CGI Animated Short Film: "Shattered" by Suyoung Jang | CGMeetup

[@magnusthered4946]

“And here you see the world’s most inefficient factory that for some reason throws away 50% of all its output for no reason"

[@eagan_1902]

I was about to say this is the reason why 1 this was not award-winning 2 this is why the real world doesn't work like this because its stupid 3 if the world worked like this then them turning gold is probably them getting brainwashed 4 Fuck this entire Quandry with a jackhammer

[@doppelhelixes]

would have worked if they used chicken hatchlings and reversed the genders. But that would be logical...

[@felixjohnsens3201]

@@doppelhelixes But the male Chicken Hatchlings would not be simply destroyed, but used for Food...

[@doppelhelixes]

@@felixjohnsens3201 yeah no - you can buy frozen male chicken in bulk for cheap. Because they are 'trash' in those factorys. The reptile community can't use as much as the industry produces

[@jungoogie]

@@doppelhelixes "Reptile community" - Bit harsh. But deep in one form of rabbit hole.

[@spiritthesnowyowl8948]

For those that are confused. The female robots are not instantly getting scrapped, their job is throwing the actual scrapped robots into the flames to keep the factory going

[@nicolasdlcful]

XD

[@El1sejr123]

So like if they can’t do it do they get burnt?

[@Originalyoutubename2.0]

So whats the message?

[@xaviersmith5154]

​@Originalyoutubename2.0 not everything has a message. Or needs one.

[@Mindofanidiot]

Im pretty sure theyre keeping a furnace up so whoever is up there us getting warm and cozy, one of my proof that they are keeping a furnace up is in one part a group of female robots were spinning a gear

[@originalnameoriginallastna4266]

Company: "Let's make boy and girl robots but throw away girl and waste most of our metal and everything" "Uh, that w- " *S H U T* "

[@Rychard1299]

But i the boy guys

[@aubreyhaven8972]

Actually, the female robots aren't being "thrown away and wasted". They are being melted down and remade into more robots. It's symbolic to how women for centuries have been seen as only useful as a means to create the next generation, and having no other purpose but as baby makers.

[@LisaRowse]

The point.

[@Staniand_Virtanen]

Muslims: "Nice factory!"

[@parker-boy98]

I'd be like, "But I like robot girls. :(" I'd even make that goofy pouty face.

[@robllover2755]

The moral of the story...You should give everyone golden armor and jump boost.

[@elogsd1384]

True

[@Iris_zzz07]

Yeah true

[@vladimir2641]

Yes indied And Prise the Sun My friend

[@lilypad7778]

Lmao

[@Foundation-Is-Christ]

Preach bro, preach

[@Scotch7574]

I like the fact that nobody in the comments care about the message, but rather the robots design and the lack of efficiency of this factory. Edit: wow I can't believe i still get replies!

[@KaiWuckert]

Whats the message here?

[@Scotch7574]

@@KaiWuckert feminism.

[@NoRegs30]

@@Scotch7574 That’s not a message, that’s an ideology The message here is poorly conveyed which is what makes the comments a mess, most people come away confused and make a joke What I think the author is trying to say is that society puts emphasis on specific aspects of people and elevates them while keeping down other aspects which are innate to people, i.e. for females to work in making new “robots” and do nothing else What the creator fails to convey is that this also applies to males, it’s just that it applies in different ways, for example, the stereotype of the man is the hard worker who must give his all to keep his family together Both are bad and are in no wat reflected in the animation, which goes for a simplistic “women are forced to care for the next generation and have no choice in the matter” angle, which is completely untrue Are there morons who believe this, yes, but most people don’t believe this anymore This feels like an animation done before first wave feminism Or maybe the creator had a tremendously bad experience with the society they live in, idk

[@-insertarnombredeusuarioge7340]

The message is clear, the """metaphor""" is dumb and superficial

[@silverdededestruction2197]

@@Scotch7574 I think this film does a poor job of making a message about feminism since I cannot comprehend it after multiple rewatches

[@sethydeathy]

Robot: I will go through here Wall: Not with those thighs

[@LittleDeadlyBox]

What about female sex dolls without a hips?

[@CNMNbun]

Chun-li robot

[@ElitaTheCat]

Damn gurl

[@ElitaTheCat]

Thick thighs

[@stevenrobbins7458]

Fat shaming.

[@manuelgorraiz1785]

50% commets: T H I C K 50% of other comments: waisting metal

[@flashy902]

100% pixar

[@shardinhand1243]

facts matter

[@Obedthian-UK]

Pou

[@sallystandish7105]

They may be “waisting” metal but that WAIST (I was making a play on how you misspelled wasting)

[@Catrin3]

A webo :>

[@lettucedeity9326]

I remember when my little sister first came home. My dad said "better luck next time" and yeeted her into the bin.

[@shadowcarlos5541]

whaaaaaat?

[@shadowcarlos5541]

It's not for being rude but your father is stupid or what

[@matrixxxx235]

@@shadowcarlos5541 he's making a joke obviously

[@shadowcarlos5541]

@@matrixxxx235 nooo seriously, if you don't tell me I don't realize

[@SnowyBlizzard275]

r/thatjusthappened

[@antaresmaelstrom5365]

Another weird thing (to me) that I haven't yet seen in the comments is that the factory seems to be running on a weird stereotype system. The female bots all get massive thighs and a significant bust playing into a stereotype. But the male bots just stay stringbean almost default models. At equal stereotypes I'd expect a much wider chestplate and big upper arm servos or something.

[@victorangelbencosme8796]

Another with the brain made pudding

[@antaresmaelstrom5365]

@@victorangelbencosme8796 What?

[@xx_hivewars_xx9013]

Obviamente se refiere a que le faltó detalles al vídeo. Únicamente resalta la hipocrecia , es un buen comentario.

