Vocal Coach reacts to Rammstein performing Du Hast LIVE in Paris

We're back at it today with Rammstein! This time, thanks to your guidance, I'm listening to the whole band perform live. This is Du Hast from The Director's Cut of RAMMSTEIN: PARIS.
Watch the original video uninterrupted: • Rammstein: Paris - Du ...
🎶 Website: www.thevocalyst.com/
💙 Patreon: / thevocalyst
#rammstein #duhast #reaction

[@SubwaySweden]

The most impressive thing about this video is getting French people to speak anything other than French

[@christopherconard2831]

They can. But only German, and only when that when that German is accompanied by a lot of explosives.

[@KingKharnivore]

​@@christopherconard2831 Okay, this made me laugh 😂

[@DaryoGoinden]

Music is a universal language that brings everyone together as human beings we are. Music = unity 🤘🤘🤘

[@andrewfurey2999]

​@@christopherconard2831 😂

[@jackieraulerson2005]

To me, it was the guy on the treadmill

[@timhutchinson8485]

Till Lindemann is a trained pyrotechnician, and does a lot of stuff with fire/fireworks in his performances.

[@Templarofsteel88]

He got certified after a cloth caught fire during one of their shows.

[@vegasviking86]

Not only that I believe he's labeled a "master" pyrotechnician at this point

[@s.mcpherson6354]

@@Templarofsteel88 I believe if you check interviews, Till (who I'm a big fan of), was certified before the accident, but not careful. They brought in Nikolai Sabottka of FFP (a pyro design firm), to professional the shows up. Since then they hire regional designers for each tour, as most bands would. I believe if you check, Wonder Works did the North American shows just before the pandemic. Like most businesses in life, concerts look like one thing from the outside, when really they're collections of contractors, with the band being the promoters main contractor. Then lighting, costumes, makeup, media, trucking etc. etc. They are huge operations often running three simultaneous stages for major groups on huge tours.

[@hansdampf640]

i never noticed that firework stuff at the concerts 😜

[@tspawn35]

Feuer Frei is my favorite song when it comes to Pyro.

[@HauntSlider]

I have worked many a Rammstein show in the US and one of the things I love about them is how cool and kind they are to the local crews. That being said, another of my favorite things is their contract for a show, literally, says "No fire, no show." The shooting of teh fireworks over and back across the crowd is live. You can see it in any live video of their shows.

[@meatball1974]

I'd read that they are all ticketed (if that's a thing) pyro technicians just due to the liability of it all.

[@filyp1984]

The environment hates them.

[@pauljohnson8112]

Especially Till

[@nesframe]

damn thats so cool, have you talked to Till or the other band members?

[@holliecasey5463]

@@meatball1974 that is true.

[@susanf3846]

I saw them 2005 at Ruisrock Finland. Just before their performance there was huge thunderstorm, heavy rain and lightning. They had to postpone their gig, thousands of people waited them and under the dark sky in the middle of summer their pyros looked even more amazing! It was something I never forget! It's more than a concert, it's more like theatre/opera, they're amazing alive, everyone should experience Rammstein live once in a lifetime!

[@erssound]

Everyone needs to see them live at least once in their life

[@anderswallin3883]

I saw them live last year here in sweden, and i am so happy that i got to do it. It has been a dream of mine for a long time. That pyro creates a lot of heat tho. We got cooked xD

[@slobodailinista]

Yeah bro. Belgrade 2010.

[@stuffwelike7184]

​@@anderswallin3883 That would be freaking awesome, I'd love to see them in Sweaden along with many other bands .

[@bogdana7304]

facts

[@notlisztening9821]

No longer. If you have any selfworth and compassion, you won't go to any more of their concerts. All the concerts I have been on so far were the best concert experiences of my life, but i sold my tickets for july. I have too much selfrespect, to cheer for someone, who drugs and rapes minors.

[@tbdavey]

Till is a licensed pyrotechnician. He does it all.

[@brianhatfield4346]

And he speaks like 7-8 languages which also amazing

[@angryangro2139]

not true, they have a pyro team with them

[@PalleRasmussen]

No, they have a professional company doing it these days.

