FIRST TIME HEARING THE BEE GEES - I Started A Joke REACTION | Rere Reacts

[@tmcmurdo826]

One of my favorites of the early pre-disco Bee Gees. Another early favorite is Massachusetts. It’s good to hear Robin singing in this one.

[@cspringer333]

60's Bee Gees were fantastic.

[@RNDReacts]

Indeed!

[@jthaw]

The Bee Gees have a very deep catalog of brilliant music. You haven't scratched the surface.

[@davisworth5114]

The haunting mystery of "I Started a Joke", finding a new generation of souls. Such thoughtful reactions.

[@BD4-ManchesterIsRed]

Finally someone who knows when not to talk. Thank you so much. An easy decision to subscribe.

[@RNDReacts]

Blessings, I really had to take in this one ✨

[@RegenaCox-yy1rl]

This was Robins signature song, and when he died they said his some put a recording of this song on his chest and then broke down crying.

[@marlecmarine5393]

Robin had a great voice, his rendition of 'Massachusetts' live in Australia 1989 is a must watch, in fact the whole concert was great live performances from all the Bee Gees

[@HiramMendez-s9m]

Thanks for one of the most honest reactions that I have ever seen on any video,You must have an old Soul.

[@RNDReacts]

I appreciate that 🩵

[@Isleofskye]

@@RNDReacts I have just Subscribed as I like you and your content.:) As I am in my 8th decade,I remember The Bee Gees when they returned to England,after emigrating as a family when they were all young. You can see a video of them on KZbin performing in Australia as 8 and 10 year olds in stage and Robin here is VERY different on that. THE video and Bee Gees song for you is ALONE and,please watch the accompanying video showing all stages of their life in Home Movies from 8 years old.ENJOY.

[@ToniMilne-dx7hu]

Yes, this Robins signature song during concerts, but he did have many songs that it was primarily him on lead and Barry would accompany him. I don’t know if they were hits but they are worth a listen if you want to explore The Bee Gees. As follows And the sun will shine Country Lanes Come on over The singer sang his song Bodyguard My life has been a song Road to Alaska I’ve just got a message to you I don’t want to be the one Love me Don’t fall in love with me. Enjoy all they have to offer

[@tomharrison6607]

robin gibb what a voice

[@beangelic1000]

My favourite Bee Gee

[@scottdrapo8321]

It's Beautiful...Missing Them

[@Sandra6411]

Barry did lead most of their songs from the 70’s up. Robin (who lead this song), lead most of their 1960’s songs. This song was from the 60’s.

[@BGWhisperer]

No, I think it was at least equal in the 60s. Barry lead at least as many or more songs in the 60s than Robin did. Basically, it is as the Bee Gees themselves said in an interview: Barry is lead 1, Robin is lead 2, and Maurice is harmonies.

[@nelerhabarber5602]

@@BGWhisperer Right, Barry lead more than Robin but they shared lead verses in many songs!

[@beangelic1000]

@@BGWhisperer You are correct, back then Robin sang lead and on the others he was co lead with Barry.

[@beangelic1000]

@@nelerhabarber5602 No the poster is correct, Robin sang more songs as lead, and also co lead with Barry. Barry sang more lead in the disco era

[@nelerhabarber5602]

@@beangelic1000 Maybe unknown songs, but all well known songs before the disco era are sung by Barry, in the morning, spicks and specks, every minute, first of may, words, how can you mend, lonely days, tomorry (the cucumber castle songs), lonely violin, rest your love, all of my live........ From Robin I can name only 4 songs, massachussettes, I started a joke, my world, juliet. And believe me, I know all this songs from the TV(shows) and the radio at his time in my country, Robin was almost not present, not even in the youth/music magazines (only as a Bee Gees), while there were reports, covers, etc. from Barry!

