my kids before we watch the movie, because even the better movies simply leave such a lot out. They are fun to watch, but more shallow. I finished reading OotP with my son today and we watched the movie later and we both agreed that the whole scene in the department of mysteries is longer, darker, more thrilling and, consequently, better in the book. Which is a pity.

[@tcrobot]

My hate for Umbridge is only matched by my respect for Imelda Staunton. She's an amazing actress.

[@craigwapples4200]

Right a great actor is one who makes you hate the character so much you can’t unsee the character

[@HeraldOfChaos76]

I swear Imelda Staunton is the bravest actress that ever lived from what I heard there wasn't a single person who applied for umbridge and she only got the role because she was the only one but how she played it was phenomenal but that's why I would have been like I'm going to need hazard pay and a good health insurance because I'm going to need so much therapy with all the hate mail lol but it turns out people really did love her and honestly I'm so glad because I can see why people did not want the role LOL

[@paden1865able]

It takes a massively talented performer to embody such a horrid person and make that character so very easy to hate.

[@HeraldOfChaos76]

@@paden1865able believe me when I say that is so true 😂 like I'm serious when I say that she's up there with Heath ledger on the acting scale like seeing her like that I would have never guessed 😂

[@88COR88]

The torture of Harry was the event that caused me to look more broadly at how adults were portrayed the in the books. Adults are oblivious and incompetent so it's no surprise the young people don't trust them enough to notify them of the abuse. Dumbledore uses people as pawns, Snape's abuses are brushed aside or ignored by the other teachers, and the Slytherins are consistently awful yet always seems to be in the lead for the house cup. Is that how young people really view adults? When my daughter read the books as a teenager I sat her down during book 4 and asked her how she felt the adults in the books matched the adults in real life. She felt the teachers behavior matched her teachers IRL (she was in public school and most, not all, of her teachers were burnt out), but she didn't understand how the parents could be so stupid. So we discussed how she thought her Mother and I would have responded if she was put in some of the scenarios described in the book. Unfortunately she has had some bad encounters, like most of us did, so she had real examples to draw from and I was very glad to hear she felt she would come to us for support. I know all kids are not raised in the same environment but I definitely recommend reading the same books your kids do so you can use the stories as jumping off points for important discussions.

[@Dionysus999]

It's great that you can connect with your child and have deep conversations about the concepts, she'll be a very smart woman one day able to use critical thinking skills with what you've taught her.

[@DELL.ACNT.]

You sound like a very interested, hands on parent. Wondering how your child is perceiving the world, and figuring out how to ask her these things through something she’s interested in, like Harry Potter, is very deep in itself. I’m sure your kid will fare just fine in this world. She’s got you, not everybody can count on their parents for their intimate thoughts, you have to build that bridge of trust with them. That’s a very powerful tool in life. The genuine love and concern of a parent makes all the difference in who they become as adults. She’s blessed to have you.

[@kevinness9341]

Harry standing over his parents grave hit me pretty hard after I became a parent myself; the thought of my own child standing over my grave and thinking what Harry thought at that time 😢

[@hotcomodity21]

My mother died when I was 16. And although every single aspect of harry potter has always resonated with me, this part in particular really hit me in the chest. 😢

[@kevinness9341]

@@hotcomodity21 I'm so sorry, I can't imagine losing one of my parents at that young an age.

[@simsgirlgem]

@@hotcomodity21I lost my mother at 27 and I still wasn’t ready I can’t imagine having to do it as a child

[@cherryb893]

With everything Harry went through - or should I say had to put up with - it's a miracle he turned out decent.

[@rumanatarafder616]

Because he always had a good heart and he didn't let vengeance or bitterness consume him in the end. He cared about doing the right thing more.

[@magdalenaklapper5926]

Idea: HP books have a strictly defined time frame, we even know the daily dates of some events. What was happening in Muggle Britain at the same time? Eg: Voldemort's attac on baby Harry, Quidditch World Cup, Battle of Hogwarts ect.

