Drum Teacher Reacts: Led Zeppelin - 'Heartbreaker' | Madison Square Garden, NY 1973

OG Video | • Led Zeppelin - Heartbr...
SUBSCRIBE! ► www.youtube.co...
DRUMEO 30 - Day FREE Trial ► www.drumeo.com...
DONATE | REQUEST a Reaction via PAYPAL ► www.paypal.com... | or hit me at andrewrooneydr...
SUPPORT | BLOCKED VIDEOS | Join My Community and hit the PATREON ► / andrewrooneydrums
SWEETWATER Latest Drum and Percussion Deals ► imp.i114863.ne...
MERCH STORE ► andrew-rooney-...
Be sure to check out www.lalal.ai/, a next-generation music source separation. Remove vocal, instrumental, drums, bass, guitar, synthesizer, wind and string instruments, and piano tracks without quality loss.
Use my link to sign up with LALAL.AI ► www.lalal.ai/?...
Go and get free minutes via the refferal program!
DRUMEO GEAR!
Blue Quiet Pad: hi.drumeo.com/...
Drumeo Sticks: hi.drumeo.com/...
In Ears: hi.drumeo.com/...
Tone Control Kit: hi.drumeo.com/...
Quietkick: hi.drumeo.com/...
BUSINESS INQUIRIES ► email | [e-mail]
REACTION PLAYLIST ► • Drum Teacher Reaction ...
Web ► andrewrooneydr...
NZ Drummer Podcast ► andrewrooneydr...
Get My ORIGINAL 'Drums & Coffee' COFFEE MUG! ► andrew-rooney-...
DRUM GEAR!
USA fans: Find the best deals on Drums and Percussion at SWEETWATER!
CURRENT DEALS! ► imp.i114863.ne...
SWEETWATER DRUMS ► imp.i114863.ne...
NEW ARRIVALS ► imp.i114863.ne...
Electronic Drums | Roland V-Drums TD-17KVX ► imp.i114863.ne...
My BUDGET THREE-MIC SETUP | • Affordable Drum Record...
4 Mic set up | • Recording Drums | 4-Mi...
My BUDGET 4-MIC RECORDING Gear list |
Vic Firth American Classic DRUMSTICKS - 5A - Wood Tip | imp.i114863.ne...
HEADPHONES | Sony MDR-7506 | imp.i114863.ne... ($99!)
Focusrite Scarlett 18i8 3rd Gen USB Audio INTERFACE | imp.i114863.ne... ($419)
SNARE | Shure SM57 | imp.i114863.ne... ($99)
OVERHEAD (right side) | Audio Technica AT2020 | imp.i114863.ne... ($99!)
OVERHEAD | Audio Technica AT2035 | imp.i114863.ne... ($149)
KICK | Sennheiser E902 | imp.i114863.ne... ($199)
Camera GoPro | imp.i114863.ne...
- RING LIGHT | imp.i114863.ne...
Additional Highly Recommended MICS:
- TOMS | Sennheiser e 904 Dynamic Drum Microphone | imp.i114863.ne...
- OVERHEADS | Shure KSM32 Large-diaphragm Condenser Microphone - Champagne | imp.i114863.ne...
Extras Required To RECORD:
- Tama Boom Mic Stand | imp.i114863.ne...
- XLR Cables | imp.i114863.ne...
VOICE GEAR!
Vocal / Podcast:
Shure SM57 | imp.i114863.ne...
Shure SM7B | imp.i114863.ne...
Shure Beta 87A | imp.i114863.ne...
DRUMS / CYMBALS:
Snare 1 (Recording Custom Aluminum) | imp.i114863.ne...
Snare 2 (Ludwig Supraphonic) | imp.i114863.ne...
Snare 3 (Ludwig Acrolite) | imp.i114863.ne...
Yamaha Stage Custom Drum Kit | imp.i114863.ne...
Yamaha Recording Custom Drum Kit | imp.i114863.ne...
Pearl Export 5-piece Drum Set with Hardware - Pure White ► sweetwater.sjv...
Zildjian 22 inch K Dark Medium Ride Cymbal | imp.i114863.ne...
Zildjian K 14 Hi Hats | imp.i114863.ne...
Zildjian 18 inch A Zildjian Thin Crash Cymbal | imp.i114863.ne...
Zildjian K Cymbal Set - 14/16/20 inch - with Free 18 inch Dark Crash | sweetwater.sjv...
DRUM HEADS:
SNARE: Remo Controlled Sound Coated Drumhead - 14 inch - with Black Dot | imp.i114863.ne...
TOMS: Remo Emperor Coated 4-piece Tom Pack - 10/12/14/16 inch | imp.i114863.ne...
KICK: Remo Powerstroke P3 Clear Bass Drumhead - 20 inch with 2.5 inch Impact Pad | imp.i114863.ne...
DRUM HARDWARE (Yamaha Lightweight) | imp.i114863.ne...
Vic Firth American Classic DRUMSTICKS - 5A - Wood Tip | imp.i114863.ne...
VIDEO:
Camera (Playing) GoPro | imp.i114863.ne...
Teaching/Talking: iPhone (11)
FREE Transcriptions ► andrewrooneydr...
#ledzeppelin #reaction #heartbreaker