[@dadog1635]

@Kaya yaya you really think your have curves😟

[@Sparrow_Bloodhunter]

They're obviously making twink robots, the himbo robots are made on a different assembly line, instead of females that one accidentally makes fat dudes and shoves them in the fire hole.

[@razter6678]

Why would some machine create a female robot just to scrap it 15 seconds later?

[@Chilling_pal_n01anad91ct]

Machine is women. It's procreating people. They are meeting glass roof (glass wall), which is an obstacle for girls raise... But in the movie, main obstacle is girl's asses.

[@thejugernautkiller390]

@@Chilling_pal_n01anad91ct Two things... First they are creating something they consider it useless. What leads us to our second part WHY WOULD YOU BUILD SOMETHING WITH A FUNCTION THAT YOU WON'T USE!!??? Who teh hella is their guionist a kid with a very basic concept of the glass roof, equality, idk what more to put, etc...

[@Corghy]

The author is trying to make a metaphor. 'it's difficult for girls to be boys' No shit. It's difficult for me to be an elephant and use my nose as a trunk.

[@Chilling_pal_n01anad91ct]

@@thejugernautkiller390 nature and sociaty - different things

[@Chilling_pal_n01anad91ct]

@@Corghy i'm not sure about your theory... They are not trying to be boys. They are trying to get up: cover with gold and fly away..

[@zacharymarino8926]

all I can think about is the fact that this company wastes 50% of the material it inputs through something they themselves designed. and the fact that before we see her denied it was very clear that everyone got through

[@sutekina2066]

I don't think they thought of those things because they were trying to focus on the bigger main point of the video

[@willywiksaas3244]

Yeah! So What, it has a few mistakes. Oh, and BTW, did you not notice that they were forced to work a machine? So they DO have a purpose. (Eh, kinda.😅)

[@ira5290]

Willy Wiksaas and then d e a t h

[@lolanicolau251]

they generate the energy at the factory

[@lucaspec7284]

@@lolanicolau251 very inefficient process, they waste more energy pushing that cog that a dynamo could produce

[@punyachandna2271]

To everyone who's asking that "this is so illogical why would they produce the female robots just to throw them away", they are actually being sent down in the basement and being forced to do hard labour and they keep working there until they die of exhaustion. If you notice carefully they are pushing the cogs and they make the whole factory run whereas the male robots were "sent up in a golden armour". So I think it signifies that women in this society are treated badly and exploited even when they have such major roles in running the society and very often don't get the privileges that men get just because they were born in a different body and don't fit the society's "mould".

[@rinconusmc]

Yet in reality they don’t work nearly as hard and are indeed much more coddled. Characters should be reversed.

[@oliviapayne4983]

@@rinconusmc so you’re saying your own mother, who built, birthed, and raised you, was coddled?

[@rinconusmc]

@@oliviapayne4983 as compared to a male in her same position? Yes.

[@TOP0PERCENT]

I just don't find it "believable". Lol. Men didn't get everything handed to them. In fact, men had to do more to get democratic rights, like voting, than women had to. All women had to do was ask, and yes although we are equal and should share everything, doesn't mean men got everything easy. Compare this shit to today's standards, when men have the highest suicide rates, lowest graduation rolls, and they are hated by media and politicians just to seek female demographics validation, and they're also the most alienated in society, doing the hardest labours, when a woman can simply open an OnlyFans and start earning basic wages? Oh cool.

[@TOP0PERCENT]

@@sofiastunning8978 You said nothing with all those words..

[@ANganAnh]

Another message here is, if someone makes a change, people will follow you. It doesn't matter how hard something is, you need to put your heart in it.

[@schorltourmaline4521]

Yes, but that also applies to if the "change" you want to make isn't really a good idea. People are kinda stupid like that.

[@newblood5]

Then why even divide the robots by physical lines? There would be a much better way to write this story to play to your theory. This has focus, and that is "feminism"

[@Tim0feyK]

When I decided to change a thermostat, I was just yelled at

[@mnemosineastral3626]

Nah, the message here is wokesomethig...

[@DJdoppIer]

What video is trying to teach: "Feminism." What I learned: *_"MEGA THICC."_*

[@supremeknight5384]

Big brain

[@Az90110]

Pixar has influenced many

[@skarletstar]

I can't press the dislike button, people tried hard, animated robots, but ...

[@suyoungjang3345]

Oh well 😂 at least you noticed what I wanted to say. I’m glad🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@Leche-Paterna]

Nªsty

[@mosiden4656]

Moral of the story: Don’t have big hips

[@morphoblu4]

I get the message, but why would the factory waste metal and parts on women if they just gonna be thrown away?

[@suyoungjang3345]

KodyJett1 they actually work at the bottom of the factory. They are invisible, but they are the one who generate the energy for operating factory

[@swifty2550]

@@suyoungjang3345 Death!!😂

[@shilenci]

D de no entiendo ni una wea

[@markemmanuelbuenaventura4126]

Are you the one who did that short film? Nice

[@JustAGuyWatchingYoutube1753]

KodyJett1 they get reused

[@jasyon4149]

Moral of the story: dont cut in line

[@FleetosBurritos]

@Rainbow🌈 thats only little kids which are dumb, mature people know it isn’t true, also they’re joking

[@Thats_not_fair.]

Yes, true

[@Dzaiinay]

I taught! Moral of the story: Woman can be strong 💀😭

[@Pumpkin969]

​@@Dzaiinay who said that

[@Dzaiinay]

@@Pumpkin969 Me gurl why?

