He Is Not the Father | Judge Mathis

The plaintiff used to date the defendant, and they share a child. However, the plaintiff learned he wasn't the father and went to jail for not paying child support. He's suing for emotional distress. The defendant insists the plaintiff failed to show up to court to take a paternity test. The defendant is countersuing for emotional distress.
#JudgeMathis #Court #Mathis #RealityTV
Subscribe to our channel below:
/ judgemathis

[@onemikenation2783]

Is she really yelling at this man at the end for not helping her take care of a kid that's not his. What in the hell is wrong with her

[@TopherGrant]

Typical hood mentality. She doesn't think about what's best for the baby, only herself

[@tom11zz884]

Entitlement.

[@tarjayday3062]

Delusional

[@girlypink3771]

That what I said … like this dummy 😂😂

[@jeterjacknat1]

She's a certified nut case

[@papalegbasson2447]

Why is she all in his face yelling about not providing for the child? When it's not his child😂😂😂

[@jacobestevez7570]

... trifling madness ...

[@HolyRollerTV]

because thats what FBA women do...

[@dineilbtv]

She lyin. Women need to be jailed for this

[@teamtaylor0605]

As a woman I agree with you, there should definitely be a consequence for telling these type of lies.

[@NickysWorld88]

Same thing I said. When she first started talking i could tell she was lying

[@ruffadamsthegreat.2662]

She's definitely a Liar. "THEY put him on child support!" Yes, because you lied to them too.

[@richardwilson7207]

Right 💯 %

[@Orlandoloc83]

Doesn’t mean he isn’t a cornball I hate dudes like him. Want to play step daddy till she needs a favor every single day lol

[@pixiebezona]

Being loud doesn't make you right 🤦🏻‍♀️

[@TopherGrant]

Like Trumpers

[@silethaking279]

💯

[@Judah_13]

That's one seriously loud and obnoxious so called woman.

[@christiandilday7543]

He needs child support reimbursement smh

[@DamagedGoods77]

ASAP

[@christiandilday7543]

White judges are bias and choose profits over parenting

[@lolabombshell8978]

is that a thing ? 😮

[@amandabarrett2472]

She should be jailed for allegedly knowing it wasnt his baby but let him be locked up

[@Ev-rd2lw]

Exactly 💯

[@cosmicpressure]

Yeah that was a little wild

[@kimf442]

Right!!!

[@tarjayday3062]

FACTS

[@silethaking279]

💯💯

[@Strawberryfreeze3000]

Getting locked up over child support for a child that’s not yours is wild wild..

[@breeziem4988]

The defendant is the type that will lie to have someone arrested

[@meltonbell5739]

Unfortunately that type is 7% of the population

[@Shabazzatta]

The type!? She is vehemently in his face as if he guilty of ANYTHING!?

[@blackpowerpuff6155]

​@@meltonbell5739 Did you mean 70%?

[@jacquiemylove80]

AGREED

[@susiesolangesimpson2828]

If you mislead your own daughter then why wouldn’t we think that you mislead him as well??????

[@Judah_13]

Add this one to the very long list of such cases.

[@blackpowerpuff6155]

Right..

[@tdrco.collections]

Message!

[@Eltown33]

She tried to cry herself out the case 😂😂😂 bunch of lies.

[@brooklynhuana]

Girl why do he have to look YOUR CHILD in the face and tell her that YOU lied..this woman is crazy

[@biancawilliams748]

That's only if he's telling the truth

[@queenb2713]

She upset that she has to pay $4000 back...

[@sarahrean7174]

The show pay so what is her pb 👀

[@getbusydrizzy5296]

SHE GOT SOME SERIOUS ISSUES ---AND NOW SHES A MOTHER? THATS TOUGH ON THAT CHILD

[@SBoy-ks6wt]

Exactly! Imagine that thing your mother being. SMH

[@liona1657]

This woman seems a nasty woman.

[@Erica-zg7yo]

I agree

[@heavyizthacrown-5842]

She’s had a baby to get a monthly check out of dude.

