Top 9 worst game theory videos (1000 Subscriber special)

[@blanktank3793]

Dafawfilizer: **Established fair points in his video** Game theory fans: Nah hes just a hater

[@smolboiproductions2984]

Haha

[@presidentpeashooter4617]

I love game theory but I’ll give him credit he’s not one of the people who hates him for no reason he has fair point and I’m glad to agree to disagree

[@kernowpictures2002]

That is a pretty backward thinking way to dismiss constructive criticism

[@GravenWorldwide]

More evidence to MatPat’s point on Mario kissing Daisy: He literally debunked his own point in another video as saying that Luigi was in love with Peach, they got married and Mario then moved on with Daisy. So MatPat not only made a horrible point but debunked his own point in a seperate video!

[@stargamer8878]

He does that a lot.

[@shellyvision9693]

But hey, that's just a theory. A really bad theory.

[@sirgandy3822]

I know this was made 2-ish years ago, but Sans is Ness should be on here.

[@jamesesterline]

I don't believe that theory, but I like the idea of EarthBound and Undertale sharing the same universe.

[@rage_2000]

I like the Sans and Papyrus are Gaster

[@smolboiproductions2984]

I liked that theory

[@justaspectator9762]

It's kinda convincing if you only watch the video. But if you dig deeper it sucks

[@pooxel]

This was before Sans is Ness

[@benjaminrearden5724]

Honestly i'm a fan of Gametheory and his other Channels but he is very hit or miss with his theories.

[@gavinphoenixballesteros3080]

Plasma Wave Why...?

[@webs2099]

@@gavinphoenixballesteros3080 whoosh

[@gavinphoenixballesteros3080]

knuckles the echidna ?

[@webs2099]

@@gavinphoenixballesteros3080 it's a meam

[@gavinphoenixballesteros3080]

knuckles the echidna Okay then?

[@JohnnyHikesSW]

The "Link is dead" theory is also absolutely horrible. Majora's Mask is about people who are faced with certain doom, so of course death is a major theme in it.

[@JohnnyHikesSW]

So people in the game aren't about to die? The moon isn't really crashing down? Yeah, right.

[@Luigiawesome13]

***** There is a video by someone name The One I believe that gives WAAAAAAAAAAY more evidence then that moron does. Basically, after watching this guy's (or girl) 2 part videos (part 2 is called extras), you'll definitely be convinced that MatPat is an idiot.

[@UndertakerU2ber]

Midnight Slay3r LOL Link couldn't have died that young because then there would be no Twilight Princess...

[@dylanwilkins480]

Link&Luigi64 It doesn't even matter anyway. Nintendo has come out and stated the Termina is a parallel universe to Hyrule.

[@cyruscrompton8221]

***** Ya he missed so much, kids turn into skullkids not automatically grow bigger bones and doesn't give a good reason and when he fell HE COULD'VE HAD A FAIRY OR FELL INTO WATER, also in the end he fell off his horse, not a huge tree

[@avisreviews5471]

3:11 I mean, I know what a theory is, but what is a Teory?

[@loogi4062]

A Teory is a typo of theory..OR it is a theory made by game theory that sucks.

[@sandraboswell6036]

Avis Reviews An ascended theory

[@frankkoolpops5182]

A hypothesis supported by evidence

[@yaboichase147]

It is a typo not a kind of theory

[@TheChefBoo]

@@yaboichase147 That. Is. The. Joke

[@lightningstrike2001]

Actually,he disproves hiself by making a new theory video on mario timeline

[@Dafawfulizer]

+lightningstrike2001 I know. This video was made before that

[@Thornskade]

+lightningstrike2001 Theories are not facts, one theory cannot "disprove" another.

[@finalhunter6177]

Thunderciba got a point there that part was still the low point but atleast the most of the video actually did something logical

[@finalhunter6177]

Thurbo2 also it kinda can since what he said in one video contraced the other there by debunking part of it

[@Iamverylazy]

You have no idea how relieved I was to see the Rosalina theory on this list.

[@alevel20warbear37]

"The Wii U had bad graphics" looks like MattPat never played Xenoblade Chronicles X. those graphics come near breath of the wild on the Switch.

[@wlitmerrid2266]

dude that was the longest 40 second opening I've sat through today

[@P_-P_P]

same. I have seen a 2 MINUTE intro and it felt faster than this one

[@redshepherd32]

doesn't help that he's using a music track that intentionally starts off slow in first 45-50 seconds. I love the track normally, but I really don't think drawing from the first 30 seconds of the track is helping people get excited for what your showing

[@user-or4eo9hr6k]

The Scarlet Shepherd Atleast it was a good song.

[@Marshall.R]

"The longest 40 second opening" Say that again, but slowly

[@SmugProductions]

This video was made when it was considered cool

[@daddyno.1391]

the only think i dont like about Gametheory(fanbase) is there are so many peoples take some of the theories as a fact and not its just theory,a good one too take,is the pyro(tf2) theory,i mean i dont care about if other peoples actual belive that,-__- anyway good list/video

[@vinnyreed723]

Matpat 2015: a few logic missteps Matpat 2017: an egotistical bragger who always thinks he's correct/a major sellout to anyone willing to give

[@MrChomper4SmashTrend]

Pretty much. MatPat has truly fallen from grace despite his rise in popularity.

[@thunderstudent]

My least favorites are "Mario is mental", "Pyro's gender" and "Fnaf was all just a dream", hell he disproved his own theory on the video after it and he STILL thinks Dream Theory is the way to go when he's so blatantly wrong!

