First Time Watching DUNE PART ONE (2021) Movie Reaction & Commentary

Thanks for watching! Don't forget to subscribe for new videos.
Follow me, stay up to date, share memes and support below:
Patreon: / ryancarrington
Instagram: / itsryancarrington
If you want to send me something:
Unit 101913
PO Box 7169
Poole
United Kingdom
BH15 9EL
#MovieReaction #FirstTimeWatching #Cinema
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
If you would like to support the channel via a donation, you can now do so below:
www.paypal.me/...
Thanks so much! ☺️
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Music Used - With Thanks.
BG Music: / prodimmortal
Outro Music: / waspymusic
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Storyline
Dune (titled onscreen as Dune: Part One) is a 2021 American epic science fiction film directed and co-produced by Denis Villeneuve, who co-wrote the screenplay with Jon Spaihts, and Eric Roth. It is the first of a two-part adaptation of the 1965 novel of the same name by Frank Herbert. Set in the distant future, the film follows Paul Atreides as his family, the noble House Atreides, is thrust into a war for the deadly and inhospitable desert planet Arrakis. The ensemble cast includes Timothée Chalamet, Rebecca Ferguson, Oscar Isaac, Josh Brolin, Stellan Skarsgård, Dave Bautista, Stephen McKinley Henderson, Zendaya, Chang Chen, Sharon Duncan-Brewster, Charlotte Rampling, Jason Momoa, and Javier Bardem.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
FAIR USE:
Creative Commons License
creativecommon...
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, commenting, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS

[@RyanCarrington]

CATCH PART TWO HERE kzbin.info/www/bejne/jHiZXpprbdWEgsU

[@spyro257]

the vid is gone...

[@hellomark1]

In the books there's no magic. "The Voice" is just extreme psychological conditioning. The director described it as "the voice of a thousand grandmothers telling you to do something"

[@71lizgoeshardt]

Yes, Bene Gesserit have the power to decide at conception, male or female. Jessica was ordered to bear only daughters to Duke Leto, but because she loved him so much and he wanted a son, she disobeyed the Reverend Mother.

[@JeshuaSquirrel]

Indeed. A Bene Gesserit has conscious control over every function in the body, even the autonomic functions. The development of sex characteristics, as with all development, are from the application of certain hormones in certain quantities at certain times during development. There is literally no such thing as an unwanted pregnancy in a Bene Gesserit. In one of the books, this control is described by the question, "Can you move your small toe independent of any other muscle?"

[@anonymousmuse9092]

BRO i'm less than 10 minutes and you're already my fave reactor. not a lot of people who watch Dune pick up on the social commentary of it all, the way the story parallels irl. i love how you analyze the underlying themes. you've got a new subscriber here!

[@RyanCarrington]

Thanks so much, man! I guess if you're aware of this stuff, it's so glaringly obvious. Hope you enjoyed the rest of the watch. I'm currently editing Part Two. These movies are quite a pain to chop up with how detailed they are 😅

[@titokrause]

Yes. This is one of the best reactions to this movie. I think I've seen all the reactions and this is definitely up there with the best. You got the tone of the movie right from the start and some points that not everyone gets.

[@BouillaBased]

I put Frank Herbert right up there with Tolkien when it comes to world building. The novels he wrote for the Dune universe were rich with descriptors and every character and culture was so thoroughly fleshed out that the story pulled you in. You don't even notice the density of the text. As an aside, a friend of mine was an extra in the Lynch film for Dune. He played both a Fremen and a Harkonnen. We would always kid him about shooting himself as he ran across the dunes, every time the subject came up. Just one reason why I watched it several times. It's interesting seeing what different productions choose to focus on, and how designers for sets and costumes can interpret those rich details that Herbert included. I absolutely love what they've done with the visuals and sound design in this version.

[@clash79]

Absolutely, but Dune is so much more an interesting read than the lotr trilogy, imo. And it's plenty great on it's own

[@Obiwankanoli]

The Joe exotic edit was chef's kiss my friend.