[@thememeking8079]

Thick thighs save lives is what I learned from this💀💀

[@That_Russel_Pup]

BRUH HELP 💀

[@пользователь3-к6э]

Кто заметил из русских , что на заднем плане играет советская песня"из чего же сделаны наши девчонки?" Или мне кажется... Кстати привет всем русским !😁

[@crekerlazgame6596]

забавно

[@gray-p86]

Да, это она. Даже в титрах указана🙂

[@MartMesyac]

Привет) я тоже узнала песенку. Из чего же из чего же из чего же... Сделаны наши мальчишки

[@densnayp]

неужели тут существуют русские?

[@Leviy4elik]

Из переглядок и мармеладок...

[@contentinmotion]

Moral of the story, women should work together to break the glass ceiling.

[@md.abdullahbinmurad9223]

😂

[@jax5498]

@@jiyakuches220 But this plot is kinda more weak and bit feminist

[@jiyakuches220]

@@jax5498 Kinda of...

[@cannonballjenkins2757]

@@jiyakuches220 To simplify to what we need, is Equality for everyone, Equality for religion, race, nationalities, etc. There were times when women weren't able to do things men did. I like to think that was in the past and think about the future with more equal rights for everybody

[@ToxicNoodle71]

Chihin Chan But why is this film reflecting the past that barely anyone alive now witnessed

[@DiosMaquina]

el corto mas progre de toda la vida, muy bonita la animacion, pero el mensaje es lo mas ilogico, incoherente y sobre todo PROGRE que haya existido.

[@bogartrodriguez6265]

Cierto

[@user-yj6gp1zt3x]

¿Por qué progre? A lo mucho es feminista

[@Karmarit-geo]

@@user-yj6gp1zt3x es la misma cosa al fin al cabo, se hacen las victimas y destruyen cosas

[@tec2138]

@@Karmarit-geo jaja les cae el vidrio como en la manifestación

[@matiascepeda5953]

Tuve que ir a c@g@r despues de eso.

[@The1sillygirly]

Sooo.. the message is that women must band together to get superpowers like boys?

[@krixpop]

Absolutelly ! Women want to work (and die) in mining industry, deep down there ! The same, they want to work in Building , road construction, carpentry , etc ! They fight for Women's right to work those dirty long hours jobs ! Equality !

[@farvision]

@@krixpop idiot

[@sesshomarulover02]

@@farvision how exactly is he an idiot? Are you trying to say a woman shouldn't do what a male does for a job? Then you sir are the idiot. What he says is true we woman want to work whatever jobs guys can do. We aren't weak like how some males think we are. I am a female that has 2 jobs because I'm taking care of a disabled mother while trying to make money to pay for bills and etc. Also females aren't just for making babies and females aren't made to stay in the kitchen either. Females are humans, we have feelings and case if you have forgotten. God made the first female from a male's rib cage. which was from Adam.

[@sesshomarulover02]

they are trying to say that a female is just as strong as a male

[@How_To_Drive_a_TARDIS]

@@farvision u upid idot

[@luikaus22_]

The message is womans just breaks everything

[@redrocket8062]

😂😂😂

[@limply6557]

The reason why they are getting scrapped

[@dickgravestonerahhh]

@@limply6557 the reason why you are a toy

[@shadowcarlos5541]

@@dickgravestonerahhh Friend, please study so as not to say feminist or macho comments, we already have enough that 50% of the human population is retarded

[@dramaticapoppy4173]

@@shadowcarlos5541 I agree with what you are saying about equality but you shouldn’t use the R slur because it is really offensive to people with disabilities

[@kingkaijuboygodjira3116]

Damn she Finna be the new elastic woman.😏😍

[@ChrisTheClownn]

Gay

[@kingkaijuboygodjira3116]

@@ChrisTheClownn indeed you are.

[@dragonnst]

@@ChrisTheClownnactually straight.

[@Koost495]

investors: what is the scrap rate at your male robot factory? engineers who put into production, in addition to male robots, also female robots without any coordination: yes

[@Savjoart]

Y'all I think it's about breaking the glass ceiling

[@nadirwoodson9321]

it is

[@arashsharifi5951]

@andrea no way how do u know that

[@moonlightprincess12]

@andrea literally all films have meanings :/

[@james_ceo]

@@moonlightprincess12 So if it has a assassin does that mean “Kill everything you hate”?

[@nuttynuts4601]

@@james_ceo Kill everything you're payed to hate ;)

[@yuki-thejaklix4554]

0:35 This scene is so cuuuuute❤I don’t why but everytime I see a difference between male and female i feel so happy😭💖 And yeah I don’t care really about the movie idea because now i don’t see anyone hates female

[@alphasimaed]

Create a beautiful Robo-Waifu. only to throw her away. What they were thinking!?

[@gremlinton9815]

the male robots were robo-speedwagons you don't need women when there's speedwagon

[@jameslorens915]

You my friend, are a man of culture

[@Yourdailycardriver]

*I think there was a feminist 7 year old in charge*

[@rodolfofarias913]

Sorry mister Johnson

[@ivanamaralyt3184]

In less than 15 seconds they discard them

[@hudyrudy8590]

oh, i think i get the message. : : : : : : Apes together strong

[@Metalbringer92]

GOOGA BOOGA! *smashes rock*

[@nilotadeu1840]

Return to monke

[@CentristGirl]

Monke

[@maxwellquipey1]

See, this person got it

[@sanidhyagupta7468]

This story also shows us the true meaning of the phrase 'unity is strength'.

[@race10ftw]

But for real who wants to throw away some T H I C C robots anyways

[@fw.fatherjamal]

Fr🤦🏾‍♂️

[@ingressman1992]

To all of those judging out there, this is possibly a presentation piece for any and all animation studios. Ringling college only expects the above average coming in and the best of the best going out because they get a kickback from studios for their "graduating or graduated" students. Not to belabor a point but each student puts their all into a short film and their portfolio to get accepted into good animation studios. Cartoons and anime ain't easy, especially a smooth full feature length movie, cut some slack and shove the sjw comments aside.

