Officer ARRESTS Citizen For Asking TOO MANY Questions

Install Raid for Free ✅ IOS: clik.cc/QhjBW ✅ ANDROID: clik.cc/UEr7h Start with💰50K silver and get a Free Epic Champion 💥 on day 7 of “New Player Rewards” program
**CORRECTION** M4 went on to settle his claim for an undisclosed amount.
Welcome to Audit The Audit, where we sort out the who and what and the right and wrong of police interactions. Help us grow and educate more citizens and officers on the proper officer interaction conduct by liking this video and/or subscribing.
This video is for educational purposes and is in no way intended to provoke, incite, or shock the viewer. This video was created to educate citizens on constitutionally protected activities and emphasize the importance that legal action plays in constitutional activism.
Bear in mind that the facts presented in my videos are not indicative of my personal opinion, and I do not always agree with the outcome, people, or judgements of any interaction. My videos should not be construed as legal advice, they are merely a presentation of facts as I understand them.
FAIR USE
This video falls under fair use protection as it has been manipulated for educational purposes with the addition of commentary. This video is complementary to illustrate the educational value of the information being delivered through the commentary and has inherently changed the value, audience and intention of the original video.
Original video: bit.ly/2OsXgKN
M4’s channel: bit.ly/2Qzo4vz
Sources:
Refusal:
bit.ly/2XtGq2u
bit.ly/2O3onxe
K-9 units:
bit.ly/35lTdXI
bit.ly/2D1tOWR
Rodriguez ruling:
bit.ly/344nWZ0
bit.ly/2qklgYJ
bit.ly/35fY8t1
Locked containers:
bit.ly/2KCrppU
Patreon: / audittheaudit
Facebook: / audit-the-audit-209178...
Twitter: / audittheaudit
Audit the Audit 2: bit.ly/2CD2b6j

[@AuditTheAudit]

Thanks again to Raid for sponsoring this video. Install Raid for Free ✅ IOS: clik.cc/QhjBW ✅ ANDROID: clik.cc/UEr7h Start with💰50K silver and get a Free Epic Champion 💥 on day 7 of “New Player Rewards” program

[@pfunk9632]

Finally an audit channel that is reputable enough for a sponsor 👍 This is the only audit channel im proud enough to share without seeming like a crazy person. Good for you, keep up the great channel ✌️

[@danporath536]

Audit the Audit Glad you have sponsorship.

[@grannygear1001]

Audit the Audit / thanks be to sponsors!

[@grannygear1001]

They broke into his car because of a two day late inspection sticker? I have rescued dogs, a trick dog, agility dog, and a therapy dog. I know dogs do make mistakes.

[@SuSpInTiOn]

@@Cinzanos83 What's your deal? AtA needs to eat just like the rest of us, he works hard on his videos and gathers information, case law, etc. to inform the Auditing community on interesting stories, I hope he did make a lot of money but that doesn't change my opinion of him either way, I want good content creators to thrive and the only way many can is with Ads in their videos, if this means we can continue to get content then I'm more than happy to watch a minute ad so we can keep AtA around longer! It's not cops advertising on his channel, so it's nothing that's going to change his objective and subjective reasoning so let the man make some money to stay afloat and stop being sad a content creator gets to make something from their hard work!

[@Jpeazify]

Update: M4 sued the city as a result of this false arrest and reached a settlement of $160,000

[@domingodeanda233]

So cool

[@Callie1981]

@@Capybaraking76 Ever heard of Google?

[@Paul_dw_Kersey]

Fantastic!

[@knightofsapphire1601]

This right here, is the best part of these videos. Thank you.

[@SF-lf5cu]

that fine should be paid by the officers who conducted the traffic stop and not the citizens tax dollars. it seems ignorant to have this citizen essentially pay himself for the trouble caused by the officers.

[@dexagalapagos]

When a K9 unit is called and gets a "hit" and then finds nothing, that K9 unit should be deemed unfit for service and retired.

[@Anarchic1989]

I hear the police can train their K9s to get false "hits" to search vehicles.

[@dexagalapagos]

@@Anarchic1989 Naturally. It's just a legal workaround for them to search any vehicle they want at any time by signalling their dog to sit.

[@Anarchic1989]

@@dexagalapagos That's just bullshit lol.

[@paulrash7249]

What would happen if the K9s were declared "unfit" after exposing the car searched to have no drugs? Police K9 units would then PLANT drugs to insure their K9 was NEVER declared unfit...I KNOW FOR A FACT HOW CORRUPT MANY OFFICERS ARE ! ! ! I not only have current and former friends in law enforcement but also a few family members who told MANY stories of police abuse (this was in Philadelphia during the 70s & 80s) including suspects who needed serious medical attention after falling up elevator shafts...yes, up.

[@gregkey9799]

@@paulrash7249 OK, I gotta ask, how does one fall up an elevator shaft? It seems to defy the laws of physics.

[@nathanmiller9918]

As a teenager, a long time ago, was at a field party when several sheriffs came on the property. They lined us all up and had an obviously old dog walk the line. It alerted to nothing. Most of us had weed in our pockets. We didn't have the heart to tell them that their dog no longer worked.

[@halinaqi2194]

Lol dkm

[@__-bz7wh]

Lol

[@WarPartyFitness]

I may be wrong but I thought they were trained to hit on objects and not actual persons. And that is why I’m school they ask people to leave their belongings on the desk along with bags etc.

[@adamwillis908]

@@WarPartyFitness So the dog wouldn't be able to detect drugs in a backpack while a person is wearing it, but would suddenly become able to detect them when the backpack is placed on a desk? Unless human beings emit some kind of dog interference pheromone, I'd have to question that logic.

[@Playingwithproxies]

@@adamwillis908 it’s not interference it’s training. If they are trained to not alert on humans they will not hit. It’s probably for the safety of the officer as a person could attack or run if the dog alerts on him.

[@michaellopez4746]

I can't believe they arrested the dog and put him in dog jail.