[@raiyanrazni]

Would you believe the quality of mat's research hasn't changed at all even to this day?

[@MSOGameShow]

"Who do you blame? The Killer? Or the company that made the gun?" Given the public reaction and outcry for gun control every time there's a murder... Also lol @ all those dislikes from GT fanboys.

[@RaidenKaiser]

I like matt patt I and I like his videos but I despise the behavior I get from his rabid fanbase when I disagree xD and I know Matt Patt himself would never like it when his fanbase goes apeshit on disagreeing with a theory

[@breanawatkins7393]

I know. Disagreeing with Game Theory fans is like walking in a mine field. Sure, eh has his rational fans who will argue in a civil manner but then there are the ones who will immediately insult you no matter how peaceful your message comes off.

[@RaidenKaiser]

***** well I have had worse than insults thrown at me had a few threats and black mail happen once lmao like that time I said I disagreed with the link is dead theory one of his fanboys blackmailed me into getting kicked out of facebook group over it and well I let him tell to group leader to ban me instead of taking it back xD then I got a death threat once too that was amusing xD

[@robrot404]

Devlos Marona youre right, he enjoys it.

[@NordicCarved]

They're loyal but... Too much so sometimes.

[@FatallyParasocial]

I know, and it's a THEORY. Matpat even says it's just a theory at the end of every video, yet the fanbase doesn't seem to listen to it.

[@Dafawfulizer]

Please Ignore the number 8 entry. I screwed up and I'm aware that I screwed up

[@Dafawfulizer]

Mr Rainbow Sheep I said that nintendo stopped their copyright claims awhile ago, when they didn't

[@imdone439]

Really ? I could have sworn that it was just Mario in the original game and not his father.

[@john5.joe5.48]

damir divovic We don't know if Jumpman is really his father, but we do know for sure, they are different people, they are very likely father and son.

[@rtrif3804]

It's just a Theory

[@connixome9x514]

RTrifPlays 1:12

[@supermariodan3887]

Thank you for saying Mario is not evil! Mario has been my hero since I was 5!!

[@tidebringer4517]

I was 2 not to brag but I feel ya brotha and no I’m not a 90’s kid I’m a 2000’s kid

[@lincolnwaugh4047]

@@tidebringer4517 I'm a 1999 kid

[@lincolnwaugh4047]

Well was a kid

[@ElectricPikachu64]

If I was born two years before I would have been a 90s kid

[@klowell19]

I hate the "Mario is mental" video

[@mogreenjo1562]

that one tractor ME TO

[@joannzivalich-schutz1492]

Don't we all

[@HepatitisLord]

I love Mario & Luigi, they're my favorite duo!

[@thelegendarymarioman8461]

Me too i hate it SO MUCH

[@furiousstudios4438]

I actually like it. The only problem I have is that it contradicts another one of the Game Theories. That one is the Mario Timeline theory where it is revealed that jump man and Mario are 2 different characters. Yet MatPat says that MARIO is the one abusing DK, even though it’s actually Jumpman. (Unless the Mario timeline was after the mental video, then that could make sense)

[@THE-qx3ry]

Mat pat also put mario being mental in a fun facts video

[@javariyearwood6792]

Spung Bob DYKGaming

[@cypherice3834]

Spung Bob yes that was bullsh*t if you say "but that's just a theory a game theory" it should not be in a fun facts video.

[@BoopaKing]

Spung Bob You mean the end credits thing where they talk about videos the narrator of that video had done? It was not a presented fun fact.

[@jordy4263]

I absolutely hate that theory!

[@BoopaKing]

***** Well he did say "May". And on multiple occasions he's said he couldn't give less of a shit if he's wrong :/

[@legendofsonic3979]

It's just a theory...AN AWFUL THEORY! THANKS FOR WATCHING!

[@danieldolf3844]

*AN

[@everlee6274]

Buuuurn! 💣🌋⚡️☄️🧨🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@robbiewalker2831]

@@everlee6274 MatPat retires.

[@jesusandfriends]

all the game theory fans are coming *puts on a soldier helmet* be prepared.

[@MrSmiley-en1ej]

Grabs AWP

[@steffansmith2585]

+Crystal Gem gentlemen please *grabs ghaster* this will work

[@josephrivers2587]

+Crystal Gem grabs guts sword

[@themichael8116]

I like Game Theory. I still do. I just don't care that they're flawed. It's enjoyable to watch. And I don't hate this guy or anyone that doesn't like GT. As long as you don't hate me for liking it, I'm good.

[@ziggystardust7001]

+Joe Fishy "grabs golden revolver and a steam punk tommy gun"

[@ItzSkyBound]

looks like 1400 people cant stand peoples opinion

[@jcamackay101]

2500 as of 2020

[@naomihowie]

Yea

[@Desperateforanewfandom]

And *thumbs down* people can't stand it as of 2023

[@cargopros8246]

"Well, his fnaf theories are good." Matpat: *TRIGGERED*

[@RamonIsHim]

I disliked in the beginning of the video but then I realized these game theory episodes really do make no type of sense. Needless to say my dislike went away.

[@r_moisty2739]

Hey, *it’s just a theory ...* *A GAME THEORY!*

[@thewillster18]

Oh god the nostalgia, I got chills watching the intro again lol. Used to watch this channel all the time (dafawfulizer)

[@ewetwentythree]

YOO SAME! underrated creator, don't watch their videos as much but whenever I see a new one in my recommended I'm happy to see him still continuing with content.

