I use 3 criteria to determine the best personal and home protection dogs.

[@MontanasandBoots]

Rottweilers are number 1 for me too. My parents would let me and my friends go outside in the mountains outside our house when we were 8, and they would send us with a Rottweiler named Natasha. She would watch us like a hawk and nosed us towards the house when the sun started going down. She broke down a screen door to get to us once. Rotties are my all time favorite breed. They are bold, loyal, and extremely protective of their family.

[@gilmoregibson9184]

Don't forget about the Doberman and the Beauceron!

[@viajero1004]

You know it! Rotties are #1 at home protection!

[@MichaelStephenson51]

Rottie, without doubt. I have an 80lb female I have started taking to the dog park. She is friendly enough, especially with the other dogs, but I have noticed that when anyone is coming through the gate she will position herself about half way between whereever am and the gate. Once they are in and she has determined they are OK she will go up and meet the dog. After that they can play and everything is cool. She is nothing compared to the 120lb female we used to have. As Joel said, just based on her stern "look", my guess is nobody would even enter the dog park ;) (I never took her so don't know for sure).

[@ElephantPatronus]

When I was in my 20s we had a 75 lb boxer named Duke. I used to take Duke to the park. I'd sit up on this little hill and read a book while Duke would play at the bottom of the hill down by the water. One day I was really into my book and didn't notice how late it had become. The sun had gone down and it was dusk. Suddenly Duke comes flying up the hill with his hair up and stands at attention in front of me staring at the parking lot behind me. I turn around to see that the parking lot is empty except my car and one other car. Then I see a man watching me from behind a big oak tree. As soon as he saw Duke he turned around hurried to his car and left. I shudder to think what could've happened if I hadn't had Duke with me that day. I loved that dog. ❤

[@GreenWitch1]

I have a boxador. Sweetest dog ever, but if crossed, he wouldn’t back down if someone tried to hurt his mommy.

[@aportilla007]

I have a boxer as well, she already proved herself versus a perv approaching my daughter in the parking lot at night.

[@jonathanschmidt990]

Feel you, Boxer also a great breed

[@Ponygirl1111]

Yes to the Boxer! My boy is a white boxer, and deaf, but the deafness makes him a mind, face & body reader. I don’t know if he has it in him to hurt anyone intentionally, BUT….he is so, so fast & intense with his front legs, that I can’t even play with him. It breaks my heart because he is a true angel in fur, and doesn’t mean it, but I can testify as to why they are called Boxers! Mine is like a velociraptor, he’s leave a huge scratch on me, from shoulder to thighs. My Doberman uses his stump tail as a weapon, and steps on your feet, but doesn’t play as rough as that Boxer does!

[@marcushennings9513]

I received a boxer as a present and although the most expensive ($800) it was the worse dog I ever had. I called trainers and breeders and most believe that even though it was purchased from pet store it was bred at a bad puppy mill. In contrast my best dog was a pit mix and was the least expensive ($75) from the rescue shelter.

[@shaleighamarie]

I have two German shepherds that I’m so grateful for with something they did for me one day. Here’s my fugitive story! Last year my husband and I were chilling at home(I was in the shower) when there was a police chase that went down our road. We live in Amish country on a very off the beaten path road, so this was VERY unusual. I get out of the shower and my husband gets in, and I went into the bedroom and heard a big crashing sound, so I looked out the window to see a cop car ramping the hill in my front yard. The people running from the cops tried to hide behind my chicken coop and made a break for it through my electric horse fence, where the woman was caught. Night goes on, hours pass, they called in two counties so there were at least 10 cop cars and the fire department looking for this guy. Drones, people on foot everything but a K9 because the handler was on vacation. We see them loading up and leaving, so I went out to see if they finally got him(it had been about 5 hours at this point) and they didn’t. Just said to lock everything up and protect ourselves in any way we might need to, but he was “probably” gone and “probably” not dangerous 😳 Next morning rolls around, and after a quiet and sleepless night I decide to take the girls out to do their business. As soon as they get out they both run to our horse trailer hackles raised and making sounds I’ve never heard a dog make. My smaller one that we got as an older dog from an abusive owner went in the trailer and was going INSANE. My older one that is super bonded with me came to my side and stayed with me as I went to see what was happening. Turns out, the guy was in my horse trailer! I called my dog off of him, and shut the door and called 911. It was so creepy and surreal, he was staring at me while I was one the phone the whole time, luckily he wasn’t armed. But I was out there alone and couldn’t get in contact with my husband because the 911 call was taking what felt like years. But my girls stayed with me, one by my side and the other following the guy and making sure he kept his arms inside the trailer as he was trying to figure a way out. It took the cops 45 minutes to show up, and they were so surprised by how two of the sweetest most well behaved dogs ever managed to keep the guy in line enough to where he didn’t try to run again. The fugitive piped up and said that he wasn’t stupid enough to try to run because they would have chased him down and torn him to shreds 😂 So I can personally attest to German shepherds being amazing guardians, because I have seen the proof!

[@bboness713]

Black shepherds definitely have the "look". I love them as a breed

[@PraytheRosaryEveryDay]

In my experience as an owner of many successive GSDs and 2 presently, they are feared and respected universally. They still have the look if any dog has it. As a German friend says, "Ah, German Shepherds, ze fines dogs in ze world!" I agree.

[@painfulltruth5551]

Could of at least asked why he was being chased, if he had a believable answer, and it wasn't a serious crime,I'd have told him to be on his way 🤷‍♂️ The police did say he wasn't dangerous, put the kettle and man the man a brew😄

[@pamelalee9677]

Very cool.

[@MrsFitzus]

When I worked at a boarding facility it was the Rottweilers that always made me feel the most safe. I'm 4'9" and the play yards were right next to an old movie theater and every time there was a weird person out there or a scuffle in the parking lot, they would pretty much "adopt" me as their family and get in between me and the threat. They would stand against my legs and encourage me to hug them and take comfort when I felt nervous and he would just totally take control of the situation. He still listened to everything I told him to do and was wonderfully obedient, but it was like another level of situational awareness. I've wanted a rottie ever since.

[@dannyh5937]

Love hearing stories like this. Certain dogs are fearless when they need to be.

[@chanellovvesyou]

Situational awareness is a really good word to describe Rottiea.

[@subaruspirit7690]

That's an amazing story to share!

[@tuffybaxton6162]

Silly question, do you think they'd fight a bug? I'm not the biggest fan of bugs and I had a cocker spaniel who'd fight any bug that freaked me out, roaches, wasp, spiders... You name it, he was on it!

[@TrishaVincent8057]

Two stories. A woman at a dog boarding facility told me her Rottweiler lunged in the air, so it could push a soon-to-be ex-boyfriend on to the ground. The boyfriend became violent to her. The Rottweiler pushed him on the ground and stood on top of him.. Also of note. I took my small dog to a groomer/grooming school. The owner brought her dogs to work. One was a pit bull mix, and one was a fully groomed foofy-looking standard poodle. The owner told a student to take the poodle with her to go get the mail. There had been some suspicious activity near the back of the building. I asked why not take the pit bull mix. The owner said the standard poodle was the more aggressive of the two dogs.

[@czechmydog1669]

Very happy to see the Rottweiler made the list! I have a story of my own about my Rottweiler. We stayed for a while at the house of my sister in law and during the day I let him be outside if he wanted. What I didn't know was that somebody would come to the house that day to deliver fire wood and that my sister in law left the money below a stone near the entrance. So this guy does off the firewood in front, opens the gate, enters the property and goes for the money. I see him from a window and just observe him as I'm not sure what he is doing there. Then I see my Rottweiler coming from the backyard to the front, standing a few meters from the guy. The guy freezes and they are staring at each other for a while. Suddenly the guy starts to run away, so I panic as I'm not sure what my Rottweiler will do and I run outside. I see my Rottweiler fly past the guy and block the gate. Then he gets up on his hind paws and jumps at the guy to make it clear he will not pass. No growl, no bark, no bite. I run over and tell my Rottweiler to move, he does and stands by next to us. I apologize to the guy and I find out about the agreement he has with my sister in law. All good, he was just in shock. From that moment on I was so impressed with my Rottweiler, he was only one and a half years old back then but he solved the situation perfectly and without violence! I would have been in a lot of trouble if my Rottweiler had bitten this person, but he didn't. He perfectly assessed the situation and just made sure this guy doesn't leave the property until somebody comes to figure out what to do with this guy.

[@jaisekharnair6040]

For me it is the Doberman! Absolutely loyal, protective, intelligent and very trainable. And they are wonderful with kids too.

