Tori Amos - Silent All These Years (From "Live At Montreux 91/92")

[@TearInTheirHands]

People say that The Beatles, Michael Jackson, Led Zeppelin, Mozart and others are the best musicians ever. They ARE some of the best, but only Tori goes beyond music and into something so profound that the English language has no word to describe it. Saying that Tori is the best musician that has ever lived would be an understatement... ...but that's just my opinion. ;)

[@chrislam4081]

I fully agree!

[@danasimpson9875]

You are so right, she sings from her soul

[@FinnMcRiangabra]

Tori Amos better than Mozart? Fuck off.

[@daleishus8420]

Id do er

[@FinnMcRiangabra]

@lil minch Is a reply what you are looking for to validate your pointless existence?

[@billyhughes9776]

This song is still so darkly honest and stunningly beautiful 30 years later. Tori's presence on stage,...just incredible.

[@amandalynn3108]

AMEN

[@garyrobert9085]

If you're still out there watch this. Although it's labeled as an interview, it's really a conversation between two people who very much respect each other and this song is discussed deeply.

[@Jean-pg2zi]

❤

[@loganoneil1]

I had the DISTINCT pleasure of meeting Ms. Amos way-back-when when 'Little Earthquakes' first came out and she was doing the college circuit and performed at Northern Illinois University (I gave her roses!). A few years later I won a radio contest to meet her again in Chicago (and she remembered me (apparently I was the first one who ever gave her flowers!). I absolutely adore her and her music! This will always be one of my all-time favorites!

[@MsSwthrt102]

so sweet, bless!

[@hickt003]

You are so lucky

[@Morpheus903]

That must have been incredible!! I’d love to meet her. I pretty much listen to her older stuff, like this. I’m not even sure if she still performs. Anyone?

[@sunnyelaine999]

"Sometimes I hear my voice and it's been here, silent all these years." Best line from the song.

[@amandaellevis2392]

sunnyelaine999 zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz come on who cares if its hard to play. It’s boring as fuck. I definitely don’t care if she’s a mermaid

[@Adam-vp1cl]

@@amandaellevis2392 you should be silent

[@eleanormoody3859]

I love all the words but the lines that 'get to me the most' are, "Years go by and I'm here still waiting for somebody to understand". I am 74 and have just found someone who listens and understands! Someone who wrote a comment in reply to yours is obviously not a listener and, so, will never understand. Your's and my voices have been silent all these years. I hope you have found someone who listens and understands, Sunnylaine. I heard you, I listened and I send you so much love. I'm just sorry that it has taken me 11 years to discover your comment. Eleanor

[@eleanormoody3859]

@@Adam-vp1cl Why?

[@eleanormoody3859]

@@Adam-vp1cl Why?

[@TheItalianDNA]

This concert was just such a magnificent moment in Tori's career. I'm so jealous of those who saw this live.

[@patricklevinerose1359]

I saw Tori sing this live in Ann Arbor. I was in the front row six or eight feet from Tori. It was a magnificent night.

[@jkrenz77]

Yup, I saw her at the State Theater in New Brunswick, NJ in 97? with my college buddies. It was amazing.

[@Starkim918]

@@patricklevinerose1359Likewise! I saw her at Hill Auditorium when I was a student at Michigan MANY years ago!

[@lindsayashworth7815]

She is on a different level. She makes everyone in her footsteps seem like amateurs. Tori and a piano. Nothing else. No bullshit.

[@heckler511]

Today's pop tarts can't hold a candle. Maybe Gaga but that's about it

[@vanness3859]

That’s what I said on her live version of winter,so unlike today with all these distractions to cover up just how untalented these artists are today.This is talent just a piano and her beautiful voice.

[@davidsseena6570]

What’s truly astonishing is how her music is an incarnation of itself-constantly morphing, blending nostalgia with the present. It feels like a bridge between memories and now, familiar yet refreshingly new. Her sound is timeless, existing outside of trends, always resonating with the soul.

[@StevegarwoodNet]

This song is really well written and seems hard to play. I think is a Masterpiece.