[@4megapete]

When the fat cop said "what constitution?" I almost lost it😂

[@Dannysphotography]

Peter Gebhardt smh 🤦🏻‍♂️ he looked so stupid

[@yummygummy3416]

time stamp please

[@23e.chromosoom]

dont like fat jokes butt goddamme your a fat cop...jesus. is it required to be fat...

[@warblerab2955]

yeah, he shouldn't have asked that, but nonetheless, case law is legally binding(unless a judge rules that a given ruling is in violation of the Constitution.

[@jbrhel]

I just stumbled across this video. Before I even watched it I read your comment "what Constitution?"

[@MDAdams72668]

serve and protect has become harass and collect

[@trealsteve]

They only serve and protect corporations. Always have. Always will.

[@rabbit0664]

That and sit on there bum and shoo people away. Long story short I tried to file a report. They refused and kept sending me from department to department.

[@donttreadonrick9981]

To insalve and imprison.

[@rabbit0664]

@ApplePie That's a real shame. Sorry that happened to you and wish the cops were more helpful to us and those who need them.

[@war32mec]

Exactly right!!!!

[@toddr2265]

Can you imagine how many hundreds if not thousands of people they've illegally detained and arrested before this video came out.

[@Levegetable]

Fuck Ukraine.

[@tracyeaves4847]

Minor offense -- the officers escalated the stop into an arrest. Clear example of Tyrant behavior......Must all be removed from law enforcement.

[@lil.mountenlighting7682]

My dude representing himself and winning what a baller

[@cerebrumexcrement]

😎

[@jeffrejr1]

You keep all of the cash.

[@brettmoore3194]

@@jeffrejr1 you mean illegal promissary notes that are devalued daily with occult symbolism ,one of them being Moloch ,deity that needs children sacrifice

[@jeffrejr1]

@@brettmoore3194 ​ Brett Moore I just mean lawyers are the ultimate hustlers. Moloch is a lawyer when in human form.

[@brettmoore3194]

@Ja Sa the all seeing eye is actually a visual representation of how the eye actually works. The field of view is how they trick us into believing there is a curve

[@bryanjaeck4828]

I am over 70 years old, I have interfaced with police for decades. My experience is that about 75 to 80%of the officers should not be wearing a badge, bullies, thugs, idoits caring guns. These guys fit right in again.....

[@gfredsen]

About my age too. I have posted previously of seeing a police academy class. I thought most of them simply appeared mentally deficient.

[@nikdrown]

This is just the way the govt likes them too.

[@rayh592]

60+ years.0 positive reactions. I have been put in danger at least three times by office negligence.

[@chosenpeople5881]

thank you sir

[@chosenpeople5881]

larry andrews son you should cast the first stone then . faultless.

[@arnold8746]

I've had a dog alert on my and they ultimately found nothing. After an hr or so on the side of the road with 5 cops, I ended up getting some bs ticket for having an out of state license after living there for 30 days. When I went to court the judge actually called on me ahead of everyone and told me I could just leave. Apparently he read whatever report and saw it for the crap it was.

[@naconaco1]

Good !!!

[@soulgazer11]

"It is irrational for officers to expect citizens to unquestioningly bend to their will" *Best quote of the video* 💯

[@grndiesel]

You know it's bad when a guy can represent himself in criminal court against the police and WIN.

[@walterknight1550]

I’ve gone to court and lost several times. Anybody can make a mistake. No big deal.

[@richardboals371]

And they're going to start winning more and more and more and I'm going to see to it I'm starting a company called the pro se law firm and we only get 7% will take you by the hand and walk you through the courts we can't represent you but we can sure give you the tools to show you how to use them and I'm going to help the help a lot of people because 7% is way better than 37%

[@MrGA555]

@@walterknight1550 It is a big deal when it’s costing citizens over 300 million

[@Idontanswerquestionz]

Ya. Not in West Texas. Jury finds you guilty no matter what. I guess they're all just excited to be part of something. I was foreman on a grand jury once... No matter how shady the case or evidence, EVERY SINGLE brief that was brought before us was approved for prosecution.

[@terrymccown5215]

Lmao. Now that is funny foreal they went to school for this lol omg

[@Gorfvan]

“ If a fast food employee exhibited the same unprofessional behavior, they would be fired immediately “ Ive never heard a statement so accurate. Law enforcement is literally the one of the only fields in which one can act like a complete jerk and get away with it. There are higher standards at McDonalds.

[@whateverjones5473]

And, with a badge and a gun, they have the power of life and death and imprisonment for innocent people. I grew up in Atlanta and St. Petersburg, Florida with crooked Nazi cops. Even in my own family. Other than a child molester, there is nothing worse than a crooked judge, DA, or cop, who have power over us.

[@anthonyhutchins2300]

I say that hit all the time... Its like when they shoot the wrong person but deem it okay because they "followed proper procedure". If I didn't note someone's allergy when I put an order in at work It doesn't matter that I put the order in the right way they fuckin die... I know you killed someone but you know how to use the POS.

[@natenav8247]

Lmao look at our president bro

[@rc5924]

Yep

[@kayliesellers8718]

@@natenav8247 you sir are a asshat.

[@Heathensauce]

The dude gets an A+ in my opinion. He did everything absolutely perfectly. I feel like you didn't give him that A+ for his lack of knowledge of the laws because he was legitimately concerned and had no idea if what they were doing was lawful and I wouldn't either. He was calm, challenged their statements but didn't go against anything they said, and when they gave him an ultimatum, he questioned if they were allowed to provide an ultimatum. Though I don't believe he should have questioned the officers as much and I think he should have complied as he puts himself and his dog at risk to these thugs but him questioning them was a legitimate concern and I believe this wouldn't have been taken seriously if he didn't do his due diligence as a citizen and properly questioned these thugs- i mean police officers. I am sure these thugs probably got a slap on the wrist and no actual repercussions though. Honestly, when I see a poor skinny white man like this driving with his dog being treated like a drug dealer/addict because he's in a cheap car and wearing a beanie, these police officers do not portray themselves as anything more than thugs and bullies with guns.

