Joel Osteen’s ‘Mary’ Movie Gets the Gospel Wrong | Ep 1112

[@Raven.Tulips]

I live in California (a couple of hours away, near Sacramento), and I hadn't heard about the news involving those kindergarten boys until now! I'm so thankful to hear they survived-thank God . This story is truly heartbreaking. My husband and I have two young boys, ages 4 (almost 5) and 6, so this really hits close to home. Sending heartfelt prayers for those precious boys and their family, as well as for their classmates and the school staff. 🙏

[@Finny_finn_finn]

After watching this movie "Mary"...I'm not sure that Joel Olsteen has ever read the Bible

[@user-lo9po5mp5u]

Joel olsteen honestly LOOKS demonic.

[@aurorableh90]

I literally felt so offended by the movie I’m so glad I found my people 😭❤️❤️

[@hees0009]

Thank God those two boys are alive! May they recover fully physically and emotionally.

[@THORO20]

Please never EVER stop speaking so boldly of your faith, the Bible and Jesus. ❤ I love and appreciate you so much

[@pamelacollins2746]

It’s no surprise Joel Osteen got the gospel wrong. Sadly he does not seem to know the true gospel.

[@FaithandSunshine]

Stopped watching the movie in the first 3 minutes. Felt demonic!

[@ThinkHEAVEN-YouTube]

@@FaithandSunshine When you DON'T EVEN MENTION a place called Hell, how could it NOT be?

[@moviegirlbeth]

I got through 10 minutes and turned it off. You are so right. It was terrible! I even told my teenager not to watch it.

[@fitgiddlin21]

May I ask why it felt demonic. I was interested in watching it just to see what the outrage is about

[@arosete3512]

@@moviegirlbethI felt the same way. It was awful

[@LizS817]

Same!!! I could tell it was portraying a false teaching

[@nikkireeves3483]

I am a member of the SDA church, currently in California right now, and only heard this story briefly mentioned at church this weekend. Thank you for your unbiased coverage, and your prayers!

[@QMW11]

I'm an SDA in Florida and hasn't heard it until church this past Sabbath either

[@salberthal88]

Catholic here, and we were urged NOT to watch the film as it contradicts Catholic teaching.

[@imnottheone5538]

!!!!!

[@AllieBethStuckey]

Good to know!

[@ponderingskeptic6745]

@@AllieBethStuckey although not the case here bc the film contradicts solid biblical teaching as well, the fact that it contradicts Catholic teaching is not the reason why one shouldn’t watch it. The true biblical teaching of Protestants also contradict Catholic teaching, and that’s a good thing. If it was in line with Catholic teaching, Mary would be portrayed as born without sin, and the focus would’ve been more on her suffering seeing her son suffer and die, rather than on Jesus and why He had to suffer and die to secure salvation for His people. The glory is either shared with, or given more to, Mary.

[@TriciaPerry-mz7tc]

@@AllieBethStuckeyAllie. How come you are on social media constantly talking about people sins and business and all this stuff. It’s unbelievable unbiblical We are told not to do this and yet people like you and Candace Owens claiming to be Christians especially as women and doing this. It’s gossiping and awful. Please stop. Your mouth is what is getting you all in trouble and if you had the HOLY GHOST and knew the word of God you would know

[@salberthal88]

@@ponderingskeptic6745We’ll have to agree to disagree. Thanks

[@cl5193]

I watched that televangelist weirdo on 60 Minutes many years ago. The interviewer, I forget which one, asked why he didn't have the cross in his church? He had some mealy-mouthed answer about not wanting to offend anyone. Snakes will tell you who they are. You just have to believe them.

[@NicholaWallace]

Joel Osteen has missed the message of the gospel for a very long time. Did he ever preach it?

[@kimberlym-67]

Missing cultural context and adding what isn't found in the Bible is A dangerous game.

[@squeaksohko5863]

Shocker! Joel Osteen is wrong about what he teaches?

[@christophermason3275]

Of course he’s wrong about what he teaches!! He’s a false prophet who puts emphasis on health wealth material blessings and that if you have more faith then God will somehow bless you. He preaches the prosperity gospel which is by the way no gospel at all. He NEVER addresses sin, repentance, sanctification holiness or HIS WRATH! Jesus Christ spoke of people like him as wolves in sheep’s clothing. Make no mistake about that

[@spookykatelyn2161]

​@christophermason3275 so true and I watch the movie and trailer and I already having issues with how Mary story was portrayed as well as how they use the angels Gabriel and lucifer. Because I don't remember lucifer being in Mary story when she delivered Jesus in this world. So this movie is not biblical accurate

[@larrylafferty3836]

@@christophermason3275 tryed to warn my inlaws that love olseen they pulled the judge not lest you be judged card on me now im truely wondering if there really saved however they do pray over there meals this confusses me

[@zoearrow3297]

ALLEGED assassin. Let's not forget about our legal system where we are all innocent UNTIL PROVEN guilty. Thank you for your wonderful content.

