Back to terrorize Valentine once again [Red Dead Redemption 2 - Part 14]

[@sophiag7005]

John is captured by the O’Driscolls, shot, hung upside down, and beaten to within an inch of his life but shrugs it off. John sits at a poker table with Floyd, an old cowboy who refuses to go all-in, and he’s put at the top of his all-time revenge list

[@JohnTwolfe]

Floyd got what was coming to him, the smug bastard. The O'Driscolls seem chill tbh

[@sophiag7005]

@@JohnTwolfe The laws of the West are sacred, and in his next life Floyd will think twice before wasting someone’s time folding on a 20 cent bet!!!

[@veinprotection]

John in his villain era was the highlight of my day. please keep having little evil robbery moments and lassoing of npcs, I have never laughed harder

[@luke5041]

37:10 Love John realising he was completely surrounded by gators lol. The bayou is such a cool area to explore, home to some of the creepiest interactions in the game too.

[@narkedandafraid]

I love that the devs added loud ass donkey noises the entire time you’re riding the “zebra” back. Literally - loud ass.

[@Murdacamjr]

the last 45 minutes of this episode was a fever dream 🤣 the stranger off the cliff was fucking hilarious

[@fractiousjope]

Absolute bedlam!

[@AngeliqueStP]

John went full-steam into his Patrick Bateman Era. lol.

[@djbeema]

Floyd broke something inside John

[@tiffinihansen6054]

Hey Guys, It's Tiff. I know Noone is following my comments on my struggle to play this game myself, BUT I FINALLY have gotten the hang of it and am SOOOOO proud of myself. (I'm a newer gamer). Thank you John for making this game look SO FUN and amazing that I didn't give up and kept trying due to your Let's Play. It may not seem like much, but you really do have a positive influence on your fan base. Even if it's just the little things like teaching us how to play games. +🤠 to us both😂

[@fractiousjope]

This playthrough is such a comfort for me,and many others. Thank you John!

[@themerovingian7154]

41:15 no the game aint bugged The mission is only available at night time and you reached there when the sun was about to rise

[@cupid3890]

those darn gators

[@SNP80]

Wasn’t expecting that the twist of this gameplay was John realizing the biggest villain is “Mutton Chops” Floyd. 😂 If you want to investigate the spookier side missions, definitely check that swamp out in the Bayou again where you heard that woman’s voice but didn’t see anything. And the stranger mission with that guy there is pretty good. Like others said, it’s a night time one and I think the game wouldn’t let you start it because the sun came up. There’s some good spooky side quests for sure. My favorite one is the serial killer one which you’re definitely making progress on.

[@Zutakameku1]

The look of disgust on John’s face when Strauss talked about collecting Downes debt from his widow ..yeha man it’s really scummy

[@htefragile]

The well-known Red Dead experience that is "I'll be doing X", then getting sidetracked and suddenly it's 3 hours later. 👌🏻No shade, it's just fun to watch you running into things. The game's really good at that, haha.

[@reiji-xi9zm]

This video made me realize that we need a poker episode. John's trash talking is top tier.

[@billmcmango4229]

The stranger in the marsh can only be activated at night, hence the title: "A Fine Night For It." Trust me, you dont want to pass this one by.

[@khrast9056]

"This guy's alive. It's better this way, you can hear him screaming." Never change, John.

[@0zzkat]

John, we U.S. folks needed our favorite series SO badly after the past couple days. Thank you so much for this, happiest I've ever been to see our high-honor Arthur Morgan!

[@liio415]

Abso-fucking-lutely.

[@cheekyguza]

The serial killer in the game quitting his 'job' after seeing John descend into madness at the end😂

[@kristofferjarvis5884]

That guy being yanked off the stage coach . Amazing and hilarious.