[@exarch404]

All that, but imagine the dude is black. Doesn't matter what he's wearing, doesn't matter what his car looks like, and suddenly there's a drastic increase in the odds of someone being arrested (or worse) for aggravated eye-rolling and public displays of disagreement.

[@SavageRoosterOnThaLooster]

@@exarch404 stats do not support your claim.

[@BillyBasd]

Drug laws need to go. All drugs need to be handled like alcohol. This is dumb

[@funkyfranx]

@@exarch404 My God, trust someone to turn it into the oppression olympics.

[@daveg-Vancouver_Island]

@@SavageRoosterOnThaLooster hhah ahhh yes they do!! Maybe not fox opinion stats but obviously those are not based on realty’

[@charlesflorida1004]

I can't believe they arrested this guy because they were upset they didn't find anything

[@kenosabi]

They do it all the time. There is nothing more frail then the average cops ego.

[@imamarillo16]

When that officer said "what constitution" is when this went from reality to comedy central

[@didyasaysomethin2me]

9:15 Officer: "What Constitution?" Everybody knows that the Constitution is fake news. Just ask Trump all about that "fake" Emoluments Clause. 🙄

[@watershed44]

@N7_NahNo Proves the officers are "the enemy" war criminals, enemy combatants, and guilty of treason. The driver should have immediately demanded to go free or shoot the enemy dead. They are guilty of treason.

[@GeekOfAllness]

He did immediately amend his statement to clarify what he obviously meant. Clueless people constantly use the phrase "the law says....", to which the obvious counter-question is "what law?" In this case, the guy used the term "constitution", and the cop instinctively used the question "what ". It's no different than a clerk saying "enjoy the stuff you just bought" then you inadvertently reply "you too!" before realizing that made no sense in context. But really, you just expected them to say "have a nice day" and gave an appropriate reply.

[@watershed44]

@GeekOfAllness Oh looky we found the piggy...look at the "copsplaining".

[@GeekOfAllness]

@@watershed44 Sorry that it was necessary to explain the painfully obvious. But clearly there are plenty of people too intent on proving some ridiculous agenda to bother with pesky things like truth or reality.

[@craigparse1439]

5:50 The officer deployed a K-9 unit claiming "officer safety". I'm sure hundreds of law enforcement officers are seriously wounded by expired license tabs every day.

[@MiguelTiempos]

Very nicely put!!!

[@KamikazeELF]

"Officer safety" after being asked 2 questions lol.. What a waste of times and resources. Yep we pay for this lol

[@liz090833]

They do caution against the mentally incompetent having sharp objects. License plates have very sharp edges and thousands die from paper cuts every year, they've really put their lives on the line. Have some respect! 😀🤣😃

[@AssassinIronMan]

@@KamikazeELF forced to pay for even

[@lt4753]

Yup! Tim Mcvay was caught by a broken taillight. Doesn’t matter the reason for the stop. Comply

[@silentj2k9ross3]

The more I watch ATA, the more I’m convinced the police are given too much discretion under the law. There needs to be clear and defined boundaries for the police to interact with average citizens. I think the most annoying thing about this interaction was that the cops stood there looking like M4 was wasting their time, when they were the ones who prolong it.

[@raphaelmorgenshtern3939]

imagine someone asking you a harmless question and your first logical thought being “im gonna arrest this man and possibly ruin his life”

[@trucid2]

"What Constitution?" The one you swore to uphold and protect.

[@wannabus7094]

Hang all traitors. Sic semper tyrannus

[@JWSmythe]

I'd like to think that the cop was smart, and he was asking as the state or federal constitution. That's probably not the case.

[@horatiohornblower3757]

I've had a dog "alert" on my car twice, when I've never had drugs in my car. Shows how accurate those dogs are.

[@IamWhoIam2023]

K-9s are trained to show the same alert when the cop wants them to

[@BostonSox41]

The dog might not have actually "alerted" as they each respond in different ways . The officer can SAY the dog alerted just to have "reasonable suspicion" and search a car without the owner's permission. With an officer with this attitude you can almost always bet the dog is going to "alert" and your car's going to be searched! And if they're REALLY dirty cops you can bet something you've never seen before is going to be found in your car. There's a video on here that a officer finds a white powder in a plastic bag and says it has tested for cocaine and arrests the man. The substance is sent to the drug lab for verification and it came back powdered sugar from a donut! Come on! Any cop can tell donut crumbs!

[@fredkithcart5237]

Had one hit at a border Patrol checkpoint. They lift dog up into my Semi truck and it ate my cupcakes and jumped down. Officer gave me 10 bux for the cupcakes. Appearently they were the dog's treat for a " job well done."

[@MrBollocks10]

The dog did it's job. His owner wanted to search and dog made his master happy.

[@MrBollocks10]

@Jacob Thompson haha. you are witty

[@deliberatelyaverage]

Police cameras are perhaps one of the best things to happen in recent years

[@devenmacintosh4124]

Still think it should be automatic dismissal of court case and jail time if an officers camera is interrupted or turned off at any time

[@deliberatelyaverage]

@@devenmacintosh4124 That would just mean it’s better to attack the police officers camera

[@jenniferl7309]

I’d be most upset that the good boi had to go to the shelter, even for a few hours. Poor baby, that was probably traumatic.

[@mudaykiran6763]

"What Constitution?" Question from a police man?? I believe he should be fired just for that one statement.

[@ShimrraJamaane]

Yeah, like the other commenter said, there are multiple. Each state has its own constitution, as well.

[@ikat_tracer]

He meant which you dingbat

[@georgemegaw2925]

It’s Buena Vista VA…where they put the “H” in Hick.

[@donstaunch7895]

And fired for being morbidly obese so unable to perform required duties...

[@JensMorrison]

If he needs to know which constitution, he should be fired. Obviously the guy is talking about the 4th Amendment to the United States constitution.

