Illegally Arrested For DEFENDING Her Brother!

[@TheBudgetGunCollector]

It’s hard to defend the citizen when he actually stole the backpack and had a trash can filled with purses. I’m just glad the dude got his backpack back seeing as it had military and bank documents

[@chipsweaters]

If he was white yall would be defending his rights.

[@Mrs.and.Mom.of.5]

That’s what irritates me about this episode. ATA didn’t even mention how the thief confessed to it and told them he threw the papers out.

[@william9922]

Unfortunately the thief threw the documents out all over the road ways

[@adamelam6385]

Yes, I have little sympathy for a thief. If you jump up in a cops face screaming you are getting arrested. 95% on Audit the Audit they show some of the worst cops in America but not this time.

[@hbk314]

@@adamelam6385 🤡

[@konradterlikowski8788]

She mentioned going into the bathroom. The backpack was found in the bathroom - she knew very well that there was the stolen stuff. She is a thief, as well as her brother.

[@Jboylio33]

She heard him mention it. If you listen carefully he actually told the officers to check the bathroom when they were going in to secure the home. So he went from saying there was no backpack there to telling them to check the bathroom where the backpack was found. She was upset with him because he technically consented to them going to check the bathroom.

[@BoomBurster]

If you’re going to speak with officers, there’s no technical mind frame- only literal. “Check the bathroom” is literal. “You want to search my car?” Even if asked in a tone of disbelief/repeated to make sure you heard correctly IS literal. They will take everything in engagement as literal immediately. Even if you “techcnically” said, said things without the intent of providing consent. She knew this. Guilty af Well technically not. Until proven but if it goes to jury we all votin the same.

[@konradterlikowski8788]

@@Jboylio33 I didn't hear that earlier. But when You mentioned that, "Go look to my..." then the screech of the lady - it might have been "bathroom" that he said. But she looked very agitated by that. No way she didn't know about her brother "business".

[@Jboylio33]

@@konradterlikowski8788 something tells me she knew about his business or played a role in it. The police should not have been able to check the trash cans because of how close they were to the house, but finding a bunch of empty purses and wallets in the trash can and her being so pissed off about them going through the trash I think she knew they would find something there. I really believe that she was acting up and being so animated to attempt to distract them from the evidence they were going to find.

[@konradterlikowski8788]

@@Jboylio33 It depends. It looked like the purses were spiling out of the trash can and the police noticed it without even touching the trash. If that what it was, it was reasonable because the evidence was in plain view.

[@seanachack6249]

Yeah the issue is that this wasn't some "anonymous tip", the guy got his stuff stolen and was giving police concrete evidence that it was located in that residence.

[@JonathanLedbetter]

Still needs a warrant

[@revamp8835]

Didn’t watch the recap but the original video a while ago, searching trash bins you need no warrant since it’s abandoned property. Searching homes you do need a warrant, and in the video they even say step out we are obtaining a warrant. The victim had a tracker

[@ulize.]

​@@JonathanLedbetter nah you don't nt though. Trash can searches are fully legal and he consented to a search of his residency

[@Anyienk9]

@@JonathanLedbetter And they had asked for one, but while they were waiting they decided to ask the owner for permission to search the house, and eventually got it. And as it was said in the video, the police had the right to keep the owner out of the house until they could search it because they were afraid that he would destroy the evidence.

[@megannoe2057]

@Revamp The trash cans weren't on the curb ready for trash pickup. It was on the curtlage of the property. Now, curtlage laws very from state to state, and I'm not sure what the curtlage laws are in this case. Considering the trash cans are on the side of the house, it'll be questionable if the search upholds in court, I doubt it.

[@Mushruums]

I think the sister is the one who stole the property. She knew exactly what was in the garbage bins and got extremely defensive when they searched the trash. The brother didn’t seem to care as much as she did

[@B345T1N355Official]

Should both be charged with theft then tbh

[@joshjje]

Thats the feeling I got too, but regardless IMO the cops overstepped their authority several times. So all you need to do to get someone's house searched is show a ping on your phone pointing there... yeah, without a warrant no less.

[@kacperwroblewski3716]

@@joshjje A GPS is a PC. When you have a PC, you don't need a warrant to secure the scene.

[@pete5516]

@@kacperwroblewski3716right, so I know lots of you are tech illiterate so I’ll explain this from the POV of someone who actually works in tech and knows a lot more than you. It is INCREDIBLY easy to fake a GPS signal. There is literally no proof that they didn’t just use an app that lets you put a tag down on someone’s house, Unfortunately this is very easy to do, anyone could do it to you right now. Hope this explanation helped your little brain to understand.

[@monkeychife]

@@pete5516ya know you can explain that without sounding like a know it all douchebag.

[@ryancrazy1]

can you imagine having the cops at your house looking for a stolen backpack, and you don't bother to at least... hide it?

[@chonky2129]

I’ll bet he’s been doing this so much he can’t even keep up with what they’ve stolen. That’s crazy that the trash cans were just full of stolen goods.

[@klatubaradanikto]

I would say if you are going to snatch purses for a living that part of your business plan should include not answering the door for police.

[@TheFruitingChamber]

@@klatubaradaniktolol

[@explicitDTP]

He was high as a kite

[@Inquisitor6321]

@@chonky2129 yeah - a whole trashcan full of stolen stuff. A career thief.

[@Travisrogers87]

With that many bags and purses it’s a shame they weren’t charged with organized crime. This is clearly a whole operation they’re running.

[@jmdenison]

These shows are not about that. What they are about is how the police act when they are in the presence of civilians and their property. The trash cans were on the side of the house and likely part of the curtilage And that means hands off until they get a warrant. They've got the GPS tracking device all they have to do is wait for some judge to rubber stamp a warrant. By opening up the garbage cans now they jeopardize the entire arrest. Which is not good for law-abiding taxpayers.

[@SykotikShadow]

I'm pretty sure they'll keep an eye and investigation on this place and residents now after this.

[@Blue-hf7xt]

How about actually investigating and collecting evidence? Innocent until proven guilty.

[@brydonthunder]

She probably incriminated herself when identifying the exact location of the backpack. And.. the thousands of dollars of stolen merchandise in a garbage can...

[@Ender1king]

@@jmdenison it's still a viable comment. They know what this channel is about. They are just stating that its a shame how they stole all that stuff, yet weren't charged for that.

[@hatterson]

I feel bad for the dude who had his bag stolen. Gets his bag stolen, acts responsible, makes it clear he's not looking for revenge, just wants his bag back, etc. Then the sister shows up and he's parked in and stuck just sitting there in his car while the girl is freaking out and a million cops are going around the house.

[@SheyVick]

Plus the thief dumped his papers out in the street before this interaction so he didn't even get his documents back

[@jmdenison]

I don't feel she was freaking out that much as making it clear to the officers that any trespass on their civil rights would not be tolerated. And I think that's fair. The fact she was loud about it, well okay she's probably just a loud person. I don't agree with her personal attacks in the car. But sometimes her freaking out may have avoided her brother from getting beat up and that's always a worry with these cases

[@eugenetswong]

She appeared threatening, even when stepped back a bit. I think that putting her in the car was best way to reduce conflict. Audit The Audit messed up on this. She's a third party and has very little right to come so close to cops. Her yelling went beyond free speech. She was too distracting.

[@hatterson]

​@@jmdenison This video didn't show a ton of her behavior, but I've seen other longer videos on this incident and she was pretty out of control at several points. From the extended video it's clear the officers initially detained her when she attempted to enter the house. She wasn't arrested for this, simply detained. Then, while sitting on the step she continued to loudly interrupt the officers as they attempted to talk to the homeowner, that seems like clear verbal interference/obstruction to me. I don't know if that would be able to rise to an actual obstruction charge, but it seems more than enough for the officers to be justified in removing her from the scene while things play out. An additional patrol vehicle arrived and the officer who seemed to be in charge of the scene asked the newly arrived officer to place her in his vehicle. At that point nothing had been mentioned about her being under arrest, it seemed they were simply removing her from the scene so they could complete their jobs. While she was being walked to the patrol car she repeatedly attempted to pull back against the officer and resist him moving her towards the car and then repeatedly was pulling away from him as he attempted to do a brief pat down before placing her in his car. *That* is when it was mentioned she was being placed under arrest for resisting.

[@Blue-hf7xt]

Bootlicker

[@felixklusener5530]

Interesting that the young man didn´t seem to have a problem with the Police searching his home, while his sister freaked out about it. It could almost seem like she was the one hiding incriminating items in that house and not her brother.

[@lindaward3156]

ya think?

[@OBBOYS]

I mean if you didn’t know the potential consequences of allowing something, then you’d hope someone would advise you to do different. Trash is still public property once it’s placed at the street.

[@ricksturdevant2901]

Ms Camacho is a scary bag of trouble 😬 I bet the Camacho clan have had their skirmishes - confrontations - tussles - and run ins with the law, glad I have a different zip code

[@dontmindme633]

Yeah she was likely in on it

[@Rolkey]

He obviously doesn’t know his civil rights.

[@TheZerokool187]

Yeah, I’m gonna go with the cops on this one. They caught the thief and things got escalated because his sister didn’t know how to control herself.

[@Ragnarok0312]

I would have to agree. As stated in the video at one point, GPS tags do warrant probable cause, so the trash cans search was a little rushed, but warranted. After the sister was barred entry to the home she was still presenting hostile language both verbally and physically. I agree with the disorderly conduct charge, but she's very lucky that she did not get an obstruction charge.