[@bulb9970]

I remember watching him when this video was popular, but I’m glad he dropped the 40 second long intro

[@roseydog07]

That Mario is Mental segment that you did was SPOT ON!!

[@noahwood2620]

I like to consider the top 3 worst theories on this list a trilogy of their own known as the "Game Theory is ruined" trilogy

[@Tommedian]

Dafawfulizer: they are all Wii U exclusive Nintendo: hold my delux

[@ignoreeverythingonthischan3147]

Number 1 Kirby is a threat to dreamland.

[@Pip200ne]

just going to point this out, Matpat: It's a parallel universe! Dafawfulizer: The tree is different!

[@kernowpictures2002]

“Tom? Do you reckon there are parallel universes?” narrator” Meanwhile in a parallel universe where…..” The meanwhile series by Tomska

[@WolfShadowhill]

Most ironic part about the wiiU theory is that I watched it on a wiiU

[@KingOskar4]

I must agree with most of these things, can't believe that some people does grab matpat's theories as facts though. I still like game theory and now also you, Dafawfulizer, someone must have said all of these things, thank you so much!

[@danielhowe6238]

Ya know, when MatPat says "It's just a theory..." he's not contradicting himself. He's just saying that this is what he thinks, and that you are allowed to not believe him.

[@darthestar8791]

Yeah.

[@EvTheBadConlanger]

ActUaLlY tHE sCieNTifiC dEfIniTioN oF A tHeOry iS “any explanation of a set of observations that has been that can be tested and reproduced”. sO acTuAlLy, yOu’rE usInG aN iNcoRrecT dEFinItIon. 🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓

[@jean-simonplourde9446]

Finally someone who shows that game theory has REALLY bad theories...

[@thatguynamedryoshi8646]

Jean-simon Plourde dude everyone knows game theory has bad theories

[@axelperez2917]

I know that this was 3 years ago but their theories are just for fun

[@AreesDaOG]

Hey shut up

[@NetConsole]

Amazing, but i'm sad the Is Link dead in MM theory not being here. That one was equally as offensing as most on your list.

[@machohedgehog1725]

Dear everyone, if you think that "it's just a theory, you're being too hard!" Just remember, Aids from space is a theory

[@pepperonipizza8200]

Just going to point this out. People had posted FNAF theories such as Phone Guy being the killer, and the Marionette being the first victim WEEKS before Game Theory has said that. Coincidence? I THINK NOT!!

[@pikyso8616]

I used to LOVE Game Theory until he blew up with his FNAF videos. After that, GT Live came out and all his videos became pointless live streams and his theory's became weak and boring.

[@dronkusdonkus9190]

well live streams arent pointless i mean games are for fun

[@dronkusdonkus9190]

Ruby Williams Anti UTTP its just theory not fact self centerd ass

[@DanielTGaming]

And that Undertale pope video... WTF, Game Theory?

[@dronkusdonkus9190]

Daniel T. Gaming that video even if the pope didint understand he proves his point

[@dronkusdonkus9190]

Ruby Williams Anti UTTP dammit your back

[@Bencrazymonkeyman]

The whole Cheep-Cheep argument is stupid, Toad, Luigi, Peach and even Rosalina can burn Cheep-Cheeps with fire, but Matpat just targets Mario.

[@Bencrazymonkeyman]

And they all use Mega Mushrooms too!

[@jonwootton2181]

Some people are annoying as hell, but there are still people that like and actively defend them Why I have no clue Also, Mat Pat is a stuck up douche that truly believes his theories are fact I don't even trust most critics because they're unfair But a complete tool that comes up with stupid theories and thinks they are true That's incredibly lame

[@DefinitivNichtSascha]

How can some people get so worked up about Game Theory. Even I believe some, if not most theories are complete and utter bullshit, but it's still entertaining to see the ideas some people might come up with. Though the people who accept these theories as canon are stupid as well, which is why Game Theory has some really bad fans.

[@JosephRobinsonSMBX]

It's not just the fans. MatPat himself seems to actually believe that Mario is a psychopath.

[@thelegendarymarioman8461]

I know

[@Ante9696]

it's just a Teory, a Game Teory.

[@RiverCiver]

Tanks for watching.

[@verydumbkid4568]

daylin cropper but it's just a theory, a gay theory

[@ever1024]

I'm SO GLAD that you chose number one to be Mario is mental! Seriously, I think Matpat made that video to piss people off and ruin childhoods!

[@kingjlinza]

George V.A that theory is the reason why I don’t like Game Theory anymore. I originally liked him because of his “Science of *insert random video game move here*” and his 5 Nights at Freddy’s theories. But then I found the video “KZbinrs react to Racist Mario,” MatPat was in that video, he said he was a psychopath, and a lot of his fans said that he was right. That right there made me lose all interest in Game Theory forever.

[@htg98]

YOU'RE RIGHT!!!!

[@theordinarygamer3575]

The funniest part is that was my first video but I don't take this as fact just as something to think about.

[@jonwootton2181]

That and taking games too seriously Games are supposed to be an escape from reality With the exception of sports games games are supposed to be unrealistic But that doesn't stop people from taking them seriously or coming up with half- assed complaints

[@jonwootton2181]

Uh, I meant games are supposed to be unrealistic (except for sports games)

[@Rit957]

I agree with a lot of this, even as a Game Theory fan, but #8 should of been replaced with "Link is Dead in Majora's Mask". You definitely did pick out his worst videos.

