American Shares Truth on Xinjiang and Tibet Controversies in China

0:00 Introduction of Tibet and Xinjiang
0:32 - What was Tibet like 20 Years Ago?
3:00 - How the Chinese government works in Tibet
5:20 - Is the Tibetan language being lost?
7:00 - Why learning Mandarin Chinese is important
10:14 - How a Common Language Helps Ethnic Minorities
11:17 - Introduction to Xinjiang Province
12:14 - How Do Xinjiang people treated a mixed raced American?
13:45 - The Xinjiang Cotton Industry
15:45 - Is there religious freedom in Xinjiang?
17:19 - Is there a genocide in Xinjiang?
19:35 - Truth of Mike Pompeo and US Political System
20:32 - Why is it difficult for the West to Understand China?
21:27 - China’s mistakes in building it international reputation
24:00 - What is one thing you want the world to know about China?
--------------------------
✅ Watch Part 1 of my Interview with Shaun Rein on Hong Kong: • American Shares Truth ...
📚 Shaun's Book "The End of Cheap China" Here: amzn.to/3oQAyPS
📚 Shaun's Book " The War for China's Wallet" amzn.to/3BDJyNy
📚 Shaun's Book "The End of Copycat China" amzn.to/3LY7sbg
✅ Follow Shaun Rein on Twitter: / shaunrein
✅ Connect with Shaun Rein on LinkedIn: / shaunrein
--------------------------
If you'd like to support the channel / 如果你想支持我的频道:
🅿️ Patreon: / cyrusjanssen
☕ Buy me a Coffee: www.buymeacoffee.com/cyrusjan...
🧧 WeChat / 微信: prnt.sc/u3inr6
➡️ PayPal: www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr...
₿ Bitcoin: 32go3tLiu88jibJhWgK3RstmXsW2FFELJ8
--------------------------
✅ Subscribe to my newsletter: cyrusjanssen.substack.com
✅ KZbin: kzbin.info?...
✅ Facebook: / cyrustalkschina
✅ Twitter: / thecyrusjanssen
✅ 西瓜视频：www.ixigua.com/home/446806905...
✅ B站视频：space.bilibili.com/1052709457
✅ 抖音：@温哥华老外
--------------------------
📸 Products I use to Produce my Vlogs:
Camera: amzn.to/2M9pWqx
Tripod: amzn.to/2OUz2dh
Microphone: amzn.to/2u1oJNs
Lighting: amzn.to/2UWkSw8
Drone: amzn.to/3jw1WxF
#china #tibet #xinjiang

[@CyrusJanssen]

✅ Watch Part 1 of my Interview with Shaun Rein on Hong Kong: kzbin.info/www/bejne/bp-7q2lsd9mZopI 📚 Buy Shaun's Book "The End of Cheap China" Here: amzn.to/3oQAyPS 🙏 Interested in supporting the channel? Join our Patreon team: www.patreon.com/cyrusjanssen

[@relaxwhc]

There are many Americans leaving the US due to problems like safety, expensive fees and the attitude of the people 🔥 I think it would be interesting to talk about it. 💥 The European (KZbinr) recently made a video series about homelessness in the US and it looks extremely horrible 💥

[@relaxwhc]

If you want to know about the life and details of inner Mongolia, follow the Mongolian vlogger 多多其木格❤️

[@robertgittings8662]

*Americans to Xinjiang - what we call a False Flag Operation* *🚩🔴 To attack and contain China's Raise - you need a pretext to do so ... - this is one of them*

[@samsliu]

Indian language hasn't been spoken in US and Canada for a long time, it's a genuine cultural genecide. While all the Tibetan and Uyguar are able to speak their languages, Western medium say cultural genecide in China?

[@thinkerr]

Superb interview. Big fan of yours Cyrus!!

[@bruits8960]

I am Tibetan, I used to study in the UK. I once got into an argument with an Italian who said that China had stolen Tibet and that the Tibetans should be independent. (I guess he couldn't tell I am Tibetan by my appearance.) I told him I am Tibetan and that the vast majority of Tibetans in China were very thanks for the Chinese government and that the Chinese government had never tried to eradicate Tibetan culture, but had protected it very well. The Italian was obviously surprised and then said, "That's because all the Tibetans who don't like the CCP have been killed off and people like you are the only left... Anyway, when a real Tibetan stands in front of you and tells you something and you don't believe, I don't think there is any point in continuing this conversation.

[@mangosorbet768]

Spot on. Aboriginal language here were extinct from hundreds to couple. As if west really care about minorities.

[@shawnhennity1769]

It is the typical definition of "brainwashed".

[@jesussonofgod6284]

@@shawnhennity1769 What does it mean?

[@shawnhennity1769]

@@jesussonofgod6284 Sorry. my post was referring Bruins Italian story. that Italian was a textbook definition of brainwashed.

[@weizhang2834]

There are a lot of stupid people in San Francisco Bay Area, even some professors put stickers on their fridge “ free Tibet “ or put on their car body “ free Tibet “, I asked them: do you fking know where Tibet is? The USA propaganda have been crazy they put those fake stories in book stores even those never existed in China history , 优胜美地park book store , Stanford university, UC Berkeley book store , “ tian an men massacre “ those fake stories they made up , force the world believe those fake stories. I am sick of talking with those people who brainwashed but they said I was brainwashed

[@nsng1298]

A few years ago, my family and I were in Venice. As I was walking along the street, an Italian shouted at me, "Free Tibet!". I approached him and shouted back, "I am from Singapore!" But the idiot kept shouting "Free Tibet". The ignorance and racism of some of these Westerners are beyond belief!

[@CyrusJanssen]

Geez that's just shocking...

[@0animalproductworld558]

The reason why bullies are so common in the WEst. They even bully and harm their own race. What do you think lol

[@user-dc4bl1cu2k]

It's called white liberal racism

[@swiftedapple]

I am actually from Karamay, XinJiang, and we were able to travel and study in San Diego, USA, this shows how much the Chinese Government and even the CCP cares about our choice and our life. This is literally the only channel's comment section that I am comfortable speaking this in the US.

[@CyrusJanssen]

Thanks for sharing your perspective and valuable insights!

[@elanor2123]

Why the U.S among all places? And did the ccp pay for ur tuition fees..?

[@wentaofeng5548]

@@elanor2123 Well there are many reasons tho. I, myself, am a Chinese who has spent roughly ten years in US studying and working. Back to your questions. For the first one, many Chinese parents would like to send their kids to US for education (college mainly), bc in their minds, the high-level education offered by US were greater than local schools (I wont consider the education itself is better tho, but from what I have experienced, the certificate from a high-ranked college in US definitely makes it easier to get a job interview in China, somehow big shots in China just feel the certificates from schools like Harvard or MIT are superior than the ones granted by local schools). Also, the College Extrance Exam in China is way too hard if you want to go to a good college (completely different level compared to SAT or ACT, I scored around 2100 in SAT in 2011, which is not too bad and I considered myself a mediocre high school student in China), so many parents decide to choose another way which is having their kids studying aboard. There are actually private agencies and companies to help them rebrand their kids and make their profile shine more in order to get accepted by high-ranked colleges. US definitely isnt their only choice tho, but since it has the most high-ranked colleges, people just tend to conisder it as their first choice. As for whether CCP pay for the tuition....well, not likely. Certainly there are programs about studying aboard offered by government but it is very very difficult to be selected as a candidate, way more difficult than passing the College Entrance Test. You would have to be the best of the best to even apply for the program

[@docvideo93]

If we ever meet in the USA, I would love to buy you a meal and have a conversation with you. - An American

[@shaunrein4708]

Thanks for sharing your firsthand experiences as someone from Xinjiang

[@jmt9107]

My niece who’s Chinese and Caucasian visited Xinjiang 20 years ago felt exactly as Shaun Rein ( an honest journalist and great speaker) that she finally found a place in the world that she physically belonged. Uyghur boys thinking she was one of them tried to woo her. Thank you Cyrus for introducing us to Shaun. I urge folks to keep sharing these programs.

[@shaunrein4708]

Glad your niece and I found the same experience

[@projectpitchfork860]

I hope you mean caucasian as in, from the caucasus like gergions, armenians, azerbaijani, etc. and not caucasian as in white.

[@user-wt4jf8bc1t]

@@projectpitchfork860 As a Chinese , these are no different. We think that Slavs are whiter than white people.

[@samsliu]

Indian language hasn't been spoken in US and Canada for a long time, it's a genuine cultural genecide. While all the Tibetan and Uyguar are able to speak their languages, Western medium say cultural genecide in China?

[@thegreatneess]

"Indian" itself is racist term used by colonizer when they came to new world Native or Indigenous is a better word

[@Shenzhou.]

China even preserve and teach the Mongolian written script to kids in the Inner Mongolia province, whereas the people in (Outer) Mongolia use the Cyrillic script imported from Russia.

[@ireneserrano4570]

exactly... 🤦

[@whatalittlepig]

American won't understand... Because most of them can only speak One language... So in their minds it must meant that learning Chinese you must give up your own language. Like what they did. Most of them are German, Italian, Irish..... And yet they don't speak any of their own language. They are projecting their own cultural genocide image on to the others...

[@vicgravelrides]

hmmm i believe you are wrong on that comment the Inuit language is spoken , have been to canada , US ,china , Japan

[@F_Liu]

China doesn't have a problem with constructive criticisms from Western countries, but before the West points fingers at China, look into itself to see if it is in a high moral position to do so. China doesn't appreciate hypocrisy.