[@philosophyforum4668]

But they didn't show the search or show the backpack.

[@seppukumouse8005]

@@philosophyforum4668 The brother tells them its in the bathroom, he gave them permission to check his house.

[@norfsidekickz5130]

Doesn’t matter who y’all agree with 😂 Chertisha sued the police department and won

[@philosophyforum4668]

@@norfsidekickz5130 I don't believe you, but whether or not one would applaud such a "victory" depends on which party you are more likely to be in the position of. So don't violate #8: "You shall not steal."

[@hornedgod2873]

I’m just glad that military kid’s stuff was recovered. He seemed like an innocent victim

[@William47345]

he looks that one shooter. like he looks almost like a clone. id keep your eye on him. getting military training on how to use weapons. how to shoot, how to clean houses etc.... He could be a bigger danger then mr bag stealer

[@Halfrican4111]

The military is never innocent

[@gagelochard3731]

@@William47345wtf?

[@dreadfulspiller8766]

@@William47345 He is a hero versus the trash who stole his bag.

[@AcornElectron]

He was an innocent victim. No seemed about it.

[@whyisblue923taken]

It looks like she was the one stealing things and her brother is just so stoned that he doesn't realize what's happening in the house.

[@badjuju98]

The sister is an enabler. She knows what's going on and tries to protect the clueless brother.

[@frankmarano1118]

Not only that but she charged at them screaming aggressively. I wouldve detained her at that point for being a loose cannon

[@abrilguillen4036]

maybe but she knew her rights probably as much as the cops

[@EATAJR]

She needed to be detained.

[@ThatGuyX2]

She's probably in on it.

[@anti-classist]

She didn't do anything illegal though, the cops did.

[@experienceofchris1108]

I’m fully convinced the sister was the one stealing which is why she started acting crazy when she saw them looking in the trash can. She seems more like a serial thief and the brother seems more like a chill “whatever” kind of dude

[@linkingwithnaz1295]

Yeah def

[@lindaward3156]

my thoughts exactly. it's hard to imagine him snatching purses. her? absolutely!

[@doompod]

Same

[@Ena48145]

I saw this bodycam video a really long time ago when it first came out and you make a fantastic observation. I always found it bizarre how out of control she acted

[@tomraineofmagigor3499]

legally speaking she's right though. They need the warrant first if they don't have permission. If someone is proven guilty afterwards that doesn't invalidate trying to maintain their rights

[@dadstruck4293]

Dude was accused of stealing a back pack and had a garbage can full of purses and wallets. A jury would likely convict, that being said, not having a warrant could prove difficult for the state.

[@roro-jj1fv]

e cops (criminals of police) overstepped big. Time The gabage cans were outside & anyone could put stuff in them .. also the cop has no evidence putting bag in his hand anyone could have put it in there .... also if cop was allowed in house to secure for warrant it was for bag anything else is fruit of poisonous tree including the paraphernalia grant if in plain site it would be cool IF they waited for the warrant but they did not

[@killshotskillington1028]

It’s the legality of obtaining the information that the purses and wallets were in there. If it can be suppressed they have no case

[@dadstruck4293]

@@killshotskillington1028 but if they found the stolen bat in the house, it still builds a decent case.

[@sendthis9480]

Wasn’t the lid open a little? That’s more than enough to recognize a purse or wallet.

[@Noodlepunk]

You do not need a Warrant to search trash cans. Once it is thrown away it uo for grabs. Most trash cans do not even belong to you they belong to the state.

[@fuferito]

She's definitely been using her own brother's garbage bins to dump things she steals.

[@chipsweaters]

If he was white yall would be defending his rights.

[@johnjames7289]

I'm sorry but you better be right about that claim. You can be civilly sued fir defamation and slander.

[@mystery_to_history]

@@johnjames7289 LOL WHAT? for an internet comment lmfao good one

[@vidura]

@@johnjames7289 And you can be butt raepd even during a normal day walk. Life is dangerous and your butt is never safe, anywhere.

[@derekrodriguez1023]

@@vidura wise words, that’s why I duct tape my butt cheeks shut before I leave the house everyday. No one is catching me slippin

[@justNGC604]

Wouldn't be surprised if it turns out that SHE actually ran this "business" and somehow convinced her simple brother that all of those purses and backpacks filling his tiny home and trash are somehow her crafting hobby.

[@FrylerMcFrow]

nah lol they love stealing

[@NunchucksHabit]

He got a felony for receiving stolen property between $5k - $10k. She got a misdemeanor for receiving stolen property < or equal to $2500 & possession of drug paraphenalia. She was charged with a felony for battery/threat to a LEO (repeat offender) & misdemeanor resisting/obstruction (repeat offender).

[@justNGC604]

@@NunchucksHabit Leading to what sentences? (If you know it.)

[@StephenSpring1]

@@justNGC604 it got dropped to disorderly conduct with a 50 dollar fine +200 or so for court costs

[@ChunkyMonkaayyy]

Sister’s body language wasp 100% “oh no, we’re caught”. She knew what was going to happen and her fight or flight reaction was to try to gaslight.

[@Blue-hf7xt]

You don’t understand how she was defending her’s and her brother’s Rights. Being guilty of a crime doesn’t Negate one’s Rights.

[@ChunkyMonkaayyy]

@@Blue-hf7xt 👌🏽

[@Blue-hf7xt]

@@ChunkyMonkaayyy so you are not very bright? Do you want cops searching your property? This violations of rights are used against innocent citizens every day. Police thugs don’t care if you are innocent or guilty.

[@carryeveryday910]

@@Blue-hf7xt Non guilty adults don’t act how she did though to be fair.

[@Blue-hf7xt]

@@carryeveryday910 non guilty Ha ha like non vegan. What human behavioral degree do you have?

[@christiananderson8686]

Sister steals stuff and hands it off to her brother, ditching the remnants in his garbage. Also convenient how she "happens to be passing" when she sees the officers looking in the trash 👀

[@jnew2162]

He definitely called her or texted when the guy looking for his backpack first came to the house. I believe the backpack owner went and talked to the guy before calling the police.

[@ThatGuyX2]

​@JNEW I believe yall both correct. She's probably the lead thief and the idiot brother takes shit to pawn shops etc

[@kalrikelari]

Did u stretch before that reach?

[@xXInfamouzGeoXx]

Oh the irony when she yelled “things would be much easier if you just didn’t break laws”

[@mufin6930]

Stealing cash from somebody's wallet or purse is one thing. But stealing the wallet or purse and discarding it when they are almost _always_ full of bank cards, licenses, documents, sentimental items/photos makes you, in my opinion, an absolute scumbag trash human being. Same goes for if you steal somebody's phone and you wipe the data card and pawn it for $100. The phone was probably worth $1,000 and had TONS of important information and sentimental value on it. No pity from me at all for thieves who steal these items. They deserve whatever sh*t comes their way.

[@ronniejacobsen3000]

Lolol... Fuck yeah...

[@trash_panda95]

Did a search on the sister, Chertisha Camacho , on the Circuit Court database for Wisconsin. She has quite the array of misdemeanors herself including shoplifting, violating restraining orders placed against her, etc. She deserves an F for how she behaved. I don't know what ATA was thinking.

[@gunner3921]

Can’t say I agree with you on this one. In my eyes, the officers did a great job trying to play both sides here. Officer said they were going to secure the residence, and the sister began furiously yelling and charged the officer. He pushes her back and explains again that he is securing the residence. She walks up to him, still yelling, and begins flailing her arms. She is obviously a distraction and interfering with the officers lawful duties.

[@Archon_of_Freedom_]

Agreed 💯 and her attitude was rotten.

[@Kadori328]

@@Archon_of_Freedom_ Dosent matter can't break the law to imprison someone

[@doriankamanzi6874]

dosent matter how bad her attitude is they went without without persimmon then got arrested for speaking and they said she was ristiting when she did not at all they lied and broke the law if your house got searched and they said it smelt like weed for no reseon ytou would be pissed as well if they dident even listen to you then arrested you for speaking which

[@doriankamanzi6874]

@@Archon_of_Freedom_ dosent matter how bad her attitude is they went without without persimmon then got arrested for speaking and they said she was ristiting when she did not at all they lied and broke the law if your house got searched and they said it smelt like weed for no reseon ytou would be pissed as well if they dident even listen to you then arrested you for speaking which when your a offcier you cant use you emotions because she was yelling that is not professional

[@gunner3921]

@@doriankamanzi6874 Not her house, she does not have domain. This is like saying my neighbor can order the police not to enter my home even if police have PC. I know arguing with you is going to be like arguing to a brick wall, however it's important to remember that the charge stuck and she pleaded no contest instead of not guilty.

[@kacpecie]

Actually if you look closely, the cop reports purses in the trash on the radio before he opens the trashcan up. A claim of a stolen backpack and purses STICKING OUT of the trash is definitely gives probable cause to not only search the trash but the whole house

[@andrewfowlkes3838]

Finally someone acknowledges this! People keep trying to say it was a violation but Uber the plain view doctrine they are allowed to open the trash can AFTER they see the purses STICKING OUT OF IT. Even ATA says that a court could go either way on this one so I don’t get why the people in the comments thinks it’s 100% a clear violation when in reality it’s a bit of a gray area

[@kacpecie]

@@andrewfowlkes3838 another thing is the woman came at them screaming, they even had physical contact (officer pushed her out) and didn't get arrested. The exact moment they decided to arrest her was when she PUNCHED HERSELF IN THE PALM with her fist. I believe in many cases that has been sufficient grounds for assault

[@maddog5814]

Its like if cops see an arm hanging out of a trash can, would we really expect them to look the other way like "nothing to see here, just a trash can"

[@HyperVectra]

Ireasonable articulable suspicion != probabile cause

[@godassasin8097]

reasonable suspicion can't be used to search houses you need a warrent for that

[@svenjorgensenn8418]

Illegal yes, sympathy no. Criminals belong in jail. But we need to do it the right way.

