Shaykh Atabek Shukurov | Mortgages, Madhabs & Molvi-ism | MindTrap 48 | Mufti Abu Layth

[@nischay1810]

What a top man Shaykh Atabek. Love him. JazakAllah khayr for bringing him on Mufti saheb.

[@SB-co9py]

I’ve been waiting for this for years.

[@moinmuslim4482]

Two legends in one frame

[@iftekharul_islam_ifat]

33:00 I just love the chemistry between these two men here. This episode was an absolute treat! We definitely need a follow-up discussion. ❤️

[@hassanalbasirjamal7013]

birds of a feather

[@SafwanNet]

Spot on

[@Adrian-yf1zg]

Great to hear from a hanafi trying to follow the true spirit of the Imam. Imam Abu Yusuf more or less was a hadithi hanafi, and was so spared the criticism the other hanafis faced from the die hard habalis. I personally think the mutazilis were right on many issues, but we only hear their views from their enemies who "won the war and wrote history".

[@Xaviergonzalez85]

Read "The Wahhabi Myth" by Haneef James Oliver.

[@upquark31415]

And Mu'tazilis only have themselves to blame. There was no need to take the khalq al-Qur'an issue to the state level. Their persecution during the mihna is what turned the sentiment towards their adversaries.

[@hassanabdaladl]

@@Xaviergonzalez85 looks like that book is written by a salafi, trying to save face for the salafis, and white wash reality.

[@mrnomad1737]

Extreme mutazolite also justified being married to their sister..they used logic to the extreme. People missread and misquote and misunderstanding. Both Ibn Sena and Imam Ibn Taiyuan had a lot in common but this is either overlooked or overshadowed by the liberalism tendencies with ibn seenas idolised. Both are byproduct of their time and addressi g their scholars of time. So let's be balanced. projective relativity understanding does great deservice.

[@UnderBaseBeatz]

Love that you did a podcast with Shaykh Atabek! JazakAllah Khayre!

[@rosh70]

Mufti Abu Layth - Not sure if you fully realize, but your videos like these are so much the need of the hour. May Allah SWT bless you manifold for opening minds and hearts. Aameen.

[@imammazhar]

Allahuakbar! May the Almighty revive the genuine school of reason; the school of al Imām Abū Ḥanīfah al Nu'mān! Bārak Allāh fīk dear Muftī for this insightful episode with Shaykh Atabek ❤️💯✌🏻

[@rabbi619]

Is it ok to reject a hadith book that is unauthentic like the books before bukhari like mussanaf ibne abi shaiba, mussanaf abdur razzak, baihaqi these type of book that has more daif and mozu hadith is it ok to reject these hadith books and another question is it ok to reject hasan hadith can we reject hasan hadith please answer these questions.

[@abdq4712]

1:09:54 'Hadith is not valid except from the fuqaha, and it is not valid except for the fuqaha', that is something to truly ponder.

[@mustikhan7512]

Thank you so much for introducing Shaykh Atabek. I have watched Atabek’s talks and I am so grateful to you mufti coz Atabek is doing a great job of breaking the silence on Hadrat Ali and his staus in Sunni Jamaat. Sunni Scholars do not talk much about Hadrat Ali.

[@mustikhan7512]

I did’nt know Shaykh Atabek and now after watching your mindtrap, started lustening to him on other youtube channels. All independant islamic scholars are doing a great job by speaking honestly and daringly about problematic hadiths, hadrat Ali and on many other historical and political games played by that time kings, governors and how they influenced the islamic literature .

[@shien121]

Beautiful conversation

[@ekaa96]

Wow, Amazing guest! Love it.

[@Roadtodotca]

Two Legends!

[@immers12345]

Great level of respect between these 2 intellectuals. Really enjoyed it. Alhamdulillah!!! 👍

[@kyzersmansion2487]

Amazing, big fan of shaykh atabek!

[@rosh70]

Irrespective of any differences based on knowledge (mainly, Fiqh), both these Learned Personalities are my favorites. Very good discussion - looking forward to more such discussions.

[@rg8128]

Shaykh Atabek is an absolute Don. His way of flipping topics on their heads. Just a brilliant and epic Mindtrap. Please mufti book the Shaykh for 3/4 hour slot. Stay blessed

[@ertugrulbayrak11]

So much dignity and respect between you two very enlightening to see! Much respect love!