[@KingBoxingandFitness]

If you know the child is NOT his then WHY put him on child support ??? 🤔 lies lies

[@yung1717]

Right she’s lying about that. You can only put a legal father on child support. So that’d have to be his kid biologically or adopted. Not just a boyfriend

[@NKAB4]

Exactly even if she was receiving government assistance she could’ve disputed that…

[@lavidaloca2344]

​@NKAB4 not if he signed the bc

[@sereneamani1713]

@@yung1717 In what county, state, or country is that true?

[@lewing981]

The state will fille child support when you apply for government assistance. She could have told them that she didn't know who the father was but he signed the birth certificate so he was responsible for the child.

[@peryole]

"he wasn't helping me"...why would he help you with a child you claim you always knew wasn't his.

[@amandabarrett2472]

She is a sorry excuse. Why Doyle allow her to be in his face

[@AkinolaWilliams]

Doyle is an actor. Not a real bailiff

[@amandabarrett2472]

@@AkinolaWilliams then he's supposed to act like a real bailiff

[@asiaanderson5556]

​@@amandabarrett2472😂😂😂😂

[@bigboywhoadie]

That's a big woman.. Doyle didn't want no parts of that. 🙅🏾😆

[@adrianaheras1291]

​@@amandabarrett2472😂😂😂😂

[@ramsesstafford4640]

Lock her up period.

[@stickymickey4603]

Chileeee why’d she agree to come on tv???

[@jm2297]

She probably needed the appearance fee, cos logic wasn't it!

[@sarahrean7174]

The show pay the 4000 dollars

[@DirtyBoyKennelz]

😂😂😂

[@justhereyeah1112]

This is why I’m glad some hospitals have already started implementing that “fathers” are not allowed to sign birth certificates without paternity proof unless the couple is married.

[@yung1717]

… y’all “fathers” need to stop sleeping with random women if you think women are planting babies on yall

[@radonspace2098]

​@yung1717 Clearly, this one did. 😂

[@sereneamani1713]

@@yung1717 True. But THAT scenario was NOT THIS.

[@Ginaaaa555]

You went through trauma with rape. So why would you put your child and him through some bs.

[@ChangedUpNowWhat]

I didn’t understand what the assault had to do with the paternity. I’m a Victor myself but I couldn’t connect the dots as what that had to do with the baby. Was she saying that the child resulted from the assault? Imma rewind it.

[@1980tiffani]

@@ChangedUpNowWhatyes, in the beginning she said she was SA’ed and got pregnant as a result. But continuing to listen to the case I think he was messing with the lady when she happened to be assaulted , so there was a question of who was the father.

[@1980tiffani]

Misery loves company.. so damn sad.

[@y_e_i8213]

Why does he need to be petitioned for paternity test when she knew he wasn’t the child?!

[@tavyn01]

Cause his goofy ah signed the birth certificate. You know she gets benefits. So child support was automatic

[@odog76543]

​@@tavyn01he signed it because he didn't know he was not the father. I bet he didn't know paternity was even in question. Just think a little deeper before you maintain criticism of him: How would she know at conception that the alleged rapist would be the father of the unborn child (as she claims she told him) if she was in a (sexual) relationship with the plaintiff that whole time? She's having unprotected sex with the plaintiff regularly, and then allegedly got raped by a different man during the relationship with the plaintiff. It would be impossible for her to know who out of the two would be the father prior to the birth without an INVASIVE prenatal DNA test. If she actually got one, it would prove she actually took steps to confirm the true paternity of the child, which would make it more reasonable to presume she made the plaintiff aware before he signed the birth certificate. She produced court documents about missed court hearings, so she definitely would have shown a prenatal DNA test result if she actually did one. She wants people to believe she told her teen boyfriend who she is regularly sexually intimate with that she was raped but knew that only the rapist impregnated her, and that the teen boyfriend willingly and knowingly signed the birth certificate with no DNA test that they freely offer at the hospital post birth??

[@ceejay9919]

She def lied and if she knew he was not the father, why would she put him on child support? Sneaky bih

[@NC-wf4ki]

If she knew he wasn’t the father she should have said that from the court!!! She didn’t miss one meal.

