Is Bryan Kohberger Guilty? | Analysis of Probable Cause Affidavit in Idaho Quadruple Murder Case

This video answers the question: Can I analyze the probable cause affidavit in the case of Bryan Christopher Kohberger?
Support Dr. Grande on Patreon: / drgrande
Subscribe to the Bella Grande Media Podcast: / @bellagrandemedia
Dr. Grande’s book Harm Reduction:
www.amazon.com/Harm-Reduction...
Dr. Grande's book Psychology of Notorious Serial Killers: www.amazon.com/Psychology-Not...
Check out Dr. Grande’s merchandise at: teespring.com/stores/dr-grand...
References:
www.nytimes.com/interactive/2...
www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/...
www.idahostatesman.com/news/l...
www.cbsnews.com/news/bryan-ko...
www.dailymail.co.uk/news/arti...
www.foxnews.com/us/idaho-murd...

[@shawngallo4429]

I was almost killed when I was 28. I was hiding under a blanket and he was standing right over me but did not see me. I thought I was going to be strangled to death. My heart was beating so load I could not hear anything. When you think your going to be attacked or die no one knows how they will react until it happens to them.

[@byrontendo]

No you weren’t.

[@chrismillerfitness]

Shut up this about you

[@VeeAmericanEagle]

Not saying you’re lying but he couldn’t see the printed body under the cover?

[@yome6132]

@@byrontendo LMAOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

[@wangcockdickspecker622]

Yeah you just made this up under a blanky😂

[@TheSouthIsHot]

"If Bryan is the killer, his motive was based on obsession, revenge, and/or sexual domination, not because he was trying to plan the perfect murder." I agree completely, Dr. Grande.

[@robertotamesis1783]

Wasn't Bryan a part time security guard? , Why didn't he bring a gun. Unless the security agency suspected there something wrong in his mind.?🤔🤪

[@PistolP33]

Yes; too many mistakes. He tried to feebly cover his tracks and a little planning, but all he had to do was: Keep his cell at home Park a mile or so from the scene. He does jog, so he's in shape Scour the rooms to retrieve left-behind evidence Finish off the witness if he in fact saw her Any half-wit could figure this out. The ONLY thing missing that we're oblivious to is motive. But the other likely/tight facts could have been avoided.

[@NoSpam1891]

I hope this guy gets a fair trial. Otherwise the arguments will go on for decades. We certainly can't rely on the media for self control.

[@chenal7445]

@@christianveganprincess we don't know that yet. Piquerism is a form of sexual interest, cutting people....

[@BlvckMamba]

@@christianveganprincess It was most definitely sexual in nature.

[@noelnewlon]

Thorough analysis. The female who witnessed the perp leave and failed to call police could have been suffering from "car hood" syndrome: you hear a strange engine noise, yet refuse to investigate, hoping it's not really a problem.

[@ForAncientKingAndElvishLord]

Oh fuck that's what it's called? I suffer from that.

[@brigit.the.seagoat]

“The female” - weird wording

[@spacewalktraveller1]

Car hood syndrome 🤣😂🤣🤣😂

[@hawksnest7527]

Rest In Peace Ethan, Xana, Kaylee and Maddie ♥️you did not deserve what happened to you. 💔

[@tamitatangoto5134]

The Bible tells us that unexpected things happen to all of us. No they didn’t deserve it you’re right. But it wasn’t planned either. I mean it wasn’t planned by God. (Ecclesiastes 9:11,12)

[@karenjohnson5792]

What happened to the dog?

[@karenjohnson5792]

Did he kill dog?

[@flightofthebumblebee9529]

@@tamitatangoto5134 too often people reject God because they think "why did God allow this to happen!". I don't believe it works that way, because I also believe in the Christian Faith and the worst monster alive could find redemption thru God. If that's true then God doesn't "allow" awful things to happen because he gave us free will and I don't see it like God is monitoring our every move all the time. If you're acting in sin, the Lord is probably not in your spirit and soul in the first place. It's very hard to explain and accept but I'm 40 and made tons of mistakes yet it gives me peace to believe it.

[@simonchaddock3694]

@@karenjohnson5792 no he did not not murphy anyway

[@Surge_LaChance]

Please remember that we are only being told what we're allowed to know. There's more to be revealed.

[@DrLuke49]

That smile @1:37 of the video says it all 😳

[@thefirstsurvivor]

@@DrLuke49 the "no teeth" smile is a universal sign of crazy

[@louniece1650]

Good point.

[@TheFireproofWitch]

I'm hoping there's a super logical explanation for DM's non-reaction.

[@louniece1650]

@Paul Thomas They left out a myriad of info.

[@ccooper6343]

Bryan thinking that DM had called the police is one analysis I haven't heard anyone else use for the reason he didn't have the time to Kili her and why he sped away quickly. Thanks for your insight. The surviving room mates are very lucky to be alive, imo.

[@lareeseblaque8303]

I'm wondering who called the police. It was a male voice.

[@jcnewcomb67]

Was it a male that called I thought they said it was a female I thought I herd

[@robertotamesis1783]

Never wake up a sleepwalker in his path while he holds a knife.

