Keeping The Cash without Reason

[@blinkxx3240]

“honorless greedy liar”😂😂😂😂😂 with a straight face. That took me out lol

[@davemathews7890]

Yeah, don't mince your words, bud.

[@faithsmith7253]

I love how he showed absolutely no emotion at the end when he said “Judith is an honorless, greedy, liar.” Lol!!!!!😂

[@MelissaRae1975]

Looking right into the camera

[@cinnamonrollonapancake]

Military trained - Straight to the facts, no fluff.😐

[@clarissar1528]

I had to go back and see it after I read your comment and I can't stop laughing! 😂😂

[@maryelaine-blinstrubchambe6083]

She is!!! And she has her husband by the testicle.

[@rachelharper3778]

Ahhhhh hahahaha! He made Doug shudder! Listen to the part right before Judith walks up.

[@NJgateway]

The husband was lying! He said no before the judge was even halfway through her question. That seems so shady to me. Also, I think the reason why the husband didn't come is that he's a bad liar and he did not want to be questioned by the judge. The landlord acted like she wasn't sure where the husband is at, he might be at work? She knows where he's at!

[@fzklan7535]

That's not a logical conclusion. The "no" answered the first part of the question. "Did you ever give him permission to take any of the furniture that was furnishing the place" pause "no" "and ..." "no" again.

[@Kelly22345]

He said no after the 1st question

[@keishalebray1996]

@@fzklan7535 exactly he didnt take any of the furniture, tge husband told him he could MOVE the furniture to the barn so the landlord still has it unless the husband threw it away. i have a feeling the husband isnt telling her alot of things

[@DD-d6d3]

@@fzklan7535 wrong. The audio is: "Did you ever give him permission--" "No."

[@marleonetti7]

i refinish tubs and showers and i can say that he did NOT crack that plastic / fiberglass shower , they are stress cracks that will happen on their own when they get to be a certain age if there is not enough support under the shower when it was first installed . the plaintiff should have not been charged for the shower .

[@thomasferris1905]

A few people said that the plaintiff was a Shifty grifter, but I don't see anybody bringing up the fact that the husband said no before the judge finished asking the question. That's shady AF

[@NJgateway]

I was looking for this comment. I totally agree!

[@newsflash7609]

I think the husband took the question to be "did you give him permission to take the furniture", initially. He said "no" to that and then confirmed "no" again when the question was extended to "take the furniture to the barn". I don't think that's necessarily shifty. It's the husband's assertion he didn't give him permission to do anything with furniture.

[@lcam9241]

@@newsflash7609 I completely agree. That's exactly how I took his response. //// The plaintiff didn't have any legitimate answers to me. At this point, after watching a thousand episodes, I'd advise my kids to GET EVERYTHING in writing when dealing with rentals.

[@ericedwards2853]

I was wondering about seems kinda weird and surprised the judge didn't seem to catch it

[@Nameless_mixes]

Bingo! Exactly what I was thinking! Answering a question so defensively before the question is fully asked can be a tell tale sign of a rehearsed answer that someone gives before they have the chance to think and accidentally tell the truth or get caught up in a lie.

[@patim5953]

I don't believe the defendant or her husband. Especially when she made the comment about not being smart when it comes to being a landlady. She had other renters there too so she knows what she is supposed to do. Glad the Plaintiff got some of his money back.

[@marleonetti7]

but somehow her landlady skills were up and running when it came to keeping his deposit and researching online as to the value of everything she was accusing him of taking or damaging .

[@lisavee4670]

Kurt was left speechless...😆

[@saramichele7366]

A rarity! Lol

[@WVnurseJo]

Husband said "No" before JM finished her question about the barn.... That is shady

[@Channel-JJ]

Shady AF

[@marilynwillett804]

He was probably watching the show BUT they should just give him his deposit back.

[@its.teetime]

I feel like she worded the question wrong. Like of course he was gonna say no to that

[@marleonetti7]

i refinish tubs and showers and i can say that he did NOT crack that plastic / fiberglass shower , they are stress cracks that will happen on their own when they get to be a certain age if there is not enough support under the shower when it was first installed . the plaintiff should have not been charged for the shower .

[@binyoung7297]

@@marilynwillett804 People's Court is not a live show.

[@davemathews7890]

Throwing a wild party is not a good reason for withholding a tenant's security deposit, unless the partygoers damaged the apartment.

[@saramichele7366]

And if she didn't write in the lease that he can't have parties too.