[@Dafawfulizer]

+KingRyt Thanks

[@Vinman1509]

+Dafawfulizer Yeah I agree. I am a fan of Game theory, but entries like 2 and 3 were just terrible by MatPat. I mean, basically each video is just guessing.

[@robbiewalker2831]

@@Dafawfulizer About the Donkey Kong Jr. Story, if we are to accept that Baby DK is Modern DK and not Cranky, then that could also be the same DK who appeared in Game Boy Donkey Kong, which includes Donkey Kong Jr. In the narrative. Mario could be defending himself in having DK locked up after that wild goose chase. Also, I’d like to Imagine Cranky is a Zoo Gorilla and DK is a Circus Ape, as Zoo Gorillas would be less active in doing fitness, but a Circus Ape could be very active because it’s doing a lot of things to work off the weight; and the same logic could apply to their animations: Arcade DK is jerky and storyboarded, but Game Boy DK has extra frames of animation.

[@WatsonDynamite]

you should turn the music lower and your voice audio higher. It's pretty hard to hear you at some points.

[@Peach_Creed]

Did Matt forget that there are second and third pokemon evos in the wild as well? Battling is needed to continue the life cycle.

[@IAmTheKnight26]

The flat earth theory has been disproven again and again, but it is still a theory, therefore not all theories are true

[@bluecoin300def.8]

The Mario is Mental theory is stupid. I'm sick of people saying that Mario is a jerk. You are right. It's not Mario's fault that wigglers and cheep cheeps try to kill him. Even if Mario was mean to his brother (which he isn't) it's not like he killed Luigi. This happens irl too. A lot of brothers and sisters get in fights, can be competitive and are nice to each other. But yeah, most of this stuff is blamed on the player. Good video.

[@EpicSamurott]

While I like game theory, you did bring up many good points.

[@antaresraven6708]

well we do have our likings. good thing you didn't overreact, like many other fans on different channels, heck fandoms in general. nice to see someone else keeps your cool down. and I agree with this video points.

[@afxpunky2795]

yeah game theory makes mistakes

[@jesusVazquez-ut9kh]

yor rait

[@kyleturner7309]

EpicSamurott Yeah I enjoy watching Mats videos too I totally agree that some of these points really have legs to stand on.

[@willdean6256]

This guys last point made absolutely no sense. If nobody believed in any theory, then they wouldnt exist in the first place. Do you really think Charles Darwin didnt believe in his own theory on evolution, or that people dont belive in it now? Also, your voice needs some improvement.

[@SuperAveryBrosSauceD]

FINALLY I've been waiting on this video for a long time! Thank you Dafawfulizer My top 10 was gonna be 10.Earthbound Evil Theory 9.Majora's Mask Theory 8.Megaman's true Villan 7.Pokemon are humans theory 6.Sonic's True Speed Theory 5.Old Kirby Epic Yarn Theory 4.The Wii U is New Virtual Boy 3.Problems with Peach Theory 2.Rosalina Unmasked Theory 1.The (Of course) Mario Mental Theory Witch made me hate the Game Theorists in the first place.

[@beneil2]

so when that going to be out?

[@john5.joe5.48]

That's a good list.

[@JustinAmador]

I agree on 1 i got pissed I was like why is mario mental just because he's mean to luigi??

[@john5.joe5.48]

Justin Amador And Mario being "Mean" to Luigi is just teasing.

[@SagittariusAyy]

The Rosalina Unmasked theory was fucking bullshit.

[@em8222]

I really understand how he's going with this. Usually MatPat makes pretty weird theories.Such as his theory of "What is Yoshi?" or his Kirby theory. I have the same feeling about his other channels, (Movie theory, Food theory) In his movie theorists channel he made a video about Rubble from Paw Patrol being a replacement pup. Like, that just ruins the show for fans. Also from the Paw Patrol video he made, he said this: "The old Rubble passed away, If you look at his truck it has scratches as it has already been used. Same with Rubble's hat." He also said this: "When you look at the episode of Ryder telling Rubble how he got the job, You can see on one scene that Rubble has a Pup Charm on the screen, Ryder also had a colour yellow on is Pup Pad. How would Ryder already have it?" MatPat's basically ruining everyones favorite games, shows, and more. I think he should stop. Who agrees?

[@zxrof34r]

If you don't mind me asking, what has he ruined on Food theory? Also I don't really see how he is ruining games, shows, etc., it's just stupid fun, that a lot of fans take to heart to much

[@puppetstudiosstudios]

MatPat getting mad at Nintendo copyright late is like all the Mr Enter haters in 2020

[@puppetstudiosstudios]

except for the fact that mrenter said some shady shit about covid that i have forgiven him for and nintendo copyright is the worst its ever been but we dont need to talk about that lol

[@kingboxbird6885]

2.4K dislikes are from 8-11 year olds

[@annietrinity1833]

This is the first video I've watched from you after looking for GT hate videos (goddamn, the Undertale saga is bad). Keep going; your editing and line reads definitely needs practice, but you at least have potential. There's enough confidence, charisma, and effort put into the production value to make the tripping over lines barable. And so many up and comings just don't even have that, so this is refreshing.

[@Dafawfulizer]

+Annie Trinity Thanks

[@Dafawfulizer]

+Annie Trinity I think I've improved in the year since this has been made

[@matshbocks]

+Annie Trinity did you mean the hate video or theories?

[@matshbocks]

For the under tale thing

[@annietrinity1833]

Littleb plays I love Undertale, I just think the GT series on it was (is?) bad.