[@abstrusepaladin]

Gee almost good til the end there. The internet's general understanding of "Sjw's" is fabricated and loud, cropped, overscaled examples. You don't have to exaggerate the very real opposition.

[@errornull390]

I think someone payed for this obscure porn vid

[@postaldude39]

But what has that to do with gender?

[@EmmaTheSmol]

​@@postaldude39 they didn't mention gender because it is irrelevant to the point they are making. the point being that a lot of effort was put into this animation and people need to acknowledge that and not just judge and mock it. Regardless of the intent and message, it is well animated and that deserves credit.

[@elongatedmanforever1252]

​Did we see the same short??

[@sokaybraun2188]

Little did she know that the place the male robots were going was just a big stadium where they fight to the death.

[@BrunoHartmann-]

Seems like the masculine dream

[@TheXdante23]

This movie is as subtle as an elephant in a library 🤣 hilarious

[@unaninanine3743]

Good animation. Weak storytelling.

[@dixit_2060]

What weak storytelling are you serious

[@How_To_Drive_a_TARDIS]

They're really good at subtlety

[@grodon100]

@@How_To_Drive_a_TARDIS u mean absolutely

[@KaiReel23]

Its actually quite clear to me (story). Shattering standards of the world about women role in the society. Feminism if you need a quick term or a "cathegory-box".

[@jacobliu1274]

@@dixit_2060 The logic here its weak a machine follows instructions those instructions are made by humans for a machine to create 2 types of robots and only 1 be accepted is not what would be money efficient for coorperations nor (arguably since their robots) humane. As for the metaphor its just some femenist propaganda.

[@omega7057]

Tan sutil y suave como un accidente ferroviario

[@kole4ko]

Так странно слышать песню "Из чего же сделаны" в короткометражке, сделанной в совершенно другой стране. Приятно удивили, спасибо)

[@mareritt4688]

Я думала я одна это услышала )

[@jopokusiksmp8535]

Не не за Путина а за советский союз

[@leraanders3106]

Только данная композиция по-моему совсем не уместна к очень фемскому и бессмысленному мультфильму

[@midrim5228]

@@leraanders3106 Как раз наоборот, песня говорит о том, что девушки - сильные духом и крепкие телом, как и в фильме Настоящий феминизм - это не то, во что прекратили его неадекватные бабы, а то, за что боролись женщины раньше и чего почти добились, например, за работу, на которую не берут женщин (женщины-токари, женщины-пилоты), и это очень даже хорошо

[@2rbina_2rista_]

@@midrim5228 лол, сделали бы зарплаты равные и убрали бы тупые гендерные стериотипы... А так считай ничего не добились.

[@intensaemozine8330]

It’s kind of obvious it shows that people should be equal

[@DeathDragon-lh3rg]

It's Basically the 19th amendment and woman rights

[@ofal5124]

and they are equal arent they?

[@intensaemozine8330]

Ofal they are but some people aren’t in other countries

[@DeathDragon-lh3rg]

@@ofal5124 yeah all people are equal but the 19th amendment is when women get to vote

[@JanKowalski-un6kf]

@@ofal5124 no, they aren't... really

[@joyamaya6479]

Please this should be a movie, it’ll be great

[@grunt4943]

no not rlly

[@goofyTokarooni]

I actually think it would lol

[@spinosaurusstriker]

@@goofyTokarooni it would be very stupid

[@NikkiG1134]

Make it a war machine with guns no matter the gender because ultimately no one cares? ok. Make it woke shit? nah.

[@Better_call_Floppa]

It would be a great comedy

[@woffydoggy686]

I think the story it's... poor. Only puts tons of basic feminism on film and throw it to people.

[@md.abdullahbinmurad9223]

Agreed

[@jak8714]

Certainly the plot is weak, though I think it also feels very...meaningful. People talk about the unfairness of sexism, the glass ceiling, but when you think about it... Well, this video put it best. The glass ceiling means we're throwing away a tremendous amount of potential, every day, and for very little reason. If nothing else, the video says that very well.

[@thefurry7165]

@@jak8714 Being a man has it's advantages and downsides. Women can talk to any stranger and no one will think that they're doing anything bad, but when a man does, he must be a creep. Also, women can get angry and yell at men, but when men do that to women, they're misogynists and sexists. At least that's how it works in *our* society. The Islam is a whole different world.

[@jak8714]

@@thefurry7165 I am the last person who would say that any one gender has it easier than the other; if the video had been about a man getting badmouthed for his efforts at childrearing, I would be just as upset. And, certainly, men have their difficulties. I think the main difference (at least in this context) is that women aren't just facing unfair challenges, they are being kept *down*, forced into a state of dependency and weakness on an institutional level. Men might not have every advantage, but they still have so many that the words 'equal opportunity' have become a joke.

[@dragoncakebomb549]

WoffyDoggy oh can it shithead

[@ParkersPlayground]

plot twist: there are actually TWO lines in the droid factory, one for male droids, one for female droids, and there was a bug in the factory's computer systems that went unnoticed, and this bug caused 25-50% of the total output of the to AT RANDOM produce the wrong gender of the droid. the droids that are normally thrown away on each line are ones that either have an oversight or bug in their programming or are the wrong gender for that line of droid production. that is why we would see female droid disposal on the male line, and vice versa. and yes I was almost certainly high as a kite when I wrote this comment

[@doritodorito492]

Then it's a trans allegory I think

[@ryonatimefun7814]

I definitely would love to see more of this kind of stuff

[@jedrzejkoszewski4342]

I think i know how to change it to make it better. Firstly i would remove division of the robots to male/female (especially male/female symbols) and replace it with various robots in different shapes and sizes, each made for different job. Secondly i would change the glass wall to have more holes in order to fit the right robot to the right job. Lastly i would make the main character actually fit one of the holes, but not the one that she (or maybe he or it) wants to fit into and the reason that she is discarded is because she tries to go through the wrong hole. She would again end up in the incinerator but in this version there would be other damaged robots that either didn't fit any of the holes or tried to fit in the wrong hole. Together they would break the glass wall like in the original short or combine into giant mech that would break it.

