The Lost Players of Survivor

They were cast, then they weren't. These are the lost players of Survivor.
/ idoled_out
Music: Silent Partner - New Tires
The Lost Players of Big Brother: • The Lost Houseguests o...
Intro: 00:00-01:20
Mystery Maureen: 01:21-02:55
Mellisa McNulty: 02:56-05:03
Craig Saint-Amour: 05:04-05:58
Toddzan Robertson: 05:59-07:11
Doo Kim: 07:12-07:52
Willie Gault: 07:53-09:07
Jared Fields: 09:08-10:17
Brooke Burgess: 10:18-11:36
Jimmy Kelleher: 11:37-12:51
Mystery S46 Alternate: 12:52-14:04
Outro: 14:05-14:54

[@XanderMatthews-nv9zf]

Melissa’s quit actually meant that Sylvia who single-handedly chose the tribes was given 0 shot at living on the luxury camp

[@ashen_roses]

The camp that she led the building of, BECAUSE she built it. One of the shittiest twists they've done

[@IdoledOut]

Sylvia was so screwed over it's unreal!

[@christinekelleher4972]

jimmy k wont quit hes a farmer!!

[@giovanniorellana2200]

Thank goodness Davie was on DvG instead of Jared

[@itzwakk335]

dodged a bullet lol

[@lastdayonearthmysteryman4849]

@@itzwakk335Absolutely!

[@mehgend3914]

Davie should’ve won! :( stuck with the incest congress guy forever now

[@robbybaker6657]

Huh, I didn't know he was bad. I only knew he's Cirie's son

[@lastdayonearthmysteryman4849]

@robbybaker6657 Did you watch big brother twenty five?

[@midnalazuli793]

Imagine how Troyzan felt when he realized that he had been axed in favor of either Colton, Monica, or Kat.

[@1Nanalo]

They dont cut men for women... men are cut for men.

[@bryantedwards6679]

And it’s probably Colton if they wanted to keep the gender balance 😂

[@nicholasjessup6788]

Troyzan probably would’ve been a better pick than Colton. The only saving grace of having Colton was having his fiancée Caleb on the cast.

[@rowan4573]

"And also Kane" Made me do a spit take

[@itzwakk335]

remember that one episode in 44 where they tried to give kane content? had me crying

[@sw7665]

Reminds me of when Bruce in 45 name-dropped Kane of all people as if that would impress everyone.

[@danimegaladon]

i know him in real life we’re from the same hometown i clipped it for him you’re welcome kane

[@MikeGlasses]

“Tall bearded man”, is the new survivors chekhov's gun. I need to see this playout in the future

[@sw7665]

I don't know why, but I find the whole bearded player who other players are talking about that isn't even a player (with the necessary added citation) hilarious.

[@colinloveland6667]

He's already iconic I need to know who he is 🤣

[@Sixersszn0]

If Jared did get cast production would probably just censor out his bad behavior so I’m glad he went on a show where we see everything 24/7

[@owenpierce4874]

I feel like Troyzan probably sent in his clothes because they were still weary of putting Colton on the cast.

[@58twright]

I would have much rather seen Troyzan

[@uglyaniimals]

@@58twrightagreed and i think troyzan is a douche

[@andrewreinwand4942]

I’d like to think the bearded mystery man from 46 is Rupert with like, sunglasses on or some really generic item that makes no one realize it’s him like some cartoon/comedy sketch.

[@itzwakk335]

Idoled Out and Ethanimale mind meld oh the power

[@LivTheSlayer]

Im very glad Jared was on big brother where we could see all the horrible stuff he had to say instead of on survivor where it would've been mostly cut out

[@moviemaniac14]

I’m a tad shocked to see you uploaded a video knowing usually every holiday, you take the week off. Thankfully I’m glad to see this one.

[@IdoledOut]

I'm taking a week off either in April for my birthday or in mid-May when I'm going to Mexico (haven't decided which yet), so I figured I'd upload today so I don't get punished too harshly by the almighty algorithm

[@moviemaniac14]

@@IdoledOut awesome. Well happy early birthday.

[@queenzoroark]

Nina Twine was considered to be on DvG, so we could have Cirie's son and Sandra's daughter in the season

[@mistatrapstar]

should have been a captain’s season.

[@58twright]

Wow

[@dakotaterry62]

She dodged a bullet, she’s an all time fave in Aussie.