[@Abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz1024]

1:19 it's just a theory A GAME THEORY you had it coming

[@GoomblsnaxII]

This is the first video of your's I've seen and I really enjoyed it. Good job.

[@simongray8119]

Wily also made all the robot masters but 1 and 9. MM4 was still Wily,he just blackmailed Dr.Cossack into reprogramming them.

[@JadePharaoh]

A couple of honorable mentions for me would be "Ness is Sans", and "Phoenix Wright is the Real Villain of Ace Attorney".

[@tysondennis1016]

The Mario timeline,and odyssey's importance in it. That's a theory for someone!

[@voiceofreason467]

You know I love how the whole "Mario is Mental" bit is so completely contradicted by his timeline video on the Mario series, which, let's face it... is a lot better than 99% of the timelines out there, including yours.

[@voiceofreason467]

Ruby Williams Nobody thinks it's true... learn reading comprehension next time.

[@MixxedBerries]

"Nobody it's true" **tells him to learn reading comprehension**

[@MixxedBerries]

What's not going to work on you? You don't like people on your side? Alright, later.

[@voiceofreason467]

Explodinator Um... reading and spelling are not the same idiot. And thanks for that...

[@MixxedBerries]

So you can read without knowing how to write and vice versa?

[@seanmyster6]

Thanks for making this video, now I have a way to effectively explain to people why I have such a strong hatred for Game Theory.

[@hollyputvin917]

the problem is not the content of MatPat's videos, but rather his fans, there are just some people who accept his videos as fact, when they are not. BTW, he is going to do a special video where we get to see if the big companies who's games he did theories on prove or debunk them. So, he isn't always worng, a major one was Scott Cawthon, creator of Five Nights at Freddy's, confirmed most of his FNaF 2 Theory which Scott mentioned in his comment on Steam about the cononisty of the games and the book.

[@m4hblaze]

I really didn't like his Mario is faster than sonic theory.I remember that one part of his evidence was that Mario completes his first stage in his first game faster than Sonic in his first stage

[@jem7316]

Did you watch Gnoggin's debunked version.

[@m4hblaze]

Julian McCray Yeah,I just watched his debunked theory on how fast Sonic is

[@john5.joe5.48]

mahsterblaze28 I'm not really a Sonic fan, but I don't like that theory either.

[@m4hblaze]

John 5./ Joe 5. Never liked that much of his Mario theories that much either

[@m4hblaze]

John 5./ Joe 5. He even debunked part of his Mario is mental theory in his Mario timeline theory and his Rosalina theory

[@Artisticfakeshow]

Mat Pat just got roasted lol

[@destroyernoah]

Bloodmoon [official] you funny

[@bobbyboswell13]

thank god someone finally said something about the whole they were turned into bricks not brick blocks

[@IceWitchofTsurara]

With the whole megaman theory, does it state anywhere that Dr. Light created any of the robot masters outside the first bunch? I think the main point on why that theory is wrong is the fact that Wily builds every robot besides the first group (or steals them from someone else) and Blues.

[@trine7967]

You should make part 2 (Ps: The "Gaster is Sans and Papyrus" theory is one the worst theories ever)!

[@NoobhunterSigma7]

19:11 - To MattPatt: *cough* Lateral thinking with withered technology *cough*

[@josephcross8464]

I never really get mad at MatPat's videos of theories because to be honest, I don't take them seriously. I know it's only entertainment and even if he does his research and shows his evidence and even if he believes he's 100% right, I know that in the end he only does it to entertain people, to give them something to chew on, and earn an honest buck while doing it. I don't agree with his theories most of the time but I think they are kind of amusing and, when all's said and done, pretty harmless. I am really surprised not to see his "Link is dead" theory here, as I know a lot of people hate it.

[@erichill3378]

but in his mario is mental theory he did not do enough research...

[@josephcross8464]

Eric Hill : But it's obvious the whole video is just meant as a joke, no need to get worked up about it.

[@erichill3378]

Joseph Cross well thats not very nice! I was supporting you!

[@josephcross8464]

Eric Hill : Sorry, I didn't want to sound mean, I just misinterpreted what you wanted to say.

[@erichill3378]

Joseph Cross alright.

[@koja9337]

I have a theory about Pauline! Pauline is Mario's MOTHER. I mean come on who is he one that saves Pauline. It's Mario's FATHER!!! She probably came to the Themepark opening in Mario vs DK Couse her SON invited HER!!! And about DK taking away Pauline. He probably THINKS that she is MARIOS girlfriend. We all know DK I'd not smart. He probably doesn't even know that's his mom. But hey. It's just my theory... CALLES DEBUNK THEORY! *gets punched in he face*

[@koja9337]

*CALLED

[@harrisonread6445]

+KojaMapping that was apart of the mario timeline gt posted

[@koja9337]

I did some research myslef and my sources point to Pauline=Mario's mom

[@harrisonread6445]

i had a feeling i just felt like telling you

[@thegrandxbunny2073]

I remember as a kid I watched his (and other theorists' vidieos) constantly and took them as gospel. I am so glad that I got rid of that toxic mentality.

[@bugglemagnum6213]

5:07 nintendo never stopped claiming videos, and "harassing" them is such a reach, if anything, they're the ones harassing creators.