[@Emily-xk2du]

1:59:25 Arthur accidentally shoving the dude into the mud with the biggest shoulder check of all time and the one-two punch of the incredibly impatient "You'll be FiNE! (calmly) What's all this commotion?" ajdklaj this game rocks. I also love John's reactions to Tori to casually doing her business right in front of guys the past two videos, and his (very justified! I was taken aback too!) indignation at being told off by BILL of all people and his snarking on him with the "It's so DUMB it'll work! But I ain't dumb!!" thing lol. I flipflop on Dutch, sometimes he seems so manipulative and grifting everyone with his schtick, but most of the time I want to trust him because he kinda reminds me of Jeffrey Dean Morgan and I got a soft spot for some of his characters lol.

[@radlegowaffle]

the red dead games are honestly my favorite of rockstar, SUCH a good game with SUCH good characters and SUCH a a good story and so much to do in the map, along with either bugs (not to the point of breaking the game, most times ahaha) to an animal shitting during a point in the story, its so unintentionally so good. i played the games myself and its such a good experience, even though i probably didnt even experience half the stuff in the game, but id 100% recommend playing it yourself at some point ;u;

[@artoocase]

The “weird little rural instrument” you heard in Rhodes is called a jaw harp. Pretty easy to learn to play.

[@sejin1014]

John, someone may already have mentioned this, but the yellow missions progress the game so you can't accidentally miss them at this point. There MAY be a couple that are missable late game, I don't remember, but that's for much later. However, the white icon side missions ARE missable. If you progress the story too far, the white ones may become unavailable and are then gone forever, and so are any follow-ups to them in later chapters. So don't stress about the yellow ones, John Marston will patiently wait for you no matter how many Valentine terror trips you go on. But if you intend on doing a white one, don't hold off in it for too long. Sorry if I'm coming across as trying to backseat, and I hope you don't feel like I'm spoiling anything. Just noticed you've mentioned this, and I remembered having the exact same questions/mishaps during my first playthrough, so I just wanted to share some info that hopefully will help.

[@cupid3890]

I think he knows the difference, there's been times where a story mission becomes unavailable because the character isn't in the area for it (asleep, etc). besides he's not super into 100%ing it for this play through and he can always play in his own time for that lol.

[@sejin1014]

​@@cupid3890Never implied he was going for a 100%, you can still want to finish a side mission's plot without being a completionist. Other than that, my take was that he's been uncertain a few times about some missions, hence why I clarified. Even if John already knows, someone else who just picked up the game thanks to this playthrough might not 🤷🏻

[@adriells5695]

Floyd probably went to the table to meet new people lmfao

[@Emily-xk2du]

Loved the poker rounds at the end but omg John's increasing frustration was so funny and the way he SNAPPED was absolutely the cherry on top (Edit) THE LASSO OFF THE CARRIAGE AND THEN THE SUNSET LMAOOOO

[@PhlightYagami]

John had the quintessential Rockstar experience at 2:56:00. Those cackles made me so happy as someone who's loved letting loose in these games for 20 years.

[@harukahoshino]

I love John trash talking NPCs, specially while playing poker.

[@amodelmannequin]

John accidentally starting the Micah mission lmao

[@princessfetus]

the stripe joke made me laugh so hard, i am obsessed with these jokes.

[@AngeliqueStP]

John's definitely hitting his 'Dad Joke' responsibilities with a savagery.

[@AngeliqueStP]

Thank You John for the 3 hour reprieve from Doom Scrolling... My mental health really appreciates these videos.

[@ibby1295]

doom scrolling sucks

[@AngeliqueStP]

@@ibby1295 [sigh] Yeahhh and I know I shouldn't ... but it's hard not to when you're a disabled senior that's about to lose her only source of income.

[@secretxxstars]

​@@AngeliqueStPthinking of you, amigo, and hugs if u want em 💖💖

[@AngeliqueStP]

@@secretxxstars There's 3 things I'll never say no to: coffee, cheesecake, and hugs from a friend. C'mere you... [bear huggles]🥰

[@mika7072]

I think we all needed this series to continue. Thank you so much John. It honestly made me forget about these last few awful days.

[@deadsmoke5514]

That last 45 mins, were the best part of this video. My ribs hurt from laughter.