[@Dagrizzb]

It's the only way to prove we are truly better than the criminal. That we will not compromise our integrity. Does it make it more difficult to obtain a conviction, yes. But that conviction will be undisputable.

[@TEverettReynolds]

I don't know how "illegal" it was since the lid on the trash can was not closed, and something that looked like a bag was visible. I think the case could be made, just like when a cop can look into your windows and see drugs on a table. if the cop can see the garbage and the bag without opening the lid, then it leads to the investigation.

[@chipsweaters]

If he was white yall would be defending his rights.

[@jasonBrown-ol2lz]

On top of that the officer was throwing trash away when they saw the objects

[@ISRAELITE.ZEBULUN]

So lock the cops up!

[@mobrocket]

Sister should use that energy against her guilty brother not the cops...

[@racecitypatriot66]

She probably helping him steal too

[@jamescordes8673]

Guilty? What? He’s a good boy. Probably just got home from church and helping out handicapped orphan kids and had to deal with all that right after. Just stopped home real quick to change into his crossing guard outfit to help the elderly

[@MylesLong82]

@Dr. Pyssinshytz These are KZbin comments. Wtf you talkin about? lol

[@terrenceodonnell6347]

I agree with all of this, but the fact that WY still has a BS charge for THC is an absolute joke

[@MrAndywills]

@@racecitypatriot66or was he helping his sister?

[@stephenhenley7452]

She wasn't arrested for defending her brother. She was arrested for interfering to the point that the police couldn't do their job including getting in their face. Giving them both a C is ridiculous

[@timthehistorian]

They were violating her brothers 4th amendment rights, then the pigs arrested her for telling them they were breaking the law

[@squirreltamer2548]

Well, those supposed pigs as you call them found a trashcan full of purses and wallets. I’d say that it gave them pretty good sufficient probable cause. So 4th amendment goes out the window. Tell me why would she throw such a fit if nothing is wrong? Have you heard the phrase, “Thou doth protest too much.”? They should have detained her, not arrested. If she threw a bigger fit for being detained and got physical, then they can slap on the obstruction charges and arrest her.

[@kittyunderwood8918]

@@squirreltamer2548 Also want to point out that they were searching trashcans that weren't considered public property because they weren't at the curb yet, so they violated his 4th amendment in order to find those purses

[@Andy-rf8rr]

@@kittyunderwood8918 We're going to ignore the Airtag that brought them to the home? That alone is enough probably cause

[@Bot-yx7gt]

​@@timthehistorianquedate' callao' perkin, por wns como vo' mi país está en la mrd.

[@EmeraldRich]

I remember watching this body cam in full and this just had me infuriated. Sis was making it way worse than it actually was.

[@rockcityfpv9117]

She was mad they "the cops" made it worse.

[@apc_46and28]

@@rockcityfpv9117lol she was mad that her brothers hustle was busted.

[@Jigsaw0g]

@@apc_46and28 damn straight

[@technne-gu1yu]

it was funny, most criminals like them are just dumb if you're going to do crime, dont have a fuckin trash can with them bare assed in it, like you got to be special kind of idiot to just throw them in your own trash not in a black garbage bag or anything, if i was a judge i would charge his ass for each individual bag and wallet put his ass in prison for 40 years lmao

[@aquaop1]

​@@apc_46and28 I take it you're an only child, because if Police were harassing any of my brothers I'd be furious too. Especially when they were entering his house and on his property without a warrant and only providing for "application".

[@Rhyd]

She’s not defending her brother, she’s attempting to prevent the officers from discovering the serious amount of crimes committed by her brother. The amount of victims that he caused to have literal trash and full of stolen bags and purses is insane. The brazenness of it leads me to believe he isn’t working a lone and has done this for a while.

[@Rhyd]

@@bojohannesen4352 Just a typo, no psychoanalysis needed.

[@I.____.....__...__]

People seem to think she as involved (or maybe it was her dumping ground and the brother wasn't even involved). Not impossible. 🤷

[@ftrwrwbg]

I completely agree, but it’s still very frustrating to constantly see police place people in cuffs for words alone. At the moment she had done nothing deserving an arrest.

[@twilightsparkle75]

​@@I.____.....__...__ but regardless she is interfering and obstructing in the investigation of a crime. so whethwe or not she knows of her brothers misdeeds, she os still involving herself into this situation

[@twilightsparkle75]

​@@ftrwrwbg its not words alone, she got very loud and boisterous, as well she started walking up on officers aggressively and frankly she seems entirely about to go off amd there have been many times where these mannerisms lead rapidly to escalation and violence, so its safest for all parties involved, officer and civilian, to restrain disorderly individuals.

[@tcelltech2518]

The sister literally threatened an officer with death and you gave her a "C" grade 🤨

[@anthonynash8079]

She threatened to get her lawyer.

[@MrDzoni955]

@@anthonynash8079 I don't remember the full video well but I think she threatened the officer that was driving her to jail. But im not sure

[@tcelltech2518]

@anthonynash8079 She did, she also told an officer "I will kill you" 🙄

[@sippingthe]

@@anthonynash8079 it’s not in this video but if you look at the uncut version she clearly threatens the police officer and his family

[@TeslaGengar]

@@anthonynash8079 she said “i hope your wife gets raped” to the officer

[@BetofromTX]

Sister deserves an F. She was not arrested because of her vebal attacks, but her actions. Any reasonable person can see she was quickly escalating everything.

[@lfaf9509]

Sister deserves a B. Because although she was right that the cops were breaking the law, and the fact that she called them out on it is why they kidnapped her, but she allowed them to bully her into taking a bad deal which made her look guilty of a crime she did not commit.

[@danieldotcom3743]

@@lfaf9509 lol bruh she was very obviously trying to get the cops away from the house because she knew what was up. they literally found the bag that was stolen because of an airtag, like theres no way around that especially since the dude's military items that NOBODY else could've gotten a hold of besides the original owner, and had so many stolen things that they had to throw them into the garbage. like do you know how many things a thief has to steal before they just say "fuck it this is too much stuff lets just start throwing it away" lol. i am very anti police but there is zero room to debate that these people were nothing but low life thieves who finally got what was coming to them, plus she literally threatened the lives of the cops & said she hopes the cop's wife get r4ped. She deserves a huge F+ lol

[@lfaf9509]

@@danieldotcom3743 A few things I can easily brush off. 1. Saying you wish or hope something happens to someone, is in fact Not a threat. 2. The cops are not allowed to search a trash can that is located on the side of someones home, without a warrant, which these cops did not have. Which makes that search a crime. 3. When the sister saw the cops, breaking the law, she stopped them. They did not arrest her because she was breaking the law, they kidnapped her because she was calling out their crimes. 4. Even if she "knew what was going on" that doesn't change anything I have said at this point. The cops do not have the legal authority to just choose to ignore the law like they were doing. His or her actual guilt when it comes to the stolen bag, does not change the fact that they have rights, and they were violated. 5. It is not immoral to lash out against your kidnappers, or to wish them harm, it is expected. She was being kidnapped, she was about to be sexually assaulted by government officials/workers, and or raped. She had every single reason to wish the people who were harming her, and about to cause her greater harms, harm. It may be illegal to resist, but it sure as heck is not immoral and it sure as heck should not be illegal if the thing you are resisting is a crime against you. 6. There are processes in place, to protect everyone in these kinds of situations, the cops did not use those processes, they did not get a warrant, they did not follow the law or policy's, they just kidnapped the woman because she was trying to hold them to the law. They chose to break the law, which makes any conviction of theft nearly impossible if he gets a decent lawyer.

[@danieldotcom3743]

@@lfaf9509 not readin all that bruh u just delusional 💀💀💀

[@mostcoolkid78]

@@lfaf9509 your crazy

[@Sopperduck36]

This is one instance where I gotta defend the cops. With the trash can full of empty bags and purses, as well as the backpack in the house with the air tag and important documents. It's hard to defend anyone in residence or related to those staying there. The sister clearly knew he was guilty or affiliated and tried to make a scene to bail him out.

[@cargopilotguy305]

I oppose the police since they didn’t have a right to search those trash cans.

[@christine_lovelace]

I don't agree

[@ssgemactv]

​​​@@cargopilotguy305 Exactly, the fruit of the poisonous tree doctorine basically says that this evidence is going to be thrown out because it was obtained illegally.

[@darinr3748]

@@cargopilotguy305 apparently you have not been listening to the video. They absolutely have the right. I would also have to say that you seem like you are not a law abiding citizen. A garbage can full of empty purses and wallets? And that doesn’t raise your eyebrows? I bet it would if it was your wallet in the garbage can.

[@freebehindbars8654]

I agree. I’ll be the first to call out wrong doing, but this is not one of those case imo. You’ll always have a few basement dwellers that think every incidence is a case for misconduct on the police.

