AI Music Is Still Awful

[@davidarnold2456]

Her mom died of a computer virus

[@cerebrumexcrement]

😂😂😂😂

[@joanabug4479]

They always go after the more vulnerable. She started believing in those anti-antivirus conspiracies 💀

[@blu3260]

She should've subscribed to NordVPN 😔

[@whoevenisthatlady]

@@blu3260 she probably thought VPNs caused autism 😞

[@beautyandtheoffbeats]

Ahh😂😂

[@JOHNwasBORN]

AI: Artificial Intelligence AI: Anna Indiana GUYS I have a game theory-

[@theobscureandtheabsurd9381]

Anna Indiana sounds like a porn name too. Do you think she'll also be a porn star if her music career doesn't work out?

[@worth-ec3ho]

forgot about allen iverson. respect The Answer.

[@JMcAfreak]

Anthony Indianthony

[@Rena152]

I'd say that's actually pretty smart, but knowing these people it was probably just a lucky coincidence

[@DrMcFly28]

Sure, but it's just a theory

[@theboi5584]

When the world did not need her in the slightest, she came back with full force

[@AdnAdnAdn]

She’s not the artist we deserved, but she’s the artist we didn’t even know we didn’t need

[@enigmadrath1780]

She's going to save the world, or burn it to the core trying.

[@LynnColeMusic]

Right, exactly. And that's what makes it such an amazing act. Anna wasn't born. She was engineered. And she was created to get that exact reaction out of people

[@AdnAdnAdn]

@@house9850 sounds like the AI would technically be the songwriter in your case. it’s normal for artists to release songs that someone else wrote for them. but the writer obv needs to give permission, be compensated and credited. So the real question is, do you need permission to release a song written by AI? And who would actually give you that permission? Would it be the developer of the AI you used? And would you need to credit the AI and/or somehow compensate it (or the developer) for writing the song? Legally speaking, I’m not sure of any laws that answer these questions yet because im pretty sure we’re still in the Wild West of the AI songwriting era. eventually some AI dev will sue an artist for releasing a song written by their AI, and legal confusion will ensue. Until then it’s tricky because if you do the honest thing and credit the AI, maybe the AI dev sees it and sues you for royalties from the song. Whereas If you lie and say you wrote the song yourself, then no one would ever even think to suspect AI was used (even if they did, it would be tough to prove). at the end of the day, if music is just a hobby and you aren’t making money from it, you’ll likely never have to worry about any of this. Safest bet probably is being honest about the AI’s involvement, and just keep the AI program you used to yourself.

[@LynnColeMusic]

@@house9850 Depends how you do it, and where ai lives in your process, what kind of work goes into making the thing. Look, if you've put a week into writing a song and producing it with ai, it's yours. There's no reasonable way to argue that it isn't. There is a lot of craft there... or there can be. I think ai is a terrible time saver, but it's a fantastic way to break out of your comfort zone as an artist and see your work and creative pipeline in new ways. My friends over at Dadabots said that we're in the late 1970s of ai music right now. Sort of like when keyboards just came out, and nobody understood them yet. Only a handful of people doing really interesting or innovative work while everything else was kinda just... sludge? I like that comparison

[@nashbeats_1]

All AI pop songs are literally just all of Taylor Swifts catalogue put in a blender a watered down ngl 😭😭

[@visaman]

I was thinking more like Radio Disney.

[@PhoenixTwoFiftySix]

Insult to Taylor Swift. This is like taking Kidz Bop and asking the AI to give it more country

[@GenderRebelMusic]

mine as well?

[@zarroth]

@@PhoenixTwoFiftySix nah, taylor is garbage corporate re-hash music in the first place. Makes total sense given what she really is.

[@Fading_Rain]

Anna Indiana threatens to release new "music"

[@GizzyDillespee]

Captured By The Captcha is gonna be a banger of an album, for AI

[@ItzJuanG]

​@@GizzyDillespee"Please select all images of the pieces of my broken heart" BARS 💯🔥✍️

[@farrellmcnulty909]

Or shoild it be that the mad scientists who created this mannequin are threstening to release "new musuc"

[@nicjo_]

😭

[@6dragondaddy913]

I'm scared she's going to turn out to be the AI from "I Have no Mouth and I Must Scream" but she makes you listen to her music as torture...