[@saeerseik7577]

Please bring back him😭😭😭

[@معراج-ل4ب]

😭

[@blissmadmenful]

Thank you for bringing such a great person on your show. awaiting the follow up with the sheikh on ur show.

[@thehourglassfan3515]

What an enjoyable, respectful dialogue! Hopefully, the two of you will have another one soon! God bless you both.

[@alexanderhomoky1140]

Bar Atabek opening soon! (inshaAllah) ❤

[@hassanabdaladl]

Mufti you need to schedule this 2-3 hour talk with Shaykh Atabek asap lol that made me excited

[@mohamedakram1183]

WOW Shaykh Atabek

[@fraudsfc]

Wow. What a guest and what a discussion!? Thoroughly enjoyed this one mufti. Thank you and I look forward to more discussions with the sheikh on your program. It was excellent

[@shahrukhgilani5246]

مفتی صاحب ایسا معلوم ہوتا ہے دل کی بات سن لی آپ نے! اس قسط کا منتظر تھا!

[@khanG-gq9hc]

Incredible! 🔥🔥

[@Strawberry40789]

Mufti Saab please make another Interview with him about the topic about Imam Zufar

[@asiemmalik736]

Next meet up could focus on voice of reason when approaching Quran and Hadith, book Maliki principles in approaching Hadith, and when do we understand Quran literally or allegorically ? 👍🏼

[@Mohammed-er3il]

26:00

[@waleeyahya198]

Two Dons out there!💪😎

[@jivaji2028]

Please do part 2🙏

[@syedzainrehan]

Aswr, excellent discussion masha Allaah(swt). Would love to see more from akhi Atabek. jazakum Allaah(swt) khair!

[@slkslk7841]

Was waiting for this mindtrap !!!!!

[@memememmee7794]

Mufti, thank you for keeping it professional the whole way through! Shaykh atabek deserves our full attention and may Allah bless you both with the best

[@Saracen786]

An incredible discussion thank you both. Got so many questions in my head after this. Please get Shaykh Atabek back soon- can’t wait!

[@RayyanMusa]

This was an amazing insight into how the personal preferences of Ulama affect how they give their opinion on Fiqh and do not follow the principles laid by founding Madhab scholars.

[@muslimabubakar9384]

Please let us have part 2! Please

[@samid7214]

Legends 💪🏻

[@asathelogiclaman637]

I am literally even ready to beg Mufti for a round 2 on other topics of Islam.... I really hope Mufti ji there will be another mindtrap with atabek brother💞✌️💯

[@usmant100]

Epic! I reckon a weekly session of these two legends dealing with common issues of today would literally revolutionise Islamic thought! ! Thank you for your efforts MALM🤘

[@Ali-jm4re]

Mufti sahab did you do your mufti course at the near by disco club?

[@mohamedakram1183]

I sm still waiting for Shaykh Stabek last 3months but still no reply. Thanks Mohamed Akram

[@musicstan9139]

Where can i get the classical text mufti?

[@hassanabdaladl]

Lol "the legend, the man, the myth". Ya Mufti, the saying goes 'the man, the myth, the legend' hahahaha

[@umeriqbal5406]

Mufti needs to watch John Wick again to get his quotes right.

[@waqaryounas3057]

He says it probably in 1 32 25

[@tx6314]

Any books on the early hanif is mufti saab?

[@whatsupwhatsup9498]

21:28 What about the great religious scholars of Egypt who also shaving their beards? At least the moroccan scholars are no hypocrites and I'm not even a moroccan, but I think it's so disrespectful to talk about the scientists like that, Who are those guys to judge others like that as if shaving beard is the worst thing a human can do. I mean shirk and immoral behavior is everywhere in Muslim countries and we are being attacked from all sides and the only thing we worry about is the scholars shaving their beards.

[@omerfawadrauf7369]

Can someone please share the interaction between ash. Atabek with Sh Asrar.

[@zoolothman3609]

amazing discussion as always mufti. a shame it was cut short though. but greatly appreciate your time and efforts to bring these much needed discussions to the masses! Thanks a million.

[@mohamedakram1183]

Masha Allah

[@m-i_]

Lets address the elephant in the room: as awesome and reasonable shk. Atabek is, he has vids with him believing in black magic, Mahdi and the return of Isa( opposite of Mufti's views) Wish next session would be about these. Thanks Mufti for your time and effort!