[@curtisj2165]

The sister knew the police would find evidence of her brother's wrongdoing

[@jess_o]

Or her own

[@selseyonetwenty4631]

I love it when she said 'this would all be much easier if y'all didn't break the law' 🤣

[@chattingman6777]

Which is going to get thrown out for an illegal search.

[@acatwithaids5398]

@Chattingman home owner consented to search. Another crimnal gone 😎

[@cammobunker]

Pretty sure she's involved, likely she's what little brains there is in this operation. Brother seems quite...slow.

[@michaelbarnes7351]

They way the sister acted I would not be surprised if she was the one who stole the laptop and hid it at her brother's house.

[@apc_46and28]

Yeah she’s def in on this hustle, or benefits from it at the very least.

[@godgrinder2219]

Exactly!!!

[@carryeveryday910]

“ May not have known that the backpack was inside of the residence” Love your videos, but he clearly stated at the beginning of the encounter that he was the only one that lives there, and that he knows everything that is in his house, so he clearly knew the bag was there based on his own assertion

[@kaliss7192]

This is why I unsubbed from this channel. He stopped being unbiased s long time ago. Now it just seems like he hates cops.

[@UnroyalYeet]

@@kaliss7192you’re exactly right. he started out unbiased and now he’s clearly anti cop

[@onorebakasama]

Not necessarily. He COULD say that, but if his sister spends a lot of time there, then he couldn't possibly know everything in the house. She could forget stuff there all the time and he wouldn't know it. This is normal, expected, even. And it might be part of why the sister showed up so quickly. Even then, it's unlikely that most people know everything that's in their houses, especially if they have a lot of stuff.

[@Jaydee800123]

@@UnroyalYeetor maybe, just maybe, there is little to no content posted where both parties are acting civil and professional during a police encounter.

[@UnroyalYeet]

@@Jaydee800123 with millions of interactions every year with police and civilians i’m sure that’s not the case. but those civil interactions don’t get views. being anti cop does.

[@daveblackman816]

I’m normally against tyrannical cops, but cmon, they had all of the merchandise in the trash. Fair game. Their behavior didn’t help at all. Looks like they stole the backpack.

[@thesuperpimpplaya1]

Not justifying the guys behavior but that in itself is a problem. They shouldn't have even been searching or looking at anything.

[@jordanmorris5194]

Yeah the trash was on the curtilage- in fact it was right next to the house. They actually needed a search warrant or it’s a fourth amendment violation

[@okaro6595]

​@@jordanmorris5194 Criminals have all the rights. Fuck them.

[@strafer8764]

@@jordanmorris5194 f the amendment. They stole. They don’t deserve rights.

[@armadildo6468]

@jordanmorris5194 anyone canwalk on curttlage. The lid was ajar being visible to the public. He had reasonable suspicion. The woman is a looney.

[@ericcrabtree7404]

She was correct about the warrant and advising her brother not to give them permission. You should always make law enforcement do the full spectrum of steps to exercise their powers and protect yourself. Still, this family is likely a criminal enterprise - so eff them.

[@GoodForYou4504]

Exactly.

[@S0L12D3]

I wouldn’t call them an enterprise, just some bums that steal peoples bags

[@psygnosticrevenant6773]

Agreed, and even the guilty have legal rights that must be respected.

[@S0L12D3]

@@psygnosticrevenant6773 “I smell the odor of weed coming from the house” boom your rights are gone

[@psygnosticrevenant6773]

@@S0L12D3 Wrong. As it says in the laws cited in the video, smelling weed does not grant carte blanche access to the house. Did you even watch it?

[@bigisrick]

She's using her disabled brother to cover for her crimes. Absolutely disgusting. Definitely siding with the cops on this one.

[@waltergrimes8075]

Where did they say her brother was disabled??? I believe she either stole the backpack, wallets and purses or they both did. But either way she knew they had been caught and she was doin everything she could to keep them out of the house and trashcan.

[@3OONZlE]

i’m sorry disabled? like i’m genuinely confused, did they mention he was disabled?

[@Kidblurr02]

This whole case will get thrown out. Search of the garbage was illegal

[@investigator2016]

@@Kidblurr02 was it? The can was open on this officers camera and he was calling in the purses before he even opened it.

[@XemnasKaijin]

@@Kidblurr02 they had probable cause. Crime was reported - there was a visible ping of the AirTag inside of their home, and the officers used that to look through their garbage, and found more stolen goods.

[@kaedyngraham1860]

How much did they bribe you bro what the hell were you thinking with this video 😂

[@ianjenkins8114]

Agreed! Defending the indefensible sure is a quick way to loose credibility

[@rodstinson537]

Wow 😳, this is one of a slight few I am in agreement with the police, usually they are violating someone, but to see they are doing their job the right way, good on them, I give them a C-, but I give the sister a F

[@quiteLargeTuna]

Agreed officers like these actually doing their job and serving law abiding citizens should be applauded

[@roro-jj1fv]

e cops (criminals of police) overstepped big. Time The gabage cans were outside & anyone could put stuff in them .. also the cop has no evidence putting bag in his hand anyone could have put it in there .... also if cop was allowed in house to secure for warrant it was for bag anything else is fruit of poisonous tree including the paraphernalia grant if in plain site it would be cool IF they waited for the warrant but they did not

[@andrewfowlkes3838]

@@quiteLargeTuna isn’t it crazy how many people on the comments are against these officers?

[@minumero4094]

The backpack was found in the premises.... That's all we need to know... I don't care about the marijuana odor... Yeah, he sounded like a pothead anyway, for all i care... But....Have you ever got a backpack stolen, with all the personal information that's in it?..IT'S A FCKNG NIGHTMARE! 😠And these guys had been doing this to several victims (judging by the wallets and the purses found in the trashcans) who knows for how long! 😡 There's no way I can condone any of the behavior displayed but this "sister" ...In my eyes, she's just a partner in crime!.. I'm actually appalled she got away with just having to pay a fine of $50.. That's bllshìt! This is a freaking criminal enterprise what they got going on there 🤔

[@selseyonetwenty4631]

@@andrewfowlkes3838 They should try coming to the UK. British Police would not even turn out to answer a call like that, it's happened several times and they are not interested. They issue the victim a crime number and tell him to claim on insurance.

[@aaronsouthard8366]

Nope. This is one of the few times I can't even see things from your POV. She was out of pocket and the brother was atleast respectable.

[@svenjorgensenn8418]

Honestly. She was the theif and her brother was the holder.

[@aaronsouthard8366]

@@svenjorgensenn8418 I get that feeling too.

[@Roz4628]

Really feels like the sister is at fault, and is getting defensive because she was using her brother's home to dump evidence.

[@mikehannigan848]

certainly seems that way, instead of browbeating the cops trying to recover stolen military gear she should have maybe used it as a teachable moment for her bro...but her reaction is just as telling of her involvement.

[@andrewfowlkes3838]

Ya she was def the mastermind who organized their little snatch and trash scheme they had going on, that’s why she was so defensive about them looking in the trash cans.

[@PsychobabbleRapp]

yep, I am with the cops on this one

[@SomeGuy.with.a.Beard93]

I can’t stand a thief!!!! Kinda pissed that I’m on the side of the cops that broke regulations.

[@ed3839]

What kind of moron criminal dumps the evidence in trash cans next to their house, and not even sealed in plastic bags? As I've heard a prosecutor say, "We don't catch the smart ones".

[@sussologist]

I really can't see how she can be justified in her actions. A literal trashcan filled with purses and the bag was in their house.

[@kamb8s]

And finding this evidence through an illegal search means what to you?

[@ncscooterz]

The sisters body language and attitude is a telling sign that she’s knows her brother is guilty…….

[@wadestanton]

body language and attitude got a lot of girls burned to death in Salem Mass USA

[@radfoo72]

​@@wadestanton Act like a witch, get treated as one💁🏻‍♂️

[@wadestanton]

@@radfoo72 do you think USA will start killing people for acting like witches, again?

[@badzi4200]

I get what you are saying but imagine how many cops who have used this reasoning to illegaly arrest someone.

[@tres311]

@@wadestanton yup, and thank god for that era of natural selection.

[@migueldelmazo5244]

I would think that the fact that the trashcan was so full of stolen property that it raised the lid high enough that the contents could be seen without opening it is relevant. The cop could see many purses, etc. from plain view and since that is unusual and relevant to the question of a bag theft, it gave RAS to begin an investigation.

[@roro-jj1fv]

e cops (criminals of police) overstepped big. Time The gabage cans were outside & anyone could put stuff in them .. also the cop has no evidence putting bag in his hand anyone could have put it in there .... also if cop was allowed in house to secure for warrant it was for bag anything else is fruit of poisonous tree including the paraphernalia grant if in plain site it would be cool IF they waited for the warrant but they did not

[@killshotskillington1028]

Has to articulate that in his report or it will get tossed

[@hdlc4635]

It's not relevant and no one has asserted that it was a pile of stolen merchandise except you.

[@HorusHerotic]

​@@killshotskillington1028 well I'm sure that will be real difficult. Might as well let the criminals go. /S

[@rosiemontenegro5985]

No stolen bags or wallets was seen on video but not warrant either to go inside the house. Thats there favorite words stop resisting & i smell weed, i smell alcohol for them to justify there wrong doing they get away with it all the time. And what happen to freedom of speech she can call them pigs if she wants because its her freedom of speech again.