[@cakewingdaisy3396]

The whole idea of the story is equality. Showing how men get the jobs and the woman have to sit and do nothing. Here it shows the woman robots working together to break free and o the same jobs as the men bots. Its supposed to show equality

[@yourfavoriteheritic6441]

@@cakewingdaisy3396 we get the story shown...... amazingly put together. but way to on the nose. if this came out a few years back... ok falls in line but in 2019. mainstream feminism has been falling apart due to internal strife. the only places left with a "glass ceiling" are those that feminist won't criticizes.

[@Akalim]

I like this a lot better!

[@lukelcs8934]

@@yourfavoriteheritic6441 Agreed. Honestly, man and women being equal is the status quo at this point, and most modern feminists are men haters rather than true supporters of equality. Sad how just about anything can get pushed too far these days.

[@LisaRowse]

Yes but that misses the point. It is meant to be succinct. Currently people don't get the message even with it being on the nose.

[@NotBrian420]

Like, This animation is metaphorically about women rights

[@D4y_Br3ak]

True

[@BunnyJolf]

@@D4y_Br3ak but it seems more like how stupid companies can be

[@D4y_Br3ak]

@@BunnyJolf why did you @ me?

[@NikkiG1134]

Companies until woman’s appreciation day

[@lefeline9192]

Es ironicamente gracioso porque los trabajos "sucios" y que implican gran esfuerzo fisico lo realizan en una inmensa mayoria los hombres, tambien es ironico lo de la montaña de "cadaveres" cuando la tasa de mortalidad tanto en suicidios, accidentes laborales y en accidentes cotidianos tambien es mas alta en hombres, es mas, puedes interpretar esto como una alegoria a la guerra, donde las mujeres trabajaban en las fabricas reemplazando a los hombres en la mayoría de labores porque estos eran llevados a la guerra a morir (Porque a muchos se les obligo a ir sin entrenamiento real).

[@elmaestropanda3381]

Aparte de que la fabrica desperdicia recursos en crear robots mujeres para usarlos como combustible, tendría céntimo si fueran robots defectuosos o que están en mal funcionamiento pero seguiría siendo ilógico

[@JohnQuezadaHuayamave]

@@elmaestropanda3381 toda la razon.

[@lulu7425]

A teoria da guerra faz mais sentido. Os robos masculinos vão à guerra e as robos femininas são usadas como combustível... mas e depois? Quando elas quebram o vidro e saem livres? O vídeo é legal mas não faz sentido

[@dervarre]

In reality, a large number of male chicken chicks are killed at a tremendous speed even at this moment. lmao

[@Felinaondrugsmiumiu]

And a lot of baby girls are getting killed in Islam bc they are seen as embarrassing especially when it's the first born normally the women giving the child would also get killed

[@zombieman333]

​@@FelinaondrugsmiumiuI know, we organic beings are beyond of cruel.... I hope that the robots take over this world and make something better from it!!!

[@doritodorito492]

these are not chickens

[@ИсаКапаров-е5ч]

​@@Felinaondrugsmiumiuwtf are you talking about? Where is in Koran say's kill baby girls?

[@theAlphatron]

The visuals are great, music was very good, and the premise seems compelling until you actually stop and think for a few seconds...lol I enjoyed it otherwise but perhaps do another version where the premise is more clear and concise. I see what this was trying to say but it failed to really say it in a compelling and clear way. As it stands there are more questions than answers here.

[@ahumbledude757]

its just a metaphor i guess. at first i saw a sex toy factory but it all comes to being a metaphor

[@LisaRowse]

It was very clear to me when I frist watcher it. As with all things interpretation is key. It is clear to me because I have experienced this.

[@razyel7550]

FEMINAZIIIIIIIIIIIIII

[@mansfieldtime]

For those that may question this. It is probably the best representation of the late 1800 to the early 1900 England. Between 1500 and early 1800 women could not only join but run guilds. In the 1700 men started treating women very poorly. While English women never had the right to vote before hand, now they were being removed from their earned positions of power. It stayed that way till 1918 when English women fought for and one the right to vote. Yes this was WW1 and when men returned to England many things were changed so both they and 30+ year old women could all vote.

[@NikkiG1134]

Cool

[@baconsir1159]

Hmm, I _wonder_ what the message could _possibly_ be? All jokes aside, the animation and designs are quite beautiful and visually appealing. Shame it’s being used to push an obviously ridiculous narrative.

[@emberkeil6513]

"Any narrative that doesn't fit to my extreme standards are ridiculous and don't make sense, if it doesn't make sense to me, it doesn't make sense to anyone"

[@MrAhkmid]

Kind of just a generic message of empowerment, don't really see what's wrong with that.

[@baconsir1159]

@@emberkeil6513 I thought the sarcasm in the first sentence was pretty obvious, but I'll clarify for you. I know very clearly what it is saying, and what it's saying is ridiculous.