[@angryangro2139]

@@brianhatfield4346 i think, he speaks english, russian and some french, that´s it

[@CyberBeep_kenshi]

​@@angryangro2139 but he IS licensed, they all are

[@backdoorman1971]

That’s the beauty of Rammstein. It’s controlled chaos. Till Lindemann is a poet. A performer. A timid kind soul .. but a beast on stage. You get it all. I would recommend you to attend a concert. It’s a beautiful experience ❤

[@tsfbaf303]

lol You fell for his stage persona

[@sirunlegit8782]

Didn’t age well I guess

[@SpaceMissile]

@@sirunlegit8782 how? edit: oh, I just found an article. blah.

[@standinsilence]

​@@SpaceMissileYeah maybe you should also watch that Till The End video. Im a fan of the music but definitely not him as a person.

[@controlledchaos804]

🔥😈😈🔥

[@domeplsffs]

I love how open minded she approaches stuff she isn't familiar with. Presenting your view like this, is actually very valuable to other peeps like me, who come from a different walk of life. Thank you very much for sharing your reactions and your proffesional view, i learn a lot

[@flightgamer7849]

The very definition of owning a crowd.

[@TheKatoffen]

So wie der Rattenfänger von Hameln.

[@jalf0007]

There is that three things you will always find in a Rammstain concert: an experience (not just music), great metal music, and fire, LOTS OF FIRE!!

[@stephanewantiez164]

and amazing lyrics from Till, with a lot of hidden meaning and messages

[@UncoordinatedPixie]

4 actually. You forgot Flake on a treadmill!

[@jalf0007]

@@stephanewantiez164 touché

[@melissacarson9047]

Our young daughter calls it “popping fire”. 😂

[@Nr4747]

You are correct that this song has a bit of a techno vibe, the sub-genre is called "Industrial Metal" (or sometimes just "Industrial") and describes early-ish Rammstein very well.

[@HerrBowski]

Rammstein themselves describe their music as “Tanz Metal”.

[@Chr1sWaterous]

Came to say this

[@glorgozorgon]

​@@HerrBowski really? its almost impossible to dance to rammstein, wtf 😂

[@HerrBowski]

@@glorgozorgon It‘s actually impossible to listen to Rammstein nowadays, after what happened last year.

[@glorgozorgon]

@@HerrBowski what happened???

[@amp-xo6lr]

Live is where Rammstein shines . Some of the very best Musical Theater and Rock Opera you'll find anywhere.

[@bdobel6353]

Do not forget, that this was in France, french audience, German lyrics and they are singing. This is the most remarkable thing about ting!!!

[@Fuzzllmao]

underrated comment. very true.

[@nicolasdubos2797]

Indeed, but remember that technicaly most french people are from germanic, acendancies. Some parts of France teritories went from german to french domination overtime like alsace or loraine. And that even franc was a germanic tribe. We fought a lot each other. But we share some blood. And we recognise each other as celtic based people. The only thing is that rome was more implanted in France than in germany, which turned the langage and maners into something more latin and civilised. But we're still barbaric people in our minds. World champion of strikes. And f.. y... to the power, supposed to bring us down. Liberty or death is the barbaric way. And every people that shares that way of life is our brother.

[@patrickhavard6631]

I have no idea what he Is saying here in America but I'm singing just like him. He could be saying destroy America and I'd still be singing

[@JonBaldry]

Great reaction and I'd strongly recommend 'Engel' from the same gig. Given that Till Lindemann suffers from extreme stage fright, the performances are even more impressive

[@deed5811]

Engel live in Paris someone added English subtitles to this version kzbin.info/www/bejne/lZvbo6tuaLt1gsk

[@peterworth9403]

I swear...Every time I see a later year's performance of "Engel," that wing apparatus gets bigger. And Till becomes even more of a beast. I did not know about the stage fright. That explains a lot about why he puts so much pyro and such into the show. It takes some of the attention from him. And sends the crowd home knowing they will NEVER forget that Rammstein show. Never been to one myself, but I've watched enough of the live performances to understand the hype.

[@thefluxcapacitor1]

Would it be the Engel performance from the New York show from a previous tour? I've only watched this one in full once, but the New York performance of Engel is amazing.

[@peterworth9403]

@@thefluxcapacitor1 This video is from the a paris show they had recorded. Great damned show. Till walks those wings forward like a beast from the depths of Hell.

[@thefluxcapacitor1]

@@peterworth9403 Yeah, I totally forgot he used the wings in the Paris show. I know he doesn't use them any more. I was just recalling the performance from the Live in Amerika performance where he uses the wings.

