How some Muslims try to deny what's obvious

[@scienceisdope]

Support me at: Buymeacoffee: buymeacoffee.com/scienceisdope Patreon: www.patreon.com/scienceisdope_ UPI: scienceisdope@icici (QR Code available on www.scienceisdope.com/support ) Video on Zakir Naik: kzbin.info/www/bejne/mJend4CEaZZlo9U

[@DragonOfTheMortalKombat]

I think that it is wrong to force a child believe or think stuff like religion and god before their tiny minds even know how to think properly. In one way, it is a forceful conversion.

[@fictionsolosanyverseyounam7599]

Top best Scientific channels- 1. Science is dope 2. Pale blue thoughts These are the only actual Indian scientific channel that back up Thier evidence

[@GoogleAccount-kc6rt]

Can you make video Samadhi? How real it is? There several shorts keep floating on KZbin where live people took samadhi.

[@real.123]

How someone can write there are 360joints in our body in a book 1400 years ago Don't just apply science after passing 10th

[@N0Xa880iUL]

Dude, after this video you don't need coffee, you need protection! 💀

[@amritanshushanu3583]

"If u can't convince them just confuse them"... This is the basic agenda of modern propounders of every religion. Ur doing a fabulous job Pranav!

[@adwaitvedant3297]

If any religion is trying to prove anything supernatural in the domain of empirical reality , trying to peddle pseudo science then that religion must be discarded thoroughly ....While if any religion is touching those points that science doesn't bother to touch should be taken seriously...E.g Science doesn't teach liberation ( dissolution of ego self) ....Science doesn't talk about nature of pure consciousness....What neuro science is trying to find is source of consciousness of a living person....But it can never teach you why consciousness should be the only identity of the human and not the body....Science will never teach you rationalisation of ethics and love ( the true love that is detachment from clinginess in the observed world and not attachment)... Advaita Vedanta philosophy deals with all of these ...And discards god , heaven , hell as just illusion of mind....Listen to acharya prashant on Vedant , Ashtavakra Gita , Bhagwat gita... Ashtavakra Gita clearly discards heaven, hell and all bullshits...And focuses on Truth only....

[@iotasymbol8498]

Ya that's it and thier believers will question every Scienctific theory which is form by giving evidences and experiments!! But follow thier book without any questions it's just childhood indoctrination plus thier low iq brain, 😅😂😂😂

[@REHANKHAN-en5zn]

@Srinivas King just a good story

[@annoyingexorcist]

Bro blame the believers not the Religion

[@ManzoorKhn212]

​@Srinivas King source? 😂😂

[@adityasinghjadoun6675]

This is tight slap on the face of haters who call you anti-hindu just for being scientific.Keep up the good work👍

[@uchhihasasuke7360]

just shut up man !! After comparing all the major religions conclusion is that dharmic religions are the most chill religions compared to others.

[@sankalpsatpathi7082]

👋

[@creativerse6447]

20% of India's population is Muslim. So by that logic, 25 of his videos should be on Islam. But here's only 2. Also the tonality of this video is more peaceful than the one against Hindus where he just goes abusive.

[@gaurav-hn5zd]

He still is anti Hindu. He's not being hard on some Islamist guru or common dumb Islam beliefs in a way he was examining Sadhguru's each and every line almost mocking him . He's just criticizing their belief on evolution which is too soft and mundane topic to hurt anyone at all. He's in his safe limits with Islam.

[@sankalpsatpathi7082]

@@creativerse6447 Imagine this situation- Aapki mummy aapko danti rehti h aur aapke father chup rehte h, to aapki mom aapke father ko bolti h 'aap bhi kuch bolo isse, ye aapki hi laparwahi ki wajah se bigad rha h', then ur father half-heartly scolds you just to show ur mother. His critisizm towards other religions is the same. And these idiots so proud of their father comment "tight slap to...."👋 Idk this phrase just makes me laugh😂

[@vishalahuja2136]

we are the small community of rationalists. I love to see that rational thinking is promoted and accepted on your channel. While being surrounded by parents, relatives, and my elder sister(aged 34) who practise superstition and stupidity, i feel little relaxed watched ur video.

[@Jeevanmn]

Welcome to the tribe- life will be 1000x simpler if you are rational

[@noelrodrigues8179]

Same here,my parents feel me questioning religion is just a phase of my young age but as i grow old and start feeling lonely i will start loosing my rationality and believe without evidence. I really hope i never lose my rationality even when I am old as that is who defines who i am. I believe only what has evidence or the possibility of evidence like aliens existence r a possibility but u can't say for certain whether aliens exist or don't,so i am agnostic when it comes to the belief of aliens as any extraordinary claims would require extraordinary evidence. When it comes to the god which Einstein believed i am agnostic atheist as God is an extraordinarily claim without evidence,but i have no evidence to disprove god either. Hence i am agnostic atheist towards the diestic god which Einstein believed. But When it comes to Christianity,Islam, Hinduism and Judaism i am atheist. Now bcz i am atheist and not agnostic atheist, the burden of proof lies on me that their gods don't exist ,and the biggest proof i have is their own scriptures which goes against scientific theories and provides extraordinary claims without evidence.

[@funtuber9155]

Dont call it stupidity, I am an agnostic, and surely do not believe in any religion. But the point of god is debated because it means different things to different people, for most, the concept has been their last hope, and hence they accept it as it is, you would be having something of your own. Disrespecting someone's ideas and emotions is not being rational in anyway!

[@keyurpatel1982]

It looks like your rationalism has told you that Muhammad buying and selling women and children and ordering the rape of captured married non-Muslim women in war and Muslims feeling proud about it, is less of a problem than for you than Muslims denying evolution. Your rationalism has allowed you to justify slavery and hold All Muslims responsible for denying evolution rather than glorifying slavery legalised and practised by Muhammad. It is better not to be a rationalist like you if rationalism teaches you that slavery is less of a problem than denying evolution.

[@noelrodrigues8179]

@sm2411there r many logical fallacies in your comment. motherland is a concept that exist within countries,like russia,india,Iran,turkey don't mix nationality with religion. Secondly many religions never expanded bcz they never had the opportunity to. Take buddhism as an example, it expanded in South Asia but couldn't survive in India as it was wipped out by ancient Indian kings.U could argue that those ancient kings like ashoka expanded Hinduism by wipping out buddhism in India. Today there r many organizations that r expanding Hinduism in the west as well. So yeh ur defination of motherland in Hinduism is quite subjective by saying Hinduism doesn't expand. Similarly many white guys believe in Judaism and Christianity,but the origins of these religions r from the middle East. So if Judaism didn't expand how is it that most Jews r white.Same logic applies for Christianity. Secondly Science is not built on believes or assumptions but evidence that can be tested,yes hypothesis also exist which is still based on evidence.What do u mean by rationalist u met r scared of alliens? How is the universe conscious, consciousness is related to biology,while study of universe is related to physics u can't just put two words from seperate domain of science into one word? And how is Stephen Hawking supporting your argument.

[@iramkhan5975]

Religion approves of science when it proves something that is written in their book might be right. I've had a physics teacher denying evolution and stating plants are not living.

[@7araaz790]

There are a few points I want to mention: 1. Watch videos from a Muslim guy called Subboor Ahmad on KZbin. He has talked a lot on this topic and has even debated some of the top atheists on this topic. 2. Science is constantly changing. The most prominent scientists today can be proven completely wrong in the future. The Quran doesn't change as we believe it to be the direct word of God. 3. Science can never explain how humans possess so much more intelligence compared to other animals. According to science humans evolved from apes but humans possess more intellectual capability than all the 20 species of apes combined. Infact, humans probably possess more intelligence than all the animal species combined. How can such an anomaly be explained through mere science, humans must truly be special, different from all animal species. 4. According to Pew research center, Atheists, agnostics, and other people who do not affiliate with any religion will make up a declining share of the world’s total population in the near future. So contrary to popular belief, atheism/agnosticism is on the decline globally.

[@real.123]

How someone can write there are 360joints in our body in a book 1400 years ago Don't just apply science after passing 10th

[@sadiqakhan277]

@@real.123 zakir naik fan do some research on this 360 joints and who first talked about it.

[@iramkhan5975]

@@real.123 oh I sure do apply all the science I need when I deal with human anatomy every day

[@real.123]

​@@iramkhan5975 ur qualification

[@Abdullah-mn6sw]

Pranay is wrong, I am going back to my WhatsApp videos of cat offering namaz, goats with allah written on their fur and giant skeletons of direct descendants of Adam found.

[@aanjneyvishwakiran7097]

Haha

[@bikashji122]

Haha underrated comment 😂😂😂

[@sadiqakhan277]

🤣🤣 too good

[@sajid279]

Andbhakt spotted with fake id even Sadiqa khan id is fake

[@brazenbull36]

Mashallah 69ft. Adam skeleton found

[@calebhesbrew9729]

Thank you for this video. I live in a muslim country and it is very difficult to argue with them. This video helps me a lot..

[@aishwarykalosia1998]

Which country

[@manofscience69]

@@aishwarykalosia1998 you've 13 chances to guess.

[@himanshuverma1747]

Keep your calm and think.

[@one_autumn_leaf69]

@@aishwarykalosia1998 Maybe Indonesia

[@towardsuniverse]

Don't argue... Don't tell... They must have been confronted with truth that hinders their belief... Just accept that some people have closed minds .. Just tell and walk away☠️🐾....

[@moinuddinsyed66]

Religious people be telling science is not 100%true while their religion is not even 5% true

[@AtheismLeadsToIrrationality]

@@sajid279 Thought* Adventure Podcast

[@sajid279]

@@AtheismLeadsToIrrationality uff yes

[@gokutu1002]

they are the one invented the sciene bruh

[@sajid279]

Islam is true ..unlike other religion who cant prove their authenticity... Make lies and speak anything and it becomes religion that does not happen in islam... Also the scripture are authentic with carbon dating and chain of narrations

[@gokutu1002]

@@sajid279 true

[@Hussain-cc8xz]

If only ppl watched him more than creators like beer biceps

[@koshal8852]

that is because they hear what the want to hear not what they need to

[@real.123]

How someone can write there are 360joints in our body in a book 1400 years ago Don't just apply science after passing 10th

[@xyzguesswho9537]

and if that was the state of today's society then we would not have needed someone like pranav ! Only cuz things have been messed up all this discussion comes into the scenario. Creators like beerbicep arent the cause of the poor condition of society we have today but the product of that poor soceity is beerbiceps 😆 As they say politcians only reflect the state of society as they are the outcome of it......Politicians cant change the society but the change in society wld change the politicians and change in society comes through preachings of wise ppl like gautam buddha. Need one today :)

[@minimalisthealth]

Those neo-spiritual kinds (Beer Biceps, Sadhguru etc) are the worst of the lot. At least with the outright religious videos there's no deception, it is what it is - faith based on old outdated scriptures. With the likes of Beer Biceps there's the issue of psuedoscience which could mislead people who genuinely want to learn and give up on old faulty ideas.