[@zach22russell]

1) Dylan hears odd noises 2) Dylan Sees a man with a Black mask 3) Dylan waits 7-8 hours to contact police 4) Victoms Dog found at the crime scene alive 5) 1122 Kingman road "party house" Had multiple noise complaints 6) Multiple people some under age would come in go at the "party house" 7) KZbin videos shows Bodycam footage of police talking to one of the victims about noise complaints 8) police went to the "party house" twice in one night due to noise complaints. 9) Bryan Kohberger asked police if he was the only one that's been arrested Now until further Evidence/facts comes out I find it very odd that Dylan waited hours to contact the police. I find it very odd that the dog didn't bark at the stranger or if the dog would bark nobody in the house herd the dog barking. Now to say Dylan froze up/Shocked for 7-8 hours is pathetic of an excuse. You don't become that mentally checked out bc you saw a man in a skii mask in the middle of the night. (IM NOT BUYING IT) As for the multiple noise complaints and many party goers going in and out of the house I mean sure I get it if you get an noise complaint hear or there but it's unexcusable To have multiple noise complaints and very unexcusable for the police to show up twice in one night. So they obviously had some angry neighbors. You look on Google maps the party house is surrounded by a near by apartment buildings and multiple houses close by in my opinion there may be more then one suspect, the Dylan girl seems very suspect to me and as far as the evidence police has found. Went thru his father's trash and found DNA of what exactly?? Let's say he thru evidence away at his father's home on December 16th the day after him and his father was pulled over in Indiana. If he thru evidence in his father's trash around that time how would they able to gather that DNA qhen the arrest happened December 30th?? Plus the trash gets picked up by the garbage man once a week Plus how would they able to match that DNA in the trash to the DNA in Idaho in such a small amount of time?? Maybe I'm not understanding this Also Dylan see the suspect gets a visual of the suspect where a black mask and bushy eyebrows but yet experts claim it was to dark for the suspect to see Dylan ???

[@airam-sj2172]

Yes, I haven't heard that hypothesis either, until now. Dr. Grande is very inquisitive. That's a very plausible possibility.

[@Drewg351]

I have a 19 year old daughter at college. She's "sticks to herself" a lot. I could 100% see my daughter reacting similarly to DM. Unless my daughter saw something, or heard something criminal, she probably would've done the same thing, closed her door, locked it, and figured "everything is OK. I don't want to make a big deal out of this. It's probably nothing". There's absolutely no way the thought of "maybe 4 of my roommates were just killed and I should call the police" would ever enter her mind. It's easy for all of us, especially older people, to say "what we would've done" now understanding what took place, but that's not fair. This girl was cleared immediately by investigators and was helpful and truthful. Her description was very accurate. If she had anything to do with these murders or to hide, she could've just told police "I was sleeping. I didn't see or hear a thing", but she didn't. She was honest and told the police everything she could. This poor girl will undoubtedly live a lifetime with regret, survivors guilt, and a myriad of other emotions. Give her a break.

[@-._.-KRiS-._.-]

Exactly. Internet trolls would be calling for your daughter to "start taking her meds" after thinking that something like a quadruple stabbing could have just occurred. They'd be doing the same for DM if she had taken immediate action. DM is very clearly in a lose-lose situation here, amid public opinion. I wish her the best and I hope she's able to receive any help she needs.

[@judithgannon5642]

She heard something

[@SerendipityChild]

You've raised a sensible young woman

[@440SPN]

This whole series of events is absolutely horrible. Its so obvious that evil lurks among us in the most ordinary situations of daily life.

[@odonata9838]

I totally agree! This killer existed surrounded by academic and therapeutic experts yet no one had a clue. He was even stopped by law enforcement and he escaped their radar. Though some accuse him of being a "sloppy" criminal, other crime scenes featured more physical evidence but failed to catch the murderer. Many assailants are deluded, believing they are above the law and superior to police. Homicide cases can go "cold" really fast. Families have to fight to continue investigations.

[@rockscousteau]

I just dont see how they did not find blood in the car fronm the victims. Or their blood anywhere. How is that possible

[@MalouDK]

as a female, if I lived in a renowned party house, seeing unknown people at 4am and having a lock on my door, I'd lock myself in regardless of feeling scared or threatened or not. Better safe than sorry

[@ann-mariepaliukenas19]

I agree and I think that’s why she did that.

[@zzz7zzz9]

@@ann-mariepaliukenas19 if that's why, then she would have said that's why. Don't put words in her mouth. She froze, out of fear. Pretty sure that wasn't likely a normal routine for her, in her residence.

[@ann-mariepaliukenas19]

@@zzz7zzz9 I’m not “putting words” in anyone’s mouth.Maybe you should do sone more research

[@ann-mariepaliukenas19]

@@zzz7zzz9 you don’t know what happened,neither do I.Maybe she dud freeze,must have taken her hours to defrost 😳

[@zzz7zzz9]

@@ann-mariepaliukenas19 we know what we've been told. It's been stated that she froze from fear. I doubt that was a nightly occurance, from all the supposed men going in and out of their revolving front door. And we have been told that one was scared of a stalker she had. They aren't letting random dudes enter at all hours if that was the case. There's things we know, things that we've been told. Making up anything else, is pure speculation.

[@HexagonFL]

Thank you, Dr Grande, for being a very reliable and accurate source of information on groundbreaking crime stories. Subscribing to your channel has made it much easier to get the latest information on these cases without having to sift through questionable internet news websites.

[@JesusAlfonsoRafael]

Guess where grande his info from?

[@seandaugherty2033]

That's pathetic I can watch the news and get same information were he got it lame

[@ruthmajor6566]

Kind of a creepy voice and analysis...just saying!

[@69erthx1138]

@@ruthmajor6566 Doc Grande is rather monotonic and demonstrates little if any facial inflections when discussing emotional hot points. The makings of an objective researcher with an impeccable "poker face." 🤓

[@aleshag13]

Not too accurate as he reported Dylan's room was on the 1st floor, per the affidavit, her room was on the SECOND floor. Very important detail to get incorrect.

[@ryanpearson9596]

This case is such a nightmare. Poor kids. I hope family and loved one's can find peace someday.