[@gonzie3915]

cops get an A+ for helping buddyguy get his backpack back, & for taking two scumbags off the streets

[@I.____.....__...__]

But the way they did it was illegal and they were just just thieves, not human-traffickers or cartels. There was no immediate danger to anyone. They absolutely _could_ have done it the right way instead of breaking the law and risking the entire case getting thrown out. 😒

[@lonnmoore5568]

@@I.____.....__...__Thanks for proving a law degree from a crackerjack box is worthless

[@knicks5426]

@@lonnmoore5568 wdym

[@silvaskiproductions3937]

they will be back out soon enough probably to reoffend

[@fcukyou2_]

​@m thieves are pathetic, low life, bottom of the barrel scum. Jail is too good for them, they should lose a hand for it, like we used to do to them.

[@bellumclash2337]

That has to be one of the most generous C grades ever. A successful prosecution for the threats would have faced a tough challenge, but her words were contemptible & the cops exercised a lot of restraint. Yelling & screaming at the cops while they tried to talk to her brother was interfering with their ability to do their jobs. She's lucky to have plead out with a misdemeanor, but her mouth is going to get her into trouble with someone, sooner or later.

[@alexsnow3319]

Your headline is misleading. She wasn't arrested for defending her brother. She was inserting herself into an ongoing investigation and obstructing. She was becoming irate and combative. She needed this, this is a Karen.

[@777guy1]

Guess this guys videos aren't getting views. He's resorting to clickbait 😂😂😂

[@GRIGGLES97]

The title is the usual reaction people have when first shown the video. Watching the video, shows that the content creator didn’t side with the views of the title. Like saying “my disappointment is immeasurable and my day is ruined” when you have a great day.

[@alexsnow3319]

@@GRIGGLES97 I remember watching the whole video when it was first released. Already knew what was gonna happen.

[@joshp8535]

His headlines are always misleading. Click bait is what it is. Dude wants views, who can blame him? It's one of my least favorite things about the channel, but I'm sure it brings in new viewers.

[@sendthis9480]

@@GRIGGLES97 It’s intentional. He leaves out bits of info and purposely gets the kids (his viewers) all excited and emotional. He even trips up his own info from previous stories. He searches out this sort of thing. And then twists it so it fits a narrative.

[@andrewfowlkes3838]

Bottom line is that if it weren’t for these cops, that guy never would have gotten his bag back. Props to the cops on this one for doing what needed to be done to help the victim instead of protecting the criminals.

[@MrPbhuh]

They could have gathered a search warrant first and secure the residence, the fact that they started already searching the trash enters a gray area, nothing stopped them from going to a judge first to avoid all legal disputes, instead they acted on their own, which then leads to potential 4th amendment violations. So these kinda situations lead to gray areas, which then leads to disputes.

[@andrewfowlkes3838]

@@MrPbhuh you’re right that this is a gray area, especially because the trash lid wasn’t shut because of how full of stolen items it was so they could have potentially seen the purses before they even opened it fully. But at the end of the day the cops helped a man in need and did what they had to do.

[@hbk314]

Terrible take. Police have a responsibility to do things legally, not trample peoples' rights. This is absolutely not a case where the end justifies the means. They illegally searched the garbage can and illegally entered the house. Yes, the guy got his bag back, but any charges in this case should be DOA thanks to the officers' crimes.

[@XemnasKaijin]

@@hbk314 The garbage can search is questionable at best, lawful at the least. The trash cans are so close to the curb that a court would probably side with the officers on them being able to search the garbage. Outside of that - securing the home and obtaining a warrant was on the up and up. These two thugs got what they deserved and the victim got his bag back. Justice served.

[@hbk314]

@Jonathan Berroa-Silfa You don't get to enter and look around in the house prior to obtaining the warrant. If anything from the garbage can or walk through of the home was used to apply for the warrant, the whole case should be dead. What else did they have? An Airpod signal isn't probable cause in itself. I've seen police believe someone's missing phone was in a vehicle in a parking lot because the building the owner dropped it in was blocking GPS signal. The cell tower data happened to place the dot on a vehicle outside. The trash cans were clearly right against the house, and there's no rational comparison to be made to cans placed out at the curb for garbage collection.

[@Black_Blow_Fly]

If you watch the full video she threatened the officer’s family. Leaving this out is extremely misleading and irresponsible reporting.

[@whyisblue923taken]

Yeah. I hate cops, but they did good this time.

[@dizzydinonysius]

No she didn't. Why exaggerate? She said she "hoped" his wife... It doesn't even qualify as a "veiled threat". Your comment is extremely misleading and irresponsible. Besides, it was brought to your attention because it was included and he even highlighted it! So WTF are you complaining about? Maybe you'd save yourself some embarrassment sticking to children games or at least spend some time on comprehension.

[@Black_Blow_Fly]

@@dizzydinonysius you’re full of sh t. ATA edited the original video leaving out quite a lot of important details.

[@MisterRawgers]

The owner of this channel has done a great job misleading people and giving out grades that make zero sense. Dudes in way over his head and just coasting at this point.

[@linkingwithnaz1295]

This channel will leave things out or make weird assertions sometimes. This is one of those cases.

[@LaneBee]

to be fair, the brother gave them permission to go into the house and she has no right to intervene since it isn't her house. While she was screaming at them, he said what sounded like 'just go in and check"

[@U2B_Viewer]

I seen this video when it was originally released. I thought it then, and I thought the same now. The sister knows exactly what is going on with the theft. She probably got her brother wrapped up in her crap 😕

[@WiscoDbo]

Just did a little sloothing on the wisconsin access court system. Turns out she has a bit of a history with retail theft, harassment, violating terms of restraining, tresspassing, and destruction of private property. Don't move to Wausau folks.

[@jf8138]

They are both in it together, the brother is NOT disabled and fully knows what is going on, too.

[@michaelmartin4816]

That's why she was so quick to pull into the driveway & starts to interfere! She didn't want the officers stumbling on to her little operation!

[@dionbomers1312]

horrible of her to say she wishes the officers wife gets r*ped😔

[@Man-vs-Metal]

I'm ok with someone getting a quick pop in the mouth for saying that.

[@milesdyson5211]

But she's Black they can do no wrong or your a racist.

[@poisonduckee]

Odds are the cop will probably fulfill that wish at some point in their marriage.

[@poisonduckee]

​@@milesdyson5211 you should delete this comment. It's stupid.

[@SaltyPancakesJrThe2nd]

@@poisonduckee You’re saying it’s more likely than not that the cop is going to rape his own wife? I highly doubt it, we have no reason to believe he’s a rapist, that’s a bit extreme lmao

[@Denkar11]

One of the best parts of living in a state with legalized marijuana laws is that the police can't use the old 'I smelled weed' statement to justify search warrants.

[@Infamous-gu9ht]

Unless you're in your car

[@Yoda_Saint_Cloud]

EXACTLY!

[@Yoda_Saint_Cloud]

@@Infamous-gu9hthow do you think I get my legally obtained marijuana from the dispensary to my house? How do I transport it from my house to a friends house for a cookout? It’s in my car. That “smells like weed” shit doesn’t work in states that legalized it. Yeah, it smells like weed, because I have weed.

[@mrfunnylookinhayes9088]

This is why Minnesota just passed it. Because they was only arresting black people for just this.

[@Infamous-gu9ht]

@@Yoda_Saint_Cloud it has to be in a sealed dispensary container. They don't smell when they are sealed

[@TheSilentCheetah]

Despite the legality of their seach of his trash, it's quite possible the reason why the sister was so defensive was because she didn't want the officers discovering the trashed bags of other victims. Her brother has clearly done this to a fair amount of people to have it stacking up in the trash. And the fact she mentioned the bathroom and it sounded like she specifically didn’t want that area searched, tells me she may even be helping him. Or perhaps, she's the mastermind behind everything and her brother is more just a witness and provides a base of operation for her crimes. Either way, the bag was eventually found in the bathroom. So one or both of them are into shady business.

[@alex86fire]

Especially since the brother also mentioned something about laundry (indicating that maybe that was the one room he didn't want the police officers to check).

[@dizzy1369]

The sister just made things worse and escalated immediately with her hostile demeanor.

[@JordanHarris]

To be fair they didn't have permission to be in his house, and she didn't break any laws.

[@JordanHarris]

Durrrrrr

[@Manche-De-Pelle]

she tried to protect her brother from the one who are suppopsed to protect the citizen ... The cops illigaly search the property of her brother. What you would have done in her position ... probably swallow the whole boots ???

[@codrelif]

They stole the guys backpack. Give me a break.

[@zazuch]

Just because someone may have committed a crime does not mean police get a free pass to violate your rights. This is a precedent you don't want to set as it would get abused. They already abuse peoples rights we dont need them to feel even more free to do so.

[@piper998877]

Agreed, but what if they hadn't and it was actually next door at the neighbors. Would you be okay if cops searched your house like that?

[@ChristopherBurtraw]

​@Digital Soldier ah, so let's let them search any house for any reason if we "have nothing to hide". That's not how things work in a civilized society.

[@agrape2887]

​it was not a "may have" He did steal ot and it was found there, the airtag is very much not a "may have"

[@sarajuanaict]

​@digitalsoldier2795I would never let the pigs search my house without a warrant that's ridiculous

[@neoclassic09]

Maybe if they stopped stealing things they wouldn't have to deal with this

[@jamescordes8673]

Right. Ironic of the sister to tell the cops not to break the law.