[@RyanCarrington]

I forgot I did that 😂

[@terrifyingclipss]

best reactor ngl, hopefully you will post dune part two

[@RyanCarrington]

Thanks man! Ahh, I definitely will. It's watched and recorded but it's even more difficult to edit than this one was 😅

[@peterreist2882]

The bene gesserit are what Jedi’s were based on in the Star Wars universe

[@RyanCarrington]

Makes a lot of sense! I thought about and mentioned Star Wars a fair bit during this movie haah

[@russellward4624]

​@@RyanCarringtonyea Lucas lifted quite a lot from Dune.

[@dudermcdudeface3674]

If Lucas based the Jedi on the BG, he wasn't paying attention. BG are basically a cult of dominatrix-eugenicists. They're constructive overall, but deeply cynical and sinister.

[@sirperybLakeney]

...one of the things.

[@matttyler8331]

Most of the desert scenes were filmed in Jordan. Apparently they had to construct over 100 miles of road to get to the various desert locations where filming was done.

[@dudermcdudeface3674]

There's also a TV miniseries version from 2000. Low production quality overall, but they made up for it by doing it like a stage play. Ian McNeice in the role that Stellan Skarsgard plays here. It was clearly a labor of love, so I always recommend it to people who like the current movies.

[@RyanCarrington]

Yeah, I'm only just hearing about this now in the comments. I was completely aware of its existence!

[@dudermcdudeface3674]

@@RyanCarrington The whole thing is available here on yt for free. Although the resolution is pretty low.

[@jentoby73]

I’d also recommend the sequel miniseries Children of Dune based on Herbert’s second two books Messiah and Children of Dune. James McAvoy’s performance is the standout. First thing I saw him in and made quite an impression.

[@dudermcdudeface3674]

@@jentoby73 Absolutely. Folks who just finished the current movie who don't want to wait years for the next one can watch the Children of Dune miniseries as a direct sequel. They'd just have to get used to the different cast and CD-ROM era effects. But it achieves some amazing results with score and acting.

[@di3486]

The miniseries shows that good script and acting are the heart and soul of a good production.

[@marcusc9931]

04:43 The reason they need spice for space travel is there is a strict ban on AI. (for historical reasons - leaving your thinking to a machine makes you a slave to whoever controls it) That's why the duke has an assistant trained from birth to be an autistic genius, serving as a living calculator - they just don't use advanced computers. But making a precise hyperspace jump requires calculations no human could do - so instead they use a "navigator", a man who spends his whole life so high on spice, he can see a bit into the future and guide the ship safely. The navigators' guild is one of the most influential forces in the universe.

[@johnohrstrom5112]

To be more specific, a strict ban on computers!

[@hoon_sol]

When Paul is exposed to the spice in the desert and kneels down in the sand and says, "I recognize your footsteps, old man...", it's meant as a double entendre, but which isn't as clear unless you've read or are aware of the books; it of course is meant to literally refer to Gurney coming up behind him, but Fremen call the worm "the old man of the desert", so when Paul says he recognizes its "footsteps" (the worm approaching) it's meant to represent that he has some transcendent affinity with the worms due to his role in and prescience about what is to come.

[@xen0bia]

I think you meant Gurney and not Duncan.

[@hoon_sol]

@@xen0bia: Entirely correct! Edited for clarity.

[@clash79]

Ditto. I got such a kick out of hear him saying this when I saw it in the theater. Denis is a clever boy, just as Frank was

[@MikeBobpokie]

Might I say, loved your reaction.For your information, a detail, the Baron floats , Duncan is a supreme fighter, the Sadaukar drop perfectly. These are all due to suspensor belts they wear, you'll see red lights along their back. Read the books. So much background information. This is one of so many details you are missing. Anyway ,your choice, but must say appreciate your comments on the craft of the movie.