[@muzamil_pasha]

@@real.123 Stop spamming and go pray

[@MohdSaif-no2dx]

Man i am so confused,all my family members are orthodox muslims,just continuing what is passed from generations without any logical thinking or questions. I can't even questions beliefs or I will be called Kafir, I don't know should I believe in it or not.

[@amoghavarsha5715]

Dont believe any religion only because of society

[@MohdSaif-no2dx]

@@amoghavarsha5715 yeah but they will kick off me from my house

[@fictionsolosanyverseyounam7599]

​​@@MohdSaif-no2dx lol I heard othordox Muslim but never heard Muslim version. Even religion have divisions?

[@ayudhdasroy7090]

Listen to them until you are independent. After that, you are free to do whatever you like

[@normal1person-ns3ws]

@@MohdSaif-no2dx keep it to urself and dont indoctrinate ur child

[@tariq_sharif]

Awesome, from former muslim ...

[@scienceisdope]

Thanks a lot man!

[@ghost-wasay2611]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/a3exdoKgqrqbfqc

[@biochemdoc_yasir]

I am following your channel since beginning, and I sincerely thank you for your tremendous works, aimed to spread rationality and critical thinking. No matter what we believe in, we cannot be blind and deny the obvious. Keep up the good work!

[@shoibahmed9079]

Counter argument kzbin.info/www/bejne/j3mahGqpjZpkjK8

[@ashilyjustin4748]

💯

[@sajid279]

Do you believe the universe came from nothing?? Even the mobile phone in your hand has a creator..do you thing human body so complex and the universe with precise laws and fine tuning is just a matter of chance from itself or from nothing... This is the most illusiory thing someone can believe.. Read about Cosmological contingency argument, the necessary existence and fine tuning of universe... There is not a shred of doubt in existence of god... Morality cant exist without god as each person will have own morality and it will be okay for some to have sexwith mothers and fathers...and they willeven passlaws likethat...

[@sajid279]

Watch Theology Adventure Podcast and you will find these people fooling ignorant young people

[@zasyed114]

What makes you think that you are not following the philosophy of evolution blindly unless you have not heard the case from those who oppose the theory.

[@lucifergaming3763]

As a Muslim I want to say thank you

[@sakibmir5360]

Lol what type of muslim are you Do u even know what is he talking about

[@AmeyVikram16]

@@sakibmir5360 I think he's a rational and open-minded human. That's it. And that's more important than anything.

[@studypurposeonly69]

@Srinivas King wtf

[@sakibmir5360]

@@AmeyVikram16 rational 🤣 Bruh u guys don't even know what this video is about Ur rationality is that something came from nothing

[@AmeyVikram16]

@@sakibmir5360 Refusing to accept a scientific theory is rational then? According to you? Bro, I don't give a damn about any religion, even yours. What's true, and what has been proven is more important than what someone wrote in a book in a desert centuries ago.

[@mohammedmusaib4862]

We need to support science and channels like this Respect 🌻

[@shadymello9146]

Still dream of the day we get own vcauce and kurtsgesagt

[@satanicvoicex]

​@Srinivas Kingyou are spamming this everywhere why ? On science channel bro is not even understand a truth

[@satanicvoicex]

@Srinivas King I understand But truth doesn't have to be spammed But imo keep spamming 😉

[@vanessahargreaves528]

@Srinivas King Dude stop ur tastleless jokes

[@vanessahargreaves528]

@Srinivas King Dude Sadhguru is not equal to Hinduism. So there's ur absolute error.

[@tarinagarwaI]

It's truly pathetic how a single KZbinr's (sabood ahmad) half-baked arguments can gain such widespread acceptance among the online Muslim community. Who needs to consult actual experts or conduct rigorous scientific research when you have the word of a non-scientist to rely on? I mean, why bother with the scientific method when you can just blindly follow the latest apologetic trend? It's not like the principles of evolution have any significant impact on our understanding of the world around us, right?

[@awesomeanimalsandmemes6232]

Right?right? Right?????!!!!

[@tarinagarwaI]

@@awesomeanimalsandmemes6232 what?

[@awesomeanimalsandmemes6232]

@@tarinagarwaI just continued the joke from your last sentence

[@tarinagarwaI]

@@awesomeanimalsandmemes6232 alr

[@Srikanth-lt6wz]

Imagine if he applied even half of logical thinking and rational arguments he used against Darwin's theory on his religious beliefs!!!

[@reintroverted9155]

"childhood indoctrination", lol

[@AmeyVikram16]

Well, I think that all religions should be open to more criticism and scrutiny. Religious and spiritual beliefs are part of our lives, then why shall they be shielded from being brought under fire. Even be it Islam or Hinduism.

[@shubhampushkarofficial]

Imagine if Srikanth used even double of his hands to slap himself, that he used to type this comment.

[@arindamghosh5438]

@@sm2411bcoz he is rice bag

[@samarth_raghuvanshi]

@sm2411 My brother, you've missed the point of this video as your complaining about the very things that he very clearly talked in this video, so let me address both of your points, and let me know if I misunderstood something- 1} I don't believe religion is idiotic, nor do I believe science is dope because it has theories and theorems! I only believe in evidence, science is a body knowledge and for any claim to be part of it needs to have evidence supporting it, and on the basis of evidence theories are made, to further understand and predict the phenomenon! But on the other hand religion doesn't provide any evidence for what it says, now I'm not being biased here or ignoring evidence provided by religion, it is simply that the so-called evidence are already criticised & proven false. 2} ‘You said, scientist and archaeologists keep changing things, and are not sure but religious texts have not changed for thousands of years!’ I mean brother, science is a body of knowledge and it is continuously evolving on the basis of new things that are constantly being found or understood, and as Pranav said in the video, “do you want knowledge that never improves and stays the same, or do you want knowledge that improves, and updates itself with every new thing you learn?”

[@elon-gatedMusk-rat]

मुझे तो लगता है कि विज्ञान ही लोगों को एक साथ जोड़ कर रख सकता है इस वीडियो के लिए आपका बहुत-बहुत शुक्रिया

[@adityasinghjadoun6675]

you seem like a smart person but better stop idolizing scammer elon musk

[@IAm-xp6sb]

आपने मेरे दिल की बात छीन ली 👍👍👍👍

[@sonofuniverse6355]

Lol or wo kese ? Logon ko nationality, religion, culture, language jodta hei not science.

[@awesomeanimalsandmemes6232]

@@sonofuniverse6355 we can still be connected solely based on our identity of being a homo sapien.All the other identities only create more divisions and small fragments of human groups.International/globalist humanism is the best key for future🔥

[@elon-gatedMusk-rat]

@@sonofuniverse6355 religion to nhi hi jodta hai. Ek religion ke log aapas me jud ke reh sakte hain par dusre religion ke logon ke sath judne me samsya hoti bi hai.

[@shobhitjain1978]

"The mistake that's being made here is that there is no empirical idea that can be set in stone. If you're gonna wait for such a thing before you change your beliefs, then you're probably only looking for an excuse to keep your beliefs and you were probably unwilling to change them in the first place." DAAANG!! Nice Rebuttal!🔥

[@sakibmir5360]

But my question is Why would we believe in evolution of man from apes Because believing in this theory is just like believing on God

[@sai_69]

​@@sakibmir5360 Because there's evidence for it. Lots of it. You need to educate yourself first to understand that evidence. Start with "the origin of species" by Darwin.

[@siddharthnarayanpatra1843]

@@sakibmir5360 Because there's evidence. It's not just one person who is making up stories. There are many biologists who have worked on it. They don't just believe what's being said but they try to find the truth.

[@InshalHassan-r4s]

He did make a very good point though , but it can be logically deconstructed easily. His point: Muslims shouldn't be waiting for the theory of evolution to be 100% true rather they should accept it , as it is ' beyond reasonable doubt ' while giving the example of the court room. Question is , Who defines what is reasonable and what's not? As something being reasonable differs from person to person❔❔❔❔ Let me explain it. Even if we , just for the argument's sake accept that theory of evolution can be beyond reasonable doubt , even then it is not unreasonable for Muslims to reject it specially when Muslims have these 2 Tennets 1st: when they are coming with a very strong , logical and rational bias(God existing and Islam being true) against it because The bar of something being reasonable differs from person to person and from their biases to biases and to non biases and 2nd: The bar of something being reasonable also differs depending upon what's at stake for the observer (as For Muslims Islam and Even God's existence is at stake so the bar of it being reasonable is higher than for an atheist who doesn't have anything at stake here) Example of first tennet(having a rational bias against something considered being beyond reasonable doubt by the atheists)🫴: It was first reasonable for the judge to accuse Mr y for murder because he had video evidence against Mr y and Mr y being present and running from the scene. But now after some months the judge is kidnapped and the kidnappers place him in a room where some illegal software engineers are editing someone's video in a very realistic manner to prove him guilty of murder and they can also capture anyone's finger prints to use it on the murder scene and the judge saw it all and then the judge eventually got released from them after the judge's family pays kidnappers money. Now after some months the judge is faced with a similar situation in which someone is accused of murder and there's a video evidence against him just like mr y was proven guilty but now the judge doesn't give his verdict and says it's not clear that this man is the murderer because the bar of the reasonability of previous case in which Mr y was found guilty on a video tape has been increased because of a rational bias The judge has after being kidnapped , Proving that it's not unreasonable for Muslims to doubt the theory of evolution because of the strong rational bias of Islam being true , they have! Example of 2nd tennet(The bar of reasonability is increasing due to what's at stake)🫴: Imagine there's a big black cloud of smoke at location x and sounds of screams are coming from it and fire fighter trucks 📢are going towards it Now if someone says to me while I am observing it ' I will ask you a question and you have to answer and that question is , that , Is there a fire? And if you answer correctly I will give you a brand new car ' Now it's beyond reasonable doubt for me to say anything other than ' yes there is a fire for sure ' But the questioner increases what's at stake for this question for me and says ' If you answer it incorrectly , I will kill you and if you choose to go your way without answering the question I will let you go ' Now What's at stake for me to answer what something was ' beyond reasonable doubt ' a little while ago has increased and now I am doubting if there's actually a fire or is it a film's shooting scene? Now the bar of something being reasonable has increased , because my life is at stake and it's reasonable for me to doubt the previous case of fire , given that , I as a Muslim know Islam is at stake in this , as compared to an atheist who doesn't have anything at stake and may believe anything! Conclusion: You can't accuse Muslims of denying something which is ' beyond reasonable doubt ' for the atheists by comparing them to Muslims , as Muslims have a strong , logical and Rational bias against it and that , what's at stake for Muslims to accept the theory of evolution is far greater than an atheist who can believe in anything!