[@margingains2937]

I was looking for this comment

[@md5053]

The Mary movie was an abomination from start to finish. The only reason I kept watching was morbid curiosity to see what crazy thing was going to happen next. It’s like they took multiple Bible stories from the Old & New Testaments, added some fictional stuff that never happened and put that all in a blender and mixed it up and dumped it out in movie form. It was completely ridiculous. 🤦🏻‍♀️

[@rhondapatterson1]

Thank you! I don’t deal well with that and spend way too much time trying to make it make sense. Grateful I can dodge this one.

[@aphoticzone]

It's straight out of the fake "gospel of James". Mike Winger just did a video on it.

[@shannonnichols3415]

This takes away one of my favorite things about Mary…her role as wife and mother & also Joseph’s role as husband to a young woman he’s betrothed to (I studied this & found the betrothal at the time meant basically to be married for one year but not consummated.) If anyone else has studied to find out differently, please let me know! My point is, think about being 14 & telling the world you’re pregnant but you haven’t had sex! Even people who love us are still going to be thrown by this! And she had to be a bit nervous to wonder what Joseph would think, even just right at first!😮

[@larrylafferty3836]

i loved the way Joseph handled it reminds me of what Jesus did for us

[@JMagnoliaSalas]

She wasn't 14. She would have been 17-19.

[@Madddnessssc137]

@@JMagnoliaSalasI wasn’t sure how old she was. But also, you know women that are raised in different cultures might be more mature than women in the American culture. Google says 15-16, but I don’t know.

[@Kroh13]

@@JMagnoliaSalasno she was very young in the Bible ..

[@lisamoag6548]

Joseph was a just man.

[@kathymathison9131]

I didn’t know the Mary movie was from Joel Osteen. I knew it was way off but told my husband it was just another wrong movie from Hollywood. No wonder it was off! Joel Osteen doesn’t know about the Bible indeed! He is so misguided.

[@sherrymeadows8758]

Very much so ! Pray he gets right with Jesus!

[@kaytosoarox]

Mike Winger just covered an in depth video on the gospel of James which was a big inspiration for the Mary movie. Sheds a lot of light on why the writer chose to go that direction

[@amccoy5199]

Mike Winger was talking about the fake gospel of James, not the true book of James. The fake “document”, for lack of a better word was used for reference and background for this awful movie. I just saw that he has another video out today with more information about the fake “James” that I’m going to watch ASAP. I really like Mike Winger. He is a humble teacher and thoroughly studies scripture.

[@jerilowehowell6015]

There is nothing regarding Mary in the book of James. Has to be a reference to a gnostic false book.

[@kaytosoarox]

@ yes it is ****the false gospel of james

[@jeannetteelizabeth144]

I am so glad you took out the time to speak on and critique this movie, Allie Beth. Movies such as this when poorly made, end up causing more confusion and problems with people that won't necessarily pick up the Bible and read it for themselves (which is VERY IMPORTANT TO DO!), but instead, they tune in and watch a movie, just ASSUMING it's going to tell them the truth of what transpired in the Gospels. Ugh...Poor Mary as the servant of God has really gotten a bum rap for the last 2,000 years, and has been very misunderstood as a person and her role that the LORD God had her play while living her life in Nazareth, as a JEWISH woman, in a JEWISH neighborhood, betrothed to a JEWISH man, hoping to have many children and looking forward to her life with him. Biblically, we KNOW what happened. Some of man's traditions have gotten in the way of everything, and it has made it harder for people to know the truth from fiction when it comes to people like the Lord Jesus, Joseph, and Mary, and the way they had to live their lives out once these prophecies of the Son of God being born to man started to come to pass during Mary and Joseph's lifetime. Many people do not understand Mary's role in the Bible. She is the fulfillment of Isaiah 7:14--the LORD God CHOSE her to be the mother of His Son. In order for her to carry Him in her womb, GRACE had to be placed upon her so that her inherent sinful human self would be made "pure" so that she could carry the sinless Savior of the World. IF the LORD God did NOT do that (hence the reason why Gabriel came to her and said, "Hail Mary, FULL OF GRACE") to and for her, she would NOT have been able to carry the sinless Word of God and birth Him. Growing up as a Catholic, they did not explain well enough biblically, what Mary's role was to us. The Holy Spirit took over that for me about four years ago, when He knew I was ready to receive the truth about her, and respect her more than I ever did before (I left the CC over thirty years ago, and only went back recently to attend the TLM; I love to attend non-denom biblical churches and messianic congregations as well). I heard of this movie, but had no idea Joel was behind it. There would be no reason to have all these so called "theological" and unbiblical "experts" like Muslims, Mormons, etc. having any say whatsoever in a movie about Mary, Jesus, etc. to begin with. Both of those are cults anyway, and there was no such person as a "Muslim" back then. There were those who definitely prayed to the demonic entity "Allah", but again, it was 600 years later when Mohammed came on the scene, with his false claims of Gabriel meeting up with him, etc. Anyone who knows the Lord Jesus Christ and His Word, and has a solid relationship with the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit dwelling within them, will know when a movie such as this is not worth watching after a few minutes or so of it being on. The Holy Spirit will usually let us know not to even waste our time, especially since (and sorry, no offense, but...) it has a connection with Joel Osteen.