[@mymelody_13]

I still have to watch your newest RDR2 upload but this was probably my favorite episode so far! So glad I get to finally experience this game for the first time and I couldn’t have picked a better playthrough for it. It’s been fun!

[@GolemCC]

I, for one, am here for John's psychopath arc.

[@Cheddarhead7]

Was that a swamp-ghost John heard before the gator hunting? It was a creepy moment

[@InterstellarLatte]

Yes many cool, freaky things happen at night in the swamp!

[@LadyMisalein]

Its "the lady in white" ! I hope he witness her again ❤

[@InterstellarLatte]

I love this playthrough. Thank you for creating a comfortable, safe space for us!

[@lizzy6828]

I love how john was like "idk if we'll have time for another story mission in this video" and then proceeded to spend the next 45 minutes playing poker and being the villain

[@mikari3498]

Youre legendary John! thank you for being such a consistant stream of content. Your personality is such a calming and entertaining presence to watch. 🙏

[@MartinGiadrosich]

The horses are my favourite mission with Albert. Arthur just likes Albert :D Thanks for showing off his storyline!

[@jarjarblinks1418]

I've recently been getting caught up on these but the entire poker scene and the aftermath was so funny lmao I love how you make those parts so entertaining!

[@zoloft_theblob]

this has been one of my favorite RDR2 episodes.. john’s chaos / villain arc after poker in valentine was gold , i honestly couldn’t stop laughing 😂

[@yutodsynp]

this series is deadass my comfort LP, thank you john 🙏

[@Emily-xk2du]

Yeah, agree with John on the fun reveals on each of Margaret's animals, they were so funny. I love Arthur's snarkiness and indignation for the animals, and his casual swagger into the Emerald Ranch situation lol

[@thefailbender]

Catching up on these pretty late (sorry!), but wanted to say I'm pretty sure you're spot on regarding why Arthur likes Albert Mason so much. He's absolutely my favorite side character; every interaction is just so silly and wholesome. Incidentally, my precious horse Maria was the silver dappled pinto from the Albert Mason mission. There's a way to get after the horses quick enough that you can catch it, although it took 5 or 6 retries. I meta game for pretty horses, apparently. Fun fact about the tiger and lion mission: while driving the circus cart back after getting the "tiger" caged, I managed to get the damn thing stuck *perfectly* between two trees and the horses would NOT back up. I had to reload and do everything again. Then, when I went to do the lion part, somehow my horse managed to teleport *perfectly in front of the lion* so I couldn't shoot it without, well, shooting my precious Maria. So I had to reload THAT. And finally, when I went to loot the lion, the game somehow positioned me slightly underneath it, so when I finished "skinning" it, I fell through the world. Eventually it teleported me back to Emerald Ranch but yeesh, I'll never forget that sidequest.

[@pauleagleton7113]

John officially lost his mind after that poker game 😂😂😂

[@trippalong77]

That ending TOOK ME OUT. I’m trying to laugh quietly at my office desk, then John just goes ape on wagon man. 3:03:36 I can’t breathe

[@sutefani13]

John did say he would fight anyone who was rude to him. This episode takes the cake! " I fee like I need to make more of a statement" lmao

[@girlpaintsworld]

John! Not sure if you’ll read this but the 3 am shack people are talking about is the one you came across that has all of the unalived cult people in it. It’s close to Emerald Ranch. BUT there’s another house that’s in the Southfield Flats close by the area of the church and shacks you first went to in this video that’s worth checking out. You passed it once in a previous video, it’s a house that’s connected to a smallish crop field. It’d also be cool if you kept doing full episodes similar to the hunting episode you did except with different activities! Like an episode where you continue the serial killer mission or an episode where you just do treasure maps, or dive deep into the creepy, supernatural aspects of the game because there are a lot.

[@AngeliqueStP]

Love that idea! I've said on previous videos that I REALLY hope he follows the serial killer storyline to its conclusion, ...and a treasure map episode sounds fun af.