[@InshalHassan-r4s]

​@@sai_69 This evidence is purely based on Assumptions of random mutations and atheistic nonsense! Prove atheism first then and then look at science with its lens and then teach it! He did make a very good point though , but it can be logically deconstructed easily. His point: Muslims shouldn't be waiting for the theory of evolution to be 100% true rather they should accept it , as it is ' beyond reasonable doubt ' while giving the example of the court room. Question is , Who defines what is reasonable and what's not? As something being reasonable differs from person to person❔❔❔❔ Let me explain it. Even if we , just for the argument's sake accept that theory of evolution can be beyond reasonable doubt , even then it is not unreasonable for Muslims to reject it specially when Muslims have these 2 Tennets 1st: when they are coming with a very strong , logical and rational bias(God existing and Islam being true) against it because The bar of something being reasonable differs from person to person and from their biases to biases and to non biases and 2nd: The bar of something being reasonable also differs depending upon what's at stake for the observer (as For Muslims Islam and Even God's existence is at stake so the bar of it being reasonable is higher than for an atheist who doesn't have anything at stake here) Example of first tennet(having a rational bias against something considered being beyond reasonable doubt by the atheists)🫴: It was first reasonable for the judge to accuse Mr y for murder because he had video evidence against Mr y and Mr y being present and running from the scene. But now after some months the judge is kidnapped and the kidnappers place him in a room where some illegal software engineers are editing someone's video in a very realistic manner to prove him guilty of murder and they can also capture anyone's finger prints to use it on the murder scene and the judge saw it all and then the judge eventually got released from them after the judge's family pays kidnappers money. Now after some months the judge is faced with a similar situation in which someone is accused of murder and there's a video evidence against him just like mr y was proven guilty but now the judge doesn't give his verdict and says it's not clear that this man is the murderer because the bar of the reasonability of previous case in which Mr y was found guilty on a video tape has been increased because of a rational bias The judge has after being kidnapped , Proving that it's not unreasonable for Muslims to doubt the theory of evolution because of the strong rational bias of Islam being true , they have! Example of 2nd tennet(The bar of reasonability is increasing due to what's at stake)🫴: Imagine there's a big black cloud of smoke at location x and sounds of screams are coming from it and fire fighter trucks 📢are going towards it Now if someone says to me while I am observing it ' I will ask you a question and you have to answer and that question is , that , Is there a fire? And if you answer correctly I will give you a brand new car ' Now it's beyond reasonable doubt for me to say anything other than ' yes there is a fire for sure ' But the questioner increases what's at stake for this question for me and says ' If you answer it incorrectly , I will kill you and if you choose to go your way without answering the question I will let you go ' Now What's at stake for me to answer what something was ' beyond reasonable doubt ' a little while ago has increased and now I am doubting if there's actually a fire or is it a film's shooting scene? Now the bar of something being reasonable has increased , because my life is at stake and it's reasonable for me to doubt the previous case of fire , given that , I as a Muslim know Islam is at stake in this , as compared to an atheist who doesn't have anything at stake and may believe anything! Conclusion: You can't accuse Muslims of denying something which is ' beyond reasonable doubt ' for the atheists by comparing them to Muslims , as Muslims have a strong , logical and Rational bias against it and that , what's at stake for Muslims to accept the theory of evolution is far greater than an atheist who can believe in anything!

[@fictionsolosanyverseyounam7599]

Top best Scientific channels- 1. Science is dope 2. Pale blue thoughts These are the only actual Indian scientific channel that back up thier evidence with fun explanation

[@DipayanPyne94]

I can make better content than them. Should I start ?? I have been wanting to start for more than a year now. Just no time ...

[@atheist_1.1]

Channel named ' Nissaram ' is also best . It's in Malayalam . I think English subtitles is also provided

[@V-for-Vendetta01]

This one's gonna ruffle a lot of feathers 😂

[@AmeyVikram16]

Doesn't matter much. What's right is right.

[@V-for-Vendetta01]

@@AmeyVikram16 didn't discount that.

[@anmolt3840051]

Not especially

[@yash1756]

His every video does

[@7araaz790]

No, it's not. We Muslims have dealt with this topic from a long time now. There are a few points I want to mention: 1. Watch videos from a Muslim guy called Subboor Ahmad on KZbin. He has talked a lot on this topic and has even debated some of the top atheists on this topic. 2. Science is constantly changing. The most prominent scientists today can be proven completely wrong in the future. The Quran doesn't change as we believe it to be the direct word of God. 3. Science can never explain how humans possess so much more intelligence compared to other animals. According to science humans evolved from apes but humans possess more intellectual capability than all the 20 species of apes combined. Infact, humans probably possess more intelligence than all the animal species combined. How can such an anomaly be explained through mere science, humans must truly be special, different from all animal species. 4. According to Pew research center, Atheists, agnostics, and other people who do not affiliate with any religion will make up a declining share of the world’s total population in the near future. So contrary to popular belief, atheism/agnosticism is on the decline globally.

[@wtfifham3042]

I believe people won't just change their belief in an instant. The only way People can be more open and rational about things will be with Education and consumption of Knowledge. Great Work Man. Appreciate it.

[@7araaz790]

There are a few points I want to mention: 1. Science is constantly changing. The most prominent scientists today can be proven completely wrong in the future. The Quran doesn't change as we believe it to be the direct word of God. 2. Science can never explain how humans possess so much more intelligence compared to other animals. According to science humans evolved from apes but humans possess more intellectual capability than all the 20 species of apes combined. Infact, humans probably possess more intelligence than all the animal species combined. How can such an anomaly be explained through mere science, humans must truly be special, different from all animal species. 3. According to Pew research center, Atheists, agnostics, and other people who do not affiliate with any religion will make up a declining share of the world’s total population in the near future. So contrary to popular belief, atheism/agnosticism is on the decline globally.

[@_Arsh_x9]

I am open to gain knowledge and educate myself and my beliefs are sided when I am going to learn anything, but I am good Muslim and pray 5 times in day, and Islam is in my heart. Thanks to science is dope

[@LmFao535]

​@@_Arsh_x9 yeah , its okay . Im a hindu and am very rational as well. Even tjoygj I am spiritual for the sake for preserving my culture. But I don't foall for the unscientific BS and am very sceptical

[@pratiswar5977]

@@LmFao535 You're literally me.

[@InshalHassan-r4s]

​@@_Arsh_x9 What are you talking about? Theory of evolution is based upon assumptions of random mutations which is an atheistic nonsense , first prove atheism then look at science with the lens of Atheism! He did make a very good point though , but it can be logically deconstructed easily. His point: Muslims shouldn't be waiting for the theory of evolution to be 100% true rather they should accept it , as it is ' beyond reasonable doubt ' while giving the example of the court room. Question is , Who defines what is reasonable and what's not? As something being reasonable differs from person to person❔❔❔❔ Let me explain it. Even if we , just for the argument's sake accept that theory of evolution can be beyond reasonable doubt , even then it is not unreasonable for Muslims to reject it specially when Muslims have these 2 Tennets 1st: when they are coming with a very strong , logical and rational bias(God existing and Islam being true) against it because The bar of something being reasonable differs from person to person and from their biases to biases and to non biases and 2nd: The bar of something being reasonable also differs depending upon what's at stake for the observer (as For Muslims Islam and Even God's existence is at stake so the bar of it being reasonable is higher than for an atheist who doesn't have anything at stake here) Example of first tennet(having a rational bias against something considered being beyond reasonable doubt by the atheists)🫴: It was first reasonable for the judge to accuse Mr y for murder because he had video evidence against Mr y and Mr y being present and running from the scene. But now after some months the judge is kidnapped and the kidnappers place him in a room where some illegal software engineers are editing someone's video in a very realistic manner to prove him guilty of murder and they can also capture anyone's finger prints to use it on the murder scene and the judge saw it all and then the judge eventually got released from them after the judge's family pays kidnappers money. Now after some months the judge is faced with a similar situation in which someone is accused of murder and there's a video evidence against him just like mr y was proven guilty but now the judge doesn't give his verdict and says it's not clear that this man is the murderer because the bar of the reasonability of previous case in which Mr y was found guilty on a video tape has been increased because of a rational bias The judge has after being kidnapped , Proving that it's not unreasonable for Muslims to doubt the theory of evolution because of the strong rational bias of Islam being true , they have! Example of 2nd tennet(The bar of reasonability is increasing due to what's at stake)🫴: Imagine there's a big black cloud of smoke at location x and sounds of screams are coming from it and fire fighter trucks 📢are going towards it Now if someone says to me while I am observing it ' I will ask you a question and you have to answer and that question is , that , Is there a fire? And if you answer correctly I will give you a brand new car ' Now it's beyond reasonable doubt for me to say anything other than ' yes there is a fire for sure ' But the questioner increases what's at stake for this question for me and says ' If you answer it incorrectly , I will kill you and if you choose to go your way without answering the question I will let you go ' Now What's at stake for me to answer what something was ' beyond reasonable doubt ' a little while ago has increased and now I am doubting if there's actually a fire or is it a film's shooting scene? Now the bar of something being reasonable has increased , because my life is at stake and it's reasonable for me to doubt the previous case of fire , given that , I as a Muslim know Islam is at stake in this , as compared to an atheist who doesn't have anything at stake and may believe anything! Conclusion: You can't accuse Muslims of denying something which is ' beyond reasonable doubt ' for the atheists by comparing them to Muslims , as Muslims have a strong , logical and Rational bias against it and that , what's at stake for Muslims to accept the theory of evolution is far greater than an atheist who can believe in anything!

[@affan867]

please please make more videos on islam i am an exmuslim atheist and i have to say general muslim poplution in this country doesnt have slightest hint about rational and critical thinking and there are many false ideas about science i am trying my best to educate and make the younger kids in area more aware about science and rational thinking thats why please make more videos on islam debunk

[@shoibahmed9079]

Come on qaiser ahmed raja every Saturday Or Awaz e haq live. Every Friday Join Live stream by clicking link and prove you point

[@tivky]

@@shoibahmed9079 Awaz e haq ? I mean seriously ? Dude a pakistani guy who can't even show his face while sitting in Pakistan ?

[@zasyed114]

@@shoibahmed9079 How do I contact you?

[@M5FTZ]

Haha idk how on earth u got that idea but no. Our religion is quite logical based on the beliefs we have

[@atharvabhosale3529]

​@@zasyed114 this comment is so disgusting

[@SherlockH0lmes]

Yep most of our( Islam) videos I watch are like this..... they'll tell us what we want to hear....Hmm well most of religious videos are like this one😂.... Need more of these type of videos from you 👍

[@shoibahmed9079]

Counter argument. Join live stream every Saturday and have a discussion on evolution kzbin.info/www/bejne/j3mahGqpjZpkjK8

[@sajid279]

Watch Thought Adventure Podcast... No one can deny existence of God.. Read about Cosmological contingency argument, Fine tuning of universe, Consiousness and you will find athiesm is illogical

[@tss8085]

@@sajid279 are you serious? You find Atheism illogical and religion logical?