[@kelseywilliams2255]

I agree

[@michaelwood5704]

Agreed I just commented explaining why and how

[@DaveTechCA]

I've had two..Problem is short life expectancy

[@jashanbrar8668]

Na Doberman is a rat dog

[@frankiefavero1666]

@@jashanbrar8668 in what world? They are personal protection dogs.

[@jeanette_voerman]

In Australia, most crims would think twice about messing with a cattle dog (heeler), which tend to be suspicious of strangers. These dogs have been bred to shrug off kicks from 700kg+ cattle with rock-hard hooves, so a kick from a human is feeble in comparison. If owning a large breed isn’t an option, a heeler is worth a look.

[@cazgerald9471]

Mad Max 2

[@bethaniestephens6]

I have a heeler/German Shepard mix and he’s the best. Tough little guy and very protective of me until I tell him someone is ok and then he’s a very happy, friendly pup!

[@homesteadinginmohavecounty1626]

I agree with this. I have 2 and they would definitely attack anyone who posed a threat.

[@jw-vx8im]

Try find a heeler that is a bit taller in the legs. They have a more imposing look

[@alicegorsen1968]

Not a good dog with kids that's for sure.....

[@dontwren]

something so special about rotties and dobermans. My single mom worked late so as a young kid I was home alone a lot, but we had adopted a rottie/dober mix that was my best friend and guardian. She looked like a slimmer version of a rottie, but still blocky and big. We had a mouse problem and every time one would run past me while I watched TV on the floor, I'd scream and jump up on the couch! and she'd lay in front of the couch and block me off from what scared me. lol Made me feel so safe. The backyard was our oasis, one day before school I woke up early to play with her, but she must have been sleeping outside, just out of view. She only heard someone rustling around and didn't know it was me, woke up and came charging around the bushes snarling that scary sound like I'd never heard her do before. The instant she got eyes on me, she darted past me and dove under the porch steps! She was so upset she had scared me, I had to coax her out with hot dogs just to pet her and let her know it was okay. She had been abused before we adopted her, so she probably expected a beating for her mistake. Still, she was so gentle and sweet to me, and so protective and intuitive. I'd love to have another rottweiler someday. Unfortunately, not long after that my mom got married to a huge asshole who had an aggressive male akita, but our female rottie/dobie was the dominant one. Hurt that jerk's ego and he made my mom get rid of her. I was absolutely devastated. She deserved better. Her doggie soul is surely in heaven now, so I'd just like to say: Maggie, thank you for making my childhood safer! I'm sorry the adults in our lives were so horrible to you, but you were my best friend and I loved you so much. You were the goodest girl 💕

[@c.burwell2618]

Cat person here. Many years ago I had a friend tell me she was getting a rescue Rottweiler. All I knew about the breed was what was in the news, and I was horrified. I couldn't imagine that anything good could come of "rescue" plus "Rottweiler". She was so excited when she got her that she brought Mercy right over to introduce me. I melted. To date, that was the sweetest dog I have ever encountered. She loved people, she loved other animals - especially cats. No, not to munch on them. She adored them. When it came time to guard, Mercy was on it. Rest of the time she was a silly, chill dog. I have had a soft spot for Rotties ever since and have sworn that if I ever am able to, I will get a Rottweiler and go through the training it takes to have one. RIP Mercy.

[@matrixcom69]

My belgian malinois saved my house from being burglarized a few years back. Had a few guys jump my fence to get to my house and my dog went into a barking frenzy and came at them. These degens bolted back over the fence and bent the top railing on the way out. He's not the perfectly trained dog, but he's hella good at guarding our general area.

[@matthewmontalvo5066]

Yeah I wouldn’t want to mess with a mail the person is screw if that dog gets piss off because their no Out running them or escaping them they’re super Athletic with the attitude to bite deep and do damage. Only down side is you will never tried that dog out 98% of the time and you have to exercise them if you want your stuff not to become chew toys

[@Rinchiio]

DEGENS! Thanks! I've been looking for ways to call such people. We have a Mal also. Nothing can breath/move outside without being noticed.

[@Rinchiio]

@@matthewmontalvo5066 yup fastest dog ever. Shockingly so!

[@Noahsark17]

Structure, consistency, humility and cardiological development(joy) is the foundation to Dog training. Our Malinois and I live this everyday, not the most easy, but the most trainable and lovable. One hell of a personal protection companion. They change you from couch potatoe to hiker bill 💯

[@mskatefish]

My favorite plus Dutch shepherd. They’re very sharp! And brave

[@AlopiasTale]

Growing up in South Africa, my grandmother owned a plot of land in Sasolburg, she had two absolutely gorgeous Rhodesian Ridgebacks, who were primarily guard dogs. They were very good at it, they kept strangers who approached the boundary away, very good with me as a kid too. I could be rough with them and they were very gentle with me. One time we woke up to these two barking like mad, they had cornered a bullfrog in the corner of an empty swimming pool. I tell you, whilst they were barking, they were too scared to get too close to this animal, but then again, I understand. I wouldn't want to mess with a bullfrog either....

[@Steve8624]

The European working line sable German shepherds, in my opinion, are far more intimidating looking, and have better temperaments than the American show lines. Nonetheless, I agree with the list.

[@kylasbibi]

I agree. My GSD is the bi color (tan feet black body). Her mom was a working line sable and grandmother solid black GSD.

[@akodo1]

I agree that the type of GSD makes a big difference

[@StratMatt777]

When I was a kid I had a showline female GSD. The working line sable male I have now is TERRIFYING in comparison if he sees another dog. I'm going to build a second fence because of how he loses his mind when he sees another dog.

[@jw-vx8im]

I hv a black sable and I challenge anyone to jump the fence or go in the yard alone. No takers so far

[@akodo1]

@@jw-vx8im I'll be your huckleberry

[@nogames8982]

I agree about the Akita. My friend was in the Marines and he was from a very rough neighborhood. He was worried about his mom being home alone so he got an Akita for her. After a year he was on leave and he walked in the house and the dog attacked him. So between yelling for his mom and telling the dog good dog the situation worked out just like he wanted it. He knew his mom was safe with that dog around.

[@kcakita2162]

I've had 5 Akita's over the past 25 years, and I currently have 2 living in my house now. A 110# female and a 125# male. Both are extremely loyal, both are extremely protective, and both are excellent guard dogs. You will not get into my house uninvited. With that said, they are extremely loving, extremely gentle, and if you are invited into my house they will not leave you alone wanting nothing more than your attention. They are both great at the vet and great when getting their bath. It's all in how a dog is raised. And by the way, Akita's are NOT a dog you just leave outside. That's a recipe for disaster. They are a breed that wants and needs to be inside living with their owner as a pack. And when you are talking about an American Akita, 100# plus is normal. Your video is great and your list is too. Of course, a lot of this is subjective and people are bias, me included to towards the Akita. But that's good since there are so many wonderful breeds out there for people to choose from. Thanks for the video!

[@my99songs]

I have a Japanese Akita, she's always been super sweet and gentle with all people and dogs, I thought she never would have been a good guard dog. But one day some friends she's never met came in uninvited, she met them and their dog nose to nose when they opened the door, and I've never seen her so pissed off, she was growling and lifting her lips, lunging, we knew if we didn't hold her back there would have been at LEAST a bite. After that day I've been very confident about her abilities as a guard dog, I'm never doubting again 😆

[@greencarpetgrowing]

My American Akita prefers to be outside in our fenced in back yard. Mind you, I’m home working inside. She will bark loudly if anyone is in the front yard, let alone coming remotely towards the backyard. Her parents were outdoor Akita’s too. She loves being outside watching for rats, mice, lizards, possums, skunks, etc. She is ultra loyal and affectionate with me. On a walk in the woods, there was a vagabond acting strangely and my girl went ballistic!

[@patrickmowatt8560]

I've been a rottweiler owner for going on 25 years, and I can attest to your description of "other level" within your criteria. My first rottie was Wolfgang, also the biggest at 135 lbs peak. Wolfie was the most intuitive and gentlest of the three- most times, he'd do whatever you wanted him to without the need for a command. His method of "delivering a message" was non-verbal, non-violent, and yet crystal clear. I'd have buddies over and occasionally, as guys do after a few drinks, there would be a play wrestling match- all friendly stuff, but not on Wolfie's watch. The instant a match started, this 135 lb dog would shove his way between the two combatants and just stand there, alternating looks back and forth between them. And that was enough on every occasion to put an end to the rough housing. On another occasion at a summer party at a friend's cottage, with about 50 people and half a dozen dogs running around the place, somebody brought a lab puppy to add to the mix. Couple of the other dogs that were there were the meatheads, the instigators you'd expect trouble from, but once that puppy arrived Wolfie watched it like a mother hen- any time another dog got close he'd stand between it and the puppy, and didn't tolerate any nonsense. Great channel and thanks for the vids!