[@nickolaosviniaris2305]

she makes me cry..so so sad

[@chrislam4081]

@@nickolaosviniaris2305 Would really appreciate it if you could send me the wording of this beautiful song. My email address is [e-mail]. Thank you ever so much.

[@marknc9616]

@@chrislam4081 The lyrics for this song are in the description of this video.

[@Apocryypha]

i love that the audience doesn't scream every 5 seconds. i wish i could have seen her back then!

[@eleanormoody3859]

I am 74, Apocrypha, and I never understood why teenagers screamed so much at The Beatles concerts! They couldn't hear them singing let alone hear the words! I saw Tori back then Amazing. She is so emotive and I really resonate with what she has to say. Console yourself with the fact that you can watch these videos. We didn't have them when I was young! I send you much love. Eleanor

[@schepler2]

I saw her back in the early/mid '90s and she was amazing.

[@nygrrl99]

@@schepler2 Agreed, she is amazing live. She is a true artist.

[@ladycroissant3744]

Tori had actually scolded some nitwits in the audience who talked through 'little earthquakes' earlier in this concert. ("are you guys here to talk, or to listen to music? No, really!") So yeah, I would think that they've gotten the message and shut up for the rest of the show!

[@takeapart1530]

One of those perfect songs where your exposed heart is both bleeding and on fire when listening and you just know it's the same for Tori playing it and that makes it even more amazing. Wish there were more artists like her these days.

[@lookoutlizzy3623]

She is golden. Her words are pure poetry. She is the music. She is without doubt my favourite musician of all time. ❤

[@godessceline]

I'm very new to Tori, I only discovered her a few weeks back and I am completely in awe. I can't wait to discover all ehr work and already I can feel her music starting to have a life-changing effect on me. Very few artists can do that for me but if they succeed they have my heart forever. Tori's purity and honesty si unlike anythign I've ever seen and the fact that the entire world is not obsessed with this amazing music is a mystery.

[@reemerger]

I wish I could hear her for the first time again, as 31 years ago.

[@robostory1711]

Tori Amos, Bjork and Trent Reznor were pretty much my artistic inspiration growing up.

[@Lissa5628]

Same plus Dave Gahan

[@uzi978]

They inspired each other quite a bit, too.

[@Lissa5628]

@@amelie5525 agreed 👍

[@keithfreeman7725]

I was already 'grown up' and I could add more to your list, but I will say my musical journey through life has been lyrics and emotions stirred, if it doesn't make me feel something... It's poop! Tori has never failed to make me feel something. Still the finest female I've ever heard.

[@zirconviper]

It's hard to listen to this song without crying. Tori sings and plays so beautifully.

[@JulieFernz]

Every voice mannerism and little facial expression she makes when she's playing makes my heart ache. Love Tori!

[@Zudhg]

Julie Crawford ❤️

[@user-xn9bw2es3x]

SAME

[@Murderith7]

She is pretty much the only artist I feel is better live than on the album....like 100000 times better...she cares SO MUCH about her audience...she interacts with them every single second, while still giving a mind blowing musical performance. I would kill to see her live...

[@jimvad]

Her best performance of her entire career. This blows me away.

[@katey03]

I love the power in her piano playing. You can hear someone else play a piano but she has such her own style, its intriguing how someone can put so much in their music and yet some people over look all the emotional aspects. she is so connected with her music.

[@jandlhoward1]

I love watching her live, you think she's preforming just for you, like you're the only one there. My husband and I went to one of her concerts years ago. Best money we ever spent.

[@VampireSeal]

It is so hard for me to believe this was 91/92. It seems like yesterday to me, and hardly the early 90s. Her music is timeless. I can't believe she's close to 50 now. It makes ME feel old, I guess (I would have been 10 or 11 when this came out, I thought this music was out when I was a teenager, but I guess it was longer ago than that). I listen to other music from the era, the pop music, and it sounds like the 90s, but this could have come out yesterday.

[@vinyllotus]

This is one of THE greatest songs ever.

[@Bijan-84]

"Silent All These Yeats" is talking about serious matters throughout our lives, ranging from our faith in religion to our most shameful memories. My dear Tori, who are you? Are you from this world? I can just say that I owe you so much my dear.