[@theodoornap9283]

I would just like to point out that it's probably easier to generate "country" music with AI than most other genres because contemporary pop country is EXTREMELY formulaic and repetitive

[@CordeliaAurora]

Honestly I've heard southerners listen to this exact type of generic bs while driving

[@bengreenbank]

It sounds no different at all to modern pop country. People wouldn't know the difference in a blind A/B test

[@ryanquick07]

Reminds me of how I feel when I accidentally see a tiktok...like breathe please

[@TheFapFactory]

EXACTLY. And the sad part is a lot of people eat this type of generic garbage up. So the AI probably was able to calculate that at some point and then decided this was the route to go lmao smfh

[@acatnamedjoex4688]

That, Hiphop, and radiorock.

[@treyturner9707]

Hannah Montana, Anna Indiana, Alexas Texas, who's gonna be the next country star Tacoma Oklahoma?

[@evil_icicle]

Georgia Georgia

[@Randomjackass135]

But Tacoma is a place, not a common first name. Then again look who I’m talking to you’re named after a thing a lunch lady does

[@carter_lovejoy]

Caroline Carolina

[@mitchellanderson3068]

Gina Carolina. Pronounced just how you’re thinking

[@TheAndrewj96]

Morgan Oregon, Elaine Maine, Ramona Arizona, Tori Missouri, Tippi Mississippi.

[@manic_ferret]

whoever decided it needed a visualizer of an uncanny girl singing while sitting completely still should be locked up

[@FalloutTributeMusic]

This! And next time he should pick channels that actually write the lyrics and create a decent song because of structure. This video would have been totally different If He woulda used my channel.

[@manic_ferret]

@@FalloutTributeMusic You must be mistaken, nowhere did I say “I support AI music.” Your AI Slop is buns. Fuck off

[@manic_ferret]

@@FalloutTributeMusic LoOk aT mE i cAn WrItE lYrIcS delete your AI slop and learn how to make something yourself

[@RealSlowLike]

​@FalloutTributeMusic nah, Ai is objectively lame and anyone that uses it is a sad and pathetic.

[@MasoTrumoi]

If they didn't make a horrifying tween visualizer no one would've even reacted to it.

[@FamilyJules7X]

what if they made anna indiana so uncanny just to distract us from the fact that fantano has been ai this whole time

[@iankrasnow5383]

What if Family Jules has been making AI video game covers this whole time?

[@travis.t7773]

Holy that would be a five-head move

[@lasagnahog7695]

I suppose granting sentience to a melon is a form of AI.

[@SunshineAndRainbowsNShit]

Yooo its jules

[@jamiecloughgaming25387]

Badaboom Tush!

[@jammadamma]

Why does she look like a 12-year old with makeup? Is that the idealized woman these days?

[@ideac.]

Sneako type of girl

[@Nuvizzle]

For AI enthusiasts, yes

[@llynxfyremusic]

Absolutely nothing on the face at all, no freckles,, no blush, no random discolouration. It just looks completely untextured and inhuman

[@visaman]

You might be projecting.

[@Gustoberg]

​@@visaman AI bros are like, EXTREMELLY flexible by what they think about the age of consent, it's like asking crypto bros about it "mental maturity" is what they'll respond.

[@grapesmash3517]

Anthony, how could you post this. I thought we agreed sexism was bad. I bet if Anna Indiana was called Andrew Indiandrew you would give these tracks 10s.

[@TheAndrewj96]

As an Andrew, I certainly would.

[@eatfrenchtoast]

okeee

[@fcktherich6913]

Indiandrew!!!😂😂😂😂

[@MrMkG2]

if it was called To Pimp A Grownup Goodbye he would've given it a 10

[@davidkippy101]

or Anthony Indianthony

[@queen-patches233]

the creepy babyfaced child star has me wondering who made it and why they arent being investigated.

[@lepus6511]

The first thing i noticed was the creepy baby face. Someone please investigate the hard drives owned by whoever created this

[@Robstafarian]

Almost every aspect of her appearance changes from thumbnail to thumbnail, and one of them looks like she might be in junior high!

[@kay-412]

genuinely disturbing icl

[@user-jk7vp7vn2k]

she was made by a real girl who wanted to become a singer but she never got the support from her parents and she considers herself too ugly to show her face on the internet. it's likely a cooing mechanism or some sort of attempt at reclaiming what she was denied

[@ZephyrusAsmodeus]

Somebody mentions it at least, god am I sick of creepy shit like that

[@BigOwl51]

I miss the old Anna Indiana. Betrayed by this town is a certified hood classic.

