WHO'S THE BEST SIMIC COMMANDER IN cEDH - Play to Win Gameplay feat. Tomer of MTG Goldfish

This week we have Tomer from MTG Goldfish/Commander Clash on, to find out what Simic deck is best in cEDH.
WE HAVE:
Tomer on Edric - www.mtggoldfis...
Dylan on Rashmi - www.moxfield.c...
Cam on Sakashimi/Kodama - www.moxfield.c...
Tyler on Kinnan - www.moxfield.c...
Go check out commander clash - / @mtggoldfishcommander
NEW METAL SHIRTS - www.bonfire.co...
NEW PLAYMAT DESIGN - www.playtowinm...
PATREON/DISCORD - / playtowin
ALTERSLEEVES - www.altersleev...
TCG PLAYER AFFILIATE LINK - shop.tcgplayer...
MERCH - www.bonfire.co...
PLAYMATS/TOKENS - www.playtowinm...
PODCAST Spotify! - open.spotify.c...
PODCAST iTunes! - podcasts.apple...
LINK TREE - linktr.ee/play...

[@jimmykeffer7401]

Gosh I love Dylan and Cam’s friendship, SO much chemistry

[@aeolus7762]

The more and more I watch cEDH content, the more I love the direction channels are going, but most of all this one! Having Cam to play off of in person during each interaction consistently and how well each cut is put in, I just love it every time! Keep it up!

[@artemoila1]

I love how Dylan always uses his hands vividly while talking. Any greek or italian background?

[@PlaytoWinMTG]

Oh yes big time Italian

[@danieledata7609]

I'm italian and when i saw Dylan for the first time i thought he was someone i met during my high school

[@anthonymarciano6050]

gli italiani sono i migliori

[@alessandrodellanno948]

Yo I am italian, and yeah ... Dylan,are you one of us? 🤣🤣 Tell the truth tho

[@StackedEDH]

@@PlaytoWinMTG oh hell yeah

[@javierfernandez7879]

I believe that in a match that is four simic cEDH decks, the winner would be the one that could draw more cards; or saying it in a different way, the one that has the most consistent draw engine.

[@jesseeng9598]

Which is why I'm surprised there was no Tatyova deck

[@frankdetank9126]

Tomer returned! I loved the game. I do have to put my plug in though... let's see a "best Enchantress Deck in cEDH" video! I'll keep returning to your comments to request that video :)

[@grinreaperoftrolls7528]

That was great! Also, I didn’t realize chrome mox couldn’t exile artifacts until yesterday either lol. I was also playing kinnan, and I tried to exile the same card

[@tserrofz9]

I know I said I missed the multiple games but really what makes your videos so good is the cut in explanations. I really like this. Keep that up.

[@StephenPaulRamsey]

But Cam... as the Yusri deck has shown, when you have a 50/50 chance you will lose at least 85% of the time 🤣

[@mars___sumner]

Scott Steiner math

[@kallanlierl8539]

Yall are my favorite cEDH channel! I really appreciate how you explain your lines of thought on difficult lines of play

[@VRanger100]

I know a few people who hate Simic with a passion since its recent power creep from Standard. Gonna show them this video to get a reaction; hopefully I’ll survive.

[@paulmcclain642]

Oko and Uro ruined Simic for me too. I've only just recovered from them, but I never want to see a Teferi, Time Raveler again for as long as I live

[@eliluttrell7637]

Wavebreak Hippocamp definitely gets card of the game. This card has always been underated since release and I'm glad to see someone else using it.

[@MstrKipper]

I saw the Edric and was so hoping it was Tomer with his turns deck : )

[@pnelllott7300]

Two yrs. old but I learned a lot from this, I will probably watch it again. thanks for this.

[@jonlamoreaux1889]

Shouldnt tomer shuffle green sun's back into his library?

[@MM-oz9nx]

Yes, he should have

[@dustyfox6511]

Tomer isn't very good at magic...

[@illbetthisnameisnttaken6598]

@@dustyfox6511 He doesn't make good cEDH plays from what I've seen. I don't think he pays attention to the meta enough to be fully in tune with it. He's more of a casual player from what I've seen & how he talks when politicking. It can take a bit to really pick up the nuances of cEDH, so he may just still be figuring it all out, there's a lot of things to consider that will never present themselves in a casual game that's for sure.

[@andrewpope6459]

The speaking after is soooo good!!! Please keep it in everytime!

[@paulmcclain642]

Having watched every video on this channel at least twice I have determined that . . . Tyler wears the same grey wool sweater a lot (at least on his wrists)

[@juliuscoolius6924]

Loved the vid as always! I do have one gripe with it, however. I love your playmates with the weapons and whatnot: it looks awesome! I think they look really great when your playing in person, but online, it’s hard to see the cards. There is just so much visual output from those corners of the screen that’s it’s hard to keep track of the cards on it. With a that said, I am still eager to order mine for in-person play and can’t wait to see another video, regardless of which mats you use!