[@AndrewRooneyDrums]

Led Zeppelin/John Bonham reaction AND Drum Covers PLAYLIST! kzbin.info/aero/PLqspKksRqaUU0mOzsrOqtb7vDTmRyuqkN&feature=shared DRUMEO 30 - Day FREE Trial ► www.drumeo.com/andrewrooney/ SUBSCRIBE! ► kzbin.info FULL REACTION PLAYLIST ► kzbin.info/aero/PLqspKksRqaUURy8K34sBSKvuGo3ApmLC2

[@rogercaruso9337]

Andrew, I was there for all 3 nights. Nineteen seventy three meters of square garden first time seeing that was a film more east nineteen sixty nine I believe

[@Peter-oh3hc]

Read a story about where a guy was working with john paul jones as a producer. People were used to interacting with him as a producer. One day he was in a corner playing the bass. Everyone going about their business. He started playing Heartbreaker and everyone stopped talking and everyone stopped moving.

[@PeterTea]

It was a stroke of genius to have The Song Remains The Same recorded in cinematic quality audio and video. I’m sure Peter Grant had a big hand in that. Happy New Year 🎉

[@AndrewRooneyDrums]

Happy new year! And I haven't forgotten you were one of the original Led Zep supporters!

[@ralph6968]

i never heard this version of Heartbreaker before ,it's beautiful ,outstanding.

[@bowtiefidenine]

Thanks for the Led Zeppelin ❤

[@AndrewRooneyDrums]

You bet!

[@fractaljack210]

Found you because of Zep so long ago...so happy they're back. Great reaction, as always.

[@AndrewRooneyDrums]

THANKS

[@josephmanzuni8593]

Best band ever. The only band to have four perfect musicians in one act.

[@randywissler9923]

Queen

[@josephmanzuni8593]

@@randywissler9923 Roger Taylor of Queen said during Led Zeppelin's induction into the British Music Hall of Fame, that he is not worthy of John Bonham, cause everything he does was inspired by Bonham.

[@theborgster8497]

Tool comes close

[@randywissler9923]

@@josephmanzuni8593 oh I never said Roger was on John's level, but all 4 members of Queen are masters of their craft as well as elite songwriters.

[@josephmanzuni8593]

@@randywissler9923 Zeppelin is ranked no 1 rock band in the world, for a reason .. they have the best singer, best bassist, best guitarist and best drummer. Queen is their protege. Enough said.

[@eatthisvr6]

The intro to this is soooooo groovy. It just sounds amazing and effortless

[@donnelson6694]

Led Zeppelin. Live and dangerous! Fun!

[@john9508]

Saw them at Knebworth in 79 and they were awesome

[@AndrewRooneyDrums]

Epic gig!

[@richardharrold9736]

​@@AndrewRooneyDrums funny thing is that all the reviews at the time said it was awful, Page was off his head on heroin, Bonham was drunk, the PA kept feeding back and the band themselves felt it had been less than successful...