[@emberkeil6513]

@@baconsir1159 You seem to have not read my message, I'm clowning on you because you say that women empowerment and the breaking down of gender roles is "ridiculous"

[@officiallyrandom2614]

@@emberkeil6513 Ok I know I'm late I'm running on Nutella rn so this may be all over the place but... When did they say that female empowerment was ridiculous? There's a difference between a message and a narrative. A narrative is just what the story is while the message is conveyed through said narrative. The narrative in this case is that the factory is making female and male robots, but only discarding the female ones. Now the message is that females should rise up, cool. But the narrative for it just doesn't make sense. Why would a factory throw away half of what it makes? Why make females in the first place? This is what this person is saying is ridiculous. Oh jeez that was an essay

[@seich-of-lacan-getter514]

A true hero is someone whose actions inspire others to take action

[@sariabirkin7068]

Are you a true hero? ♥

[@CNMNbun]

@@sariabirkin7068 no

[@NikkiG1134]

The replies made me chuckle

[@antonioevascojr.4308]

*CLANK**CLANK**CLANK**CRUNCH* YEOOOOOOOOOOWCH

[@IKnowYou457]

I love this, or at least the idea that one person with an idea can try and try and feel like they haven't made any progress, but others see it and join in because they have.

[@nicho.7400]

Why make something if you gonna destroy it seconds later lol

[@keredo854]

good question lol, not only for this factory but also for places where they do treat women like trash. like why are they created if you won't let them participate in society ?

[@Whatingodsname]

i ask that question to my little brothers all the time

[@cannonballjenkins2757]

@@keredo854 This video wont even reach to those countries tho. The countries that treat women as trash are usually in the middle east and some parts of Africa

[@-l-l-8801]

People who draw and have self esteem issues: *profusely sweating*

[@NeonRahkshi]

Why make *Lot's of* something, if you are going to destroy it seconds later?

[@ElMurfy1987]

El video tienen buena animación y el mensaje de romper las barreras está bien, pero me falla 1 cosa: Y es que para hacerse dorado tenías que estar en una plataforma en la parte de arriba y al final del video se hacen dorados sin subirse a la plataforma como los demás.

[@AbelPeña2067]

Se equivocaron en hacerse doradas, hace ilusión al oro, y El Oro es un símbolo del capitalismo

[@LittleDeadlyBox]

@@AbelPeña2067 Feminismo comunismo equisde

[@elmaestropanda3381]

El oro representa al sol, y el sol representa la masculinidad, la plata representa a la luna y la luna representa la feminidad

[@nick_neon1611]

No me convence lo de llevar a las robots hembras al vertedero. Deberian haberlas empujado a la cocina.

[@ldrago7458]

@@nick_neon1611 para que crees que era el fuego? Para destruir un robot de almenos 30 millones de dólares?

[@seanchen4487]

average chinese baby experience

[@davidcassion2495]

HOLY SHT XDDDDDDD

[@Frozen-Ice]

I like how the printer is somehow able to create two different models without a second printer, but also they are creating a second model to just throw it out. Like bruh, if thats not one hell of the worst employe in the world of the year, idk what is ☠️💀☠️

[@thatonedude977]

To be fair I think the females are being thrown down there to run it otherwise the furnace layout makes no sense

[@Frozen-Ice]

​@@thatonedude977 valid

[@cerberusloki.9226]

A crime there isnt art of this of *that* variety

[@JA3NE16]

These are not ordinary robots...they are revolutionary robotx

[@psychoman1355]

This is good. The animation is high quality and the message is both clear, and its presentation is entertaining. Plus it doesn't try to shove said message down your throats.

[@mamateteyoyo2895]

What was the message tho?

[@psychoman1355]

@@mamateteyoyo2895 Now that you mention it…. I’m not really sure. At least the short is mildly entertaining,

[@Deadman6]

It’s a bit of a ham-fisted message that’s kind of stupid when you think about the logistics of the world itself outside of our own.

[@omglarryisepic8973]

The Boy robots:just sitting around and doing nothing The girl robots:DIEING

[@mistergrieves]

Really liked this. I wish there was a little more dramatic tension before she broke the wall. Maybe if she tried other ways before realizing that the it was inside her the whole time?

[@LisaRowse]

The robot before her banged it with her fist. She realised simply hitting the wall with her fist would not work.

[@veracityofficial9382]

Thicc thighs... Save lives

[@imlivingunderyourbed7845]

Hotel... Trivago

[@agentdarkhd]

@@imlivingunderyourbed7845 jokes? mind blown

[@Bloomie_ig._.]

The ending is that the female robots broke the glass separating the female and male and the female robots became golden too

[@fireelixir84]

This was definitely inspired by Pixar 💀

[@fantasy873]

people, Hello!, this is about sex discrimination and how even in today's society women aren't treated equally despite the fact we've proved that we're just as good as the boys!

[@Cijjbnjjif]

And how exactly have you done that?

[@dannyalian]

Bruh

[@ClownBrian]

well that´s nice and all, the storytelling still sucks ass, has no coherence, no logic, it´s not even a good analogy for real life, hell it´s a really fucking terrible analogy to real life. half through it i asumed this was gonna be about transgender

[@T0astedR0asted]

Fantasy 87 uhh, women are equal to men & this is just saying that women are still “inferior” in 2020🙄🙄

[@TheScarletLadle]

Pay attention to around the 1:20 mark. You will see the fembots pushing gears and feeding the furnace. It's not just about inequality but recognition. The fembots are moving everything for the manobots in the background and they just carry on without acknowledging it.

[@Abdiel262]

No one helped me graduate from university more than my father, and no one offered me a job just because I was a man, I had to work and earn it on my own. In the same way, surely no man oppressed you to make this short film. Just say.

[@shi2866]

Based

[@AngelloFreeman-ub3ug]

Giga Chad

[@shinsuohitoshi2336]

Who asked?

[@AngelloFreeman-ub3ug]

@@shinsuohitoshi2336 Me.

[@NikkiG1134]

@@shi2866adopted

[@amanosolavery3561]

If I were an employee of this factory, I would raise the issue of the competence of the directorate either at the party committee or at the general meeting, because the outrage shown is blatant irresponsibility and waste of funds. In a good way, the prosecutor's office should deal with this, because half of the plant's products simply do not fit into the production plan, and it was impossible to allow this unintentionally.