[@Lin-xj1mm]

A saying goes "When you point your finger at someone, three fingers are pointing right back to you."

[@topixfromthetropix1674]

My wife was born in Lhasa. Missionaries and explorers of the 1950's described Tibet as an "open sewer." Because my wife's mother got sick, they had to walk to China to catch a train to Chengdu. The Dalai Lama never built a school, a road, a hospital, a bridge, rail, or airport. China told the DL to stop facilitating spy documents the CIA was smuggling out of Russia. The DL allowed three more spy missions to cross Tibet and the Chinese stopped it. Under the DL, life expectancy for Tibetans was 33 years,...under China, life expectancy is 56 years, and the lowest point in Tibet is 13,000 feet so people have altitude sickness a lot. Peruvians chew coca leaves to combat altitude sickness but there is no coca bushes in China. I haven't been to Xinjiang but I did know and spend time with a Uyghur family who ran a restaurant in Qingdao. Rule of thumb: when the US says terrible things are going on somewhere and that place has oil, natural gas, gold, iron ore, and 122 gemstones, you can use that information as organic fertiliser. ( Wa an Tsing Tao piju, xie xie.)

[@weizhang2834]

Shaun is amazing, he spoke out what our Chinese wanted to tell the world. Thanks Cyrus for your wonderful interview, you are the best !

[@hangtuah888]

Two mistakes he made out of ignorance. One is that Carrie Lam as CEO did not muscle up to the rich tycoons of Hong Kong and the housing issues. In the interview with Liu Xin, she already advised that she has earmarked some additional housing to be provided. Forgot the numbers of apartments to be build. The other is the Chinese government failure to deliver to the world their success and capability. He forgets that humility is a trait that the Chinese cherished and even resort to self deprecation to hide their success. The Chinese government's role is to boast about their achievements but rather to let their progress and development speak for themselves unlike the Western mindset of bragging first achievement second. There is no point triumphing about the Chinese good governance as it is for the Chinese people and not the West. The West and the Westerners demonise China out of their own racism and for that he failed to understand. Lots of the demonising is racism based and nothing more nothing less. Racism is irrational and hideous and you cannot change their mindset and hence the leadership leave it to the FOMA spokesperson to deal with the outside world via their press briefings.

[@weizhang2834]

@@hangtuah888 it was a disease under the British government ruler created before 1997 , but the last 23 years, the local administrator did a bad job too . It was not her fault, but she didn’t care for the poor before the rioters in 2019 . At least didn’t pay more attention to the real problems in HK which the capitalism created

[@shaunrein4708]

You are too kind. Thank you

[@bclu7343]

Absolutely agreed, I had been to both Tibet and Xinjiang, these folks are telling the true facts !

[@shaunrein4708]

Glad to hear your experiences mirror my own in Xinjiang and a Tibet. The truth needs to come out

[@sansan2591]

bullshit

[@user-iz4bu5wc1t]

problem is medias controlled by USA,how u gonna change them?no way.

[@MorrisDugan]

Of course it's always better to believe anonymous writers like you, rather than people who write fact-checked articles based on confirmed eyewitness reports for major publications.

[@PZLong]

@@MorrisDugan hundreds of so-called fact-checked articles which usually funded by same few major cooperative organization with one-sided eyewitness claim with no evidence but only accusation

[@relaxwhc]

If you believe China is a peaceful and progressive country, raise your hand ✋🙋🏻‍♂️👍

[@lincolnteh1963]

✋

[@jostham]

Do you know America is peaceful progressive nation?

[@miaouscleaumonocle]

Shaun mentioned what he saw in a Tibetan primary school: kids taught in Tibetan and in Mandarin. Daniel Dumbrill filmed a secondary school in Tibet: they were taught in Tibetan and in Mandarin, AND they were learning English too. Their local language, the common national language, and the international language. Oh, and in Dumbrill's video, it showed that this program was common for all, for the vast majority of Tibetan kids, but also for the few Han kids, who were taught half in Tibetan too...

[@goingmonotheist783]

First off.. Wow.. A Jew huh? What does he think about what's happened to the Kaifeng Jews? Is he even aware of them? He just casually mentioned Jews in his over 18 religous policy (true ✓) But then again.. Where are the Jews now? Matter of fact, what happened to the local Israel studies department, even at the local university~ I'm tired of you guys just hiding behind " No one said china is perfect".. No one says china should be!! The point isn't that it should be perfect, the point is about having the kind of government that literally decides these kinds of things for people, at the threat of having your organs harvested~ The problem is the catagory of problems all it's problems are falling into~ Throwing the world back to times when communist were busy gulaging people, crushing religion, and micromanaging people down to who you're allowed to be friends with.. How could you so dishonesty say that it's (the 18yr old policy) just because the gov wants people to choose their religion freely!!! You do know that even inviting people to your religion, all and any religions ( ! Even the "approved" ones.. you didn't talk about that policy) is banned/ illegal! What choose?! Who can even offer! And it's also a "policy" that party members CAN'T be part of any religion.. They MUST be athiest. Literally~ Some of the first postures you see on the walls of any immigrations office is literally "keep your religion to yourself".. And every religious establishment's leaders must literally be chosen by local party officials, AND they literally line the whole building, inside and out with political slogans.. There's much much much more than you dishonestly reduced things to seem.. You're a liar.. And how dare you talk about who is and isn't "brainwashed" when the chinese are literally the ones forming their opinions in an information bubble! Why aren't these conversations had on youku?! Why not on weibo? If they are so confident of their convictions, that are totally not just spoon fed.. Why not have a free internet, and see how it goes? Stop lying! All you guys ever talk about is oh.. look how great they've developed the place, and spread oppertunities.. A) No one is complaining about that! It's about the Unnecessary communism based costs! Singapore is authoritarian, and they developed very fast too.. So did korea.. So did malaysia.. so did taiwan.. without crushing people's faiths, micromanaging people's lives, and being sensitive criminals with so much to hide PLUS all the members THEY report purging in corruption scandals. You're from shanghai.. What was the little red mansion scandal about.. and how confident does that make you that people aren't just being gRaped with impunity, like peng shuai, and in xinjiangs labour camps? What's wrong with you! B) Isn't that such a colonial excuse? The same excuse you hear from Israel (you dare talk about israel, and conflate that with what china does to Uyghurs.. the palestinians fire rockets, and fight all the time, plus there are literally no jews in palestine allowed! What's wrong with you!! I'm actually from a muslim background saying this!) When "bad old" israel says "but we turned the desert into an oasis, but we made the only democracy in the middle east, but we produce so much for the world.." How come when israel or the white man says it.. it's not acceptable.. but when the guys who will never give you citizenship, and will cancel your visa in a sec say it.. 🤷‍♂️ you totally accept that!! Which actually brings me to your worst point.. That ohhh everyone is so hard on the ccp.. Are you crazy?! What would the me too movement had done to any politician in the west over allegations of gRape?! How much do minorities complain, get a platform and can riot, and burn down cities without anyone charged.. How many churches were burned down in canada, and what happened to anyone involved?! No one excuses the west because of "culture".. But mr. Not brainwashed wants to literally side step logic, and special plead "culture" every two mins.. And it slides🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️ Look at how the west treats white russia in the media! The ccp is literally a spoiled, over sensitive, criminal sugar daddy.. With an o so fragile heart.. And if you want to see what real "cultural conviction" is.. go to japan, and see how their cancel culture doesn't need to be pushed by the government AT ALL.. You know why? Cause that's ACTUAL "cultural attitude" that lives in a free, unprotected BUBBLE.. Not your dam gov led brainPOLLUTION.. You dishonest, seculaRUST, non humane, bot~ And YES the muslims in china ARE FORCED TO DRINK AND EAT PORK EVEN (depending on where you are).. Because otherwise might put their "behavior score" as "highly religous" and "dangerous".. 😠

[@mhow4967]

@@goingmonotheist783 1/You wrote too much and I have understood very little. This was due your poor written skills. 2/Those things you've told us were 90% nonsense. 3/Cleanse your soul if you have one I live in USA and Canada and I'm not Chinese.

[@goingmonotheist783]

@@mhow4967 1) "Your poor written skills" 🤔 "Written".. (This is after your very small comment was "edited").. 👍 Thanks for your critique~ 2) I wonder how you'd know! Seems from number one you had a problem reading/ understanding what I said.. 🧐 But you can judge 90% of it, without a single example of my so called nonsense.. 3) Cleanse my soul? If I have one?! Says who? Guy who doesn't believe in souls? You a christian? So what you're american? I am too.. And unlike you.. I've actually been in china for five years.. AND 我会说中文。 Unlike this liar in the video.. Matter of fact, most critics of china can speak chinese. Especially the biggest, most agressive ones. All those news agencies he complained about are actually very restrained in what they report/ say. Don't believe me? Compare them to ADV china, Laowhy 86, or china uncensored.. or NTD china in focus.. 😐 Was my english better mr. Educated american.. Or would you rather have this convo in chinese, or arabic.. ~

[@r.gronkowski856]

So you're both from a SCHITHOLE(excuse the C) country governed by SCHITHOLE leaders, SO WHAT?

[@shaunrein4708]

The kids I met in Tibetan indeed were all also learning English. Multi lingual, impressive

[@peterlo3772]

“China is not perfect, but have a plan to improve”. This is a great conclusion.