[@susannebass5503]

2nd Annual Zepathon 🎉 Great to kick off the start of their second Album. Analysis spot on having seen them twice the real magic is on stage ❤ Thanks as always Andrew🥁🥁

[@finessemuse2123]

We are here my friend! Happy New Year, ringing it in with BONZO!! Super fun doing this collaboration once again with you and Andy, Led Zep 1 last year and now Led Zep 2! ❤😊🎉🎉

[@susannebass5503]

​@@finessemuse2123❤❤🎉❤❤

[@sooth6059]

there's a perfectly good full live version out there, this grinds me cause I know what every scene/song is being used to make the edit lol

[@mikewoodrow5878]

Yup, the Bonzo head shake to JPJ is actually from Dazed and Confused (same show) - about 2 minutes before he gets the bow out.

[@scottzappa9314]

Man I want those drums, LOL. I surely spent some extra time worshipping at the Bonzo alter at the Rock Hall of Fame (at the time, perhaps 2003). The kit from Zeppelin 4. Which was, of course in total contrast to Neil Peart's very elaborate kit they had there, pretty spartan but that's all he needed. Dig another Zeppelin week.

[@mjm5081]

Must've been awesome to be so close to that kit! I never tire of hearing those amazing drums!!! RIP Bonham and Peart My 1 and 1a ❤❤

[@scottzappa9314]

Yes sir@@mjm5081

[@basher5107]

I saw the green sparkle kit at the HOF and I just stared at it thinking of all the songs recorded on that kit,I was totally mesmerized

[@mjm5081]

@@basher5107 ❤

[@Wendelvendel]

I have no idea how i missed this one! Thanks for this.

[@AndrewRooneyDrums]

Hope you enjoyed it!

[@H0tchips]

What a great clip and review. They had a lot of time to fill in that didn't actually have video. So unfortunate. But the sound, and the band killing it. I'd say it is practically impossible for Jimmy to play a solo of any song of any concert the same way twice. And Bonham's intro.

[@juliemanarin4127]

They are always magnificent

[@DavidRosenbloom-vv8tl]

Now that's live music!

[@EdA1]

Always great to hear my favorite drummer of all time, although quite distracting to have footage that doesn’t sync up lol!… So looking forward to you running through the entire second album, my favorite! Support coming your way 😊

[@AndrewRooneyDrums]

THANK YOU!!!!

[@vickieray]

I’m brand new to your channel but am a lifelong Zeppelin fan! They are my #1 always 🎶🎤🎸🎹🎼 They were a live band for sure!! I listen to them daily along with Deep Purple with the AMAZING Ian Paice on drums, Black Sabbath with Bill Ward on drums which I see you’ve reacted to alot already!! Dive into some more Deep Purple for sure!! Look forward to watching your channel 🎶🥁 Happy New Year from North Carolina 🎆

[@susannebass5503]

Welcome ❤ I'm a lifelong fan of all those bands too! Hope you enjoy being part of this channel I sure do😊

[@vickieray]

@@susannebass5503 I’m really enjoying it so far 🎊🎶🎉💥 Happy New Year!!

[@papacarl2002]

Hey there - I was just commenting how Andrew’s channel was such a blessing to find back in 2020 - glad you’ve found it now. Be sure to check out the young female Japanese drummer Yoyoka doing *amazing* drum play throughs of many LZ songs as well as Deep Purple and many others. Either check her channel out or dig into Andrew’s archive and watch the smile spread over his face watching her for the first time doing Good Times Bad Times. 🤘🏼🎧🤟🏼

[@finessemuse2123]

Glad to have you join us! Just in time for Zep week! 😊 Andy has a lot of great content and playlists.

[@vickieray]

@@papacarl2002 thank you! I followed Yoyoka several years ago. I believe she was like 8 at the time. She is absolutely amazing 🎶🥁

[@henriettaskolnick4445]

Happy New Year to one and all! Your critiques/comments are exactly what was said then (and occasionally still to this day) about solos/improvs during a song in concert, in that some considered it overly self-indulgent and bloated and one of the reasons why the emerging punk scene at the time considered them dinosaurs because they wanted music that was to the point, raucous, and in your face. I agree with you in that the improvisation meant you weren't playing safe and when they were on - they soared...and occasionally sank, but that is where the discovery of new phrasings, riffs, etc. are found. It was something they all understood as this quote from Bonham shows: "There were times when I blundered and got the dreaded look from the lads. But that was a good sign. It showed I'd attempted something I'd not tried before." I'm looking forward to another Zep week and it's fitting for January as Jonesy's birthday is January 3rd and Jimmy's is January 9th. Cheers!