[@rhymhizsong4214]

❤

[@pipemartz]

Wolfgang sounds like a one in a million. I had a one in a million once (Hershey), but it was a cocker spaniel mix. So not a guard dog, but his loyalty, maturity, and emotional intelligence were off the charts.

[@larag4646]

I chose a doberman over a rottie because the doberman will force me to be more active than a rottie would. I love how my dobie makes eye contact with everyone we come across on walks. I don't think he's trying to intimidate them. It's just that doberman eye contact thing they do. He's really friendly with people if I let him greet them but he definitely gives that "I see you and I'm watching you" vibe when we're out and about. I have no idea if he'd actually protect me or my kids with biting someone but we certainly have "scary dog privilege" with him.

[@xdrazormon454]

Dobermans are like an over protective daddy dogs

[@pipemartz]

Dobermans are hands down the most beautiful in my opinion.

[@NoWordsNeeded1000]

Giant Schnauzers are on the same level as German Shepherds, Dobermans and Rottweilers. They are used as police dogs and military aswell. And a great family pet!

[@solj3322]

@NoWordsNeeded 1000 I've been doing quite a bit of research on the Giant Schnauzers as an option due to my allergies; how would you describe training them? Did you find them to do well like a Rotti would with accessing situations and having good impulse control?

[@rottweiler938]

They definetly wouldn’t have the look aspect for this list though. Obviously I would say that temperament is important, but looks definetly are important as well- looks could also protect the dog from getting into a fight / getting injured if the intruders decide to not even attempt it.

[@ygrus7094]

​@@rottweiler938 dude, Giant Schnauzers look scarier than Akita's, Dobermans and GSD from this list, and are heavier than Dobermans, GSD, and compared to Cane Corso

[@NiagaraBTC]

I think it’s only popularity that would keep the Giant Schnauzer off the list. Definitely has the look (IF ears cropped) compared to a German Shepherd or Akita.

[@gusz4019]

Stubborn. Very stubborn. Can’t compare em to these breeds especially to Rottweilers.

[@heatherorcutt4266]

I have a 13 month male Rottie, I just love him to pieces and couldn't agree more with your perspective. When he was very young, my 11yo daughter wanted to get him "Intruder Training." She said this entailed running on a treadmill and teaching him how to attack "bad guys." When he turned 1yo I asked her if he still needed the Intruder Training and we laughed. He just inherently knows to protect. His deep voice, which he only uses on occasion, sounds very scary, and when alert looks very intimidating. He's a very sweet boy and loves to play. But when we take him places with us in the truck, and he sees suspicious characters he is full alert and would no doubt protect his family if need be. No Intruder Training needed. Lol

[@rustyshackleford9154]

When you're a criminal that deals with cops alot. A German Shepard definitely makes it to number one, in terms of "the look".

[@terrirojas]

My uncle had a Rottie, Kelly. One day, he comes home and finds her in his barn, blocking two guys, who were stealing gas, in there. Kelly let them on the property, but didn’t let them leave. Good girl. 😂 We have a Pyrenees, Dobie, and American Bully mix. He’s charming and terrifying all at the same time, and has a big bark!

[@asp1213]

Can't argue with your choices. Would love to hear your opinions on popular US breeds, positives, quirks, challenges, etc.

[@Anon_E_Muss]

Yes please!

[@alexandradittmann8588]

YES, that would be great to hear!

[@andihd8768]

There's a reason Joel picked Rottweiler as #1.. do you remember the children's book, "Good Dog Carl"? And subsequently all the ones that followed.. because their brilliant, loving, level headed, loyal souls. My Dad had a coworker that would take his everywhere. I loved when he came by because I was the only one he liked in the family. For those welcomed visits, I was the most confident kid in the neighborhood. My siblings didn't torture me, my mom didn't abuse me. Life was great.

[@Oldwoman1977]

I loved your choices. I’ve had Ridgebacks all my life, from the day I was born 64 yrs ago. They are wonderful guard dogs and have always protected me and my 3 children growing up. They just don’t look as fierce as the dogs on your list, but they certainly can be! I love your channel and thank you for all you do to help us. Your dog is gorgeous ❤️

[@adamwespiser9209]

Love Ridgebacks! Any dog that lure courses is A+ in my book! I wonder if a bit more of that prey drive could be directed into people to make them better guard dogs? Still, a pissed off Ridgeback is definitely a man eater!

[@sarahtara5546]

I agree with you. I worked in a Rhodesian Ridgeback rescue for 2 and a half years. They are very confident and brave. They are definitely great guard dogs and can definitely be intimidating.

[@foxinthetwilight4046]

They are great beautiful dogs. And I imagine a well-trained and angry one would be very intimidating to a would be robber or assailant. My neighbor had a few. The last one just passed a few months ago.

[@alanglowacki6266]

I have a female Ridgeback that is 84 pounds of solid muscle has a presence about her that intimidates a lot of people. She is super sweet and I wondered if she had it in her to protect the family if needed. There have been two times that she thought something was not right and showed that she was willing and capable of protecting the family. If I didn't know her and ran into her when she was on guard I wouldn't be comfortable, the difference in growl and body language surprised me. She is seven now and we are getting a European doberman puppy in a few months to keep her company as she grows older.

[@sidneybales9062]

Lol I have friends whose RR love virtually everyone, except Grandpa. When Grandpa came into the house, she would pin him against the wall. I tell people I was like Mougli who was raised by Rhodesians instead of wolves.

[@nightkraken7257]

Ive had Great Pyrenees for many years now, though they are usually used as livestock guardians, when raised as house pets they transition well into home protectors.

[@alexandradittmann8588]

Oh I bet, yes! Greetings from a fellow LGD owner; Estrela in my case, but they seem very similar in many regards. Even the looks: Just imagine a GP after they've rolled around in mud :-)

[@GreenWitch1]

My mom had one. Sweetest dog I’ve ever met!

[@TwoTall1988]

From what I understand, GP are not "attack" dogs and generally only alert and look intimidating.

[@texaspatriot3587]

Your list is perfect. The top 3 were the ones I debated when I decided to get a new dog after losing my pittie. I truly wanted a Doberman, but house insurance, and traveling in the RV with camp restrictions, I had to say no. I decided on the cane corso, and couldn't have made a better choice for us. My female is 3, and my male is just over 1. Female easier, but male is more scary looking. Lol. Ur videos have helped over the yrs and corrected all of my concerns!! Captain and Morgan (their names) thank you for teaching me. I love their loyalty and attentiveness, but still have the ability to go anywhere with me. They love people and dogs, lives with a few cats and a mean chihuahua , plus we have 8 grandkids that visit regularly, and we like to have friends over to the pool. They do great with every one!! BUT--no one, and no critter (we live on a few acres in the woods) that's UN-invited can get in my yard or house, and or even close to us. Great list!! ❤️❤️

[@dania1059]

Totally agree with your number 1. This is a breed that their eyes can look right into your soul. Another breed that can do this is a Dogue de Bordeaux.

[@KingsMom831]

I feel like any & all breeds, mutts & mixes are capable of this, but I know just what you mean. Our dog is 1/2 Dogue de Bordeaux & the people we got him from said when he looks at you, it’s as if he wants to crawl inside your soul☺️

[@dania1059]

@@KingsMom831 I have boarded over 600+ dogs and I have never experienced anything like having the dogue de bordeaux check me out like that. Intimidating to say the least! But once you have the rotties and these guy's trust, you are golden for life with them and they will surely defend you.

[@KingsMom831]

@@dania1059 Absolutely!

[@vikingdogmanship]

@@KingsMom831 🥰🤗 Agreed! Hope everyone is having a good day✌ Much Love

[@KingsMom831]

You too!😊👋🏼@@vikingdogmanship

[@TPinesGold]

The neighbor's rotty story reminded me of a story about our GSD when I was a kid. • I was 14 • older boy (John) from next door was home from college • my family was in our kitchen, John stopped by to say hello; all of us in kitchen catching up with John • John was telling a story and in illustrating some part of his story he walked over to me (both of us standing) and grabbed me with both of his hands around the top of my shoulders near my neck. • without making a sound, our GSD had her mouth locked onto John's forearm. • of course John instantly let go and backed away from me ... and was practically white as a sheet. • Katie immediately let go of his arm. • John's skin not punctured; just some temporary teeth impressions. • all happened so fast no time for anyone to react before it was over. • Katie never trained for anything except being a good family pet. • Great with all visitors, kids or adults, before and after this single event. • ferocious every day of her life when mailman, UPS, garbage man, paperboy on the property -- acted like she wanted to bust through the front window. Otherwise calm and quiet. Greatest dog for a kid from age 6 to 18.