[@angelagraves865]

The spice must flow. In the book(s), those who can afford spice, which is pretty much only the wealthy, take it and use contact lenses to hide the blue eyes of their addiction. Most people take it for the health benefits (e.g. prolonged life, increased vitality, and improved awareness). The Bene Gesserit and Spacing Guild also take it for its ability to unlock prescience. But spice is highly addictive and withdrawal from it is usually fatal. Should spice become unavailable the entire system would crash.

[@arong4906]

Not usually, always.

[@Rhodair]

Aye, it typically could triple someone's lifetime, and I think it's cool how instead of computers or AI making hypertravel possible, it's people high on spice, looking into the future to see if they'd fly into stuff. And yeah, biggest downside is once your exposure to spice is large enough that you've the addict eyes (in the books, they were entirely blueish glowing eyes - both iris & sclera), you had to stay on the spice or die.

[@justusbraz]

You were a joy to watch with. Good insights. I'm excited to watch the next one with you. If you are a reader you should for sure read at least the first four books.

[@blackspell666]

finishing the story^^. its like 20 books. this one is the first half of the first book (6 books originally - expended upon later on)

[@EllisBurksSuperCollector]

I started watching your reaction thinking that its not my type of movie but it actually looks pretty interesting so I'm gonna come back to this. Thanks for lubing up my interest.

[@RyanCarrington]

Haha I like how you snuck that in there. It's really good, man. The only minor negative is where it ends. But with the sequel already out, that's no longer a problem. It's definitely worth your time.

[@EllisBurksSuperCollector]

@RyanCarrington I figured you would enjoy that lol. Cheers man! I'll give it a watch. Have a great day.

[@johnohrstrom5112]

Gotta pay attention to little things in this movie. Like when Paul says he recognizes Gurney's footsteps and the scene where they fight and Paul going for the killing blow to the neck would have gotten him stabbed in the torso. Edit: There are many payoffs in part 2. Watch this one again, then immediately start part 2. It picks up like an hour after part 1.

[@RyanCarrington]

He also uses that same parkour type vault I noted in the beginning with Gurney.

[@johnohrstrom5112]

​@@RyanCarringtonaaaahh! So you've seen 2! Amazing. Auto sub my guy, only halfway through this one but I'm excited for your reaction to 2. May thy knife chip and shatter. If you don't know the importance of the phrase, it's a show of respect indicating you've fought many battles and at the end of your life, you could give no more. Another payoff from his fight with Jamis. And Fayed says it flippantly... Best of luck from across the pond.

[@clash79]

In case no one covers this in the comments...on rewatching these movies, every time you make an assumption about why someone is doing or saying anything, you're probably at least partially right...but it's all more nuanced than that. I highly recommend the book, as you'll gain so much from it. But not everyone's into reading 600 page dense novels. The movies do a pretty good job of portraying it, but it's so layered that it will take several viewings to really grasp it all. But it's a hell of a fun journey!

[@simple_scribe]

Can't wait for part 2. It was satisfying watching your reaction because you picked up on so much. I just watched one where the people didn't get it at all lol

[@RyanCarrington]

That's actually good to hear because when I was editing this, I caught so much more than I did the first time. I was a bit disappointed in myself 😅 I went into part two even more clued up.

[@rebeccablackburn9487]

Baron Harkkonnen is played by Stellan Skarsgaard.

[@JeshuaSquirrel]

My guess is the main obstacle to adapting this saga isn't the special effects technology but rather the strong poliical themes running throughout. There is a lot to keep track of and communicate when you can't peer into the thoughts of every character like in a novel.

[@cheesehands3112]

Love that you sat down with a coffee expecting it to last forever, but by the end you just wanted it to keep going haha.

[@RyanCarrington]

I want an extended edition like Lord of the Rings haha

[@johnohrstrom5112]

​@@RyanCarringtonDenis Villeneuve, the director has said he won't release extended versions. That said, this movie and especially part 2 could add 20 min and I would still want more! He has confirmed part 3 though. Bless the Maker and His Water.