[@kamo1450]

I know there’s a lot of confusion as to why Dylan reacted the way she did. I’m glad so many people are still sympathizing with her while trying to understand her reactions. Obviously none of us can fully put ourselves in her shoes but we can try. Personally, a few months ago, I was alone in my dorm room as my roommate was away at her boyfriends and our room was unlocked as it always is (we don’t trust ourselves not to lose our keys and it’s really common at our school to leave the door unlocked). I woke up around 4am a random guy barging into my room, wearing all black with a backpack, and standing the middle of our room before he grabbed my roommates laundry basket. I was so sleepy and confused all I did was say “dude… wrong room” and he said “oh shit” and sprinted out, not even closing the door. I closed the door and went back to sleep. Looking back I cannot fathom why I didn’t freak out, especially as a young woman alone. I never reported it and I don’t know why I reacted the way I did. Perhaps it was bc I was barely awake or couldn’t process the danger I was in? I can only dylan being in a similar hard to understand mental state. We do weird things when we can’t process our surroundings. Also, side note, I had been drinking that night and my understanding is Dylan likely was too. Perhaps the drowsiness and alcohol played a part. Her reaction doesn’t make my suspicious of her, more pity than anything, as I am sure she is beating herself up (undeservedly).

[@odonata9838]

💗👍

[@yanaandbear]

Yes; agreed. Also: these are very young people. An older, wiser, more experienced adult would probably react very differently to someone being in his/ her space in the middle of the night.

[@emilymartinko720]

love this comment! seeing people be suspicious and even downright blaming her for not calling the police immediately. the mask part is super depended on context-considering ethan stayed over often, it wasn’t totally unusual for other people to be there at night, and wearing a mask in someone else’s home when visiting isn’t weird at all these days. i think women also often tell themselves they’re overreacting, i think it’s possible she was scared but just pushed it away, because no one would expect such a horrible crime to occur just out of the blue. i just wish people would be more compassionate to the surviving roommates, they’ve just experienced a hugely traumatic event, being kind and understanding towards them is the least we can do

[@MegaDonzee]

Lock your door sweetie, it could save your life.

[@eh1702]

I once fell asleep in my dorm room in daylight on top of the bed while studying. I woke up in the dark, standing, two or three feet from the side of the bed. This was the year that that Danny Rolling guy had murdered students in Florida but was not yet caught. I can’t say to this day whether the soft clunk I heard was right then or a sort of memory of what woke me - but I knew someone had just shut the door to my room. I also had a flashing sensation in my eyes despite the dark. It was a long, narrow room - window behind me, door in front of me, everything totally dark. I had an intense urge to not be trapped at the back of the room and rushed forward. A couple of feet from the door, just in the alcove between door and closet, I passed through what I can only describe as a column of warm air: i do not recall smelling anything, but I knew for certain it was exactly where someone had stood. I even knew it was a make, and how much taller than me. I opened the door and stepped out into the corridor. It was very quiet. Even the drunks and party animals were asleep. All of this took just four or five seconds. A guy coming from the dead end of the corridor a few rooms down. He had to have passed the last room-doors, reached the fire escape door and realised it was alarmed, so he’d turned and was starting back. Still fuddled by sleep, I strode out along the corridor and we both stopped at the only turnoff, where there was a eight angle short corridor to elevator and stairs. He was well muscled: as I looked at his biceps at my face level, I said he didn’t live here, and he politely, blandly, agreed. And just stood there waiting. There followed a bizarre exchange where I offered him reasons why he was on this floor - visiting a friend, got out the elevator in the wrong floor, got lost etc - and he politely declined each one. This was getting a bit Red Riding Hood. He was wearing his tanktop rolled jp almost to his nipples, one of the narcissist fads of that year, showing his daunting sixpack. My brain FINALLY got into gear and I realised I was even standing well within his (much longer) reach. I stepped back, turned and hustled back up the corridor, and he moved almost as fast away towards the elevator & stairs. Cursing myself for doing the stupidest thing ever, back in my room I called the building security. They told me I probably had a bad dream. Nobody came along to check anything. I was a foreigner there. All of us Europeans were already incredulous at the lack of security in the dorms - horrified at the “herd book” at reception - but the locals seemed oblivious to security. I got back from class the following afternoon to find a message from the city (not campus) police, and when I called they asked me to go down there. The officer (or deputy,, I have no idea) an older man, got me to describe what happened and then describe the guy: he had an unusual detail about his face, and when I mentioned it, I saw the officer knew it very well. In the days that followed, half a dozen people told me of their encounters with this guy (how he bumped someone’s desk as he came round the room corner and calmly picked up and put back a pen that rolled off) and half a dozen others told me of other people who had been assaulted by him. He had been prowling for weeks. Remember, the Florida murderer of students had not been detected yet. The university at no time alerted students about this or any other prowler.

[@helenbirdart]

I can imagine Bryan's astonishment when he returned to the scene of his crime and there was zero law enforcement activity. I cannot wrap my head around the lapse of time before 911 was called and the possibility of victim resuscitation had it been sooner than later. Excellent breakdown of this disturbing case Dr Grande. Thank you!

[@tomdallas3690]

He was crazy to go back. Maybe he was looking for the knife sheath, but he made the mistake that a lot of people do....they can't resist the urge to go back. It was really reckless and could have easily led to him being caught if not for the knife sheath.

[@mysterywriter888]

He had moved to Washington in June and had until November 30 to change his registration to Washington from PA. I thought that seemed fishy at first too but it's not actually. He did meticulously clean the car out the police say and wore surgical gloves to empty the garbage at his parent's house and even took their trash to a neighbor's can instead of using his family's garbage can! That says "guilty" to me! No one does that!

[@nickh.4917]

I agree in context, but I have done each of those things. I wash my hands after taking the trash out, but wearing gloves isn’t a stretch. When I clean my car it is top to bottom. And my neighbor and I often use each other’s trash cans. If mine is filled and my neighbor’s isn’t it costs money to add an extra trash bag to mine but nothing if neighbor’s isn’t filled. So, yeah, all together it seems odd, but not individually.