[@shaunrein4708]

The plan is the key

[@relaxwhc]

If you think the US should deal with its COVID mess instead of bashing and stopping China, raise your hand ✋🙋🏻‍♂️👍

[@1beachworshipper]

✋

[@lincolnteh1963]

✋

[@JB52520]

@sooje nite Bear in mind, I think what the US is doing is horrible. We're interfering with China's technological development, effectively attacking the economy and military, by blacklisting Chinese tech companies and blocking the purchase of EUV machines from ASML. We're engaging the Chinese navy in their own waters to "contain" them. We're trying to weaken China's soft power through negative propaganda. Our tariffs were unnecessary and confrontational, and Biden doubled down on a policy likely tweeted from Trump's gold plated toilet. That's only what we're allowed to know. The full extent of it is probably horrifying. For what it's worth, I'd stop all of this sabotage in an instant, then beg the world for forgiveness.

[@buckduck8936]

@JB in their own waters? China doesnt own the SCS or the indo pacific.

[@r.gronkowski856]

Neither does America buck duck , why are they in the SCS thousands of miles from home, of course you're going to say "freedom of navigation" that's fair if America is just passing by to get to some place else, but PERMANENTLY THERE for 5 decades? how would you feel if someone sent a S. W. A. T team to your back yard with SNIPERS loaded triggers pulled and there PERMANENTLY (freedom of backyard navigation) would you feel THREATENED? LAME American excuse, no leg ta stand on

[@mimiwinarto9164]

It is not about communication. The US simply can't tolerate China's remarkable growth so it will go to any length to curb China's rise. The US is getting desperate and things will deteriorate in the years to come. China just needs to take precautions and be well prepared for the worst.

[@ngheanchoong]

absolutely agree

[@relaxwhc]

The US will be in deep trouble when the world don't use USD currency, so they have to bash China desperately. Well, their end is inevitable 💥

[@ngheanchoong]

@@relaxwhc Chinese digital currency will Compete with US dollar.

[@r.gronkowski856]

Means America will have to pay back all the debts they owe to other countries and no longer be able to print endlessly , that could get UGLY

[@jascforfun7576]

Once China upgrades it's hypersonic nuclear arsanel to guarantee wiping the US from the face of the earth in MAD and updates to a first-strike posture to match the US, then the US mafia military will tippy toe around China as it does with Russia. With the US military rendered impotent by retaliatory annihilation of their homeland, China can wait as the US cannibalises itself through pulocratic rot and a growing hyper-partisan divide that has Americans clawing at each others throats. Easy peasy lemon squesy and "What a beautiful sight to behold". Nancy Pelosi.

[@Earthman99999]

I've visited China four times yet never been to Xinjiang. Looking at other people's travel videos of the region... looks interesting because of the Uighur culture. The camel rides in the desert looks like fun. Maybe one day I hope to be able to go. I'm glad I did get to go to Tibet one time and saw the beginnings of what Mr. Rein said about the improvements to the infrastructure there. I went there in 2014 and saw a lot of construction going on and new roads being paved. The natural scenery there is very impressive.

[@vancat6232]

You surely missed a lot since you didn't have a chance to go to Xinjiang. Amazing place, amazing people, amazing food...

[@shaunrein4708]

Xinjiang is awesome. Try to visit

[@miglu8588]

one of the most interesting part of my hometown Xinjiang is not only the Uighur culture, but the multiple culture together, there you will find the independences of each culture but also the integration among different cultures, I have been in so many countries in Europe, Africa and also in so many provinces in China, Xinjiang is definitely worth to visit, you are welcome.

[@hg1288]

Western countries, led by US consistently accused China of "Genocide" of Muslims in Xinjiang. I found it strange that if that is true, why countries like Pakistan, Saudi and many Islamic countries in the Middle East and elsewhere still maintain relationship with China, some even have very good relationship with China for a long time. I remember once there was a man in Florida wanted to burn the Koran, the Muslims around the World were outrage. If one man intended to burn the Koran raised such emotions, "Genocide" of Muslim People anywhere in the World will be an "Earthquake" event around the World...strangely we only hear from "Christian Countries". Hmmmmmm

[@YWu-ze1op]

I feel these christian countries aren’t Christians. How can a Christian country invade other countries and colonize other countries and enslave their people? How can a Christian country wipe out 90% of native people and take their and build another country? I read the Bible. The Bible says love one another as I have loved you. There would be no WWi and WWII if the Christian countries had adhered to the teaching of the Bible.

[@LW78321]

Exactly!

[@tony37068]

Christians stand up for Muslims, because Mohammed and Jesus are brothers.

[@wenliu5905]

Your analysis is very correct. In fact, people only need to use their brains and think a little bit to expose the lies of the US and Western media about China. But most people in the world are mindless followers. They believe what the media says, without the ability to think independently!

[@liongjiahwong5478]

If America loves Muslims, they don't have to kill one million Iraqi.

[@bogao283]

It is difficult to tell truth specially on certain issues. But you are doing it seriously with heart... A lot of respect to you!

[@helenli7423]

thanks for your people😘😘😘😘😚

[@goingmonotheist783]

First off.. Wow.. A Jew huh? What does he think about what's happened to the Kaifeng Jews? Is he even aware of them? He just casually mentioned Jews in his over 18 religous policy (true ✓) But then again.. Where are the Jews now? Matter of fact, what happened to the local Israel studies department, even at the local university~ I'm tired of you guys just hiding behind " No one said china is perfect".. No one says china should be!! The point isn't that it should be perfect, the point is about having the kind of government that literally decides these kinds of things for people, at the threat of having your organs harvested~ The problem is the catagory of problems all it's problems are falling into~ Throwing the world back to times when communist were busy gulaging people, crushing religion, and micromanaging people down to who you're allowed to be friends with.. How could you so dishonesty say that it's (the 18yr old policy) just because the gov wants people to choose their religion freely!!! You do know that even inviting people to your religion, all and any religions ( ! Even the "approved" ones.. you didn't talk about that policy) is banned/ illegal! What choose?! Who can even offer! And it's also a "policy" that party members CAN'T be part of any religion.. They MUST be athiest. Literally~ Some of the first postures you see on the walls of any immigrations office is literally "keep your religion to yourself".. And every religious establishment's leaders must literally be chosen by local party officials, AND they literally line the whole building, inside and out with political slogans.. There's much much much more than you dishonestly reduced things to seem.. You're a liar.. And how dare you talk about who is and isn't "brainwashed" when the chinese are literally the ones forming their opinions in an information bubble! Why aren't these conversations had on youku?! Why not on weibo? If they are so confident of their convictions, that are totally not just spoon fed.. Why not have a free internet, and see how it goes? Stop lying! All you guys ever talk about is oh.. look how great they've developed the place, and spread oppertunities.. A) No one is complaining about that! It's about the Unnecessary communism based costs! Singapore is authoritarian, and they developed very fast too.. So did korea.. So did malaysia.. so did taiwan.. without crushing people's faiths, micromanaging people's lives, and being sensitive criminals with so much to hide PLUS all the members THEY report purging in corruption scandals. You're from shanghai.. What was the little red mansion scandal about.. and how confident does that make you that people aren't just being gRaped with impunity, like peng shuai, and in xinjiangs labour camps? What's wrong with you! B) Isn't that such a colonial excuse? The same excuse you hear from Israel (you dare talk about israel, and conflate that with what china does to Uyghurs.. the palestinians fire rockets, and fight all the time, plus there are literally no jews in palestine allowed! What's wrong with you!! I'm actually from a muslim background saying this!) When "bad old" israel says "but we turned the desert into an oasis, but we made the only democracy in the middle east, but we produce so much for the world.." How come when israel or the white man says it.. it's not acceptable.. but when the guys who will never give you citizenship, and will cancel your visa in a sec say it.. 🤷‍♂️ you totally accept that!! Which actually brings me to your worst point.. That ohhh everyone is so hard on the ccp.. Are you crazy?! What would the me too movement had done to any politician in the west over allegations of gRape?! How much do minorities complain, get a platform and can riot, and burn down cities without anyone charged.. How many churches were burned down in canada, and what happened to anyone involved?! No one excuses the west because of "culture".. But mr. Not brainwashed wants to literally side step logic, and special plead "culture" every two mins.. And it slides🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️ Look at how the west treats white russia in the media! The ccp is literally a spoiled, over sensitive, criminal sugar daddy.. With an o so fragile heart.. And if you want to see what real "cultural conviction" is.. go to japan, and see how their cancel culture doesn't need to be pushed by the government AT ALL.. You know why? Cause that's ACTUAL "cultural attitude" that lives in a free, unprotected BUBBLE.. Not your dam gov led brainPOLLUTION.. You dishonest, seculaRUST, non humane, bot~ And YES the muslims in china ARE FORCED TO DRINK AND EAT PORK EVEN (depending on where you are).. Because otherwise might put their "behavior score" as "highly religous" and "dangerous".. 😠

[@shaunrein4708]

The truth must prevail. The world needs to be balanced on China

[@goingmonotheist783]

@@shaunrein4708 The problem isn't being balanced.. the problem is that the negative is exactly what the ccp doesn't actually want to be honest about, or change.. The "balance" you're talking about is to just say without stating the critical specifics: china has "problems". China has 1.4 billion people.. that's alot of problems in china~ China isn't perfect, but hey, check out the bright side.. No one ignores, nor wants to ignore the good side.. Everyone recognizes the advance, it's all about the cost.. And you KNOW they are NOT about "being balanced".. They're about the sandwich method of sugar coating.. and not even getting specific about the bad in the middle.. And ofcourse, good exaple is that you yourself didn't address my comment.. You didn't talk about the kaifeng jews.. Did ya?

[@Lu-yg5pr]

@@goingmonotheist783 copy and paste 💀 . Why are u crying ?