[@Zerbyte]

The original movie was adapted a bit for the big screen so there are differences from this one that follows the book much more closely. You should watch the original, it was amazing to us back in the 80s and still one of my top sci-fi movies. And to the Editor, that overlay of the cat with the chanting cracked me up. Well done.

[@HeisenBird]

Funny that you should mention The Matrix, as the Matrix trilogy is (with no spoilers) very similar in plot beats to the first two Dune books. It was basically a cyberpunk adaptation of Dune and Dune Messiah.

[@jennadawson7949]

My favourite book. Favourite director. And now my favourite movie. But your reaction to this was by far my favourite as well. I like watching reactions to this movie. It's been a long time coming and alot of people were " Debbie doubters" Great job. Looking forward to your part 2.!

[@RyanCarrington]

Oh wow, high praise indeed! Glad you enjoyed watching along. Will have part two out soon! 🤙

[@jennadawson7949]

Well if it's out soon hopefully you got a chance to do a reaction, then go to the theatre. It blew my mind! I'm pretty sure when third comes out it will be just like Lord of the ring.

[@somthingbrutal]

@21:46 its not just the blue eyed people they don't trust, remember its been a day or so since an assassination attempt. most wars inside the empire are wars of Assassins as moving troops is hideously expensive for instance it cost the Baron most of his money to launch the invasion

[@RyanCarrington]

Great points 👊

[@ThaBeatConductor]

Shout out to knowing who Guthrie Govan is. That guy is a freaking wizard. Subbed just for that. xD

[@petergoddard1960]

You've probably already seen part 2 by now. Mind blowing. Only takes us to the end of the first book. Great reaction.

[@hoon_sol]

Well, while "Paul" is a common name, partially because it's short and simple, it's also an ancient one. Funnily enough, it's of Roman origin, from "paulus", meaning "little" or "small"; you'll see how it ties in.

[@JeshuaSquirrel]

It is curious what the Fremen use for lube in the deep desert. Actually, a lot of bodily function questions regarding preservation of fluids.

[@RyanCarrington]

Ahahaha

[@zoesumra9152]

Apparently the guys have...er... worked on methods of reducing expenditure of bodily fluids. There is some speculation that they do the deed very quickly. Still, their tents recycle all liquid...

[@shainewhite2781]

The big hit of the year 2021, $406 million dollars against $160 million dollar budget.

[@bsimester2010]

Probably would have made a lot more if not for the pandemic. Not a lot of people went to the theatres at that point.

[@dudermcdudeface3674]

The Emperor's role in the Harkonnen attack is kept the deepest of state secrets. In the book the Sardaukar (the Emperor's troops) deploy wearing Harkonnen uniforms. The movie has them attack in their own uniforms for audience understanding. The Imperium is a feudal society, so you're not wrong that their style of war is old school. These armies aren't really soldiers, they're warrior-cults attached to a single person or family.

[@somthingbrutal]

when Duncan makes that jump i think the device he activates on his belt is a suspensor allowing the long jump

[@RyanCarrington]

Ahhhh that makes sense!

[@djC653]

@@RyanCarrington yes and you see them on the Baron's back in his 1st scene, that line of red lights. Hence the floating at the end of the spider scene.

[@Gilgie101]

Yes Ryan, we all saw that spill.

[@RyanCarrington]

No you didn't 😂

[@LordVolkov]

"Don't let him suffer..." Jamis was dead when he hit the ground. Paul knows how to kill, and wouldn't shame Jamis further that way. He was a friend of Jamis.

[@DuBstep115]

Basically impossible to kill someone fast if you hit in lower back, Jamis would have been suffering

[@LordVolkov]

@@DuBstep115 the crysknife is 10"+ and can penetrate armor... It's less knife fighting and more of a short sword. We do not see where Paul strikes Jamis, or the angle the blade enters, only that it is from behind. A wound to the liver or heart (up through the ribs) would be fatal, with loss of consciousness from shock/bloodloss.