[@JohnBonhamisEverything]

Yes!! Can’t believe Jimmy is turning 80! Seeing him play while he inducted Link Wray into Hall of Fame was Fantastic! I’d forgotten about JPJ’s b’day so thanks for the reminder.

[@sicotshit7068]

Every concert they did was different, they’d last 3 to 4 hours. Same city 3 nights in a row, each night would be different, they loved improvising. Achilles Last Stand would be a good one to watch for drumming, or Bonham’s 15 20 minute solo Moby Dick live at Madison Square Gardens.

[@PeteBarnett]

brilliant comments as ever - HNY from the UK

[@AndrewRooneyDrums]

Happy New Year!

[@jonathanmilo]

“When you’re not playing it safe, that is rock.” Or Jazz Or Blues Or Reggae Or every creative that risks it all. Beautiful, thank you.

[@AndrewRooneyDrums]

HAHA! Great point!!! Music vs computer...

[@andrewplumb6544]

Really enjoyed this, grew up with Zep, the silent conversation between Bonzo and JPJ during Page's guitar solo, well you can just imagine. I'm sure Page was quoting the Allman's Mountain Jam in the solo.

[@davidcarter4247]

That silent conversation was from Dazed and Confused. The producer of this video used other clips from other performances to cover those parts of the original movie that showed something other than the band on stage

[@OutOnTheTiles]

Another great episode. Thank you 👍

[@mannybravo237]

Bonzo dancing his way home from the gig! 10:10😎

[@Ash_Hudson]

At some point you seriously need to react to their How The West Was Won live album. My god. The drumming on that is incredible, so is the mix.

[@zzzyyyzz]

This is how you ROCK!

[@papacarl2002]

Happy New Years Andrew!! Great to check back in with you after being offline for a bit. Finding your early reactions to Led Zeppelin and Yoyoka was such a blessing for me back in 2020 during uncertain unsure times. Yours is still one of my favorite channels and want you to know how much you are appreciated- I think it was during your viewing of Achilles Last Stand live, when you stated that this was art, I knew you f’kn got it. Many thanks my man. 🤘🏼🎧🤟🏼

[@JohnBonhamisEverything]

Thanks @AndrewRooneyDrums, @FinesseMuse & Susan(hope I spelled your name right)! Love this song! Most of the footage is Dazed and Confused but this was put together well bc Heartbreaker was “lost footage”. That’s why it was mostly about the stolen Tampa concert money from the safe in the movie. Happy New Year!!

[@susannebass5503]

Thanks this gives myself n Finesse great joy.....2nd Annual Zepathon 🎉🎉

[@finessemuse2123]

Thank you for the great feedback and this week is going to be fun! Live Heartbreaker from the Song Remains the Same film, you are correct, was all chopped up and did not even play a majority of the song. It was supplanted by the lock box theft scenes. I'd be willing to bet some of the listeners on the channel have never heard this full live version audio before, because they have only seen the movie and have not listened to the album. TSRTS live album is a forgotten gem. This fan tribute video to this live Heartbreaker is the best I have seen on KZbin. I love the shots of Bonzo on it, especially the end how his stagger and swagger in the white suit matches the beat intro to Whole Lotta Love, LOL! 🎉😂

[@JohnBonhamisEverything]

@@finessemuse2123 I love the ending also-perfect! I listen to the album at work all the time-it’s unfortunate that the footage was “lost”. I kind of wish Andy could have let it run into MSG version of Whole Lotta Love, for me it’s tied with Earls Court Encore version.

[@JohnBonhamisEverything]

@@susannebass5503 Great joy indeed! Need alot more Zeppethons imo!

[@susannebass5503]

@@JohnBonhamisEverything definitely 💯 Finesse and I have collaborated 2yrs now and Andrew is so kind. If you haven't check out all the ZEP he's done...it's a lot👍

[@marcosfranca8706]

The reason for the image being this great it's due to be recorded in 30mm film! If I'm not wrong 30mm film resolution quality can surpass 4K resolution! So u take that and add a bit of color grading editing we can do nowadays and we have Zep in 1080 HD!