[@CNMNbun]

Bro stop trying to sound smart you aren’t even using the words right.

[@just_roseyy2226]

Does this story mean that woman have rights..?

[@serfsesa9927]

No, we just need to break them right

[@just_roseyy2226]

cinnamonbun♡ makes so much sense.

[@krisztianpovazson4535]

No, it's about biology, society etc. being a CONSPIRACY to stop women from being men.

[@ira5290]

its mena brake glass becuase womin to thig

[@T0astedR0asted]

Mãlløw Çùp idk, it doesn’t make any fucking sense & its just made to push some sort of agenda, is what i’m seeing

[@Hiroshimayayy]

CGI:*Creates a new video* The respect guy:R E S P E C T

[@tealnaga8107]

This is why Ringling is my DREAM COLLEGE!!!

[@xientau9028]

It's a nice-looking animation, but I'm not really on board with the premise. Equality always seems nice, until you realize that the positions that the other group filled wasn't just high profile jobs like teachers and directors, but also sewage workers, soldiers, truck drivers and assembly line workers (robots can't do everything just yet). Considering their armored appeareance, I wouldn't be too surprised if the fem-bots discovered that the others were flying off because they were being used as projectiles. (In which case it doesn't make sense why their makers are throwing away half of the ammunition produced, what a waste!)

[@one-shotrailgun8713]

Yeah, but the logic in the factorys sorting system is completely idotic. Atleast give the fem-bots a job that contributes to the workforce like in our world. (Yes I know, you mention the fem-bots being thrown away for no reason.)

[@kiddcooties]

One-Shot Railgun you can see in the film that they are used for work. there’s during the gears for power

[@one-shotrailgun8713]

@@kiddcooties oh, thanks man.

[@mightbeahuman3442]

Guerdithe Cius, really together anyone can overcome anything

[@nadirwoodson9321]

@@mightbeahuman3442 two cripples can't overcome a flight of stairs though

[@combive8744]

Let’s all be real if they didn’t throw away female robots the company would be making millions of dollars each day (and you know why.)

[@JRH087]

Love the message behind this, very well done 👌

[@mamateteyoyo2895]

Okay what was the message tho?

[@minchai2943]

@@mamateteyoyo2895 wow, so you couldn't get the subtlety of what this animation is saying

[@doodlegod9249]

@@mamateteyoyo2895you need to give everyone a golden armor and a jump boost

[@budderman3rd]

@@doodlegod9249 Can confirm. This it the message

[@razyel7550]

FEMINAZIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

[@Aurumental]

I really want this made into a movie.

[@oudor1865]

Plot twist: Men go war ☠️

[@namelessandsouless1]

A bit heavy handed with those metaphors, ain't ya?

[@LittleDeadlyBox]

The moral of the history is: Dont buy a male sex doll just thic female sex dolls with a golden armor.

[@alexandrenemo2296]

Что то этот мультфильм довольно короткий. Я ожидал большего, например целой войны. А тут просто женщины смогли разбить стеклянную стену и отправиться наверх, вслед за мужчинами

[@thefactspherefromportal2740]

Moral of story. There is no gender. Only rage.

[@farvision]

No, it's about breaking the bias against women.

[@How_To_Drive_a_TARDIS]

@@farvision glass ceiling DESTROYED with facts and logic

[@thefactspherefromportal2740]

@Ali Shabbiri correct answer

[@Marguns21]

I see several problems with this kind of factory...

[@ogwijiisbae8076]

Moral of you have thighs you are forced to work in a factory making skinny people

[@sweetpea6927]

People who say it’s stupid bc the factory is throwing away half of the product are missing the part where she didn’t go where she was intended to on the belt. She followed a man and tried to fit into his role, like a woman in real life would try to overcome what role is expected of her and go where she wants. However, she is seen as defective for this and thrown away, along with every other female that tried. Idk how y’all missed the point when they literally shattered a glass wall, aka a glass ceiling, that was designed to only allow men to pass through.

[@suyoungjang3345]

Love you. Thanks you so much for reading all those what I wanted to say!!!!

[@VaporwaveLover2000]

This CGI was probably made in a shitty place where women are actually oppressed, because I'm pretty sure women can do that now.

[@sweetpea6927]

@@VaporwaveLover2000 yeah, im not taking opinions on women’s oppression from ‘Sebastian the big pp man’ seriously.

[@VaporwaveLover2000]

@@sweetpea6927 What oppression

[@impulseelectrobrine1259]

Well that was a stupid design why put them on the same conveyor belt

[@hellohowareyou9745]

One of the less thought out films unless this referred to hundreds of years ago before women broke through that metaphorical wall into equal rights. I may be biased because I live in America where the rights between men and women are equal, but this video was clearly directed at Americans so I don't see the point in this short. The director is supposedly from an Asian country which may explain it, but the rest of the contributors aren't. Overall, if animation like this was available in the late 1800s to early 1900s, this would be a masterpiece, but otherwise, it was wasted animation budget.

[@xxangelofhellxx7555]

In that instance, better to try to see it from the perspective of the director and not the contributors who have a bastardized version of "equality". Everyone has their own perspectives on it's message, no matter how blatant it is. If this film was made in a foreign country where women truly were considered second class citizens (and they do exist, plenty in fact), then let's see it from what the director wanted to tell.

[@hellohowareyou9745]

@@xxangelofhellxx7555 Makes sense, but I feel like it'd certainly be more powerful if 1) this was aired in South Korea (or wherever the director currently lives and 2) the other contributors also lived in an unequal place. And definitely, I'm not sure if I made this clear in my first comment, I completely understand if the director's country was sexist and completely love that they're doing this, but I don't know much about South Korean (I think in the description it said South Korea) gender history, so I'm not sure. But the two primary points still stand.