[@imperialinquisition6006]

I mean, just what happened in real life? The Gulf war in 1991, along with the following no fly zone and air strikes that the Uk took part in. The election of Tony Blair as PM in the mid 90s. The end of the Cold War and the societal changes that took place in the 90s etc… What exactly did you expect to be going on? The characters in the series probably heard about all this but of course had more important things to be dealing with.

[@horseradishpower9947]

​@@imperialinquisition6006Labour - thus Blair - in May 1997. So the Prime Minister would have been John Major. If this helps.

[@ottocarius7814]

It’s not UK related but a big deal is the German reunification and the collapse of the Soviet Union in 91

[@King_of_Blue-Eyes]

The books are way darker then the movies. I agree.

[@blazechaos9802]

This series is so good please continue

[@andeeharry]

I always wondered what happened with Umbridge when she was dragged away and after reading the comment section and the mythology section, I am safely say that no wonder she would always panic at the sound of hooves.

[@JamesDavy2009]

To say the least she became a hippophobe.

[@thomasa8814]

I hope they bought her dinner first at least

[@Erica_Brenda]

I think the ending when Voldemort is killed for the final time, in the books is so much better than the movies. In the movies no one would even know he was killed or who killed him.

[@kenhollis6197]

Indeed. The movies would have us believe that Voldemort was a subhuman monster, when the fact was, he was just a man. A maniacal, tainted, inbred shell of a man, but still just a man, and he died like one.

[@Erica_Brenda]

@@kenhollis6197 I agree, Ken

[@aishakhan1609]

@@kenhollis6197 Exactly 👍🏼

[@vinitvsankhe]

Umbridge probably suffered the same fate that sadly women suffer among a gang of rowdy men.

[@Dadofer1970]

The 30 dark aspects covered over 3 videos have been great. I would like to see some of the more triumphant aspects that the movies didn't quite capture. Harry bonding with Kreacher over the death of Regulus. Kreacher leading the house elves out of the kitchens to fight. Wizard families from all over, not just Order of the Phoenix, arriving at Hogwarts to fight in overwhelming numbers. And, most of all, Neville's full story. edit: one particular satisfying part of the books was Harry repairing his own broken wand that he loved so much by using the Elder Wand (the only wand powerful enough to fix a broken wand).

[@MsRadred6116]

Yes! Thank you! I was so very disappointed with this being left out of the movie, as well as the difference of Harry breaking the Elder wand in the movie. Of course in the book, he replaced it in Dumbledore’s tomb for safe keeping, knowing that the power of the wand would be broken when Harry died a natural death.

[@nathanbutler78]

I always thought the Ron in the brain room scene was one of the most ridiculous scenes in the book. I'm glad it didn't make into the movies. It was almost as ridiculous as spew.

[@hotcomodity21]

I agree, except SPEW wasn’t ridiculous 🤔

[@deserabailey8500]

I just thought of this! Did dumbledore KNOW that Voldemort would try to kill snape?? He knew Voldemort wanted the wand, And would find it, and he prob guessed that voldy would try to kill the previous owner for it, and maybe thats another reason he made sure Draco wasnt the one to kill him.....?!?!?! Oh my....

[@Ola-jz7oj]

Of course, Snape is just an another man whose death was planned by Dumbledore. In his plan to defeat Voldi, he planned to sacrifice many but not himself, until the curse on the ring forced him change this plan. Somehow, Voldemort made him become a little better man 😂

[@JustSaiyan317]

Long story long Dumbledoors plan was to have Snape kill him as a “mercy” as he was marked for death anyway from the ring, and because it was an established agreement between the two, the plan/theory was that because it was an agreement and not a “dual”, the elder wand wouldn’t succeed to anyone and it would “die” with Dumbledoor by technicality. Draco doing what he did was never part of his plan, everyone had the belief (wrongly I might add) that the only way to take ownership of the Elder wand was to kill the previous owner… which also makes no sense when you consider Grindlewald wasn’t killed, so it’s hard to really understand what their theories were based off of, let alone what Dumbledoor was thinking about in those last moments. TLDR: Dumbledoors plan was for himself to be the last “rightful owner” of the Elder wand as technically Snape didn’t beat him in a fight/dual. It’s all rather confusing as his plan revolved entirely around a theory.

