Give Birth Here for Dual Citizenship

[@davidfeng5871]

As from non-American perspective, dual citizenship is the best way to open up the job markets and avoid wars. American tends to only think about tax savings.

[@spacesandplacesoutthere]

Yeah because Americans get taxed for EVERYTHING EVERYWHERE.

[@Stobus44]

Dual citizenship is more likely to be the reason for a war instead of avoiding a war.

[@hasinabegum1038]

Job markets.USA is The biggest Job market in The world

[@samuel.fraser]

I think about avoiding wars over everything else personally

[@ramimbintybindu9840]

​@PatRisberg26th runner..

[@rahuliyer7456]

As the child of legal immigrants to the USA from India, i got my US citizenship by birth in the USA. Both parents were Green Card holders residing in Chicago at the time. Dad got his US citizenship two years after my birth. Mom git hers 5 years after my birth. BTW.. Dad answered the Vietnam Draft card he got. Both of my parents renounced their India citizenship after naturalization. India doesn't allow dusl citizenship. So, what this means is I could technically qualify for a full India citizenship, but why? The US has a better passport....and I live and work in the USA. I ain't getting an India passport and giving up my US passport. There is one thing I have done though. I got my OCI from India. It is actually a visa not a citizenship for India... almost like their Green Card. I have it. My wife have no interest. FYI. My wife of 19 years is a dual US snd Vietnam Citizen. She immigrated to US from Vietnam after marrying me. So by my wife I have acquired a Vietnam residence visa also. We have talked about relocating to Mexico. Will pursue a Mexican citizenship when we cross that bridge.

[@kth6736]

You dont qualify for Indian citizenship naturally since you parents decided to make you a US citizen and chose on your behalf.

[@VamosViverFora]

My Portuguese grandpa lived in Brazil for more than 80 years and never bothered to ask for naturalisation. If that so, he’d lost his Portuguese citizenship as Brazil didn’t allow dual citizenship in the past.

[@andytaquechel6933]

That means you're eligible for the Portuguese passport

[@VamosViverFora]

@@andytaquechel6933 I am a Portuguese national already. Dual citizenship actually. Luso-Brazilian.

[@GustavoVarela-ws1pi]

Spain has birthright citizenship for children of parents from 14 different countries. It s called citizenship by simples presuncion. If a child of 2 colombian parents is born in spain the child is spanish by birth. It s a gap in the law but it works

[@GustavoVarela-ws1pi]

@@MuzzaHukka right point is if you are brazilian and arrive in spain 7 months pregnant and you do the process ( which if you pick the right municipaçity takes 1 month) you get a spanish by origin child. And a 5 year validity residence permit for the parents in which you don t need means to support yourself.

[@GustavoVarela-ws1pi]

@@MuzzaHukka if you can t take advantage of this spanish gap in the law. You have portugal if you are 7 months pregnant give birth and put the child in kindergarden for 1 school year you get child ´passport.

[@GustavoVarela-ws1pi]

last year a child born in morocco before her mother entered a migrant boat got spanish citizenship by birth. A court said her mum couldn´t register her camerronian because she didn even got moroccan birth certificate so court ruled spanish by birth as to take in account the supreme interest of the child.

[@GustavoVarela-ws1pi]

@@MuzzaHukka point is with little effort anyone can have an EU child. Through spain in case you can take advantage of the gap in the law or through portugal. Arrive 7 months pregnant in portugal the baby attends 1 year of kindergarden in portugal you get the child ´s passport.

[@GustavoVarela-ws1pi]

Portugal has almost full birthright citizenship. 1 parent is a legal resident or resides in the country illegally for 1 year. Even if your child does not immediatelty qualify he will after one parent gets legal residency or the child go to school for just one year in portugal.If your child is born in portugal he is almost sure to get citizenship. Parents get residence permit. Even if you give birth you leave and return when the child is 10 he still only needs 1 year of schooling in portugal.

[@miguelgustavobohorquezblan3754]

This is 100% true, I don't think people realize this is a huge opportunity to get an EU passport for their children. I have a friend who gave birth in Portugal after living here for like 6 months and they got Portuguese citizenship for their twins because they had legal residency at the time of the birth.

[@GustavoVarela-ws1pi]

100 percent true huge opportunity. Specially if you are an entrepreneur you get a D7 residence visa you are qualified for an EU child from the day you step in portugal.

[@GustavoVarela-ws1pi]

Because they are portuguese by birth those children have right to: spanish citizenship in 2 years; brazilian citizenship in 1 year; mexican citizenship in 2 years. Easier right of abode in macau; easier movement in portuguese speaking countries; easier movement in the ibero american space. If you are wealthy and you get a d7 visa or d8 visa the baby automatically becomes portuguese.