[@alexthemess101]

me and the boys blasting anna indiana in the streets of baltimore

[@Bombdizzle]

She's sold out maaaaan

[@mewnboy]

we’ve LOOOOST it all 🎶 😔✊

[@Hips.oo8]

I miss the old anna set on her goals anna

[@book_roblox]

@@Hips.oo8 seen on her horse Anna, the cowgirl Anna

[@MechanicalRabbits]

she will never be Hatsune Miku

[@gunier.j.kintgenanimations]

At least she has something resembling a soul, AI music is *truly* soulless.

[@MsZsc]

polar

[@Nilluos]

Hatsune is made by real people just using a AI voice, this is just ai music entirely lol

[@MechanicalRabbits]

@@Nilluos miku is not an AI voice, they got the voice provider to record every single phoneme on different note ranges and built the software from there. Newer vocaloids and other similar software like synthesizer V do use AI technology for more natural transitions between phonemes, but the recording process for the voicebank is still the same I think.

[@MechanicalRabbits]

@@Nilluos no it is not and you didn't get anything. I hate this snarky know-it-all attitude that's all over the internet nowadays man it's impossible to have a real conversation.

[@maxrona137]

The AI's accent is changing faster than Drake's

[@mickey4125]

It's a madness AND a badness

[@hectors.graciano8706]

More like Kamala 😂

[@tshatos6442]

Are you referring to when drake raps he sounds different than when he speaks? Or something else?

[@mickey4125]

@@tshatos6442 Nah he culture-vultures his way around the world, assuming the accent of whoever he's working with. His stint over here in the UK was particularly cringe-inducing, but see also his fake-as-whitegirl-dreads patois, the southern affect he uses when he's down in ATL etc etc etc. Man took so many parts of other people he forgot how to be himself.

[@tshatos6442]

@@mickey4125 I just got douche chills

[@fhusmogg]

I misread the title of this video as “All Music is Still Awful” and I was like “damb tony I respect the transparency”

[@mickey4125]

Damnthony Transparentano?

[@theurbanyouth]

But AI music is better than modern music created by people.

[@firstnamelastname7244]

​@@theurbanyouthcap

[@theurbanyouth]

@@firstnamelastname7244 NPC

[@pizzaman8918]

@@theurbanyouth boy do I have a few albums for you: Abbey Road Revolver Graduation Dark Side of the Moon The Wall Master of Puppets and many more

[@Jedderz08]

We all know that when you turn 24 you unlock the rest of your emotional skill tree

[@remmy107]

I'm 28 and still haven't unlocked everything. Maybe it's due to my starting class😢

[@esme_melody]

i’m 25 & i think the last time i felt an emotion was at 23 maybe?

[@malum9478]

i mean...kinda? moreso, that's around when your brain _actually, finally_ finishes developing.

[@Tuxfanturnip]

@@malum9478 according to a study that stopped monitoring development at that age

[@Alkatross]

I've only been in my training algorithm for 10 minutes and have more emotional depth. Pathetic

[@privateprivate1865]

To be honest.. I wouldn't even have noticed this was ai if i heard it on the radio, because modern country music is just that bad. I'm not even joking

[@GoredonTheDestroyer]

AI songwriting is like Vocaloid for people who think Vocaloid is weird.

[@ChickenTenderBender]

LMAOOO

[@benjiusofficial]

FACTS

[@hejai792]

It seems like they’re not using anymore SynthV thankfully

[@whatsthisidonteven]

God, I almost forgot Miku exists, gonna go cleanse my ears from this shit, thx

[@zer02xjxzzingxnbxtches]

Yea but vocaloid is actually takes little more effort since its like an instrument used to sing songs that is written by humans; none of that generated, stolen bs

[@caseygecko]

7:52 brown hair, brown eyes, in a music studio,,, too many fingers,,,,,,

[@ConflictingJumps]

new song lryic?

[@Ponsobobo]

Isn't it funny how country is the most easily predicted by ai?!

[@chrishealton3830]

Modern “country” is the most vapid thing you can find out today and people absolutely gobble it up.