[@uglyaniimals]

honestly her being on aussie survivor instead might have benefitted her legacy ?? i do like her but the fact of the matter is she isn't a particularly big personality so she probably would've been lost in the shuffle and potentially considered a disappointment in a cast with as many great characters as dvg. instead, she got put on a season with one of the worst casts in any survivor ever, was tragically medevaced during a time in the game where she was super well positioned but went out early enough that she didn't have a particularly big target headed into her return season, leading to a deep run for her there

[@Ethanimale]

That Jimmy Kelleher one kind of blew my mind. If only we could have gotten him on BB25 too!

[@IdoledOut]

He seems so fun from his social media! Very adorable old man vibes with a loud Boston twist

[@Hockeyhobo89]

This is why you’re the best. Your video topics are just the most creative and interesting.

[@colinvanblaricom6573]

The name Maureen came from the fact that Mark Burnett was on a news show in 2001 promoting the Survivor Borneo book. AO had just started production and he said that a 40 year old mom named Maureen had dropped out last minute due to being afraid.

[@felixvecchiarelli6458]

This is going to be interesting! Thanks!

[@codypagels1598]

Assuming he doesn’t immediately spill that Cirie is his mom, the other Goliaths trying to figure out why a dumb exterminator who says “fuck” and “bro” 6 times a sentence was put on the Goliath tribe would have been funny.

[@itzwakk335]

yeah looking at the extremely chill, accomplished, and secure personalities on goliath jared 100% would have been an early boot

[@petermcgill3405]

And people might recognize him from the Game Changers loved ones visit

[@XanderMatthews-nv9zf]

I feel like people forget that this tribe also had Natalie, Jeremy, Mike White and mother flipping Angelina This tribe was not chill well rounded adults even though Angelina was a selfless, 800 foot ladder climbing queen

[@itzwakk335]

@@XanderMatthews-nv9zf when you look at the ages and the places they are in their lives and careers it checks out

[@tylerhaggerty4805]

Jimmy sounds like a good addition to any of these new era casts. He certainly would add much needed age diversity.

[@martinking1993]

I'd never get tired of Michael Skupin jokes 🤣🤣

[@brobag9885]

Another W video from Idoled Out

[@snobey]

So maybe the video about the alternates? Bob, Erik Cardona, Austin...

[@IdoledOut]

This would be so fun, and I've actually tried to do research for this exact subject. But there's a shocking amount of alternates who got on, and every time I think I've uncovered all the alternates someone else confirms they were an alternate at some point or another!

[@josephinelilith3224]

I know Max Dawson was an alt for Caramoan.

[@tubagal13]

@@IdoledOut Maybe you could make a video on the top 5 most "successful" alternates? Sort of a counter to your earlier video about the top 5 players who didn't want to play Survivor?

[@maxxh5331]

@@IdoledOut Trish Hegarty was an alternate for One World, Daniel Strunk was an alternate for Millennials vs. Gen X, and Kellie Nalbandian was an alternate for 43.

[@MrJTSizzle]

Jared “I just started viewing women as people a few months ago” Fields. Hobbies include: Nepotism, Misogyny, Cheating on his girlfriend, Cutting people off in conversation (especially women)

[@saralougy486]

Austin was also a last-minute alternate this past season. I am not sure if anything is known about who he replaced but I would be curious to find out!

[@robbybaker6657]

Great video! I was actually watching one of your old videos when I got this notification, lol. I am kind of suprised the original Sabrina Thompson wasn't on the list, but maybe I'm wrong and she doesn't fit here. Anyway, I hope you have an amazing day, Luke

[@IdoledOut]

It was unclear to me if original Sabrina was just in casting, or if she'd already been cast, and I couldn't find the original interview where Sabrina mentions this to confirm. Probably would have been worth a mention though!

[@Frames12521]

Apparently Jimmy uploaded a video on his TikTok applying for 47 Also, what about the male on 43 who's spot was filled in by Geo?

[@IdoledOut]

I don't think we know anything about the guy Geo replaced, but I'd love to know who he was!

[@uglyaniimals]

conspiracy theory: he replaced jimmy who had to pull out to shoot squid games

[@thomasdent9430]

There's a player by the name of Joel, who got cut on survivor Gabon and similar to Troyzan, had all his stuff sent to Gabon but was then called a day or two before boarding a plane that he had been cut.

[@Aceinthedesert25]

The thing with the mysterious beard guy is the best thing to come from the 46 pre-season! We need him to play!

[@madelinehutchinson]

I do wonder who Austin was a replacement for on 45, the Reba 4 would have been vastly different!

[@SmilePlsNow]

Omg what was with the RC slander??? LMAO

[@gabrielmarquestrindade7804]

right?? i liked her lol

[@mikegoldberg8939]

I wouldve loved to see troyzan on the show with his brother, but only if they forced him to go by Toddzan

[@freddytang2128]

It’s April fools today so I can’t wait for second video to be released back to back

[@worldsasuri9430]

Oh wow!Interesting!