[@akshara487]

Great to see more open minded people here

[@anzalrashed4910]

@@tss8085 Atheism The belief that there was once absolutely nothing. And nothing happened to the nothing until the nothing magically exploded (for no reason), creating everything and everywhere. Then a bunch of the exploded everything magically rearranged itself (for no reason whatsoever), into self-replicating bits which then turned into dinosaurs. And they mock your beliefs.

[@cosmiclegend4181]

This Argument of suboor ahmed against Evolution has actually become quite popular among online muslim community and literally every apologetic muslim uses it to debunk Evolution

[@7araaz790]

There are a few points I want to mention: 1. Subboor Ahmad had debated some of the top atheists on this topic. Watch his debate with Aron Ra and Cosmic Skeptic. 2. Science is constantly changing. The most prominent scientists today can be proven completely wrong in the future. The Quran doesn't change as we believe it to be the direct word of God. 3. Science can never explain how humans possess so much more intelligence compared to other animals. According to science humans evolved from apes but humans possess more intellectual capability than all the 20 species of apes combined. Infact, humans probably possess more intelligence than all the animal species combined. How can such an anomaly be explained through mere science, humans must truly be special, different from all animal species. 4. According to Pew research center, Atheists, agnostics, and other people who do not affiliate with any religion will make up a declining share of the world’s total population in the near future. So contrary to popular belief, atheism/agnosticism is on the decline globally.

[@real.123]

How someone can write there are 360joints in our body in a book 1400 years ago Don't just apply science after passing 10th

[@AmeyVikram16]

​@@7araaz790 Exactly brother, you just believe it to be the word of God. But beliefs are out of question here. Just because your holy book is very sacred to you, it doesn't make it immune to errors, misconceptions, prejudices and unscientific facts. Nor does it prevents your book or religion from criticism. The theory of evolution should not even be a necessary topic of debate anymore. There is ample evidence to support it, and it has been tried and tested time and again. Sure, improvements will come and go, but the basic principle of evolution of species is undoubtedly correct as per the evidence, or rather, I should say on par with our observations of various organisms. What someone wrote in book about God centuries ago can have any relation to modern science, I don't understand.

[@ayudhdasroy7090]

@@AmeyVikram16 well said

[@uttamraj3786]

@@7araaz790 Science has already explained why humans are comparatively more intelligent than other apes. and you are concluding that humans are special because they posses intelligence but there are many things in which animals are far more superior than us like sense of smell, physical power , speed , endurance. It's your perception that intelligence is the parameter for being considered special. What if some alien species decides that bacteria are the king of earth because they are the oldest surviving species on our planet? Humans certainly affected earth the most, a medium sized planet orbiting around a very average star in a very average galaxy among the millions other galaxies where life could exist in an infinitely large constantly expanding universe and due to this "accomplishment" you think our species are special. This perception of yours and many religions is not only childish but laughable.

[@asifahmed3521]

Bhai mere pure family me akela me hu jo religion ke chizo pe question karta ha and reasons jab puchta hu to koi bhi ek insan answer nhi de pate samajh nhi ata kaise ye log itne murkh ho sakte ha kabhi kabhi lagta ha ye log milke mujhe hi mar denge anyways Keep it up bro hail science 🙌

[@am.miran.]

Bhai marna mtt .

[@bruhbruhbruhbruh684]

If we want to be advanced then we must first stop believing in any superpower

[@indianboy59]

@@bruhbruhbruhbruh684 your claim is fundamentally flawed

[@bruhbruhbruhbruh684]

@@indianboy59 prove ke wrong

[@_Arsh_x9]

Bhai you families doesn't know religion and questions Islam and searching for answers, if you will do same, your next gen Kids name is only muslims or may be atheists, may Allah bless you

[@kiranmaimandadi9560]

Be it any religion one should understand all these books were written as per the knowledge of the people on that time line. Could've been better if someone written updated versions of these as we receive updates 🤣🤣. But no.. They made unquestionable for a reason and i feel this is what makes critical thinkers move away from spirituality n religion. It is like 2 sides of a coin..

[@elon-gatedMusk-rat]

Absolutely right

[@awesomeanimalsandmemes6232]

If religious books had been updated constantly,they would have reached philosophies of universalism and humanism and all other philosophies would have been removed.

[@sonofuniverse6355]

@@awesomeanimalsandmemes6232 well it already is in upnishad.

[@MarkRyanNZ]

Such a supportive comments section and a beautiful community in the making. ❤

[@compassioniseverything4262]

Jahannami ho tum 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@sajid279]

Please watch Theology Adventure Podcast... If your phone is created by someone..how come the entire universe with laws and fine tuning come to existence... Also morality exists becs of god as when god is removed each person can decide good and bad and some can choose to do sex with mother and father with consent..and later pass lawslikethey re making for homosexuality and lgbtq

[@sajid279]

​@@compassioniseverything4262 your comment is not compassionate brother..

[@compassioniseverything4262]

@@sajid279 The best act of compassion is to bring rationality in the minds of vulnerable people like you. I follow compassion and not pretend to be compassionate like you. just adding brother to the sentence won't make you good being. I hope you know you are obligated to slit throats of kuffars. I hope you know you know there are at least 10 verses that ask you to hate kuffars like me. Your peaceful god has nothing to do with inclusivity. Only and only who prostate before that being is considered worthy of living. Fithrate saari insaani thi, Fithrathi tha wo rabb. Khoon se sani talvaare thi. Khele huqumat tha sab. - Zafar This existence in itself is consciousness. You dont need a super special entity sitting up any there judging your deeds especially the most silly stuff like what you wear, eat, live with, how you shave, walk, talk and even worship. It's an absolute nonsensical. If there is anyone obligated to provide evidence its you who believe that sun sets in muddy water prostates to the throne of your God and come back in the morning from exactly the same place. Does your God think Arab is the only piece land. Is he not aware of the poles, where sun doesn't rise and set like in Arab. Are you guys crazy or acting to be one? The idea if hell and heaven and the description of it given your book is worse than cheap third grade s**ual fantasy book. Grow up.

[@mukundha7621]

​@@sajid279 dude morality exist also because of science incest cases deformities even science says causing marriage is nearly incest and look at uk Muslims population itself they have children with many deformities and yess you are right relegion provides morality but also let's say incest relationships with a parent and theur offspring that ensures that kid will be deformed society's who practiced incest dialowed it due to not giving better offsprings plus islam morality is for Muslims and lgbtq is the same extreme as wahabis what lgbtq lack is moral support but a Muslim kid in Switzerland will support salafi in middle east but want secularism for himself

[@chitranshsrivastav4648]

Huge respect to Pranav for disclosing a personal incident of him being a murderer just to provide a good analogy to defend science.

[@sakibmir5360]

There is a lot of problems with analogy He said evidence of cctv footage How can he compare this type of evidence with the small evidences for evolution

[@chitranshsrivastav4648]

@@sakibmir5360 what is the evidence that your Prophet ever existed? Any cctv footage or photo of him?

[@sai_69]

​@@sakibmir5360 All those dinosaur fossils aren't exactly "small" lol.

[@kartya2000]

😂

[@subhuman3408]

@@sakibmir5360 Small evidence? Lol. The entire field of paleontology, anthropology, geology, taxonomy, Microbiology, embryology etc. All depend on theory of evolution. Massive corroboration of evidence from so many independent fields. No other scientific theory in human history has this much support.

[@manofscience69]

Balls of Steel everyone. Here we go.

[@markjitu]

Hope India will be A country with scientific literacy some day.keep it up bhava

[@awesomeanimalsandmemes6232]

Being a country with scientific literacy and being a country that believes in irrational beliefs are not mutually exclusive. Hell,it is not even mutually exclusive for a person. But that can't be an excuse for the display of scientific illiteracy at instances

[@abuthahirumarhathab4201]

@@awesomeanimalsandmemes6232 It is mutually exclusive. U can't be a scientifically rational and literate person and beleive in wonders and magic put in different religions. I would gladly pick the former than latter

[@awesomeanimalsandmemes6232]

@@abuthahirumarhathab4201 the reason why it isn't mutually exclusive for religious people is because they will be applying scientific literacy in other sectors in life expect for their own religion.Same goes for pseudoscience believers.

[@user-ur9wy1lt8z]

This guys channel is BOGUS channel whose agenda is make money off popular people with large followers. Basically a clickbait channel banking on a fraction of mass followers. Clever business idea but it's Bogus and misleading. Much shameful actually!

[@abuthahirumarhathab4201]

@@awesomeanimalsandmemes6232 they resolve the contradiction of their beliefs by applying science only when they get benefit and when it feels like they have benefit in supporting religion, they support it. I have little respect for that sort of people.

[@arusirham3761]

I am an ex muslim from Indonesia and I just want to say thank you, you made me embrace rationality and to stay away from Islam. You see there are myths among muslims that scientific discoveries of our age were already mentioned in the Quran and Indonesia is a country with most muslim in the world, so this kind of myth is very common. But from your videos I realized that Hindus also made such claims and those are false. Now I can't believe in those myths, wether they are spread by muslims or hindus. I am now in hiding but I really hope that one day we could meet and talk to each other. Keep the good work 👍👍👍

[@sadiqakhan277]

I also hope someday i can meet and talk to like minded people like you all. Right now staying safe is most important.

[@irajain9340]

I'm so glad that you could find a rational path for yourself !! I'd recommend the channel Apostate Prophet, another great channel specifically for ex muslims. And i agree, pseudoscience and illogical arguments exist in almost all religions, no religion is truly scientific. If you don't mind me asking, you said you are in hiding, hiding from what? The government because you are an apostate? I hope you are okay!

[@real.123]

How someone can write there are 360joints in our body in a book 1400 years ago Don't just apply science after passing 10th

[@franzka9824]

​@@irajain9340 lmao suggesting clown channel

[@sadiqakhan277]

@@irajain9340 hiding starts from your own folks, relatives, neighbours and friends government comes last

[@AbidSuhail]

Thanks from an Ex-muslim

[@optimus-prime703]

Hi. I am also ex.muslims

[@pratyushprakhar5610]

​@@optimus-prime703 bhai lagta bharat log islam dharm चोद rahe hai 🤔

[@syedsalman6239]

We need more people like you ,to bring our generation out of ignorance 👏

[@anshumanpanda1227]

We need more ex Muslims like you to speak up. The future of the world isn't looking to good otherwise.

[@allahlesboslu2_9]

Ex m sahil , Zafar heretic are already doing this 😂😂

[@lakshmidevi0123]

@@anshumanpanda1227 more ex Hindus too 😁

[@anshumanpanda1227]

@@lakshmidevi0123 Yes plz. We want quality.