[@ModAnonMTG]

Wow, honestly wouldn't have clocked that Chrome Mox thing, I don't remember the last time I read the text on that card

[@viniekoza]

That Baby Jeebus guy is in all EDH channel that I'm subscribed. 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@skylarthoma5353]

Pulling that Cyclonic Rift when you did was extra good, because if Tomer had the opportunity to go to combat he would have drawn a toooon of cards. That Rashmi sure did go off, gg!

[@bluebomber285]

As a Person who plays a Rashmi Commander deck, I'm already in love, even if our decks do two different things.

[@PlayingWithPowerMTG]

Great episode!

[@afspeellijstnaruto]

This was a cool game. Would have loved to see Kodama a bit more since I have personally never seen it going off in my own decks :p Temur decks next! I see too little temur decks ^^

[@PlaytoWinMTG]

Which 2 color pairing should we have battle next??

[@xrlylyl4089]

Azorious, for the 2 hour long video of 4 stax decks :>

[@gorzakMtG]

Gruul SMASH

[@TheBlind310]

Boros 100%. Boros does not get enough love in cEDH and EDH in general.

[@jacobjensen7704]

@@TheBlind310 we have like, one good cEDH Boros deck man. That match is gonna be a slug stax fest. And this is coming from a mainly Boros player.

[@Goldfisher]

Boros, and get Richard with his Rograkh deck for that one lol.

[@jonathanosagie1829]

how did i only now find this channel, you guys are great

[@Charlesxo]

You guys are easily my favourite content creators overall anywhere. Keep it up and thank you for the videos!

[@matthewmartin9983]

Princess Mononoke is one of my favorite movies. That alter is fantastic Tyler!

[@enzofortunato4919]

Any chance to have rashmi decklist? Really love the channel and I play ONLY simic/mono g decks, so this is my fav episode by far. Great job guys

[@pelossus]

sick 1975 shirt cam!

[@sudo7976]

Yay my favorite KZbin content. Thanks bro

[@Jose-wq4zr]

Been binging the channel recently and man Tyler is an assassin

[@alexhoude]

Yes finally, I have been waiting all week

[@angelagrace8499]

Love the fact that in this pod we have a midrange deck, a fastpaced combo deck, an aggro deck, and a contol deck even though they're all just simic

[@apock2474]

Baby Jebus out here supporting all of cedh

[@marvel_imagine1713]

@ 2:37 I think Tomer forgot to shuffle green sun back into his Library

[@7uxedomask]

I’m projecting Rashmi as my first Cedh deck so this game was really fun for me to watch! I’m much more excited about her now!

[@kstandish42]

BEST CURSED INTRO YET! Also, I fucking LOVE Tyler’s Kinnan Alter after Princess Mononoke. I actually want to commission an alter for my Ukkima and Cazur after it.

[@phillyc7946]

Great game guys. Will yall be doing a Rakdos one of these anytime soon?

[@orsettomorbido]

Ohhh, I thought I missed it when Tomer talked about it on twitter! But nope! Hell yeah.

[@brandong9145]

Could we get a drop shadow behind the on screen text? They kinda blend in with the background and adding that would distinguish them a little more

[@isaactodd1256]

Love seeing Tomer on here. Thanks for the fun video.

[@LemorasCards]

Didn't think I'd enjoy 4 simic decks this much. Rashmi looks so sick.

[@sivancohen4940]

"hes either gonna do it, or hes not so I have a 50/50 chance" - cam. donald trump might walk into my room right now, start dance, jump off the balcony and onto a plane like in a movie, or he might now. according to cams logic there is a 50% chance that will happen lmao

[@Agumon2509]

In the beginning Tomer green sun didn’t shuffle back lol

[@Arcdemon44]

The Princess Mononoke altered Kinnan is so cool.

[@thifelicii]

Flawless game played by Dylan. Wooow. Huge

[@oddball_covers]

I think we should see the best grixis deck next. Kess, rog Silas, inalla obeka

[@ngbrother]

This is the match up I've been waiting for

[@edgyedgyogre9363]

Rashmi is my favorite deck at the moment, and I like seeing her here

[@grinreaperoftrolls7528]

I don’t think I’ve ever clicked a video faster

[@timc0212]

Dylan explained that Cyclonic Rift so well here.

[@rosavigXD]

Where´s Tatyova??

[@DrunkenLee]

I feel like tatyova should’ve been in this video but these 4 are solid too. Maybe edric might’ve fallen but I could be wrong too

[@benso309]

What happened to cams finger.? I hope he is okay. Hoping for your fast recovery Take care

[@theogrist2348]

It's always great to watch cEDH with you guys. While I enjoy mons and playing with power, yours always seems more raw and normal reactions from people. I know that you're a magic and cEDH channel, but would you ever consider playing other fantasy games like Warhammer? It has a very serious level of competitive nature to it and requires a lot of thinking

[@lordosis5650]

I love CC trying to understand hull breacher. Whole preacher? Hope Richard? Whole breacher? Lol

[@wilfulbuckle13]

Great watch during my lunch break.