[@4ledki]

Why would he do this weeks after the murder and not immediately.

[@nextinlinetoo]

@@nickh.4917 agree. I would add that a cross-country car trip can leave a vehicle pretty messy. I have not read anywhere that the car was cleaned in PA vs somewhere else. Only that it was meticulously cleaned. If his intention was to destroy evidence, seems like he would not have waited a whole month to clean the car. Perhaps he cleaned the car twice. His movements on Nov 13th include several hours in the Lewiston area. I wonder if that is when he cleaned the car, and perhaps tossed the knife into the Snake River.

[@rubiirae]

Well, consider they just drove across the country and that car looked visibly filthy, I wouldn't put too much emphasis on cleaning the car. He could've cleaned it closer to the date of murder instead of at his parents house, because during the month led up to him driving to PA, he still had to drive that car to school. As for wearing gloves to take the trash out, I do the same because I usually have to double check if I've separated all the recycle items from the regular disposal pile so I wore gloves to prevent my hands from getting dirty, then tying up the bags again and grabbing them to the communal recycling bins. Not defending BK by any means, just saying those two incidents are easily explainable and quite common.

[@burt591]

The DNA on the knife sheath is what says "guilty" to me. There is so much evidence there's no way this guy gets away with it. One of the dumbest crimes I've ever seen, he might as well had taken a selfie while at it

[@willard998]

Hi from Spain Dr. Grande....we love your videos over here!! What a heart-breaking case...my heart goes out to the family members who lost those precious kids...kids that were doing everything right...❤

[@sashachitownvillegas6850]

Love your take on this case, by far the best i've seen thank you for your dedication love your videos ❤️

[@Melza77]

Regarding Dylan’s behaviour - it was stated she froze when she saw the intruder. One can speculate as to her behaviour afterwards but I think it’s important to remember that not all the information was provided in the PCA. We will have to wait for her testimony in the trial to hear the full story.

[@crazyfunnyusavideos88]

I believe her.

[@AshleyLebedev]

My guess is Dylan either went into a freeze state OR she found the guy in the house extremely freaky & scary but was so used to it being a party house full of strangers she didn’t know whole story & just felt a roommate had a huge creepy creep over & chalked it up to that. I don’t think humans can always compute something that bad can happen when they don’t truly think it can happen to them in their life. Biggest question I truly have is why he left her alive. Perhaps he was that exhausted or didn’t see her. It also occurs to me he felt the cops were already called & just tried to exit stealthy but then sped away as soon as out. It’s so creepy - that detail.

[@karenneill9109]

I wonder if he said something to her, maybe told her he would be watching, so don’t call the cops. The affidavit is missing a lot of details, they easily could have left that out. I do think it’s because he found his target, though.

[@CountessKitten]

I believe that Kohberger did not see the roommate when she seen him. That's the only thing that makes sense. Because he wouldn't have left her alive had he seen her.

[@wasteddemise2286]

No matter how you cut it, it doesn’t make sense. He had a knife and was wearing a mask. So why and how would Dylan assume it was all okay?

[@Arizona_lilly]

Come on the moment he leaves all the room mates r dead ??? I would said that first before anything not wait til someone in custody now she still has to go to court to identify him

[@thisdidntagewell]

Drunk out of her mind is all !!

[@gailkelly4651]

Hello Dr Grande ❤️...it is always so interesting to hear your perspective on these cases and your analysis. Thank you Dr Grande ❤️

[@Jms4448]

I have not been getting your videos in my suggestions prior to today. I’m so glad I finally did! I’ve missed your dry humor. It makes these horrific topics bearable

[@PaigeAshleighB]

From the numerous reports of this being a common party house, and two of the girls coming home from the bar + ordering late night food, Dylan likely concluded that the man she ran into was someone who the other 2 girls brought home from the bar or at the very least invited into the home. She locked the door because it was a strange man to her-any woman would do the same. As a roommate she’s privy to her other mates business, probably thought the other was drunk crying over her ex bf (that she had been drunk dialing all night). None of it is far fetched when you put yourself in young naive college aged kids shoes. No one should blaming this girl or questioning her.

[@waynejohnson1786]

Agreed, she didn’t lock her door because she knew her friends were murdered. She locked her door because a stranger was in her home.

[@l.w.paradis2108]

I agree that no one should judge her. The facts concerning what she did that night are facts she provided to law enforcement voluntarily, to help them establish probable cause for Kohberger's arrest. I disagree with normalizing not calling 911. We can suspend judgment about her, without saying it's "understandable" that a person would fail to call 911. You are supposed to call 911. This crime has to be thoroughly investigated. It's tragic for the other roommates, but they have to be investigated. She can decline to be questioned further if this is bad for her mental health, but if a court subpoenas her, she will need to testify.

[@herculesbrofister265]

Exactly. It seems fairly common sense when you have roommates that they're gonna have people over you don't know. But common sense is something conspiracy theorists tend to not have Maybe grande should do an episode on these conspiracy theorists.

[@realty634]

Bryan was incel with no girlfriend and took his frustrations out on those girls

[@zoomer9686]

dude was wearing a mask though, hard to find an innocent reason for that

[@RealTigress]

I’m surprised how many people think he was set up, or just enjoy turning things into conspiracies. This is a solid case. I don’t think he was thinking too clearly while planning this so made all those mistakes. It’s very disturbing & just sad.

[@waynejohnson1786]

Some people are just contrarians

[@robgau2501]

Yeah. People are not used to an open and shut case.