[@lakshmidevi0123]

@@anshumanpanda1227 yeah especially when Radicalism by R$$ IS AT PEAK. So much hate nowadays that a normal discussion becomes toxic 🤮

[@vish3161]

It has also been shown that the amount of genetic diversity the human race has would not have been possible had we all descended from Adam and Eve. With the Adam and Eve theory, what intrigues me is how the second generation would have come into existence without incest !

[@ayudhdasroy7090]

"Sweet Home Alabama"

[@REHANKHAN-en5zn]

A class 5 science book has more useful knowledge than all religious books combined.

[@raoera9192]

Only urs not all ok

[@REHANKHAN-en5zn]

@@raoera9192 denying doesn't changes the truth

[@elon-gatedMusk-rat]

Spirituality is what that you won't find in your textbooks rest all could be found in the books of our curriculum. How to improve one's thinking and lifestyle should also be included in our syllabus

[@raoera9192]

@@REHANKHAN-en5zn yes ours hindu so called religion is not religion it's a society and culture and combination of all is hindu so we have so much of evidence yet not confirmed but yets its

[@vanshmakwana9954]

So you have read all the religious books?

[@riaagarwal6840]

The major problem is that some religions allow the followers to leave whereas some (eg: Muslim) think that is reason to kill😢

[@adm2399]

No religion allows to leave; go read texts of Hinduism how it calls to torture a person to death if he dares to cross his varna boundations.

[@riaagarwal6840]

​​​@@adm2399 please state your source. I would love to learn. Also crossing Varna is not the same as losing your religion. No where in any Hindu, Buddhist, sikh and other religions does it sanction death for leaving the said religion.

[@mukundha7621]

​@@adm2399 lol as a hindu I do accept something that is illogical but also pantheism is about seeing God in where you exist no hindusim don't have apostasy laws I know many Muslims who are afraid of theur own family is they say they became a apostate not to mention the sahih hadiths on killing apostate is legally allowed in islam only laws of a non-muslim country doesn't allow it

[@khanzai21]

Muslim is not a religion😂

[@moonchild27]

The most idiotic thing that I've ever heard is definitely that Muhammad split the moon into half.. like the scienctist must have had second hand embarrassment debunking that myth😂

[@Anon89093]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@abi3751]

And semen comes inbetween ribs and spines😂

[@ملحد-ل5ب]

Don't forget the flying donkey 😂

[@forsearching]

​​@user-do2ph2bh7m your prop**het was a pedo f him Give me any evidence for your claim

[@gamingchamp23525]

​@user-do2ph2bh7m then where is your proof of this event happening? How come other people at that time did not notice this revelation, don't be stupid.

[@AmeyVikram16]

Good approach, Pranav. Criticism from a pragmatic perspective is always necessary. Be it about any religion, sect, ethnicity or country. It's important to fight against misconceptions for the truth to prevail. Good job

[@tajjuddinajmeri7559]

I am a muslim...and i just loved the way you put forward your point without being disrespectful..keep up the good work...

[@goku-jb7us]

Same

[@ghost-wasay2611]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/a3exdoKgqrqbfqc

[@uchihaitachi7744]

maybe you should watch videos of Qaiser Ahmed Raja and Subboor Ahmed regarding this topic.

[@Whoami1988_]

Why are you still a Muslim then? Lol 😂

[@diaryofnricom163]

If we cite Quranic or hadith verses, is that disrespectful? What about this ? Sahih al-Bukhari 2925 Narrated `Abdullah bin `Umar: Allah's Messenger said, "You (i.e. Muslims) will fight with the Jews until some of them will hide behind stones. The stones will (betray them) saying, 'O `Abdullah (i.e. slave of Allah)! There is a Jew hiding behind me; so kill him.'"

[@Raj-cs1tq]

You are a brave man to talk about these things openly.

[@RPPIK]

"Before a child learns what to think it is told what to think" well said 💯🙌 + the person copy pasted Zakir Naik

[@Djklj]

*how to think

[@owaiskhan7047]

So, according to you we should stop teaching children.

[@taksh8989]

@@owaiskhan7047 no, at least provide them knowledge with insights to reality

[@maths_nerd]

@@owaiskhan7047 How did you jumped on that conclusion? It means teach your child to "how to think" and not "what to think". Give them the opportunity to question the Quran. When they come from school and say these things in the Quran is not in accordance with these things I learnt in school, don't beat the shit out of him for asking a question. Let him think as he grows.

[@sohamshinde7978]

@@owaiskhan7047 STOP TEACHING LIES .

[@onlymusic1691]

Addition to 9:45 Darwin did not consider mutation while giving his theory as a result according to him , Evolution occurs as a result of small, Directional changes. This part of theory is changed in Neodarwinism and mutations are given a major part in Evolution which are rapid , directionless , random changes.

[@awesomeanimalsandmemes6232]

Exactly!!!💯

[@Jonsnow3375]

Appreciated❤.. they tell us " evolution has no proof..so we can't accept it as a fact ".. but they don't show us any proof regarding Adam and eve😂 that's actually absolute truth 🤣 instead of showing us the evidences of creationism, they keep on beating around the bush

[@sajid279]

Evidence of creationism? Here it is.. Your phone had a creator.. Do you think the complex universe with precise laws popped out from nothing... Watch Theology Adventure Podcast

[@Jonsnow3375]

@@sajid279 so you are saying my phone is a complex thing which has a creator (a complex being) ... therefore universe which is more complex must have a creator right?! Well so by your logic our complex universe has a creator who is more complex than the universe...then he should have a creator too and so on🤣 stop giving bullshit examples..i have gone through this type of bullshit arguments thousands of times... And for your kind information I haven't say that the universe came out of nothing... We don't know exactly where it came from.. that doesn't mean we have to accept a unproven claim.. bring something new boy

[@Jonsnow3375]

@@sajid279 and read about fallacy of compositions... We are made of cells right? Can we see our cells without microscope? Nope... Does that mean we can't see ourselves???🤣 If something is made of something.. then it's not necessarily mean that the features of former should be in the later and vice versa... Similarly if my phone has a creator then it's not necessarily mean that the universe should also have a creator.. (i am not saying universe has no creator 100%.. i am just denying your claim... If you are claiming then you have to prove it)

[@positron3055]

@@sajid279 yah Adam and Hawa made from mud by Allah 😅😅😅

[@aveshdiamond6763]

I would like to say the belief in Islam is life is test if everything is prove d then wouldn't everyone will believe in the unseen so tell me if a large portion of quran is rational and rest can't be proved and can't be disprove either such as heavens and hell,jinns,angels etc If 80% of things can be proved, have been proved and rest can't be disproved I find it easy to believe

[@007Saad007]

Muslim here, I must say firstly that I appreciate you making this video. I am constantly trying to challenge my own faith. Evolution is one of those few topics which I have not reconciled with completely. This animated video by Smile2Jannah is just one interpretation of the matter and I happy to see it getting scrutinised. I'm eager to take this discussion to people more knowledgeable than I am and see what they have to say.

[@sajid279]

Watch Theology Adventure Podcast channel... Athiesm is illogical...

[@Soham.69]

​​@@sajid279 Being Religious is more Illusional, Illogical and delusional than living as a happy athiest(me)

[@andsmile3]

You can listen Ghamidi on this thing evolution. He was convincing to me

[@M5FTZ]

@@Soham.69 shush ur not superior to religious ppl

[@007Saad007]

@@Soham.69 what's your strongest argument against theism? or more accurately, monotheism?

[@sauravmajumdar3436]

Keep up the great work Pranav!

[@risingaditya4206]

Now here all Muslims will come and say pranav is wrong, when he criticise some points about Hinduism they support, when the turn is there they will play now victim card, as they play always 😅😅😅😂😂😂so chill guys

[@objection6061]

Found 1 in the comment section already 😂😂

[@yash1756]

Sounds more like you WANT them to act this way lmao. Edit: not to mention your other comments on this channel show even how you are offended when he debunks Hindus lmao

[@objection6061]

@@yash1756 idk about the first point in your comment but now that I check his other comments, your second point seems fair

[@real.123]

How someone can write there are 360joints in our body in a book 1400 years ago Don't just apply science after passing 10th

[@mohdyaqoob8294]

Its seen who is playing victim card. 80 cr but still having election slogans like hindu khatre me hai. Most coward religion with most backward thunking

[@harryx18]

I'm an ex-muslim and thank you for this:) you are really dope

[@_Arsh_x9]

To kya hogya bkl,

[@awesomeanimalsandmemes6232]

I think we ex-religious people should make a group chat. Will be pretty fun tbh. But the biggest concern is the group becoming toxic and hateful towards religions as happens with many such groups made previously. That defeats the whole purpose of rationality.

[@padhlekyakarrhahaituyahanp1011]

@@awesomeanimalsandmemes6232 tru

[@dobbysurfs]

@@awesomeanimalsandmemes6232 try r/atheismindia

[@spainwithoutans792]

​@@awesomeanimalsandmemes6232 Don't. If any apostates identity comes into public things can get ugly.

[@ShikharMasseyMusic]

Before a child learns how to think, Its taught what to think. , quotes noted

[@Mahmud-ir2kz]

I want to save our Muslim community from ignorance ,pls make videos like this as Muslims can understand what is the problem with Islam ,how it can affect our life ,it can destroy our whole life in confusion ,it makes us anti humanist .So pls make videos on islam and also on other religions.

[@real_world_view_]

No one here is ignorant go watch suboor Ahmad and evolution

[@Mahmud-ir2kz]

@@real_world_view_ muslims are definately ignorant because they think from heart ( an organ),but i have brain and i think from it ,and my brain is enough to understand that islam is immoral and useless.

[@Ghostrider78927]

@@real_world_view_ you are really a brainwashed fool brother I was also like you few years ago but now an exmuslim

[@pankaj5080]

So on this video we have Hindus, Muslims and Christians coming together appreciate this video. Good atleast science is bringing them together. That is what called rationalists and scientific temper

[@Pantheist2602]

You could have added an 'ex'

[@md.shahiquesubhani7241]

​@@Pantheist2602 After watching this they are becoming ex religious😅😅😅 Are you an athiest or agnostic???

[@Mockheed_Lartin]

​@@Pantheist2602nah, I'm still a pretty rw practising Hindu, and I feel there is no need to correlate science with religion,for me just enjoy Hindu culture without making any pseudo scientific claims, and just become an atheist while talking science no religious bs in between, and yeah I like this guy's videos 😃👍

[@sonofuniverse6355]

@@Mockheed_Lartin I'm also Bhakt 🕉️ but I don't like this dude video. I like those video which talk about only science and explain various things and those videos which only explains upnishads/religion. I study Geeta and try to follow it.

[@sonofuniverse6355]

@@Mockheed_Lartin for me religion is below God. Even if all religion is false still God is absolute truth for me. Even if religion is false it is carrying the human civilization on it's back, without it we will get doomed.

