Going to Town On a Car

The plaintiff says she and the defendant were dating the same man at the same time. She says the woman got jealous and angry and threw a brick at her car, scratching the plaintiff’s son. She’s suing for repair costs. The defendant says she found out she was being cheated on, but she claims some kids damaged the car, not her.
Case #24-191

[@damarishernandez2738]

The plaintiff : 🤡 The defendant: 🤡

[@NP-zs5ui]

The culture: 🤡🤡🤡

[@Bih1stOfAll]

@@NP-zs5ui Whose "culture"?

[@NP-zs5ui]

@@Bih1stOfAll Judging by your dimwitted moniker, I would say yours.

[@Lovely_1One]

@@NP-zs5ui YOUR culture you troll! Think about your history and the ish y’all are doing as of TODAY!!!!! 🧌🧌🧌🧌🧌

[@magicworld3242]

FACTS............

[@WVnurseJo]

Two grown adults acting like children, over a man that's in prison... That saddest part is those kids having to witness their nasty behavior, and chances are will grow up with the same nasty attitude. Sickening

[@Channel-JJ]

it is not just a chance it is a statistical certainty

[@duha1893]

I wouldnt call any of them grown. You are right the saddest part is they are raising children... children that will inevitably become the nasty scummy people that raised them. The world would not miss these two at all. Straight scumbuckets

[@janicester]

They already have that nasty attitude. Look at what they did. That young girl being a witness didn't mean a thing to me. She's a hoodlum just like the rest of her friends.

[@derrickaustin6930]

Facts she should have stayed with the first dad.

[@Kimberly-pf4iy]

You are 100% right. These parents need to set a good example for their children. Acting like hooligans is not the answer. Shameful!!!

[@kaystar3434]

And we wonder why young children grow up to be so hateful and disrespectful. It starts at home, not school.

[@twill1007]

👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽

[@scottbrewer1408]

Hmm, I’d ask why can’t it both .. hate is camel’s back situation unless ur discussing the mentally unwell

[@kelferg]

As a teacher I’m shook…because I know this is the kind of chaos some of my students grow up in.

[@phuckyouqweef7927]

Sad... and will only get worse

[@Dr_Ferg_PharmD]

This is the wrong ruling. The judge kept asking why would the little girl lie, but the questions is, why would she just randomly confess to assisting with vandalizing this ladies car. 🤷🏽‍♀️ That lady would not have gone off on that voicemail the way that she did if she was lying.

[@tooprada606]

I agree! I think the little girl lied her butt off and there’s no solid proof she destroyed that woman’s car

[@startinajackson606]

Exactly, the didn't do it

[@kimeshafraser1749]

I only came in the comment section to find smo say this. I agree. Judge must be blind to kids or smt. I think they told that kid what to say so that she could get her butts out the heat. It was all over her face

[@Dr_Ferg_PharmD]

@@kimeshafraser1749 Exactly. If I were the defendant, I would sue the little girls parents for part of the damages. Especially seeing how she just confessed. That will teach her about lying. 😒

[@debg4212]

I AGREEE

[@manthony777]

Marilyn asks "Why would a 13 year old lie?" A cell phone, iPad, $50, fear, braggin rights, protect her own bottom. The defendant said proudly "I put him out." Then don't complain that he's with somebody else. I'd split the blame and give the plaintiff $2,000. She can put it on Devin's books. smh

[@natashakhamo8696]

Agreed. The kid looked proud of herself at the end. I think they are all responsible

[@brunolidade]

she probably never whatched those cases in which teenagers kill other people and lie about it. there's a great movie with this theme: The Hunt (2012).

[@syw9882]

Was coming here to say this! There are a ton of things that could entice a child to lie! My only hope is that her grandmother wouldn’t be in on that.

[@venusmikaela5885]

I agree! I think Judge Marilyn was wrong on this one !

[@JRenae-uv5yx]

Right and the kid story didn't even make sense!

[@crystalshaw8744]

Low self esteem will get you every time.