[@DuBstep115]

@@LordVolkov loss of consciousness maybe, but dead when he hit the ground is impossible. Even if you cut the femoral artery the biggest one in body, it takes 2-4 minutes to die from blood loss. People are still alive when you guillotine their head off

[@RyanCarrington]

Part 2 coming to KZbin soon! Make sure to subscribe for that one. You can catch the full-length reaction over on www.patreon.com/ryancarrington

[@HoopleHeadUSA]

Loved your Half Baked reaction, please please do Harold & Kumar Go to White Castle! But then skip the sequels lol

[@hellomark1]

I love how much you appreciate the cinematography. It's not nearly as epic as this but I can't recommend Arrival (2016) enough, also by denis villeneuve.

[@Gilgie101]

The Dune movies are packed with intense sounds. The night I went to see Dune 2 at the Ultrascreen, our showtime was cancelled due to the speakers in the theater blowing out.

[@TheRedStateBlue]

this happens roughly 23,000-25,000 years in the future. humanity is not finished evolving. our minds could potentially be strong enough to control bodily function, like determining the gender of a conceived child.

[@peterreist2882]

My favorite book of all time. shogun is my #2, so been some exciting viewing for me recently.

[@notjustforhackers4252]

Cheers man, this reaction was perfect as a plot summery for part 2, its been sitting on my SSD for weeks now....I forgot all this stuff, damn.

[@OathofLight]

Some excellent song lyrics: "My hat smells like lubricant, I don't wanna touch it Wait, this isn't mine! And it's not a hat!"

[@TeamHarrisonMachine]

This was a great reaction

[@RyanCarrington]

Appreciate that. Glad you enjoyed it 👊

[@TeamHarrisonMachine]

@@RyanCarrington no problem. Can’t wait for the Dune 2 reaction

[@clash79]

Ha! What a great edit, whether intentional or not. Ryan says I thought he was about to get lucky and he ends up getting dead...cut to Paul saying "it's confusing" lololol

[@clash79]

26:31 for reference

[@RyanCarrington]

😉

[@ToeKnife166]

Paul - means "small". Paul in the Bible was a convert to Christianity who then devoted himself to converting as many people as possible and setting up communities of worship and interpreting the teaching of Jesus. He was instrumental in spreading Christianity. Maybe a bit like Paul spreads the Fremen way of life? St Paul is often considered the most important person after Jesus in the history of Christianity.

[@LewdTrout]

Easily my favorite reaction to Dune. immediately picked up on all the subtext or politics religion and prophecy. I think you'll really enjoy part 2. Time for me to go through your back-catalogue of videos now :D

[@RyanCarrington]

Ah man, I've already done Part 2 and wow! (Not on KZbin yet) After watching this one over and over while editing, I went into the sequel with an even better understanding. It moved so fast compared to this one, which took me by surprise. Glad you enjoyed the watch 🙌

[@ofthenearfuture]

Nice pickup on the similarities to Blade Runner 2049, it is the same director. And Denis Villeneuve does as much as he can for real, so the majority this film is practical. And even more so in Part 2! After reading Dune it was his dream to make it since he was a teenager, so he really put his heart and soul into this story, and I think it shows. From the cinematography and editing, to sound design and music, to the casting and incredible acting, this is by far one of the best sci-fi series ever put to film.

[@MsAppeljack]

The first film here is setting the stage for the second film, which is fruition. Cheers.

[@Danilo-u7f]

43:56 in the book, humanity has developed superior quality in producing military grade materials. thats why the ornithopter was able to perform like it did.

[@russellward4624]

TBF Dr Huey expected his wife to die. The point was they were torturing her and he wanted her suffering to end.