[@DucHuynh-js1ch]

you can clearly tell from her facial expressions, that she is hooked from the very instant the drums kick in... 😊 welcome to the Rammstein family 🤗🤗🤗

[@Uncle_Neil]

you just know she listened to "Volkerball" a dozen times or more, no doubt.

[@sandraglasgow]

She is hooked ok and she loves Till!! 😂

[@wobblysauce]

From the Piano version being the first one.

[@asmodeoloyalvillacorta508]

The vocalist, Till Lidermann is a MASTER when it comes to fire. He's certificated to work with it and to use it however he pleased.

[@timhutchinson8485]

A lot of Rammstein’s music (especially the earlier stuff) has a lot of influence from German electronic music of the 80s and 90s.

[@notwokevikingrules401]

also called industrial like Die Krupps

[@arnodobler1096]

Kraftwerk

[@19FlyingWombat76]

It`s more like German Electro/Goth/Industrial and as Musician I can really tell that Electro/Techno and Industrial are two complete diffrent Regions in Music...... Sure, electronics and Synth`s are included but to say that`s electronic is like to say "I can hear sound" as it is just a word in this case....

[@19FlyingWombat76]

@@arnodobler1096 Alter.....was hat Kraftwerk mit Industrial zu tun?! o.O

[@arnodobler1096]

@@19FlyingWombat76 mit elektronischer Musik, Bub!

[@tosa2522]

Lead guitarist Richard Z. Kruspe (right side on stage from your point of view) watched Till weaving baskets, singing along to pop songs from the radio, and then talked him into becoming the lead singer of Rammstein.

[@TheVoxbox13]

👍 Thanks for posting this. I'm rather new to Rammstein, and wondered about how they formed such a unique band. This inspires me to do some reading. Cheers

[@annegretkasten6277]

​@@TheVoxbox13They played in different groups in the GDR and knew each other. Then R. Kruspe said they should form a new band.

[@JohnJulitz]

I love that all the original members have been with the band with the start and that they guys are still crushing it despite being together for nearly 30 years (and being in their 50s/60s).

[@arbtek2279]

To understand Rammstein you have to experience at least one concert. The feeling of standing in the crowd and how Till takes everyone with him. Unmatched.

[@WyndStryke]

The fireworks were real, running along cables (you can see the way the track dips in the middle). Till is a licensed pyro, and that forms the basis of their live acts. The lightning was the only thing added in post-production. They're great to see live, I have seen them a few times. Till has his own side-band too ("LINDEMANN"), as well as being a part of Rammstein.

[@antivanti]

I really think that the added effects just cheapens the real effects. I'm ok with the slow motion shots but not the stuff added in post. Also the hectic music video editing just distracts from the live show experience. It just feels like the editor tries to hide something or doesn't trust the quality of the actual show 🤔🤷 I do like other things he (Jonas Åkerlund) has done tho but he's a music video producer

[@VonLigenstein]

@@antivanti zRemember this was done in 95... before CGI ... remember Star Wars cam oiut in 77 then they remastered it in the 90's made creatures more life like ( insted of everything a model theyc could now computer generate / enhance the model) now look at last start wars movie, Carrie Fishecher is dead yet they ' brought her backto life' using old footage and CGI) Back in the 90's flames and fireworks t aa STADIUM performance was un heard of, what visual effects did most bands bring? usually it was just and extended variation on their songs...

[@antivanti]

@@VonLigenstein The song is from the 90s but the shows the footage is from were recorded in 2012 and released in 2017. Their earlier live DVDs are much better at showing the grand spectacle of the actual show.

[@michaelgoetze2103]

@@antivanti I agree. I find the post production work a bit irritating, particularly the enhancement of the explosions. It removes you from the actual experience. The concerts are impressive enough, no need for enhancements.

[@Tarkus_]

@@antivanti I agree with you. It's shot more like a music video, which takes away from the live feel. And with the lightning effects added, it's normal for the viewer to wonder, since that's obviously fake, what else is fake? Seems completely unnecessary for a live video (as opposed to a music video). It's still an amazing video. But I think it would be even better if the director wasn't trying so hard to impress us.

[@FHB71]

First of all: Good job pronouncing "Rammstein"!!! I need to emphasize that this is in Paris and you have this huge crowd (I assume mostly French people) singing in German. That in itself is a huge thing!!