[@tomcarter6076]

Must must must react to Fool in the Rain

[@writethisthat3613]

Some of the visuals look like they were taken from the Dazed and Confused sequence from MSG concert.

[@MrBedZeppelin]

Happy New Year, Andrew! Thanks for the vid requester! Fun Fact; "The Song Remains the Same" (still available for purchase) DVD/Movie/Film was edited footage from the three Zep shows at Madison Square Garden, in 1973. Due to limited technology, (1975 when they released movie) some (if not most) of the finished film had multiple edits to create this sort of a mash up of video and audio. The MOST important bit is the best AUDIO was used from one of the three nights whereas the video and some of the audios have been clipped and edited to make one hell of a great movie. So YES, you are right, Andrew.

[@AndrewRooneyDrums]

Thanks for the info!

[@basher5107]

They also didn’t have enough video to sync up with the video so some of the movie was reshot on a London sound stage-if you notice JPJ wears two different shirts and Jimmy has shorter hair

[@09jetta]

Loved the audio! Struggled with the video being so far off, even though warned ahead of time!

[@andrewmason7207]

cheers man . happy new year fe scotland . look forward to zep week

[@nikosalmpanis-ty3jt]

The best band ever🤘

[@MsDrummergirl]

I've been playing live for man years. Well, singing live. And I'm of the old school. No click or autotune for me. All live in the moment for me 😊.

[@targetshootr]

I think this was the part of the movie where the cop is chasing someone around the stadium. Not sure but a couple of the scenes were buzzkills. Anyhoo, it's great to look back at a time when fans could get right up to the stage. We were crushed getting into their last gig here which was shortly before people were trampled at a Who concert which ended the 'open seating' thing pretty much everywhere. We sat 20 feet away at eye level just off the main floor for 3 1/2 hours.

[@user-me3by4in9o]

Please can you do nobody’s fault but mine classic zep

[@user-gl5kj1fm5x]

i think he did the knebwoth version a while ago

[@user-mc6xy7xl6f]

someone threw together a video to go with the audio here. But the story goes, Zepplin hired a big time company to record their New York concerts so they could make "the song remains the same" movie, But the frigin idiots only recorded PART of each song! not the entire show. Peter Grant was furious. In order to make the film they had to go into the studio (Shepperton) 2 yrs later and act out the missing footage. Jonesy had cut his hair short by then and had to wear some ridiculous wig to match what he looked like. LOL

[@alexgolovchenko3791]

Hi, Andrew, love you, love your sincerity, your honesty. Got to tell you, your subscribers, your listeners, you've got to read Geezer Butler's book, 'Into The Void'. It gave me some mind blowing insight into the business, into Zeppelin, into John Henry Bonham, so poinient and heart wrenching. Anyone who really cares about this must read this book, I strongly recommend it. A must read to everyone who cares. It really hit me deeply.😢

[@exalhoa]

Just put it in my Amazon cart. Can't wait to read it! Thanks for the tip.

[@AndrewRooneyDrums]

Sounds amazing!!!

[@BillBowman-vu3jw]

Happy New Year Andrew! What a great way to start the year!! 👍🏼

[@CosmicVagabondPixie]

OMG!!! YAY!!! **Luvit** **Thank YOU** ha **Swoon** **Melt** i am SOOO **Grateful** that they got some of their stuff on Film so wish there was more like totally wish they had Filmed them ALL course! BUT i am just sooo freakin ecstatic that they did ANY at all Thank Goodness for what we DO have!!! & i wish there were a freakin Time Machine so bad ha Where's that confounded **Time Machine**

[@mjm5081]

Andrew, Happy New Year to you and yours! Wishing everyone ✌ ❤ 🎶 🙏 ❤ 🌹 John 🌹 ❤ 🙏

[@AndrewRooneyDrums]

Happy New Year!

[@mjm5081]

@@AndrewRooneyDrums 😃 👍 👊

[@AeroDude73]

As has probably been said, this is from their movie

[@markj8493]

Dude!!! If you really want to see some great greasy improvisation, Dazed and Confused from TSRTS album and the video is a tour de force. You will NOT be disappointed!!!