[@Nameless_mixes]

The defendant herself admitted that she wasn’t that knowledgeable about being a landlord. I bet she, her husband, and whoever else was involved didn’t do a walkthrough with the tenant/plaintiff. Then they wrongfully kept his deposit and thought he wouldn’t have the time to sue them for it given his military status.

[@aprilshowers769]

Her husband left her to deal with everything. When asked where he was she seemed un sure he was even at work

[@madi8561]

period

[@loyalwaddington3068]

He said "no" before he heard the question

[@bobbleheadmoe]

I died laughing at his interview after the verdict lol

[@leddoandroidgirl]

I did too. It almost felt like an snl sketch. 😅

[@ProudElefant44]

Judge Millian to the husband:” I just have one question for you…Did you….? Husband:”no!!!!” Well those two deserve each other. She was trying to fix her old raggedy house with tenants money. And she got the audacity to drag this guy to court when most of the time he wasn’t even there. A friend of mine had a roommate who was in the military and at one point he was gone for 6 months but his rent was still paid. Shame on this old crow

[@mannygomez5213]

She didn’t drag him to court. He drove her to court you idiott

[@ProudElefant44]

@@mannygomez5213 you fkn dumba&&. Watch it again puTo

[@mannygomez5213]

@@ProudElefant44 You sound upset

[@maryelaine-blinstrubchambe6083]

I have a feeling that the landlord ruled the roast in her home and hubby damn well better agree with her. I believed the young man and thank him for his service.

[@Ricky32908]

This guy probably has seen some shit, and does not wanna come back home to a landlord keeping his deposit after not living in the house for a YEAR, and paying every month ON TIME

[@peekaboots01]

Exactly. God bless him. I would have been disappointed if he hadn't recovered anything.

[@TheAray6]

Exactly who know who was going in and out of the house while he was gone.

[@rosestachel9378]

It is a shame that man had to come back from combat to deal with liars like Judith and Stan.

[@katiemilady4232]

Without my glasses I thought your comment said Satan instead of Stan...but I guess, it fits 🤣🤣🤣

[@binyoung7297]

Not condoning what the landlord did, but what combat.

[@ProudElefant44]

And I already know why she didn’t want her last name out too. But it’s probably Judith and Stan Rosenberg

[@benmartinez1267]

@@ProudElefant44 you think being an antisemite in the comments is funny?

[@ProudElefant44]

@@benmartinez1267 you clown. I have Jewish blood in me. And I can still call it what it is. Go eat rocks

[@monaeeuniquee2534]

I think they were shady ppl I believe the plantiff had permission to move stuff

[@vivoyeur]

Well I can tell you that there are some lying & greedy landlords and leasing management companies. I was accused of stealing a refrigerator. Thank GOD I had the foresight to have one of the managers write, sign & date a letter which read that I had replaced it with my own and theirs was put away wherever the put it (storage area?). I believe him.

[@katiemilady4232]

Oooh, you'ee good! I'm not a renter for some years now but when I was, I could have tsken a page from your book! 👌👌

[@vivoyeur]

@@katiemilady4232 Thank you. 😊

[@oldageisdumb]

But there are also lying, greedy tenants that trash places and squat. We’ve seen them on this show. It’s not one side or the other that’s better.

[@LawsonPatterson]

That sounds like the guy was renting a shit hole. “Take advantage of my generosity”🤣

[@Channel-JJ]

Yea what generosity is she talking about, they had a business agreement.

[@marilynwillett804]

No just probably an old farm house, or an apt. in it.

[@glenncurley680]

The Husband is a liar! He said, "NO" before she finished her question. I agree with the tenant, "Judy is an honor-less, greedy, liar".

[@familytv9585]

He looks like a JC Penny’s model out of a catalog and she looks like an elementary school teacher.😅

[@jamesomalley6339]

Her husband didn't even listen to the full question before she even finished... c'mon judge Cant believe you didn't catch that

[@Ahhmisohornie]

Unfortunately, a lot of landlords try to take advantage of service members and think because they have orders to leave the state they won’t press the issue of a security deposit. A lot of times you’ll get some unknowledgeable younger adults who don’t know what to do and these idiots get away with ripping them off.

[@karondalittlejohn]

Simply because of who the lad is (plus there being other tenants), I would have just sucked it up, as a landlord! Thank you for your service sir!

[@cinnamonrollonapancake]

Exactly. We owe them much more than they get.

[@peekaboots01]

Exactly!!

[@peekaboots01]

@@cinnamonrollonapancake so much more. It's sad.