[@wbw911]

oh no Green Sun!

[@eliluttrell7637]

Simic battle. Where's the OG Momir Vig? You get to tutor every time you cast and Rashmi is in the 99 for even more draw power. Though I will admit having Rashmi and Momir at the table seems a bit redundant play style wise.

[@014TheValentino]

Wavebreak hippo turn 1, great play n great vid

[@esrohm6460]

only 3 basics in 2 color seems a bit excessive in the color fixing. in bg you mostly have green 1 drops so having a basic forest in the opening isn't that bad

[@dess8815]

Now that as fun to watch great game guys

[@kellyperry5009]

Never saw how rashmi wins, thst was sweet! I definitely want to incorporate some of those lines into my non grixis lists. Thanks all!!!

[@calwomack94]

Why aren't the starting hand sizes symmetrical?? 😬😫😫

[@TheWaffleDad]

Great game. You make me want to build Rashmi

[@chandlergard5342]

I love the lists everyone brought! Question for anyone, any guidance would be much appreciated! WHO'S THE BEST RAKDOS COMMANDER IN cEDH?

[@devinbrunson4871]

Hey I got a question how do you guys afford these cards?

[@calubras]

Great as always!

[@becklarson8767]

Hey can't you not use mdfc's for discard land triggers? I was fairly confident you cannot do that

[@hipposlapper]

Love your videos guys! Please keep it up!

[@dhov760]

My playgroup watches, love you Lance and Kye.

[@zeroclout6306]

Me: I wonder if this Rashmi value/control deck I'm building is a good strategy? Let's KZbin some games with her. KZbin:

[@williamcopple1507]

Why didn't Tomer shuffle his green sun into his library?

[@damiantey4593]

Very fun game!

[@firstandlast.1254]

Best part of every Sunday!

[@TripsAhoy]

Nice to see Tomer and not Richard without his actual cards! ;) Lol

[@louisgreen3071]

Why didn't Dylan just use the gitaxian probe rather than discarding it?

[@basicgiraffology3709]

Do CEDH players run Homeward Path? I see all these games were someone just holds a Gilded Drake target forever, I get not having the land in hand, but wouldn't it be a nice addition? I'm just curous

[@PlaytoWinMTG]

Hmm not much but I think I’ve seen Gitrog players use it. If you’re in low colors, specifically green so you have more tutors for it AND your commander is your combo piece, then It might be worth considering

[@basicgiraffology3709]

@@PlaytoWinMTG I play against so many decks in casual that like to steal, and was in a game with a guy who build a deck for a little competition for a friend's birthday that was all about taking commanders from other players. I ALWAYS put a Homeward Path in, not only for me, but for political power. I'm not a big CEDH player, so I was super interested to hear thoughts on this land, super awesome that you responded lmao

[@TheSpiritombsableye]

17:30, now I will expect a part 2.

[@allbadmanners]

Why didn't Tyler attempt to unsubstantiate cyclonic rift? Did he want it to happen, it didn't seem like it, but he gave Dylan free force of will mana ironically.

[@caelgunkel6869]

Wait is Pir and toothy actually gonna be on the next simic showcase?! Or was that just a joke lol. I love pir and toothy but they kinda suck competitively and I’ve been waiting for content on it

[@PlaytoWinMTG]

Both

[@EvanPlaysPc]

Loooooove Rashmi, excited for this one

[@EvanPlaysPc]

Spoiler for the game: I have cedh Rashmi and oh my god that's the nut start, I dream of those starts hahahah

[@Grunik1618]

Alright Dylan and Cameron, I have a very important question for both of you. Favorite band?

[@AndrewRaymund]

For the algorithm! Great episode as always!

[@11epicnoob]

Alternative title: Simic Standoff

[@jqohnthao8714]

You guys should play a game where all the players have the same commander...let's say nekusar. That'll be fun lol

[@pepperonization]

Turn 1 polluted delta is the new meta!

[@benjaminarmstrong9627]

More tomer please!

[@Riverbud]

Who would've thought cyclonic rift is good? 😆

[@Turn2Ugin]

Nice video as always kings

[@geeganasaw3895]

At 9:29 you couldn’t discard that mdfc to mox diamond because it is not a land on the front side of the card

[@drmurkinu7663]

I'm sure Tomer was stoked to die by card draw lol

[@timothydoyle9916]

For the algorithm love the content

[@mohammadkhalifa3176]

Yo Tyler what happened to your finger? Are you ok?

[@MRDUALITY]

My boy Kinnan!!!

[@LucasCotrim19]

Great game!

[@aaronyu4919]

They did my boy momir vig dirty 😩

[@youtuber4545]

No Tatyova :( Sad simic noises.

[@heathbasner9276]

interesting win decking out opponents with unlimited mana

[@joelprive3458]

I wish Rashmi was playable and the meta wasn't as punishing

[@ejlopez2348]

No Momir?