[@ronaldmeyers1745]

Cimment not necessary

[@boogster9526]

⁠@@ronaldmeyers1745very necessary…she’s nasty as hell

[@toya8955]

She put the him thru all this and he is not the dad. She knew he wasn’t the father

[@toya8955]

She wrong but u going to pay him $4,000

[@brandonray4379]

Yup. Every bit of it. You damn right.

[@sybilwhite1259]

Why didn't she go to the father of her child rather than railroad the other young man 😕 who isn't the real Father of the Child!!!! She's got a lot of nerve.

[@MaryjaneLove]

_&& she claimed she was raped . . 😢

[@MichelleM-pj6nf]

She knew the child wasn't his butt put him on child support???wow she awful

[@mikeaddison5697]

She need to be mad at rapist not him

[@carriecrawford2122]

That's if it is true...

[@reesewashington181]

That trauma may have created a lot of anger issues for her.

[@teemoney9865]

No disrespect but I dnt believe that lady by a long shot its already hard 2 tell ya story like me on things of being violated, and u would keep the child by the person who hurt u and not being arrested 4 it, this wild she should b in jail

[@RolandWilliams-rl7ly]

She lied so much ! That is if she really was ? Who knows ?

[@faisamohamed6292]

This is actually the most ridiculous case ive ever seen! The entitlement of this women is crazy! Poor guy & poor child !

[@wheresierraat]

The defendant has some serious trauma to unpack. Only a good therapist can help her to heal. She has a lot of misplaced anger, animosity and resentment towards the plaintiff. But, I doubt she told the plaintiff that he wasn't the father. I'm sure she told him that he was the father because in her 15/16 year old mind that was a lot easier to accept. The plaintiff certainly deserves a lot more money than what was awarded here.

[@radonspace2098]

She lied about being violated. Believe this 'Narcissist' at your own peril. That's right ladies, I used the word.

[@user-tv2wk4yy2y]

Preach

[@ahsguyton4940]

People really need to be mindful of who they sleep with.

[@user-tv2wk4yy2y]

That's facts fr 💯

[@jessij6641]

She was stalling in 06 she ain’t want those checks to stop. She keep saying he didn’t help me with what!!??

[@sybilwhite1259]

Is this woman really serious?? She should be incarcerated for the Crap she put him!!!

[@carshalei2569]

Im just tryna see how the hell you even FILE for child support on a man that's KNOWINGLY...NOT the father!!! Whether he signed the birth certificate or not, he's doing YOU a favor. I think she lied about the rape 💁🏾‍♀️

[@queenbee3828]

She made that rape up, to explain being trifling as hell!

[@lavidaloca2344]

Whenever she applied for government assistance, they automatically went after the noncustodial parent on the birth certificate

[@christiandilday7543]

He needs to got to family court for child support reimbursement smh prayed for him

[@toya8955]

he will not be reimbursed from the court

[@Sheistyscorpion]

@@toya8955agreed. I didn’t think reimbursement was a thing

[@carltonwomble4790]

It’s not. I am a paralegal at a law firm that practices Family Law in North Carolina. The most the court can do for you in this situation is stop the child support payments from coming out of your check.

[@christiandilday7543]

@@carltonwomble4790 white man is so bias and unfair we need child support reform and soon

[@christiandilday7543]

@@toya8955 that's sad

[@justmedoingme]

Why would she put on child support if she knew that he wasn’t the dad she’s grimy

[@lavidaloca2344]

She didn't. Since he signed the bc, then they automatically went after him if she applied for government assistance

[@odog76543]

​@@lavidaloca2344it was her responsibility to notify them that he was not the child's father. She said to Mathis that she knew during the pregnancy, so she can't hide behind "I didn't know or wasn't sure which man was the father!" She knew he would be put on child support when she applied for government assistance. She definitely chose to do nothing when he got arrested for child support for a child she knew was not even his. I find it very interesting how so many women decry dead beat dad's, yet frequently let those men off Scott free and willingly allow men who are not the father's to get charged child support and arrested instead. Then throw up hands and say "not my fault, not my problem"

[@lavidaloca2344]

@odog76543 that girl was 15, not some diabolical plotting baby mama, plus he was even older than her so they both were old enough to know better 🤷🏽‍♀️ also since he signed the BC, it doesn't matter what she says, they have to go to court to get him removed, not just by her word.