[@peters6345]

People dont seem to understand murder is not ok.. yeah i imagine that company has lots to answer for. But this is cold blooded murder. People being upset by casting a Jewish actress to play Mary .. we live in bizzaro world

[@papabear562]

When I saw this movie advertised , I knew it would not be truthful to the scriptures. And now that I see that Osteen was involved, it makes that determination even more correct. I will never watch it. Thanks for talking about this on your show Allie.

[@mizzLopez]

Same.

[@laurens8623]

Love your blouse allie beth. Hi from Norway 🇳🇴. I try to listen replays when I can. Bless you sister. Merry Christmas

[@Andsol9930]

That color looks really good on her.

[@christophermason3275]

Jesus Christ definitely is not an effeminate savior whereas he’s supposedly lovable adorable never judges anyone. He DOES JUDGE RIGHTEOUSLY!!

[@dorothyhinkel185]

Mary was a great believer. She was young but had a maximum amount if sound doctrine in her soul. Her spiritual life revolved around the Temple. Mary knew...

[@reetayoung]

I started watching Mary & stopped because it wasn't biblical

[@maricordova6285]

My sister stopped watching when she saw that the devil appeared to Mary. She was creeped out by that.

[@julierichey5336]

Mike Winger did a good video on this.

[@tommibaker6091]

I was taught some basics of that twisted story and watching Winger, now know where it came from. A false gospel of James

[@shannonnichols3415]

@@julierichey5336 Thx! I love Mike and will go check it out!

[@jaziybabe]

I was just going to say that haha super interesting that they didn’t make it all up? They just took it from this heretical gospel…

[@claudiasmith5257]

@@tommibaker6091KZbin videos will tell you why you are wise about the book of James! Keys of the Kingdom Holy Bible will reveal the Truth for those who seek God’s Divine Truth nothing but the Truth ~ it’ll knock your socks off! Christopher Sparkes is the man who in his obedient calling to translate God’s Truth ~ 27 years of incredible research, God Is Revealing His Truths for His Remnant. God bless you, and everyone seeking God’s Truths.

[@jackprice7828]

Very good narrative Allie on the state of mental health in the US. It's very closely tied to the absence of God in the lives of people and is a spiritual issue too.

[@annamolini6190]

Absolutely devastating what happened to those boys and for all the other children who witnessed it! Praise the Lord they are still alive!

[@jfgmjlk]

Watched the trailer a few days ago and already thought this is a false gospel!! But yeah what should we expect nowadays…

[@Supercladding]

Isaiah 45 I will not give My glory to another!

[@SachelleCambria]

Some people are too blind to understand that.

[@user-lo9po5mp5u]

You nailed it

[@k11155]

@@Supercladding God will not give his glory but he makes us to participate in his glory John 17:2-5: Jesus says that he has given his glory to us, and that we will experience it even more in heaven.

[@realcryptodogg]

i just came across your channels and appreciate you cover all these topics. It seems you are doing well commercially as well! Praise god! Fyi, thanks for covering the shooting in CA. Our kids are around that age and I don't think any of our friends know!

[@kimberlym-67]

@@realcryptodogg Exactly, I had no idea but now I will keep the whole situation and families in prayer.

[@Mdtknew]

Thank you for your balanced presentation and demonstration of the different words used for different sad stories of all mentioned religions and so much more & I appreciate your vocal tone too by not becoming overly dramatic and emotional and for asking for prayer for all

[@joannatripp7831]

I so appreciate your common sense that you bring back to the table of discussion. I also appreciate all these things that you brought up that are not in the view of the general public. Thank you very much for keeping us updated. In addition, this is just kind of a side note, but I really wish that people would talk more about health savings accounts. It is not always good in the light of a very unhealthy insurance society that we rely completely on that. And it can really help. So for those who can have a health savings account any or even just start a savings account for those health issues that might arise. I know that we started doing that and it helped incredibly especially when a surprise diagnosis came for our daughter. It can really help in so many ways.