[@ericferguson9989]

"What constitution?" Clearly the officer is large enough to qualify as his own principality.

[@sfmc98]

Right, where a written constitution doesn't exist, just the mood of the tyrant.

[@mkp1214]

Mans his own country

[@ericferguson9989]

@@mkp1214 He is kind of large.

[@CatsClaw44]

🤣😂

[@davidsteele1667]

Did you order a Large Farva?

[@jdhappy7663]

Even when the charges are dismissed you still have to come up with the money for the tow, the impound and the fees for getting your dog out. Plus the time you missed work. I've never heard of them giving that money back without an additional court case.

[@jontapp9947]

He was arrested for not helping the police search his car??? What is wrong with these people?

[@JohnSmith-en8vx]

Officers like this are a disgrace to the badge.

[@tesseract1877]

All officers are disgusting

[@audideus9731]

@@tesseract1877 I was about to comment the same thing.

[@enigmaticbrain1225]

Still waiting for someone to show me IN THE CONSTITUTION the dog exception to basic fourth amendment rights. I'll wait.

[@watershed44]

@Kolya-The-Vodka-Guzzler Wow you're STILL one of the only people that gets it! The police are an UNconstitutional illegal standing army and also violate their oath. That makes them war criminals, enemy combatants, traitors, and guilty of treason. The penalty is death by hanging.

[@williamhughes205]

This day and age they are all a disgrace

[@ferrywhite3720]

They knew he didn't have drugs so they made up a charge to justify stopping and searching his vehicle.

[@Avenus112]

Corruption.

[@tohrazul]

The stop was legal. He didn't have a current sticker on his vehicle. Everything else came from the fact that he questioned their authority. These officers should be suspended and retrained before they are allowed to go out on the streets again.

[@nspring06]

I love that the officers justification for the search was "Well case law says we can do we just do what we want"

[@derekfcc]

But if you elect to use the ‘because I can’ justification, things escalate. I love how he just causally threw out ‘hindering’ before the officers could, lol

[@PHAToregon]

4:20 best part is the cop not expecting the guy not to consent and then struggling harder than a toddler to articulate

[@diji5071]

False alerts should come with consequences.

[@brianstiles8166]

Diji, there was absolutely no reason for this. Not only was the search unwarranted, they taught the dog to lie.

[@diji5071]

@Larry Chandler Yep.

[@robertvehorn4832]

Thay DO. You have to file the charges or nothing happens.

[@mrandersen6872]

Then the police would plant drugs to make sure theres never a false alert

[@diji5071]

@@mrandersen6872 Yeah, man am I glad I live in a city where for the most part the police aren't corrupt. And they're pretty damn lenient tbh. And somehow they keep the gang and criminal activity to a minimum.

[@jmpayne333]

Just admit it cop. Your being rude because he wouldn’t bow down to you.

[@jinkisaragi874]

Isn't that always the case?

[@susux7332]

Most of them are on an ego trip.

[@kirixen]

Would you rather be happy, or right?

[@barneybrown7543]

They don't take those jobs to protect and serve they take it to harass and dominate and hopefully fulfill a kill fantasy. The perks of being able to drive drunk and armed are really limited now but they still have the power to turn the camera off and film only what benefits them. Until the camera is fixed to stay on and be public and available to anyone the corrupt cops are going to prosper and multiply

[@kirixen]

@@barneybrown7543 you are completely detached from reality. Please don't procreate.

[@larrym7442]

This was one of the best real life situational videos I seen in a long time and an accurate account of what can and dies go down. Thanks for sharing.

[@FaarookeHill]

All that for a expired tag...

[@julioso011]

“I don’t need your consent” you say that to your wife too, officer?

[@petermoller8337]

If your wife says no, and you continue then a rape has actually happened.

[@esreimi]

@@playgroundofsound7683 go fuck yourself

[@jdmforever5583]

Or his boyfriend😂

[@kiddingme01]

Nope - she runs the home, that's why he must use his 'authority' while he's away from home

[@thomasmcann9474]

@@esreimi 🙄

[@robcarley7506]

Those cops seem like they had the mentality of "We stopped him, We need to find something or provoke him to do something just so we can get an arrest"

[@ShadyS-2012]

slow days in bum fuck nowhere, gotta get their jollies somehow...so glad it ended in a nice big payout for the guy and his sweet little pup!

[@TheDemockery]

@@ShadyS-2012 These dumbSh!t pigs (no offense to honest and servant officers) do not care one iota about costing the city / county / state the settlement amount, or for that matter, any payout. They justify their power trips with their egos. In their eyes, this guy was guilty before the dog arrived. Officer had no probable cause in that the young man reeked of drugs, alcohol or displayed any other signs of illicit / illegal activity. Cops like this are losers and give good cops bad reputations.

[@PBMS123]

I don't think they had that mentality. But there are ways to go about "sticking up for your rights". This guy thought he knew the law, but didn't, and his behaviour certainly dind't help the situation. i.e. the locked container bs, not winding his window down, and the manner in which the questions were asked didn't help the situation. The police can ask you to exit the vehicle. You not winding your window down to talk, or to make it difficult to talk is a sure way to actually get pulled out. He could have asked the police, "are you asking, or ordering me to?" (rather than a particularly wordy, and what to most would seem as an antagonistic refusal under the guise of a question) at which point he would have probably gotten an answer and then he should have opened it. As has been stated before, the street is not where you argue the legitimacy of an order, or police conduct, it's in the courtroom. He wasn't up on the law, because if he were he'd know that a K9 alert gives probable cause to conduct a search warrantless. And that the SC ruled that the boot is part of the vehicle and that now that it had progressed to a full search that the boot was now able to be searched.

[@timhawks6101]

@@ShadyS-2012 What was the payout?

[@engineergaming1669]

@@PBMS123 “the guy” sued the city for the false arrest and won, he handled everything perfectly

[@KISSMYACE3203]

I've been in a similar situation, going to Cali for a race from Oklahoma. Got pulled over in Arizona, declined search, K9 brought in and "hit." Have never once had drugs in the vehicle for the 7 years I had it, and observing the dog, it definitely didn't alert.