[@arshaanfur]

Ya the whole elixirs for covid thing got new a bit sus too. But whatever I'm sure he's not doing anything that's harmful to the health

[@Adrian-yf1zg]

Nothing wrong with differing views even if they seem wacko. He is comfortable having a dialogue and is not a deobandi hadithi fanatic... Which in my view is good, as it adds more diversity.

[@m-i_]

@@Adrian-yf1zg take black magic tho, it's a superstition.

[@Adrian-yf1zg]

@@m-i_ yes i don't believe in it. But i would say the vast majority of muslims do and they have some hadith that support them. Deobandis like ashraf ali thanvi also have books supporting that. While these are points that can be argued over, i'm glad mufti concentrated on the issues of hanafi fiqh, aturudi aqidah and the primacy of hadith status... I'd rather hear the shaykhs views on those points than all the other stuff which agrees with most deobandis/muslims anyway.

[@UnderBaseBeatz]

Who cares, no elephant in the room. There are differences in opinion amongst those that are qualified to draw those opinions! God will still reward the effort of the scholar that got it wrong! It's all good.

[@hammadsiddiqui8421]

Thank you mufti

[@DarioHaruni]

Check out also the Hanafi of Turkey, Albania, Kosovo and Bosnia. Nothing in common with Pakistani Hanafi.

[@somayyamughal8313]

How?

[@DarioHaruni]

@@somayyamughal8313 u mean Why?

[@AbdullahodSandzak]

I can attest to what he says. The hanafi of Bosnia and turkey are very Syrian style hanafi, which are not as "hardcore" as the Indian hanafi. But again, in India you have deobandi and brelvi which are kind of different to each other.

[@DarioHaruni]

@fahad alam check out Hoxhë Drilon Gashi on KZbin if you understand Albanian. He's from Kosovo.

[@tausif3k]

why is that?

[@avnisekiraqqa3365]

Wy dont you dialog with Paul williams

[@wajahathussainalhanafi1369]

Asslamo Alaikum Mufti Sahab, I hope and pray that you are ever green as always. Mufti, I wanted to contact you but my Fb account is closed. So couldn't get in touch with you. I have sent an email to you as well. Please could you check. Thanks. Best Regards.

[@mdabdl4225]

If we can see ustaadh wajahat Hussain and mufti discussing Hadith (and its principal) would be fantastic. As seen from wajahat Hussain videos he has v good command Over this subject. Mufti Sahab plz look into this request as it will another as they say in Urdu damakedar video (explosive hahah )

[@chin8062]

Really interesting conversation, would love to see Shaykh Atabek to embrace social media and share his works.

[@fulaan1]

Muwatta by the narration of Imam Muhammad??

[@mainulhusainkhan1333]

Assalamu alaikum. Personally I respect both of you, as you are trying to do something unprecedented. May Allaah show you the right path. I have a question on the concept "Mortgage = taukil + murabaha". In Murabaha model, isn't it like the seller has to own the property before being able to sell? We know that banks don't deal with the product or house itself, they transfer the money to your account and you are the one who buys the property, then bank treats your property as security against non-payment. Bank is, in my understanding, only dealing with money, unless it is a house in foreclosure. Am I getting it wrong? it would be great if this was explained a little bit more. Jazak Allaahu khair! By the way, the 'taukil' rationale was mind blowing indeed.

[@businesswatch1206]

In Murabaha transaction, it’s a Shari’a condition that the Islamic bank needs to own the asset prior to selling. The Islamic bank purchases the asset in its name and then sells it to the customer under Murabaha agreement. In case the customer acts as an agent, he then purchases the asset on behalf of the Islamic bank and then purchases the asset from the bank under Murabaha agreement. The non-Islamic bank usually transfers the funds to the customer’s account to enable him to purchase the asset. It doesn’t need to own the asset. However, in both Murabaha & non-Islamic banking transactions, the asset is mortgaged as collateral.

[@mainulhusainkhan1333]

@BusinessWatch and ​@MrNK, many thanks for clarifying. This helps me understand it better.

[@shahjahaAn]

Maa sadqeh

[@gondala]

the quality sound of syaikh attabek is bad. i cannot hear clearly what he said.