[@jamestrotter3162]

Stephen was full of grace also-"And Stephen, full of grace and power, was doing great wonders and signs among the people."-Acts 6:8.

[@T.Truthtella-n3i]

Mary was described as “Full of Grace” BEFORE Christ was conceived in Her Holy Womb, let alone before He shed His Blood on the Cross.

[@k11155]

@@jamestrotter3162 yes. But he is full of glory (while he's dying) after Jesus died and resurrected. But Mary is full of glory before Jesus born. That's the difference

[@ThinkHEAVEN-YouTube]

There's a wife without a husband. And two boys without a daddy. That's difficult to even grasp. 🎉 (He's NEVER coming back 🏡 home....)

[@LizS817]

I literally turned it off 2 minutes into when Gabriel told Marys dad she was going to fulfill isaiahs prophecy and be the greatest blah blah. I was like NO thats JESUS!! Makes sense now that i know joel olsteen made it.

[@Kroh13]

Yep didn’t even waste the rest of the time either

[@Livefreeordi]

Osteen lost me a long time ago. He’s a disgrace to organized religion

[@kakiskorner3937]

Terrible movie…very misleading…couldn’t finish it/waste of time…sloppy…no biblical basis….!

[@Kroh13]

Watch the best Christmas pageant ever .. that’s worth your time

[@kimberlym-67]

The whole point of using Mary as mother of God was that she was humble and she was obedient to God. She was not outwardly special. That's who God uses the humble. The ones you wouldn't expect that the world would use.

[@NicholaWallace]

Mary was the mother of Jesus, the man, not Jesus, the Creator God.

[@kimberlym-67]

@NicholaWallace Well put. Thank you for that. ✝️

[@donbailey2765]

Allie, your narrative is so insightful. Thank you for your work…

[@AZLorie-kl5ow]

Osteen was responsible for that atrocity of a movie?! Why am I not surprised... You'd think that he wouldn't be deliberately trying to drag people to hell with him. 😢

[@megred7364]

"It is God’s favor on her that makes her special." 💯 Allie! This is the essense of the Catholic dogma of the Immaculate Conception. In the words of Pope Pius IX: "The most Blessed Virgin Mary was, from the first moment of her conception, by a singular grace and privilege of almighty God and by virtue of the merits of Jesus Christ, Savior of the human race, preserved immune from all stain of original sin." CCC 491 Protestants and Catholics may disagree on the Immaculate Conception but we are definitely in agreement that the grace Mary was full of was wholly from God and not of herself. We agree that she was favored by God and the favor he blessed her with is what is so special about her. She is a humble servant of the Lord and an example for every Christian to also say "Behold, I am a servant of the Lord. Be it unto me according to His will." God bless and may the Word of the Lord dwell within all His people this Christmas.

[@itsspiritual8645]

Mariology desecrates the sacrifice of Jesus Christ.

[@Jesus_is_the_1way]

Amen, so beautifully said ❤

[@robinleong8310]

"There is ONE God and ONE mediator between God and man, the man Christ Jesus." 1 Timothy 2:5 Mary does NOT carry our prayers to Jesus. Jesus Himself prays for us. “Consequently, He is able to save to the uttermost those who draw near to God through Him, since He always lives to make intercession for them.” -Hebrews 7:25. This is one movie I have no desire to see. Thanks for letting us know what's really going on in the movie, "Mary", Allie. Always a pleasure to listen in to your broadcasts. Have a GREAT Christmas break with your family!

[@T.Truthtella-n3i]

Mary is the Mediatrix of All Graces, this is what the Church of the Living God teaches. True Apostolic Christians have always believed this.

[@mooreoftammie]

@@T.Truthtella-n3ino. Not Biblical. Roman Catholic heresy.

[@kathrynmaria1585]

Do you ask people to pray for you?

[@mlizzaklizza498]

You misunderstand what is meant by mediation, and prayer. We are called to pray for one another, and are united with all the saints in heaven. The Communion of Saints is not possible by our power, or the power of the saints, it is possible because of the Will of God. Asking the saints to pray with us, and for us, is no different than asking friends and loved ones to pray with us, and for us, except they are not distracted, and tempted, by the stress and evil of this world. They are face to face with Jesus. I urge you go read Revelation. The prayers of the saints are poured onto the alter as incense. Mary is described as Queen of Heaven. She said her soul magnifies the Lord, she points us to her Son, and teaches us how to follow Him. She asked Jesus to perform His first miracle at the wedding of Cana. On the Cross, Jesus said “Behold your mother.” He wasn’t only asking John to take care of His mother, but everything Jesus said, while dying on the cross, was for all humanity, for all time. When you ask your friends and family to pray for you, they are mediating for you. When we ask the Saints, and especially Mary, they are mediating for us in the same way, but they’ve already been cleansed of their sins, and don’t have all the distractions of this world.