[@slipspectrum9253]

K9’s have been proven to alert based on absolutely nothing but their handlers micro-expressions and desire to make their handlers happy. A lot of would-be good K9’s quickly get corrupted by bad handlers. A “witness” that’s less reliable than a coin flip should not be admissible any more than a lie detector outcome is…

[@nickoloes]

So glad we have brave cops like these keeping the community safe.

[@theonlyalexoliveira]

“It’s yes or no” This is the language of cops who are excited and have you near cornered. When they start speaking like this you are in danger.

[@timtompkins8774]

You're right. "it is irrational for officers to expect citizens to unquestionably bend to their will" and yet every officer wants you to

[@barondystopia]

And so do many citizens who believe that if you don't comply, you deserve to die.

[@amado0001]

nazi pigs

[@B_Bodziak]

For this young man to be charged with obstruction is ridiculous. He was incredibly polite and not once did he say he was refusing to do anything asked of him. At most, he said "under duress". This officer was way out of line. Reading his police report, you'd think this young man had to be dragged out of his car at gunpoint.

[@fridgerator3786]

“Every” implies all. That vast generalization isn’t helping.

[@icepick859]

Police need to be seriously defunded and scaled way down

[@ErikKnepfler]

Watching tons of these, it seems a very useful question people could ask in response to any officer request/order is "are you asking me, or are giving me a lawful order to do it?" If they say asking, the answer is always no, because if they have to ask, that means that they require consent and cannot order it, so the answer is obviously no. If it's yes, then you always do it, even if you think it's unlawful, and deal with it in court later. If they bark "yes or no" I would think the best response is to cover both scenarios forcing them to answer. in this example, i.e., "if you're asking because you require my consent to search the trunk, the answer is no. if you say it's a lawful order, then I'll open it. if it turns out you're wrong, that will come out in court. if you have the legal right to break into the trunk, then I'm not going to stop you. so you have your answer." If they repeat "yes or no?" then you just repeat everything you just said.

[@ErikKnepfler]

@@sparkyUSA1976 interesting but with cops I think it's simpler. they are always either asking or ordering. you need to know the difference. if you're not sure, ask, and expect them to get pissed off, but hold your ground. if they require your permission, that means they can't make you, which means you have a right (that people fought and died to give you) that says you don't have to and therefore should not, lest you dishonor those who died to give you those rights.

[@dctimagery]

"If the average fast food employee exhibited a similar degree of unprofessional behavior, they would be fired immediately" LOL

[@daveyjones9506]

Ol' Boy represented himself and still got it dismissed! BEAST!!!

[@stevecarroll4217]

When a court case has been thrown out the officer in question should be fined for misuse of the badge

[@oregondude9411]

Officers need to carry liability insurance. If they are found guilty of anything while on the job, their insurance should pay out and there should be a high deductible.

[@brandoncaldwell95]

@@oregondude9411 sorry, but i have ti but in on this. As a dispatcher, i had the option fir the insurance. Yearly cost was $5,000 out of a $35,000 income. Lets not forget taxes which is 20%. That does not include the other odds and end of dental, vision, healthcare, Social Security, unemployment ect. $35kx20%=$28k $28k-$5k=$23k (Odds and ends) Take home of $21,000 Thats $1750 a mount or $875 biweekly. Keep in mind, this is needed to live on which you simply cant in my area. The pathetic part, thats the highest paying job as a grocery store is only $1000 a month income.. With that said, the deductible its plenty high enough. Its not even insurance to say the least, but lawyers when required. The county/city pays for the end settlement not the officer. He does get reprimanded and it states on fike that transfers to every department he gets employed at. If a large enough hit, it goes to state files against his peace officer license.

[@henrynichols7541]

@@brandoncaldwell95 others do it,so can you

[@royalloyalty8248]

They SHOULD be charged with Corruption. That should carry minimum 7 years.

[@byroncosta8614]

For sure....

[@ejscales2276]

Any dog that gives a false detection of drugs should be decommissioned

[@HectorMartinez-gy8kp]

Shame on that supervisor for letting that go down like that

[@bng2679]

This guy is lucky they didn’t plant the drug in his car. It is not uncommon.

[@tasanas3029]

Corrupted pigs only want to destroy normal ppls lifes. They are uselesw to get any real crimminals

[@brittanylawless680]

he's white

[@tracyseymour7553]

@Google LIES 2 f u There's a good movie from 1989 called "An Innocent Man" starring Tom Selleck. It's about crooked cops who plant drugs on people in order to obtain a "bust." The clothing and hairstyles may be dated, but the movie is worth a look.

[@johns.3619]

@@brittanylawless680 I assure you cops don't give a fuck what color you are

[@tracyseymour7553]

@ALex Klassing True, but I think it's a good movie

[@perasima6533]

The cop who stopped him is a local "star" in that area and he's been well known for harassing people for petty things and generally abusing his authority.

[@Shogomockid]

Do you know this to be true?

[@p.doetsch6209]

@@Shogomockid Based on this video do you know it's not? He's guilty until proven innocent in the court of public opinion.

[@erichkorman710]

If so his chief should be fired and prosecuted as an accesory to his crimes. Both are traitors to America and our laws

[@harmendejong4754]

@@erichkorman710 its called the thin blue line also 6 weeks of training to be a cop ... without a rather in debt psychological evaluation of the candidates CRAZY..

[@HowardDPVT]

@@p.doetsch6209 you mean in the court of officer opinion.

[@PaulSmith-pe1kh]

This guy was as respectful and patient as anyone ever should be. This was absolutely absurd

[@commonmannn4961]

"I don't want to - are you forcing me?" - "lright, he's not going to unlock the door..." - that's a federal felony, right there. He is lying under color of law to abuse a citizen.

