Rick Danko singing I Shall Be Released at Richard Manuel's memorial service.

[@gregoryadamo1956]

Discovering this on 12.29.23 - Rick would have turned 80 today. His, Levon, Garth. Richard, Robbie, and Bob's music have been so important to my life for 55 years.

[@jimrebr]

It’s January 3rd, 2025, so Rick would be 81, if he had lived longer. I loved Rick, Richard, Levon, Garth and Robbie, though I think Robbie shouldn’t have ended the Band at The Last Waltz, he could have just left The Band, but then we wouldn’t have The Last Waltz. They could have just had The Great Thanksgiving Dinner with The Band and Friends, it would have sold out either way & maybe Richard wouldn’t have unalived himself…can’t change the past though, what’s done is done.

[@Gurkmassa]

This is so hard to listen to. You can hear how close Rick is to crying. And as the bassist of one of the greatest rhythm sections of all time, I think him struggling to keep the rhythm says a lot about how crushed he was about Richard's death. This was such a beautiful tribute to a lovely man and musician who left this earth way too early.

[@scottyshomesteaduniversity7778]

I’m sure he was not sober… I don’t blame him! Before anyone attacks me… he’s a relative. I’m sure I wouldn’t have been sober at my BFF’s funeral either!

[@hannejeppesen1809]

No one is judging Rick, this was so beautiful and sad.@@scottyshomesteaduniversity7778

[@joelong7448]

You could always see how good of friends they were. Many great ones have passed, but these guys for me? Music Goliaths.

[@Killguy-]

I mean to be fair to Danko I don't think organ is always the easiest to sing along to solo. The chord changes here are a little whacky to me

[@rd264]

beautiful singing

[@jjforno]

This was NOT at the funeral service in Canada on Sunday March 9th. This was two days later at the Overlook Methodist Church just outside the village of Woodstock NY. I arranged this “Service of Remembrance” with the Lasher Funeral home. It was standing room only and it was for those who loved Richard who didn’t go to Canada for the funeral. My father and I sat with Rick and others got up to speak and tell stories to celebrate Richard’s life. Rick thought the service was going on a little too long and that’s when he got up to sing. As he said, there wasn’t plans to do so. It was the very end of the service. The date was Tuesday March 11, 1986.

[@pez---]

respect x

[@traceychrzanowski926]

Beautiful. Was Levon there?

[@jjforno]

@@traceychrzanowski926 no, he had just gotten back from the funeral in Canada and didn’t attend the local service

[@giaccobrazzi]

I believe this was recorded by my father?

[@jjforno]

@@giaccobrazzi yes Josh, Andy recorded this. - Joe F.

[@savanna1980]

Here reminiscing after the loss of Robbie today. What a healing force The Band's music has been to me throughout my life! I'm grateful that my father introduced me to real music as a child (of the '80s.) I can't help but think about how Garth must be feeling today.

[@rsmith7853]

😢😢😢

[@Johnnynbk]

This is about Richard Manuel

[@michaele.]

Garth has a facebook site

[@savanna1980]

@@Johnnynbk I understand that this was for Manuel. I simply said I was visiting this video after the loss of Robertson.

[@jamesclayton161]

Garth I'm sure is feeling lost and so was everyone else . It's hard for me to say this since as close as I ever got to the band was their music so all I've ever read , listened , or heard someone who actually knew them which many of the people I honestly thought knew what they were talking about since the stage and light jobs I worked was with a few people that where their training rodies so yea I got some insights on the Band Members and it was taken very hard by all members of the tight knit group and it simply reverberated thru all and questioners didn't have much sympathy for any of their private lives . As I read these comments other than the original comment by johnnycardboard was a sincere comment which a lot of your replies where way outta line , I mean read the comment and dont reply with such negativity i mean come on guys damn use that thing above your shoulders for something else other than rin & stimpy's cartoons and take a break since I don't know of one negative comment that has ever been givin about The Band just simply try to be human every now & then . Peace be with you all and anyone who comes here for the music and may everyone you hold close have peace in their lives as well !!!