[@taxie27]

He was on a mission...he had planned this, was enraged of the 'haves' and he was one of the 'have nots'...he had issues relating to ANYONE, honestly. He's been 'sick' for a LONG TIME. I believe he became obsessed with killing and getting revenge for whatever he felt, MANY years ago. He tried to fit in, by doing many things, and he snapped.

[@isitoveryet9525]

I see the majority of people just saying he’s innocent until Proven guilty. I notice the true crime community online assumes an arrest automatically equates to guilt, which isn’t always the case

[@deemen7132]

Just cause people like me are giving bryan a fair shake to prove his case Doesn't mean we are conspiracy theorists!

[@janelleyharris5042]

Thank you for more videos Dr. Grande!

[@harpazoseason]

The best. 🌵Thanks for distilling this information. I was waiting for you to do it.

[@barbaralovenvirth8726]

Person not calling police under these circumstances is just beyond belief...

[@shaniceb.5129]

It’s depressing that there’s a possibility one of the victims was still alive but slowly dying.

[@Mom4DVJustice]

And had the police been called a life could have been saved. The roommate not calling the police, even after going through the period of shock and her behavior after are concerning. I feel for the families of the victims who can’t help but wonder if maybe.

[@Marymackthequeenofwack]

@@Mom4DVJustice you sure do hold strong opinions for someone who's likely never been in this situation. You can speculate all you want but until you've been in her shoes and YOU respond how YOU expect her to, you should maybe extend a bit of grace to her situation.

[@Mom4DVJustice]

@@Marymackthequeenofwack please. This will definitely be brought up by the defense, and the jury will want to hear from her. I certainly feel for the 4 victims who lost their lives, and their families. I can empathize certainly with them and how that must feel. Of course the discussion here is speculation. However, these behaviors were indicated on the probable cause documents. Not speculative. Our opinions based on these documents and the details in them. I found her behavior and actions to be concerning prior to those documents coming out by calling her friends to come out before the police, 9 hours after the murders and then when affidavit was released, the additional details were outright shocking. so you can take a seat you’re certainly entitled to your opinion and I’m not going to attack you for them. BTW nobody has been through her situation. Not to judge jury or the attorneys.

[@Marymackthequeenofwack]

@@Mom4DVJustice miss ma'am you can sit your ass on down "it's about how we FEEL"...there's your problem, it's not about feelings it's about FACTS. You expect that you are entitled to your *opinions* dogging out someone who's no doubt drowning in survivors guilt and here come yall in the peanut gallery with these strong opinions based on what? An affidavit statement and your feelings? GTFOH

[@Mom4DVJustice]

@@Marymackthequeenofwack LMAO 🤪

[@natalier7204]

Thanks for giving us a concise overview on what’s going on in this case, Dr G.

[@MV-wn6kc]

Thank you for standing up for the victim who didn't call the police. Some people really do seem to lack the empathy to see the various reasons why someone would react in that way.

[@odonata9838]

💗👍

[@kirbyd0g]

Bravo Dr Grande, you are my "go-to" when analyzing these situations. Well done, as always.

[@eurikia1961]

Waiting for your inputs..always on point, Dr Grande👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾

[@rebekahklemm1210]

Always love your content, Dr. Grande!

[@justnoted2995]

Such a great update, thank you Dr. Grande

[@justanavgguy7802]

A very detailed & complete analysis based on what is known & has been revealed to this point. I appreciate your efforts, Dr. Grande!

[@SprucedandGussied]

Dr Grande, your work is prolific! You make me want to work harder 🙂

[@reconstructingleslie4597]

Dr Grande your voice is calming and reassuring! Thanks for keeping your channel classy ! You’re one of the few I follow on this ❤

[@yukuhana]

Very exhaustive, organized, and comprehensive analysis based on what are available so far. Thank you for the video!

[@80kokoro]

Curious to know if BK returned to the scene the following morning to observe if his crime had been discovered yet or to search the area for his missing knife sheath.

[@marklogan1360]

Yes, he returned in the 9am hour.

[@tablelandstranquillity5008]

So the killer went back to the crime scene after what he done. I wonder why. Scary.

[@rubyoro0]

@@tablelandstranquillity5008 He wanted to know why it hadn’t made the news yet.

[@MicheleEngel]

@@tablelandstranquillity5008 I've heard that it is not at all unusual for a killer to return to the crime scene at least once. And that law enforcement will likely stake out the crime scene afterwards for just that reason.

[@jeanniesmith3356]

He probably thought the cops would have been there already. Obviously he was wrong.

[@penriquez99]

Excellent summary . Thanks for explain so clearly the complexity of this case. Your order and logic is 👌

[@lifeguardpro8379]

You provided some very good insight which I had not considered. You always provide an excellent analysis.

[@lynnMaJeStIc]

Glad I found Your Channel!!! Thank you!

[@petejames1326]

Thanks for the update Dr G i knew this case would be fascinating to you too.

[@PeregrineFisher]

I love hearing your perspective. Thank you for doing these videos.

[@hayleylowe5429]

Thankyou Dr Grande, no waffling just straight to the main points plus sarcasm. Love it.

[@AmrGdr]

Thank you for the quick summary. I was looking for this.

[@betterbee1304]

Strange to think that Bryan Kohberger is less than a mile away from me in the courthouse. Strange that someone on KZbin is talking about the town I live in and the school I attend. In a town this small. This is a surreal time in my life, I'm sure others in the town feel the same way. Thanks Dr. Grande ❤️ I appreciate your calm, objective views on this case. I think it's important work that you do, it can help prevent things like this from happening again by teaching us some warning signs. No one expected this, I'm sure they did feel safe with so many people but it's wise to be cautious.