[@echoesofmalachor3700]

In 1872 Robert Cheesebrough patented the first petroleum jelly called “Vaseline”. Although it was not intended for sex, Vaseline quickly became a popular choice in lube. These days, using Vaseline as lube is highly discouraged, as it can lead to bacterial infections in the vagina

[@lyssalovesit]

Apparently im already subscribed to your channel..not sure which video did it but hey hi im sorry i dont remember. ANYWHO! lol loving this reaction and im excited for part 2 💜

[@RyanCarrington]

Aha well, welcome back 🙌

[@lyssalovesit]

@@RyanCarrington lol thanks! Not sure why or where I went because you're awesome 🤙💜

[@RyanCarrington]

@lyssalovesit aww thanks! Yeah, I hear that I vanish from feeds quite a bit from other people, too. maybe I swear too much for the algorithm and advertisers. This one was pretty bad, even by my standards 😅

[@shainewhite2781]

Coming soon: D. U. N. E. Messiah.

[@luciaarnaotorrego6852]

Loved your reaction as always. You should watch society of the snow. It's a great movie and I would love to hear what you have to say about that one. If you do watch it I recommend the original language with subtitles, the acting was amazing

[@justusbraz]

Duncan is the hero. Now and far into their future. He is a catalyst of The Golden Path.

[@TheGoIsWin21]

If I had a nickel for every time I'd been so early to a video drop, I'd have two nickels. Which isn't a lot, but it's weird that it's happened more than once. Thankfully I had enough lube to slide into the comments fast enough to be first 😂

[@RyanCarrington]

Ahahah 👏👏👏

[@TheGoIsWin21]

@@RyanCarrington For my real comment though: Dune was long considered to be essentially "unfilmable". Similarly to Lord of the Rings, it's an incredibly DENSE series of books that build out the entire world over the course of a LOT of words. Equally similar, both the LOTR adaptation and this Dune adaptation succeeded by effectively choosing what material to leave in and leave out. With Dune, a lot of stuff is alluded to that makes sense if you've read the book, but is very unclear to a layman. One example is homeboy rolling his eyes back into his head when he's doing some calculations early on, which you commented on. In this future, humanity has outlawed "thinking machines" beyond a certain capability (because lol AI wars, like always), and as such has pushed the absolute limits of human capability, utilizing genetic lineages and extreme training in order to push the human mind to be capable of doing such extreme processing. So, when my guys eyes roll back, he's accessing that part of himself that's capable of the high processing power in order to come up with a calculation. It's part of why things are also so feudal. When you need an absolute extreme specialist for every little task that computers do, it just makes more sense to have "a guy" for everything, which melds nicely into a feudal heirarchy.

[@Usernamenottaken2k]

Man your lube game was on point for this one. Keep it up!

[@RyanCarrington]

😅 Appreciate it!

[@UberMcFailsauce]

I believe the scenes on arakkis were filmed in Jordan

[@angelagraves865]

If you like to read, I can't recommend the book(s) highly enough. If reading isn't your thing then check out some of the YT videos about Dune. *SO* much had to be left out of the movie and knowing what that stuff is will only help you understand the Dune universe, which is complex and highly developed. Quinn's Ideas puts out the best and most in-depth Dune content, imo. Nerd Cookies and The Lorebrarians are also good channels for learning about Dune. You'll learn about the Bene Gesserit, the Spacing Guild, Mentats, Paul's sister Alia, the life cycle of the worms and the Water of Life, the Fremen, the ban on technology, Suk doctors and their training, and so, so much more.

[@peterreist2882]

Exactly. The guild, bene geserit, c.h.o.a.m, mentats, suk doctors are barely if at all explained. Say what u want about the 1986 movie, but Irulan gave almost all the info above in the first 2 minutes of that movie. I loved the movie don’t get me wrong.

[@Thetasigmaalpha]

There’s also the 2000 SYFY channel mini series.

[@di3486]

I liked this one much better than the second😊 this one has a mystical feel that I only can expect from Dune.

[@RyanCarrington]

I actually know what you mean. The sequel goes into high gear, but I like the vibe of this one.