[@Karmakatt6]

Richard was only 33 during The Last Waltz, literally already spending half his life on the Road. All of The Band were ancient souls.. RIP Boys, you’re forever missed, continue to inspire and are always within our hearts and minds. XOXOXO

[@johnmcafee2353]

Rick danko and Richard Manuel are both geniuses in my opinion 💚

[@pabloperez4063]

All the band

[@MarvinMonroe]

In my opinion that's a fact and not simply an opinion

[@genogentile733]

the whole tremendously talented group unfortunately selfish robbie was egotistical and clueless

[@teacup3133]

Lovely men

[@1travstone]

It’s not just your opinion, friend. The Band were truly amazing

[@LuAnnHeston]

I'm 66 years old, I grew up with The Band, & all the amazing music from back then, I am so thankful to have been brought up with all the important, beautiful music I was surrounded by. RIP, thank you for all the joy you brought to all of us with your music!!!

[@allenlashleysr]

Agreed!

[@FRATZROCKET]

I miss Richard, Rick and Levon sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo much. Never heard 3 voices like theirs ever.

[@RachelWeeping]

It seems like we're rat's trying to get through a maze. When we go younger rat's replace us. But the younger rats don't know who Richard and Rick and Levon were. There in lies the tragedy. Not that we're gone, but that the people who got us through this mess aren't remembered.

[@tbbb2]

It's not possible to listen to this and not get chills....right?

[@R-D-bj6ot]

Rick Danko's tears can be heard between each verse

[@mikea-m1457]

Just Garth left now.....Good God , what a talented lot , never ever to be replicated or replaced.....

[@johnknottenbelt2727]

This song became a silent partner to me from when I first heard it on 'Music from Big Pink' in 1968, Richard's plaintive voice tugging at my heart, like some forgotten child at its parent's clothes. Then during my incarceration in Brixton prison for stowing away from South Africa to England, merely 4 days before my 21st birthday, 15 November, 1969 while awaiting repatriation, it became a form of salvation for my sanity. Now here I sit, shortly before my 75th birthday, in my home in Durban SA, with the sad comfort of this masterpiece transporting me to a thousand memories, all held together by the strains of a tribute by a brother to the man who steeped us in its comfort while trying to dispel his own loss & sadness ❤

[@rafaelwillems3244]

I feel what you mean I guess. Some say this was a too simple song from Dylan. But who on earth never felt the killing feeling of emprisonment and the longing for freedom. This applies to all of us & could be sung in any church mass, or in a mosque or a desert.

[@newyorklad3994]

My cousin Gary served in Nam. He got me the brown album when I was in high school and I was hooked. Later, in the 80's, I was teaching at Marist in Poughkeepsie and went up to a small dinner club to attend one of the last of The Band's performances before they went to Florida. The dinner club had the word Texas in it. Before the performance Rick had a T-shirt table set up and we said hello to each other. When Richard sang he seemed lost, and Levon nodded affirmation-encouragement to him. I was not surprised when weeks later the news came about Richard. When they made the mold for The Band they put on a lock and threw away the key. They were one of the most unique creative artists of my generation. Thanks to all you guys who supported them

[@janeswann8956]

❤

[@robertbruce6865]

Joe Forno’s book, Levon’s Man, discusses some of Richard’s self esteem issues. It’s a good, but sad, read.

[@bruceedwards8339]

Maybe the club was The Lone Star Cafe?

[@pac401]

Most bands are lucky to have one decent lead vocalist. The Band were blessed with three outstanding vocalists. There will never be another group like them again.

[@ricardofreitascalle7702]

God bless the Band.

[@russellgraves7396]

I can’t get enough of Richard’s voice. Rick nailed it these guys were the real deal.

[@nathanwhitten8950]

Thanks for sharing this. I have never heard Rick sing in a falsetto. He almost sounds like Richard. He does a great job.

[@jezebeljones659]

And that's gotta be Garth on organ...?

[@inthegamepodcast6596]

The song ‘It makes no difference’ Rick hits those notes.

[@inthegamepodcast6596]

@@jezebeljones659 yes it is Garth, I was told the only one that did not show up was Robbie. I am sensing nobody liked Robbie, might be the fact he took credit for everything including writing the songs. My own personal opinion after listening to interviews and the music, Robbie was the least talented singer and musician in the group.