[@direct.skc.2]

Back in the day, 10-12 years ago, when I was doing my own research I stumbled upon the 'Dawah movement' in the UK and watched many of their videos having similar claims on scientific theories. That is when I realised how stupid the idea of creationism is and gradually got convinced that the roots of Islam and Christianity are just fiction. These eventually made me dig deep and analyse all other religions including mine. All of those studies confirmed my understanding of the physical world and was convincing enough for me to eventually become an atheist. Now I am at peace! 😇

[@khanzai21]

Universe started with bigbang before that there was nothing not even space. And what caused this bigbang? 1: 1:"NOTHING". What a scientic and logical thought, it completely make sense 2: "GOD". Well how stupid it doesnt make any sense. Well i can only clap and admire the logic of some scientists 👏👏

[@khanzai21]

If the idea of creationism is stupid than athiesm is also stupid. It is based on a concept the universe has created itself and it self explain it existance. So when a human mind ask the question about the existance of himself,nature and universe the irrefutable evidence doesnt exist. This is where the believe system comes In your case the believe rest on development of science and finding in future the explantion of self existance of nature. In the case of monoestic religion the believe system is god created universe and he communicated with us through his messengers.

[@prabhat_me_1391]

Even though I am not a muslim, but I got emotional by seeing the animation guy's conclusion 😂

[@ajaved1037]

The guy is definitely an orthodox Muslim... He already had those conclusions set... so, he was bending facts to make them parallel with his religious beliefs

[@sakibmir5360]

@@ajaved1037 lol no Provide some points Don't just make claims . U guys are pathetic 🤦

[@studypurposeonly69]

But the animations are dope though not gonna lie

[@fish00p]

​@@studypurposeonly69 animation so good, he's literally being referred to as "animation guy"

[@lucky_lol]

​​@@studypurposeonly69 I think he has learnt them from Kurzgzegt It looks way similar but simple awesome!!!

[@cosmicwarriorx1]

Thanks.... Great video Pranav.

[@Beckham6578]

If any Muslim gets offended by this video...Then Congratulations your brain is normally functioning bcoz getting angry is normal functioning of brain....So if your brain is normally functioning...Then you must start thinking rationally 🗿🗿

[@md.shahiquesubhani7241]

Same goes to all religious people because they believe in creationism

[@humanbeing4076]

True, I saw a comment asking for his address 😒

[@godman6591]

@@md.shahiquesubhani7241 still muslims are much more orthodox than any other religion

[@kayden492]

​@@humanbeing4076 💀

[@awesomeanimalsandmemes6232]

@@humanbeing4076 they just want his cupcakes☠️

[@ajaved1037]

Keep making this kind of videos... It's gonna hardly change those indoctrinated minds but it's something... PS(My personal experience)- Being born in a Muslim family, I always try to argue with these beliefs but the funny part is they act as if I'm the illogical one

[@_Arsh_x9]

Bhai tu rehnehi dey agar Tera dil me imman nahi Hai na to rehnehi De, Mai bhi kuch saalo pehle aise tha 9-10th me tha jab meri family Muslim thi, magar Mai sirf namaz padha tha and Quran Ghar wale kehte the bsss Jabardasti to nahi keh sakte Lakin born to upbringing keh sakte Lakin bro Mai 2 saalo se eak dam change hogya, Pata nahi kyu dil me apne aap Islam utar gaya, kisi ne zor jabardasti nhi Kari, apne aap, and ab Mai Ghar walo se zyda' follow ' krta hu teachings of Islam, may Allah bless you brother

[@ajaved1037]

@@_Arsh_x9 Don't worry it's not like they hate me or anything... It's just a simple fact that I don't have similar beliefs as they do... And they know it (obviously they want that part of me to change, but neither do they force me or hate me for that)... And I don't hate them either... I mean their my parents for God's sake and No-one is more important for me than them

[@kaif5799]

Lol, I have the same experience

[@bharatvardhamane2406]

Sometimes same happens with me bro

[@sajid279]

Watch Theology Adventure Podcast... and read about cosmological contingency argument, the necessary existence, the fine tuning of universe, conciousness...you will find athiesm is illogical...

[@echelon1014]

I think the part where he says "rapid changes in biological features" is a common trait you also see in Christian apologists (I instantly remembered that Discovery Institute clown Stephen Meyer said something similar) where they call millions of years as a "short duration" even though scientists use it as in comparison to the total time, thereby effectively undermining the extent of years it took for those changes to occur.

[@KayDeeVee23]

1.We eat for energy and we use our energy in reproduction. Theory of reproduction is that "two different genders from a similar species give birth to new similar babies because they want to keep alive their species existence". 2. How do any animal get evolution? → by the reproduction 3. My whole point was that we get energy and use it to keep ourselves (including me and all the humans) alive. "SO GIVING DONATIONS CAN'T BE A QUESTION ON THE THEORY OF EVOLUTION".

[@yumeko1993]

Humans have indeed evolved to stay in a society and help each other, so as to survive, in the end.

[@skshivam300]

Well i am so happy to find out some Muslims is comment section are developing scientific, logical and critical mindset and are questioning those verses of quran which is unscientific and illogical.

[@sca8217]

This is a very crucial video for Indians to watch. Too often we take general happenings in our day to day life and attribute it to either God or erroneous Science. In this day and age of readily available information, there is no reason for anyone to believe in hearsays.

[@heheboiii3566]

Religions are cool they give us holidays and cool mythology. 😀 Other than that I'm not even interested in my own religion.

[@Pantheist2602]

My dream is to be a boss and make my atheist employees work their ass off on holidays 😅

[@heheboiii3566]

@@Pantheist2602 😂

[@SDR02]

Yea, the only thing I like about religion, Holiday.

[@luffy34__]

Yeah Thing I like about hinduism that great stories and great content it provides other than that I don't believe in any God

[@imokay17890]

@@luffy34__ we can make anime on Hinduism😅

[@wednesya_7750]

Thank you for this video! I admire how well you articulate your perspective. Since you shared your opinion, I wanted to share mine, too. You don’t have to agree with me or embrace Islam, but I hope my perspective adds something to your worldview. After all, questioning is how we grow and learn. While science answers the “how,” Islam addresses the “why.” What is the meaning of life? Why do we experience suffering? What happens after we die? No equation or theory can solve the ache of these questions. And here’s where Islam steps in. It acknowledges human vulnerability and gives purpose to our struggles. Islam doesn’t deny suffering-it explains it as part of a divine test. The Quran reminds us that we are created with free will, that our choices matter, and that our lives have meaning beyond what we can see or understand. And yet, in tragedy, in that deepest despair, don’t we all reach for something beyond? Perhaps you don’t. Perhaps in hardship, you simply soldier on, trusting your own hands, your own heart. That’s admirable, and we all do it-yes, even believers, even Muslims. But isn’t it curious how easily you can reject faith, any faith, with such certainty, as though you are beyond mortality, beyond fate? Science, yes, has given us wonders! Medicine, technology, knowledge of the stars. And of course, we turn to doctors, to experts who work tirelessly in their fields. But at the end of the day, science only brings us so far. When it falters, when it can’t answer, what then? I know you are a good person. I see it in your kindness, your thoughtful words. This isn’t meant to make you anxious or fearful; I just wish you could see why people turn to faith, why they hold onto something greater than themselves. I hope you have a good life! :)

[@footballfever09]

THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR THIS ONE. AS AN EX MUSLIM THIS WAS MUCH NEEDED

[@webdev643]

He refutes nothing. Darwin Theory is still a theory and debunked by scientist .

[@muqki2178]

​@@webdev643well then you clearly haven't learnt anything and are too stubborn to change bc you want soo badly to believe in God rather than the truth.

[@muhammadmuzzammil9055]

@@muqki2178 bro read books bro I mean ur bible not everything are science..Sooner or later you will die too dont you want to think why the dead people can't come back to life and who give life to them when they were living their life..May god guide us to the right path..

[@AK-hm7ls]

​@@muhammadmuzzammil9055If all the cells in your body are working fine you have life. If they are not working fine you are dead. If you force your cells to die then you brought death upon yourself. You see? Nobody takes or gives here. The word "life" in your context is like water to be filled in a bottle. It's not real it's just a word. If anybody has given life(in current context )then it's just your dad and mom nobody else. Certainly not a omnipresent all-powerful being called Allah or Christ or Shiva or Ramm. I hope I was basic and respectful enough to answer your question.

[@Abdullah-mn6sw]

People thinking butterfly from caterpillar is evolution is just like how for some reason Muslims think as per evolution we cane from monkeys and they argue why monkeys are still there.

[@sadiqakhan277]

Zakir naik fans really believe that. they remind me of so many monkey stories 🤣🤣

[@mukundha7621]

Dogs evolved from wolves and dogs can offspring with wolves named as wolf dogs this shows the evolution proof plus the gene mutation the habitat well Asians, blacks and brown ans white have different facial features and blakc people have commonly sickle cell problems while white have gluten problems simple why white people ancestors consumed way too leas carbs and Asians have high amount of lactose intolerance without the basic evolution you wouldn't be seeing this Muslims find complexity is very simple texts like if prophet said kill the lizard with one smack it is a great deed I would see Muslims defending it with science the moment you say why you talk about science they go into defensive mode it is a hive mentality at most I can see Hindus disagree with some scriptures and make qualsm with other which is similar to science and evolution and some pagan faiths but abhrahamic faiths can't they rather focus on fighting among themselves to prove who is false while scene gets advanced

[@karthiknr9142]

Now suddenly you are right for the people who have been supporting you for being left! Facts are always bitter! keep the good work going!

[@yash1756]

Only find people appreciating him in the comments lmao. Not to say that muslims aren't offended but to argue that his fan base is made of rational liberals and neither RWers nor irrational lleftists

[@dutt_arka]

​@@yash1756 I agree with him. Damn it feels good to be a gangsta...Sorry, Rational Liberal.

[@karthiknr9142]

@@yash1756 Now that's open to interpretations, u can't actually differentiate. u can see leftists being hurt in this comment section itself who had subscribed to this channel after seeing him criticizing sadh guru, beer biceps and such, when peaceful community wasn't touched.

[@yash1756]

​@@dutt_arka oh good, no worries, random nobody calling me gangster doesn't offend me

[@dutt_arka]

@@yash1756 I wasn't calling you anything,my friend. I'm a rational liberal myself. Anyway, understandable..have a nice day.

[@cejojohn]

Thanks!

[@scienceisdope]

Thanks a lot!

[@xyzguesswho9537]

amazing work pranav ! This is some work that adds value to society otherwise even fraudsters earn name/fame/wealth but dont attain inner peace/satisfation cuz materialistic consumption cannot do so.. the right kind of work which is the need of moment is itself the PURPOSE OF LIFE. And u r on the true cause so hatts off buddy.