[@HappyDT]

Great interview with Shaun who shared his real life experiences on the ground about Xinjiang and Tibet.

[@sword7872]

Yes his first hand knowledge makes those US politicians using the genocide accusation look like ignorant fools.

[@goingmonotheist783]

First off.. Wow.. A Jew huh? What does he think about what's happened to the Kaifeng Jews? Is he even aware of them? He just casually mentioned Jews in his over 18 religous policy (true ✓) But then again.. Where are the Jews now? Matter of fact, what happened to the local Israel studies department, even at the local university~ I'm tired of you guys just hiding behind " No one said china is perfect".. No one says china should be!! The point isn't that it should be perfect, the point is about having the kind of government that literally decides these kinds of things for people, at the threat of having your organs harvested~ The problem is the catagory of problems all it's problems are falling into~ Throwing the world back to times when communist were busy gulaging people, crushing religion, and micromanaging people down to who you're allowed to be friends with.. How could you so dishonesty say that it's (the 18yr old policy) just because the gov wants people to choose their religion freely!!! You do know that even inviting people to your religion, all and any religions ( ! Even the "approved" ones.. you didn't talk about that policy) is banned/ illegal! What choose?! Who can even offer! And it's also a "policy" that party members CAN'T be part of any religion.. They MUST be athiest. Literally~ Some of the first postures you see on the walls of any immigrations office is literally "keep your religion to yourself".. And every religious establishment's leaders must literally be chosen by local party officials, AND they literally line the whole building, inside and out with political slogans.. There's much much much more than you dishonestly reduced things to seem.. You're a liar.. And how dare you talk about who is and isn't "brainwashed" when the chinese are literally the ones forming their opinions in an information bubble! Why aren't these conversations had on youku?! Why not on weibo? If they are so confident of their convictions, that are totally not just spoon fed.. Why not have a free internet, and see how it goes? Stop lying! All you guys ever talk about is oh.. look how great they've developed the place, and spread oppertunities.. A) No one is complaining about that! It's about the Unnecessary communism based costs! Singapore is authoritarian, and they developed very fast too.. So did korea.. So did malaysia.. so did taiwan.. without crushing people's faiths, micromanaging people's lives, and being sensitive criminals with so much to hide PLUS all the members THEY report purging in corruption scandals. You're from shanghai.. What was the little red mansion scandal about.. and how confident does that make you that people aren't just being gRaped with impunity, like peng shuai, and in xinjiangs labour camps? What's wrong with you! B) Isn't that such a colonial excuse? The same excuse you hear from Israel (you dare talk about israel, and conflate that with what china does to Uyghurs.. the palestinians fire rockets, and fight all the time, plus there are literally no jews in palestine allowed! What's wrong with you!! I'm actually from a muslim background saying this!) When "bad old" israel says "but we turned the desert into an oasis, but we made the only democracy in the middle east, but we produce so much for the world.." How come when israel or the white man says it.. it's not acceptable.. but when the guys who will never give you citizenship, and will cancel your visa in a sec say it.. 🤷‍♂️ you totally accept that!! Which actually brings me to your worst point.. That ohhh everyone is so hard on the ccp.. Are you crazy?! What would the me too movement had done to any politician in the west over allegations of gRape?! How much do minorities complain, get a platform and can riot, and burn down cities without anyone charged.. How many churches were burned down in canada, and what happened to anyone involved?! No one excuses the west because of "culture".. But mr. Not brainwashed wants to literally side step logic, and special plead "culture" every two mins.. And it slides🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️ Look at how the west treats white russia in the media! The ccp is literally a spoiled, over sensitive, criminal sugar daddy.. With an o so fragile heart.. And if you want to see what real "cultural conviction" is.. go to japan, and see how their cancel culture doesn't need to be pushed by the government AT ALL.. You know why? Cause that's ACTUAL "cultural attitude" that lives in a free, unprotected BUBBLE.. Not your dam gov led brainPOLLUTION.. You dishonest, seculaRUST, non humane, bot~ And YES the muslims in china ARE FORCED TO DRINK AND EAT PORK EVEN (depending on where you are).. Because otherwise might put their "behavior score" as "highly religous" and "dangerous".. 😠

[@sword7872]

@@goingmonotheist783 listening to the msm lies is meant to make you very angry. You should ask why are these people not angry? Which perfect society did you come from anyway and what right does it give you to be the judge?

[@goingmonotheist783]

@@sword7872 What msm lies~ You can't just claim someone is lying without evidence! ESPECIALLY if you're literally talking about someone who INFACT is secretive, censoring, and isn't some kinda magical exception from any rules.. communists always go on social engineering bs that often involves horrific bs.. Literally all the time. And the question isn't why am I angry mr. High on soma~ The question is who labotamized your capacity to be angry when you should.. What fantasy world have you been brain-polluted into, where people criticize the ccp, and not their own govs too?!!?!? What lala land have you obliviously slid into, where we don't also get angry at our govs when they do bad stuff too?! What kinda of regressive, backwards, isolationist, non human mentality are you using to just say "mind your own business"?!?!! Those guys aren't angry cause they're literally on the "whatever, it's not happening to me" pill.. And foriegners are actually treated VERY DIFFERENTLY from local chinese.. and they know that very well.. Why are YOU so comfortable with consequential dishonesty?! You think helping people get away with crimes is ok, as long as they also SO CALLED make "economic development" in a region where that's literally not special AT ALL.. In a location that was ALWAYS RICH "mainland china"?! What's wrong with you? You think it helps things get better to be a b? That just gets gRaped, then has money thrown at her, and is told to be ready again whenever~

[@sword7872]

@@goingmonotheist783 if media doesn't provide evidence they are lying. The uighur genocide has already been debunked.

[@ranigao2046]

"If you are a school child in the US, you have to learn English." I cannot agree more.

[@gelinrefira]

You mean an Italian American kid learning English in an American school is not cultural genocide? You don't say...

[@winniefrain968]

It is a great interview and really appreciate the true insights of China. People do need to go to China and see the Today's China, I genuinely think that it is one of the best countries to live in, much much better than some of the dominating Western Countries.

[@shaunrein4708]

Appreciate the kind feedback and support

[@s.vortex]

The controversy around learning Mandarin is the dumbest thing I've heard. I'm from Indonesia and we also have hundreds of local languages. The only way we could communicate with each other is through the common language (lingua franca), that is the Indonesian language, which is taught to every kid at schools.

[@ronlyon4645]

even in indonesia, it's mandatory to learn mandarin, english, and bahasa indonesia since the elementary school until senior high school.

[@Shenzhou.]

I heard that during Soeharto's rule of Indonesia, the Indonesian government regarded the Chinese Indonesians as a problem (Masalah Cina) and banned expressions of Chinese culture through language, religion, and traditional festivals in Indonesia. Also, the ethnic Chinese living in Indonesia were pressured to adopt Indonesian-sounding names.

[@bv2011]

@@Shenzhou. what you heard is true and i m the lost generation grew up in that dark era. My generation lost the proficiency in mandarin as the teaching of Mandarin was illegal. I sometimes feel sad of mainland Chinese ignorantly judged us harshly for not speaking mandarin fluent enough. If only they knew what we have gone through.

[@itsthepowerofmusic]

Yes, and no one said Indonesian government do cultural genocide to Javanese, Sundanese, etc...and if China did the same thing it is a cultural genocide... RIP logic...

[@ronlyon4645]

@@Shenzhou. many people believe soeharto is the west puppet installed in order to curb spread of socialism in the country. Because when soekarno (1st President) was in power, he accept every faction including communism at the time and known quite close to beijing rather than washington.

[@estevencamacho]

When "patriotic" Americans start talking about what they don't really know about regarding human rights, I bring up the topic of the book The 1619 Project and they get all defensive about our history. Such hypocrites.

[@ngheanchoong]

a illiterate person shout loudest defending himself to cover his shortcoming

[@truthseeker000000]

This is an excellent interview with Shaun Rein. Mr Rein is highly respected for his insights on social, economic and political issues regarding China. Shedding light and speaking the truth about the false narratives perpetuated by so many Western media outlets about Tibet, Hong Kong and Xinjiang is so important. The US has SO MUCH to gain from developing a great friendship and mutual understand with China. The work you are doing with your channel is so important in bridging such a friendship and respect for both China and the USA.

[@shaunrein4708]

Appreciate the kind feedback and support 🤝

[@maggiema2777]

Thank you both for this interview, not only for the rest of the world to know the truth but also for a Han Chinese like me to know more about my own country, i have never realized how much i have taken things for granted till the day I left China and moved to UK 8 years ago, I am shocked about how people were brain washed by western media in terms of China and Chinese people, I really hope people not to make comment about China till you get there and see it with your own eyes, we are so grateful for what our government has done for us more than ever and move back to China next year will be a dream come true for me and my family!

[@Mike-eb5si]

@Luciuswolf yet you don't comment about the degree of lies in the west. It's easy to point at someone for speeding 20 over the limit, whom of which is speeding 50 over the limit.... idiotic...

[@maggiema2777]

@Luciuswolf They don’t need to tell you anything, as matter of fact we don’t need to be told by anyone, see with your own eyes, when one government spend all their tax payer ‘s money on war and the other spend on infrastructure and improving people life, the difference is there and the fact is fact!

[@cohendarwin5365]

@Luciuswolf like biden know when russia will attack Ukraine. Even putin dont know the exact date.

[@shawnlu9637]

@Luciuswolf Your attitude is just a perfect example how brainwashed you are by your media with Hatred.