[@mikedirado4270]

Do you think Harry not raging on Dumbledore at the end of the order of the Phoenix was dark? Its my favorite HP chapter ever

[@brianbrady3086]

I don't know if they were dark per se... But in order of the phoenix the scene with mcgonnagol and unbridge when discussing harry's potential future after hogwarts and him wanting to be an auror. Also when Mcgonn agol was getting observed by umbridge.. Finally all the OWL exams where it included in the end we see hagrid get attacked at night.

[@GeneralKenoobi]

I would like to give thanks for being alive in this time, where we have the best Harry Potter channel ever created uploading on a regular basis for all of our Muggle brains to truly enjoy the Wonderful Wizarding world of Harry Potter ❤

[@HarryPotterTheory]

Thank-you for watching!!!

[@GeneralKenoobi]

@@HarryPotterTheory No, thank you for posting!! I've been a Harry Potter über-nerd since I was 7. I'm 21 now, and my love has only grown, in large part due to Pottermore and lore channels like this. You are by far the most concise, least biased, and overall best produced lore channel I have ever watched in any overall fantasy topic. Keep doing what you're doing please!! And just know that you have so many loyal fans until the day you stop posting

[@thatvaultgirl1018]

Harrys breakdown in Dumbledores office always makes me tear up. I obviously have not gone through the same situations as Harry but i can relate to feeling so angry and done with a situation you cannot escape that you go into a rage. Am i proud of it? No. Do inrealize im a human being with unresolved issues that had no clue how to properly channel and express what i was feeling? Yes. There are a few situations from other shows/books that make me upset like that, such as Shawns breakdown in the Good Doctor and Sams panic attacks in Atypical.

[@kyleeames8229]

1:36 I’m actually glad that was omitted from the films. It’s unrealistic because of a phenomenon known as infantile amnesia. Basically while its inclusion in the story may have added a touch of drama, a baby physically cannot form long term memories. The challenge of a fantasy author maintaining the readers suspension of disbelief is hard enough without the inclusion of scientific inaccuracies.

[@jenlfpotter3870]

That isn't strictly true about babies not being able to form long term memories. A groundbraking BBC Child Of Our Time episode about exactly this, proves that. I myself, have memories of wearing these fleecy sleep suits. I asked my mum what age group one of them was and she told me, 0-6 months. Wow! It was big for me when I was wearing it. I can remember sitting up and playing with the soft plastic feet on the bottoms of the legs because I liked the feel of it. I also remember sitting in washing up bowl playing with water or in a plastic baby bath, I had a swing in the back garden or yard, but mum says I was just a toddler when I was swinging in it. I remember sitting in a highchair at one of mum's friend's houses, I remember staying overnight at my Grandparents and sleeping in a cot they had there for me. Mind you, we used my old baby equipment for my cousins when they were born nearly 9 years after me. I remember opening presents on my second Birthday and a few other baby related things like that.

[@thylightjess9168]

Love this to start my morning!

[@darrelljohnston8676]

I was kind of hoping Umbridge would be found dead with dozens of crossbow bolts stuck in her.

[@Kakarot64.]

Umbridge doesn't need a Horecrux to escape Death.... Death doesn't want to be contaminated by her presence so it rejects her.

[@SnowtimeRL]

I can’t believe Harry didn’t use killing or torture curse on umbridge

[@danielgartin-oh9ik]

Great video dude

[@mark_chrishane07playz51]

Love your videos

[@pavise6333]

It's understandable why some of the parts were cut or toned down to avoid the R rating

[@andeeharry]

The films cut out a lot of stuff and toned down a lot of things because of the ages and PC rating, but now with the new reboot coming, nothing is going to stand in the way. THEY WILLL show everything and explore the books at the deeper level. I know Rowling is going through third round of negotiations with NBC universal and warner brothers to get the new dealing going, since HBO max dropped out due to licencing issues. I for one can't wait to see Peeves. He was my favourite.