[@odog76543]

@lavidaloca2344 you're being pretty damn hyperbolic and disingenuous by using words like "diabolical" to suggest that a teen being deliberately deceptive for material gain (child support and government assistance) is either diabolical or innocuous, but nothing in between. Perhaps we can substitute your word diabolical for "trifling", "shady", "wrong", "despicable", "scummy", or any number of other apt adjectives that can describe behavior that falls short of a corny supervillain scheme. In any event, knowing you caused your boyfriend to get arrested for a "crime" you know he did not commit is certainly worthy of any number of descriptions like the ones. I listed. As is suing for emotional distress caused by her own lie to her own child about paternity.

[@tiffanymitchell06]

As a woman myself... She lied and she knows she did... She hurt him and her on daughter for her on selfish needs

[@Hsauce429]

Outside tha court room !!wut da hell wuz She talkn about !!!! He aint tha damn Baby Daddy !! She must can’t hear gud !!!!

[@83kiarra]

Why did she put him on child support if she knew he was not the biological father

[@83kiarra]

Okay i understand the state opening the case, but i dont understand them clarifying all of this earlier

[@tom11zz884]

He need to run as far away as he can from that entitled ratchet

[@silethaking279]

💯💯 I wouldn’t have had a comment at the end…deuces ✌🏾

[@y_e_i8213]

Why are they letting her get all in his face aggressively at the end? If a man was doing , they would’ve nipped it in the bud immediately. Had he swung bc he felt threatened then he would’ve been arrested.

[@King-Killa-Ca]

Another Lying Baby Mother 😂#BachelorGang #NoKidsGang 🏃‍♂️✌️😂

[@444clockit]

If you knew he wasn’t the dad then why you even let him get put on child support? She could’ve easily said “he is not my child’s father “ right? Some women are trifling man , I would never

[@kandi668]

If his name is on the birth certificate then she just can’t say he’s not the dad. Paternity has been established at that point. It’s not a simple fix once the birth certificate has been signed. That is a legal binding document of who birthed the child and who is responsible for the child.

[@lewing981]

That would have cancelled her benefits. She could have got them back but was eas going to be a long process

[@georgewabwire824]

She gets knocked by someone else and lets a brother stay in jail for her lies!!!!!!what a Satan??

[@meicolar1724]

She lyin...she could have prevented him being put in jail by telling the court he wasn't the father

[@deliahighsmith7916]

The mother seems very toxic. She showed her true colors at the end.

[@hoolierun4432]

Just here for the comments. I knew the men would be throwing their nails at the screen for this one right here LMAO

[@Viva__XO]

She's trying to use that emotional thing to convince the judge, not one year dropped. Fake

[@melnicole7902]

She said that the state opened up the child support case but she had to give his name for them to open up the case. They don’t just pull a name out of thin air.

[@rodericksears638]

Glad she proved his case for him

[@breeziem4988]

Adrian bout to comment why he keep telling people it’s better to be and stay single the plaintiff played himself for signing the birth certificate

[@jawjaboi]

The system is broken. She should be jailed for playing these games or pay him back

[@genocidemoose9293]

Everything you have just watched and heard is the reason why she will always be a single with a sad song to sing. 🤔😒

[@cptfreeman8966]

Man listen a woman told me I was the daddy of her daughter. She got BLOCKED. Felt bad and came back around a couple years later just to find out I really wasn’t the daddy 😂😂😂

[@blackspider1405]

Ohh, she has some nerve..

[@mylazyroots]

She showed her colours. shameful. Women should be arrested for lying about paternity like this.