[@Johnnyb-zd3pc]

After watching Jared on BB25, thank god we got Davie instead.

[@jeongluvs7524]

I LIVE FOR YOUR SKUPIN SHADE

[@FuelByFireOfficial]

I appreciate this topic. As a finalist reject its nice to see some other rejects get some recognition.

[@patrickkenneally3016]

Melissa will always be a big “What-If” in Survivor lore. In hindsight, her dropping out might have been a blessing in disguise. They were originally going to divide the tribe by race again like they did in Cook Islands. Doing that once raised a lot of eyebrows, if they did that again, the show probably would have been cancelled.

[@shadowninja6689]

...Is that confirmed? I mean when have they ever done the same season theme twist twice in a row? I was under the impression at the time that they did a 25% white/black/Hispanic/Asian cast for Fiji just to prove a point that they didn't just cast so many racial minorities last season for the tribes by racist twist.

[@ashen_roses]

I really doubt it would be cancelled. America isn't the PC SJW woke regime people caterwaul that it is even NOW, much less back in 2007

[@patrickkenneally3016]

@@shadowninja6689 It was mentioned in the TV Guide preview for Survivor Fiji. It’s on KZbin if you want to confirm.

[@SpanishFly120]

I mean, personally my thought is just that it's more of a blessing she dropped out pre-game than that she tried to force herself into the game. Like, she could've had an even worse mental health situation if she was actually dealing with the game itself ongoing too.

[@SurvivorQT]

Nope it was always gonna be 10 vs 10 with a pickem

[@gohawkeyes358]

We need Survivor's most heated player rivalries next

[@58twright]

Survivor 40 was originally supposed to be rivals until they changed it to all winners at the last minute I wasn’t to crazy about a rivals season however I think it would be interesting personally I think they should have waited until season 50 to do an all winners season & that could have been like the final season personally I feel survivor has already ended

[@uglyaniimals]

brandon hantz vs phillip or bust 😤😤😤😤😤😤

[@queenzoroark]

Bobby Jon vs Jamie

[@Gashnaw]

I would have loved a US vs Canada season.

[@JAMPD3]

Another one: Da'Vonne was cast for survivor but was dropped bc they wanted her for BB. I can't remember if it was her returning season or her first (I think returning), so she would've been in either Kaoh Rong's cast or a part of MvGX/pre-Game Changers theme. She's talked about it before but recently talked a bit in depth about it on her yt channel.

[@W81Researcher]

If she was on Survivor she'd be an early boot. She was too out there and over strategic.

[@Ori_Kohav]

Thank god they didn’t cast her. A transphobic mother with the mentality of a brat

[@thomastracey7677]

jelinsky my forever goat

[@tommyfry2166]

Tyler from Worlds Apart was actually in the NFL as well

[@christinekelleher4972]

jimmy k Boston looks like terry Bradshaw

[@josephinelilith3224]

7:10 I've also been told that at various points they contacted Sandra & her daughter Nina, Cindy & her sister Mindy, and Shane & his son Boston.

[@calebos268]

I feel bad for Troyzan. He could've gotten his return in BvW with his brother, then didn't get voted in to 2nd Chances. They really need to find a way to bring him back for another season.

[@temporal4652]

I thought for sure you were gonna bring up joe don from pirate master in this video

[@miamira1856]

wasn't Adam Klein and his mom going to be on sjds until her cancer diagnosis, or is that just a rumour?

[@IdoledOut]

I researched this a bit and Adam's always been (understandably) a little coy about it. I reached the conclusion they were in the casting process and almost certainly got deep, but never officially cast. I should have brought all this up as a possibility in the video, though!

[@W81Researcher]

I wished he was. Because he would not have done well on that Survivor and the person who takes his place on M vs Gx doesn't screw David.

[@freddytang2128]

Anyone else saw the title of this video and thought it’s about players that passed away?

[@tjowo1]

might be a little late to it, and someone else mightve said this, but austin from 45 was an alternate and got put in last second as well

[@the1-upclub98]

Because Craig was pulled, we got Candance heroically flipping off Brad Culpepper.

[@booshbear]

and we are better as a society for that

[@mienafriggstad3360]

😮 wow Jared was almost on Survivor

[@wierdoben14]

ALEC WAS GONNA BE A DAVID?!?

[@RavenLuna-ii6lx]

Makes sense as that would balance the tribes physically.