[@leonardomule2060]

could you explain the religious/faith references in this song? :)

[@Bijan-84]

Leonardo Mulè "I got the anti-Christ in the kitchen yellin' at me again Yeah I can hear that Been saved again by the garbage truck I got something to say you know But nothing comes" And if you look at "Little Earthquakes" album as a whole, you'll find what I mean.

[@gytisbaranauskasjagmort6059]

Yeats is a freudian slip or did you really mean it? Cause while I like her a lot, she's nowhere near Yeatsian level.

[@butchbrewer4923]

@@Bijan-84 I like you

[@ultraviolet6989]

Just a woman, her voice and a piano. So powerful.

[@luckyleo7]

Tori still gives me chills and brings tears to my eyes even after all these years, wow, timeless. Thx!

[@zagnut36]

The 90s was a great Decade for women in the music business such incredible talents

[@miscelaineousvideos]

Tori Amos once said that this song was her mantra... over time it has become mine as well. I love her live renditions of it.

[@CelticRaE19]

never lose the child inside, that is the true you

[@margrichards9494]

I fully agree

[@eleanormoody3859]

I loved those words you wrote, Techno. When my sister and I were children we were told that, as we were 'juniors', our opinions counted for nothing. When I grew up I became a teacher and I always listened to the children and, at the age of 74, I still am. It's wonderful! I'm still a child at heart, Children have so much to teach us. Much love to you, Techno. Eleanor.

[@celticgibson]

Ah Little Earthquakes era Tori. Amazing. and sensual. She really lit up that stage.

[@seqartguy]

Amazing. One of the songs that can STILL to this DAY give me shivers and goosebumps....Thank GOD for Tori.

[@JaimeHu1]

Leaving an abusive marriage this song really hits home. The words really fit and help with healing... Thx for sharing this song :)

[@dneuf6146]

Tori, still fully waiting to be appreciated. This performance and lyrics are subllime!

[@SirGraylon]

I saw her at the Orpheum in SF about this time. One of the best concerts ever. A spotlight, a piano and aTori Amos. She was amazing.

[@petergreen2552]

Beautiful beyond measure. She is so unique, especially live.

[@lindayost9854]

Tori, this is one of my favorite songs. I love you.

[@nicolekoretsky9062]

It's 2020 and I am still amazed and humbled to have seen Tori live in 1993-to have shared her space-time in my 20s is a gift that is difficult to reconcile. I feel damn lucky. She is a light or empathy, experience, honesty, solid genius that takes my breath away, and commentary, witness, truth, and I can't believe we are all so lucky to have either grown up with her or to have found her, just when she was everything we needed. And the music isn't bad, is it? ;) Spectacular.

[@TroublesomeOwl]

i discovered tori in about 96... saw her for the first time in 2001. Multiple times since, has been an incredible journey every single time.

[@RudyGold]

“You best pray that I bleed real soon”I understand this line all too well. Deep scary. Beautiful song!

[@Lawsbian]

She still looks damn good. Not to mention she's an epic human being, and her genius and her passion will never fade.

[@szem02]

She is definately an original. She is so in her element when she performs, as though she is making love to her piano and piano stool. Beautiful all around.

[@glassmermaid24]

She's been inspiring me for 11 years now, and it's funny to compare the feelings through the years. When you go from 15 to 26 the way I have the shit and the pain yet beauty it all delivers at once. She was once my only friend long ago. Now it's all broader and shared in front of my eyes now. I love her very much, and I can't see how anyone can't. Unless for laughs, but no she's the real thing. Period. Very personal stuff too like she could sing about having a period.

[@neorich59]

Talk about hearing a pin drop? I had the privilege of hearing what I judge to be one of the best piano players in the history of pop, certainly one of the most original, many years ago and was in the balcony where you could lean over and watch the crowd below. And it was the first and only time (well Kate Bush too!) where I witnessed an audience agog and awe struck by what they were hearing!

[@chapchapman]

Her facial expression was just in such a perfectly fine detail, i love especially her eyes. This is what we call Charisma.