[@dorothycrowell2867]

Agree* this was 100% jealousy

[@Jsarmy87124]

And for what a jailbird

[@MzTyraB]

I love how the Defindent says “I have nothing to say” then proceeds to say a lot. 💁🏾‍♀️

[@roshonthomas786]

i really believe the child was coached to say that,

[@dorothycrowell2867]

I dont* the defendant was furious was cuz she was RATTED OUT* nothin makes a shit person angrier than the truth

[@RumbleRish]

What motive would that little girl have to lie? Maybe the plaintiff told her that, if she won, she’ll give her a hundred bucks??? Sounds like a good motive to me! If that 13-year-old was willing to go along with the vandalism without a second thought, it’s not a stretch to think that she’d be willing to perjure herself for money…

[@dorothycrowell2867]

That plaintiff was telling the TRUTH* the biggest sign of the truth is the defendant is furious* nothing makes ppl angrier than the TRUTH

[@dorothycrowell2867]

If the plaintiff was lying, the defendant wouldn't hv cared abt rhe testimony* she got furious cuz that girl was RATTING HER OUT and INCRIMINATING HER

[@RumbleRish]

@@dorothycrowell2867 are you serious? I’d be way more upset about being falsely accused of something so terrible than about the “truth.” I’d also be way more upset about having to pay a money judgment for something I didn’t do. Actually there are plenty of things that would upset me more than the “truth.”

[@DeeSol28]

I’d be waaaaay more upset to be accused of something like that. I would be losing it.

[@DeeSol28]

@@RumbleRish I’d be upset too

[@timothysmith7838]

I can guarantee you this feud is not over.

[@LOVE_ALL_AROUND]

This case really affected the judge. You could see it especially when reading the verdict. Preach JM!

[@lashundavis156]

The look on the plaintiff's face when he said the floozy plaintiff 😂😂the defendant got pissed off once she saw those letters lol girl nobody wants a man in jail

[@Channel__777]

💀

[@alyssahamlett]

I know u could tell she was HEATED, they're both losers thinking they're winning

[@camarojai6832]

When she saw those letters she was ready to jump…. You know he got an ear full when he talked to her

[@Channel__777]

@@camarojai6832 😂😂 yes “ I saW tHeM wiTh mY OwN tWo eyEs”🤣

[@ButtonsCasey]

Apparently those two want a man in jail.

[@ashleyzerone4102]

This one was just WOW!! I give so much credit to JM for what all she said to both mothers because they truly needed to hear it!

[@RicKyir]

This episode gave me every piece of Rachel enjoyment that I needed🤣 Jail? bricks, cussing, staredowns, kids, prison letters, reprimands from the judge, red pumps, 2 tone color hair-dos...I LOVED EVERY MINUTE OF IT😩😩🤣🤣 Lord forgive me

[@theaquarianalien]

Lmaaaaaao same but imma pray for the kids because maaaaaaaan🥺

[@spinjunkie8178]

Lol!

[@laphenixlife]

Don't forget going the wrong way at the end

[@citygirlingraham]

Systematic breakdown of the family. Here we are!

[@thaisburroughs1020]

The grandmother agreed to let the little girl testify. So she didn't have to pay anything

[@ebonyswope]

Even if the defendant didn’t throw the bricks & rocks, she could’ve coached the kids to do it. This whole case was a joke!

[@dorothycrowell2867]

Agree* she was def involved

[@erik15th]

You know damn well her jealous azz was throwing bricks stop yo ish!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@Cheesycheddar642]

It’s so sad that these women have no self esteem and self worth.

[@APHWildHimaruya]

Messy messy messy smh...all over some winner who landed his butt in jail? Yeah...they ALL need some therapy 🙄

[@d.marisafernandes9945]

Damn, not what I expected, I don't agree with the ruling. But then again just my opinion

[@carachase2007]

Right! I was thinking she would be awarded half of what she asked from the defendant. Then I figured judge would say to sue the parent/guardian of the little girl who testified in this case to participating in the vandalism for the other half of the judgement! 🤷🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️

[@DeeSol28]

I don’t agree with the ruling. Kids can be coached and that plaintiff look like that’s something she would do. There was no real proof but a little girls testimony that can be easily influenced. Hearing the VM confirmed that the defendant was innocent cause I’d be pissed as hell too

[@kittyb275]

Judge is confused why the little girl would defend the other lady and lie for her. When the child admitted she allowed someone to tell her to go beat someone up. That little girl does whatever other people tell her what to do. She's easy to manipulate.