[@jaepatterson6162]

How tf you mad when you put this man on child support claiming he knew it wasn’t his child and got him put in jail? She low down this story don’t even make sense he needs to be compensated period and he wouldn’t have signed no birth certificate knowing a child ain’t his

[@phaldaz]

10:38 Doyle dropped the ball at at the end, letting her step up to him like that, talking all in his face

[@odog76543]

Yeah, that was not right letting her get all up in his face swinging her hands and even poking him.

[@mashondaknight9132]

The audacity of the defendant to sue ...this is phatnity fraud and yes the plaintiff needs to reimbursed for whatever he spent and women who don't know who the father is should get an abortion and give the child up for adoption.The defendant is lying look at her yelling in the end.

[@bellladonna2071]

She has a lot of nerve yelling at this man. Smh

[@sheilasembly-crum8447]

I understand her frustration but she is WAY too confrontational at the end.

[@SireneKalypso]

Nah she's delusional

[@radonspace2098]

What's to understand?

[@brittneyberry4934]

What do u understand?

[@SBoy-ks6wt]

If understand anything about her “frustrations” u may be as delusional as her.

[@wackyrobinson8795]

And why she had to let judge know she a student? A student of lies😂😂😂

[@SBoy-ks6wt]

Boy I didn’t think stuff like this existed… Imagine lying to a man telling him a child is his collecting child support then counter suing him for $5,000 for deceiving the child… The nerve of this Rhino

[@fwb1012]

She’s raising children😮

[@silethaking279]

💯

[@keyahboo100]

So you knew he wasn’t the father but yet you got him locked up

[@britanimckinney1964]

They both were young. At 15, I highly doubt she told him it wasn’t his baby she was carrying. He wouldn’t sign papers to agree to pay CS for a child he knew wasn’t his. She also could have stopped him from being jailed by advising the court of what really happened and him not being the father. She came on the sho to disclose about being graped so she could have told the courts so he wouldn’t get locked up. Trifling smh

[@breeziibbabii]

If you knew he was never the father why would you put him on child support?

[@shirleyredd6107]

Why should he pay u for a child not his U need help woman u are not stable

[@soulflowerpeace9236]

It's not his kid....what more does she want.??

[@oiohnyx6107]

Granted she was raped, and it isn’t his kid she should be going after the bio dad if possible. So he can be held accountable, I don’t think a 15 year kid is going to be noble and take care of child that’s not his.

[@YolandaAdamsfan]

So, a rapist could end up with visitation rights to her daughter, whose existence is due to being rated? I swear, y'all hate women so much that any thought of rationale and trauma for an innocent child is secondary.

[@oiohnyx6107]

@@YolandaAdamsfan That’s not what I meant, allow me to elucidate my point. By the bio father being held accountable I meant as in jail time(if possible depending on statue of limitations), child support and no visitation. Considering the mans a rapist I highly doubt the court of law would even entertain the idea of visitation rights.

[@SBoy-ks6wt]

Who is to say she is was actually rape. She’s a proven who instantly goes for the sympathy card. She could have easily lied about that to make up for the fact that she cheated on her bf and got pregnant. With this type of person you need documentation. If no police and no rape kit can’t take it as a FACT.

[@QS0924]

Lmao when he said, "where she at?" at the end.

[@yokimawhittaker5193]

Why did she expect him to help her when she told him he isn't the father?🤔

[@TrinTheGoddess]

She was wilding at the end. He is not your child's father, ma'am!! 😩

[@jasonturner763]

She just plain out evil.. that's wild fucking up his life and more importantly that baby smh

[@MsBizzyRae]

You know the man is not the father but you petition to have him arrested? This is pure madness!!!

[@angelanisa19]

Vindictive evilness

[@lucegene5223]

Glad he won. She's got some anger issues as shown after the case that might land her in jail if she keeps up the ' in your face ' attitude. Wow.

[@keishasmith379]

Once again if all states made it mandatory to take a paternity test in the hospital it would eliminate confusion and problems. And even if u want the parent to pay up front at least let them know and have an option to take a test.