[@xxangelofhellxx7555]

@@hellohowareyou9745 I'm not disagreeing with your points. I'm simply giving you a brighter perspective. I am taking your point and offering a more positive alternative.

[@hellohowareyou9745]

@@xxangelofhellxx7555 Oh, sorry about my wording, I understand that you agree with the comment, but I was just explaining why there was some difference that you didn't awknowledge in your comment.

[@Amarant127]

Nice, now women and men will work together cleaning sewers. Oh wait...

[@TTFTW]

GUYS SMASH OR PASS???

[@martanots1948]

SMASH!!!!!

[@fossil1266]

Great animation but the story seems poorly done I get they are going for a women in a men’s world deal with a literal glass roof and being tossed to the side just because they aren’t a certain type but the use of robots doesn’t work in this situation since robots are factory made specifically it would imply they make female robots just to throw them away thoses symbols on their chests are clearly different parts and instead feels like someone is gonna get fired for wasted a lot of money and resources making robots they kill 15 seconds after making

[@TAiiNE]

I thought the same thing. The animation was nice. But the story it tried to tell fell a bit flat.

[@rogerramiussergeialexander5541]

Haha, that would be an interesting prequel. "Overworked engineers revolt, cause millions of dollars of damage and halve humanoid drone production"

[@BunnyJolf]

Poor consept Great execution

[@fossil1266]

@@rogerramiussergeialexander5541 or maybe it’s like specifically a female worker/inventor who wanted to get her design out there and be famous but didn’t get the all clear from her bosses who like the current model so she did it away hoping no one would notice unaware the quality scan would fail all the new bots she made and just keep killing them maybe even have it at the end where both models are successful like how irl some people like small phones and others prefer bulky phones and also saying cooperation and understanding is the true best way for progress and there isn’t one real answer

[@spongeintheshoe]

Look closely when it zooms in on the furnace. You can see female robots pushing large bins toward it.

[@pronicanc]

If anyone is interested, the music playing throughout the video is called "what are our girls made of?" and the song is quite typical and a little stereotypical, because in the lines of the song there are the words "what are our girls made of? From flowers, from bells, from marmalades," etc. the song is old, it seems, since the Soviet era, but in the year 17-18, a remake of the song was released on KZbin in which the words "what are our girls made of? From iron, from aspirations, from dedication and battles.". The song is called: Nike из чего же сделаны наши девчонки?

[@Asdelas]

Don't ask me why but I think this has the potential to be r34

[@Frostshock15]

This animation shows how strong women are and should be treated equally as men.

[@Frostshock15]

@@austinvanheeswyk7122 what's that supposed to mean?

[@NikkiG1134]

Honestly…………………….it’s such a no brainer that I can’t find a good way to mock the simplicity and obviousness of it

[@UltraEpicVids]

So that's how frieza got his golden form

[@CristalTaoy]

Love 😍

[@How_To_Drive_a_TARDIS]

You should not spam

[@ghazianmuhamadzhafiri7350]

with this video. we can prove that women and men, have the same rights. women are not weak. because they work to take care of the household without being paid, every day. With this video, we can't underestimate women anymore!!!

[@silva_jay1424]

guys, they don’t get thrown away, they get put to work. all the scrap is the ones that passed from overworking. you can see them pushing cogs or something that power a furnace

[@NikkiG1134]

We all overwork

[@m6ggot_brainzZ]

How every Pixar mom built

[@danielaherrera8427]

The style is good but the story didn't intereset me.

[@Mochi_GachaFan]

OMG I SAW THIS ONE TIME LIKE YEARS AGO AND I FORGOT ABOUT IT AND WHENEVER I REMEMBERED IT I COULDN’T FIGURE OUT WHERE I FOUND IT OR IF IT WAS JUST A DREAM!

[@jasyon4149]

Men being sent off to war while women get sent to do the labor work that was previously done by men

[@suyoungjang3345]

Because men didn’t allow women to be at work, at war, at any kind of “public” area. But that’s only for high class women. Women were at war anyway, and women never stop work in history.

[@jasyon4149]

@@suyoungjang3345 women were allowed to go in public areas

[@jasyon4149]

@@suyoungjang3345 women werent really involved in war either, they definitely werent drafted

[@silmerialoriel9632]

​@@jasyon4149 who makes babies if women are thrown into slaughter ? Also not much women want to be killed in loud explosions (there are, but not much) . Just let the privilegied men being massacred instead .

[@jasyon4149]

@@silmerialoriel9632 who impregnates women without men? The fact that men were drafted and sent off into certain death as early as 18 yrs old means they werent enjoying too many priveleges

[@notoff8656]

Where are the women who do all the work? Are there many women scientists? Which woman would give their life for what they love?

[@Neotrec]

Women mostly specialize in healthcare and education which are important for sure but not like technology, scientific research and politics level important

[@notoff8656]

@@Neotrec Who among men have women surpassed in health care and education?

[@Neotrec]

@@notoff8656 that's what I meant, they specialize in those parts but men do too

[@notoff8656]

@@Neotrec men created these areas

[@mk3pigeon407]

Why would the factory make something they aren't gonna use? That's just a waste of metal

[@theconductoresplin8092]

I don't see any modern relevance but ita nice

[@theconductoresplin8092]

@Janet Baker And you must be living in the middle ages

[@RimWulf]

@Janet Baker buurrrrn

[@How_To_Drive_a_TARDIS]

@Janet Baker men just don't understand anything about women, I mean what are those things?

[@theconductoresplin8092]

@@How_To_Drive_a_TARDIS Well whats to understand exactly

[@niclastname]

I love how the people replying to you are trying to "fight sexism" by being extremely sexist to both men and women lmao. They're not only sexistly saying that men as a whole can't/don't understand something based solely on their sex, but they're also saying all women are intellectually limited to all think and act alike based solely on their sex...