[@swampylemmy986]

When people say that it's "just a theory" and "don't be so serious about it", they are actually just using a way to defend and are not actually bringing up any valuable points. This is a bad reaction - normally because this argument is used to defend popular people and why their videos are basically not able to be criticized. im not going to go any further than this because it's 1 am and im tired

[@swampylemmy986]

Confirm Level Viewer true

[@DarkkirbyKRPG]

Confirm Level Viewer Don't get me started on that argument. I debunked a few of his Mario-related theories, one of which was the "Toads are zombies" theory, and the MatPat drones replied to me with this: "Yeah well, he has millions of subscribers so he's obviously doing something right!" "Who should I believe? A nobody or a handsome man with millions of subscribers?" I mean, dear god. They don't even have a leg to stand on, let alone MatPat's theories.

[@Rot8erConeX]

Not sure if you're going to reply to this or not, but there is one thing I want to say. The fact that you try to disprove his Rosalina Unmasked video by saying Peach is alive when Rosalina's mother is dead means that you didn't understand the temporal mechanics invoked by the video. He is saying that Rosalina is the daughter of *a previous universe's* Peach. That the Mario universe is like a heartbeat, and every time it restarts things end up similar but not identical to the way they were before. That she was able to survive the end of the universe thanks to the Lumas - exactly how Mario himself survived the end of Galaxy 1. That said, you also bring up the point that the trees are not the same species, so couldn't be the same tree. Which also could be used as good proof that the theory is false - up until you realize that since the universe has died at least twice since the tree in the picture book (once between Rosalina meeting the Lumas and the start of Galaxy 1, and once at the end of Galaxy 1), the tree wouldn't even be there anymore - and even if it was, the body beneath it wouldn't be there. Now, do I think that MatPat is the holy grail of game theorists? No, I feel that honor goes to Gnoggin/Lockstin. There's many a Game Theory that I think falls short of the mark - I myself have come up with a few holes in his recent "Mario at the real-world Olympics" theory. But this particular theory is one that I want to not see attacked by someone who doesn't understand the temporal mechanics involved. If someone can disprove it and understands the temporal mechanics, I'm all for that. (When Gnoggin made a call recently for people to send him theories that they want analyzed, I sent him that one. I actually want someone to analyze it, just to shut up the people who merely dislike it because it supposedly breaks the canon OTP.)

[@wapepe_]

"Peach and Rosalina were orginally going to be related" that means they aren't, theory debunked.

[@lawofgames9978]

Ok there are many things wrong with this so let me explain some examples. Even if the universe was reset when Rosalina's mother died, that still does not mean that Peach is her mother, because in the book it's stated that she lives in a HOUSE BY THE HILL! And before you say "Some people call the castle a house" Nintendo gets very spastic about the details in their stories, and Rosalina and her book never stated that the Mushroom castle is her home. So the whole thing about the "restart of the universe just to see her mother again" is just wrong. The same applies to the tree, and even if your theory was true and the universe was reset for that reason wouldn't the tree be the same one in the book and at the same place (also the tree Matpat pointed at was at a different location)? I mean that's what the word *RESET* means, everything that existed before the resetting has to be the same. Also when in Matpat's video did he say anything about Rosalina going to a different universe?... NOWHERE! So where did that statement even come from? Even if you try to prove what I said was wrong, like what the guy said above me, there's still one point that destroys this whole theory: "Rosalina was originally intended to be related to Princess Peach". The key word being "ORIGINALLY"! Meaning yeah we wanted it this way but changed the idea, also meaning THEY ARE *NOT* RELATED!

[@Pimpeaux]

The amount of attention MatPat doesn't deserve is the equivalent to his ego: Through the roof.

[@Dafawfulizer]

True

[@robbiewalker2831]

@@Dafawfulizer If anything, at this rate, along with Egoraptor, MatPat is the Real Psychopath of Game Theory. He didn’t even care about Etika’s death, by using the news of his death as a joke for a video about cancel culture!

[@eyt3046]

@@robbiewalker2831 Wait, really?

[@abeljudah6341]

Although i am a fan of game theory, i respect the way you have done this video. There isn't too much hate and practically all of it is debunking and not spiteful jokes. Good job!

[@pacattack2586]

3:14 But that's just a Teory - The 'H' teory. Thanks for watching

[@abysslight2490]

The only problem I have with the number 1 entry, is that MatPat totes it around like it's his golden boy, his best video ever, when he himself has debunked a huge part of that theory in two separate videos. He claims Mario is a womanizer, but he only mentions three women, Pauline, Peach, and Daisy. In later videos, he makes the claim that Pauline is his mother, and Peach end up with Luigi and having a child with Luigi, not Mario. so he's in a steady relationship with Daisy, and he likes to hang out with his mother and Sister-in-law. Where's the evidence now?

[@itscat322]

It's just a theory,A DUMB Theory

[@matshbocks]

Preach

[@dabluepittoo-aqua4213]

I just thought is Paleine Mario's mom?

[@dabluepittoo-aqua4213]

It could be. I mean if dk and Mario were born at the same time (Yoshi's island DS) and gorillas age just as fast as us wouldn't the third dk not be jr and Mario is not jumpman? Also Pauline is Mario's mom and they give birth and walk home, leaving stork to carry the baby.

[@dabluepittoo-aqua4213]

I don't bealive so but theirs no evidence supporting or ruining the theory. We each have our own opinions but it is a possibility as it's no reconfirmed. Tho it's just a theory so please don't get mad and you don't need to bealive it, just a fun thought to help with a Mario timeline.

[@dabluepittoo-aqua4213]

Then DK was younger than DK Jr! And they were both born at the same time! Look I don't wanna start a debate so please leave me alone. I wanna comment on other things without this stupid thing blocking all the good posts!