[@barbarjinx3802]

You need to get the soundtracks. In 2 Arrival is the best track. A culmination of many themes wrapped up in the Keisha Haderach.

[@rg3388]

The seemingly ordinary names result from people clinging to their terrestrial heritage. This also explains the bagpipes and the speaking of English. The name Atreides derives from the house of Atreus in Greek mythology.

[@Frederiknshansen]

Well... Technically they speak "Galach" in-universe. The movie is in english.

[@rg3388]

@@Frederiknshansen Good point. The novel also makes this accommodation for terrestrial readers.

[@rg3388]

@@Frederiknshansen I suppose that would allow for the possibility of a version of the film being made with no terrestrial languages spoken and with all dialogue subtitled accordingly.

[@chrisherber1635]

The fighting style is supposed to have Filipino stick fighting as the foundation.

[@billybillee8160]

you said Lube

[@RyanCarrington]

Can't help myself

[@russellward4624]

A customer called today looking for organic, vegan, free trade personal lubricant. I've finally found a way to beat my meat cruelty free.

[@RyanCarrington]

Sorry about that. It was an emergency.

[@LaughingMan2GIG]

After you watch part 2 I recommend watching the 80s movie for kicks

[@robertbunting3117]

I've seen the version from the 80's so many times it verges on being truly pathetic...ok no verging at all it is pathetic. and these two movies blow that one out of the water.

[@iliketostayhome]

18:18 that very well could have been the doctor's wife. "They take her apart like a doll." That's what the Harkonnens do. Terrible things.

[@BlunderMunchkin]

I think it's more likely that it's a Tleilaxu creation. The Harkonnens don't do biohacking.

[@russellward4624]

Ah, a Guthrie fan. Knew you were a top G.

[@RyanCarrington]

Dude is a wizard!

[@somthingbrutal]

the sign language is the Atredies secret battle language

[@travisgray8376]

Dune part one n dune part 2 adapts the first dune novel while the David Lynch one adapts the whole book as one movie. Better watch part 2 before Lynch's dune otherwise U spoil the ending n plot points for part 2. So watch part 2 then the 1984 film also in 2000 the Syfy channel adapts the first dune novel into a 3 part miniseries should check that out too. The first dune novel was written in 1965.

[@travisgray8376]

Paul the apostle. Paul is not a modern name it's ancient n the aredies in dune the family is Greek n traces their ancestry to King Agamemnon who took Troy. That's in the book but no backstory is given in the film.

[@larindanomikos]

Denis Villeneuve also directed Blade Runner, the new one. I am a big fan of David Lynch. The only thing he did I didn't like was Dune. I felt he was a poor choice, not his kind of thing. It felt like he'd never read the book. I did and he missed the mark.

[@bullpup33]

Two is gonna blow you away. Its way better. IMHO. Watch the 1984 version after you watch the second part.

[@LordVolkov]

There are 2 previous versions of Dune. The 1984 David Lynch (worth a watch because it's insane, look for the spicediver edit) and the 2000s SciFi miniseries Frank Herbert's Dune (the most book accurate - 4.5hr total runtime). If you can forgive the terrible CGI of the miniseries, it is the most faithful to Frank's work.

[@RyanCarrington]

Ahh ok! I hadn't heard of the mini series

[@djC653]

@@RyanCarrington there are 2 mini series the 1st one is the book Dune, the 2nd one, Children Of Dune, is the 2nd & 3rd books in the book series. There are 6 books in the original series. Great reaction tnx

[@LordVolkov]

@@djC653 Yes, the second series is also very good, but diverges enough from the books that they couldn't put Herbert's name on it in good conscience.

[@djC653]

@@LordVolkov didn't catch that tnx

[@di3486]

The miniseries is great!

[@gnomescape]

Lubetube or Youlube? that is the question.

[@RyanCarrington]

I've been asking that one for a while..