[@moniquepollard1763]

I really don’t understand how I’m some cases if the litigant doesn’t have all the evidence she’s like tough, yet others she’s willing to call recess or let them call someone. It’s like the judge has in her mind who she wants to favor and bends rules for the select few.

[@mamathemeat]

Yeah she uses her “judgement” because she’s a judge. That’s what they do 🤣

[@moniquepollard1763]

@@mamathemeat sometimes her “judgements” seem pre judged. Like she’s willing to do more for litigants. There were many instances when a litigant didn’t have all their evidence and she said tough. Where as there are others where she will take a recess to let them get their evidence.

[@mamathemeat]

@@moniquepollard1763 yes maybe if she doesn’t help them then she thinks they are full of it. All judges do that . They are just ppl at tne end of the day

[@peekaboots01]

@@moniquepollard1763 it depends on the case. She has already read the complaint and answer and looked at any exhibits before the show, so she already has an idea when to just let it go or when she needs testimony or evidence from someone else to help make her decision.

[@stfuyoutube423]

I think the defendant is a lying 🤥 old bat 🦇!

[@kittyfan]

VERY convenient that the husband isn't there to testify. For all anyone knows, the shower stuff was broken by hubby when he was away.

[@Nomadicninjas]

I know that look. He’s seen some shit. I hope he’s getting help.

[@armynurseshark]

Yep

[@Channel-JJ]

Curt was not about try and push the plaintiff's buttons 😁

[@laurad2403]

Curt did not know what to say to the plaintiff during the post-case interview 🤣 one of the few times he did not give some type of response

[@jasminehaywood7682]

I was thinking the same thing 🤣🤣🤣

[@armynurseshark]

Curt knew that dude is on the edge

[@MelissaRae1975]

Hell I think he was scared lol

[@katiemilady4232]

This is the Q&A... Judge: Did you ever give him permission to TAKE the furniture (question completed below Stan: No Judge: (finishing the question) and put it in the barn? Stan: No I took from that maybe he was thinking the wife told JM that he TOOK the furnture then realized she told him he put it in the barn so Stan said no again. So he said no to taking it and leaving it...so what was it. Both shady liars. I loved that end...Kurt was finally left speechless "Judith is an honorless liar". Yes Sir, she is. Thank you for your service. 🙏💪👏👏👏

[@WeezyJeffersonYo]

I noticed the Plaintiff doesn't answer Judge Milian directly with a yes or no. Any question she asked him he never does.

[@melknowles3936]

I knew he was in the military before even saying it.

[@barbaraness4507]

The comments that the plaintiff made at the end were crude, and didn’t make him look good. He could have expressed himself in a more tactful manner.

[@marleonetti7]

um , lady , it was not your generosity that allowed him to live there , it was the fact that he paid u RENT ! and i refinish tubs and showers and i can say that he did NOT crack that plastic / fiberglass shower , they are stress cracks that will happen on their own when they get to be a certain age if there is not enough support under the shower when it was first installed . the plaintiff should have not been charged for the shower .

[@EasyGrilling101]

You just had to poke the bear didn't you, holy crap this was one of the best episodes!

[@leofredette19]

" Claiming he had " Wild Parties " but you've never actually seen one.

[@Lolalenice]

Woman and her husband took advantage of that man they figured military man won’t care

[@williestubz7957]

My man had the crazy stare, kurt knew not to mess with him

[@Channel-JJ]

You know Curt wanted to say something but thought better of it, I think his butt tightened a bit after the plaintiff spoke. 😂

[@joeanthony9162]

Yup. Not only was she lying, her husband said No even before the judge finished her question. He was definitely lying!!!

[@tamekadavis6641]

Hand over the cash lady. Lol 😂

[@michaelmarquez6133]

This crap pisses me off, people rent out there houses and always want to keep the deposit. They get surprised when someone is actually using the property, The fact that she kept it without even sending a letter or anything and didn't give an itemized list Is ridiculous! And she acted pissed off because they threw parties!!! Who the he'll cares ! How does that effect her? Her own grandson is living there and the beer cans looked like they were in the trash

[@randomrebecka6778]

I don’t believe the landlord at all. I think she’s a liar and just wants money and I also think this was a horrible horrible judgment from Judge Milian. The shower surround I guess I could see may be a small amount but the furniture no way.

[@Jamericancutie2024]

those landlords are scammers 😂

[@Liv2Pnt]

It's always the same question on the street in these cases..."Who's shadier, landlords or tenants?" Come on, Harvey...