[@michelletruelove7783]

Stay safe. Crazy world. Prayers to your town for healing n closure

[@lizlee6290]

I grew up in a college town very similar to Moscow, down to population size. Many people have no idea of the safe, small town atmosphere. It's not urban at all. Pretty much everybody has mutual acquaintances (or relatives!). This whole thing is a horrible aberration. Moscow is still a good town, a safe town, no matter what.

[@blackbartthepoet3820]

How I felt when he was caught in the Poconos

[@lawrencemartin24]

I watched a friend spiral towards madness when his meds became unavailable. He lost his longtime job when his employer retired and shut down his business. His job was a lot of his identity. Then he lost his benefits for his prescriptions. Unmedicated his new wife saw how "strange" he had become. She went for divorce. Now unmedicated he spiralled down. He snapped. Took an ax and killed her and her adult daughter and then chickened out on killing himself. He made it in the world without hurting anyone for 50 years. Had he been able to have easy access to meds I think he might have made it. Maybe... Now doing life without parole. His name is Charles Nettlebeck. One day...A few hours...A stressful situation...things go terribly wrong. Lots of seemingly normal people out there in life are very much on the edge....

[@sbrooke210]

And often a later onset of schizophrenia, or similar mental disorders. BK may have gotten by due to his structured environment and parental coddling.

[@sarahjaye4117]

So awful and also so bad that people can’t just get the meds they need:( I met a guy who ended his own after losing benefits which is super sad though at least he didn’t take any other lives.

[@noavocadoanymore]

That correlates more closely with a lot of other homocide cases though. The snap and killing of the partner/family member. But stalking a house and being methodical in the way this guy has is less common.

[@ninamc6116]

I’m sorry you had to experience this. You make very good points.

[@Ran-33]

He's a low life who blamed his murder on everything else but him.

[@hollym4870]

I appreciate this thoughtful, detailed and bullet point representation of the facts. So many questions were answered for me. Thank you, Dr. Grande!

[@jennyferrios245]

Wow! You answered so much of my questions! Thank you

[@nightwood4379]

Good morning Dr. Grande, Appreciate your update and analysis on this horrific, unthinkable tragedy-hoping the families that lost their loved ones receive justice in the courts.

[@amyfrey444]

When I was Dylan's age, I was very niave. I had a man come to my apartment and was insisting he needed to come in. I told him no and shut the door quickly, locked it and then sat on my couch scared with a big pair of scissors (it was all I had.) He came back with a knife, insisting he needed to find his uncle. I did not open the door, but I told him his uncle wasn't there and that I didn't know his uncle. I was terrified, but I didn't call the police because in my young mind I thought the police would be mad because the guy was not there anymore and I thought maybe I could get in trouble. I think my reluctance was being niave and inexperienced. Now, I wouldn't hesitate to call police. I could also imagine that Dylan convinced herself that nothing happened because how often to horrible things like that happen, she didn't go look because she didn't want to know and if she saw something truly horrible she didn't think she could handle it, so she waited. Then when it got later and later she called others over because she didn't want to see the reality of what she feared. I don't know....that is how I could imagine feeling in her situation. My heart is so heavy for her.

[@deemen7132]

Guy at your front door with knife? You're an Idiot for Not calling the cops!!!

[@weirdflex8158]

I doubt it she probably thought it was nothing and went back to bed and I don't blame her it's not her fault or at least it seems that way with the evidence currently.

[@c0dead]

this never happned

[@Hasblock]

This story you shared something worse than naïveté and you probably need to get your head checked out by the good doctor

[@CountessKitten]

Exactly i agree with all you say here.

[@marcelt7203]

Excellent work. And congratulations on the positive decoration changes in the background! The big cactus now being in the middle of the table creates a much more peaceful atmosphere on the table. And it gives me great peace of mind as the situation with it being on the side of the table didn’t sit right with my a**!

[@johnnyzippo7109]

As always , phenomenal content from Doctor Grande

[@trishworkout9915]

Best analysis I have seen in this case. Thank you for your professional insight.

[@SelineShenoy]

Hello Dr. Grande, just want to say that I appreciate the work you put into creating this content. I really enjoy watching your analysis of various cases.

[@gigiarmany4332]

Yes

[@lloydw185]

@@gigiarmany4332 I Concur.

[@julieyoung3315]

Good Day, Dr Grande. Very interesting, indeed.

[@lareeseblaque8303]

Always really like your input. 🌞

[@karenscherrer]

Yayyyyyyyyyy!!!!! I HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS VIDEO ALL DAY!!! Thank you!!!! You are the highlight of my day!

[@Mjj633]

Happy New Year, Dr. G! Thank you for another great video. This really is a very unfortunate and sad situation. There was no need for this individual to do what he did.

[@kaileim970]

Excellent breakdown as usual Dr Grande. Thanks for the new insights.

[@BucketHeadianHagg]

*Dr Grandes Patreon is the best I’ve seen so far* It’s an entire 2nd channel, filled with all new uploads every single day (that don’t get posted here) really funny bloopers, personal stories, and cool random stuff.

[@supermeansadie6753]

Great analysis as always Dr. Grande!

[@PAS_2020]

I am so freaked out that the first floor roommate saw a man in black with a mask, striding through the hallway, totally frightening her, and then went out the back sliding door, and the roommate didn’t call 911 for almost 7 hours. My heart breaks with the thought that some of those roommates could’ve been breathing, possibly still alive, for all those hours. 😯

[@les0101s]

I'm sure she had no idea they were hurt. We know what happened to those 4, but she didn't at the time. It's not something that would occur to most people, especially when they were used to seeing a lot of different people in the house.

[@whitneywhitney8356]

@@les0101s but she heard someone say someone is in the house 😮

[@amyhenningsgard8618]

@@whitneywhitney8356 Nobody screamed for help. It was quiet after she shut her door, so she assumed all was okay. Just a thought 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@weirdflex8158]

@@whitneywhitney8356 so what? That may not have been very out of the ordinary for them if she heard someone screaming and violence than it would be her fault but I don't see what she did wrong here.