[@PT84]

Similar story my brother and I were at our friends house boxing in their yard. My brother punches my friend really hard and their GSD grabs my brothers thigh with her mouth. She never broke his skin but she waited to make sure my brother understood to stop.

[@jaeger251]

That’s a great story. Thanks for sharing.

[@GreenWitch1]

Great story! I had a GS that was kidnapped 30 miles from home. 3 months later & 2 rivers, he made it home skin & bones. Most amazing dog ever!

[@TodayIFoundSomethingShiney]

My favorite dog growing up was my aunts German shepherd Rottweiler mix named Samson. He was 120lbs and he was an utter sweetheart with me and all my tiny siblings. I could rough house with him, pick him up, snuggle, etc. Someone tried breaking into their house. Samson took care of him. Dude was arrested at the hospital trying to say he had a motorbike accident. I was playing as rough as normal with Samson the next day

[@maegankaz4943]

I would love to see a video on how to train/condition dogs to be protective dogs without unnecessary barking or aggression towards friends/family.

[@samcresp5440]

Good introductions and distinguishing guests and strangers. Socialising is the key component. It can be as simple as teaching that when you say hello, handshake, etc, that’s a welcome. If there’s none of that present, go nuts. It’s a little difficult to comment what someone should do for their pet, but I wish you well

[@jaeger251]

Typically, trained guard dogs, are a bit dangerous to be family dogs. Best thing to do is, get a breed with strong guarding instincts as a family dog. If shut pops off, your dog will know what he has to do.

[@mattwarner8273]

My rottie cues off me, stranger comes to the door she will bark at them. If I invite them in i.e. a tradie, she will look at me then sniff them follow them around for a bit and then come back and sit next to me. No special training. She never barks at children though.

[@Ponygirl1111]

Yes 👍

[@lilykotzev2081]

A guarding breed generally dose not need this training unless your going for a professionally trained dog. If socialized enough they understand normal human behavior and abnormal behavior. If your friend comes over in the afternoon for coffee they aren't bothered if someone taps on a window at 2am that's a different story and they will react

[@MissTee4me]

I was thinking of getting a boerboel, however as a 140lb woman I think a dog pushing 200lb is a lot for me. So I have been debating what to get and after watching Prince- there is something so noble about him. I think he would be a great companion. I love how he’s excellent with the family- but definitely daddy’s dog.

[@alexandercameron1977]

Thanks Joel for your analysis. I have owned German shepherds, Airedale Terriers and now have a Rottweiler. Forty years ago I used body conditioning to let my dogs know if I was comfortable. My Rottweiler is loved by all 1500 inhabitants of my village but anyone who was aggressive or intimidating would be stared down by my girl “ Boss”. Boss would never bark or lunge , she judges the situation and acts accordingly. I love her!

[@johnestock7348]

You are spot on . I have a 110lb Doberman now . But when my children were little we had a 140 lb Rottweiler he was the best ! I could leave his leash on stroller walk away and god help anyone who tried to come near them ! The Rottweiler was from Germany and my Doberman is from Serbia . Keep the videos coming love them your techniques are awesome 👍

[@heidimonroe4444]

When I was researching breeds for a pet that provided home security. The three breeds I considered were GSD, Doberman, and Rottweiler. We ended up with a Dark Sable GSD and it's worked out for us. I agree that the black/brown and tan is inherently intimidating. Rottweilers were known historically for being nursery guard dogs, I think they have a bad reputation due to potential behavior rather than actual behavior.

[@marriahjustine]

My uncle used to breed Rottweilers and I was young enough to not understand that people thought they were scary. All I knew was the puppies gave me hickeys and that when I stopped petting the mom she would nudge my hand until I pet her again. It was a big surprise for me when I found out they’re seen as intimidating guard dogs and good at being exactly that.

[@elizabethjameson3231]

It's "bow"ceron like bow and arrow (I'm French and we had one when I was very little :) ) I was right about your top three, but the Akita surprised me. Once you said it, I could see why, though. There is just something about them, some kind of vibe, that is very off-putting to strangers. They're intense and they feel unpredictable and difficult to win over (ie, they're not going to suddenly love you forever if you offer them a cookie).

[@oui2826]

Je sais pas d'où tu sors ta prononciation mais c'est pas du tout ça

[@57colliegirl]

I would love to oi wn a Beauceron. But they are rare to find. Why is this? Thanks. I have a bi-color working line GS.

[@MinecraftKlepacz]

@@57colliegirl cause these are not as easy to "handle" comparing to other breeds. Mainly as Beaucerons mature at 2,5-3 years. The same applies to Giant Shnauzer (and this one also requires specific grooming). Beaucerons are more Independent than Dobbies, GSD, Malis/Dutch as for centuries had to work not only under direct owner supervisor , but also on their own. Beauceron tests/challenges the owner during the puppyhood - which lasts years 😅.

[@elizabethjameson3231]

@@05Sacredvalley apparently we pronounce "bow" differently lol

[@sidneybales9062]

@@elizabethjameson3231 I'm sitting here going... Bow... Beau... Bow... Beau. It's the same.....

[@myrnawaiters2191]

The reasoning behind choices on your list makes the most sense. After spending countless hours of KZbin research I ended up getting a Cane Corso. If I had read your list then Rotty would be my choice. Impulse control of my Cane Corso depends on some variables. If she is Hungry (she's food motivated), she becomes really jerky & a tad unpredictable. If she meets new people without having been exercised, un released energy makes her look and act more intimidating less controlled. She requires daily obedience training because she is dominate. She plays wayyy too rough when I'm not around. She isn't interested in making friends with dogs who are dominate or overly friendly. She does occasionally test her place with me. I have to put her in check EVERY time. I can't speak to her the way i do my other dogs. Nor can i be overly affectionate without making her work for it. The upside is my Corso is extremely smart, is very loving,learns very quickly, she aims to please, and can read the true nature of different humans. She loves every human she meets, yet there have been 1 or 2 she showed a display of aggression with. Suprised the he'll out of me. In hindsight I believe she did this because I mysel did not like the energy of those two strangers. She felt my spirit. Now I know i must maintain a peaceful spirit when outside the house.. She naturally knows when to protect me.

[@DD-hj3sj]

If you can handle your corso next time look into a presa Canario. A different caliber of dog and not for the weak but such an amazing breed for experienced protection dog owners.

[@bencoman]

Not making your list due to lack of size and intimidation factor, but just wanted to share a story of intelligent guarding by a Border Collie. I was 16 and my brother 6. We were play fighting with him hitting me with a pool noodle. Every time he hit me I'd yelp in mock pain. Our 18-month-old Border bolts from the other room straight at my brother, then suddenly pulls up just short of leaping on him - because obviously, he's family. After a moment of distress, glancing quickly back and forth between my brother and me (him still hitting me with pool noodle) she leaps up to grab the noodle, ripping it out of my brother's hand, and trots back to the other room to lay the noodle at my father's feet. Totally amazed the way she solved that puzzle.

[@crazedinkblot]

I would love to see you work with American Akitas! Ever since I started watching your videos (mid-August 2021) and trying your methods, I've seen a huge improvement while walking my American Akita (3-year-old female). Thank you so much!

[@sibeldjc1864]

Pretty sure at 06:22 you’re talking about “Senza Tempo Cane Corso”, I think she’s really great 🐾 Thank you so much Joel for each and every video, so grateful for everything I learn with you 🙌🏽🙌🏿🙌🏽🙌🏿

[@terridavis9278]

Yes ! Bosco, Prince and Preacher from Senza Tempo Cane Corso are the only dogs I have seen give corrections to other dogs that are not in their pack without having an actual fight. It is truly amazing to watch these three give corrections.

[@centralflife891]

Most of dog behavior I learned from her 🥰

[@DejanNovakov]

Regarding Cane Corso, I think that Bruce Wayne from Jason Corey is one of the best-behaved dogs I've ever seen kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4TTnpt9iMZ2etU of course there is a lot of work put into this dog

[@shawnadavis7434]

Commented just recently saying Senza Tempo Cane Corso. She needs more recognition for her beautiful pack of Corsos. I’m a daily watcher on her channel. Thank you for bringing her channel to viewers on here :)

[@NA-su3jk]

Any channel that has dogs interacting will have dogs correcting each other. Look up Brandon Fouche channel, you will love it.

[@franjohnston9492]

I have 2 Leonbergers, just standing back from the gate watching keeps people out.. great list .. I enjoy your videos..