[@laylor4360]

shes a child, give her grace

[@cindymann3673]

I’m still unsure if the little was being truthful. The defendant was so adamant before court.

[@deshonebonyrowland-ward4552]

It's the end and walking in the wrong direction for me!! 😂... Girl u know you helped destroy that car.. They're both exactly what the judge said.. Horrible role models and they absolutely live for the drama as if life ain't hard enough 🙄🙄🙄

[@vintagehippie3647]

My guess is is there are more women who are either pregnant or have a child by the same man.

[@apoliticallevi]

Damn Peoples Court is on a roll. Like 10th video of the day! Ps. I’m not complaining.

[@Channel__777]

😂

[@mrsa2you365]

Why didn't JM ask how far they live from each other? How old is the daughter and how did her daughter get there? And why was her daughter there in the first place? And why didn't she bring her daughter court? She put herself at the scene and didn't say she told the kids to stop or even stop her own child from vandalizing her car. So you see your child vandalizing a person's property and you don't say anything?! That's an admission of guilt by itself. Deplorable, despicable and disgusting behavior on her part.

[@bettythomas1720]

TRUE EVERY WORD and I caught that when she held up the jail mail up. He's back in jail don't care about either them or the children.

[@themzqueen5490]

I really feel like the lady was telling the truth and the kid was being coach

[@alyssahamlett]

😂😂 omg this just gets better and better. it's insane people like this exist

[@tawandapatterson5845]

Life is way too short for nonsense!! Just sad!

[@camarojai6832]

I wish we could see him…. I hope they don’t keep going at each other, too much unnecessary stress

[@HighMaintenanceMinimalist]

Why? We already know what he looks like. A gold toothed dusty with his pants sagging down to his knees.

[@dragastarr2926]

Girl, he already he ain’t cute or nothing 🤣

[@righttoouropinionthanks4710]

Wow, this is so, so sad! The poor kids -can’t imagine what they are learning from all this. SMH! 😮

[@tialstewart]

Both of them are going to continue to mess with the guy! Damn shame

[@greeenfilter8084]

Judge’s summarisation was spot on. Both disgraceful role models… PERIOD

[@modestinemungo4661]

Dang, OK and nobody has taught this young lady that when speaking to other adults you are to say "Yes ma'am, no ma'am" "Thank You", "Please" etc.. Didn't even straighten her out in the court room. How she answered the judge smh. Who are raising g these children?. I wish I knew

[@thedopemom7697]

She walked the wrong way😂😂😂 Idk why I’m so tickled by that😂😂

[@AnikaBren]

Sad that these 2 beautiful young women do not know their self worth and do not realize that they can do so much better than this jailbird. That he will never help them in life and will do nothing but cause them pain and strife.

[@wpjohnston0213]

plaintiff bringing so many guests like this is Family Feud!! 🤣 😂

[@maryelaine-blinstrubchambe6083]

Judge you are wrong! Didn't you listen to the tape? I believe the defendant.

[@GangstaBoo7]

I couldn't help but laugh when the Plaintiff is playing the recording and is mocking some of the words..like how many times did you listen to this? You really are enjoying this 💆🏾‍♀️💆🏾‍♀️ I can't

[@chojnackibaby4014]

Oldie but good

[@kamwilliams5541]

This is what I came to say

[@mzfancy4767]

Yup I remembered this one.

[@cocodiva0213]

Yep! Heeeyyy my fellow OG Peoples court fans 👋🏾☺️

[@dragastarr2926]

I’m just ready for the episode where they were suing over stolen checks to drop and I will be set 😆

[@fancyndzefu7798]

Two seemingly grown and intelligent women fighting over a "bomb" as judge Judy would say. Worst part is including the children who'd grow up thinking this is OK and the cycle continues. Parents pls do better especially in front of children.