[@danielfinn1526]

Robbie did write most of the great songs.

[@jez2466]

@@inthegamepodcast6596 whatever else Robbie Robertson did, he is certainly not the least talented musician. He is the only one who had a succesful solo career. Who knows how the Band's songs were written, but Levon Helm barely wrote a song after leaving the Band. I suspect that Robertson wrote the songs and the rest of the guys worked on them and contributed here and there. Probably he should have given them more credit with the song writing. But we don't know.

[@johnunkerman]

It doesn’t get more real than this man ❤️ 🙏

[@neilredmond1011]

Luv Richard Manuel,recently watched a interview with Eric Clapton who talked about how much he loved Richard and how fragile he was but had this magical persona about him great interview, R.I.P Richard

[@buffikit]

Utterly heartbreaking. Such a huge loss.

[@davidkapel7056]

I live only a few miles from Rick's old stomping grounds. He will be missed just as much as Richard. Sad times.

[@inthegamepodcast6596]

Good old Norfolk County

[@nocellphone]

Hauntingly beautiful...

[@jamesmccarthy5086]

As I hold back my tears, I wish Richard had gotten to live much longer. He could’ve done so much more. I hope he has a special mission in heaven! Rip to Robbie also as this is a few days after his passing so that’s why I thought I’d play it. Rip to Rick and Levon and other Richard as well!

[@OldStationRecords]

Richard Manuel was such a talented person...such a voice...in the "shape I'm in" shines...such a loss...could have done a giant work if remained on this side....great musician, rest in peace

[@Argotero]

Richard Manuel its been my favor singer all times, the deep power of his voice, the most sensitive approach for popular music. The first time I heard him, was in the incredible Lonesome Suzie who has been by my side all my life .... thanks Rick and friends.

[@thejawshop-AdventureRecording]

Rick brings us into the room, after all these years they both bring soul to us.

[@jessedixon4391]

I was attending a Bonnie Raitt concert at the Valley Forge Music Fair on the day that Richard died. Bonnie performed a tearful, heartfelt, and heartbreaking dedication to Richard that I will never forget. There were no dry eyes in the house.

[@eamonnmorris5331]

Richard Manuel ... always remembered ... never forgotten ...

[@kevindigo22]

I cannot watch or listen to this without tearing up......

[@kurtcole9574]

f, I just broke into tears. The Band has been one of my favorite bands since the late 70s when my older brother loaned me the cassette of greatest hits. Rest in Peace my friend.

[@sleadie59]

This rips through my heart

[@johnremington1538]

This is an amazing piece of history! THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR SHARING!

[@timshelley8635]

Absolutely beautiful! Always loved this song and it has never moved me more.

[@JamesDuncan-sh9zy]

I was there that day & Rick’s rendition was absolutely Heartbreaking! That’s Garth on the organ. Packed house, including Levon, with very few dry eyes in the house.

[@Sparks53]

The Band holds such a special place in my heart and I loved the playfulness and humility with which they came across. They were great to see live and I will .sure miss them all. Garth Hudson is the only one left living. In the early years Garth, who was classically trained, actually tutored his band mates

[@lastnamefirst4035]

How sad. Especially very end when Rick said God Bless You Richard

[@jimbob12404yahoo]

I was at the memorial for RICK at Bearsville Theater, and a lot of people got up and sang. Robbie even showed up to eulogize his friend, and it was a celebration of a life, rather than a sad day. Now we ve lost Robbie....

[@salbonshwahggi8132]

Oh My goodness, this is a beautiful but sad surprise. The photographs of Rick and Richard are priceless. It must've been really difficult to sing this without crying. You can hear it in Ricks voice that he had already been crying. Thank you so much for sharing this with us.

[@gostrum1]

I’ve been listening to a lot of Levon and the Hawks do their soul/r & b covers and Manuel was just a fantastic singer

[@SuperMcabral]

What a wonderful tribute! It had to be so hard. See you guys in Paradise! 😎✌️♥️

[@TheLastWalenta]

Music holds a monopoly over my emotion. I love this so much. Thank you, @J F

[@waltw4537]

The chorus just spontaneously sprang from my voice.... Then heard the room singing also.. What a moment it must have been...