[@carryeveryday910]

Sister was definitely in on it. Trash can full of bags screams a larger operation even if just between the 2 of them. The fact that she was so angry demonstrates she likely was in on it seeing as adults don’t behave that way especially when they aren’t guilty of anything though some people are terrible at controlling their emotions. I think a court would likely find searching the cans as justifiable due to the air tag popping on the house and the fact that they were more or less readily accessible from the side of the house same way a driveway is an invitation for the public to come up and knock on your door etc. Glad the complainant got his stuff back.

[@TrekBeatTK]

I actually think the search of the trash was legal. Those look like city-issued bins, which means they are property of the city. They didn’t search through anything bagged, only opened a lid.

[@revamp8835]

It’s tragic a dedicated law channel doesn’t know the law. Law school 101 - which I took, they teach you trash / recycle bins are excluded from needing a warrant because whatever is in there is abandoned property willingly put in there to be thrown away.

[@vengeance1]

Plus the bin was overflowing, you could see a purse sticking out without even needing to open it first. That alone is probable cause to investigate.

[@whyisblue923taken]

@@revamp8835 It depends on the location. Most of the time, you can search it when it is a certain distance from the home, where it can be collected. It doesn't matter here anyway because the purses were seen before fully opening the bins. They had enough reasonable suspicion.

[@revamp8835]

@@whyisblue923taken No matter where it is , when you put something in the trash you’re abandoning it and you want it gone. It’s not curtilage like a shed near your home like others tried to say

[@AW-xg4zn]

@@revamp8835 You can't go on someone's property to search their trash can without a warrant, which is exactly what they did here. You also can't claim you smell weed to produce probable cause for a search of someone's home, which the officer also apparently did here. This is some gross misconduct you're willing to defend here. I can only hope some day you meet some cops who feel the same way about rights and laws as you do.

[@nickmuaythaiandfitness]

The lady only escalated things. She should have been mad at her brother for being involved.

[@SomeGuy.with.a.Beard93]

There’s people in the comments suggesting that she was the one doing the legwork and the brother was emptying bag and tossing the evidence.

[@christopheraaron8299]

It's possible the sister stole the bag and knew it was inside the house.

[@MrPbhuh]

Pretty sure its the job of the cops to deescalate, dealing with people who get agitated is not too much to ask for from people who are paid by the public. Especially when it isn't clear if they are violating the constitution

[@KebabMusicLtd]

We don't know for certain that either of these people were involved. Perhaps all those items were stolen by a person or persons unknown and that person(s) were using this residence as a dumping ground. The trash can's outside, so anyone in the vicinity could have been responsible. It seems very strange that these two would steal so many items and then 'dump' them in their own trash-can. Best to use the trash-can of that unsuspecting guy a couple of doors over. Maybe his spicy sister gave someone the big-elbow and they want to get even.

[@S0L12D3]

She probably wasn’t mad at her brother cause she knows they steal stuff. She was only mad at the cops cause she knew they got caught this time….

[@w211100]

That girl knows everything that her brother doing ( and might work with him on it ) Could you imagine that you get ur stuff stolen and these trash bags act like they are victims I was upset 😡 while watching this video

[@MikeS309]

She is probably the main one doing the stealing.

[@PaxHeadroom]

Her brother might genuinely be uninvolved

[@paulmidsussex3409]

I love that she is completely unembarrassed that her brother is either a thief or someone handles stolen property.

[@alanwoodwind5265]

Older brother or dad is a profilic abuser and criminal too.

[@TheLegenDacster]

Any psychologist will tell you that she is complicit as hell and came over in despair to try to save the day but that was a terrible decision.

[@ra2186]

Are you a psychologist?

[@pete5516]

Hi, quick English lesson here: psychologist doesn’t mean the same thing as mind reader. Hope you understand English a little better now

[@bucks_in_6]

Seriously, how can Audit the Audit possibly defend her?

[@michaelmartin4816]

Yeah, I just commented on how this channel has gone downhill! How the hell are they going to give her a "C" with how she was behaving? Unreal!

[@godrifle]

He's trying to be unbiased. I don't like how he gives a no grade to a lot of people given the slightest impairment, but he is grading her based on her ability to navigate the police encounter. She knew some of her rights, but didn't tell her brother to just go inside and close the door. He can't give her an F for being a criminal because they're innocent until proven guilty.

[@georgemaragos2378]

HI - I believe his grading is based on the persons actions in accordance with the law Did she just express her concerns and give her brother advise - Yes - Is that illegal - No Did the officer have 100% legal right to search the trash - maybe but the needle is closer to maybe not Is there something about "objects in plain sight" - the bins were not hidden Mario gave them permission to enter once or twice I think Mario is easily lead by others or at least has high regard for his sisters advice Many have commented she was well aware of what was in the bin and dont let police in the house because she was aware the backpack was there - i dont know how involved she is

[@Figgy20000]

@@godrifle Sorry to AITA but getting up less than a foot from an officers face while screaming and making intimidating hand gestures for the sole purpose of stopping them from entering the property is 10000000000% resisting. That is going far above and beyond her 1st amendment rights, they didn't arrest her until she was literally stopping them from entering the property after the owner had already given permission. She absolutely knew what was going on and the officers had every right to arrest her in order to properly secure the house. Extremely biased with this one

[@sandphoenix4296]

Even animals have rights

[@gcDaydays]

Sister gets an F, she definitely knew about the thieving going on in that home. Guilty people often behave like she did. The ping alone should be justification enough for law enforcement to at least be able to obtain said item if not to search the home with that goal in mind. I sincerely doubt the accused had nothing to do with the theft considering the trash is filled with purses and wallets. Rate the officers whatever but thieves get absolutely zero sympathy and most certainly do not get get a freakin C-.

[@HyogaX9]

knew? she was most likely the brains of the operation!

[@peppipoohductionswakashunt3157]

Agree, thieves are my most hated parasites on this planet.

[@kotlolish]

She might be but that's for the court to decide. In reality... we gotta be transparent. If she gets a F for shouting at police and not breaking any rights.... despite being a criminal. Then police can use that logic when you raise your voice in frustration due to a police officer trying to squash your rights. The police conduct was questionable... and remember.. ATA rates things acordance to what happens in the situation.. not the outcome. At that moment the police had NO SOLID EVIDENCE of thefts at arrival. A bin with wallets isn't "SOLID" either.. it's STRONG CIRCUMENSTATIONAL and raises "Reasonable suspect" She probably knew all of it.. but that's not how the law should work. There is another case where an "Airtag" was used to raid an old lady's house with SWAT where she was innocent. The reason being, the airtag was tied to weapons and a stolen car. So SWAT raided the house despite not confirming the weapons or stolen car being there and the AIRTAG had a range of 5 houses.. the old lady was the most "Center" of it. So she gets a C-, cause if we don't give "suspected criminals" the same right as "suspected innocent people" then Police will use it against you to make a false arrest cause "you happen to be like the "suspected criminal" Though I do like to add she is a repeated offender and if someone of the police knew who she was.. then it changes everything.

[@andrewfowlkes3838]

@@kotlolish Did you miss the part where she literally tried to push past the cops to get inside when they said they were gonna clear the residence? Did you miss the part where she resisted by pulling away when they attempted to put her in the car? I swear it’s like you people are always against the cops and you’ll ignore the misbehavior of the citizens they deal with…

[@peoplez129]

@@kotlolish Since there was tracking pin pointing the home, it could be said that this was an active crime in progress, which doesn't require a warrant. No different than if a thief runs into a home. The modifier is the fact that a crime was reported, and a GPS signal pin pointed where the criminal went. No different than a guy on the street pointing to a house and saying "The bad guy went in there!". That's probable cause enough for a warrantless search. On top of that, the police also had other probable cause: The purses/bags sticking out of the trash. Since they are evidence of a potential crime, in plain view, that is probable cause that allows them to search the trash without a warrant.

[@themanofjusticetheladyofju9991]

She seems to be the person that is responsible for all the theft going on. Her behavior screams guilty guilty guilty. I hope she finds a better way to make money and speak on this to help others stay away from this behavior.

[@finneyp]

“In the face of verbal challenges to police action, officers must respond with restraint” They’ve got confused here - they’ve actually responded with ‘restraints’.

[@jerbwood]

This guy with the backpack is smart and I'm glad he got his stuff back. As for Mario, he is a thief and a loser. Hope he spends some time in jail and learns his lesson. As for the sister. Only a moron would come to a house with their boyfriend with a warrant. She basically asked for all this.

[@TheFantasticFordy]

kind of annoyed that ATA just took her word for it that she "was driving past" lol, that was an obvious lie. but it doesn't really matter

[@TheFantasticFordy]

@@UltimaBahamutZero her charges were already upheld and i'm sure his will be too

[@DarrylJenks7454]

@@UltimaBahamutZero at least the kid got his bag back from her thief brother.

[@RedboneUnincorporated]

No criticism for the cops, you absolute fktrd.

[@RedboneUnincorporated]

​@kooladbestrapper way to miss all the points.

[@bigslurpee2078]

She said she hoped the cop's wife gets raped then gets surprised when he wants to try and hit her with a charge?

[@KazutoKirigaya-nk1mq]

Freedom of speech

[@KRITORISS]

@@KazutoKirigaya-nk1mq1A has limits....you cannot threaten and cannot yell fire in theater or bomb on plane...etc....try again

[@KingInky13]

"I'm the only one here and I know what's in this house and there's definitely no backpack in here". Yeah, I'm not waiting for a jury to decide whether he's guilty or not.

[@nickoblicko7046]

I remember this! They found the bag and documents. Would have thought that was significant.