[@rhondabarksdale2762]

I hope they both get themselves together!

[@BlkMagickGaia3]

I believe that the defendant didn't do it personally but had a lot to do with it being done.

[@jasmineharris1049]

Judge MM was completely disgusted with these two women and rightfully so 🤦🏾‍♀️

[@jhopson4733]

Why would she conclude that the child was NOT lying 🥺

[@ctilly5859]

I love when they walk out and go the wrong way 😂

[@prayforthe_1644]

Like Biden

[@ctaylor6688]

Judge got them all the way together especially the part about the 💌

[@MatandMarty]

I love the fact that the judge called them out on their stuff.

[@johnp.2267]

"What reason does that kid have to lie?" Gee, let me count the reasons, judge: 1) She's afraid. 2) She's been paid. 3) She's been brainwashed. 4) She's been threatened with withholding something/losing something/not being allowed to see her friends unless she lies. 5) She doesn't like the defendant. 6) She's 13. 7) She wants to be on tv. I guess the judge's world doesn't include teenagers who lie.

[@mrsmith8737]

14:15 of course she’s a great role model for her kids, both of them are. They are showing them how to one day be somebody’s baby’s mama AND how to be the other woman.

[@CalmQuiet7]

the 13 year old lied, the reason why she claimed its not her so that they don't have to pay for the damages, simple. I feel the judgment was wrong.

[@carliebk17]

Exactly my point. And not only that but the plaintiff gets to mess with the defendant

[@lolojones5422]

Judge Milan when she yelled LA LA LA LA LA to get the plantiff to shut up lmaoooooooo 10:05 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@h.Freeman]

The irony is the judge got it wrong...I live across the street from them and the girl that testified is the plaintiff friends daughter...it's sad that two grown ups would put kids to lie and be despicable themselves

[@ABALLAM3]

Great. This case is fascinating.

[@fionadarlingb]

Two grown desperate women fighting over a jailbird, meanwhile they're raising teenage daughters who are exposed to ratchetness and a disassembled community. Their kids probably don't have a father in their lives. Generally mothers want the best for their children, but these two show the exact opposite 😠😞

[@ChenisenenebooWelch]

That little girl lying what kind mother is she rising her daughter like that

[@devinpearson7857]

Not everyone should be a parent. They need to work on their personal problems privately.

[@TimothyLittle13]

"Don't try to one up me because I will one up yours!" - Peggy Hill

[@MrBling67]

What a way to set a example for the kids

[@bresams2917]

14:22 when the dunce tried to walk off cute the wrong Way 😭 You can just tell the defendent is Off , Petty and Salty towards everybody else over a Bum! Cheated on her . Smh keep that little girl told on her safe

[@susanlindsay7970]

I'll bet this judge has been a wonderful mother.

[@cynthiamixon2548]

Over a guy that’s in jail. Great ladies y’all are some kind of roll models for your kids. SAD😢

[@kaykepop4084]

Why go through all of this over a guy that clearly has to depend on them just to manage in life and is in jail!? Learn to love yourself so you do not have to settle for less. I pray that none of the children involved in this case will look to either of these women as examples. They are both ridiculous and extremely stupid!

[@jenniferalston1635]

The judge got it right & spoke the truth .. these women are ridiculous & should be embarrassed to fight over a man in jail .. the scary part is they have kids .. smh.

[@danielposey5326]

The Plantiff brought the whole family to court

[@beatricesantos140]

She was proud to show them letters! JM just finished telling her "GIVE YOURSELF SOME WORTH" and she goes and does that... HARD HEAD MAKE A SOFT A$$

[@gildacenelus9500]

She waiving that letter like it’s worth something 😭 girl clown behavior isn’t cute

[@dogcat1951]

The judge shouldn’t have given that woman any money. Give it to the girl who had to witness this foolishness in a college fund for her goals to be a vet. There’s still hope for her but she needs better role models

[@alohamarzia]

yeah i wish she could do that if they were shitty people but unfortunately she still has to follow the law

[@ButtonsCasey]

A kid that possibly lied? Yeah great example.