[@mambashay81]

Excellent list, especially your #1. Rotties are so special and take their main role of protecting their families seriously!

[@alexandradittmann8588]

Good one, Joel! I'd suggest Giant Schnauzers as well: for the list. Or, maybe, for a future extended list. Black, similar in format and breed origin than Rotties (both were originally cattle dogs and guardians, then police dogs, personal protection dogs and one of the breeds frequently trained for Schutzhund in Europe). Don't know, though, how popular they are in the US. Naturally protective, kid-friendly and fearless. I grew up with one, so I'm biased. But 80 pound, jet black Hasso was infallible when it came to evaluating potential guarding situations. Chased would-be burglars off the land and charged a suicidal guy who thought pushing a teenage girl around on the street was the way forward. That was at 6 months of age, prior to any of his Schutzhund training. Sometimes, my best friend (also a teenage Schutzhund-trainer at the time) stayed over, and the Schnauzer loved her to pieces. But whenever she went about "testing" him by shoving and play-boxing me (without my invitation, as this could have gone very wrong), he'd act very measured: Entering the space between me and her, pushing her back by jumping up and taking her arm into his mouth. Gently, never biting down. And vocalising in a loud mixture of growl and howl, probably to signal he didn't really want to hurt her. Only reason I don't have a Giant Schnauzer right now is they are generally very intense, boisterous and stubborn; not easy to manage. Instead, I picked a German Shepherd and an Estrela Mountain Dog. The Estrela is a naturally highly suspicious livestock guardian (and almost unheard of in the US, I think, but well-known here in Portugal), and the Shepherd backs her up whenever there is something potentially unruly going on. I guess, having a Dobie or Rottie nicely combines the natural guarding aspect and the ease to manage you'd have from a Shepherd, but not from a livestock guardian or Akita. Friend of mine has an Eastern European Doberman weighing 110 pounds; he says many of these lines are very "old school" in that dogs are far more aggressive than the average modern Dobie. Heavier and taller, too.

[@mikeybally4338]

I had a 125lb rottie x Doberman. Super smart, loyal, loving but ya, he was protective. Never had to show his teeth or bark or growl but when strangers approached he was very cautious. Training was a must the first few years of his life. I always felt safe that’s for sure. RIP Chip

[@eeotchbay]

I have owned Rottweilers, Dobermans and Cane Corsos love all three of these breeds. The best dog ever was my dobie, she was beautiful, intelligent, adored my kids and very protective of all of us. We were so lucky to have her for 12 years. A very close second is my first rottie, who was just wonderful with my kids. The story shared about the grandpa and rotts being on a different level reminded me of a similar experience. My twins were just home from the hospital and we had several family members over to welcome them. My rottie boy was always good with people, but always watching and monitoring. My husband's aunt decided to pick up one of the babies. The dog backed her into a corner, staring her down, then let out a low growl. I took the baby from her, and he walked away!

[@ElizabethJW]

Rottweilers were my first thought when starting your video! They are amazing dogs. Love your top 5 list and I agree with it 100%!

[@jamesclark9347]

My Dogo Argentino is one of the best I have owned. Smart she is, one time is all you have to show her, it's there for life. Super good at protection, hunting off the hook, companionship is innate to her core, Definitely have a majestic competent look. I like that you mentioned the bull terrier one of the 10 that makes this phenomenon. Plus you get your 90 lbs . Instead of 40,Knowing dogs I see the qualities of the different breeds come out in her character/ mannerisms. Points quail,took her completely out of ingrained element to herd cattle and goats. Exquisitely ran off a pack of 6 coyotes without a full lockup engagement. They fricken new better. Talking about the reactive control over your dog. That was the best I have ever accomplished and personally witnessed. Oh and that thunderous bark is second to none. Drawback as far as your list is not well known. Plus their Spendy, 10 % deafness ratio.

[@tanishascott4501]

When I was little our family dog was a Rottweiler named Chewy. He was great with guests, only chased cats that did not belong to the household and was obedient to any in the family. There was once instance I remember that Chewy broke his chain, jumped our fence, ran across the street, jumped the neighbor's fence and chased a dog several blocks away then returned home. Come to find out that my brother's best friend was entering that yard, which an aggressive dog had made it's way into (I'm assuming to get to the female chow they had), the dog was growling as it ran toward my brother's friend and Chewy had managed to come between them before the dog could make contact. I have no doubt Chewy saved my brother's friend from a hospital visit or worse. He was an amazing family dog.

[@ErickMaciasJuarez]

Giant schnauzer is a lot of the things you want to have in a guard dog: size, speed, intelligence, impulse control, and one hell of a bite. My Bart's canine teeth are the size of my thumbs. And there's something about a dog whose eyes you can't see that makes that dog truly intimidating. Those beautiful brown eyes concealer behind the eyebrows.

[@niilespunkari8832]

One lady said once, "I never been afraid next to my giant schnauzer". A big statement.

[@Shamankzn]

The Boerboel. Bred specifically for home and family protection. Definitely has the look, the capability and the loyalty to family is unparalleled. The only issue that possibly marks it down is impulse control if the owner is uneducated and does not take the time to introduce people to the dog.

[@ravenbird3014]

Found a lost Beauceron one day. She was the most well behaved and loyal girl. She laid outside my apartment door. Walked around the apartment complex at my side. Perfect. I was sad to find her owner. I lived near a playground too and she never bothered the kids. I always contemplate getting one.

[@marelidutoit6191]

Oh my gosh, totally agree with the rotwieler. When I was 16 me and my friends were walking to the shop and 4 rotties came running towards me (i think they could smell my fear...) and all 4 was around my feet with this intense demeanor. Luckily my friend was brave enough to chase them away. My mom considered getting a rottie because growing up it was me, my mom and my sister so we needed a guard dog. She did research and asked the vets and in the end we got a Boerboel. It's a South African breed historically used by the boer to protect the farms. What is awesome about the boerboel is that they are the perfect balance between a family dog (loving, soft, couch potato) and a guard dog (protective of his humans and his property). All our neighbors had people breaking in to their home, but never once did they try our house. He slept inside, because there was a period were dogs were poisoned. Needless to say I slept like a baby.

[@alexandradittmann8588]

Ah, fascinating! Boerboels, wow, super-massive, these guys. Thanks for sharing!

[@Noahsark17]

Beautiful breed, South African beauties: Boerboel and Ridgeback

[@linaleon5734]

Rotties 🙌 I adopted a 7wk old rottie female. Baby rescue. She looks like a mean little bear in her puppy photo. At 7wks I had her outside playing. Some strangers were walking by across the street. My rottie stopped playing stood stoic and her glance followed them until they were way past. Then continued playing. A challenge to raise but the bestest ever. I learned so much from her. Never bit a dog in her 12yrs. A lover, not a fighter, but would stop two dogs going at it. Rotties definitely need firm constant guidance. They are a powerhouse of a dog. I can't say enough of how proud I was of her amazing attributes and the lessons gained. ❤️

[@Althemusicman1]

I think I would agree with your choice , something to note is that there is a big difference between "show-line" types and "working line" types, I have owned both throughout my lifetime (currently I have east German/Czech working German Shepherd's) and there is absolutely no comparison. I have seen working-line Dobes and Rotties in action and they are formidable beasts. I love the Akita also, like youself it wouldn't work in my current set up. Great video.👍

[@alangrnja5349]

Yes I agree I currently have 2 Rottweilers big male and female this is our 3rd female and honestly female Rottweilers just naturally protect the house and family great with kids if raised properly...my first femaleif you brought your kids to my house ...even if she never met them before...no one could go near those kids before I gave permission...love this breed! Great video

[@42cuba]

Love your list! It’s worthy for sure. I have a Belgian Terv, full male. He has this aura that he protects his bone with, when his ears go down that he can protect when he needs to. Currently at 60 pounds… conditioning is a big thing, you actually can do it with a bit of acting, someone in full black clad approach and cause a commotion at the gate. Do that once and set the dog off, it’s on for future if it occurs again.

[@bbt9592]

Agree 1000%. Calm, protective & powerful. Amazing control when attacked by pitbull. Rottie body slammed pit so hard and so fast, I didn’t even see it in front of my eyes. At a gas station, he growled, no bark, at suspicious person approaching my car and he apologized profusely. Not for everyone, must be able to handle him and be very patient. Most loving creature on the planet, neighborhood kids love hugging him.