[@Pellerinen]

I might be wrong, but isn't the police procedure there just because illegally found evidence isn't admissable in court, so while you do make an arrest, you make it impossible to get a conviction?

[@tcelltech2518]

​@Pellerinen They didn't illegally find anything, they found stolen goods in their trash can, any judge would grant entry after finding that...

[@filipe.sm31]

​@@tcelltech2518 but they should've waited the judge to grant it. They just said they "smelled weed" and entered the house. That was wrong and could lead to a mistrial

[@kingkerry123]

@@filipe.sm31 They only entered the house to secure it, which they are allowed to do. Secure and search are not the same thing.They HAVE to secure the house (ensure there are no other occupants) for their safety and forthe integrity of an search - should they be able to get the warrant.

[@lisawagner6076]

@@Pellerinen I think the return of the back pack with the important documents and things in it, was more what they wanted here. Not necessarily a conviction for anything.

[@baldisaerodynamic9692]

she flipped out so fast and so hard, while her brother remained calm, tells me she was involved and is possibly a criminal herself by the way she went nuts. innocent people dont charge at cops like a rabid dog. if she was there to defend her brother, she would have been passionate but not running towards the house like that. she would have recorded, said her peace, been articulate and then sued for a payday. she knew what was going on and was just as guilty. she had something to lose, she was more worried about herself

[@dale117]

Some of y'all fail to realize that securing a house is not the same thing as searching a house. When a suspect tells you they are alone in their house, they may be lying.

[@rdman123]

This feels like a rare miss from ATA. The Cops didn't even use the trash as a reason to enter the home, so fruit from the poisonous tree doesn't apply and ATA spend more of the time talking about why they shouldn't look in the trash then anything else. Also when saying the sister didn't try to enter the home ATA literally showed her trying repeatedly to do so and push at the officers. Seems like pretty textbook interfering with officers trying to do their jobs. I'm no fan of police but this interaction ended with no one hurt, a victims getting their stuff back, and charges for a criminal (pending trail). Seems like a pretty good outcome to me.

[@utubepunk]

Well there's gray area when it comes to searching the garbage like they did. Seems like the police lied about smelling weed as a CYA insurance policy.

[@phukyerpheefees]

A "rare" miss. ATA routinely misgrades officers and civilians.

[@seanachack6249]

@@phukyerpheefees I disagree. I think he does a good job.

[@mikehannigan848]

@@utubepunk that "gray area" has been settled in court as a cop can search the garbage without a warrant.

[@phukyerpheefees]

@@utubepunk The trashcan lid was held partly open by plainly visible purses. Combine that with the gps ping from the stolen bag and there is no grey area.

[@JayzeVo17]

These thieves are probably the least sympathetic "victims" of police rights violations in the entire history of this channel.

[@wadestanton]

victim blamer

[@SgtLion]

Ah yes, so clearly guilty that the prosecution seems to be ready to drop the entire thing to a $50 fine. Doesn't seem so clear cut.

[@roro-jj1fv]

e cops (criminals of police) overstepped big. Time The gabage cans were outside & anyone could put stuff in them .. also the cop has no evidence putting bag in his hand anyone could have put it in there .... also if cop was allowed in house to secure for warrant it was for bag anything else is fruit of poisonous tree including the paraphernalia grant if in plain site it would be cool IF they waited for the warrant but they did not

[@faramund9865]

Doesn't mean that they don't have rights.

[@Bacteriophagebs]

Which serves to show the other side of why police need to respect people's rights, because if their basis for the warrant is deemed a violation, all of that evidence is inadmissible and they have no case. Violating rights harasses the innocent and lets the guilty go free. Police should just _never_ do it.

[@bloodhawk403]

To be honest I think the commentary on this episode was lacking. There are huge parts that ATA glosses over that would definitely impact this case. The admission of guilt, the trash filled with empty purses, and the GPS would be incredibly hard to beat in court and I think would more than meet the criteria for most of what they did. And the sister made all this worse and defiantly should be arrested, if I walked into a random crime scene acting like this I too would be arrested.

[@Figgy20000]

AITA showing their bias here. Officers did everything 100% correct and by the book. Not only that but the victim was fully recovered. AITA cares a lot more about the criminals rights which weren't broken in any shape or form rather than the actual victim who got his stuff recovered. I seriously want an answer from AITA how the officers could have done anything in his eyes to get an A+ and still recover the victims property and arrest these criminals. Oh right nothing because of his extreme bias and hatred towards officers doing their job the correct way like they did here.

[@matthewharvey3556]

@@Figgy20000 Seems like the video was very clear. They searched the garbage without permission or a warrant, likely jeopardizing the whole case since the evidence of the discarded purses would get thrown out. ALL these cops had to do was seek a search warrant in the first place and just WAIT for it. Also, what does the “I” in AITA stand for? What in “Audit The Audit” does the “I” stand for?

[@MisterRawgers]

@@matthewharvey3556 don’t cut yourself on that tinfoil 😂

[@YashayahTheAlmighty]

​@@Figgy20000good government boy good boy

[@ivand0007]

​@@tempusername-l5dWhat was wrong or illegal they did? They didn't search the property. The looked around to identify suspects and the bag was in plain view.

[@JoshHaynesguitar]

“Stop breaking laws and this would be a lot simpler” says the girl defending her brother who broke the law by stealing someone’s property. Interesting.

[@WoodlandT]

I watched this whole encounter previously and I think the actions of the officers were entirely justified. I was all set to be on the side of the arrested parties, but nope. They did their jobs appropriately Edit - It wasn’t apparent that the officers “searched” the cans beyond lifting the lid and looking inside. Considering the visibility of the cans from the street and the evidence of the stolen items indicated by the AirTag data, I think this was completely justified

[@mastacordone]

even if they contested the search i highly doubt that the courts would consider trash cans on the side of your house unprotected by a fence or anything to have a reasonble expectation of privacy.

[@SeeLifeBro]

I'm picturing this exact scenario in California. The California cops would have left immediately and said sorry nothing can be done. It really is the wild west out here. Glad the theif got caught.

[@yunofun]

Only in the larger cities. Rural areas and smaller cities the cops may still show up. Same is true in WI. If this were to happen in Milwaukee they probably would have told the guy to come to the nearest precinct and fill out a report and been the end of it.

[@iamvictorperez1482]

In Hellifornia, from my experience, most police seem to be very Cautious when it comes to dealing with possible suspects that are black

[@whyisblue923taken]

Yep. I had some cops say they can't search someone in the same house even though he had been stealing from people for weeks. He stole someone's socks and put them in his shoes, clearly visible. They let him steal hundreds of dollars of stuff.

[@mbarrett99]

The cops had probable cause to get a warrant. Maybe California handles search warrants differently from Wisconsin.

[@RumitheBartender]

That’s true. I tagged a phone like that knew where it was. It was a whole county over. The cops from where it was stolen said it’s the problem of where it’s at now. And the cops from the city where the phone was pinging said it wasn’t their problem. I got both of them on the phone and they still did nothing. It was in a bad part of town too and the cops still chose to not do anything . What’s worse is the cops said we can’t do anything after i showed them video evidence of it being stolen and the pinging location. I dislike cops.

[@DaemonRunner]

When she said "Stop breaking the law and it will be simpler" Well damn lady, how about your brother stop stealing purses and bags, and it would be simpler.

[@dishonoredundead]

I know you're trying to take a side here, but you kind of inadvertently proved how they are both wrong. Only, one is going to be held accountable and go to jail. Hopefully. The other is the government, who are immune to laws and get to write the narratives of what you see and hear. She had a great point, they should both just stop BREAKING THE LAW A55H0le! It's a Liar Liar reference, I'm not calling anyone names. Also I hope dude got his bag back, but I'm guessing whatever was in he wanted is probably gone.

[@ItIsReallyRBS]

She wasn't defending her brother, she set him up! She needs to shut up. She deserved all of this.

[@aaronsouthard8366]

Searching the garbage outside of the home or even placed an an unenclosed porch is permissable by SCOTUS decisions and something you have discussed in other videos as acceptable and fine, but here you seem to waffle and I'm not sure why.

[@TheSimba86]

it is weird how reluctant he seems to be to say anything negative about the thieves

[@baldisaerodynamic9692]

@@TheSimba86 there was a bias here against cops. maybe its that BS DEI crap these days....the suspects would fall under that crap.

[@richardbaker308]

​​@@TheSimba86 noticed that too. Guess the police just happened to find the guys backpack and belongings like gee how'd they get there...

[@I.____.....__...__]

WTF makes garbage-bins so special? What if it was a shed without a lock? What about an open window? What if the garbage-bin isn't being used for garbage at all but just a generic storage-container? WTF should ANY closed container on PRIVATE property be allowed to be searched? 🤨 That is NOT plain-view and cops are NOT allowed to open it to search, even if it's a garbage-bin.