[@Jerrremy]

Have you listened to the procedurally generated djent

[@666kittycat666]

There is something so funny about the idea that she is a heterosexual AI

[@Dkvizu]

If AI was really smart it would have sent Anna on a full Tom McDonald/ Forgi Self Suck grift campaign. That way she could be #1 on iTunes and performing next to Kid Rock on the RNC stage

[@carter_lovejoy]

Dude, imagine if Anna Indiana starts making pro-Trump music with Tom MacDonald. That would be hilarious!

[@kimaboe]

@@carter_lovejoy Don't give the people ideas, its pretty obvious they have none and will take any they find lying around.

[@geoid5388]

I've never laughed this hard at a comment 😂

[@QuicksilverSG]

"She" looks more like 14 than 24.

[@KEBJD]

ai music wants to be hatsune miku so bad

[@idonthaveanygoodnametouse1704]

Damn I must be ai

[@toiletP]

Hatsune miku is coming back to vocaloid and is going to get an ai voicebank lol.

[@someidiotmetalhead]

And even that's a low bar to clear

[@Justin-Ver-Ka]

Clearly, Fantano hasn't heard the AI masterpiece that is "I Glued My Balls To My Butthole Again"

[@ingej003]

I'm a big fan of My Arms Are Just Fuckin Stuck Like This by Jenny Stardust

[@StrangeScaryNewEngland]

I just heard a banger called something like "Taking a shit on company time"

[@Koblac]

Someone tell kanye about how bad AI is and NO ONE tell peggy about how bad AI is

[@prematuredgravy8033]

Dude fr I'm surprised Kanye hasn't used AI more

[@naohaotingala6433]

Fax Peggy's ai sample for that one song was fire

[@neuronaljunctiondecay5673]

@@naohaotingala6433which

[@TheSkaOreo]

@@prematuredgravy8033 oh don’t worry. He will.

[@Tigonawig]

​@@TheSkaOreoOh no.

[@404no57]

They're saying that the animation is 24, but it's giving 12

[@gabrieltiongco]

Finally, a TEMU alternative to Hannah Montana!

[@jammadamma]

Humans still want human connection, believe it or not. I don't think people will be genuinely emotionally touched by AI generated content.

[@ultraboner4986]

i have been emotionally touched by various ai art, music and ai text conversations personally.

[@Brandon82967]

An AI song made top 100 in Germany and BBL Drizzy made top 30 in new zealand

[@g_vost]

of course the pro-AI-ass argument reduces art to just statistics n shit like that proves the point

[@ultraboner4986]

@@g_vost i didnt, i said i had a personal connection to ai music, and i say this as a musician that made non ai albums for a few years now

[@owenmeier]

@@Brandon82967 BBL Drizzy has an element of human connection since Metro made a beat out of it though.

[@andrewkoster6506]

"why does life have to be so hard?" LADY YOU'RE NOT ALIVE AND YOU NEVER HAVE BEEN

[@aporue5893]

must be so hard being a robot devoid of human emotion,created by real humans 🤣

[@joni3805]

0:42 "Anna Indiana is the world's first all-AI singer-songwriter. She's deeply mediocre" thats just funny to me idk why

[@chronosand563]

Saying ai is still awful is like saying that melon is still bald(and octagonal)

[@theonenonlybass]

And liberal

[@dannytoons]

That kinda rhymed

[@albertfanmingo]

*hexagonal

[@DiegoBQZ]

Idk he's looking kinda Hexagonal these days

[@williamgrammer9549]

I see a septagon

[@enigmadrath1780]

Am old enough to remember the hype when Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within came out in 2001 and there was so much controversy about how lifelike the CGI was, to the point where (allegedly) some people had trouble believing it wasn't real. Lots of talk about whether within the next decade CGI would make actors obsolete. We now in the year 2024 and despite Hollywood's best efforts, CGI-for-live-action still ain't fooling people, but good golly do they still be trying. Anna Indiana is the AI music equivalent to that.

[@somedude15231]

God I remember roughly 10 minutes ago when I didn't know people were making so called "music" with AI. I miss that time. I'd like to go back to that time, please.

[@tomv4634]

careful what you watch these days lol

[@lippi2171]

The past will pass my friend.

[@scoobertmcruppert2915]

Wow…took you years to figure it out…

[@andrewlloydpeterson]

If merzbow is music why this isnt?

[@lippi2171]

@@andrewlloydpeterson tbf even Merzbow has some artistic vision, while "her" music is pure statistics of material fed into "her" algo

[@caeliachapin5317]

God. I want to see the AI industry fail, and fail HARD. I'll be waiting with a bottle of champagne.