[@haroon420]

Thanks buddy. Please do more. I’m Muslim but I don’t follow dogma and have an open mind about such matters.

[@sajid279]

Watch Theology Adventure Podcast...

[@lupoansu4225]

@@sajid279 lol

[@InshalHassan-r4s]

You are just an inferiority complexed person ! What are you blabbering about? Theory of evolution is based upon assumptions of random mutations which is an atheistic nonsense , first prove atheism then look at science with the lens of Atheism! He did make a very good point though , but it can be logically deconstructed easily. His point: Muslims shouldn't be waiting for the theory of evolution to be 100% true rather they should accept it , as it is ' beyond reasonable doubt ' while giving the example of the court room. Question is , Who defines what is reasonable and what's not? As something being reasonable differs from person to person❔❔❔❔ Let me explain it. Even if we , just for the argument's sake accept that theory of evolution can be beyond reasonable doubt , even then it is not unreasonable for Muslims to reject it specially when Muslims have these 2 Tennets 1st: when they are coming with a very strong , logical and rational bias(God existing and Islam being true) against it because The bar of something being reasonable differs from person to person and from their biases to biases and to non biases and 2nd: The bar of something being reasonable also differs depending upon what's at stake for the observer (as For Muslims Islam and Even God's existence is at stake so the bar of it being reasonable is higher than for an atheist who doesn't have anything at stake here) Example of first tennet(having a rational bias against something considered being beyond reasonable doubt by the atheists)🫴: It was first reasonable for the judge to accuse Mr y for murder because he had video evidence against Mr y and Mr y being present and running from the scene. But now after some months the judge is kidnapped and the kidnappers place him in a room where some illegal software engineers are editing someone's video in a very realistic manner to prove him guilty of murder and they can also capture anyone's finger prints to use it on the murder scene and the judge saw it all and then the judge eventually got released from them after the judge's family pays kidnappers money. Now after some months the judge is faced with a similar situation in which someone is accused of murder and there's a video evidence against him just like mr y was proven guilty but now the judge doesn't give his verdict and says it's not clear that this man is the murderer because the bar of the reasonability of previous case in which Mr y was found guilty on a video tape has been increased because of a rational bias The judge has after being kidnapped , Proving that it's not unreasonable for Muslims to doubt the theory of evolution because of the strong rational bias of Islam being true , they have! Example of 2nd tennet(The bar of reasonability is increasing due to what's at stake)🫴: Imagine there's a big black cloud of smoke at location x and sounds of screams are coming from it and fire fighter trucks 📢are going towards it Now if someone says to me while I am observing it ' I will ask you a question and you have to answer and that question is , that , Is there a fire? And if you answer correctly I will give you a brand new car ' Now it's beyond reasonable doubt for me to say anything other than ' yes there is a fire for sure ' But the questioner increases what's at stake for this question for me and says ' If you answer it incorrectly , I will kill you and if you choose to go your way without answering the question I will let you go ' Now What's at stake for me to answer what something was ' beyond reasonable doubt ' a little while ago has increased and now I am doubting if there's actually a fire or is it a film's shooting scene? Now the bar of something being reasonable has increased , because my life is at stake and it's reasonable for me to doubt the previous case of fire , given that , I as a Muslim know Islam is at stake in this , as compared to an atheist who doesn't have anything at stake and may believe anything! Conclusion: You can't accuse Muslims of denying something which is ' beyond reasonable doubt ' for the atheists by comparing them to Muslims , as Muslims have a strong , logical and Rational bias against it and that , what's at stake for Muslims to accept the theory of evolution is far greater than an atheist who can believe in anything!

[@InshalHassan-r4s]

​@@lupoansu4225 What lol?

[@kmasif164]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/pYeolIV5mLCre6c kzbin.infobs792n89oPI?feature=share

[@shivammishra6381]

I went to this video to see comments. I am literally scared of all comment in a comment I saw a person saying he was bored studying evolution from exam because he knows it's all false he said he was studying for neet. I am scared that these type of uneducated but literate can become doctors and engineers(many are) and they use science just as a tool to make money and as a way of life.

[@rayhanakhtar7619]

More power to you for raising our voice through your videos ❤

[@onomatopoeia6787]

Dude, leave Evolution these guys can defend gRAPE , can you imagine 😂 I am unaware of a single situation where gRAPE can be defended. But Mashallah these guys do know.😂

[@billaak417]

We still need a civilized discussion, i hope both channels can collab.

[@AmeyVikram16]

What sort of discussion do you expect? One in which a side is bashing the theory of evolution? Which is not only nearly universally accepted but also has ample evidence to back it. And what's the alternative? A book written way too long ago in a desert in the Middle East, which has no relation to science? I'm not against any religious beliefs, but when you mix it with science, you get a harmful cocktail. And even more so when some people believe it to be superior to science in teaching us about the world.

[@sajid279]

Watch Theology Adventure Podcast brother...

[@animegoat954]

Pranav sir always proves through his videos that Science really is dope and any superstition or illogical belief dont even stand near it.

[@SKEPTICsss]

Science 1 Islam 0

[@amandeep9930]

I watched a video a few days ago in which a Muslim was arguing that evolution was a conspiracy of Hindus because they are naturalists. 😂

[@alphaq1502]

Lmao Hindus also don't believe in evolution lol.

[@dab6923]

😆😆

[@harshkumar2473]

Yeah that was by someone called hijab .... A muslim apologist ...... By seeing him.... I could say ignorance is a bliss

[@abc_cba]

Though, i am an atheist, dear Muslims commenting in the section is a great thing, finally rational people are uniting against superstitions and thinking on what is right. Though you don't have to be an atheist like me.

[@nikhilbhansalis]

Pranav please take care. Typically any criticism against this religion puts lives of people at risk. Please be safe, I foresee the impact you'll make on KZbin India and World as important, we can't loose you.

[@tortoise7107]

Mtlb kuchh vhii Lund bhkt

[@vedalpha8415]

I support science and critical thinking but after reading sapiens book i have realised that, The change religion has brought into the society regarding people's mindset, nothing can impact in the same way. Religion brings fear into the people from doing crazy stuff and the reason we r not killing each other casually

[@adi7y4]

I wonder why a lot of terrorist still follow islam? I mean if religion really brings peace why is there a lot of unrest in the whole world!? So much so that people are even terrified to cover the stories arround the globe nowadays!

[@randomvideos5407]

That was true for ancient times. Now we have better social structures like constitution and economy

[@vedalpha8415]

Ik too me 18 years to realise this , so u can also take your time !!!

[@vedalpha8415]

@@randomvideos5407 just imagine, people do serious crimes even after judiciary is there If u sit and think abt it, it's all because of the fear of religion that makes people avoid doing all that That's why I don't mind people following religion even if m an engineering students who believes in scientific thinking

[@adi7y4]

@@vedalpha8415 People also sacrifice animals in the name of religion. Both Hindu and Muslim people. I belive self responsibility is one of the biggest trait that everyone should be taught from early age! People can teach their kids everything without religion as well!

[@Its_Pritam_]

When science can't answer a question it tries to resolve it. Science learns from mistakes and increases knowledge. Where as when relgion can't answer a question, it glorifies it as a miracle without having a second of thinking

[@noobbutsmart2326]

I am a muslim and I believe in theory of evolution, dosen't mean I don't believe in God. I don't need some scientific proof to validate my beliefs, I believe in creator because I like it.

[@pranavbagurjagadeesha1208]

Tbh, I think atleast Hinduism is comparatively more scientific than any other religion. If not, the world wouldn't be doing yoga, meditation, etc. Edit: Also, many scientists have accepted the teachings of the Upanishads, Vedanta, Gita among others to be superior than any other knowledge.

[@champion6995]

Among the 3 major religions hinduism is indeed more accepting but the role of religion itself is negligible if you ignore them.

[@nin3510]

see sufi in Islam.. they do also do meditation etc and live in thoughs

[@zasyed114]

​@@nin3510 Islam is Islam. Islam doesn't have to become Sufi Islam to be acceptable by Mushriks and Kuffar. Stop simping for anyone and everyone.

[@nin3510]

@@zasyed114 sorry brother

[@AnalystSarvesh]

Except the world doesn't.

[@ctmithun8916]

Thanks

[@scienceisdope]

Thank you!

[@Ghasi83]

Science is based on curiousity and religion is based on faith. And we don't need to mix them. Religion is a way of life and science is just a part of human urge for knowledge and understand things. Humans are very good at compartemntalization as we see everyday. I dont understand why some muslims have to use science for supporting Islam. The Islamic creed is enough to satisfy my intellect and yes I definitely have to keep blind faith too on some matters but most of the time it never came in my way for my love for science more over it was very much in line as the Quran asks us to question and reason. We should not forget the Golden era of Islam where we developed the scientific method and excelled in maths, science, philosophy and what not. We are here for a while let's make the best of it. Love your channel. No doubt science is awesome! 🤝🏻

[@Chakravartin007]

You are right faith is faith... You don't need proofs to believe in any faith.. But this constant obsession from every religion to prove their beliefs closer to science forces people to debunk their claim

[@devianadkar7969]

​@@Chakravartin007 yes. My religion is closer to science. Confirmation bias. Like some childish competition.

[@sadiqakhan277]

Dr Danish the golden era you are talking about not one of the astronomers, mathematicians credited their islamic faith for their discoveries. In fact some like al Razi are islams favourite heretics

[@yahudi7253]

Need more true liberals like you. Only and only people like you can beat bjp , rss or far right groups. Most liberals do more damage and make far right more powerful( by siding with islam). Because the fact is islam vs any religion and islam will lose every time in logic. I wish for more liberals like you and then only our politics will change, right now people vote bjp because there is no other force to counter radical islam

[@Anon89093]

Truee.. It's no lie that islÀÀmis get offended too easily and have the lowest amt of tolerance compared to other religions. The Ratio of Comments to views in this video and other video tell that story. But being a rational liberal is too difficult since people assume Liberal= Pro IslÀám.

[@_Arsh_x9]

I am open to gain knowledge and educate myself and my beliefs are sided when I am going to learn anything, but I am good Muslim and pray 5 times in day, and Islam is in my heart. Thanks to science is dope

[@action1093]

"wHy dO YoU oNly TaRget hINdUIsM"

[@pahadipilla]

He does mfker Jai shree ram 🐐

[@dhruvtyagi7351]

It's About Islam...

[@CarsArts]

​@@dhruvtyagi7351sarcasm

[@Anuradha_]

I think you as a propagator of true science.. Highly recommended channel as this channel debunked various myths, provided listeners have patience..

[@jeanettewee8805]

Pls debunk the 45 trillion loot myth story floating around Internet. Even if you calculate the entire GDP of India during the 190 years of British raj you wouldn't get 45 trillion dollars.