[@codypagels1598]

Makes sense. Bartender is an occupation that’s way more in line with the David tribe.

[@itzwakk335]

to balance the physicality

[@theojacobs8704]

Jimmy K is the GOAT He will be on survivor

[@messymop9772]

Wonder if we’ll ever see who Austin replaced

[@DaisyCup]

You can also put blue from bb25 bc production told her she needed to be on bb or survivor. I remember her saying this in a qna vid

[@rockotaylor7468]

I wish rc was in blood vs water

[@afreyno1]

I'm happy Jared was on Survivor haha, I wasn't a fan of him on BB at all.

[@jordanpappas9904]

The mention of Candice each week makes my day

[@AGJ117]

For Worlds Apart, I believe that Willie Gault dropping out is also what got Will on season to take Tyler's place on the No Collar tribe. He was originally supposed to be on the Amazing Race with his wife, which makes ALOT more sense given he was terrible at strategizing and the physical challenges. I think after observing the cast, the show was desperate to try and find a Black contestant and decided on Will as a sudden recruit.

[@AnthonyGaming69420]

Interesting

[@kayleighlehrman9566]

We got plenty of cut players out here we could probably cast a pretty good season just using cut players!

[@psychospike7458]

Adam from s33 and his mum were supposed to be on s29 but his mum couldn't go on for obvious reasons

[@Frames12521]

Daniel from 42 was apparently Adam's alternate for MvGX as well

[@psychospike7458]

@@Frames12521 I haven't watched 42 yet I don't know who that is

[@TyBoS8]

Luke! I am lost! Save me!

[@esinger23]

I remember hearing about Davie replacing Jared on DvG

[@58twright]

I think Jared freaked out about the weather right before & dropped out

[@I_Am_Zava]

Wasn't Adam and his mom also cast for SJDS also before she got sick?

[@Roachn8r]

Didn’t Adam say that he and his mom were on the list for San Juan del Sur?

[@kennethcampbell7263]

Yeah as you said 'Alternates' as they are only cast members if someone get pulled from the show. the annoying thing was season 42 and I think 43 someone was pulled for medical issues after the start really how long are you casting between each season?

[@youtubewatcher8858]

Uploaded a minute ago what timing

[@Bryce946]

And I can add another reason to Love Tina the first ever alternate to win Survivor

[@electricninja7493]

Is it just me clueless, or what did Mark Burnett do? I can’t find anything, but would like to know

[@tdarkhorse4]

didn't earl also replace somebody last minute? jeff talked about it at the reunion. earl was literally called a day or so before everyone was to fly out, just like davie was. and the only thing we can say for sure about the guy earl replaced is he was a Black man, since fiji was originally going to run the same race divided twist that cook islands ran, but melissa mcnulty's quit threw that whole thing into chaos.

[@Schweinas84]

Tyler from Worlds Apart was a kicker in the NFL. So they did in fact have a pro athlete that season

[@brunocoppola2639]

SURVIVOR IS GOING DOWN THE TUBES! They shouldn't of brought back the dropped Farmer Jimmy K from Bostom!

[@christinekelleher4972]

yup a must!!!

[@jimkelleher555]

😮cbs. You all see this jimmy k. Should be in tough as can be and a true life farmer

[@Awesometrax]

Funny how the last second drop in Worlds Apart probably made the season exponentially worse off (pending how Willie Gault is as a person of course), but then the DvG one made it considerably better off with Davie instead of Jared.

[@nathandanczak7822]

People were still going to bitch at worlds apart. Davie's only defined by idols.

[@Awesometrax]

@nathandanczak7822 Rodney and Dan were real bad sure, but if Willie Gault was pleasant then it would have been at least a bit less mean spirited (no Shirin/Will incident). Personally I liked Davie and would be all for him returning one day if Survivor was actually willing to bring back pre-new era players.

[@nathandanczak7822]

@awesometrax Than the fight would just either expand to dan or another person if shirin constantly talking as a victim and butting in other's faces with it still happens(it would have). Davie 's only real character was that he was slightly amusing about his strategy talk. So no character,(and pretty much every survivor since post Kaoh-rong filiming).

[@W81Researcher]

​@@nathandanczak7822It was pathetic how America felt sorry for Shirin and voted her into Second Chances OVER CAROLYN. Shirin's edit early on pretty much told us she wasn't an endgamer. All because of that incident.

[@seanberrodin801]

If you get on the show ever can your lower third please be “professional survivor watcher”?