[@girlpaintsworld]

@ Same!! I hope he stumbles upon the 3rd clue. I love seeing his reactions to all of these small details within the game

[@AngeliqueStP]

@@girlpaintsworld Exactly! I've had people tell me "well this content creator has a vid on it" and while I appreciate them being helpful ...it's John's reaction I'm here for.☺

[@girlpaintsworld]

@ Only the shareholders know 😤

[@Superfreaky2]

@@AngeliqueStPYeah! I would love him to finish Margarets mission with the circus animals too, especially since he said ‘i should have known there’d be no tiger’

[@dw13645]

I let out the hugest gasp when you lasso’ed that guy off the carriage 😂

[@PandaEyes47]

Thank you, John. Really looking forward to this continuation of the playthrough. Sending love to your growing family from the emerald isle ❤️

[@klaudia7996]

2:44:34 "I'm gonna hogtie you, take you to the barber" 🤣🤣🤣

[@Seihaname]

The last minutes of this was hilariously unexpected yet classic John lmao

[@veinprotection]

fun fact that funny rural instrument is called a jaw harp!!

[@cupid3890]

isn't it also a mouth harp? or does it matter?

[@veinprotection]

@@cupid3890 it has a lot of different names, all of them beautiful 😊

[@BoneStack117]

Thank you

[@maxfrog4]

John this is the funniest and best episode yet I loved it

[@patricehonez]

John playing poker is the highlight of this video 😂….(I had no idea what was coming after 😂😂😂)

[@monotonecanadian6825]

"That's a Dawg in there" is honestly amazing

[@Misskittycat_14]

I love it when John goes full psycho mode 😂

[@Yvesenjoyer666]

another banger ep. Perfect balance between Story quests, side quest and shenanigans. Died when you lassoed the guy on the carriage and sent him flying, also when you accidentally knocked over the dude at emerald ranch and then arthur was like "YOULL LIVEAnyways whats going on"

[@cheepytiger]

John finally became The Joker 😂

[@ImageryDoesFit]

Really needed some plus cowboy after the last couple of days 🙏🏼

[@AngeliqueStP]

Absolutely. [shares tea]

[@tiffinihansen6054]

Ive had this game for almost a year. I cannot get past the opening area where we learn to hunt. John makes it look sooo fun, hopefully I can get into it enough so i can start earning +🤠

[@mayanguap]

so excited to see you back to playing this game, I look forward to seeing your reaction at other parts of the game !

[@jorngaming89]

The tiny hat and John impersonating Arthur Morgan are back ❤

[@colorbythecaramelgirl1775]

Snacking on wild thyme in the middle of a kidnapping is as unbothered as I wish to be

[@bugdomrulez]

yay the wildlife museum art exhibit sidequest is my favorite!! hunting down the perfect animal....it can take so long but be so satisfying.

[@JWildberry]

Alligators in Silent Hill would be terrifying.

[@michaeltudyk8660]

The end of this episode was like that homelander episode.

[@kanelic]

John went completely psycho at the end, love it!

[@victoriarose6115]

you see kids this is what happens. you start gambling and then you have horse problems.

[@BTSB7221]

I kind of love that John doesn’t know the significance of the sepia-tone deer footage and what it signifies

[@maxgeorge3735]

I hope you finish all the debtors quests it's definitely worth it especially if you don't like Strauss

[@fractiousjope]

Yes,the storyline associated with the debtors Strauss has us harassing is very very good!

[@cupid3890]

ugh my favorite bit is when Arthur (SPOILER)

[@AngeliqueStP]

That sounds ...intriguing. Here's hoping!

[@hack1017gaming]

Omg the end of this video, absolute mayhem 😂😂

[@DACFalloutRanger]

I feel like John was still asleep after coming back from that nap lol

[@Kyyndle]

Funny enough, if John didn't accidentally fire his gun during the bank robbery, he likely woulda got away without a shoot-out. 😅

[@wishywoshua]

you can hold Y to rest and craft anywhere, that's why it did that in front of the box. and yes like other people have said some missions and events are only available at certain times so missions will disappear and reappear and sometimes you'll discover places where it seems like there's nothing but if you come back at certain times you can find things happening there.