[@veronicamayfield2075]

Totally remember the "Little Earthquakes" CD my sister had it when it came out. I became a fan instantly. Growing up in our house was brutal/ and emotional damage done. At 46 yrs old. I reflect on this music and remember being a survivor! She is a Wonderful Artist and I will always be a fan

[@trippingjune]

This is just too good. Words can't describe the brilliance of her songwriting, musicality, and performance. That voice and piano playing is one of a kind.

[@thewalking]

Stunning song. And look at her, she's so beautiful, and you can tell she puts so much into performing, there's a lot of joy in her eyes.

[@erikpeterson25]

Wow! first time seeing and HEARING this thank you Tori...better late than never ❤💕

[@paulmca8514]

A raw talent, she plays and sings with such beauty

[@StargazerCaroline]

Played the 'Little Earthquakes' CD constantly when I moved to South Carolina for a couple of years in 1992. Simply incredible, powerful like raw silk. Real as can be. Good to hear new music with Winter.

[@jmctigret]

Masterpiece

[@zeroskillz2427]

The Voice of an ANGEL!! can't get over just how beautiful she was back then!! and the daggers her lyrics threw!! so powerful!!

[@fabiogn1]

this is The kind of song That instrument and voice match perfectly in emotion . I Love Tori

[@kevinoakes1171]

WOW, JUST WOW !. I can’t stop listening to this, This is utterly beautiful. Her voice, the words, the piano playing, the short pauses and her phrasing, the emotion and how she looks at the audience. I read in the comments, someone said that it’s like she is giving out hand picked flowers, some barbed and some soft. Perfect description.

[@hellogoodbye0214]

Originally I learned this song for a friend on the piano, and after listening to it, I replayed again. I love this song so much

[@willfromyadkinville]

this album was simply brilliant!

[@parthasarathisarker]

This song is great! I heard it over and over again and never got tired. Tori, the girl you're singing about you made her heard. She may be silent all these years but her unspoken words will remain forever in this song. There're lot of us in this world are silent. Many preferred silence over existence, may be acceptence. Thank you Tori for reminding us of that moment.

[@HannaOllikainenMusic]

This. This is real feelings coming out through music. That is what it all is about.

[@modarXmodar]

I like what you said , I'm 27 years old now , started listening to Tori only two years ago .. it's so true that her music is so timeless , only similar to her !

[@mysteriousperson69]

First of all, Tori got something she always wanted. Motherhood. And yes, that kind of stress tends to age your appearance. So does time. And yay for you! You're able to point out obvious/superficial things. How about how her music has grown through the years? How about how she used to perform nearly exactly as the songs were on the CD - and now she's confident and creative, and each performance is unique! 2:38 "Years go by, if I'm stripped of my beauty. . ." You're still beautiful, Tori!

[@acoustictherapy]

This and "Winter," two of the best on the planet.

[@nickbretz267]

This is such a well written piece of music.

[@dallasponder3158]

Saw her live in Kalamazoo MI at the state theatre on her furst your. Just her and a piano on the stage. Amazing talent

[@stillclock]

what i don't understand is why people would bother posting comments slagging artists they don't like or respect. there are whole worlds of music out there. life's too short to listen to that which doesn't appeal. go get what you love!

[@MattRichards711]

Wow...I can't imagine this song not existing. I would've loved to have been there the first time that song was ever played.

[@nummelim]

This song has drilled the most beautiful hole in my soul 🥰🥰

[@lalaine1019]

I almost forgot how much her music has inspired me, in a much deeper way than words can convey. "Silent all these years", might as well call it suppression. "I hear my voice and it's been here", now that is empowering.

[@merindadiesel3370]

What can you say...masterpiece and storytelling and artist

[@melissadenby2357]

It is known: Tori is beautiful, she is talented, she is pretty unique, she is determined, strong, kind... fabulous... what many of us wish we could be, and speaking for those of us who cannot speak, whether that was her intention or not... and such beautiful sounds whether you listen to the words or not, though you should...