[@carolharris5455]

I’m so glad he won she’s a monster

[@karensmith6815]

Wow she’s a lie smh

[@nayluv1868]

How she told the man he's not the father but didn't tell the daughter lolol

[@user-hs1zr6mc5d]

I kind of believe he did know at some point and when the child support started he changed his mind. If he had doubts before she was born why sign the birth certificate and why not get a test back then. Them playing with that little girl feelings like that is sad.

[@lewing981]

Yeah that's exactly what happen. He was fine with the situation until the government got involved. He was young and naive he should have ever mad that decision.

[@tyraw1005]

If she knew, why she was taking his money. Ridiculous!

[@DaisySmile90]

Why would she put a man that she KNOWS is not the father on child support! 😡🥺

[@tosina.5023]

Yeah, I wasn't sure if she was lying until the very end she was doing all that whooping and hollering. She was lying the whole time. Trying to save face for the child.

[@ceejay9919]

Why would you put him on child support if you were so sure that he wasn’t the father back then? She’s so full of it

[@majesticmcfadden8585]

Was she saying she was raped at 15 so I’m assuming her child is a product of a rape, that’s why she “mislead” her . How do you tell a child she’s a product of her mother’s trauma ?

[@Krissy92]

She has so much anger towards him , for no damn reason. He stepped up when he didn't have to.

[@PillzBerry27]

Every state should do a mandatory DNA test before the man sign it. Men protect your seed women value your worth.

[@TopherGrant]

Hahaha protect your seed? Your "seed" isn't valuable AT ALL. There are literally billions of seed bearers. And unless you're passing on generational wealth or power, your life and the lives you make mean nothing but more low-iq breeders out here making babies as fast as the government can prints those checks

[@rianaloveiam7429]

Honestly, she has some type of nerve to put someone on child support know he’s not the father and saying that he’s willing to do so get money from someone who’s not the biological father because of what she had done to her that’s completely not right and he won’t begin to test if he knows that Baby is already not his

[@SuperCHERISHED]

The defendant appears to be violent. She was all up in the plaintiff’s space. I could see him trying to backup. I am sorry that she was raped at 15. She made the decision not to be honest with her daughter. So many children are lied to. Everyone deserves to know the truth about who their parents are.

[@odog76543]

I think she's lying about the rape. At no point was a criminal case mentioned against the perpetrator, who should also be the one she filed for child support against. Years ago I had a girlfriend break up with me via txt msg. About 1 year later, she called me from a new number, and claimed she got raped by a guy she started dating after me. All to try to get sympathy to see if I would take her back. Women will use the rape claim on a new man to instantly gain sympathy no questions asked. If they say they haven't reported it to police and have a case number, you should be very wary.

[@ervinghenderson4780]

This might be the wildest case I've ever seen on here

[@bbs_mobilecardetailing5747]

Girl stop running your chops 😂

[@lletab]

She said she knew he wasn't the father, she should never have allowed the state to put him on CS.

[@iatdtv4996]

The ability to lie about such things is sadly impressive.

[@lovelybelleee]

This happened to my best friend. The girl that he was in love with when he was in his 20s cheated on him and had two kids that was not his. He still stepped up and took care of both of her daughters. She has a good relationship with both of her children’s fathers. However, she treats my best friend like Krap. And anytime the girls need something. She’s always yelling at him calling him a deadbeat when he literally spend thousands and thousands of dollars on kids that are not his. While she left and kick it with both of her deadbeat baby daddies.

[@Iamwhoiam993]

Brothers! 1 out of 3 of y'all are raising/paying child support for another man's children unknowingly! Always get a DNA test no matter what, especially after a breakup/divorce! 🙄😒👎🏾

[@irisheyes5890]

Instead of saying , “the Government” they should say, “the citizens who work and pay taxes.”

[@DarlinReal]

What exactly was her counter claim? Oh wow! Bold is an understatement.

[@MaryjaneLove]

. &&&& She knew that man wasn't the father of her child and the fact he signed the birth certificate is crazzyyy . . . 😢😢

[@melmel9677]

If she knew from the jump he wasn’t the father, then why put him on child support.