[@RumbleRish]

A kid that went along with a vandalism without a reason and without a second thought? No thanks!

[@Astonio]

Judge Milan was hurt with this one. I love this Judge so much. Fair af.

[@tracybest5790]

Plaintiff must have listened to the VM too many times to mouth every word on Q. Think the little girl lying. Defendant was madder than heck on VM to being accused of vandalism.

[@sjones2195]

She said 3 of her kids were in the car.. then she said 4 kids. How many kids does she have?

[@philharmonix564]

I'll never be able to relate to these life experiences. Can't say i can learn anything from this case.

[@shanimorrison8730]

Imagine fighting over a dead beat guy omfg lordy lordy

[@Conker32192]

im confused . the little girl is a witness to a crime she committed? am i comprehending it wrongly?

[@naowright9308]

Believe it or not I feel bad for the defendant. She believes the best she can get is a cheating jailbird and is fighting to keep him! Both of these women are in a sad condition.

[@JohnnyMac04]

Mother's teaching their daughters, thug life

[@godfavored5]

Judge is so disgusted with this case and I truly don’t blame her. 😒 This is terrible.

[@shesuniqueinherownwaybenja7647]

My thing is, your man CHEATED, and you blame the woman🙄 why am I not SURPRISED 🤦🏾‍♀️ That’s just way too much energy, I would let her have him. Usually the man will run btw the both women until one comes to her senses. I rather cut my ties 😌 their gloating like this behavior is cute and I’m sure both dummies are still with him🤦🏾‍♀️

[@lolojones5422]

Judge: You’re both kinda enjoying this… Plantiff: I’m not- Judge: Lalalala!!! 10:05 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@Miss_Cherry]

Sad, they don't even kno they are being played against each other for bragging rights. They are playing a game and, its a 3rd women out there i swear neither one of them know about. This is a no win situation if I ever saw one.

[@lashawnwright5860]

This is a bunch of low self esteem & bad or no parenting...

[@monicamills9088]

So you brought the whole family

[@dawnh4829]

How embarrassing is that to go to court and have the judge read you right shoe turn the page and chill your whole truth, fighting over man that’s behind bars, crazy…

[@Renrens-LionessofJudah]

This is shameful all round.

[@lottaboty]

This situation is horrible, but I do think that little girl was lying. Judge Judy would require a better standard of proof.

[@flossybeans4714]

This was a extremely sad case, and the defendant was very guilty but I don't think a thing was learnt in this case as the plaintiff was overly happy and it wasn't all about her car.

[@Sadgirlsgojim]

Wow . This was sad.

[@debg4212]

I actually believe the defendant. This ruling was wrong, she is clearly enraged of being accused of something she didn't do on the voicemail. I actually don't see that the defendant is enjoying the drama. The one who likes the drama is the plaintiff. Millian has it all wrong on this case.

[@jonnell9633]

Trifling all of them.

[@lloydedwards6856]

6:40 My daughter called me to pick me up...HUH???? If she was already in her car why would she need to be picked up

[@sonquatsch8585]

oh gawd this gun be RAAAATSCHET !!!!

[@misfitmarymis9954]

That kid is a liar and the judge didn't see that. . Her lying smile said it all

[@norrinradd-7162]

Fighting over a man in Jail? Really.

[@Lillylilster]

All of this for a man in prison. Just sad.

[@coreycalloway3268]

Gut feeling the defendant didn't do it 🤦🏾‍♂️

[@irideaunicorn1620]

The defendant said she had nthn to say, but she kept on talking andnwalked the wrong way. Dont she watch peoples court

[@scamchan]

The winner seems to be the guy that is locked far away from both of those hostile women!!

[@BlkMagickGaia3]

These women are pathetic. Generational teen/single parenting has devastating consequences. These people tend to breed the most and their kids are equally ignorant 🙄

[@dadabg8747]

These damn people is terrible with their kids. If the defendant has children and the dad wants them, he has a great argument for custody if he want it!

[@polodro]

I hate to say this but that lady in the red 👠 looks like Quagmire dad 😆

[@jonnell9633]

Wrong way queen