[@CMGThePerson]

There you go guys, Game Theory, The Dumbest Show In Gaming

[@Dafawfulizer]

lol

[@CMGThePerson]

GT Bad youtuber checklist: No Prof whatsoever, Check Horrible Voice, Check Stupid Theories, Check Dumber than a 5 year old, There isn't a check big enough Bad Humor, Check Game Theory's evidence is fake, untrue, and he should not be on youtube in the first place, I mean, HOW DID HE GET 3 MILLION SUBS?!??!?!?!??!?!

[@Dafawfulizer]

Charlie Matthews-Grout My guess is because he was the first to do something, although he is very overrated

[@ToadR0XMK]

Charlie Matthews-Grout I think there are some KZbinrs that are much worse than GT.

[@robbiewalker2831]

Charlie Matthews-Grout Don't forget Decrease in quality when it *use to have good theories*... but hey, that's executive meddling for you.

[@heyjastin718]

Gooodddd I love this video, late congrats on 1,000 subs. :)

[@chipsnsasha]

Not only to mention in every game besides Megaman 9 and 1, they were all created by Dr. Wily.

[@mr.clipboard6004]

anyone from 2019?

[@platinumskulls4490]

Sorry I’m watching this in the year of the Corona

[@solarflare9078]

50% of comment sections: Actually smart peopleOther 50% Dumb GT fanboys (that some of which didn't watch the whole video)

[@arthropodliker]

Shush up You are dumb like 🏈🏀⚽️🏐⚾️

[@mf1166]

+Julia Jones GTFO GT fan

[@mf1166]

+Julia Jones GTFO GT fan

[@mf1166]

+Julia Jones GTFO GT fan

[@hagen1709]

+SSB4 Replays hey yes i am a GT fan but I can tell you I am not dumb and most other fans of GT are not either so could you shush up and keep your opinion to your self.....needless to say more.......

[@NEETKitten]

So many whiny fanboys, so little time.

[@mastercore3159]

Thank you so much for making theses videos. please don't stop.

[@temporal4652]

I'm starting to think you enjoy the Masked Dedede theme

[@temporal4652]

@Zesanactor Over-5 0:40

[@gaminggalaxies6633]

People say that they're just Theories and that means you shouldn't take them seriously, doesn't mean you can't criticize them.

[@zoltikrys]

I don't get how a channel with only 7000 subs can criticize a channel much more successful than their own.

[@sphericalcobalt4857]

because game theory is terrible

[@zoltikrys]

Spherical Cobalt To the weak minded.

[@freshcheesesmeels1405]

+The Static Spider *Strong

[@sphericalcobalt4857]

FRESH CHEESE SMEELS you understand

[@zoltikrys]

Kill The Gema Precisely

[@jesusandfriends]

If there's ever another version in the future, can you put the "Sans is Ness" Theory on the list, I thought it had more holes than swiss cheese.

[@jesusandfriends]

+Crystal Gem First off, he said that no organic material can pass through the machine, if so, than how did San's bones come through? Aren't bones organic material? Also, when he said that Papyrus could be one a Starman, than how come "Ness" Got so attached to this one monster? What makes this one so different from the others? And why did "Ness" Change his name to Sans? And how come Sans doesn't use the PK abilities or anything similar to them? Sure, he teleports and does other magical abilities, but what about Pk fire, Pk lightning, or any other attacks even similar to them? And how come Papyrus doesn't know what the sun is? If he is Starman from Earthbound, wouldn't he already know what the sun is? And if Sans and Papyrus are different SPECIES, than how come they say their brothers? And why is Sans so lazy? Ness is fit to fight any danger and sans is too lazy to pick up his socks, also, when did Ness start speaking? He was a silent protagonist, right? And when he's explaining that there is a desert/beach near the castle and he shows the map of Earthbound to compare, in Earthbound, the city and castle are very far apart, and in Undertale, they're right next to each other! And Toby himself said that Undertale has references and is loosely based on Earthbound, I'm pretty sure he didn't say that they take place in the universe of Earthbound or the Halloween hack. And how come Sans doesn't have a human soul? And why does he have a monster soul? I'm pretty sure that humans can't have monster souls, and if Sans is bleeding because he was Ness and he went through the machine thing, how come he has blood? Isn't blood also an organic material? And how come Ness can survive with just his skeleton? And how come Sans has a flashing blue eye when using his powers? Ness never had a blue eye activate when using magic, not in Earthbound or any of the Smash bros. games, and when did Ness become a super lazy and pun loving dude? Not once in any of the games he was featured in did he have a line of dialog or even one of the character's reacting to him loving puns. And if Ness became a skeleton, how come he has bone moves? And why does Sans have only one H.P and one defence and attack? To defeat Gigas, Ness must've had WAY more than one H.P, attack and defense. And how come Sans is aware of the time lines? And Sans is literally confirmed to be a monster. And when have we ever seen Ness eat food or even drink straight up ketchup? And I'm pretty sure Ness isn't a prankster type. And if the Starman is the only person Ness has and that's why he feels a strong, brotherly connection to it, why didn't any of Ness's friends join him instead of a random monster? And the symbol in the Starman is a part of it's body, and the symbol on Papyrus is part of his clothing. And Papyrus and the Starman have TOTALLY different body shapes, so it's literally impossible that Papyrus and that monster could be the same person. And Papyrus had a good reason to fight Frisk, in order to join the royal guard and free all monsters. The Starmen in Earthbound just jump out at you and attack you for no reason. And Papyrus wouldn't do that. Also, the photo album says that it's picture of SANS with a bunch of smiling people, not Ness. And Sans looks like an adult. In the game, it says that he pays the bills for Sans and Papyrus's house, and he has the build of a grown, fat man. Not a skinny little kid who probably doesn't know what bills are, also, Papyrus is found saying words like "people" or "person" When talking about a monster/monsters. Also, the phase distorter looks smaller and rounder than the machine in Sans's shed. And how come the beach called Summers had the ocean farther from the ledge than in Undertale? And no, high tides isn't a good explanation. And just because Toby worked on an Undertale hack before doesn't mean Undertale is connected to it. And why did Ness go through the phase distorter without the robot body knowing that he could die? And how come the three other kids were saved in the hack, but Ness wasn't saved there? I HAVE TENS OF REASONS THAT DISPROVE THIS THEORY, SO WHY DO PEOPLE THINK IT'S REAL? AND WHY DO PEOPLE TREAT IT AS FACT BEFORE ASKING TOBY OR EVEN GLANCING AT HIM? IT IS SUCH A BAD THEORY! Still like Game Theory though, even though I really dislike some of the episodes.