[@JohnBonhamisEverything]

That’s what I said before (kinda) 😁

[@AndrewRooneyDrums]

Sounds good!

[@zatoichiable]

Hi Andrew can you do analysis of drum playing of the band Grand Funk Railroad? any of their track worthy of talking about...

[@danielleeuwis1623]

Hi! Have you ever been introduced to Gene Hoglan on his drums in the band Death?

[@mannybravo237]

He reacts to three Death drummers, Gene, Sean Reinert, and Richard Christy. Ck out his playlist🤘🏼

[@lawsonfan5797]

Saw an awful lot of The Ocean.

[@rtalbot87]

Bonzo admitted he was not the best time keeper. Jason cut an album Disrespect for Timekeeping !

[@matthewashman1406]

most of the footage is from the ocean

[@MrResdog911]

At this point see the movie!

[@aslakrantakokko5347]

Still waiting for Ian Paice week 👌👍💪🤘😜😎😉

[@ak74114]

Music does not match the visuals because the "movie" was shot during 3 following shows in 3 days and they used the footage from each show and added those "movie parts" into it and mixed it up together, iirc...

[@AndrewRooneyDrums]

Yup all good!

[@Mikeysixkiller]

I had to look away for most of it, the lack of sync was distracting. Sonically, another legendary performance.

[@pb6270]

The video is highly chopped up and re-combined maybe to avoid copyright strikes? Bits from totally different songs mixed in all over.

[@NEWSFLASHDRUMMER]

Someone else think that "Shout at the devil" by Motley Crue is inspired by this song?? Mostly the drums with the fills, Tommy Lee must have taken inspiration from here

[@scottlindsay841]

Not backing tracks !! Real music... Zeppelin Rules !!

[@AndrewRooneyDrums]

YUP!

[@scottlindsay841]

@@AndrewRooneyDrums thanks for reply ... Enjoy your channel...

[@climber4434]

2024

[@eatthisvr6]

I recomend wll live from msg73 if you only do 1 live track from zep 2

[@flor9389]

I think click versus non click is dependent on the type of music. It makes sense with a band like Electric Callboy (I don’t know they play with clicks). It makes less sense with a looser style of rock like Zeppelin.

[@keefriff99]

I often see professionally-filmed concert footage where the drummer is shown playing the ride cymbal while the hi-hat is clearly audible, or vice versa. It’s a major pet peeve of mine as a drummer. I’m sure casual fans don’t care but it annoys me when footage is edited sloppily like that.

[@basher5107]

Jimmy Page is always known for his Les Paul The truth is he never used Gibsons in the studio!

[@richardharrold9736]

Yes he did. The first two albums are Telecaster and later on he also used Strats and Danelectros, but a lot of LZ III, IV, HotH etc is Gibson.

[@basher5107]

Led Zep III Immigrant Song was a twelve string Fender The solo on Stairway was his telecaster as well as the Fender 12 string along with acoustic Martin guitars

[@richardharrold9736]

@@basher5107 Stairway solo was a Les Paul, the 12-string he used was a Vox Phantom, and he replaced both with the EDS-1275 which he used both in the studio and live.

[@basher5107]

@@richardharrold9736 We’ll agree to disagree

[@richardharrold9736]

@@basher5107 the facts are well established and supported by photographic and film evidence.

[@philippusviridi6527]

This is a video editing mess what were they thinking when they released this. Well it was the seventies they probably were high as a kite.

[@user-hn4dj4fn3s]

I mean, what is the point of seeing an artist live, when all they do is repeat what's on the recording?

[@kenhewitt7357]

Love Jimmy, amazing guitarist but he could be so sloppy live.

[@dkelban]

Self indulgent???? GIVE ME A BREAK. Those who can't do... Become critics. Every creative person in any artistic, musical, sport, etc. Shows off their talents. If an artist exhibits their work, do we call them self indulgent? Stupid criticism of zeppelin.

[@AndrewRooneyDrums]

I think people conditioned to CHORUS CHORUS CHORUS autotuned, safe pop music that's over in 2 minutes... They MIGHT consider this type stuff self indulgent. I don't

[@dkelban]

@@AndrewRooneyDrums exactly

[@georgejamesducas9602]

Zep is a cover band, and their live is terrible and sloppy