[@nevadanate4957]

Watch those lawsuits by the music industry against the people who make AI generators, that's going to do it in. You at least won't see AI tracks on streaming

[@theurbanyouth]

Keep coping, AI music is getting so advanced, now, it's hard sometimes to even tell it a part from non-AI music, and it's only in it's infancy, which is really shocking.

[@theurbanyouth]

@@nevadanate4957 Won't work, AI music is the same as remixing, just like people do when creating music.

[@nevadanate4957]

@@theurbanyouth remixes pay royalties and are consciously made. And remixes are not all or even the majority of created music. A court will decide what AI music is legally and I really think you should brace for it to not go your way.

[@Didi_Meow_Records]

People said the same about techno. Soulless music is not new

[@mrgreenbean253]

You can always tell it’s AI cause of the choppy ass vocals

[@bravojeark]

Mushy transients on everything

[@wumbojet]

Also the garbage instrumentals and the completely soulless lyrics

[@antonioskollias6584]

New Eminem is AI confirmed?

[@dumpsky]

not true. just the shitty stuff. it's not 2022 anymore.

[@FalloutTributeMusic]

False! 95% of all songs I write sound amazing and not choppy at all. Its because of bad Lyricists that dont know how to make a decent structure and good flow pattern. Thats why It sucks.

[@swapticsounds]

And the song length is 2:42 - everybody who has experimented with Udio recognizes it. This is 5 x 32.5 seconds generation blocks, which means the user hasn´t used any cutting, and took almost everything what the AI has generated by default. Not picky at all. When I, as an actual musician, play around with Udio, I often go bar by bar or even smaller, and thereby never get these characteristic song lengths of multiples of 32.5s.

[@camillagilmore1547]

"Each heartbreak is a new song I'll write" Anna Indiana Taylor Swift ghostwriter confirmed

[@Vanessa-uo6lt]

I remember when Taylor had already announced the titles of her latest album and people on TikTok started spreading ai versions of the songs based on the titles, saying the album had leaked. And like. Nothing swifties have ever said about Taylor was as offensive as believing those tracks were actually her writing lmao

[@blakestebbe7937]

Indiana resident here: first off, it’s nice that melon is thinking of us Hoosiers. Second, southern Indiana is a bit hilly, but northern Indiana is flat farmland.

[@georget4141]

anywhere you go in the world, there’s a hoosier running things!

[@durarara911]

Wait does that mean it could actually be AI

[@ReadyMindsetGo]

But is there an Indiana volcano near a school?

[@rinash1706]

I want to be her songwriter, I can write some really lazy shitty lyrics: You slept with Stacy, You slept with Tracy, You slept with Lacy, You slept with Macy, All while dating me, Now we all got an STD, My oh my, I thought we were all AI, So how did it happen? It doesn't even ryme.

[@maxturtle7787]

Grown-Up Goodbyes feels like it ripped all its data straight from The Chicks

[@incrediblectopus]

Literally had the same thought

[@nevadanate4957]

That's why these lawsuits will do commercial AI in. You can blatantly hear what these generators trained on

[@Station_AI]

And Logic ripped data from Kendrick, it happens in music all the time...

[@nevadanate4957]

@@Station_AI except artists just do that sometimes, AI can ONLY do that, and even a human made ripoff is more interesting than AI

[@Station_AI]

@@nevadanate4957 I disagree, it's impossible for a human to make music that isn't pulling inspiration from other artists either consciously or subconsciously. Human music is only more interesting than AI music of you care about having a parasocial relationship with the artist.

[@AshPuppy]

Forget how robotic she SOUNDS, why doesnt anyone talk about how robotic she LOOKS? Only the face moves, the rest of her body and head are so stationary that its incredibly obvious and the first thing I notice.

[@kev2034]

Genuinely looks like they took a child's face, photoshopped it onto an adult body and then warped her face like those old E-cards your grandparents would send you at christmas

[@M0ONCommander]

that's the thing. singing is an athletic skill true and through. there's so much understated physicality involved in vocal support, going up and down registers, and giving multifaceted matisse to a performance. so when you look at an image of an uncanny face moving its mouth, but nothing else, it strikes entirely contrary to what's naturally involved in singing. forget the passion. there's nothing even remotely reminiscent of even the most mediocre and flat "fight song" renditions at middle school talent shows.