[@joelhansen7373]

I have a 130 lb Bullmastiff that is an absolutely fearless protector, yet he also has incredible judgment about what level of intervention is needed. I have a friend he’s bonded to & she was at a party when a drunk guy was teasing her about licking her face (which she finds repulsive) He was pretending to run up on her & she was saying, “No, no, no” while holding up her hands as if to fend him off. Before he could take 2 steps my dog had gotten up & covered about 10’ so he was standing in front of her staring directly at her “attacker.” Never growled or barked. But he knew he was in trouble if he kept coming. My friend was astonished that my dog had protected her. But it was the perfect level of intervention. He’s fabulous with kids & understands kids roughhouse so he doesn’t intervene with them. He’s just a super mellow, friendly dog until his protection instinct is engaged. His only failing is as a property protector since he doesn’t bark. So no warning barks are given to scare away someone walking around my house. If they broke in he’d absolutely be waiting for them.

[@gregb1469]

I think he just picked the most intimidating mastiff type breed for the top 5, that’s why you got a cane corso. I’m sure he could have generically said mastiff but some mastiff breeds are better than others. All of the ones I’ve ever dealt with are giant couch potatoes.

[@joelhansen7373]

@@gregb1469 - my Bullmastiff is definitely a laid back couch potato who can also clear a 4’ fence from a standstill, no running start needed.

[@gregb1469]

@@joelhansen7373 they are about as athletic as a Rottweiler, which really isn’t saying much. But still nobody breaks into a house with a bull mastiff either.

[@yhap]

Presa Canario is my top guardian breed. Definitely has the size and the strength. Also for sure one of the most intimidating looking dog breed out there. They are born with natural protection instincts and they are always alert and watching, they are also extremely intelligent and have impulse control and can read situations well. They are a little harder to work with than most of your other typical guardian breeds because of their intelligence and independence, but if you put in the work there is no rival IMO. They are also one of the breeds I think is on another level completely.

[@meganramsey2469]

Love that Akitas made the list! They are fantastic dogs! I will agree with someone else who commented that ours doesn’t like to be separated from us (his pack) and he’s an inside dog for sure, but we make sure he gets plenty of exercise outside and mental stimulation inside as well. I was actually going to ask your opinion on the breed before I saw this video so I’m glad I saw it! It would be great if you ever did a training video exclusively on Akitas.

[@ticklishgirl1]

Doberman for sure! My boy Argo is an 86lb dobie and he is insanely good at reading and sensing my body language and emotions, like you said, they can distinguish between good and creepy people very well. A while back I was walking him around the neighborhood and this guy that looks really unkempt and clearly high or drunk was walking towards us, Argo would not take his eyes off of him. As he is walking past us he reached out to try to take my phone out of the front pocket of my jeans, Argo bit his hand and shook him a little. Guy left running like crazy. I take my dog everywhere with me and people can say hi to him, but if I feel nervous around somebody in specific he immediately stands in front of me and mean mugs the person so they dont come any closer. I am a very ticklish person, when my husband tickles me I scream.... a lot. Argo just pulls him off by his clothes, he never tries to bite him. I totally agree with you on shepherds, this poor breed got messed up in recent years.

[@rhymhizsong4214]

good2know! thx.

[@claireabbott6112]

I am pleased the GSD made the top 5 :) I cannot say I love the breed from a protection perspective - but they have it - My last female saved us three times, including my young son being mugged - my recent boy saved me twice from difficult situations. But I like their work ethic, ability to succeed in almost any sport, and ability to herd my animals. Versatility is what I adore - and the bond with them is amazing. I live in the UK and have not noticed any lack of temperament. They are so much more than just a dog for protection. I shall get and post some vids of my boy correcting others ;)

[@user-il9ze9py8c]

GSD's are great. They don't really excel at any one thing, but they do everything pretty well, and in my experience, have a very solid off switch. My only issue with them is the ungodly amount of shedding.

[@Angel_with_an_a_89]

I love that you mentioned about conditioning for a dog. My rottweiler is very sensitive at the mo but I do a quiet huff which she did as a young pup when she was getting alert so now I can do that and she is prepared which is perfect if I am out or home alone but being young she thinks she has to act on everything which is hard to reassure only on my alert or essential not when workmen are in the house lol

[@nataliechristensen420]

Dobermans make good protection because they are able to make decisions. I personally feel like Rottweiler would be second but that’s just my opinion. All of the dobermans that we have had have been amazing. We didn’t even have them trained for protection but they knew when something was wrong. My mom grew up with a Doberman that met a group of kids at the front door when they were trying to force their way into my moms house.

[@joehouse3800]

Dobermans are extremely Intelligent, athletic, energetic. I'm 60,and never had to train even 1 of them for protection! It's just natural for them! They need to be socialized. They are very in tune with their humans.

[@joehouse3800]

Also don't buy them from a back yard breeder!!

[@nataliechristensen420]

@@joehouse3800 agreed

[@kimmywimmy7305]

I knew Doberman and Rottweiler would be on there. Love the Ridgeback for an honorable mention. Excellent list, I am in agreement. I might put cane corso as two and Doberman as three. Super intimidating looking.

[@sarahtara5546]

Yea, I can definitely respect your list. I have a German Shepherd. He does guarding very well, though. He always puts himself between me and any perceived threat, and he puts himself in a very confident and intimidating stance. He will also run right up to any perceived threat to warn them, if given the chance. I've had many people think he was threatening, but at the end of the day, he is a sweetheart to most everyone he meets. I will also say, my Siberian Husky is better at guarding than most people might think, too. He may act very aloof, but he is always aware of me, and if I am ever in distress, he won't hesitate to attack if needed. I have been in situations where it was called for, and he went after the threat right away.

[@kace9075]

I was thinking about Huskies :)

[@sarahtara5546]

@@kace9075 cool. Yea, I'm not the only one I have met who had a protective husky, either :)

[@fredcabral5779]

Great list! I have Dobermans and I agree that you don't need to condition them. They know what to do, by instinct. I could mention the Mastiff Neapolitan as powerful as the Rottweiler (maybe more). This guy really scares and is ready for action. There is something I love about this breed, which is self-confidence and agility, despite its size. They look for a strategic place and watch the entire perimeter, silently, arriving very quickly if necessary. I receive my friends (both with the Doberman and the Mastiffs) with peace of mind, at home. My LIST(by my experience): 1- DOBERMANN (they go beyond frightening by appearance, they anticipate it, strongly demonstrating their aggressiveness to strangers.) 2- NEAPOLITAN MASTIFF (Most scary, fearless, balanced) 3- ROTTWEILER 4- CANI CORSO 5 GERMAN SHEPPARD You channel it's in top 3(not distinguished) THANKS from BRASIL !

[@bbt9592]

100% Agree with the Rottie! Mine is intuitive and he thinks before he acts. He is the friendliest dog until someone poses a threat to me or a family member. When I take him to Home Depot, he gets a lot of attention: others pet him but stays on-guard & glued to my side. It is our first protection dog and extremely lucky to have him as an emotional support companion. HOWEVER, Rotties are not for everybody, they require a lot of stimulation/attention, must be strong & patient because ours can sometimes be stubborn. If you are not home often, (seriously) forget about getting an adorable Rottie.

[@mercydog4866]

Thank you so much for this! I've been watching your videos for a while now, but never commented. They've helped me out a lot. I'm a dog trainer and I'm moreso into the 'protection dog' training. I would love if you made more videos on this catagory about the right temperament for protection dogs or just your take on it in general. As for my top breed, it would be the Mali. I got a real life experience with one of them up close practicing in the bite suit and wow. The control and power of these dogs. I had on 2 sleeves and still had light bruises on my arm and it was a retired dog. It was just an experience to say the least, especially when the owner gave commands like barking to intimate. You could just see the drive oozing out of them when they take the dog out for practice.

[@TonyBlount]

Ridgeback is a great guardian but I agree they aren’t popular, and more hard-headed with training but very discerning. I trust mine with my family when I leave for work. He’s shown us when the occasion calls for it, he turns from cuddly couch potato to an absolute beast.

[@EvanDunn]

I'm glad Cane's made the list, I've had Rotties growing up, bully breeds, and work around k9 dogs. Corso's have more then any breed I've been around have a very natural personal protection instinct, before she was ever trained to do so, my girl would position herself between me and any person walking down the street and essentially stare into their soul.

[@Whydowegivenames]

I have never had one but yeah they have the look!