[@mittengrandma807]

@@T.Truthtella-n3iWhere is that written in scripture, please?

[@flograce8210]

He isn’t correct on anything concerning scripture. So sad leading the sheep to the slaughter.open your Bible people . Compare what false teachers are teaching against scripture.

[@bcc7777]

Just started watching that movie, but haven't finished. Guess I won't finish it now. 😒 Not surprised it would be shown on Netflix though. If I'd known it involved Joel Osteen I wouldn't have even started it. Glad to hear those babies are (physically) healing.

[@miltonrose1638]

I just watched this film last night, This was a very dark depiction of a beautiful story, i would not recommend this especially for family viewing.

[@ginaexum3345]

I’m not supporting what the guy did, but I do agree with what he said. It is so true the medical industry is all about profit and will crush you if you cannot or do not pay. Yet, when your entire livelihood is destroyed, you lose your home, have to file for bankruptcy….all for something that was never what they wanted. Who the hell thinks it’s ok to profit on someone who has cancer. Again, I do not agree with what he did.

[@GratiaPrima_]

49:34 Catholic here. If this Catholic man wanted to honor and respect Mary, the best way to do that is not to contradict what the Scriptures and the Church say of her and her role. She’s so beautiful, and points us to her Son. All this liberty was not necessary and is actually not as compelling as the truth about the Holy Family. God bless, and peace be with you all this Christmas time. 😊

[@gerardoluna9682]

I am with you, besides what it is the point to consult a Protestant pastor to help in portraying Mary in a film. Don't we have enough Catholic theologians to help with this?

[@GratiaPrima_]

@@gerardoluna9682yep! Or even worse, Mormons and Muslims.

[@GratiaPrima_]

@@gerardoluna9682even worse, Mormons and Muslims!

[@Tsoprano27]

Aisde from her role in giving birth to Jesus and being the first witness to his resurection, Mary is nothing more than a human being. Scripture does not tell us to worship or pray to her or does she ever in scripture point to her son, Jesus alone tells us that only through him we shall see the father, not through Mary.

[@jamestrotter3162]

@@Tsoprano27 Mary Magdelene was the first witness to Christ's resurrection, not Mary the mother of Jesus-Jn. 20:1.

[@melissapoole8580]

I wouldn't even begin to watch this. 1- It's on Netflix. How accurate can it be? 2- I find almost NO show is even remotely close to the bible and I refuse to watch. I did hear about this shooting. I am a former Adventist and it breaks my heart these sweet babies were hurt by demonic activity. These poor babies.

[@Melissa-sf1qm]

Former SDA here as well. Glad you found your way out!

[@silverbullet11202]

Concerning algorithms, the worst thing about KZbin is the autoplay when you're scrolling, where if you happen to sit on a video for 2 seconds before continuing down the list, you're now getting those types of videos sprinkled into your feed the next time around...

[@Emet-Debar]

Joel’s O’lsteen’s Mary movie! Here’s your sign! The huge red flag came when hearing that JO is one of the producers!

[@daphne-w98]

I will never condone murder and yet it’s interesting to see the way established, higher-than-average-income commentators talk about this, as if what the culprit did was unique. Insurance companies also walk past thousands of people as they die, and deny people who have been working and paying into that system for years, and profit from that denial. They celebrate with the riches they make from that model. And most of the richer conservative commentators are no longer in touch with what it feels like to watch that, to watch people go bankrupt while sick, for a denial to change someone’s life, or contribute to the end of it. The thousands of people wronged by insurance is the footnote instead of the story. The story that established media commentators are most appalled by is ultimately about when the elite suffer. (Which again, I do not approve of.)

[@moviegirlbeth]

Murder is NEVER ok no matter what profession they have.

[@Macnastyyyy]

You talking about the Mary movie tweets was my favorite thing 🤣🤣

[@gbrooks799]

Allie, somehow the fact that you give a reason for not saying this criminals name, RINGS HOLLOW.

[@kaylaledouxgary2200]

Allie, I know this is off subject, but last night, I listened to the interview Candice Owens did with a gentleman who served on the USS Liberty. I am confused about the content and would love to get your thoughts on that interview. I grew up knowing that Israel is God's chosen people which is why the interview is confusing to me. I hope you will do one of your podcasts on this subject. Thank you in advance....I always enjoy listening to your point of view.