[@cheddarandsourcream]

I did see a really funny tik tok claiming it was an AI country song but it probably wasn’t cause the lyrics started by saying “I drank a million trillion billion beers”

[@Yusabich]

Tough to tell tbh

[@robrotron2084]

I think a lot of those are lyrics written by a person just using ai for the sound. I've messed with AI a bit and it's not that funny.

[@stoferb876]

Checked up "her" KZbin profile. Very weird and telling that you cannot block that channel. You can block any channel you want if it's a human. Of course you can still report it, but for what? It's not like "Anna Indiana" is going to violate youtube guidelines or activate their copyright bots.

[@НАЗГУЛЬЧИК]

I’m personally happy that AI creation tools arrived so that a select few hacks who have absolutely no ability whatsoever can have the warm fuzzy feeling that they did something, even if it is objectively stupid, weird, creepy, and…not good.

[@KathyClysm]

AI really is the participation trophy of art 😂

[@JukeboxOddities]

And what if the Individual has some talent and uses ai as a tool to get out ideas?

[@JukeboxOddities]

​@@RubenMillsOfficialI bet that in the 80s, you would have denied the talent of any artist who used MIDI or sampling. And the same in 40s-50s with the advent of electronic instruments.

[@gloomiette]

​@@JukeboxOdditiesso close! Those actually take effort to play and don't do the work for you!❤️

[@JukeboxOddities]

@@gloomiette There is a common misconception that AI music does not involve actual instrumental skill/ production work. You have to differenciate between lazy "one prompt one click" songs and pieces that involve a lot of editing or the expansion of actual people playing with ai. Or sampling AI generated parts to fit a human composition.

[@hishighness1842]

She sorta looks like miranda cosgrove

[@TheAndyk123]

I was thinking she looks like if Sarah Hyland got lip injections

[@dono-t7g]

3:53 bro started his eddie vedder impression all of a sudden

[@awab1877]

5:52 The ai Lore is crazy 😂😂

[@Emperor_NYC]

And the sun is bright, and blue is a color, and the floor is made of floor..

[@mykhedelic6471]

Please finish this. I need this song.

[@MrDublem]

B A R S

[@TheFurryFurby]

No they’re not. (But I get what you’re saying)

[@obsideonstar7677]

As a person from the corn-infested hellhole that is Indiana, the flatness depends on how far north or south you are in the state. Farther north (past Bloomington, and especially up toward Indy and beyond) it gets pretty flat. In the southern portions (mostly southern third or so) it is extremely hilly, there's hills on hills and areas with small cliffs and miniature valleys. Nothing really gets to the level of mountains, but it's definitely not flat. Id recommend checking out the New Harmany State Park for a look into what some of the more natural landscape looks like.

[@RSG_TheMonster]

and water is wet.

[@invisibleig]

WHAT

[@00Tottr]

Nah

[@walter3001]

Yes, it is

[@-_-noEmojis]

and the colour green is green

[@RetroCrowd55]

Water is NOT wet

[@Ultravenom1]

I am feeling called out. I enjoy saying people's names, so i text it too like "I hope you have a great sleep X, miss you!" "Hey Y, hope your workday is easy!" "Z, why do lemons taste so good".

[@BeneathTheHeadphones]

Ai is inevitably irritating and I hate it

[@noodlebs4]

4:56 saying goodbye isn't easy thuu

[@drhall343]

I love that the first video recommendation is Rick Beato taking an L. 😂

[@ReadyMindsetGo]

This is the comment I was looking for lol

[@tropezando]

There are actually two good AI songs: "My Arms are Fucking Stuck Like This" and "I Glued My Balls to my Butthole Again"

[@birb5306]

that’s bc real people wrote them and then used AI to do the audio

[@Brandon82967]

Almost like AI is a useful tool or something

[@aporue5893]

hey oh,I don't know what I say,no.

[@chajospie]

Even when AI music becomes good, it will still be awful. Art should be made by artists, not computers.

[@xydanmusic]

Absolutely

[@FalloutTributeMusic]

You mean how art was created the last 25 years? 90% of all music you hear right now is made by computers. Autotune = AI like literally. The dude under your comment also uses Autotune on most of his songs. Hilarious. As a longtime writer I will tell every Singer from now on that they are no Artists. Because they only sing what I write.