[@pasteljoelle126]

@@whitneywhitney8356 it was a party house. If the person saying this didn’t sound alarmed she could have thought they were just saying that in response to a person coming over. It wasn’t unusual for randos to be in the house.

[@bangibabs]

If I was in Dylan’s position I would have not only frozen but would have also run back to my room and locked the door and I’m 100% sure the shock would have caused me to faint afterwards. Stress does a number on some people in the face of danger. Sad story indeed..

[@odonata9838]

💗👍

[@gapch4047]

@bangibabs I agree but I also think she had absolutely no idea what had happened. There is no way I would ever think four of my friends had been murdered while I was in the same house with them. She could have assumed the masked person was a friend of one of the others there in the house & put the mask on because he was going outside & it was obviously very cold with snow everywhere. She locked her room door to prevent any more "visitors" from coming into her room. Then she went to sleep & I'm sure didn't wake up till very late in the morning. jmo

[@knIfebOmb769]

@@ceelobrown8606you’re right in saying it doesn’t make sense, but it doesn’t change anything. I doubt she she was involved in it , it’s far more likely she’s just kind of stupid.

[@judithgannon5642]

@@ceelobrown8606 she could have called her housemates or someone else, behind her locked door.

[@SethHMG]

Simple answer is a combination of shock and intoxication.

[@ginaciaccio-passaro7878]

Dr. Grande I truly enjoy your channel. Have a wonderful day :)

[@lindz758]

Hindsight bias makes it seem to us that she should have immediately called 911 but she only had limited information at the time 1. She lived in a party house with probably many late night guests 2. She only heard crying and someone playing with a dog. 3. Many people are still wearing face masks. 4. We don't know what she meant by "frozen shock phase" could have just meant she was creeped out to suddenly see a man there and briefly froze. Normalcy bias is a common cognitive distortion where we minimize a potential threat so she likely just rationalized it away and went to bed.

[@amyhenningsgard8618]

That makes the most sense to me too.

[@TheUnofficialMaker]

maybe she passed out

[@mysterywriter888]

My father was an alcoholic. When bad things happened, I went into denial mode. So, once I hired a handyman my friend recommended. Little did I know he was a thief! So, he went outside and came in through a window that was also a door and I met him in my hallway. I froze. In some part of my brain, I knew he should NOT be coming in through my window and should have come in through the front door, but I froze and said nothing. Later when I realized he had stolen valuable rings from me that my mother-in-law had given me in case I needed to sell them at some point I realized that freezing may have saved my life. I know some people would have questioned the guy or yelled at him. Instead, I froze. I was grateful for that reaction because I lived alone in a secluded place and if he killed me the woods were behind my house. No one would have known it was him. He could have escaped easily. If Dylan had some sort of childhood abuse that could have happened to her too. Maybe it saved her life too?

[@joisagirlsname]

Thank you! Saved me typing all this out myself. She was probably used to randos being in the house a lot and even though he creeped her out enough to lock her door never in a million years would have guessed a bunch of her flatmates had just been murdered. I mean, who WOULD assume that? Not many people, IMO.

[@anthonysoto2923]

Sees a masked intruder, hears loud thuds and admits she was frozen in fear. She admitted that. So how could she sleep for 6 hours unscathed. She never called police so your explanation doesn't add up. Much like D's recounting of her actions. The defense will use this with abject glee.

[@jeanholmes7976]

Thank you Dr. Grande! This is such a sad case, and so sad for the surviving roommates. I pray they can find peace in their futures💕from Jean

[@brandonking2118]

Great video very informative

[@poodledaddles1091]

Great analysis, just subbed!

[@katechattin9380]

Keep on doing what you’re doing! Very informative and to the point!

[@missyskye_sea_land9424]

I’m looking forward to listening to this episode, Dr. Grande! Thank you!

[@yome6132]

I drink paint thinner

[@LaniLanilei]

@@yome6132 On purpose? You have a death wish?

[@yome6132]

@@LaniLanilei nah it’s tasty

[@mikewallace8087]

@@yome6132 you drink water ! That's okay , you'll be just fine unless the water comes from a Flint Michigan water tap .

[@laylayang7374]

great explanation! Thank you ! ❤

[@Clintcellington]

You did an excellent job organizing and presenting the affidavit than anyone I've heard yet. 👏

[@derekrushton1705]

It's comforting to know that one of Brian's tutors described him as having a 'brilliant mind'. So brilliant in fact, that a whole department of Academic's, (full time occupation studying crime & criminal behaviour) didn't notice the [allegedly] homicidal psychopathic killer amongst them.

[@derekrushton1705]

@@bethloureiro2648There's a massive difference between theory & practice. Most academics I've met couldn't change a lightbulb.

[@KryaDiere]

@@derekrushton1705 Exactly this. Some of the stupidest people I've met were in my college cohort. They just had good grades their whole lives because they were good at memorising things for exams, but when it came to higher thinking most of them had the brains of a 14 year old.

[@Onomastique]

His criminology academic focus was technology. I am confused how he would not know on the night in question and all the nights prior to have his computer linked to his phone’s hotspot at home while watching a 3-hour-long Bollywood flick-because that keeps the phone active and traceable to the location a perp would want it to be, not where he actually is. Why did he drive his car knowing Ring/store/parking lot/street surveillance cameras would all pick this up the night in question and the nights prior? Why not put glue on his, eyebrows and cover them, with concealer like the drag Queens do? Why use a knife with a sheath he has handled with his bare hands when it is clear he knows where to get gloves. Why talk? Why leave witnesses alive, because it isn’t like he ran out of bullets? Did he just get bored, with killing and decided he’d call it a day? If I wanted frame him, I’d take his phone and car when he was asleep and establish a surveillance pattern near the house, then, on the night in question, pay some meth head to walk through the house and spook the roommate to make sure she saw the eyebrows. So many mistakes from a PhD criminology student is definitely going to cause a decrease in enrollment in that school, because apparently nobody learns anything there.