[@nicolesalter2726]

Taylor should move to Canada where only 1 in 3 Canadians think the government overreacted to covid. Even now. Thank you for being a light in all this moral darkness, Allie!

[@meredithhall5058]

Saying that Mary is a saint or sinless or that she hears our prayers takes away from the fact that one way Jesus humbled himself was being born of a normal human girl - a girl that yes, was favored but also a sinner like us all.

[@GratiaPrima_]

That’s silly. All of that can be true without taking anything away from Jesus. She’s a humble servant. True. Who was uniquely and fully graced by God for an amazing and honorable role which she fulfilled perfectly by said grace of God. Also true.

[@Jesus_is_the_1way]

@@GratiaPrima_what’s silly about what this commenter said? Everything she said was biblically true…?

[@GrannyDi276]

Believing Mary is sinless is not biblical....praying to Mary is not biblical....there's a Mary cult within the catholic church.

[@allismama]

​@@GratiaPrima_Mary is not sinless...she was just a vessel..... So so tired of this only Jesus was sinless

[@k11155]

Not favored but full of grace. Full of grace means 100% not 80 or 60. How can someone is full of grace and sinner at the same time. Even if you don't believed it, don't quote Mary is a sinner because you disrespect her and God who made her in that way as he discribed in genesis. Sin is in saten's dominion. She can't be under the satan's dominion if she has enmity between her and saten. better to not say anything about her because you have to give account for every words you say.

[@Marc-HenryGeneste-d8h]

I appreciate you sharing. May God bring change our hearts, renew our mind more importantly may He bring us as a nation on our knees.

[@kakiskorner3937]

I love Luke’s description of Mary’s calling…movie really misses the mark~no mention of her song/praise not of herself BUT TO THE LORD!

[@nataliewhisler6763]

The whole time I was watching Mary I was just like that didn’t happen, that didn’t happen that way, and we have no idea how that happened!

[@annemariewinic4822]

I love Allie’s blouse- where did she get it?

[@mlizzaklizza498]

I’m a lifelong, devout, Catholic. The previews of this film looked suspicious to me. All the reviews I’ve seen, have been extremely troubling. There was no reason to change Scripture, and portray Mary’s personality as bold and rebellious. That said, the way Allie explains Catholic doctrine on Mary, is not completely accurate. It comes across as obtuse, or an intentional misrepresentation. No, most of your Catholic friends (at least the actual, practicing Catholics, who understand Scripture and theology) do not recommend this movie. All of the Catholic commentators and theologians are speaking out against this movie. It’s very sad, to me, not only, that a man who claims to be Catholic, has directed it, but that unsuspecting people will see such a false portrayal of Scripture and Apostolic Tradition.

[@shelleybraman5426]

Allie your doctrine about Mary was so good and we loved hearing it but when you said God gives and takes away that isn’t, that was what Job said Jesus came to give us life and give it more abundantly. The devil came to steal, kill and destroy, but you’re doing a great job and love to listen to you

[@AndreaGonzalez-qo7ni]

Allie - have you heard of the book: "The 5 Habits for Being Good News"? My church Community Bible Church in San Antonio does classes based on great Christian books and this was one I stumbled into. One of the 5 habits is hospitality. It's a very short read and I highly recommend!

[@summernicole8339]

I love Producer Bri! She’s totally someone that I would be friends with. Always love her fun inputs

[@kristinemolloy937]

Mother Mary was the most humble servant of God- her YES was the grace God allowed to start the salvation of the world caused by Eve's NO that Adam caused in the great fall. She loves all humans as her own children, and God wants us to love his momma just as he does. Love is not worship. Worship means sacrifice. Keep studying and walking your journey to learn more of what Catholics actually believe Allie. It is truly beautiful and a gift from God. Her motherhood is a gift.

[@MooJoo]

Mary is not our mother. She was the earthly mother of Jesus. God used her just like He used Moses, David, the apostles, etc. Not one single writer of the scriptures ever elevates Mary or suggests she was sinless. Yet the CC does both. Mary would be horrified at the adoration. She knew better.

[@meredithvanbinsbergen7091]

These Bible verses show that even Jesus did not elevate Mary to superior status. “While Jesus was still talking to the crowd, his mother and brothers stood outside, wanting to speak to him. Someone told him, “Your mother and brothers are standing outside, wanting to speak to you.”” Jesus asked, “Who is my mother? Who are my brothers?” Then he pointed to his disciples and said, “Look, these are my mother and brothers. Anyone who does the will of my Father in heaven is my brother and sister and mother!” Matthew 12:46-50

[@mariaapplegate1870]

⁠@@MooJooAnd this is why you are not Catholic. No matter how it’s explained to you, you (and many protestants) still cannot understand the difference between adoration and devotion. Look up Dr. Scott Hahn, he was just like you (just a heck of a lot smarter). Hail Mary.. 🙏📿❤️

[@mariaapplegate1870]

Amén. Hail Mary, full of grace… 🙏📿❤️

[@MooJoo]

@@mariaapplegate1870 I'm sorry but those pretend prayers won't help you. You should be praying to Jesus. He's the only one worthy of prayers and petitions

[@baby20latina]

25:36 “This killer”. He hasn’t even been found guilty or gone through the court process for you to be speaking this way.