[@GustavoVarela-ws1pi]

@@MuzzaHukka just easier way to get residence permit in portugal and no portuguese language test required. Also brazilians by naturalization do NOT qualify for fast track spanish citizenship only NATURAL BORN . Brazilizans by birth have fast track colombian citizenhio mexican as well hondurian and so on but only natural born.

[@oliverqueen5883]

Ireland removed citizenship by birthright the year I was born 😭 and then my parents never got me Irish citizenship (even though my dad naturalised) after I turned 5 (easy process) and then we left Ireland

[@GustavoVarela-ws1pi]

The law has changed now children born in ireland who don t have birthright citizenship qualify after age 3.

[@shueibdahir]

@@lmaoingrnCareful there brother

[@patrick1992]

​@@lmaoingrnwhats about the Islanic Republic of Sweden or Islamic Republic of Great Brittan?

[@oliverqueen5883]

@@GustavoVarela-ws1pi Doesn't change the fact that I've left

[@pixiet7321]

Married a European 20 years ago. Kids have heritage ties and I made sure they were born in Europe. Da d Europe mom American. Lucky $perm club as Andrew says

[@kwaintraub2]

I've been saying this for years. My sons now have three countries open to them to work and live: the US, Argentina, and Mexico.

[@RamyWhitlock]

How can I achieve dual citizenship for my wife from West Africa? Please. She's pregnant right now.

[@biAnthony]

Yeah, same here. Thanks

[@RamyWhitlock]

​@@MuzzaHukkathanks for showing concern. Please, what are the possible processes to get to Bolivia? Do you have anyone I can count on for the processes to be realised?

[@beautyuche]

@@RamyWhitlock Go to Mexico or USA or Canada or Brazil..Its a great opportunity to give to your children

[@hamzakhurram2910]

10:14 which european country lets you bring 5 generations through citizenship by investment?

[@gonzapacini5668]

what would be a good addition to having Argentinian and Italian citizenship?

[@FreedomPlaya]

Mexican ❤

[@funkthat]

Japan and USA combo the most prestige and exclusive citizenships, my kids are set up for success

[@anthonychen6237]

But Japan does not allow dual citizenship....so how do you plan to do that?

[@funkthat]

@@anthonychen6237 hmm if japan doesnt allow dual citizenship how do my 2 kids, my wife, bro in law and millions of japanesehold dual and american citizenships at the same time? The fact is that it is possible to hold both due to legal gray areas.

[@anthonychen6237]

@@funkthat Yes, Japan has law for that but they have not forced it very strictly!

[@YouTubefan-yj4rp]

@@anthonychen6237 Japan allows dual-citizenship until the individual reaches 22-years of age. Even after that, there still is no penalty for having dual-citizenship.

[@micco6020]

What about the military draft in birthright countries? That is a consideration

[@hexpest9328]

Love the content. Love the company. Dream of becoming your client!

[@nomadcapitalist]

Thank you for the kind words! We're delighted that you enjoy our content and have a positive view of our company. We will be happy to serve you.

[@jimj2683]

The problem with dual citizenship with USA, is if you want to give up the citizenship in the future (due to changing taxes/politics) you will be forced to pay whatever you would have paid if there was no tax treaty between the two countries.

[@hasinabegum1038]

USA has tax treaty with most countries

[@abacaxi.maldoso]

I am already Brazilian, is Mexico my best option to be a father there?

[@stevemyers2092]

just a guess but a good guess for his Dad NOT being a US Citizen....is the family owns allot of land in India. Doesn't want to give it up.

[@MyLatinLife]

Birth tourism is going to become a bigger and bigger thing

[@FreedomPlaya]

Great advice Andrew 😊 Viva Mexico!

[@FreeSkeptic]

The 14th Amendment of The Constitution of the United States starts with "Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside." The language suggests a person born or naturalized in the United States is automatically a citizen for life regardless of whether the person wants citizenship or not, and suggests United States birthright citizenship is mandatory. Interestingly, US statuatory law allows United States citizens to renounce their citizenship, free at first, but later $400 and now $2500. The language also suggests if a person renounces their United States citizenship, that person could sue to have their citizenship, technically not restored, but never renounced to begin with. If poiticians knew, would they exploit this loophole by requiring renounced citizens to pay foreign sourced income taxes? Let's hope politicians don't discover this. Some restrictions could be legislated through the "subject to jurisdiction" clause, but it's unclear to me which legislated restrictions would or would not be acceptable to SCOTUS. Another question is "Could illegal immigrants and their American born children be legislatively declared 'not subject ot jurisdiction and exclude birthright citizenship for them?" With diplomats and their children are mostly immune to deportation, where could American born non-citizens be deported to?