[@michaelfranklin1109]

@@Onomastique so maybe it was the perfect crime committed by another criminology graduate student who knew and chose to frame BK🤔jk…I think;)

[@The-Portland-Daily-Blink]

Well said. I agree. He's so guilty. The stupid mistakes he made are laughable. I hope he gets life. Execution would be too kind. Let him rot in the joint.

[@gnostic268]

Great analysis. Thank you! This case is so horrific and I'm sure more will be revealed at the trial. So glad that LE caught him.

[@TINYQUBIT]

Excellent, Dr. Grande. Thank you.

[@quantumnature514]

As always, great logic. Thanks for summarizing!

[@globes179]

The most surprising thing for me is that this would be his first offence. Usually people like this start "small," with animals, or isolated loners. But this was a big time quadruple murder and home break in. They would be more likely to offend in their own home or in a "safer" place our of the way somewhere. Could it be that this isn't his first, but just his first mistake.

[@truthseeker4084]

Dont forget that most serial killers get better at killing after their first victims, this must be hist first time in regards to how sloppy he left the crime scene.

[@canterburytail2294]

His being vegan and this crime make me think he is just a violent misanthrope and stalker, he is so scary and I hope he never gets out.

[@bettybanaszak5748]

With all his professional knowledge of criminology why not start at the top?

[@MrKidplay8819]

@@bettybanaszak5748 more noise. People at he bottom will be altered quickly to the ruckus upstairs.

[@leavesofchange]

There are many unsolved murders out there. It is possible he has already killed someone like a homeless person, sex worker, I would say a single individual. It does seem odd to start with 4 people.

[@nadinekeating3255]

The first call to 911 wasn't made until nearly *eight hours* after the roommate saw him in the house. Surveillance from the area picked up audio of the dog barking, she had to have heard that if she was able to hear the words "I think someone is here", and "its okay, I'm going to help you".

[@Laney322]

I ignore my dogs barking all the time. But once when the dog was barking mad for atleast 40 minutes straight, i looked out and saw a peeping tom. Also, there are two roommates here. One didnt hear anything

[@annelikindlund9183]

What motive would she have??????

[@Bloom5056]

I don’t know how she could have ignored the dog barking for that many hours. I read he was shut in a room? The poor thing.

[@spacesage533]

Yeah…. And I think it’s weird that when she called 911 she said that her roommate was unconscious. Why didn’t she say that there was blood everywhere and she was murdered ?there’s a big difference.

[@roxiecariere5713]

Great analysis, thank you, Dr. Todd👍

[@hillelderman]

Love your analysis

[@sharonkeenan5775]

Thank you Dr. Grande This recap is very informative. He probably knew the house would be open. Unbelievable! So sad, the worst of humanity exhibited.

[@Zeett09]

Can you assess the Utah murder/suicide from a couple of days ago? 8 dead including 5 kids. Husband did it.

[@blegend9351]

Thank you for the fantastic breakdown of the events described in the affidavit.

[@debrahunter3113]

very good interesting easy to listen to you and understand thank-you

[@sunnydays2178]

I woke to to a man’s face pressed up against my window TWICE….did I Call the police? No. I froze, but then rationalized that it wasn’t that big of a deal bc he left. And I didn’t have a description so I rationalized that they wouldn’t be able to do anything. After I moved from that apartment I realized how dumb it was not to call police…I personally think she was impaired. I read somewhere where she was at the fraternity party with Xana and Dylan.

[@rohitsingh7940]

Excellent analysis by a professional with thanks Dr Grande for your grande in-depth focus and unbiased realistic reasoning according to the rules of reasons. I am a doctor myself and this is no doubt the best I have seen so far .,! Keep up the great job!

[@JH-cx1vx]

Ooh I was waiting for this.

[@joromea4074]

Dr. Grande, your analysis of the witness and the accused's reactions are the most in-depth to date. Thank you for your insights. Warm greetings from South Africa.

[@tarheelfans98]

I literally agree with pretty much everything you’ve said. Thank for your input. I do appreciate your time.

[@barneyronnie]

Earned my PhD in mathematical physics from UNC - Chapel Hill, so I'm a Tarheel Fan😉 Dr. Grande's analysis is spot on; I would never expect anything less from him!

[@estherhastime777]

It's Dr. Grande break time and I am definitely enlightened, thank you .

[@healthlinktransport4803]

thank you. for the insight!

[@madelineklyczek5155]

The video I’ve been waiting for!

[@waitwhat564]

Excellent analysis. Clear and precise. Best I've heard yet. Never thought of him thinking DM may of called police. Thankyou Dr G.

[@countdebleauchamp]

Yes that was an insightful observation.

[@SuperAngelic5]

Good insight.

[@kathywright7395]

He is a legend in his own mind. He left enough evidence he was caught in 8 weeks.

[@norpriest521]

@@TobyN.Tucka_TNT You sound like someone who would admire A Hannibal Lector. Fucking psycho

[@tammyjohnson7401]

Thank you Dr. Grande. Explained very well.

[@brianchurch1254]

Love your channel.

[@rodneycooke6538]

Best analysis from anyone and you never disappoint. Dr Grande all day 🎯

[@annb8999]

Brian is not the only one need to be investigated

[@patricethrives8830]

Dr. Grande, I have found all of your coverage of this case very interesting.

[@charlescoryn9614]

Excellent presentation.......