[@mrnobody9104]

thanks for sharing that most heartfelt rendition with us that was beautiful!

[@Professor1789]

Thank you for sharing this beautiful tribute to Richard.

[@josephmckenna3720]

A beautiful tribute to a beautiful man

[@tangyorange6509]

Chills. Can’t believe I’ve never heard this before.

[@jimajello1028]

Richard...loved music. Loved writing with the Band. Great piano player & vocalist. Too young to have left us. Yet his extensive musical contributions to the band's sound will live on. Rest in peace.

[@jganonymous438]

RIP Richard Thanks Rick - All of you and the other members of the Band (almost all together again) helped me through some very dark times. Thanks for everything.

[@idicula1979]

Very heartfelt, I’m sorry for you loss, I’m sorry for all of us, who lost a little bit of our joy. We all lost something of an artist a talent who shared his light with the world.

[@no59do56]

This maybe one of the best songs ever written.

[@jnagarya519]

Written by Bob Dylan.

[@leh3827]

It's hard to sing when you are crying. Jist Garth and Rob left now. They are my alltime favorites, the Band. Even the name corners unique.

[@mark.gallaher3193]

Once were Brothers... Indeed.

[@patrickmcginn4435]

Rick would only live another 13 yrs after this. So tragic.

[@lastnamefirst4035]

Sad that Rick was in poor health and was a long time heroin user

[@stormbringercoming8105]

Saw The Band a few months before Rick passed. I was frightened by his appearance and voice. I just knew that he wasn’t long for the world. Rick and Richard deserved better.

[@thomas-wj9kt]

@@lastnamefirst4035 what's your proof?

[@lastnamefirst4035]

@@thomas-wj9kt look it up. Easy to find

[@thomas-wj9kt]

Met him in 1989 with his son and wife,don't have to "look it up".

[@Jefferson1969-u4s]

So moving. For his dear friend. ❤️

[@ervbefelnareik7604]

Its a shame what alcohol can do to you, this brings a tear to my eyes evertime I hear it. He should've lived on, nowadays I'm sure he would've found the help too. Just wasn't there at that particular time. Rick's voice is excellent here and if anyone could sing like Richard it would be Rick.

[@hannejeppesen1809]

Robbie wrote in this book, how they all reliazed Richard had a problem, but back then they were not a lot of talk about rehabs, besided like Robbie wrote we were no angels, we all chasing demons, and the race was on.

[@Staylogical]

I bought the 3 record Last Waltz vinyl when it first came out.Richard's credits on the sleeve were longest of anyone:vocals,piano,organ, guitar,drums(in the second rhythm section),dobro,tenor sax.And a voice like no other.

[@19wiser52]

I was at the Woodstock memorial .....it was open to the public and was standing room only....

[@zenzen1916]

All those guys from The Band lived life to the fullest🎶💔🌷🌸

[@hannejeppesen1809]

And then some, read Robbie's book Testimony. I'm of that generation, we all tried to squeeze as much out of life as possible. I was not heavy into drugs, but did my share of partying, dating ect.

[@Resenbrink]

Beautiful....thanks for sharing.

[@acousticshadow4032]

Best line from "The Last Waltz" was when Richard Manuel said, "I'm just trying to break even.". 😂

[@krisbrauen9573]

It was a great line. I wrote a song inspired by that quote.

[@llewellynwilliams1956]

ha ha love it

[@Karmakatt6]

I hung on every word in that film.. I'm sure, many still do. RIP those who've passed and Well Wishes to those still around.. "We just decided to call ourselves... The Band." -R.M

[@d.cypher2920]

😂

[@DylanRoth1860]

Talk about an underrated vocalist.

[@9921moo]

a very very sad story.....the Band did Canada proud in particular s/w Ontario from whence Rick and Richard and Robbie and Garth were from and fate intervened somehow and Ronnie Hawkins along with Levon completed the puzzle....music from the 60`s and 70`s and 80`s will never rise up again the way it once did.....

[@cassidy-beaukitt1972]

My favorite musicians forever 💙💙💙💙💙💚💚💚💚💚💙💙💙💙💙💚💚💚💚💚 thank you so much for this video💙💙💙💙

[@catmouth]

Thank you for sharing this.