[@lisaking4474]

Question for me is since there are other people on the property did they use his place while he was deployed. Did not like the verdict as I believe the husband did tell him to move things to the barn. Husband should of been in court to answer questions since he had more contact with plaintiff than she did. Also do not count out the nephew doing things.

[@TheAray6]

That shower door was probably broken when they removed the wood from the bathroom. She even said they removed the wood surrounding the shower door. Who the hell puts wood in a bathroom. They wanted to to use his security deposit and additional 3,000 dollars if they won here to get new renovated bathroom and a brand new couch. And the grandson was probably attending a lot of the parties if not throwing the parties himself!

[@kaykepop4084]

The defendant and her husband are both lying! The man has lived there for years and if he moved their furniture into the barn without their permission I'm almost certain they would have said and done something then, but they didn't. And now she and her husband are acting like they had no clue he had moved the furniture.

[@peekaboots01]

Yeah the defendants were awful.

[@TammieR-B]

Oh well...... that end comment though

[@pmabrouk]

no love lost there

[@aimeekenney1550]

How the heck does the defendant think she was being generous? She charged the man rent and was trying to keep his deposit. I agree with his assessment of her.

[@michaelshields7777]

Henry Rollins goes to the People's Court, hehehe!!!

[@Geronimo2Fly]

Man, the guy was there for years and always paid his rent on time. Just give him his security deposit back. SMH. (And I am a landlord, not a tenant.)

[@vorco8120]

I agree with the JM’s decision here. Lots of comments are saying that the defendant and her husband are lying about the furniture being missing. Im sure JM caught on to that with how trigger happy the husband was with his response and didn’t want to argue over the telephone. Also when the defendant said that she wasn’t too knowledgeable in being a landlord, I’m sure JM took that as a shady comment. Pretty sure that JM just gave the lady something to keep her from pushing anything further. Notice how JM didn’t make a ruling on the defendant’s counter claim because we all know it’s based off more shadiness. Good call from the judge.

[@jb3702]

Damn.... I'd cross the street if I saw him coming!

[@Chvyqueen7566]

The plantiff looks like he is about to SNAP!!I'm scared watching this episode👀

[@dellahicks7231]

That lady wanted her dang 15 minutes at the 7:14 mark! 🎤 The defendant came in lieu of the husband, because the couple thought JM would go lighter on a, "Aw shucks, I don't know anything about landlording judge" grandmother! Not often Curt is caught with his mouth open!!

[@vw7667]

Why wasn’t her husband in court? There telling the tenant 2 different things. He’s coming off tours I doubt he kept a messy place. I feel like the grandson was prolly letting his friends in there. House was sitting empty for a year at times

[@arianefr78]

Of course the husband is going to say the same as his wife and it showed because he answered NO before the judge had finished asking her question, and was he even sworn in?

[@brittanyylee1833]

Those shower doors do suddenly break sometimes.. mine has

[@thatsassyrepublican]

That BS, I've always heard her say that the security portion that should be doubled if no letter is sent to tenant but the double happens AFTER deductions are made if there is damage. So in his case he would only be doubling a few dollars not the entire 750 I dont get it.

[@Annie_Annie__]

Those kinds of laws vary greatly by state. In some states it’s doubled (or tripled) before taking deductions, in some states no deductions are taken at all as punishment against the landlord for not following the rules and then it might be doubled or tripled; it just depends. Judge Milian tries to follow the laws of the litigants’ state of residence rather than the state they’re doing the arbitration in (which happens to be the same state in this case, if I’m not mistaken).

[@BeKind2AllKinds]

The plaintiff is a frightening person. I hope he stays away from animals, children, and women. Walking red flag.

[@melissalewis5759]

The landlord is shady. But he’s sketch

[@graduatge105]

I don’t believe the defendant, her husband or the plaintiff. Lol.

[@angelslive9651]

That Guy was funny at the End 😂😂 she is greedy

[@EnigmaShauna]

Damn. That dude is intense.

[@-TOH-]

The guy outside the door mocking an active duty veteran with a fake "thank you for your service" is offensive.

[@yung1717]

How do you know it was mocking?

[@cinnamonrollonapancake]

I think he was just left with nothing else to say and respected his straightforward, militant response.🤷🏽‍♀️

[@marilynwillett804]

He simply said; Thank you for your service, paranoia will destroy ya.

[@peekaboots01]

Yes it was! I agree.

[@soapydesigner]

Thank you for your service and trashing someone elses house...

[@MrAllan9]

And the greedy lady pays.😆 Love it when justice is served.