[@banoko]

@@FalloutTributeMusic autotune is a tool used by artists, the creating part is still made by artists. AI is not the same

[@Tbrain-zq4ft]

@@FalloutTributeMusicwith computers ≠ by computers

[@vfloev]

​@@FalloutTributeMusicyou gotta be trolling

[@Rkruzz]

As a Hoosier (someone from Indiana) I think I speak on behalf of a great majority of us that we do not accept this amalgam of inputs and outputs as representing us and would prefer our name representation being kept to Indiana Jones.

[@NighttimeBird]

Rick Beato “I admit it…I got owned”

[@joeschianodicola1810]

7:26 you can see Anthony internally fighting the urge to click Like

[@drhall343]

The only time AI "art" is good is when it takes advantage of how bad AI is at replicating human thought processes. Like that video of an AI trying to complete System Blower by Death Grips or the ai_peter Family Guy videos.

[@erinbeaud4556]

I miss when AI videos meant that video of the rock eating spaghetti.

[@fluffsynthesis]

Batman written by an ai is insanely good too

[@M0ONCommander]

ai generated 800k word ben shapiro crack fic on AO3

[@carultch]

@@erinbeaud4556 He was eating actual rocks.

[@erinbeaud4556]

@@carultch you’re right, it was Will Smith who ate the spaghetti.

[@samthecowboy]

saying “she’s letting the stars and bars fly” in relation to having a southern accent is so funny to me lmao

[@OlYables]

3:07 Anthony got a little twanged up by Anna Indiana.

[@Grace-tg4oy]

I don't understand AI music. AI imagery has a certain uncanny, dreamlike look that I guess some people like (I don't but whatever.) AI text can be used for cheating on essays. What is the purpose of AI music? The only thing I can think of is tech bros who have lost all their humanity trying to reverse engineer something that brings people who still have souls joy.

[@kev2034]

Reminds me of that bit in Rick and Morty where Jerry is in the car listening to "human music"

[@lockytonight5110]

Most music made in the last 30 years is technically AI music sound enhancements, reverb, auto-tune, sfx, etc

[@v0Xx60]

@@lockytonight5110 Nope. Made with a computer isn't the same as made by a computer. Production is not AI.

[@RealSlowLike]

The goal is to create a money printer. They don't care if the music is soulless, only whether they can easily profit from it.

[@Brandon82967]

People still like it nonetheless. BBL Drizzy was AI made

[@cathyrayTV]

debut single was notable enough to make an honorable mention in worst songs of the year and now she gets under 1k streams per track. this might be the hardest fall off of the century

[@bigmistqke]

For a fall off u have to be up first

[@Ozzymandius1]

It’s giving Tortured Poets Department tbh. 🎶Floridaa. My friends all smell like weed and newborn babies.🎶

[@JaredtheRabbit]

In other words, Disney is evil, and the sky is blue.

[@gentlesoup_wzs]

Songs created entirely by AI should not be on streaming platforms, even if they were mixed/mastered by a human. And by the way KZbin identifies Anna Indiana in this video, although it further is not a person, it is maximally wrong

[@spaceofnaspace]

buddy doin' anything BUT the Ultra 85 review

[@superchargedmvp2984]

Edger 85 :C i want my review!!!!

[@Jerome984]

me when i cant say the n word

[@ThePhreakass]

It's not worth reviewing. Just another failed attempt to recapture the past

[@PepsiManW]

@@ThePhreakasswrong! don’t worry, you’ll get there eventually!

[@superchargedmvp2984]

@@ThePhreakass ❌

[@saintsinatra3]

The staring-into-the-back-of-your-soul-thing is beyond the uncanny valley... My blood vessels crawled...

[@mercytracemaker638]

Still better than vultures 1 and 2

[@xariacat]

I feel Ana Indiana decided pivot to country because she’d blend in a little easier there; feel like that music culture is less likely to notice that she’s an imposter, not like every other big country singer isn’t also an imposter.

[@privatesnowball3032]

0:53 THRENODY FOR THE VICTIMS OF HIROSHIMA

[@Hughfructose]

Tf

[@sebastianfayle2066]

Didn't know there were Penderecki fans in the comments here

[@privatesnowball3032]

@@sebastianfayle2066 yes sir

[@GnatHuman]

Thank you, I would've missed it if it weren't for this comment

[@Rob23465]

I hate AI. My life was better without it.