[@shawnlu9637]

@LuciuswolfGovernments are doing the similar shit all over the world, but actually CCP is relatively a better one, at least she is trying shit to improve, not like the western system treating their people like brainless shit and tell big lies to make other countries looking bad and to invade others.

[@zeissiez]

As a Chinese proverb goes: “Pointing to a deer and saying it’s a horse”, those who don’t believe in China will never do, even you put evidences right in front of them.

[@lionliu9272]

赵高式发言~

[@Shenzhou.]

Yes, this Chinese proverb _“Pointing to a deer and saying it’s a horse”_ (指鹿曰馬) has even influenced the Japanese word for _"fool"_ which is _baka_ (馬鹿), basically the characters for horse 馬 and deer 鹿.

[@zeissiez]

@@Shenzhou. Good to know 😉

[@dandanbroken8459]

@@Shenzhou. 哈哈，我还奇怪日本人怎么把“马鹿”理解成“笨蛋”，其实原意就是有权势的人可以迫使其他按照他的意思来行动，迫使他们战队选边站（贬义）

[@Shenzhou.]

@@dandanbroken8459我是从看了很多日本动漫用这词来骂人，就慢慢发现这词的来源自中国的《史记·秦始皇本纪》中“指鹿为马”的故事。

[@margaretbairan6353]

I hope this discussion will make more people know about china from people who actually live in china and talk about their experiences

[@tottiwulezhou]

Any Tibet and Xinjiang rebellion should be suppressed! Be Chinese Patriots or Be Perished! NO EXCEPTIONS!

[@peterlim1972]

@@tottiwulezhou Oh, you mean like the January 6th rebellion on Capital Hill? Those were suppressed all right. Perhaps the Chinese should get some lessons from the Americans.

[@Shenzhou.]

@@tottiwulezhou Tibet was part of China since *800* years ago, back when the Mongols conquered the Kingdom of Thibet and Song Dynasty China and incorporated those territory into Yuan Dynasty China. The Manchu conquerors did a similar thing with Tibet centuries later during the Qing Dynasty China. Just look up maps of Yuan Dynasty and Qing Dynasty China and Tibet was clearly part of Chinese history. Xinjiang was part of China since 200 BC during the Han Dynasty, where it was known as Xiyu (西域) _"Western Regions"_

[@tottiwulezhou]

@@peterlim1972 nah, American learned from China.

[@tottiwulezhou]

@@Shenzhou. Completely agree! We Chinese will not tolerate any liberal thoughts in Tibet and Xinjiang. Respect our history or you get perished!

[@bengjongoh3215]

This is the real China expert and insider. Shaun Rein gives a balance, fair and insightful view of China. Thumps up 👍

[@shaunrein4708]

Very kind of you 🙏🙏🙏

[@tonylaugoogle6322]

One of the best unbiased interview I have had watched. This world needs more people like Shaun n Cyrus to present reliable information to the western world.

[@shaunrein4708]

You made my day with your comments. Thanks

[@omg-bh4pg]

Money might have been paid for this unbiased point of view.

[@wilwps1382]

Thanks to you guys for speaking the truth. Salute to Shaun for telling the truth from your own experiences. I have been to both Tibet and Xijiang myself, I felt exactly the same as you do. Westerners who I have travelled with were impressed what they saw in both places.

[@swiftedapple]

I am from xinjiang lmao, I love it it is so beautiful and comfy

[@papabearspitz557]

You need First hand experience on what's happening in Tibet, Xinjiang and Mainland China to understand what these places has improved since CPC has put emphasis for all its people. How could Western countries talk and teach other countries how to govern their own people without understanding their unique needs.

[@jsdklfjdskdfsdf2891]

@@swiftedapple lmao. u must have a blast with tackling the haters.

[@shaunrein4708]

Glad that you have similar firsthand experiences to my own. Appreciate the kind feedback

[@MbisonBalrog]

Wait so no concentration camps.

[@ethanngo11]

What you guys are doing is so important for world peace. Our government in Australia is so embarrassing blindly following the US narrative

[@jascforfun7576]

As an Australian, it is my experience that our political and media establishment have been captured by US government and special interests. Relying on the US for our security, we are not truely independant and have to subordinate our foreign policy to the US. At the start of 2020, the US said, "You are with us or against us" with Prof Mearsheimer (Chicago Uni) even saying directly to our faces, that we'd pick security over prosperity. The "hate/fear China" media propaganda has been non-stop and escalating, resulting in over 80% of the population having a negative view of China.

[@longcimb]

@@jascforfun7576 80 per cent is at almost peak. Other than war, the trend is going to improve. The media can only this much to convert the hillbillies, but when they see the real China, things will pan out. Everything his cyclical...it goes into a depression then it goes up. WM can say they achieve it's objective but not for world peace for sure. Maybe it time for another global war......too much complacency. Chinese are practical people but if it's push to a corner, the fightback will be ferocious

[@MarkYeung1]

The image of the Chinese government among Australian people is currently rather poor. But there are many ways for Beijing to improve it.

[@shawnhennity1769]

@@MarkYeung1 "The image of the Chinese government among Australian people is currently rather poor'. It is reciprocal. The image of the Australian government among Chinese people is currently also rather poor, maybe poorer. To be frank, it is not necessary to win Aussies' image. Australia is nothing to China. Basically, Australia is a lapdog. Look Morrison's performance during G20, he is virtually invisible.

[@steventan2550]

Anglo-Saxon countries (US, Canada, UK & Australia) will continue to spew "Anglo-Saxon Nonsense"

[@victorong8207]

What if these minorities in China were taught English instead of Mandarin, would the western world also label this as “cultural genocide” ? Here in the Philippines, .English is taught as a second language but no western world is accusing us of “ cultural genocide”. Moreover, we have many minorities with their own dialects who are mandated to learn “Tagalog”,our national language, but nobody ever accused us of “cultural genocide”.

[@LifeHacksProducts]

Not yet. The US will come to any other rising nations in the SE after she is done with China.

[@cz8935]

Actually both Chinese and English are in the curriculum of compulsory education in China. In minority regions, they need also learn their native languages. For example in Tibet, they have three language courses, namely Chinese, Tibatan and English.

[@gelinrefira]

The irony is that many Chinese are taught English on top of Mandarin and maybe their local language like the Tibetan example. Is China committing cultural genocide on their own cultural by teaching English? Hilarious...

[@LW78321]

Exactly!

[@ErniJuliaKok]

Great talk show. Thank you for you both. I also have the same experience when I was visiting Shanghai many years ago. I thought they speak Japanese. Pûtōnghuà is absolutely needed. Not only in China or the United States, but in any other country, for instance in my country Indonesia, we have Bahasa Indonesia as our common language for we have about 700 different dialects, so we can communicate with each other.

[@shaunrein4708]

Shanghainese really did sound like Japanese when I first hear it.

[@cheesypuffs1342]

also, it's kinda weird how inner mongolia, the peeps can speak mongolia & mandarin. but the outer mongolians speak Russian. same with how Tibetans in Tibet speak tibetan & mandarin, but Tibetans in Dharamshala speak English Natives in Canada & the US also speak English, yet MSM says cultural genocide is happening in china? wtf?

[@mangosorbet768]

Aboriginal in Australia speaks English. Hundred Aboriginal languages only couple left to date.

[@Speedz1980]

@@mangosorbet768 and how many of those Aboriginal language are taught in school?

[@freakmoister]

@@Speedz1980 zero

[@mangosorbet768]

@@Speedz1980 zero, finding written resource is like archaeology discovery. I am in language book industry. Up till today, aboriginal still fighting fir their native title rights. So all these western claims on their righteousness is all BS n make my blood boil. The worse is ppl tolerate n still latch to to the democracy propaganda.

[@Shenzhou.]

China has even preserved the Mongolian written script in Inner Mongolia province. Whereas the people in Outer Mongolian use the Cyrillic script by Russia.

[@F_Liu]

Enjoyed the first part of this discussion very much, look forward to Shaun's valuable input, thank you so much both for spreading the truths about China.

[@shaunrein4708]

Appreciate the kind feedback and support

[@hujustin1156]

Thank you so much Cyrus to invite Shaun to share his experience and opinions here. Tibet is such a beautiful place and has been developed so much in last few decades. The policy for minority tribes are so good there which made Han, majority, considered themselves as “ 2nd level citizens”. The western propagation blinds the vision of so many people in the world, which is not good for anyone, for those misleading western media will lose the trust as lies are lies. Thank you again for both of you.

[@shaunrein4708]

Tibet is stunning. Thank you for the kind words

[@mliu662]

Fifteen years ago, when a professor at the University of Toronto told me that religions have done more harm than good in history, I didn't fully comprehend. I was an active member of a Christian church. Now I totally agree with him. Religions separate people, creating more duality and conflicts. Religious people tend to shut themselves up from testimonies of other religions and spiritual practices. They become so convinced of their own god that so often they are bigoted. When looking at western media bias towards China, (I'm afraid the majority of participants would claim themselves Christians) I seriously wonder how much they have learned from the Bible.

[@WilhelminaRa]

Its mostly the monotheist religions ,which are the big troublemakers,since intolerance is written into their codex, even though the jews can be excluded from that, because they at least dont take everybody into their ranks, its hard to convert to the jewish relligion, and if you manage that, only your child and only if the mother is jewish,can be a full jew. While Christinas and muslims take everybody and tell everyone else,that they are wrong, at least the majority of those people are peacefull, but sadly it is easier to find an religious extremist among those two groups than in Daoism or Buddhism. allthough Buddhists had a relatively violent history (fighting monks) in Japan for example they got so powerfull they tried to overthrow the shoguns and Oda Nobunaga had to crush those Buddhist power by inviting christian preachers (also to get the rifles from Portugal) and than he fought them off, after that he let the christians to be supressed as well, because he feared nad all of his predecessors too, the potential of extremism (Look up the Shimabara Rebellion). So many wars fought in the name of God, pretty idiotic ,since they all preach peace and harmony, but fail at coexistance...