[@DD-hj3sj]

Look into the Presa Canario. Protection instinct is miles ahead of the Cane Corso

[@Skinard14]

Keep up these unique video ideas. Really helps to hear your input on and comparison of different breeds

[@Anoiny]

The stories you told with the Rottweiler, I had similar things happen with my Rhodesian Ridgeback. Very good guard dog IMO. Furthermore they are incredibly intelligent - well socialized RR can automatically tell who is good and who is bad. We could easily leave our RR alone with small kids, kittens, birds, even an escaped hamster at one point and the dog became a total mamma. Wouldn't even let kids near water and he would in general drag people out of water. He would chase hares and cats when outside but when he cought them, he just sniffed them and let them go. We thought he wouldn't hurt a fly (although he caught flies, so bad analogy, but you get me). But then our garden got infested with huge rats - and the dog killed all of them. I witnessed one of his kills and he was a completely different dog - in hunt mode he had a completely different aura - a very scary one. He knew exactly what was a prey and what was not. And with people he was the same. Most people we met, even homeless people, he was friends with - and those people were good. But he absolutely hated drunks. And occasionally he went into his terrifying guard mode with some people we met on a walk (who I later learned from an officer friend were actually known criminals checking out neighbourhoods) - like we could still hold him on a leash (a very tight one in those moments), but the look he gave them, the growling and the posture gave off the right signals you want from a guard dog. Before we got him, some of our neighbours houses got robbed like 10 times in total. After we got him - no robberies. He was very visible behind the fence, jumped almost above it and passersby always felt like he could break out easily. The grandfather story you told - I had a few very similar experiences with my RR. He didn't like anyone in our household to show aggressive behaviour towards anyone from the house. And he would get in the way, take away weapons from peoples hands, bark - and if things were to escalate I'm sure he would protect the weak and bite the stronger one. Yeah RR's might look more beautiful and elegant than what you expect from a guard dog - but with their size and the muscle they look the kind of cute that can also bite your arm of. You would still be crazy to try anything with them around. They are intimidating.

[@Anoiny]

But you did make me thing about getting a Rottweiler next - I do want to get to know more dog breeds and also heard good stories of them. But to me they always looked way to cute and good hearted.

[@khaliljohnson4815]

i love the Dutch shepherd, not as big but has tons of energy. with the high prey drive and willing to make its owner happy it will be a good guard buddy

[@mskatefish]

And so clever

[@jonstrickland4848]

53 years old. My family started their pharmaceutical business beside our house back in 74. They distributed solely to Nursing Homes. We lived in a very rural area and yes, we had a pharmacy with lots of narcotics. Three of the dogs on your list we had in the 70s, GS, Rott, and Akita. There was always two dogs at minimum. My folks got us an Irish Setter as a companion only to run through the woods with etc. The only dog that ever bit anyone was our Irish Setter. Not making this up. He wasn't trained for protection or anything the like. However if you moved wrong that dog was on you. Great with us very protective of us. To this days childhood friends laugh how everyone was worried about our Rott or Akita but that damn Irish Setter would light you up! Good list I could list a separate list with none of those but still a great list.

[@trinaalurac1131]

Growing up I had German Shepards, Dobermans, and Rottweilers All wonderful dogs I have always felt safe with. Past 30 years we have had 2 Old English Mastiffs. Look, Size and the calm they have. Not a high-energy dog. Can live in Appartments if you walk them every day. I thought our first would never protect me. Our Neighbor had two large Rottweilers one male one female. When they escaped they would attack dogs and chase people in the neighborhood. I was laying in the front watching my children play and the large male made a beeline toward my children. Duke stood up and put himself between us and the other two dogs. He grabs the large male by the throat and pin him to the ground and laid his 200-pound body mass down on him till he stops moving. He let the dog up slowly and they left our yard. He did this with such calm. If a stranger came near he would place himself between us and turn sideways. He never staired them down but his mass and look made people take notice of him. Our dogs have been wonderful with livestock, Children, and guests. I am working with an Argentine Dogo Right now and they have twice the life span of the Old English Mastiff. Dogo's are growing in popularity and have been bred to be family dogs, independent thinking, work in a pack, and design for boar hunting. They have a size look and intelligence that has me falling in love with them more and more each day. We are at the trigger period of 8 months. Wish me luck I don't mess him up.

[@simonquy896]

Just found your channel. Think it is great, practical no nonsense advise and really interesting how you get into the psychology. As a recent ridgeback owner would love it if you did a deep dive into the breeds. Big thumbs up from the U.K.👍

[@lesliecunningham5293]

I found a brindle Catahoula stray and in her hay day she weighed 45lb- she wasn't much of a barker but quite territorial with other dogs. I have never had a dog since that just with her stare ( no growling, barking or pulling) could make people walk wide around us like she could. I always felt safe

[@ChildofGod474]

I've owned 2 Rottweilers. One we bought from a breeder, the other from a shelter. Both were very protective of us, without being obnoxious or using bad judgement. Mine loved water, playing "hide and seek" and being monster lap dogs. They loved our kids, and were so sweet and loyal. Our first girl died of cancer, the second died while we were at church (60 acre farm). I still can't look at video of a Rottweiler without crying. They are the most amazing dogs.

[@susieparadis1505]

I’ve had 3 Dobermans, 2 were rescues, totally loving and trustworthy with my small children. I currently have an AKC GSD who is totally neurotic, but we love him.

[@blaketyler6991]

My number one is the belgian malinois. My mal is super protective of me, my family, and my stuff (truck, house, ect.) I take her to work with me every day and she's very well socialized with people but as soon as I give the command she is ready for whatever. We had a guy running in the store once and just the way he carried himself and the look on his face, made me feel like we where gonna get robed. As soon as my mal came around the corner he stopped and started to ask about something and was stumbling on his words and finally just left. I know people say don't judge a book by its cover but come on this guy looks like he just got out of prison. I'm thankful for her and I'll always have a mal. Plus they are the smartest breed I've ever been around in my opinion! Love the vids! I hope to become a trainer one day and your content helps!

[@Rinchiio]

Would never choose another breed. Never seen anything response they way this breed does. But you have to know how to handle them and I think that's why so many people find them "difficult".

[@binary]

Amazing breed but most can't handle them

[@tracys.5143]

Our security system is one Rottweiler + one GSD + one Labx, and I feel very safe. :-) All of them are very soppy and lovely with us as family members, and protective and capable of being full on fierce to strangers. Was interesting to hear your list, thanks. I love your Prince, and am warming up to the breed.... :-)

[@Yeoman7]

I have a chihuahua and a Rottweiler 👍

[@rayj33]

Add some Chipotle sauce in there too

[@hilja33]

I agree nothing like having a family guard dog/dogs to help you feel safe.

[@viajero1004]

I just started the video, I’ll be writing as I watch. I haven’t seen the breeds yet, I’m expecting Rottweiler to be there, if not then it’ll be hard to trust your opinion. So far I agree with everything I hear. It’s pronounced Bow-sir-Ron. Ok GSD is alright at 5 maybe, I agree, let’s see your next ones hmm. Yeah akitas are good, harder to train though, more independent. Yeah Cane Corsos make a great #3, they are the most obedient & trainable mastiff. Dobermans are good, nice choice, you just have to get a good line & train- quick fact though- the rumor that they have 600 psi bite force is bs though. DING DING DING!!!! Rottweiler yes! ok you know your dogs & have my respect. You know what your talking about! You have a new subscriber! Ok the honorable mentions let’s see- American Bulldog yes! Ridgeback yes! Mention Rhodesian though so they don’t confuse it with the Thai . Nice video!

[@cheryljergens9970]

My sister-in-law had a Rott named Ruby. She went everywhere with her. Linda had a horse with a new colt. The horse thought Linda was trying to take her colt away and grabbed her waist. Ruby jumped up and head butted the horse and it dropped her. There was no command given. She did it by instinct.

[@alexandradittmann8588]

Wow, wonderful to hear true tales like that. With a Rottie, you certainly don't have to fear assaults from man or beast... My livestock guardian dog (Estrela) recently jumped out the bathroom window (close to the ground, so, no harm done) when 2 misguided neighbour's dogs chased "her" horses. The German Shepherd went out after her. I was third - using the door, though, not the window. Between the 3 of us, we chased the other dog's back to their own doorstep. They were cured from their desire to hunt horses after that...

[@ltpdogtrainingNJ]

Awesome story!

[@notesfromleisa-land]

Hah...I have a sister with a Rott named Ruby. My sister's name is Linda and she has a horse....but no colt...for a minute there. Ruby was a lovely dog. I had a Rottweiler, Dieter, and he was the sweetest boy, but you would never want to test it. He was so good with my young children...he watched over them and went with them wherever they were.