[@MauseDays]

wait reboot!!!!!! i had no idea yoooo

[@andeeharry]

@@MauseDays really? it's been everywhere for three months now, but that's fine. They expecting a heavy detailed version to spawn in 2025-2026 mark that will last 10 years. It is being done by the same people who done, Killing Eve, Conscious, Man in the High Castle, Succession

[@Titan1440p]

Thanks for the video❤

[@ninjogo5338]

I absolutely DESPISE IT When they keep cutting . These parts out. Just leave them alone!

[@mecahhannah]

Awesome as always thanks

[@laurendobinson5930]

Brilliant video xx

[@HarryPotterTheory]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@albertlamar5938]

I have read so much fan fiction over the years that it blurs with the books and movies, but somewhere in my brain is a fragment of a memory that a wizard must make preparations while alive in order to come back as a ghost, and that neither the Potter parents nor Sirius had done so. Don't recall why, apart from them being young and powerful and thinking they were indestructible.

[@korstiaanakse1]

Who else wanted to use the crucio spell on Umbridge

[@ninjogo5338]

Maybe the Max tv series’s can cover these better.

[@JackTavern629]

Oh lord I'm so out of the loop. I thought it was HBO max.... wait. Did max and HBO combine ? Yeah if so, I'm very much out of the loop

[@greensanta0666]

3:01 stared at the shining what?

[@RachelG1979]

Eveytine i see 'Dumbledore said calmly" I laugh lol. Its all over the books how calm he is.

[@Juwan1583]

It’s not misrepresentation, it’s an adaptation. Word for word line by line will never happen. Books ofc are more detailed bc it’s a book, it has to explain and express for imaginary and narration

[@katiebugg7018]

Which moment did you miss? The two moments I was looking forward to seeing. McGonagle taking four stunners to the chess while Hagrid literally throws around the group of ministry guys trying to capture him. And the scene I am most upset about not appearing in films, creatures, redemption, and the house elves stand, That scene where creature leads them out in the kitchen, screaming “strike down the dark lord for master regulus protect your school!!” well they all run out with knives and cleaver, slicing peoples legs out from under them, and stabbing them in the eyes😂 everyone talks about the not my daughter you bitch seen, but when I was reading the books, the house elves really really got me❤ also something that was too dark and got removed. Fang getting burned alive. Rip puppo

[@GafftheHorse]

Umbridges fate wasn't particularly dark, whatever happened to her at the hands of the centaurs was more than well deserved. Only a pity no one was there to sing 'Summer is a comin in'.

[@exsl1408]

Background music??

[@robthomas3968]

The darkest part of the books is Voldemorts act of Cannibalism

[@Ola-jz7oj]

There is no cannibalism in books, tho JK Rowling thought about adding such thing

[@robthomas3968]

@@Ola-jz7oj yes there is nagini the snake has a part of Voldemort inside her, & she eats the teacher

[@Ola-jz7oj]

@@robthomas3968 well, I guess you are right... from a certain point of view 🤔

[@SakariWolf13]

​@@robthomas3968That's a good point. I think we all forget that as much as Nagini has lost her humanity, she is still a human trapped as a snake.

[@johnharris5686]

The saddest thing in any book is watching aunt petunia leaving tge house she raised dudley and "harry"

[@peterratter6603]

A couple or three of things to do with Umbridge's fate at the mercies of the centaurs... It is known that JKR based Umbridge on a teacher she admittedly despised. It is known that in mythology, centaurs were known as the embodiment of wisdom and knowledge, or drunken rapists. Ron doing the 'clip clop' noise to get a PTSD trauma reaction from a catatonic Umbridge in the book is pretty shitty, even by JKR's petty standards.

[@ryanmoore7098]

Umbridge had that train ran on her 🤣.

[@MountainFisher]

So you know about the Greek myth about what centaurs do to women?