[@BretAllen1]

I’ve trained every dog I’ve ever had. I can tell you with 100% certainty that dogs are people pleasers. If they figure out there’s a reward, even a pat on the head, they will exhibit a behavior to get their reward. The dog knows if he alerts he gets praise, so he’ll alert every single time if the handler rewards them. Nothing complicated about it.

[@beentheredonethat5908]

These cops had motives beyond the stop. A bad inspection doesn't give any right for this nonsense

[@poppacapps5573]

@NotoriousProfessorChaos #99669966 velcom to nazi Germany.

[@douglashoward4206]

the fact that Hogan had a break in kit in his trunk gives that away. a break in kit in his trunk????????

[@chrisgordon5719]

@NotoriousProfessorChaos #99669966 Plus they have outsourced the training of the K-9's so the Officer is now trained by a 3rd party on how to handle the poorly trained (by others) dog. These searches should be required that 100% of the search is videotaped. So that Expert Witnesses for the defense can review the tapes for inconsistencies. Like giving the dog subtle commands to alert when there is no proof that there is anything there.

[@beentheredonethat5908]

@NotoriousProfessorChaos #99669966 that's true but he had no right taking him out of the car to begin with, which would have stopped the rest until or if the dog signaled. It was the first violation of his rights that lead to the reat

[@war32mec]

NotoriousProfessorChaos #99669966 ya know he could had had a tiny touch of drugs on his hands or fingers and when he pointed to the driver side door he could had just briefly touched it, just enough for the scent of the drug to make him signal.

[@lt4753]

M4 knows his rights so the officer doesn’t need to explain them. This is the best part of street lawyers they know it all

[@liveintehpast]

If u tell them you don't answer questions. They immediately assume you are hiding something in ur car.

[@Bansheeman6100]

M4 released a video showing his settlement was $160k

[@thatlsk]

Damn, let me go get pulled over real quick.

[@Mariuswow69]

good for him

[@michaeld9682]

Link please?

[@goodone8041]

Hopefully, he didn't blow it on boats and hookers.

[@user-ef4gf7rr9r]

@@goodone8041 And even if he did, all that would happen is he would be left exactly where he started.

[@michaeltruthson6262]

So basically the driver was thinking "hey I was just thinking I needed a new car and this doofy mcnoofy just made it possible"🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@ik7578]

The false detection rate of police dogs is 74%.

[@exercisethoughtsanddiscussions]

Is there a database for each Leo, ‘arrest/conviction’ rate? If an officer frequently gets his charges dropped by the DA, isn’t that a sign of severe incompetence?

[@guynorth3277]

Cop: "What Constitution" - and he's dead serious.

[@barneybrown7543]

They are not trained in the Constitution and often are trained to arrest you if you mention it. Not that they know what it is. They spend more time training them to kill you and get away with it than they do Constitutional rights. The very word Constitution being mentioned in a stop diminishes your chances of surviving the harrassment stop.

[@damiangalvan8029]

Well although I think this whole thing is stupid on the police officers behalf, I believe he was asking wether M4 was asking about the U.S. Constitution or the state constitution.

[@verofarias46]

WHAT CONSTITUTION..?? WTF? Is that dude still an Officer?

[@kevrob53]

I can’t lie. That was funny.

[@chrisb1923]

That’s scary

[@nadominhoca]

Driver -"what if I don't consent?" Cop - "You don't have........ I mean you don't..... that's not part of it"

[@mr.janhe_10]

BP, that says it all, uh?

[@SMPKarma]

"wwwhaaat... trying to retain your personal freedom in a police state? That's not part of it!"

[@gallifreyandefense]

@@SMPKarma I love your profile picture... true liberation!

[@DeathProductions200]

@@gallifreyandefense didn't even need to see the profile picture to see a true libertarian because of the term "police state"

[@anondabomb]

@@gallifreyandefense Anarchy leads to eventual tyranny.

[@bretta3]

This is retaliation for not answering the cops questions.

[@bretta3]

When Kentucky State Troopers did this to me, the cop extended the stop, giving the K9 unit time to get there, by claiming that my registration didn't show up on his system.

[@JubJubtheWonderHippo]

So I researched into this case, and the settlement was, it looks like, for $160,000, according to the headline from an online VA Lawyers Weekly article. Let's just appreciate that this Officer Hogan cost his city an amount that's worth over 22,000 of work to a minimum wage worker in VA in a single incident because of his carelessness, impatience, and disregard for the law in regards to other people's rights. 22,000 hours is over 900 days, so if somebody worked minimum wage 24/7 for 900 days, they still wouldn't have made enough themselves to pay off Officer Hogan's blunder.

[@mecheckraise]

VERY nice! I think that amount was justified. This again is why people HATE the police. Too many are thugs with a badge. All these ;police here should be fired.

[@birdman7135]

I wish you would have supplied a link to what you found. $160K is a rather high payout - seldom seen for even violent unlawful arrests.

[@scorpio6587]

Perspective is a powerful thing. Thank you.

[@georgegassaway2]

So, they have to pull over and write a bunch more tickets to generate an extra $160,000.

[@butteredtoast9471]

Were any of the officers involved fired?

[@perfectlyflawed3061]

“Did you tell him to alert”? “No I did not”! (Closes his eyes because he can’t even look at him while he lies straight to his face.)

[@cullen3624]

Seems like he got a settlement of $160,000 but no one was fired! Police Departments should be required to have liability insurance paid for by the police themselves. The more payouts a department has the more the insurance premium costs. That would focus their minds!

[@MedekYT]

Love the video and the channel in genneral, I've been watching your videos for about a week now! Raid sponsoring you took me by surprise and made me laugh.

[@charlesfrazier9700]

“My dog did an alert on your car.” Oldest trick in the book. The dog got a big treat.

[@shyman9023]

Many Scooby snacks, lol!

[@brpadington]

It is the oldest trick in the book. Dogs will alert on command so if the dog doesn't alert the cop will make it alert.

[@Scarlet_moon.]

dog alerted on a same spot where another dog was just minute prior,what a shock.