[@queenzoroark]

That's Peridiam'a occupation

[@corksauls9403]

There’s one theory that the 46 alternate was Feras from this most recent Australian Survivor season, which I doubt is true but doesn’t mean I can still hope it is

[@BrainstormerX37]

Jelinsly confirmed the guy’s initials were S.D. so unless Feras recently got a name change, that’s unlikely

[@colinloveland6667]

LMFAO I love Feras he needs to come play in the US too but yeah it wasn't him. Apparently this alternate was Middle Eastern tho.

[@booshbear]

i heard back in the day there was also a lesbian couple supposed to be on SJDS but were unable to play as well

[@uglyaniimals]

ugh can't believe we were robbed of that :,,,,(

[@jackkolero]

Queen Melissa!❤

[@averyseldin8485]

Didn't Adam mention that he and his mother were cast on San Juan Del Ser but due to her cancer they had to drop?

[@hklaurent]

And also Kane! 😂😂 poor Kane, he didn’t do much but I liked him

[@Menstral]

RC was super-spiffy

[@Captain-Sum.Ting-Wong]

Wasn't it confirmed the guy from Pirate Master was going to be on Guatemala?

[@XanderMatthews-nv9zf]

Joe Don, but he broke his ankle so I’m not sure where on the timeline he got cut

[@Captain-Sum.Ting-Wong]

@@XanderMatthews-nv9zf I thought it was fairly far along the process he got replaced. Apparently Blake was the alternate who replaced him.

[@PedroVieira1509]

Not this Kane shade! Idoled Out you will be dealt with! - by one of the dozens Kane fans.

[@IdoledOut]

We love our D&D king here! I shade him with love

[@Mentally_Will]

I thought his name was Matt lol

[@PedroVieira1509]

@@Mentally_Will There were two Matts on that season, none of which are Kane...

[@Mentally_Will]

@@PedroVieira1509 are you not getting the joke of when they accidentally used Matt B's chyron for Kane or do you just not like the joke

[@christinekelleher4972]

this man will be a legend CBS grab him he's a show stopper at 62 he still does hard work like no other mentally and physically and a big heart !

[@christinekelleher4972]

go jimmy k

[@itzmeconar6991]

@IdoledOut I feel like I know the mystery women from Australian Outback. The choreographer for a show I did in high school mentioned that she was initially going on survivor Australian Outback but ultimately decided not to. I think her daughter told me the reason was because she didn’t want to wear a bikini. Honestly I feel like this mystery women and the women I know are one in the same.

[@mulch144]

"heroically" 🤣

[@penndawt]

Imagine an alternate timeline where Melissa McNulty becomes the legend Parvati became.

[@58twright]

Melissa replaced Amanda Kimmel on Fiji

[@penndawt]

@@58twright But if Melissa played a strong game, Melissa could've been invited back I'n Micronesia where she goes on to win.

[@58twright]

@@penndawt that’s true we don’t know how she would have played

[@SterlingFogg]

Wasn't there a girl named Carey Schueler who was picked for Thailand? She was pulled and replaced with Penny, because she violated the non-communication rule before the game started.

[@theodorealamar9958]

This alternate would have been a lot better than Bhanu

[@customclone0743]

JimmyK is gonna win

[@victorhugocastromoura3039]

Love the vídeo! I was an alternee on the netflix hit "The Circle Brazil", spent 1 month in UK to shoot and "fortunetely"didn't make the final cut. 3 years later I realized my dream to be part of my favorite show ever, I was cast to the 6th season of the brazilian version of survivor: "No Limite". God's time is always right, trust and believe.

[@hklaurent]

What the fuss is all about Kellie though?

[@roger_towny_jr]

In Cook Islands, wasn't Sundra the alternate for a WNBA player who quit when she discovered tribes would be divided by race?

[@uglyaniimals]

good call !! i think i remember hearing abt this

[@XX-vz3fb]

The no collars would've been stacked physically with Tyler Joe Jenn Hali Vince and ... well Nina

[@TheLoserface45]

Oh BRO, I LOVE Davie!

[@jimkelleher555]

Jimmy k Boston 😮😮😮😮

[@christinekelleher4972]

get jimmy k on wow in real life he's a farmer he can win the show will turn upside down survivor history

[@jimkelleher555]

😮😮😮😮😮😮😮

[@mystiquals]

The RC shade? weird

[@itzwakk335]

no he cooked

[@uglyaniimals]

did you see her ponderosa ?

[@XanderMatthews-nv9zf]

Nah she was honestly a bit too rude and not proactive despite being on the bottom for half her game

[@stereohype1]

So...who replaced black beardy guy on 46?

[@alenaababon1523]

Maybe Austin as we know he was an alternate?