[@stephanewantiez164]

it hasn't happen since... yes a long time... 😅

[@Keepupit]

I didnt know they were French. I thought it was the German spirit!!😂

[@FHB71]

@@Keepupit Well, the concert was in Paris, so the audience is mostly french I assume.

[@p.m.4735]

I’m French and I was there that very special night, and most of us were French. I wasn’t sure they would be allowed to perform pyros indoor, as Bercy is a closed arena. I highly recommand you to watch the entire show "Rammstein Paris" so you can feel how intense it was 😉

[@susanhyatt1084]

Yes, a German standing over submissive Frenchmen. Hmmm....

[@michaelmaltzer5426]

This song is almost 30 years old. It is their iconic song… that is why the crowd is so involved in the song

[@sharon7968]

One of the main reasons they appear calm and stoic, especially when performing this song is because they have to remain on their marks at all times due to the amount of fire. The band members, who are all certified pyrotechnicians produce and stage the show themselves. I'd recommend watching videos with the English translation as the words are as important as the show they put on. Till suffers from extreme stage fright so what you see is a persona to help him perform

[@ashtonhand3672]

Till absolutely knows how to work a crowd. Dude knows how to make their music be an entire experience.

[@baka_yu9343]

If you enjoyed the crowd engagement in this piece, you might want to take a look at "Ich will" from the Hurricane Festival in 2016. There are versions where people have put subtitles to the song into the video, the original one doesn't have them I believe. As for their official music videos, I highly recommend "Deutschland" (full version, it's a little under 10 minutes), "Angst" and "Zeit". All those videos have the option of turning on auto-translated english subtitles, which are surprisingly good, I highly recommend to turn those on so everyone can follow along to what is said because it's quite important in all of them.

[@19FlyingWombat76]

The Concert in France/Neville is still the best for me (Völkerball)....got the BR`s from Madison Square Garden, Paris and Neville but the Concert in Neville has the deepest feeling and power of all DVD`s and BR`s I own!

[@kristallmett7843]

100% agree! "Ich will" is just perfect for concerts with a huge crowd. The lyrics from the chorus are literally Till asking the audience questions and the people reply. Its so much fun to watch and its even more fun if you're there :D

[@aerialarboreal9005]

Deutschland is incredible... Make sure to listen to the instrumental of "Sonne" at the end, so beautiful...

[@stephanewantiez164]

+10000 for that comment as we said in the early days of the internet I would also add "Mein Teil" live in Paris with the subtitles on for the fun ^^ kzbin.info/www/bejne/gJm8Y3-sor6Egsk&ab_channel=Bucksttabu

[@Badner83]

A very important point to the crowd engagement here... This concert was in France. And the French usually HATE speaking other languages than French!!! So thousands of French people perfectly singing along in German means a lot!

[@agatach87]

I have been to 6 concerts already and let me tell you, it’s one hell of an experience! Best live band I have ever seen, no doubt. ❤

[@rpkdamn]

I can’t think of much that I love more than non-metal musicians discovering and appreciating good metal music.

[@gunnyboone9079]

Everything you saw in this video actually took place. I was at this concert, and it blew my mind. If you noticed Flake was on a treadmill, that powered a TESLA coil, witch caused the lightening from the keyboard. The flares that came out of the gun and the fireworks that blew up the stage were real.

[@danamontagnese6063]

When you refer to how relaxed Till is during his performance, the word that comes to my mind is "focused". He's 100% in the zone while performing and this, plus his rich baritone is what makes him the most exciting thing I've seen in years.

[@chelleb3055]

They are so talented and their aesthetic is off the charts every time. What an incredible group of men.

[@kellismith4329]

Yes and all with bombs going off all around him

[@DB-pp7kj]

Hes actually got bad stage fright. According to interviews hes done the character he plays on stage helps him deal with that. Hes said he will blackout on stage and forget the lines until right before he sings them.

[@Dsarah86]

Rammstein's pyros are legendary. They perform the song Feuer Frei is in the opening scene of "XXX". The fire show they put on in that scene is what they do live. I saw them in Detroit and you could feel the incredible heat from the display. I can't imagine being on stage. It's an incredible experience.

[@IML52]

I was at that Detroit show too, and can confirm the heat from the pyro.