[@drusman7121]

Mufti sahib please one more episode on Early Hanafi school and Abu Zufar with Sheikh.❤️

[@bbaa9447]

The preeminent Hanafi scholar of today.

[@bbaa9447]

Because he knows the classic Hanafi texts and verdicts. Not some Wahabi-Deobandi petrodollar mumbo jumbo. He humiliated Asrar Rashid.

[@bbaa9447]

@Tik Rak I subscribe to certain parts of both schools Zaidism/Twelverism and also the Mu’tazila and Falasifa (Ibn Sina). Don’t subscribe to a particular one as all are human interpretations at the end of the day.

[@bbaa9447]

@Tik Rak what do you mean what is my discord? Please explain.

[@bbaa9447]

@Tik Rak I am 33, I don’t consider myself that old lol. But perhaps I am as I didn’t know about this app. Yeah I’ll download it. What is your beliefs?

[@bbaa9447]

@Tik Rak Nice. Great to find someone with a similar intellectual/spiritual journey. Would be good to discuss our perspectives and learn more inshAllah.

[@SalimCaparica]

Very Interesting! Please bring Shaykh Atabek Shukurov back for the mentioned Hanafi Madhab Episode

[@muslim-g1x]

28:00 mortgage

[@halilhasani4000]

❤️❤️❤️

[@mumen4806]

Mufti sahab 2-3 questions thai ek do hadith kai related ..not on this topic kahaa puchu insta pai reply nahi diya aapnai

[@arshaanfur]

I love shayk atabeek We need more mindtraps with him asap mufti. Get him at a time when he's fresh and awake and can talk about hanafi history without being tired. On another note though : I do think the shayk is a bit too mean to our BELOVVEEEDD shayk asrar :P

[@sheikhsadi5745]

That’s because Asrar calls him a mubtadi, even though Shaykh Atabek is far more qualified in the Hanafi school not only in its Fiqh but in Aqueedah i.e. early Hanafi & Maturidi. He actually specialises in Aqueedah

[@MegaRippon]

Two awesome scholars - a very educative session

[@kultnoir]

Abu Laith As-Samarqandi was also from today's Uzbekistan

[@drusman7121]

What an amazing mintrap Mufti sahib. Waiting for the follow up ❤️

[@ahmadhusny7849]

I respect maulana, mufti from Pakistan, Bangladesh and India, MashAllah very knowledgeable, but I am very disappointed when coming to their own culture, their culture is more important than religion, the culture is above religion. I visited Pakistan, I was shocked people worship the grave and dead body. May Allah guide us to right path

[@nourhelel2873]

Asalaam aleikom mufti.how are doing and feeling?inshaAllah good en well and family too...jazaika Allahu gairan for this mindtrap.in this three major video's.masaAllah i learn do much from you.mat Allah reward for that...zo much questions are now...and specially about problematiek hadiths and thinking in Islam...❤❤❤...may Allah subhana wa'talle protect and bless you and your family...

[@somayyamughal8313]

Majority of muslim are hanfi.. abu layth

[@abdurraheem2516]

Sheikh is grossly mistaken on the issue of Beard that the length of the beard is only raised by Indo-Pak subcontinent scholars. The first one to talk about the length was Imam Sughnaki known as sahib un nihaya. Sheikh should clear it as it was an academic mistake by him.

[@abulhakim9405]

Sheikh is awesome and his ideas and his mission is commendable. But on the other note, I think that we have fallen so behind and backward. While non Muslims just landed on Mars, we are still struggling with these low level BS stuff.

[@متين-ج4ز]

Non-Muslims are burning the world, who cares about sending a hunk on Mars.

[@justCommando]

Goodbye "islamic" culture! Hello shiny new house on a mortgage! Nothing's gonna stop me. This year or early next year inshallah 😁

[@musmanov4642]

Follow your desires

[@seleimansafi4287]

A Hanafi and a Hanafi in denial :-)

[@supporterofeastturkestanin2871]

abu layth likes spending time with half-naked (or totally naked) girls/women, he is preoccupied with making himself more and more bulkier, it is apparent from the very first glimpse at him, but despite it there are people who continue to admire him. why such people (like abu layth) roam the planet freely causing mischief on earth?! is not anyone out there to put an end to such people?!

[@omerali2690]

It seems you are personally following him, you naughty naughty....

[@kanwar47]

This Shaykh is a waffler.

[@huzaif3962]

Two legends in one frame