[@jemshadow123]

bet you the dog just smelt the other dog and was like hey buddy

[@Splintz246]

The dog didn't even do a full alert though and alert means the dog makes a full sit or lays down The dog squatted didn't even sit down all the way and he was looking at the officer the entire time

[@kpadilla137]

Officer safety is not grounds for probable cause to search a vehicle.

[@vinnievalentine421]

They are 9bviously on drugs or have serious mental issues

[@andrewmcisaac5028]

Actually, police can "frisk" (protective sweep) areas of the motor vehicle where a weapon can be hidden (i.e. center console, glove box) with only reasonable suspicion.

[@darinjones9959]

@@andrewmcisaac5028 didn't you just watch the video?

[@andrewmcisaac5028]

@@darinjones9959 Michigan v. Long, 463 U.S. 1032 (1983)

[@darinjones9959]

@@andrewmcisaac5028 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@10p6]

An ex officer told me once that some cops would put drug residue on their glove, then touch the suspects vehicle to make it so the K9 alert to this. Literally dirty cops.

[@bpdmf2798]

When charges are dropped you should immediately be awarded any fees paid and a dollar amount per minute or hour of time spent and time missed from work.

[@enforcerridley158]

"What constitution?" Oh boy…

[@leeroger1471]

the donuts was on his mind and the greasey chicken instead of knowing the law

[@jjhhandk3974]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@MrThisIsMeToo]

@@leeroger1471 Are you referring to the embarrassingly and severely obese cop?

[@leeroger1471]

@@MrThisIsMeToo yes

[@SinnerD2010]

My next statement would have been, so what Party City did you get your costume from?

[@5150Rockstar]

Their dogs are trained to make false positive detections

[@joj4541]

Not exactly, there’s just faults with the dogs detecting something simply bc they want to please their owner

[@candywilson1442]

Yes, giving them reasons to harass people.

[@coolnoah8183]

@@joj4541 Yeah it's a fault in the nature of training dogs in general. To train them to indicate that they have detected a particular scent, they must be rewarded upon doing so. In the field this then can result in false positives given that theyre used to a positive being rewarded

[@franklotion7716]

I had food trash in my work truck an was told that the dog had a hit.

[@robertcallanan7911]

@@coolnoah8183 they're rewarded even if they don't detect anything

[@nicolecatlin1942]

And I give you an A+ for giving these officers an F!!!!

[@mikerap240]

He was about to say " you don't have that right"

[@adamn5821]

The cop asks, "what Constitution." Lol. Did he ask that question when taking his oath? Smfh.

[@MarkOfTzeentch]

You are implying he took an oath.. and didnt just sign x at the end of the single page contract he was too lazy to read

[@Banininator]

@@MarkOfTzeentch ughh why I believe this is what happened sadly :/

[@cynicalcb]

Based on the context I’m sure he was asking between the US Constitution or the constitution of whatever state this was in.

[@phcusnret]

He has no idea. He obviously doesn't even remember that he took an oath.

[@itamararce7347]

If the cop read this comment, he'd probably ask "what oath?"

[@GSP-76]

I have a lot of respect for this guy...he genuinely seemed like a nice guy and didn't behave like an idiot. I hope he makes them pay.

[@threadEvent]

And his dog was so well trained and behaved lol. They were both perfect gentlemen about it.

[@kabloosh699]

@panda44r the unfortunate reality is that is the tax payer's money.

[@DIYDaveT]

@@kabloosh699 And the department says he acted within guidelines. Standard line. Makes me want to vomit.

[@tnpcook]

Regrettably, that's taxpayer money and not from the officer's own loss.

[@ithamarlowe6158]

It seems like he knew that everything the police were doing was wrong and used that in his favor.

[@nobodyyouneedtoknow4218]

as someone from southern VA, i feel this interaction in my soul

[@Steven-hk2wb]

I love this channel. My only wish is that we get more updates on the lawsuits.

[@kurtdowney1489]

M4 sued for and won 160k for false arrest. Someone else commented that.

[@johnmckenna5782]

Those police officers, especially officer Hogan, make me sick.

[@williamhughes205]

All fucking tyrants need a revolution on them

[@Logan-or5qw]

Just another reason why you should always film your interactions with the cops. If we all stood together against these unjust encounters, then maybe it will change how cops treat us.

[@alihall4505]

These kind of cops need to lose their job and pensions

[@andrzej2501]

No, they need to loose their lives. Government officials abusing their power and braking the law should be treated as terrorists. Because that is what they are.

[@lukeswain1752]

@@andrzej2501 same with politicians. Aaaaand now I'm on a hit list :)

[@Vazzzz]

@@andrzej2501 agreed

[@alihall4505]

@Micheal Mouse you right cause we live in a racist society

[@MattyKwik]

They need to be done up like Marie Antoinette, in front of an audience

[@hiiamrick]

That Judge saw me is court and asked me. weren't you just paid for suing us? I told him YES, And the cops DID IT AGIAN!!

[@05weasel]

If this kind of stuff is allowed then why not just bring a K9 to the window with you on every traffic stop to justify a search of the car? That’s crazy

[@ericthered9655]

So they never found drugs? So they lied about the dog.

[@pokey70291]

They always lie about the dog.

[@jamesbkr13]

Well to be fair they may not have lied, k-9 units are just not very reliable in general.

[@Arjay404]

Considering where the dog alerted (the door handle) it may be the case that M4 does use a drug of some kind but just doesn't have it in his car or on his person, so his hands dirty with drugs may have dirty'd up the door handle with drugs and that is what the dog was alerting to. It's just weird that the dog didn't alert anywhere else except for the door handle.

[@coder5877]

@@Arjay404 Or the dog is more intelligent than you think given its previous experience.

[@davereloader8837]

@@Arjay404 Or, givem the name M4, which is the designation of a rifle, maybe he is a recreational shooter and had gunpowder residue. Or maybe it was legal CBD oil. There can be many reasons besides "drugs on his hands". My dad was a K9 officer and dog trainer. Dogs will alert for any number of reason including just to be told "good boy". They can be trained to alert... just to alert so cops can behave like we see above and use them as an excuse.