[@SunnivavinnuS]

What about children who are all ready born and is only 1 nationality and born the same place? Where is the easiest, cheapest and fastest country to get citizenship? Thank you 🙏

[@tipr8739]

Same as everything else, you can get two options. All three doesn’t exist. Either fast and cheap, but not easy; fast and easy, but not cheap; or cheap and easy, but not fast

[@matthewnirenberg]

No where - if you're rich then CBI is an option. Otherwise you have none!

[@cavelleardiel]

Indians are very calculated in what they do (not saying this as a slight). What I mean is that since they are exposed to corruption growing up they will not trust the government, etc but will look at how to protect their family. Vivek's parents made choices to protect their children and ensure that they have the best outcome. One parent keeps the Indian citizenship and the other gets the citizenship of the country they reside in. I hope Vivek wins the Presidency as he can make the changes in the US that they desperately need.

[@RodneyKimbangu]

And when it backfires, he will blame someone else.

[@ssuwandi3240]

Kamala is exactly the anchor baby. Loser immigration if the parents had to play like a bowl beggar. Sorry i would never promote the scheme as amazing. The US set it up as last resort of emergency.

[@ssuwandi3240]

Weasel at heart , absolutely

[@johnclifford544]

God help us if that delusional grifter gets into the White House. The reality is, he is trying to become Trump's VP pick. They deserve each other.

[@77Redwood]

Vivek wants to raise the voting age to 25. I don't understand how someone can vote for someone who actively wants to take away Americans rights.

[@Gamenetreviews]

I’m American, I had my kid in Canada

[@ricdesouza1]

I am Indian- i was and am still legally married to a British girl and we have two grown children, and yet- i never took residency nor citizenship. The hoops i would have had to jump through just to get the privilege of paying tax to the British government were just too demeaning to someone who received an income more than ten times the average British salary. This was probably why Viveks father refused citizenship for the USA. The end result is most western countries get the most desperate of the immigrants and that of course comes with its own set of problems but the developed nations seem to want to lump all immigrant claims into one basket. The result is the social problems one sees with these immigrants

[@anthonychen6237]

PR visa (green card) still has to pay USA taxes globally....so not sure how Viveks father's status to stay in US long term if he is neither citizen nor PR visa holder.

[@dumdumbrown4225]

@@anthonychen6237It is near impossible for the US Government or IRS to implement global tax accountability on a US permanent resident (PR) / green card holder. Like ‘great’ Britain, the US does have a few flamboyant rules that are jokes in their own right. Setting up a corporation/company registered in another country to bring back your earnings in that country to the US is one approach, and there are many other ways to legally circumvent any tax rules. And Vivek’s father was a PR visa / green card holder - he just chose not to take up US citizenship …my partner and I are the same - we won’t take up US citizenship.

[@Denver_____]

The Imigration lawyers would love that, more paper work for a child being born in the US and not getting it automatically would boost their services.

[@Chaviero71]

I completely agree with everything Vivek stands for besides ending birthright citizenship. I'm an anchor baby myself and I'm proud to be part of a republic that that promotes capitalism while still being proud of my cultural background

[@jasonzhang6500]

Okay for Vivek to gain citizenship? Maybe he can start giving up us citizenship first before taking away this from other people

[@TimTheEnchanterpoo]

He's not a dual citizen with split loyalties... Just get... Go where the grass is greener...

[@antoniobrasse7157]

What happens to a child born in a country that is birth by blood whose parents are only residents there and not from there and those parents are from a country that is birth by soil where citizenship is not extended to their children if the children weren't born there? Can this stateless scenario happen?

[@Murmilone]

The child will often get the citizenship of the place of birth even in the eastern hemisphere in this case.

[@tipr8739]

There is often a clause where either one where they live will have a such and such for situations where no other citizenship is available

[@matthewnirenberg]

Kids automatically get the citizenship of their parents. There is zero circumstance where a child won't get one citizenship or residency (i.e. OCI, green card etc.). If a child was truly stateless then after 10yrs of legal residence in a country they'd be able to naturalize. Your scenario is impossible to occur in real life though.

[@Tee55118]

Very interesting about Ohio birth. Also, all the Americas, I didn't know....

[@eyesfreesight3962]

Is it on American constitution to give the citizenship to those who were just born on the US territory? This candidate is such a populist I think :)

[@andytaquechel6933]

Portugal is also birthright as long as the parents are legal residents

[@winterfern4881]

I was just talking to a girl from another country who came here with her husband on vacation. just to give birth to their child renting an Airbnb so the child can get to citizenship then they're moving back to their home country

[@DinisAfonso]

Nice jacket! Can you talk about special talent (research, medical, ...) resident permits that may lead to citizenship? Best

[@Mayesyy]

Yes, second that.

[@ramimbintybindu9840]

There are countries that supports dual citizenship mainly through investments...