[@hangtuah888]

Are you nuts? The Christian church is premised on the virgin birth of a child. Who in the right frame of mind and understood science would believe in this arid nonsense. China adopts Article 18 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights pertaining to religion not because of promoting religion but to ensure those who chose to believe in faiths are allowed to do so. Hence not allowing minor to adopt a religion until they are sufficiently mature enough to do so. It is using Article 18 as a shield and not a sword. That is how it should be.

[@thisiskevin1000]

They should look into the plight of Christians in the Middle East and India

[@sallyparker9278]

Religion was a way the ruling class used to control the population. The whole religion thing is that you peasants can get me now (revolt & kill me) but you will go to hell after you die, hence all rulers claimed they are decedents of heaven or god appointed or something like that.

[@hangtuah888]

@@sallyparker9278 With due respect, do you mean "descendants?"

[@pollyli2675]

Thank you Cyrus and Shuan for helping us to have a true picture of what's been going in China. I love to hear truthful report. Well done👍guys

[@TOMAS-lh4er]

A REAL day of justice is coming for the CCP leaders, We will see then which side of EVIL , that Cyrus is on or not !! The CCP will be gone before the youngest of current generations, but what is happening wont disappear,

[@shaunrein4708]

Greatly appreciate the kind feedback

[@WORLDPEACE2628]

You are one brave man for speaking the truth!

[@shaunrein4708]

The truth must come out

[@dr.paulwang1421]

Love your commentaries, not just because you shared with your audience the realities, but even more so that you are a peacemaker!

[@CyrusJanssen]

Thank you Dr Wang

[@hendycai2881]

Hi, I'm from Indonesia of Chinese descendant. My gramps are from a village in Guangdong Province, Hakka People. 10km away from his village, there is another Hakka Village that speak a different Hakka Dialect which I have difficulty understanding it 🤣 Same language, different dialect, makes a whole different in the world. This is a concept that most westerner having trouble to grasp, especially US, cause you can travel all around America, and even though some have different accent, its still quite understandable. Indonesia also have similar variety with China. We also got lots of tribes with different languages, therefore all Indonesian are required to learn Indonesia's national language (the language also call Indonesian in English 😂)

[@therealarchstanton3343]

Good people, Hakka 👍

[@allyntam9271]

It's not just minorities that learn Mandarin as a second language in China. To a large number, if not a majority of Han Chinese, Mandarin is actually a second language for them. Their home dialect is their first language.

[@questworldmatrix]

I know, right? That's why there's Cantonese, Hokkien, Shanghainese, Taiwanese, etc.

[@nonyabizness997]

@@questworldmatrix Taiwanese IS Hokkienese, as most "Taiwanese"-speakers' ancestors were from Hokkien.

[@yishenshiyi9011]

That's different. For example, Tibetan, Mongolian and Uyghur are completely different from Mandarin, including characters and languages. If both parties have not learned the language and characters of the other party, they will not be able to communicate with each other at all. the local dialect and Mandarin use the same Chinese characters, but their accents are just a little different. Even if a person meets someone outside the province, he can understand what the other person says.

[@meditadz]

What an excellent interview! I am gonna buy Shaun's book - "The end of cheap China"

[@shaunrein4708]

Hope you enjoy the read. Thanks!!!

[@Strategy_Analysis]

I went to Xinjiang about 10 years ago when I was living in China. You can see and hear both languages, and the local culture was everywhere. Went to Wulumuqi and Kashi.

[@DannyChean]

To people who accused minorities being taught Chinese as cultural genocide, how do you feel if hispanic immigrants settling in California have zero access to English education and only speak Spanish? What kind of opportunities would they to better their lives?

[@ffbeexaid4509]

Being taugｈt Chinese is genocide? Wow how stupid can people be these days?　🤦‍♀️

[@omg-bh4pg]

USA lets everyone raise their family as they want to.

[@mhow4967]

Our ancestors were Hakka and we are proud to speak to speak Mandarin too. I didn't speak English until I was 24. I grew up with French language and culture. I'm happy. Really happy.

[@plaw9188]

Hi Cyrus thank you for another informative video, it’s so amazing to see two Americans seemingly know more about China than most China experts in the west, talking about Xinjiang and Tibet, two remote areas of China. I can attest to one of Shaun’s statement; he said the Uighurs do drink beer. In 2019, I spent 36 hours traveling from Toronto to Urumqi, and stayed 8 days there mostly in the small lodging places run by either Uighurs or Kazakhs, very friendly people, and I drink beer with them. I also have plans to visit Tibet, if not for the pandemics, I would have been there last year. I will definitely buy Shaun’s books to read during the long flights to China.

[@Shenzhou.]

My favorite go-to speakers for knowledge about geopolitics are _Martin Jacques, Kishore Mabubani, Zhang Weiwei_ and _Eric Li._

[@shaunrein4708]

Appreciate the kind feedback and support

[@gunsumwong3948]

Great contribution to understanding of Tibet and Xinjiang. Although by default the western media would dismiss this video as they cannot face the truth. Whatever China does it will be evident in the end. Many foreigners like to separate Chinese into Han, Tibetan, Uygur and others but inside China everyone looks upon oneself as just Chinese. From my own exposure to the Chinese history and culture I know China has no racism. It never had because this is against the ancestor teaching. I think Chinese culturally don't sell themselves because it is more important to control one's own self than influencing other people's view. That is why China never interferes with other nation's internal affairs. If the west choose to believe their own version of truth it is not China's problem.

[@shaunrein4708]

Many Journalists have dismissed. They don't want to air the truth

[@lucleoni]

Great video Cyrus, very honest and interesting insights. The world needs more people like you guys.

[@shaunrein4708]

Much appreciated

[@siamcharm7904]

superb interview. shaun is one of the few westerners who actually knows something about china.

[@shaunrein4708]

That's very kind of you, thank you

[@siamcharm7904]

@@shaunrein4708 i'm a big fan. H64 hbs70 exeter 60 me no like sps phuket.

[@LW78321]

​@@shaunrein4708 I appreciate the work you're doing Shaun! Thank you!

[@ew5153]

I relocated to an English speaking country many years ago and had to learn the language in order to communicate. Learning a new skill in this case a language isn’t “cultural genocide”. Base on that logic people shouldn’t be allowed to speak any language other than the one they learn at home because “cultural genocide”. It was totally normal speaking my parents language at home while learning English at school. The western countries thirst for power is leading into desperate measures to keep subjugating and controlling the world.

[@bv2011]

Their argument started to sound absurd.

[@syncmaster915n]

Well said!

[@fredflinstone6601]

Then your native language will fade out in your family. That’s a fact. Happened to me and ours

[@ew5153]

@@fredflinstone6601 I still speak it very fluently.

[@user-rb7us2qm7c]

@@fredflinstone6601 not necessarily. there are plenty of bilingual or multilingual people in the world

[@miglu8588]

I am from Xinjiang, and grew up with so many different minorities in Xinjiang. One point of Shaun that I cannot agree with him anymore, biggest problem of the misunderstanding of China in western is that the communication and international propaganda are missing. Whenever we see our president Xi in international Media, is always in an extremely official way. Even in China, the president Xi doesnot do some personable or down-to-earth interviews, pity of it. Ever time when I expressed my views of reality of China in europe, most of the people were shocked because they have never heard of that. But as I brought some of my friends from Germany to Xinjiang for vacation in 2019, they were really shocked and told me the whole time that they felt being deceived since childhood in Germany 🤣 because they saw a totally different Xinjiang, which has been demonized for so many years in western. But, I mean, when I come out to tell people the truth, most of the keyboarder (键盘侠) will say that I am brainwashed by China, this is one of the biggest "joke" I have ever heart 🤣 I am not brainwashed, its the one, who just believes everything without any hesitation, is brainwashed. Thank you very much sharing this video, hope more and more people will have a real and true view of China in next years.

[@LW78321]

Good on you for bringing your western friends to visit and see XJ for their own eyes!

[@kl9518]

Great interview and knowledge by Shaun. His last answer about the Chinese is to do with the Chinese culture. Chinese always strive to improve. It is imbedded in us by our parents and ancestors. Eileen Gu's grandmother wanted her to do better in education after winning so many medals. It is not negative criticism, but to always to move forward and many Chinese children respect their elders for that. But the West has become stagnant, self-righteous and rebellious, dwelling on pity and problems.

[@shaunrein4708]

Much appreciated

[@electromega3077]

6:40 English and other other foreign languages are also taught to Tibetan and other minorities in schools. So If I follow the logic of MSM, the Anglo-Saxon countries are also participating the cultural genocide in Tibet. In fact, they are committing cultural genocide not only in Tibet, but also all around the world.

[@georgecostanza2695]

That is some very enlightening insight, really enjoyed hearing about Shaun’s (first hand) experience.

[@shaunrein4708]

Thanks so much

[@midwestmeiliguo]

Cyrus, I absolutely LOVE this video ❤️ ❤️ ❤️ ❤️ ❤️ ❤️!!! But I have to disagree with Shaun on his point that the Chinese government didn't do a good job at communicating with the world. If China is still the dirt poor country over 40 years ago, the Western government and media wouldn't be attacking China so shamelessly and viciously. The truth is that the Chinese government has done such an incredible job improving the Chinese people's life which makes the Western countries look bad, that they have to deflect their own failures by brainwashing their own people.