[@flyktsoda]

I can't finish this for obvious reasons. But isn't "she" off beat at 4:30? The "moving on gets harder" line feels very bad.

[@silashjertkristensen1203]

I wouldnt say she's off beat but def off key

[@whiteshadowbw9335]

8:20 she pulled an MGK I'm crying 😭🔥😭🔥😭🔥😭🔥😭🔥😭🔥😭🔥

[@randomeyeliner]

The thing about intrusive thoughts is they exactly do the opposite of passing by

[@GreatistheWorld]

Best comment

[@aaronsmith1474]

The ultimate problem here is that most real music is trash so the competition AI has is not all that challenging to over come.

[@alfiewillis4893]

"I assumed with all the hate this project would fall into obscurity", no, these hate clicks drive engagement, you should know that!!

[@JianAddelle]

okay atleast this guy did lol

[@xxczerxx]

7:06 damn I feel called out by this, I just checked and the last person I messaged I put "Hey (person's name)" at the start!

[@OneReallyGrumpyJill]

Mr. Melon, who is this Anna Indiana? You just stared at nothing for 12 minutes

[@JackTripper27]

“Indiana? I hear it’s so flat up there you can watch your dog run away from home for three days!”- Some old timer down Alabama way when I told him where I was from.

[@samh2340]

my brain is bleeding out my ears at least the "AI [person or character] sings [actual song]" songs are musically coherent and don't sound like they were written by a drunk 7 year old

[@uphillracer]

Ever since genres became formulaic, humans were eager to find a recipe, cater to trends, and reach the broadest audience possible. They tried to dumb it down so that little children and drunken people could still follow what’s going on. Well now, there is actually a machine that can do this. I’m not surprised.

[@Kinggizzardthegreenstuffwizard]

As someone who has lived their entire life in Indiana. She perfectly represents how flat and awful the state is.

[@jz4057]

If that’s what AI believes to be the best of us…there’s no point to keep humans around.

[@Ballin-97]

AI music is still much better than Tom McDonald

[@albertfanmingo]

AI will never be better than real artists, but it sure is better than a real artist.

[@carter_lovejoy]

I feel like Tom MacDonald will utilize AI for one of his shitty songs soon.

[@TheGreatestJediOfAllTime]

@@albertfanmingo It’s better than Tom MacDonald. Therefore your statement is false.

[@pogolaugh]

TRU

[@zer02xjxzzingxnbxtches]

Both are equally as soulless tbh

[@Gorgovoid173]

Every time "she" "opens" "her" "mouth", I get this weird uncomfortable chill in my lower back and I either fast-forward, open spotify to drown it out, or pause the video... I've always been bad with cringe, but this like 20x worse than just listening to someone sing badly... The fact that it's very clearly MEANT to sound good makes it worse...

[@birchwwolf]

8:43 imagine "warm leatherette" with these lyrics edit: thanks for getting "lies are tooollllld" stuck in my head again, jerk

[@kayfimt7769]

Called it two years ago that AI is actually going to suck and be nothing like the threat to music people anticipated. (Visual art is a different story, but for reasons too lengthy to type in a KZbin comment, music is likely safe.)

[@nickadt]

3:28 Fantano low key sending subs @ Beato.

[@RoxanneSturgis]

whats fucked up is that video isnt even related to melon's video

[@theamazingcj2748]

We need a need a monthly Anna Indiana update

[@dancoroian1]

FYI the northern half of Indiana is pretty flat, but it gets quite hilly in the southern part -- no volcanoes though!

[@ManOutofTime913]

Wasn't the Anna Indiana stuff made with unlicensed software? Did they shell out money to make more of this garbage?

[@jasontorrens626]

🎶 "Where in the world is.....Anna Indiana?"🎶

[@anthonyfaiell3263]

It's going to be awful for a while. They can probably easily recreate major hits. And easily write pop song lyrics... But to actually write meaningful songs... No... That's not going to happen for a long time. If you are a musician who plays more than 3 chords, you probably have nothing to worry about.

[@ratlungworm7035]

Think about it. Has anyone ever actually met someone from Indiana? I don't think it actually exists.

[@TheOnlyRealYeAndCudiFan]

Hi, Indiana person here.

[@ratlungworm7035]

These bot replies getting ridiculous

[@ucantSQ]

Watching someone sing without moving their torso is fuggin creepy. ...and gross.