[@yllatusmuna]

Innocent until proven guilty. Also, there's a lot of questions. Things are not adding up. He might not be the killer, but a patsy.

[@yllatusmuna]

😮

[@0612freedom]

Hail Mary, Full of Grace, The Lord is with thee. Blessed art thou among women And Blessed is the Fruit of thy womb, Jesus. Holy Mary, Mother of God Pray for us sinners, Now and at the hour of our death Amen

[@DavidMauerMusic]

Watched it a couple days ago. Not only was it terribly inaccurate, but typical to Netflix fashion, it was just a dreadful film altogether 😂

[@NCMUSIC01]

Started watching Mary. Didn't know it was from Joel Olsteen but that explains why it was creepy and I cut it off after a few minutes. Definitely not scriptural. More like a fiction movie.

[@timothymorbitzer1655]

I've never heard anybody that preaches the so-called health and wealth gospel say that God "owes" you these things, only the critics say that you are misinformed. Believe me, I've heard hundreds and hundreds of messages and have never heard anybody say God "owes" you those things

[@Lynn-r8h]

Thank you, thank you for standing up for the Truth! Mary’s real name is Miriam. She was a Jewish girl. Jesus is the Jewish Messiah.

[@melaniew4354]

How can these people say Mary was Muslim!?? Islam didn't even exist until over 1000 years after Mary's lifetime. So ludicrous.

[@jonathankim9502]

If JOEL OSTEEN is involved.... you know what the outcome will be..... 😣😣😫😫😖😖

[@ackid16]

Even with the “wrong” of this movie…this is still better than most of the trash available to viewers. Hopefully it will get secular people to take a look at the roots of the movie, and crack open a bible. Let the Holy Spirit move and see what happens. As a Catholic, I can tell you, Jesus is the one mediator, always and forever. “Through Him, with Him, and in Him, in the unity of the Holy Spirit, all glory and honor is yours, almighty Father, for ever and ever.” My favorite words to hear on Sundays.

[@bonsaipal]

How could Mary be Muslim when Mohammed hadn't been born until 571 years AFTER Jesus established Christianity? People need to do their research!

[@factsmatter4030]

Saw a video clip of him and Victoria at a hollyweird party with Lady Gaga and Maria bonavich(spl?) He can't be a good person if that info was correct

[@marico1473]

No where in scripture does it say Mary has any power. She is Jesus' mother, period. We don't need her intresation . Jesus has already paid the price and way to God the Father

[@Conservbro]

If you do not believe that Mary was perpetually a virgin then you disagree with Luther and Calvin.

[@oliviannie9705]

"I want to just briefly, we don't have very much time -" talk about the titular topic of the video. It seems clickbaity, please Allie, add the other topics to the title too. "Current goings-ons - kindergarten shooting, UHC murder and Mary movie." It just seems more honest

[@donnaw1964]

Poor people get the best insurance. My daughter was on Medicaid for a little while and she had Cadillac insurance it covered everything. I on the other hand am lower middle class and chose to let a broken finger heal on its own because I cannot afford my deductible. But would I EVER condone murdering the CEO of an insurance company ABSOLUTELY NOT!!! I am sickened by people who celebrate the murder of a man because they don’t let agree with his business practices.

[@jamilewis9555]

Mike Winger did a video showing how the movie and some Catholic beliefs about Mary are based on the false Gospel of James. He reads and comments on the entire book, and it becomes pretty clear.

[@T.Truthtella-n3i]

Not it’s not. Marian dogmas come from Sacred Tradition. The fake James document contains BOTH truth and error ( like most spurious “gospels”) which is why the Holy Catholic Church REJECTED it.

[@longstreet2740]

prayers for these 2 children

[@kathymathison9131]

Terrible movie! So much drama added that IS NOT MENTIONED IN THE BIBLE! The movie is so off it’s disturbing!

[@maryvicente3692]

Produced by Joel Osteen. Enough said. AND it’s on Netflix? Gospel shouldn’t even be in the same sentence.

[@Bun28_]

Where is your top from???♥

[@HumbleAndKind0721]

I was wondering where you bought the shirt you’re wearing? Love your podcast!