[@dianaxu7737]

Part 1& 2 of the interviews with Shaun Rein are the best video ever on KZbin. Really hope to hear more Mr. Rein’s inside about the true china.

[@shaunrein4708]

You made my day. Thank you 🤝🤝🤝

[@amyliu7046]

Learning bi-languages widen the perspectives and provide more opportunities. In XJ province, Ugur students are granted extra 150 points in the same China GaoKao exam in getting Into same Universities than Han ethnic. For Example, to get into Beijing University, Han Student need 600 points, while Ugur students only need 450 Points. Once they receive the Universities education, they indeed have more opportunities in XJ and other places. It was the case of my own classmate. I suppose same situation in Tibet, although I am a XJ person. Because that is ethnic minorities areas development policy in China.

[@jasminwu3353]

Exactly to say, Ugur students can get extra 150 bonus points, so that they can have access the same majors in the same universities with less 150 points than the Han students.

[@amyliu7046]

@@jasminwu3353correct👍🏻 thank you for clarify😊

[@r.gronkowski856]

Exact translation of "Gao Kao" is "high level exam" (Gao is high) (Kao is exam)

[@shaunrein4708]

Yes, China gives extra points to minorities so they need a lower score to get into top universities. It's a good system

[@Lin-xj1mm]

This is also a reason why as a Han Chinese, I'm so jealous of minority groups....

[@Nano-nb8ep]

When I was in Kenya, the locals told me that the pay gets doubled or tripled if you can speak Chinese, so everybody there wants to learn Chinese. I think the situation is similar in Tibet or Xinjiang.

[@soegiartonugroho]

@@magicsmurfy you can become cia bot

[@Nano-nb8ep]

@@magicsmurfy US workers are fighting to get $15/hr minimum pay. Couldn't even get that passed. In the meantime, the poor gets poorer and the richer gets richer. By the way, Trump's grand children and Obama's daughter all speak Chinese. They must know something you don't.

[@MarkYeung1]

@@Nano-nb8ep$15 US/hour? Chinese workers will be happy to earn that.

[@shawnhennity1769]

@@MarkYeung1 Just checked, average $11, many states only $7.25, no change in last 30 years.

[@Nano-nb8ep]

@@shawnhennity1769 $15/hr gives you much better living in China than in US. They have universal health care, low drug cost, low college tuition, great public transportation (no need for car), .... the list goes on. This is why Chinese GDP passed US GDP in 2014 based on purchasing power.

[@CyfClaudia]

As a Chinese born and grew up in China, I used to study in the UK. Whenever I disagree with some westerns on subjects of China, they always call me brainwashed, even if they have never been to China, speak no Chinese hence all their knowledge is from the Western English broadcasters.

[@yeolblt]

People who lack basic logical thinking always believe they are correct. That's a major problem in our world. Very few are open minded and willing to learn more about the truth.

[@stonejames135]

Shaun is so brave speaking out what he has seen or experienced the reality and truth that most of the western media never ever want to let the westerners know!

[@shaunrein4708]

It's sad the mainstream media won't tell the truth about China. Thanks for the kind support

[@kwchan3950]

Cyrus and Shaun, I want to thank you with all my heart for your Candidate analysis and insight regarding Xinjiang and Tibet. The segments (part 1 and this one) are the best I have read. I only wish people can realize and recognize what China has done for these part of the world. Wonder there are ways to send the messages to more western medias to correct their bias opinions. I have also notice during the reposting of riveter Olympic mist often the TV channels omitted the medal counts for China ever even though China has more medals than others countries! The way they criticize Eileen is unfair! United States are formed by many from different people from different countries, and also there are many did exactly what Eileen did, but they were not mentioned! It’s so unfair!

[@MarkYeung1]

Chinese media are also known to be extremely biased. This is a global problem, not just a western problem.

[@Shenzhou.]

@@MarkYeung1 Chinese media draw their data and statistics from primary sources, whereas the Western MSM media paint a negative image of China, even though their articles are unsubstantiated by sources.

[@saretgnasoh7351]

@@MarkYeung1 nah, the biased in Chinese media is still far below western media. Even Western media often use toxic fake news

[@MarkYeung1]

@@saretgnasoh7351 have you heard about CGTN? What do you know about it?

[@MarkYeung1]

@@saretgnasoh7351 "US pushing Ukraine for war with Russia" What do you think?

[@georwoogle]

Wonderful and informative interview. Now I have known Shaun and I appreciate his insight. Thank you, Cyrus.

[@olliejohnson1733]

Thank you Cyrus and Shaun for your honest and sincere exchange of experience of your life in China.

[@shaunrein4708]

Appreciate the kind feedback and support

[@haibin356]

Cyrus, as a Chinese, I highly appropriate your work that shares your unbiased insight with the English audience! Thank you so much; I hope China-US can coexist on the world stage and bring progress to human civilization!

[@2-cent]

Finally, someone says something positive about China. Thank Cyrus and Shaun. China is not perfect for sure. Every Chinese knows we still have a lot of shortcomings. That's why we are working hard to make China better. However, what most western medias say about China are wrong and malaciou.

[@jmjt3709]

More and more people around the world realizing that there are many lies spread on China and are investigating further to find the truth. 中国加油！

[@shaunrein4708]

Appreciate the kind feedback and support

[@ionvrabie375]

Compare to USA China is perfect, GOD bless China, GOD bless Chinese people.

[@boonteoh2346]

Truth is harder to savour and accept. Lies and propagandas gives the audience something of a thrill when repeated often. All China want is to be respected and compete on the same level as US and the West. Go China!!🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳

[@horridohobbies]

Can anyone name one country that is perfect? China is much less imperfect than other major countries such as USA, UK, France, Russia, Germany, Japan, etc. The Chinese people are happy with their governance, and they are proud of their country's achievements. Nothing else matters.

[@TonyOei]

Finally some reliable information concerning Xinjiang and Tibet. We get here in Europe too many lies & fake news abt it. Thank you for sharing. Great vid.

[@shaunrein4708]

Thanks so much

[@wmchan44]

A common language had kept China unified for thousand of years and this advantage is being extended to the autonomous province of Tibet, Xinjiang and Inner Mongolia for the good of the native minority people there, opening the huge economic opportunities of modern China and the highest education and skills training levels for them. China is on the right track and should just tell those criticising western politicians to shut their mouths. Time will prove who is correct.

[@relaxwhc]

Shaun Rein is far more qualified and knowledgeable to talk about Tibet and China than Adrian Zenz, Gordon Chang and serpentZa. 💥 Raise your hand if you agree ✋🙋🏻‍♂️👍

[@lincolnteh1963]

✋

[@tonybeee]

So very true!

[@mhow4967]

Fully agreed

[@lz.3333]

🤚

[@mwang168]

I thought Gordon Chang is a “mole”, just like 张召忠，have been covered China to rise up for last 20-30 years.

[@trekpac2]

Cyrus, that was quite a profound interview. I sent it to 5 of my friends. Such great work to help the world understand China.

[@CyrusJanssen]

Thanks for sharing and glad you enjoyed

[@paulvirakorn]

Thank you Cyrus for introducing us to Shaun Rein. Shaun seems to have insight knowledge about Tibet and Xinjiang.

[@shaunrein4708]

Appreciate it

[@zanecai0]

Cyprus, really appreciate it. As a Chinese living in US, who has close friends all over China and frequently go back to China, i am so shocked that US officials and media are so blatantly lying about China. And American mass, even scholars are so ignorant China but they are so sure that only they know China the best. It is amazing. Maybe US is too sick, they cannot accept any truth about China, so they made up a China of their own imagination to please and comfort themselves. the Insane part is that, when people like you try to tell them the true China, the powerful US media attack you guys saying you guys are bought by Chinese government! why US media and government put so much effort to lie to the Americans about China? What do they want to achieve? They want to paint China bad and evil so they can mobilize the people to back a war against China?

[@weizhang2834]

There are a lot of stupid people in San Francisco Bay Area, even some professors put stickers on their fridge “ free Tibet “ or put on their car body “ free Tibet “, I asked them: are you fking know where Tibet is? The USA propaganda have been crazy they put those fake stories in book stores even those never existed in China history , 优胜美地park book store , Stanford university, UC Berkeley book store , “ tian an men massacre “ those fake stories they made up , force the world believe those fake stories. I am sick of talking with those people who brainwashed but they said I was brainwashed

[@weizhang2834]

归根到底还是优越感，背后的逻辑是：我们比你好，我们应该比你好，我不能接受别人比我好。中国一定要做到比美国，比西方好很多，2030前一定要有自己的发明！督促发改委一定要在世界率先建成600的高速磁悬浮，日本2027年就要建成了，我们的实验线还没开建，没有人有魄力做个首先吃螃蟹的人，怕这怕那，中央也没进行顶层设计，发改委一群人没有作为，大量300万人口以上城市地铁被强制停建，畏手畏脚，把公共基础设施跟西方的经济学混为一谈

[@wf645]

@@weizhang2834 Some are deliberate, cuz they've been fed with fake information and from Epoch media aka Falungong ..

[@dorinpopa6962]

It's not a surprise for me. This same propaganda was used against the USSR and to some extent is still being used against Russia. Now it's being used against China as well.