[@williammcdonald2392]

Dying was a metaphore

[@RNDReacts]

Yess that’s what I was thinking

[@mikem8563]

Bee Gees-alone

[@jeffstevens4262]

God rest dear Robin, Andy & Maurice, all taken from us way too soon. Robin had the voice of angel, and now only Barry survives. The Bee Gees were an incredible band, not only producing a long series of hits for themselves from the '60's '70's and '80's...but they also wrote loads of massive hits for other stars. Your reaction was really quite beautiful, so many thanks. I hope you can do more of their iconic hits. 🙋‍♂

[@ManuelDumont-l1w]

"We're soo Full of ourSelves...that we only "realise", just how Inconsequential our lives are...till we Die(& the world keeps on Turning)" . 🤩👸👌

[@thomastimlin1724]

The Bee Gees were successful here in the states LONG before they did disco music in the mid 1970's. People forget this early work which was excellent song writing. Let alone the singing. I love their early work BETTER than the disco music. I'm 68, when the Beatles and British Bands broke through 60 years ago this year, it changed my life forever. I was already singing with all kinds of records from the 1930's t brand new. But they pushed me over the edge. I became a music teacher. BTW you have such pretty eyes I'm surprised you don't attract thousands more viewers anyway 😀

[@Sandra6411]

A couple of my favorite songs from them (other than the ones you’ve already done) are: Fanny Be Tender (R&B) Jive Talking (R&B) You Should Be dancing (disco) Love You Inside Out (Funk/R&B) Love So Right (R&B)

[@RNDReacts]

Thank you!

[@RuthBair-ht1fj]

Great suggestions

[@beverlycoulston8058]

Beautiful song❤

[@haroldhuddleston6585]

Girl, I am 91 and for a young lady, you have a lot of understanding 🤗

[@RuthBair-ht1fj]

Beautiful song. Always makes me cry. Love your reaction to this beautiful song. Some you would enjoy are Kiss of Life, I Surrender, She keeps on Coming, Walking on air and Ordinary Lives. ❤❤❤

[@danhartman8582]

Another trio that was popular in the late 60s and early 70s in the US was a band called Three Dog Night . Three singers that shared the lead in this group are fantastic . Please check out Eli's coming (live) or Liar among more hits for a taste of pure talent .

[@Almcosta25]

Brilliant understanding of an apparently simple song! Seems like that Robin as a teenager enjoyed playing pranks, but something went wrong once and he felt really guilty. I think you do have a rare perception that can only improve with time (reading, listening, watching, reflecting). Take care Rere, greetings from Portugal.

[@bpfromowc]

Beautiful song. The Bee Ges are one of the GOATS.

[@SuperKevin57]

Your analysis of this song was so touching.😊

[@MarkJones-w9d]

Jive talking is the best bee gees song

[@RNDReacts]

Mm 👀

[@yellowbeardjamesgibson9297]

​@@RNDReacts Jive Talking was a Good song & Music connects with each person differently some could say any of these were there best 1) Night Fever 2) More than A woman 3) You should be dancing 4) Tragedy Still the Best is in the Ear of the beholder ( IMHO )

[@ic5761]

​@@yellowbeardjamesgibson9297whoa, what about "Too much Heaven"

[@ic5761]

Nope, Too Much Heaven

[@yellowbeardjamesgibson9297]

@@ic5761 Thanks for your comment !!! She has already reacted to that song ( Too Much Heaven ) Yet the Bee Gees has had Many Hits like 1) To love somebody 2) How deep is your Love 3) I started a Joke 4) Words 5 ) How do you mend A Broken heart For example , However having a Full Orchestra really adds layers

[@danielbenincasa770]

the brother Robin is the main singer for this song. Listen to alot more to their songs. They are oh so good. Love your channel & reactions. This is from the 60's. Younger

[@patfinn6551]

Damn I wasn't ready for this

[@willow_wise]

Great reactions! Always love a Bee Gees reaction - all eras, any lead. Thanks!

[@HeidiDenoble]

Most people associate the Bee Gees with disco but their early work in the late 60s and early 70s was different. Check out Massachusetts, Holiday, and New York Mining Disaster and Words.