[@TC-tl8ie]

I know this is wrong, but was really hoping that the centaurs had violated Umbridge.

[@Ehrenhaider_Akainu]

Its not wrong

[@Onyxheart4754]

I don't think I ever thought of this that it's not harries worst afraid moments that the dementors bring up it's Voldemorts fear of dying that is triggered every time the dementors come around

[@D.M.Mortem]

I like this channel and all, but bro, can you please not put 10 mid-roll ads in your videos like you're leaving fried chicken crumbs for Sirius to find you?

[@MountainFisher]

What ads?

[@D.M.Mortem]

@MountainFisher I'm on mobile, so all the adds. Has 4 mid-rolls, and the before and after video start ads. Yea, 6 ads, but still. 6 ads for this video is too much.

[@MountainFisher]

@@D.M.Mortem I only saw the sponsor ad in the middle. That's wild mobile has that many ads.

[@cherryb893]

That's often KZbin's doing not the uploader. And yeah, I wish to God above they'd stop it. Google makes gazillions from adverts that don't interrupt anything at all; this is unadulterated GREED.

[@foodofthegods]

this is an amazing comment

[@ABurntMuffin]

bruuuuuh link to part 1 and 2 in your description you are losing views. I know I'm not the only person too lazy to sift through your whole catalogue to see if I've already seen them!

[@HarryPotterTheory]

Done!

[@ABurntMuffin]

@@HarryPotterTheory

[@MissJoy16]

Good looking out!

[@baldrian22]

i have to agree that not showing voldermort ordering nagini to eat the person was the correct choice. it might not be aimed for the youngest audience with deaths, war etc in them but it would be aimed to an audience that might be to young for that specific sceene.

[@jamalsonicova2509]

Slashing spell aka a knife xD

[@elizabethoneill8612]

When they try to suck out his soul

[@keith7644]

I’d a walked out of that detention the second it started

[@jenlfpotter3870]

No chance of that when Umbridge is dealing. You'd have probably been in a whole lot more trouble if not expelled or sent to Azkaban as Fudge fully intended I'm sure, to send Harry there if he hadn't been cleared of any charges.

[@DrakeSmith-tn6ij]

What if Umbridge had actually succeeded in expelling Harry Potter?

[@keith7644]

@@DrakeSmith-tn6ij Dumbledore wouldn’t allow it

[@keith7644]

Plus the type of detention she had

[@elizabethoneill8612]

Also with the OWL'S

[@emptycan666]

Barty was already supposed to be in prison f the trial lol

[@melanievetter6211]

😊🎉🏞🏝🦁

[@quoniam426]

Umbridge, in the books; you didn't show everything (thx YT), shows symptoms of having been... revise your Greek Mythology to see what centaurs liked to do to women...

[@JamesDavy2009]

All I can say is…ouch.

[@RantRadio]

Well, considering what the lore of Centaurs were, they probably took Hella turns and left her bukkaked 😐

[@jrdonaldson2053]

LIT

[@mynamesnotdan]

you know umbridge got gaped by those centaurs

[@angelcastro3129]

Cool video but... Please have your graphics people STOP using those photoshop filters. Just leave the images as they are, Your channel is above the need for such ridiculous enhancements.

[@Aleezah143]

???? I get you’re being “nice” but you’re being kind of rude too

[@angelcastro3129]

@@Aleezah143 are entitled to your opinion as am I. Enjoy your day

[@HeyThatWeirdGuy]

It's his videos I'm sure he approves the edits before he releases them. This is obviously how he wants his videos to be published

[@HeyThatWeirdGuy]

​@@angelcastro3129But you're TELLING someone to do something. That's not a option

[@Nitroh-]

Honestly, who cares.. These videos are more or less just background noise, you don't need to stare at the screen for the whole video since it's just pictures and screenshots from the movies. I just listen to the commentary while I play games. It's such a small thing to complain about lol.

[@14reasons58]

Charity's quote was similar to Barbara Lerner spectre on white Genocide.