[@aaronsouthard8366]

@@I.____.....__...__ garbage bins are considered trash and discarded, if not within an enclosed place (even if its a screened in porch with a storm door it counts as enclosed.) Then it is fair game. The courts have ruled in almost every case concerning this that . . . well essentially another mans trash is another mans treasure. If a homeless man takes your old shoes out of your garbage can it isnt stealing. You're showing the world you dont want these goods any more and left them in an accessible place. Same thing with cops searching the trash. You have discarded the items and left them out. Regarding your other points of contention. Shed with no locked door? They need a warrant or exigent circumstances (hear screaming, crying, or other form of distress etc from inside is one example thereof) to go in, or the guys permission. The Windows, cant go in them but you can *look* all day long. If contraband is left in (very important term here) "plain view" and the officer can see said item without aid then its valid. This can be pushed to limits like say.... Police believe a diamond necklace that was stolen is in this dresser somewhere, they dont have permission to look through it and the warrant isnt signed yet. They can in the meantime look over, under around it and behind it as long as they don't manipulate it (move it). So short cop A says "hey partner I cannot see on top of this thing can you lift me up?" "Sure" "holy shit theres the necklace sitting on top." They found it with a simple visual search. This can be extended to plain feel as well. "Is that a pistol in ypur pocket or are you just happy to see me?"

[@liamlynch2115]

I give the cops a B+. Taking a peek in an outdoor can is common sense and turned up evidence. The female probably stole these items with the brother. No tears for her.

[@wadestanton]

Getting a warrant makes common law

[@williamkelley1971]

A lot of things are common sense in investigations. That doesn’t mean they’re allowed to do them. There are limitations on what cops can do without warrants for a reason.

[@liamlynch2115]

@@wadestanton Exigent circumstances

[@wadestanton]

@@liamlynch2115 criminal intent

[@PreppenWolfLLC]

Her behavior in the entire video I believe supports the detainment. And she constantly double and tripled down after detainment. At one point an officer attempts to have a conversation with her repeatedly and she just continues yelling, not allowing dialog. If she had remained calm and stationary outside, she would have a defense.

[@jeffshackleford3152]

Yes, because officers are known to be considerate of people who they have arrested.

[@Thydeepestfear]

@@jeffshackleford3152 some are, some aren’t.

[@jonathanclarkson7379]

Well, its not on the citizen to remain calm in situations where police are violating people's 4th amendment rights, its on the police to not violate people's rights.

[@hdlc4635]

You would've done well and prospered in Germany from 1933 until the liberation in 1945.

[@jeffshackleford3152]

@@hdlc4635 thanks bro, glad to know I would have done well in that time, in your opinion

[@TDD-uk8pf]

She want’s to call “her” lawyer to protect her brother?

[@TheSimba86]

kinda with the cops on this one, the dude had a trashcan full of stolen purses and bags and they found stolen stuff inside the house. very deceptive and clickbait title on your part

[@williamkelley1971]

Culpability of a suspect is irrelevant to due process.

[@jameschristensen1055]

Miss Camacho charged across the threshold at the officer, such that he had to put a hand on her to ward her off. It's hard to see that as anything other than unambiguous 'obstruction'.

[@keithyoungs9435]

The problem is that she charged towards them.

[@rubenguirado4766]

My brother wouldn't go around stealing property, but if he did, I sure as hell wouldn't defend him, this dude needs the consequences, anything else is enabling very bad behavior.

[@Phla58]

What a well spoken young lady. I'm sure she had nothing to do with any of the purses found in the garbage apart from the bag the officers were there for.

[@mesmartgnome]

It can be argued that her attempted entry to the home could be interfering with official duties. They had RAS with the air tag and the trash can full of wallets and purses. As they were their for investigative purposes for stolen property, it’s doubtful a court would consider the search of the trash a fourth amendment violation.

[@meemzzyj4894]

RAS gives you permission for a pat down of a suspect you reasonably believe is armed. You generally need a warrant to conduct a search void certain exceptions.

[@celebratelife2940]

What’s crazy is the guy actually stole the bag

[@JoJo-ie8sl]

California vs. Greenwood--decided by the Supreme Court--says "a person does not have a reasonable expectation of privacy in their trash. As such, the Fourth Amendment does not prohibit law enforcement from a warrantless search and seizure of garbage." If the garbage man take your trash and go through it, so can the police.

[@Not_Always]

Which would be true if the trash can is located on the street, not up against your home where it is clear you aren't throwing away the contents.

[@CuppaGi]

I wanted to see her face when she was told they found the stolen bag in his bathroom.

[@maxsinventions8913]

She knew.

[@whyisblue923taken]

She already knew. She yells about the bathroom when she gets taken away. I believe she is the thief and he was unaware because he was stoned.

[@andrewall411]

She was awfully upset about the trash. She may have something to do with it too. I get the thought because it’s near the house but I also gotta think maybe reasonable suspicion that the bag may have been ditched after being emptied.

[@jamescordes8673]

Ironic of her to tell the cops to not break the law.

[@MaryCoster-Mullen]

Perfect observation

[@kaileerenae9719]

I’m not sure that you actually watched the whole video if you are giving her a C. She was interfering as well as threatening to kill the officers if she saw them on the street and saying she hoped his wife gets raped. That’s absolutely despicable.

[@funkeypunk2005]

Man I wish all my items had gps ping. Good for him for taking initiative on getting his bag back.

[@runeheadah]

No you don't. Any "government agency" can just call up crApple and demand that location information and crApple will happily give it up without a fight, or they might even just charge money for it. A warrant is required, except for when crApple doesn't care/would rather "play nice" with the "government". Yeah crApple advertises themselves to be so good with privacy, but the truth of what they do is the opposite. Gurgle does the same thing too.

[@Bacteriophagebs]

It's not a useful as people think. Notice how the guy said it was jumping between houses. Most of the time a GPS gives an area where the tracked object is, not a precise location. People think the center of that area is the location, but it's not. I worked for a cell phone company for 10 years and and had to explain this hundreds of times to both customers and police. If the trash hadn't been full of incriminating evidence or if that evidence had been in trash bags, or if the cops hadn't checked the trash at all, they'd never have been able to get a warrant from that GPS alone because it didn't specifically show the tracker as being in that house.

[@runeheadah]

@@Bacteriophagebs Airtags don't have GPS. They use BLE (bluetooth low energy) to connect to other people's crApple devices (even ones that are "turned off" (yes, crApple devices continue running in "airtag" mode even when "turned off", this is the crApple Mesh Network)) and triangulate (BLE can measure direction and distance) their position based on those other devices that do have their own precise position recorded. So in this case this guy's airtag was using his own crApple phone and even the perp's crApple phone (if he had one) to determine and report its location. The more crApple devices close by the more accurate the position is.

[@Bacteriophagebs]

@@runeheadah And how do the Apple devices locate themselves and therefore the Airtag? GPS. Airtags have an accuracy of 800 feet outdoors. GPS is usually more accurate than that, but the Airtag is using GPS secondhand. When the tag is inside a house and the phone is outside, the phone might not even be getting the bluetooth signal at all. You're right that the brother's own phone might have been the one locating the Airtag, because it's entirely possible it was the only one in range due to the bag being inside a bathroom. Which means the location would be based entirely on the GPS of that one device, with the inaccuracy problems I described.

[@runeheadah]

@@Bacteriophagebs Absolutely, I was just making it clear to everyone how they worked. Most people don't understand how their own devices are always tatlling.

[@JMHall1117]

I normally agree with ATA on 99% of his videos (see how i said "his" and not "their" lol) but i have to disagree with him on this one. The brother was 100% a thief and this may not yet be cofirmed but I believe the sister is in on this scam that he is running. All the empty wallets and purses in the trash bins don't look good for them.

[@TheFantasticFordy]

she clearly rushed over there to try to cause a scene and claimed she was "driving by" lol

[@williamkelley1971]

Whether or not someone actually committed the crime they’re being investigated for is irrelevant to due process.

[@JMHall1117]

@@williamkelley1971 I can agree with you on that, however with the service member telling police the bag contained military information and it showing up on the locator at the individuals house I believe that is enough evidence for “probable cause” and to at least check the trash bins. But, the situation could’ve gone a different direction if the sister hadn’t have shown up and acted the way that she did

[@williamkelley1971]

@@JMHall1117 it did not show up at his house. It showed up in the general area. They tell the sister in the beginning they’re going to check the other houses as well, so they’re not even locked in with him as the suspect.

[@agrape2887]

It was confirmed, they found the guys bag and he got it back

[@milesdyson5211]

She needed to be arrested, interfering with an investigation just to start; also Disturbing the peace, and borderline domestic violence. Running her mouth, yelling and calling them names didn't help either. She should have been rated a D for her conduct, she escalated the situation and got herself arrested.

[@Yoda_Saint_Cloud]

Domestic violence? Which one of the people that she lives with or is related to did she even come close to assaulting?? 😂😂😂

[@milesdyson5211]

@@Yoda_Saint_Cloud Disturbing the peace, inciting violence and like I said Bordine Domestic Violence when she was yelling and screaming and trying to enter a home that wasn't hers. She needs anger management classes for sure

[@pothead9963]

so gps pinged the house, the trash was filled with discarded purses/bags, and they ended up finding the backpack in the house. So they did take that shit and i hope that guy got all his documentation back. They should also look to see if any of those bags had identifying material in it to see it they were also stolen. Seeing as the initial cause for the cops being caused was a stolen bag i could see the follow up on investigating everything they found in that trash can. its wild how she's acting like the cops cops are just targeting her brothers place for no reason despite being told about the situation. Someone could argue she was covering for him and/or had knowledge of the missing gear or knowledge of the other discarded property in the trash, hence her defensiveness.

[@KRITORISS]

I was able to find the case online, ended up in federal courts because of the military ID’s etc, ended up with 151 months and 5 years supervision afterwards. Can you say oops 😂😂😂😂

[@alanwoodwind5265]

You got a link for it?

[@KRITORISS]

quit being lazy, the internet is your friend.....@@alanwoodwind5265