[@lisafaser6031]

Exceptional commentary today, Allie. The whole point of Christianity is to point to Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior. Amen!✝️

[@zoearrow3297]

I do agree the type of fame Luigi is getting on SM is somewhat alarming (YET it does show how JADED we all are re our healthcare system) but i also believe in FREEDOM OF SPEECH and people have the right to SAY whatever they want. It falls on the children and the family of this CEO to NOT go on SM and read comments - comment reading is a CHOICE.

[@diannahaw7264]

The Church as a whole has fed a lukewarm message about God and preached a devil with so much power! When Jesus's own words said Luke 10: 19.Behold, I have given you authority to tread on snakes and scorpions, and over all the power of the enemy. Nothing will harm you. 20. Nevertheless, do not rejoice that the evil spirits submit to you, but rejoice that your names are written in heaven.” 21. At that time Jesus rejoiced in the Holy Spirit and declared, “I praise You, Father, Lord of heaven and earth, because You have hidden these things from the wise and learned, and revealed them to little children. .

[@Kroh13]

You should review the best Christmas pageant ever . I thought it was biblical in a way that can reach many people . Loved it !

[@Homeschoolmama2020]

Haven’t seen this but I do feel like Journey to Bethlehem did the same thing. It changed a lot of stuff that didn’t need to be changed. It really bothers me how it ended . It shows Harold’s son showing up and the wise men telling Mary and Joseph to leave. It doesn’t show Joseph being told in a dream to take Mary and Jesus to leave to Egypt in a dream. I wanted to like the Journey to Bethlehem movie but it makes me cringe.

[@Chrissy-ot2hi]

I did watch that movie but it was a year ago and would need to watch it again to comment properly but I do recall possibly thinking along your lines. . As a Christian I can watch something and think that they have used a lot of “poetic license “ in that show. My concern is for people who don’t know the Bible well enough and so they end up believing the narrative to be the Bible when it isn’t.

[@arlenemartinez4067]

So I’m not gonna see the movie, and mainly it’s because I just don’t support Netflix. Nor do I think that Mary is any more special than we all are to God. I do believe that she was a vessel that God used just like we can all be used. I think it might be a way of showing what God can do when we are obedient. I understand that you would like for the movie to be more Christ centered, but the creators were clearly focusing on her obedience. I do think like you said that it should have stayed biblical and not make her out to be like this goddess, however, we do have to understand that the movie is not merely about Jesus, ..clearly. I don’t think that that’s what they were aiming for but the “possible experience” that Mary had. Again I haven’t seen the movie to have a concrete opinion about it just going based off of commentary, but I would think that it’s centered around Mary because it’s precisely from “her point of view”or what she “might have lived.” It’s important to know that it’s entertainment. I think that the danger lies when someone doesn’t know the gospel, when all they know, is religion and not relationship, it can cause them to believe that these movies are reality or the real depiction of the Bible specially because a lot of so-called Christians are not actually reading their word or studying it.

[@PamZuchowski]

great podcast Allie can you please give me your thoughts on elf on the shelf ?? perhaps a podcast even for next year ?

[@brentclark8276]

Hollywood didn't stick to the original source material for She Hulk or The Witcher. Do you think that if they aren't going to stick to the original source material for those shows, what makes us think that they will stick to Scripture on Mary or even The Chosen?

[@jank707]

My least favorite thing about this channel, is the story the episode title is about is always the very last thing talked about and sometimes only very briefly at that. Also, why title a video about a movie if you haven't even seen the movie??

[@patrickadams2864]

Thank you for speaking to our country I hope to help my 2 young daughters to listen to your program

[@reannfrantz9102]

Gavin Newsom is a true piece-of-work. Thankful the 2 boys are alive.

[@mamaschaff8185]

I wish your episodes were named in a way to actually indicate what your episode is going to be about.... I was wanting to hear about Joel Osteen's movie, but 30 minutes in to the episode, you haven't mentioned it. The other items are interesting, but....... I have heard about the CA shooting, although not in the detail you presented it

[@sydneysharp9686]

Use the red dot to scroll to the part you want to hear. They are separated and named.

[@karenhamrick5426]

LORD Jesus come quickly...

[@sseltrek1a2b]

Allie's reaction to the line: "trust the strength inside you..."....hilarious... (:

[@fitgiddlin21]

1:01:13 i assume you dont believe in the communion of saints then?Do protestants not say the apostles creed? You should have Keith nester on your show and have him explain Mary and why he converted to catholicism from protestantism despite his initial beliefs about Mary which are similar to yours and why he changed his mind. It would be a good conversation that i would definitely watch. I find it interesting how Protestants think catholics are so wrong yet us Catholics think protestants are wrong and completely misunderstand our beliefs.