[@atlasshrugged2u]

My signiture song. I was like "How does this woman know my life?" Every word she's singing exemplifies the hell I was living in with God awful things that were happening to me, and no one understanding what I was going through. Loved her every since!

[@Barbiestroud1]

So lovely xxx

[@chevy2599]

I love her style, in a league of her own for sure.

[@parkerburgio]

Still such a touching performance

[@beyondfake]

She is amazing live! I saw her for Choir Girl Hotel, To Venus and Back, and then in '09. She is just as amazing as I remembered her 10 years ago. I love you Tori.

[@orvgg]

This was an amazing performance. Tori is one of the truly few great ones.

[@stipetv1548]

Flawless everything Gorgeous Tori 💎

[@SimoVit]

she was so different...but always great... she's definitely a mermaid :)

[@orawalker1]

She is certainly incredible...! I love different too... get tired of "same"... I'd love to hear what you think about this artist: It's actually me... would you mind taking a listen? It would be very kind of you. thanks in advance :))kzbin.info/www/bejne/jaHbd5icob-Joac

[@africanblackgold]

She carried me through my Junior yr of college. Intense emotions with no place to go, only through her music could I breathe.

[@jhefdevibar]

Oh my Tori Amos. A girl with beauty and artistry. What more can I ask for?

[@raz1980]

our beloved redhead is on emotional fire-and she takes us with her as usual. Can't wait for the cd/dvd!

[@SterlingRe]

Just Tori and her piano. Perfection. Rediscovered her this past week. Thank god. Can’t stop watching her videos. There are several great ones from this concert alone. What a treat it must have been to be there!!

[@spmcconville]

I've been hooked on Tori since 91...wow

[@GuitarGare]

I don't think I've ever read a more succinct, profound reply to anyone like this before. Kudos.

[@SandiAnne]

Wonderful, crazy Tori Amos...Her emotional and vocal range are brilliant..The emotions and words are like hand picked flowers ,some barbed, some soft ...wonderful

[@houseofmarshall]

god's it's just so beautiful, close pianist and singer played it at a party on the beach this summer and I got really emotional

[@danpats1]

it's not even fair that one person gets to be this talented

[@Andyontherocks]

I have been lucky enough to see her perform two years in a row on the lead up to xmas in glasgow, scotland and i have to say each time i was totally transfixed! ive seen a lot of artists perform but without doubt tori has been outstanding. Each song performed in a totally unique way but never the less powerful. I consider it a privalege to have ssen her live and i show contempt to my friends who left the seat to my left empty. cray mofos! outstanding!

[@shortpotato26]

Just saw her in July for the first time, its completely worth it..:-)

[@chapchapman]

A perfect performance artistically and aesthetically. Besides her vocal and instrumental parts, all the slightest details were beautifully displayed. How she sat, how she breathed, how she smiled, how she moved, how she looked, how she raised her eyebrows, all these elements contributed to this flawless performance. Overwhelming.

[@maajonic]

she's a legend!

[@forrestgreen6765]

For all time, for all those who need a spokesperson, for all occasions, for the love of oneself

[@hellogoodbye0214]

I'm playing this tomorrow night, and I can't wait. I love her music.

[@WillohtheWisp]

her voice sends chills through me

[@20091cali]

love her! we seriously need music like this back!

[@anneliesparent7327]

The good old days. Wish she was still like this.

[@uzi978]

Seeing her live is such an _experience_. You really feel her... one of my favorite shows ever.

[@johnhassall1782]

I had a serious crush on her back then,,,,, I can see why!

[@michaelmcgilvry7123]

you weren't alone

[@MsNicole8888]

SHE'S AN REAL ARTIST!!!

[@edgaruxable]

beautiful voice, beautiful woman... Tori's a divine gift from Heaven for us mortals...

[@wenchiang12]

love the dynamics!

[@justjen9012]

tori keeps me sane.....thanks lady we are all excentric and we should be loved for it never made to feel like a freak just because we don't have to fit in a simple smothering role for our selves that kills our souls

[@jaycabkeys]

Incredible

[@gonebreaminalso]

I'd forgotten just how good she really is, wow!!! Refreshing to hear this again