[@terrymay2000]

There is just something about Richard that draws me in. Can't explain it but I think he's beautiful in more than one way. If only he knew how many people adored him.

[@nissi.k]

This is so bittersweet and special! 🕯💙🕊

[@gamedrone]

RIP All of you. Each and every one.

[@helenhess1603]

Such a great talent such a shame how he suffered with with depression great loss rest in peace Richard

[@hdessau]

wow....just beautiful.

[@RWBVanc]

Heartbreaking

[@paulabiscuit7767]

Hauntingly good.

[@hannejeppesen1809]

On majority of the songs I listen to sung by Rick, he is so soulful and puts all his feelings into his singing. Especially when he sings this.

[@GuyCabliaro]

What a voice!!

[@donhurst1409]

Oh my, if you are not crying while you listen...

[@229adven]

Wow!!!!!!

[@eduardodreifus2044]

TE LLEVAREMOS SIEMPRE EN NUESTROS CORAZONES!

[@michaelb.9548]

A lot of pain in this performance. Phew!

[@davidtullis2810]

Haunting just like every song he wrote

[@charleshendrix232]

Pretty sure Dylan wrote it

[@charleshendrix232]

@ThePizzageek There is no evidence of that. But its a nice story.

[@hannejeppesen1809]

Yes Dylan wrote it. However, Rick sang the only way he could for his friend, haunting and full of feeling.@@charleshendrix232

[@hannejeppesen1809]

Dylan wrote so what?@@charleshendrix232

[@hannejeppesen1809]

Yes Dylan wrote is, it is well documented. When Rick sang it at Richard's memorial he made it his.@@charleshendrix232

[@9921moo]

i`m back again....Life is just one sad story after another.....

[@tonysloggett106]

thanks for sharing

[@justdynee]

I was mad at you Robbie. For a long time. I understand and believe everything you said. Thanx for keeping them alive longer even though it meant ending The Band. It had to be done and you were the adult in the room. You done good from fellow Canadian Indian. The winds if the high prairie may not reach your home but, hell you're probably out there riding a horse anyway.

[@dianefishkin1903]

Robbie was supposed to say the Eulogy, he wasn't there..that is why this was not planned, sung Beautifully Rick for your "brother" Richard. R.I.P. Richard, Rick, Levon. Brothers in each others arms once again

[@hannejeppesen1809]

Robbie had the flu.

[@Jan_Mac]

You made me cry.

[@ArchStantonify]

Thank you so much for this

[@jackwiseman6165]

Love his voice. Rest in peace Mr Manuel. God bless you 🙏 ❤️

[@terrygarcia897]

Thanks Rick. Merry Christmas in heaven. TX.

[@craigsimon7658]

RIP RiCHARD.. RICK and LEVON

[@AdautoFernandes]

maravilhoso, simplesmente maravilhoso.

[@BarryHawk]

Only Richard... and only Rick...

[@JohnnyBonesaw]

Thank you

[@robotubetwob]

Singing it in Richard's voice.

[@denisretiere7917]

Version si triste et si belle. Pleurez braves.

[@McMurphyKirby]

Rick Danko said to me that Richard would pull pranks and that he thought his passing was a prank gone bad....Blessings

[@johnhealy6676]

43 too too early I hope he’s is at rest now Thank you for the music Beware of demons

[@jaycreekmore9369]

Bring a tear to my eye

[@erockelmtree7868]

A beautiful spiritual number

[@donnabroughalpelletier3685]

Beautiful !

[@justdynee]

Ultimately there are the three parts to The Band Story. The beginning with the Hawks and onto Dylan. The breakthrough to Big Pink and so on and the End and afterward. Scorsese and the Last Waltz which has since become the biggest of The Band lore. Ultimately the Prime Years were marred by drugs and alcohol and that became a huge issue with Rick, Levon and Richard in the afterward. Robbie kept them alive by disbanding.

[@ikkenhisatsu7170]

Fallen angel, indeed.

[@fionafraser-oj8lp]

very sad 2 very talented men are dead because of addiction problems may your souls live and enlighten others

[@joekosobucki2141]

Garth is the only one left! What a great band!!

[@robinaqureshi]

Haunting.