[@fannyalbi9040]

divide and conquer is united snakes ultimate goal! Just like ussr. Too bad, China is no ussr Let see, ussr leader went to america, came back, ussr broke into pieces and chaos happened until now china leader did the same, came back and then china become stronger and greater. 😂

[@MsTc007]

Great interview and insight about Xinjiang ! Thank you Shaun and Cyrus very much for your bringing out the truth about China.

[@shaunrein4708]

Appreciate the kind feedback and support

[@eagol]

Thanks Cyrus and Shuan, you enlightened me with something I don't even know during my 20 years in China. Really appreciate it and I decided to make a trip to Tibet myself..

[@shaunrein4708]

Appreciate the kind feedback and support

[@igobykkat]

I’m so glad you guys mentioned different dialects in China! My foreign friends are often surprised by how many different dialects we have , and that we don’t normally understand each other if we don’t speak the same dialect. So yes, putonghua is our official language that helps us to communicate in this country! Thank you guys for the hard work. It’s such a great video.

[@rap3208]

They are actually languages in their own right as they are unintelligible with each other. The rule of thumb is if you don't understand it, then it is a different language from yours. Dialects are the same languages that have differences in some words, accents, etc. due to location and passage of time but are still mutually comprehensible like the Beijing Mandarin and the taiwanese mandarin.

[@ronchow2010]

I personally think not forcing children under 18 into any religion is the right thing to do. For a lot of time religion has been forced onto children unjustly. Let them make a choice when the become adults. Maybe they don't need any religion in their lives at all.

[@relaxwhc]

I heard people like Nathan Rich are abused victims of religion 💥

[@slaw2224]

I think so too .

[@rogerfaint499]

Forcing children to have religion is a form of cultural genocide and that's what the west had been doing for centuries.

[@KamilaValieva-fan]

Yes, that’s the point!

[@yezih2694]

What a great interview!

[@shaunrein4708]

Thanks 🤝🤝🤝

[@jvp9703]

Restricting religion by age, that's actually a genius idea 🤯!

[@dennisconroy3459]

Great video from you two men. Many people travel to the five eyes countries, for seasonal work and study in University, they all had to learn a common language it was English language. People coming from different countries with their different languages, but in order to communicate they used the English language.

[@shaunrein4708]

Very kind of you

[@JS-ih7lu]

Absolutely great interview. Shaun is articulate and full of insights. Well done.

[@mengqi4433]

Couldn't agree more, Shaun is so insightful in many aspects.

[@shaunrein4708]

Much appreciated. Thanks for the kind support

[@shaunrein4708]

@@mengqi4433 so nice of you 🤝

[@tadikasimanis]

Excellent interview. My takeaway from Shaun’s message is really that China isn’t perfect, and neither the US and the west. So what’s so constructive about the anti-China propaganda going on in the west? Is it the envy of civilisation, or just plain stupidity, bigotry, racism, discrimination? Do they even think for a moment how the Chinese diaspora the world over feel about their crime of racial discrimination? Note: do the Chinese or China, even discriminate westerners and Americans? This is really ugly.

[@joeawk]

It is an old story not told. Capitalists afraid of Communism n Socialism.

[@r.gronkowski856]

But China isn't a communist system, only the party's name is CPC, China is a socialist system mixed with capitalism like the neighbors north of America called Canada(socialism & capitalism mixed), also Scandinavian countries are also socialist system & mixed with capitalism, but i do think China's CPC need to get rid of the first "C" (communist), bcos China is NOT a communist system PERIOD.

[@joeawk]

@@r.gronkowski856 even ideology shd be an ever learning and evolving process. Chinese culture is also multi faceted. As it is now, the CPC is looking at capitalism to cap the excesses affecting the global society. Capitalists greed and ego will revolt but will be put to place. Socialism with Chinese characteristic must triumph for humanity sake.

[@r.gronkowski856]

I agree, Capitalism will at the end self DESTRUCT, we are already seeing signs of it now, Capitalism worked well, served its purpose at the beginning especially post ww2, but if it isn't controlled or managed properly capitalism will end up HOARDING everything and eventually self defeat, China is currently looking for a balanced and common ground, i do hope they succeed

[@jmjt3709]

Agree. Even as a Chinese diasporian living in Asia, only been to China proper once in my life, I feel tremendously disappointed in the anti-China propaganda. Especially for decades of respecting to Western societies for its achievements -- in the sense that, there was so much to learn from in terms of knowledge, technology, better business practices, etc. Now, this continued wave of anti-China propaganda is so rapidly depleting the reserves of respect that I had. I can't speak for all, but I believe a good number of people in Asia feel that way. The effects ripple through all, going beyond China, to those who are related to the Chinese, and those who are associated with the Chinese. It's felt throughout.

[@currawong2011]

This is a truly extraordinary interview. As usual, many of those who watched it were receiving confirmation of their own thoughts, The pity is that such information is not on a platform which those who are ideologically, politically, and emotionally and ignorantly anti-China would access.

[@shaunrein4708]

Thanks so much for the kind words and support 🙏🙏🙏

[@chingweilai1872]

Thanks to both of you speaking and reporting wonderful truth on China nowadays. Just remember that all of those jealoss people and liars will not make themselves great

[@shaunrein4708]

Appreciate the kind feedback

[@bobjokmnk390]

I am very grateful to have a conscientious media to report on China.

[@ceciliagarcia1395]

I was born in 1949 in Hong Kong, growing up with the understanding the citizens extreme poor situation and had not motivation and ambition and hope , was due to the religion. As I grow up and came to Canada in 1980, I still have the image of Tibet as a hopeless country I sometime have the sadness of some foreigners enable their poor condition as a novelty, I am happy for them after I watch a lot of KZbin during this COVID social distancing, more time to stay home. Great insight great interview. I agree with Shaun that Chinese offerical can show some fun too. Some sense of humour can go a long way.

[@JWscandi]

It's great to have Shaun on board. I have known him for sometime, very knowledgeable person. TQVM Cyrus!

[@shaunrein4708]

Very kind of you

[@barryluo2011]

Thank you Cyrus! Thank you Shaun! I'm a Chinese living in the middle east, sometimes I have friends ask me these sort of "western media reported" questions. As a normal human being, I can't explain the answers in complete clearance. With your interview, gave me a lot of reference and guidance. In the future, I'd highly recommend whoever is interested in these topics, watch these 2 parts of interview first, then have a discussion later. Great job guys!

[@shaunrein4708]

Appreciate the kind feedback

[@barryluo2011]

@@shaunrein4708 WOW!!!😃

[@Runningbowels]

Shaun should be on for future shows. Enjoyed his perspective and opinions on China.

[@shaunrein4708]

Very kind of you 🤝

[@sd8688]

Thank you Cyrus and Sean, reporting truth of China.

[@shaunrein4708]

Thanks!

[@saburabdul-salaam2418]

Thank you Mr. Janssen for this video and the many other videos of yours that I have seen which has helped me to have a more balanced view of life in China and the Chinese government. I retired in 2003 so I have been able to spend a lot of time on KZbin and I have published three books since I have retired, the most recent being the Rise and Fall of Great Empires, which is one of the reasons I spend so much time on KZbin because I have always been interested in world history and modern culture. Being an African American, I have often been on the receiving end of negative American propaganda so I was not as receptive to the negative American propaganda about China as some other Americans. However in 1974, I converted to the religion of Islam and I am a trained teacher and a co-founder of an Islam school (K Thru eighth grade) that has been in existence for over 20 years, so I was very interested in what Mr. Rein said about China's policy concerning education and religion. As a former educator I know that the first decade of a persons life are the formative years and from a religious perspective they are the most important years. Both the American and Chinese governments use public education to instill the values that they want their citizens to have but in all fairness to the Chinese at least the Chinese public schools provide good secular education which is no true in the United States (see Michael Apple's Ideology and Curriculum). But for a serious Muslim it is not enough for our children to get a good secular education because we want our children to be successful in both this life as well as the Hereafter. Nor is there any consolation in knowing that all religions are treated the same.

[@Mike-yk7rl]

The growth rate of the Uyghur population is not only higher than that of the entire Xinjiang population, but also higher than that of other ethnic minorities, and significantly higher than that of the Han population. Xinjiang Uyghur birth rate is higher than the province's average birth rate, Is there such a genocide around the world?

[@KC-zx8hz]

Cyrus and Shaun, your interactive dialogue bring out so much information that rectify the distorted news from Western media about China that I think both of you would contribute to the common aspiration of everyone, that is, world peace.

[@shaunrein4708]

Thanks 👍👍👍

[@icecream270]

Thanks again for bringing some balance between the East and the West.

[@chuankityap6160]

Thanks Cyrus and Shaun for making the world a better place! Thanks for making a difference!

[@shaunrein4708]

Very kind of you

[@ilonailona28]

great interview! great insights from Shaun, especially the part about Chinese global communication. it is so true.

[@shaunrein4708]

Appreciate the kind feedback and support

[@Janicef247]

Great interview! V enlightening dialogue between you both!

[@shaunrein4708]

Thanks!

[@xwqi]

The 2008 Olympic Games directed by Zhang Yimou for the first time is also great, but it gives me the feeling that there are less Olympic themes. He directed for the second time in 2022. With the integration of existing technology, more feelings are brought in. To the future together.

[@Shenzhou.]

Western media calling attention to Xinjiang and Tibet have actually increased tourism to these parts of China. More people are visiting these regions and showing off how the quality of life has increased for people in these regions.

[@thisiskevin1000]

And social media makes it possible to share their trips, don't forget the hastags

[@LW78321]

I'm glad! 😄