[@lyssakate]

Haha! That cop just cost the department 160,000. Sad for the taxpayers, I just signed the change. Org petition to get Hogan fired.

[@punchcat1234]

Where’s the link

[@jashpaper8370]

Link please?

[@smoothierip5693]

yeah actually I'd also like to know where to sign for that.

[@saneman751]

What happened to his dog? Was he able to get him back before shelter killed it?

[@bravetitangrizzly]

Guler Ozgenc the answer to your question was provided in the video

[@aydenquincy1847]

I wish that all traffic stops went the same way mine did just a few weeks ago. Got pulled over for a burned-out headlight, the officer let me know immediately why I was pulled over. He was calm, professional and polite the entire time even though the street was VERY dark and he admitted that it made him a little nervous to approach my window in all of that dark. He ran my plates and license, checked on my insurance status and let me off with a "Be safe and get that light fixed ASAP. Have a good night."

[@Michael-oi5fl]

This guy has a history of abusing his power and he gets away with it.

[@hillaryclinton2415]

Always file for RESTRAINING ORDERS as these cops will want revenge.

[@rockinnova]

I love that he fought it in court AND WON!!!!

[@ScreamingEagleFTW]

you can beat the rap but you cant beat the ride.

[@jeremiahcaples963]

Still went to jail had his car towed prob paid for it and his dog in the shelter. All this should be compensated. If not its a lose in the end.

[@johnpopoff7950]

Me too. Cop should lose his job and police certification.

[@johnermactavish1162]

Won what? Cop isn’t punished. He still went to jail. His dog was taken and separated from him put in a strange shelter. His vehicle was towed. He had to invest time and money into fighting the arrest. None of it compensated. He didn’t win he just lost less then others.

[@gnzlpico]

@@jeremiahcaples963 If the whole process was illegal, the city will refund the amount of money that u paid, at least that's what AtA said in many of his vids

[@JJones-nf9ce]

Remember, always stand up for your rights. It's not your responsibility to make their jobs easier by forfeiting your rights. They are not trying to make your life easier

[@calebmantle5694]

If you want to get arrested then make $100,000s say these two phrases "I don't consent" and "I'm going to sue your department." Officers will immediately then treat you draconically and do everything they can to incriminate you, further increasing the chance you make crazy money when you do inevitably sue them. Petulant children.

[@DisturbingRainbow]

You know there's a problem when cops are finding way to circumvent rules that are to protect people from unlawful searches.

[@patrickkelly5009]

You mean attempt to or actually succeeding in subverting the laws for which they took an undeniable oath to uphold, then yes.

[@erichkorman710]

This is the Hoax police are today. Traitor chiefs around the country say their number one priority is the safety of their officers. They are not only wrong but accessories to every crime commited by cops. These are criminals violating rights as spelled out in our constitution of laws they have never read. We need a shakeup that teaches them fear of police is not respect. Respect can only be earned; nobody repects these thugs, their accesory traitor chiefs or the criminally coward prosecutors who ignore crimes by law enforcement. Any crimes by anyone in these positions should recieve mandatory minimum jail sentences like they advocate for the citizens they SERVE

[@robssr1]

We are on our way to becoming the USSA

[@grandpied]

It's not uncommon. Victors found a way to circumvent Geneva Convention prisoner of war rules.

[@Rocanala]

And when they can’t find valid reasons, the law presents enough loopholes to allow them do do this ish

[@redactedbananas]

You can't have a valid k9 alert when there was just a dog in there.

[@franklotion7716]

I had food trash in my work truck an was told the dog had a hit of course I had nothing.

[@DJColdCutz_]

I’m sure drug dogs can actually smell drugs. I’m also sure drug dogs are trained to “alert” on command. Don’t trust these assholes at all.

[@Paul_dw_Kersey]

I had a dog hit on my luggage in the Atlanta airport. My mother in law had packed me some steak for supper when I got home. I asked the cop or whatever he was, if he wanted me to open it up. Nope. And I was on my way.

[@brentfu1119]

"What Constitution?" Wow that's disgusting.

[@angelosliotscos8405]

I had an excellent lawyer named Frank in Vancouver, BC. He told me this story. Frank was out on the town celebrating a court victory with his lawyer colleges. As they left the restaurant, Frank noticed a group of cops beating an indigenous person offering no resistance. He told his party to watch this. Frank went up to the officer in charge and politely asked if excessive force was really necessary. They threw him head first into the paddy wagon and locked him up for obstruction of justice. When allowed to make his one phone call, Frank called his law office ( he owned the firm ). Within an hour, fifty lawyers descended on the police station. They released him. Frank filed a lawsuit for unlawful arrest. While he could not disclose the amount, he told me it was the largest settlement in the city's history. I applaud Frank for his courage in standing up for a vulnerable and helpless man and exposing police brutality.

[@deanodebo]

There should be a way to decommission a dog that gives false flag. This would render the animal useless and reduce this type of abuse

[@catladyrn733]

They give the k9 a signal to alert. They are trained that way. Creates probable cause and they can search ur car.

[@deanodebo]

catlady RN I’m saying someone should get a lawyer and petition the court to declare this dog decommissioned, since it gives false alerts.

[@catladyrn733]

I agree

[@Sense008]

It's not the dogs fault though. They are trained to give false alerts. If this dog were dismissed, the same thing would happen with the new dog. The problem is systemic and dismissing the dog will not change that systemic problem

[@deanodebo]

Sense008 I disagree. The dog is useful for SWAT and VERY expensive. If it were decommissioned for a civil rights violation case they would quit this practice

[@nanny-state-ifornia3692]

"What's the Constitution?" OMG, what a waste of skin - all of them. Typical cop behavior...

[@aanubis5874]

Police Officer - ‘What constitution’! Priceless. The badge should gave read KgB instead of K-9.