[@colombiangoddess]

I wish Doug was there. You know he would tell the defendant what the plaintiff said lol

[@24blunt]

haha thats what she gets. and hubby was lying

[@Sweetpea1128]

I don’t particularly like the plaintiff, but I really don’t like the defendant. I think she was playing the weak little woman role to get more than she deserved.

[@alij6940]

That husband was lying on the phone. He just didn't want sht from his wife.

[@crystalshaw8744]

Should've been titled "We didn't start the fire ". Lmbo

[@shirleywiese5230]

I wish he was able to prove he wasn’t home when the shower broke. Didn’t lots of other ppl lived there.

[@34stzoo]

10:05 This really creeped me out, both of them!

[@zachweaver8526]

that plaintiff was not lying.

[@LeolaGlamour]

My understanding is that military doesn’t have to give a 30 day notice but I could be wrong.

[@mickeypoo305]

“Yeah. Um. Thank you for your service.”

[@bearnemati6359]

The stuff he left behind has a greater value than the old furniture she wants to get money for 😮

[@ChristineJonah88]

Plaintiff should have gotten all that he was asking.

[@ainttoosara]

How if he had to pay $800 of 2x security did he only got awarded $600?

[@MelissaRae1975]

Lol even Curt knew to just leave his comment alone...scared him

[@layahYasharahla]

The man did not answer before she was done because he clearly knew where she was going . She got out ‘did you give him permission to take the furniture- NO!” Then she finished so basically I don’t find him to be a liar like the comments are saying . HOWEVER . I do think the couch was old so the plaintiff threw it out . That man also looks like he hates life lol 😂 he went from soldier to Manchurian

[@lando1071]

Plaintiff looks scary. Looks like he could go off the deep end one day 😳

[@adriankasan6344]

For being a soldier he needs to take responsibility and grow up

[@shannoncarlson6960]

Not sure I trust either of them. The plaintiff was very quick to deny everything like the defendant. I believed him until he said he didn't leave beer cans around (probably from the people moving him). Come on! Weird case.

[@lukerinderknecht2982]

The plaintiff is shady -- he doesn't directly answer the Judge's yes or no questions.

[@adrianprince7266]

I agree with Milian's ruling in this case. She balanced everything out on both sides here.

[@bhornannawindeedeigh5007]

@Adrian Prince Adrian Knight (the same person): 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮

[@latricebrown7942]

The landlords are definitely shady

[@urluvizmyluv1999]

Do I think he's lying... 🤷🏽‍♀️ idk but what I do know is I'm a soldier and during my service I've met many dishonest soldiers.

[@catherineeckstein2705]

Guaranteed they smashed that shower door after he left so they could get a new replacement for free.

[@adriennef4637]

Wow, cro magnon man has super creepy vibes. Whatever he's been through in the military has clearly traumatized him. I have ptsd so I can see it in others. There's a haunted look in the eyes almost like a cornered animal. Always being on alert and hyper aware takes a toll on a person.

[@marilynwillett804]

Relax, he has no creepy vibes. he is not traumatized. We were military many years, and my dad was in a war.

[@Web19814]

I'm going to guess Marines. He definitely seems like he has been through a lot. Either way, she is a liar

[@pizzelle2]

If you actually had PTSD or a history of trauma you wouldn’t pretend to empathize with someone and then describe their trauma-connected affect and tone as “super creepy vibes”…yikes

[@adriennef4637]

@@pizzelle2 The only yeesh here is you questioning not only my diagnosis but knowledge & experience on the subject🙄

[@pizzelle2]

@@adriennef4637 Sure sweetie, keep disparaging the trauma victim while pretending to have expertise, that makes a lot of sense 😂😂

[@iloveyouyoulovemeify]

hes intense

[@12Daze]

He seems like a fun guy...

[@kia4334]

I knew right of the bat he was military. It shows.

[@biruss]

Judith has vibes of Dolores umbridge

[@aqutron]

Boy was he Stoic.

[@millissentflemmings2216]

I could tell that the plaintiff was probably in the military based on the way he spoke. 🇺🇸

[@dennisstrope8912]

Why do you have to thank someone for their service… they volunteered for it and knew what they were getting into. Why do they need thanked

[@Klw2010]

What? That's like saying why do you have to thank someone for holding the door open for you? They volunteered to do it and knew what they were doing... Or a doctor saving your life.. that's his job right? No need to thank him.. actually with your logic.. there would be no point to thank anyone at all!

[@mamathemeat]

Because they wanted to? You don’t have to do anything

[@laquanperez2425]

I don’t believe those landlords.

[@TheRedlobsterguy]

Defendant is such a liar.