[@josiah5776]

Both my parents were German citizens legally in the US on immigration visas when I was born. I have held US citizenship my entire life. My parents were both naturalized 3 years after I was born.

[@marklutz95]

You might already be a dual citizen.

[@iashaikh20]

So once again how many countries? Where's the list ?

[@HalleSweetPea]

Which program was mentioned for the second family citizenship? Curious about this having as we are having another child soon.

[@FreedomPlaya]

Come to Mexico :) He’s talking about citizenship by birthright I.e. by being born on that country’s land. Among other countries, Mexico allows this, and I’ve been quite a few Mexican ‘anchor babies’ born to foreign parents ;)

[@HalleSweetPea]

This is our front running option. Just went for a visit without the other 3 kids and loved it. Stayed in Quintana Roo.

[@mauraece]

China just launched Visa free travel for France, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands and Spain. Persons with ordinary passports from those countries gain visa-free access to China.

[@haggai3.477]

2 Week Visa Free entry for the aforementioned Countries, ending in 2024. Somehow, the timing is concerning. Especially while wrestling with mysterious respiratory challenges primarily in the adolescent populace.

[@youtubeuserzzzz]

​@PatRisbergNOT everyone. Only a selected few are allowed 10 years for leisure. I know. As my second Citizenship does NOT qualify for China's 10 year Tourist visa.

[@SoundsofNature862]

Europe should reconsider

[@oliverqueen5883]

Lmao I’m usually mad that I have French passport by descent instead of Irish by birth, but I’ll take the visa free access to China lol.

[@djmaciiiii]

when? Are you talking about mainland china? I am sure US citizens are required to obtain a visa before entering mainland china.@@aricanaan1266

[@mochileiro21]

When North and South America were colonized, they needed people from other continents. 500 years ago, people would go on boats without returning, not knowing that one day would be much easier to move around in the world, it did not make sense their children born in the new world without the right of citizenship.

[@p.e.a.c.e.o.u.t6713]

You cannot own land if you give up your Indian citizenship that’s why so many people don’t give it up

[@radicaledwards3449]

You can give birth, it depends how you identify.

[@cker1924]

(1) The problem with unconditional birthright citizenship, is that it encourages illegal and casual/passing entrants to come and have anchor babies! (2) This guy is simply describing what some other countries are doing, in terms of granting the abused unconditional birthright citizenship to children of parents who have no attachment or stake in the country that they’re just visiting or passing through. But a simple description of what is, doesn’t justify it. This is the faulty excuse that lazy, crowd-followers use, to justify the status quo. Do we want to let an abuse continue, or do we want to stop an abuse, by doing WHAT IS RIGHT and FAIR? Allowing the anchor-baby abuse to continue, is UNFAIR TO ALL the LEGAL IMMIGRANTS, and makes a joke of the immigration policy. It is cognitive lethargy and stupid to support the status quo, if the status quo is hurting the country, by the said abuse. Vivek has clearly and precisely identified the flaw, and highlighted the importance of LEGALLY RESIDENT PARENTS, in the granting of birthright citizenship. Instead of supporting such a rare, righteous, fair, intelligent and bold leader, some lazy, crowd-following “educated” people are jumping to bad-mouth him! Such people are doing a dis-service to the nation!

[@jeremyleonbarlow]

The Constitution is sacrosanct. You guys always say so now you want to change it. No, no and no. And by the way if a foreigner who is not a legal permanent resident of the US gives birth to a child in the US like while on vacation, they are already barred from re-entering the US. The child is a citizen, but that foreigner parent will be deported and declared persona non-grata from entering the US under current law. There is no such thing as an "anchor baby." What they have done to the child is cursed them with a lifelong tax burden from a country they probably will never even live in nor want to. The United States is a developing nation based on all of the metrics, nobody wants to live in the US you are delusional.

[@nomadcapitalist]

@@jeremyleonbarlow The same people who claim the Constitution is gospel do tend to change their tune when they find the part they don't like.

[@MH-et5sn]

@@jeremyleonbarlow Nobody wants to live in the US? A developing nation (list the metrics)? You're the delusional one buddy! Also, you do know birthright citizenship wasn't in the original constitution right? It stems from the 14th Amendment and was meant to give former slaves citizenship, not illegal immigrants. It can be amended again.

[@Serge-cm5my]

​@nomadcapitalist Exactly walking talking hypocrites

[@angershark88]

If my child was born in St Kitts & Nevis while I was on vacation, could I gain citizenship in addition to my child??

[@matthewnirenberg]

Nope! Like all sane countries they only give children citizenship automatically if one or both parents are legal citizens. Your child would automatically get the citizenships you and your spouse have like in all normal countries (i.e. automatic descent / real birthright (by blood)). No one should ever be given citizenship simply for being born in a country - that endorses illegal migration.