[@rhymhizsong4214]

​@@alexandradittmann8588 StoryTelling Award 🥇😅

[@kasiagren5033]

Thank you for this video and for mentioning my breed, a beauceron (btw pronounced bo-ser-on). I was looking for a healthy sporty breed, with great herding and protection abilities. They're also calm and affectionate. They have the looks of a dobrerman and a rottie. We can't crop ears in my country, so they look less scary, but they're still intimidating. I travelled all across the country to get my girl. They're really rare, but they're there and they are worth noticing :)

[@MinecraftKlepacz]

Beaucerons are rare outside of France. They would make No 2 behind Rotties. They guard and protect their family and property without any training. If properly socialized they perfectly dustinguish what is normal and what needs attention and further reaction. I remember one late evening in the park when my Beauceron run out from bushes when she felt nervousness in my voice when responding to a questions asked by a bit drunk man. She stopped at my side with a low deep, yet not loud, growl. The Man stopped taking and stepped away, when he was 3 steps away she stopped growling, but still observed. When he was 10 steps away she "lost interest" and went back to running in the park. She has never had any pro tection training. These are GREAT dogs, but not for novice dog owners.

[@apriluplinger5490]

I had a pit bull that was a great guard dog. She got in anyone's face who made threatening moves towards her family. She would use her "scary bark" but never bit anyone. She had the look, muscular and solid. People were afraid to come into the house until I introduced her to them. I am an elderly, disabled woman who lives alone and slept knowing I was safe with her by my side. I can't wait until I can get another pit bull.

[@con-can571]

YES!!! I love this list. I have always had Rottweilers, they are the best dogs ever. My daughter is in Jiujitsu and if we want to practice sparring, I have to keep track of the dogs. They are a "referee" dog. I totally agree with your list. I've had clients with German Shepherds and they seem to be really popular with people who don't seem to want to exercise them enough. Your assessment of Dobermans are bang on. I am a short female and have come across Doberman's who's head is the same level as mine, I don't want to mess with one of those. Many folks would put a Pit Bull on the list, but I have one, and although he's barking at the fence, his tail is wagging anyone who knows dogs can tell that he's not going to bit you...but those who don't know dogs will stay away. He's the front man and the Rotti's are the enforcement. You have the best channel on youtube.

[@ElephantPatronus]

We have an American bulldog/boxer mix. He is the sweetest boy and has been such a wonderful family dog. His face is very serious and he is intimidating looking. I've had people cross the street rather than pass us on the sidewalk. Recently we had an appliance delivered and the big delivery guys didn't want to come into our house when they saw Finn staring at them from behind me. And our boy is an older dog now at 12 years old. He's still got it. None of these people have any idea what a sweet teddy bear our Finnegan is. 🐶

[@WarriorWisdom]

Great list! I actually have all 5 of yours on a top guard dog list video I did as well (before seeing this). And personally speaking, of your 5, I have owned two of them (Akita and Rottweiler). Both were great. However, the Rottweiler was indeed on another level. I could go on all day about him, but I'll just sum it up by saying he was AMAZING!

[@youwillneverguess]

Bullmastiff would be in my top 5. Their calm confidence to step between you and someone they feel is a bit shifty without growling or barking but the look lets everyone know they mean business. Their presence is enough to give anyone pause and an opportunity to reconsider their life choices.

[@niilespunkari8832]

I tried to pet my neighbor bull mastiff, it (she) said "grooo" and I kept on walking. lol.

[@bluepeach8376]

My German Shepherd is amazing. Never had an ounce of protection training but guards me perfectly.

[@botchgoddess]

I've had shepherds and a rott, and I completely agree with your placement. I'll never have another dog that I loved as much as that rott. He was majestic :). Here's a contrast between the rott and my current dog, husky/shepherd in how they reacted to my ex husband lol: The husky/shepherd goes nuts, no control, barks his head off, never really gets used to him. The rott would put on a show when he first came over, and then calmly and effectively just guarded. He wouldn't do anything overt, but the vibes were like sure, you can sit there, just don't try anything. Just pet me some more. And then if I walked in and said his name, his ears instantly went down and he was my bubby again. They are my favorite breed. I found out after he died that if there had been an incident, my homeowners insurance would have paid it and then dropped me, because apparently there's a list of dogs they don't cover, and rotts are on it. So no more rotts for me :( Edit: Oh yeah, I forgot to mention, I was never worried about walking into the house when I had the rottie. I knew only a crazy person would try to come in and if they did, they'd be shortly missing an appendage or two.

[@Tj-cg5bi]

I had an Akita for 10 yrs. Absolute Best dog Ever...Super protective, but awesome with kids and other dogs!

[@sebastianbarlutiu9273]

I'm a dog trainer in Italy and i love your vids btw.. however I have a border collie and he is a good guard dog (makes a lot of noise) and i have a malinois and I he is just at another level..just by looking at him u know u don't want to have to do nothing with him..the barking, the physical presence is just at another level.

[@Rinchiio]

100% - there are times I'm almost scared. The sound. The speed. Never seen anything like it. If I didn't hand feed from little I would probably pee my pants.

[@danielhendrickson9257]

We had a rottweiler when our kids were young. One day their cousin was over playing with them on the floor and he started tickling my youngest (about 6 yo at the time) My son started giggling and screaming a little. The dog came up behind the cousin and opened her mouth on his neck. No bite, no broken skin, just an open mouth and teeth touching his neck. He immediately stopped tickling, my son stopped screaming, and the dog backed off. Marvelous impulse control, completely instinct. The dog never had any formal training. Best dog for protection ever.

[@cherylwmh6543]

I think it depends on the "look" of the German shepherd. I have a huge black German shepherd that is SO scary looking. But yes there is so much variation in the breed that many don't have that "look" anymore.

[@xslabcabxhearsex]

I was thinking the same thing. I’m in my 50’s and have had German Shepherds most of my life.all were rescues and they knew what you have done for them.they all were extremely protective and guarding the house.all had the look he is talking about.when there hair goes up and teeth showing no one is going to approach

[@kamilanowakowska9269]

I agree with the "look" maybe Im little biased single I on two GSDs but when they aren't from a hardcore show line like the ones here in Europe or they are from working lines they look like they do mean business and they akt like it too. And when soneone had had encounters with police force they'd be more intimidated by a GSD or a Malinois that are used there.

[@florme6494]

Favourite dog training channel. You say how it is, although I can see you sometimes hold back but it’s obvious when you do it. I feel you are extremely transparent and you work true to each dogs needs. I have a 5 month old Rottweiler and 2 German Shepherd mixes. I wanted a dog to protect the house with everything going on in the world. I’ve always rescued dogs hence the GSD mixes. However my wife and I were talking about security and we both felt getting a Rotti was a benefit to us all. I won’t go in to detail. But he naturally has the protective instincts even now. It’s very strange. He won’t bite but he is quick to alert and get between us and other dogs and people, this with absolutely no fear. The only down side is the life expectancy and the health risks that come with pure breads. Fantastic dogs. I initially leaned towards a Doberman, and my wife a Rotti. HWHL. The GSD mixes would do a great job also, but we wanted that intimidating factor so things don’t need to escalate.

[@sidneybales9062]

My friend has a couple of Bouviers. The female treated the kids like they were her puppies. She was the "pillow" when they watched tv and was always in the middle of the activity. The male was a bit more temperamental and wasn't wild about the children. He would often sit across the room or the yard and watch things. They have the size. They don't really have recognizability. The few I know had good impulse control.

[@Anon_E_Muss]

Bouvs are smart and need an experienced owner and lot of exercise. As well as grooming!

[@Mrcrowntown]

I grabbed a Tibetan Mastiff for protection of self and property. She is such an amazing dog that can live aloof until she's needed. She snaps right out of chewing her bone to alert at any noise by my front gate(I live on 6 acres, fully fenced in). She's all black and once she's done growing will look like a black bear, so the look will be there as I continue to train her and she grows(She's 6mo old and already 50lbs). I do think your list is accurate for solely personal protection, but I would say the tibetan mastiff would be a good contender for personal and property protection! Thanks for kicking ass and not letting the positive reinforcement groups sway your methods. Anyone who actually pays attention to dog body language knows that dominance is one of, if not the most important aspect to utilize in creating your 'pack'.

[@Flofloris]

Hi, mu uncle had an tosa inu. He was a male wich weighed 80kg, very reliable dog, family oriented and got along very well with other dogs (not that hard to train he said). Once i was introduced to the dog he was very friendly and kinda playfull. Butt he told me a story of an attempted burglery where the person was in the yard, dog barked, the guy wasn't impressed and tried to pass by but the dog just pinned him down on the grond and waited until my uncle called the cops. no bites, just some scratches from his nails.

[@edgarlaboy3692]

My Rottweiler she was 85 lbs and was extremely protective and loving. Loved the family and never locked the door or had gated windows. Agree about the breed and selection in this list. Agree what he says about how to go about training and what's natural about natural guard dog protection traing.