[@somthingbrutal]

i think they used a lot of the same locations as Lawrence of Arabia

[@RyanCarrington]

God, I still need to watch that.

[@SCharlesDennicon]

If it's a reaction to part 1, why did you put the poster of the second movie in your thumbnail...?

[@RyanCarrington]

Tbh, I didn't even see dune 2 in there. I just saw complimentary colours and liked how they pop against eachother. I did make this right before I caught Dune 2, though.

[@shainewhite2781]

Nominated for 10 Oscars including Best Picture, but won for: Best Sound (Editing, Mixing) Best Film Editing Best Visual Effects Best Cinematography Best Original Score Best Production Design.

[@somthingbrutal]

if you want a work of art check out The Cook the Thief His Wife and Her Lover Dir Peter Greenaway

[@Rejeckted]

Dont watch the old one. It'll spoil part 2 and potentially part 3

[@dereknolin5986]

I think you could watch it after part 2, really. The part 3 thing or person you're worried about seems to be going in a slightly different direction from the book.

[@Rejeckted]

@@dereknolin5986 i wont argue with that. i actually really love the 84 film. its so weird. he's already watched part 2 at this point too so we'll see

[@stillninja2741]

Just adding some lubricant to the algorithm.

[@russellward4624]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/i364aXl5hb6YiNk This is a great no spoiler video that explains the history of the Dune universe. They left a lot out of the films. The book is so dense its just not possible to cover everything. I highly recommend reading the series.

[@zesouto3752]

21:45 E como sempre, o reactor claramente não conhece o universo de Duna e interpreta que a reação de Gurney e dos outros ao redor do Duque é por não confiar nas pessoas de olhos azuis.....😂😂😂....primeiro, todo mundo não confia em ninguém, e também, no universo de Duna existem infinitas formas de matar, inclusive apenas chegando perto da vítima...😂😂😂

[@nick4819]

The Baron is fat like that because the Bene Gesserit did it to him.

[@jcs1025]

Don’t bother watching the old one. It has some style, but the story was told poorly and the writers and director inserted some ridiculous made up nonsense.

[@dereknolin5986]

I disagree. Yes, they added some stuff, and changed the ending, but in many ways it's more faithful to the book than Villeneuve's versions. The exposition that Villeneuve hates so much really does help explain some things in more detail, and the voiceover narration partially translates the book's writing style which is constantly telling you the internal monologue of all the characters.

[@davidn5269]

Huge L, dude. The production design is so incredible. In a lot of ways it’s not a great adaptation, but it’s a fascinating movie and well worth watching for someone who is interested in that sort of thing.

[@samjohnson7869]

Yeah, I watched it for the first time a few weeks ago, and it was not good. 6/10 imo

[@znk0r]

As a massive fan of the books the old movie has is strengths.

[@FosterTravis1071]

They actually didn't change the ending. ​@@dereknolin5986

[@nick4819]

Name one place that the British took every single resource and they have none left. I'll wait.

[@tfpp1]

The second part IS out. React to it, please! 😅

[@RyanCarrington]

I watched this before the release of Part Two. But it's coming!

[@LordVolkov]

"That's annoying me... I did not see that coming!" Unfortunately, Dr Kynes death is wasted in this version. In the book, Kynes is released in the deep desert with no stillsuit and dies in a spice blow (Herbert uses the death of an ecologist/planetologist to show the reader part of the worm life cycle) and it comes back around with Chani (who is Kynes' daughter in the book) and how the Baron is dealt with. All of that is lost here, for... another worm scene 😒

[@user-wr9ej6xe4j]

These Dune movies are beyond stupid. Dont pretend to like them just for the upload

[@RyanCarrington]

What?! It's an awesome story tied together with stunning cinematography.

[@odin741]

In less than 3 minutes you managed to insult your own country...

[@RyanCarrington]

I gotta pump those numbers up. Those are rookie numbers.

[@johnwillis4706]

You need to watch the 1984 original. As with most remake, this one falls short.