[@jerrypost9651]

Loved your interpretation, young lady. As you say, there are many ways to consider its meaning. For me, it was just an incredibly poignant song, both lyrically and musically. Like many others who grew up with their music, I tend to prefer their '60s material to their '70s disco era. They actually got closer to that early stuff in their final albums 30 or so years later. Robin's vocals are truly extraordinary. Another great Bee Gees hit from the '60s featuring Robin singing lead is "Massachusetts." 👍😉

[@willfromyadkinville]

so good! Robin rocked this!

[@ToniMilne-dx7hu]

Robin seemed so introspective and wanted to be understood and valued compared to Barrry. This was his signature song, but I always felt that My Life has been a Song was his song. Always loved his voice, Bee Gees fan for life ❤️

[@richtensail]

sweet u reacted to robin singing lead, touching song, i relay like his haunting vocal, that vibrato!, personally id like robin 2 sing mre lead, he also sang lead on new york mining disaster n a cple others. bgs born in uk, raised in au, n moved back 2 uk 2 boost ver career, barry loves in usa i tnk?

[@spadams999]

I have this album. It's over 50 years old. You need to listen to more Bee Gees.

[@TheSilentdra]

have you reacted to bee gees' how deep is your love?

[@yellowbeardjamesgibson9297]

You saw Robin singing this one & most are led by Barry !!! Also the Brother Andy had his own solo career here are 2 from him Andy Gibb 1. I WANT TO BE YOUR EVERYTHING 2. SHADOW DANCING 🎶 I said if you respond to my suggestion I will send you more Bonus Nazareth ( Love Hurts ) For your Brother the pianist 1) Mozart piano concerto # 21 andante ( I call undersea ) 2) Billy Joel (the piano man ) 3) Alyssa Baker ( Can't help falling ) Elvis cover

[@barry0709]

Please react to LOVE YOU INSIDE OUT by the BEEGEES thanks ❤

[@patticrichton1135]

Robin Gibb here singing in this video is only part of the Bee Gees. They are 3 brothers, Barry Gibb, Maurice Gibb, and Robin Gibb....sometimes called "The Brothers Gibb" but known as "The Bee Gees" Their youngest brother Andy Gibb, had a singing career of his own, and was the image of his oldest brother Barry, in looks and in voice. Sadly he died very young, and was the first one to pass. Since then Maurice, then Robin passed away. The eldest brother, Barry, is the ONLY one left now. You need to take a deep dive into their catalogue.....GREAT songs, ALL of them.

[@orlandoaabello3274]

beautiful......thanks

[@RNDReacts]

Welcome 😊

[@MarkRichter-j2l]

I bet I can make you want to dance.....The Grateful Dead "Good Lovin",,,(studio version)

[@Divedown_25]

Nice song, try Seven Seconds with Youssou N'dour ft Neneh Cherry if you fancy. It's a very nice and deep track

[@brianfagan3367]

Hi there is a magnificent cover by Allie Sherlock well worth checking out imo

[@paulpennell2115]

ZZTop still waiting

[@CraigSmithson-oy4pm]

Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

[@thejoelrooganexplosion2400]

I think this song is about racism "I finally died, which started the whole world living"

[@jeffstevens4262]

Racism? How exactly...?

[@freddyhill8632]

The Bee Gees are Legends, but honestly my preference, I can't get into there 60's early 70' stuff. The mid 70's and beyond are so damn good. I say this because they have so many good songs from the 80's and 90's that folks rarely hear. Anyways great reaction, thanks

[@willow_wise]

I totally agree that there is som much in the 80s and on, some of my favs from them are from post fever era. But I've come to love the early stuff too, even some of the Australia songs when I'm in that kind of mood. Really is just something great for every mood.

[@thejoelrooganexplosion2400]

xxx

[@indyprecious1081]

you're beautiful

[@richtensail]

yeah humar is often taken v wrong way, misinterpreted.