[@Dafawfulizer]

+Crystal Gem Yeah, if I do a remake that is definantly going on

[@noahwood2620]

@@Dafawfulizer Don't forget his Mario Kart is deadly theory

[@amirgarcia547]

Great vid btw. But if it was made today...Sans is Ness would DEFINITELY be #1. #10: Cuphead and Mugman are moonshiners #9: Splatoon: Kid or squid #8: Any FNAF theory arguing that Mike or Phone Guy is the killer. #7: Rosalina Unmasked. #6: Link is Dead in Majora’s Mask #5: The WiiU is the next Virtual Boy #4: Phoenix Wright is a Criminal #3: Persona 4: Teddy is Yuu’s shadow #2: Mario is Mental #1: SANS IS NESS!!!!!!

[@pooxel]

Crono Sapien not sure if Dafawfulizer would agree if you saw his anger with his original response and with the #1 entrie I think he would still say Mario is Mental is #1

[@lawofgames9978]

Honestly I would have to say that Sans is Ness is not really as bad as Mario is mental, mostly because in Sans is Ness he's not saying that Ness is dead and he becomes Sans, and obviously isn't one of those theories that's character assassinating a good-guy as a bad-guy!

[@josiahjenksisawesome]

While there are a few that I disagree with, you covered most of my views, and I'm glad that someone else agrees on those specific points.

[@joldsaway3489]

Alright, I'd like to give you some constructive criticism on this 1. Don't record your audio in one take 2. Slow down when you talk. It sounds too rushed 3. Have a script of some kind. If you already do, try to rehearse it a bit before you record or, referring to my first point, don't do it in one take Overall, I think some of your points were valid, but I think you need to work on your presentation.

[@willeeuhm]

You're allowed to have your own opinions and all of that, not arguing with any of that. But your presentation and arguments could really use a lot of work. You don't really sum up why each video is bad very well or conclude the segments, and your stuttering is horrendous. You're allowed to record multiple takes for a reason! Some of the segments seem rushed or really drawn out, and a script would really help that out. A couple of the arguments are actually good points against his videos, but they're not really expanded upon. Something that's harder to criticize in a nice way is that you come off as an extremely arrogant asshole. I honestly don't think you're trying to, but you don't have the right to call out someone for making a video solely to get views when this video itself is complete clickbait. There's a reason Nintendo fans still like Game Theory even when he's calling Mario a psychopath, so your mass of dislikes from Game Theory fans isn't excusable to them being butthurt. It's because you presented this video in a whiny, condescending manner rather than respectfully disproving his theories. I don't think you're terrible at making videos at all, and I intended for all of this to be constructive criticism, so please don't take it the wrong way.

[@Shamazya]

William Seamon I'm going to second this critique. And, like the OP, I'm not coming from any sort of place of malice. I think the video could have been a lot stronger. Since you're not on camera you have the advantage of being able to edit your audio without having to worry about the video matching up or being distracting from the cuts. You can use Audacity (If you don't already), a free sound editing software, to cut out unintended pauses and stutters. It's okay to have a few in there but it tends to be fairly easy to eliminate a majority of the stuttering and pauses. It would also make your videos shorter which tends to be more inviting to watch (To a point.) Some people don't like to use a script for their videos because they want them to be more organic but, unless it's a reaction or vlog type video, they still tend to at least have some bullet points in front of them to keep themselves on track.

[@willeeuhm]

***** Agreed 100%.

[@keldeowater9746]

William Seamon Rosalina unmaked the mustuase bit wario and walawigi bit is wrong when did peach ever see wario and walawigig are partners in crime so how can peach like them if they are ruinning there kindom

[@D0omC0okie]

William Seamon Took the words right out of my mouth, I'm a fan of MatPat, so I was looking for something that could truly refute some of his theories with evidence and calculations of its own, but that wasn't the case.

[@sexygarfield9081]

I agree with William, this videos arguments are very very weak. It just kinda seems that he has a grudge on mat pat

[@mistab3333]

I hate youtubers that talk shit about other youtubers.

[@lorekeeperxvii2408]

Same

[@papermario332]

This video should be remade 6 years later. There are some more bad game theories out there.

[@unknowncharmander587]

As a person who watches game theory, this list is great. Mat Pat is a 20 : 80 guy with theory's. most are bad but some are very good