[@liio415]

John spent an hour shaking a man down for $10.00, went psycho-cowboy, and lost $150.00 😂 That’s what this game is all about

[@valka-u5p]

the ending with john carrying corpse of a man on him and stopping to give money to a blind man was pure anecdote

[@anacsadder]

Not gonna lie, I giggled at the spotted zebra joke XD

[@mackraft6417]

Fun fact: your only not allowed to steal horses from members of your gang 😈

[@emilyweaver]

the instrument that guy in Rhodes was playing is called a jaw harp btw

[@mikari3498]

the poker floyd arc of this episode was insane 🤣

[@samwisegamgee1243]

Poor John has just been wanting to play poker for hours now and instead keeps getting roped into missions. 😂 He was even willing to play with Micah before!

[@tommen.baratheon]

Oh hell yeah, I'm working on a drawing of Arthur right now, so this is the perfect video to watch alongside

[@cleonRIP]

I can't believe he got demonotized for saying the name of the type of dog, but can say Florida CRACKER cow all day 😂😂😂

[@AngeliqueStP]

And it doesn't make sense even by YT's own standards: I have a certain breed of cat, so ofc I look up vids on that breed ...and there are *thousands* of videos with the breed name in the title - Maine C**n! And you can't tell me all of those vids got in trouble, but it's the same idea.

[@plasticsofa]

cowboy john, time to strike a match and light up this juke joint

[@HatchlingChibi]

I wonder if it was glitched with that flower too, on the bodies in the swamp. I thought it was weird Arthur had no comment about any of that, I'm wondering if that is part of the serial killer mission but it wouldn't let you do anything about it? (I haven't finished the video yet, at 42:39 so maybe John comes back?)

[@kanelic]

John do you know you can quick-fire/hip-fire? It's really cool. I think you have accidentally done it sometimes.

[@8bitarmory846]

breaking: man kills 3 in outrage after drawn out Poker game, shot dead

[@78cheyenne]

Love this game! On my second playthrough. If you want to quickly draw your last weapon or put it away, you can tap LB.

[@thacobell4700]

John is tempted by the Minus Cowboy.

[@origamipapercut4682]

John, at the point you’re at, poker in Valentine and Flatneck Station. 😊 Well, maybe not Valentine ya minus cowboy. 😂

[@darkjedi69]

the tiny hat is back!

[@mikari3498]

this is my favorite episode so far

[@H0TR0B]

I see that John deciding to play Poker caused him to go insane and start murdering innocent people. Such is the fate of any player who tries to complete the Gambler challenges.

[@Goatsht3423]

John believed he had access to a lion but not a emerald 😂

[@commanderkorra3316]

Gators are easier than most animals to kill in the game sadly. I messed up while playing Arthur after being captures, missed with the knife kills. And one by one the enemies came down, fought them with fists and then a gun and barely made it out lol. I was wondering about the weapons, i recovered them before leaving.

[@BoneStack117]

Bahaha the ending was hilarious. Completely unhinged

[@Dantibody]

Floyd was going home to fold some clothes.

[@camykw]

You can steal horses, it notifies you when the horses belong to friends so you don't take them. Otherwise they're up for grabs to steal, sell horses, or keep the horses for yourself. If you were being sarcastic, disregard my comment. Also, fireplaces sometimes keep stacks of money up them, so it's good to search in them. I've noticed places you went to but didn't check that have money in their fire places. Thanks for the video.

[@LadyMisalein]

Ohhh cool!!! John "kinda" witnessed the girl in white!

[@themerovingian7154]

Yaaay 🎉 I was gonna sleep but now that the next RDR2 episode is here Im gonna be awake for the next 3 hours

[@sfaira4072]

John I think you got posessed by Micah at the end there.

[@psndgeekie923]

I can't stop replaying 52:03