[@ayudhdasroy7090]

Dude its a science channel, not a history or finance channel. And honestly, who cares how much thr British took from us, they wont return it anyways.

[@InvinciblePepe]

It's not a myth in the first place. Nothing to be debunked here.

[@jeanettewee8805]

@@InvinciblePepe The GDP of India in 1800 was $177 billion while in 1950 it was $339 billion, ie, average $258 billion in today's prices at PPP. So, the aggregate GDP for 1950-1800=150 years was $258x150=$38,700 billion or $38.7 trillion. Since the entire GDP of the Subcontinent for the 150 years was less than the alleged $45 Trillion, it is unlikely that the British stole 45 out of 38.7 trillion USD. All the figures cited above are at the current prices and, not the then prevalent prices. Thus, both the Nominal GDP and the GDP at PPP were much less than that, both, more so the Nominal GDP. For instance, the Nominal GDP of India in 1950 was barely $21 billion, not $337 billion. Now, as regards the Aggregate GDP over the 150 years of British Rule @ $38.7 trillion, the Per Capita GDP was barely at the Subsistence Level. So, out of the $38.7 trillion, most must have gone towards the subsistence by way of food, clothes, houses, healthcare, education etc. Thus, how much was left by the populace to pay the taxes is anybody's guess.

[@jeanettewee8805]

@@InvinciblePepe It has come to light that the widely cited figure of 45 trillion dollars, attributed to the economic losses suffered by India due to British colonization, was calculated by Marxist economist UTSA Patnaik. However, it has been criticized that her method of compounding the loot taken by Britishers at a 5% interest rate is flawed and inaccurate, especially considering that the inflation rate during the 1950s was at a lower 3.68% interest rate. Furthermore, it has been reported that the total amount of loot calculated using this flawed method amounted to approximately 9 trillion pounds, which was then converted to dollars by multiplying again with 4.68. It is also noteworthy to mention that Patnaik has made unsubstantiated and highly controversial claims regarding the number of people killed by the British in India, which she estimates to be as high as 1.8 billion. Interestingly, this claim has been largely ignored by mainstream media channels such as Vice and Wion. Unfortunately, such misleading and inaccurate claims are not uncommon in India, with stories of the Vikramaditya Empire controlling 40% of the world's land, the existence of the internet during the Vedic period, and the alleged invention of airplanes 7000 years ago being among them. Another example is the claim that Shivakar Talpade invented the airplane eight years before the Wright Brothers, and that the British stole his idea. It is important to note that such claims are not substantiated by credible evidence and should be scrutinized with a critical eye.

[@InvinciblePepe]

​@@jeanettewee8805 post source or don't spew bs at all. Anyway, TLDR.

[@PriyanshuSingh]

man this one's either gonna blow up or will get restricted

[@asad9042]

Atheist here. Love from Pakistan mate.

[@vegetal8460]

Leave the country as soon as possible . Are u in closet.

[@shot.on.iphone]

​@@vegetal8460 you don't deserve to say this if you are Indian hindu

[@abi3751]

Ohmgawd

[@rb49865]

Compared to any religious belief of human creation, Darwinism has more evidence. However, the goal of science is to find truth, and not to prove certain theory is right. Therefore, we should keep looking. The fact is, so far, all the evidence points to evolution being true and no evidence for any religions being true.

[@samiulbashir9252]

I discovered your channel a few weeks ago, and it's an absolute gem. Keep up the good work!

[@sajid279]

Watch Theology Adventure Podcast channel about contingency argument and i too have uploaded a video on my youtube channel.

[@JahanzebA001]

As a Muslim, firstly thank you for your criticism as I believe any criticism is a welcome opportunity to flesh out beliefs. Although I disagree with the fundamentals of this video, I do understand its points. However, I still believe that you missed the point of the Muslim video and absolutely disagree with the title of this video that delivers the notion that we just turn a ‘blind eye’ to anything “obvious”. There is nothing obvious about evolution or any widely accepted theories. They can always be fallible no matter how certain we get. A lot of the fallacies within this video, for example, comes from the fact that you and the Muslim video come with two totally different frameworks. Your fundamentals align with the fact that any empirical idea (such as any belief) is never set in stone or certain, the Islamic view upholds the certainty that Allah swt exists and has created everything however told through the Quran. This belief in Allah swt is derived from fitra (predisposed indisposition that there is a higher power), signs (which are subjective which have credibility to the human experience), transparency of the preservation of knowledge (the process of keeping credible data and Hadiths), miracles (how the revelation came to our beloved prophet SAW), imaan (faith), and Aql (reasoning w intelligence); All of these being stated in the Quran. Your ideas are derived from pure scientific observation which has a wider consensus of reasoning among many faiths but holds no certainty besides laws. In other words muslims believe that there are concepts that are set in stone which exist in objective reality. Science simply tries to describe that objective reality with the scientific method and reasoning. That being said: you look at the muslim video as a complete utter refutation of evolution when it aims for another purpose: the theory of evolution is not valid or certain enough to shake our fundamental religious concepts of creationism. The statements at the end of this video only reaffirms your misunderstanding of Islamic reasoning. Our “empirical ideas set in stone” were not just derived or believed from us laying around waiting for a miracle in this age. It is derived from those fundamental concepts which I have mentioned earlier. You neglect our reasoning and credibility as to why we believe in God and creationism. Our video simply states that evolution is not strong enough to challenge or shake our notion. Be it Darwinian evolution or modern synthesis (which Darwinian evolution provides an integral base in reconciling with Mendelian genetics), they do not suffice in credibility with the evidence or hypotheses. Take care.

[@eM121.]

Whom r u arguing they r pure isl***"phobes, at the end watch previous content Act like innocent but aren't Looking to earn money because this video will give views😅😅😅

[@humanbeing4076]

Hey Pranav👋 What do you think about Gaurav Thakur(GetSetFlySCIENCE) he boosted my interest for science by 10 Times when I was just 15/16YO but nowadays his videos are BJP biased especially on his FACT channel(recently changed to his name) but his science content is awesome and his voice is too good for making content even story telling and animation is good. He even claim to be Agnostic but how can a Agnostic science enthusiast got influenced by hindutva nationalism ? Is it due to lack of political knowledge ?

[@uttamraj3786]

Most of his science videos are more inclined towards entertainment rather than science.

[@humanbeing4076]

@@uttamraj3786 Agree, he uploads videos consistently for earning purpose, most of the time his videos are not necessarily important to watch but he makes video's on any science related topics and explains it as if it is huge breakthrough in science for small topics.

[@uttamraj3786]

@@humanbeing4076 Most of his audience are not even interested in science. In one of his videos some highschool kids were powerscaling physicists like hawking and einstein 😂

[@humanbeing4076]

@@uttamraj3786 really 😆

[@AnalystSarvesh]

I used to watch him until he started promoting mpl and that sort of stuff.

[@ahmefaqi]

We need more of this Pranav... Keep up the good work

[@jstahuman]

As far as I know...the latest theory of Evolution states about "minimum gene concept" i.e. there was a set of gene from where all the evolution began. I'll be glad if you explain how that set of gene came on earth....as till today we're unable to create that set of gene by creating the same environment during creation of Earth.

[@Shl.007]

I'm muslim and I love this channel I love who logically criticize something, it doesn't make you islamphobic.. i hate those people who just make conspiracy theories From some illogical religious books.. As per the comments of other videos.. majority Hindus are intolerant

[@champion6995]

Do you know that majority of the supporters here were born hindu? As for intolerance aren't Muslims more intolerant then hindus? Just look at the comment section of any video supporting homosexuality

[@positron3055]

As per cencus 2011 0.2% Indian population is athiest 😅😅 now it can be 2-3% so get out from this collectivism mindset treat one individualy

[@positron3055]

If Europe us built mindset like u then any Muslim can't get visa in those county

[@satyamraj5037]

Just a suggestion. You could announce the name of your monthly/weekly top supporters on patreon at the end of the video (just like some other ytubers do). Anyways, love your content and keep doing what you do, we all love you.

[@bharath_Chambal]

Religion is nothing but one of the first start-up.

[@Soham.69]

Rightly said😂

[@savvy_me]

Why don't Muslim try to examine the quran the same way they examine science and evolution 😆😆

[@arafatulhoque8375]

Qaisar Ahmed Raza replied to you.. Would be better if you both have a live conversation.

[@AnalystSarvesh]

1. 01:10 He mentions under condition (strong indoctrination) that one doesn't apply logic to their religion and are emotionally attached hence won't change due to emotional barrier. (Stop straw manning, atheism is not a religion. Most atheist families don't even talk about atheism let alone talk about other religion to indoctrinate against them) 2. 2:37 Modern synthesis has four parts random genetic drift, gene flow, mutation pressure and natural selection. So, if math is correct Darwinism is less than 25% of modern synthesis of evolution. 3. 3:56 Yes you are right, plasmids do transfer horizontally, it is great argument but for mutation theory not natural selection. 3:08 Pranav is giving evidence for natural selection not mutation theory. And he meant to say in simple words that the bacteria without antibiotic resistance (unfit) die and bacteria with resistance survive and multiply and then some resistance bacteria can also give resistance to other germs (according to the cdc of USA). 4. Macroevolutions does have evidence of abruptly found fossils in time scale and remarkably similar DNA from prior species. 5. 7:26 Natural selection does not act only on mutations, it happens due to gene flow (exotic gene entering population which optimizes life or does various kinds of chemistry to make it likable), preference to one characteristic when it comes to mating etc. 6. Mutations happen all the time due to high frequency radiation. Cancer is also a cause of some mutations, so are genetic disorders. (Also how did your intelligent designer make such a huge mistake (genetic disorders), they could have optimized reproduction, couldn't they? Unless they don't exist.) Also didn't y chromosome shrank some time ago? 7. 8:44 Nature has a very optimized way of deciding which mutations are good, that is survival and reproduction. You survive better you reproduce more spreading genes aka natural selection. 8. 10:45 If you say that the god has created the universe? fine. If you say god came to earth to form organisms? fine. If you say that the god repeatedly came on earth to form life? Not so fine. As I am afraid you are believing in much weaker god, as they have to repeatedly visit earth to create organisms. A more intelligent creature would have just created an algorithm and started it at the start of the universe to make organisms aka abiogenesis and evolution. Also, you are the first one speaking of multiple visits of god no one ever mentioned it and probably not even your unfallacifiable Quran. I am replying to you just in case if he deleted my comment.

[@AnalystSarvesh]

@CARTOON TV I am not spamming on every comment. I am spamming on quaiser supporters, who think quaiser derailed pranav but he didn't. He is a straw manning moron.

[@webdev643]

@@AnalystSarvesh he will debunk this guy . He mess with wrong community . It isn’t fairy tells religion that every tom diccck and harry can debunked . And you guys supporting darwin theory 😂.

[@AnalystSarvesh]

​@@webdev643 Yes, he will debunk this guy in your lala land.