[@tml0609]

Till and the guys have been performing this song in particular for decades. They have it down to something beyond an art. I'm 35 and first heard this song in the fifth grade when our German music teacher woulr let us listen to Rammstein on Fridays as a treat. They're incredible and MUST be experienced live.

[@CavHDeu]

You should not have expectations when it comes to Rammstein. They will crush it.

[@stanleyhyde8529]

Everyone should experience Rammstein live. The flames, the sound and the people. From all over the world. Tacoma dome 2010, of the greatest nights of my life.

[@DaddyDoom]

Having seen these fellas 5 or 6 times, I can say this is the normal crowd mood during their gigs.

[@scottsuydam3349]

The band comes up with the music and then Till writes the lyrics to match the music. Rammstein is the best show you’ll ever see. The greatest Industrial Metal Band ever.

[@NoName-kx8kc]

Seen them 6 times live from early 90s, their pyro is real🤘🤘. More Rammstein👍👍

[@marcuswood2204]

I feel like the song "ich tu dir weh" Live from Maddison Square Gardens is as perfect of a performance as you will ever see from this band. Such a immense example of every aspect of Til's voice.

[@tatiphotoart]

YES!!!

[@sazzycool]

I love that performance!

[@TheOdderlbert]

the snare drum in the beginnig is the 2nd best sound ever

[@blaaaaaaaaahify]

The performance is great. The atmosphere on the other hand seems forced a lot of time. It just doesn't feel at home the likes of european tours.

[@volkerrohde7683]

These guys perform the best stadium show ever. Pyro, crowd involvement and the beat with accompanying melodies and riffs. Unbelievably good!

[@Makeupdelicious1984]

His voice is so melodic and in tune despite all the freaking noise. He sings so effortlessly! Also the concert experience is a total wooooow

[@rickfromtexas4659]

I really enjoyed your reaction to this piece. The words "Du Hast" are taken from German wedding vows. The song describes the two stages of a relationship. The first half is "du hast mich" meaning "you have me." So it is about two people in love and beginning their marriage. Things of course change, and the play on words comes out in the second half of the song when it changes to "du hasst mich" (du haßt mich) which translates out to "you hate me."

[@jdsim9173]

The whole song means You Hate Me- here is the English version of the song - kzbin.info/www/bejne/h4rJhYKtoKpjbKM

[@alberich3099]

​@@jdsim9173 no yes but no. The literal meaning is Du hast NOT du hasst. One is oyu have one is you hate. The translation of you hate me is WRONG. It ebvcomes apperant when you listen to the song in german and not only the "du hast" part. It builds up to Du hast mich gefragt, und ich hab' nichts gesagt. In this instance you hate me makes no sense, as it would be translated to you hate me asked, and I di not answer, whereas in the proper translation (from their lyric booklet in the single) is: You proposed a question and I did not answer. However, that is the fun with the lyrics. It can be phonetically be understood to mean you hate me as du hast and du hasst are pronounced the same. This lead to the wrong englsih translation. But if you take tha phonetical similarity together with the underline sound and idea about marrige, the du hast becomes du hasst, just as Rick said. It is failour to answer the question which led to the hatred. Storywise it tells the story of someone askeing the(!) question. Which is the frist refrain. Willst du bis der Tod euch scheidet, treu ihr sein bis alle Tage (Do you wish to be faithfull to her untill death parts you). This is answered by Nein (no). Which leads to the vers Du, du hast, du hast mich, again written as hast not hasst in the booklet. However with the play phonetically you can verymuch now understand that the build up to the refrain can (and in my mind must) be understood as du hasst mich (you hate me). So no your shared translation is wrong it absolutly butchers the "pre-refrain". The original states. Du, du hast, du hast mich, du hast mich Du hast mich gefragt, du hast mich gefragt Du hast mich gefragt und ich hab' nichts gesagt The wrong stranslation states You hate me to say, and I did not obey - which not only gramitally is absolutly wrong (something Rammstein is rather precise about in their language as they don't modulate language to fit the narrative, but they change words a left over from their time in the GDR where they had to be very careful what words to use) but also wrong with respect to the information. They change the You have asked me, and I did not reply to You hate me and I did not obey.

[@rickfromtexas4659]

Sorry, but I got the story of the song from a German friend when I lived in South Korea. He worked there for BMW. He was raised in East Germany like the band members. The English version of the song which they have sang in the past, is not the same as the German version. I will go with what my friend shared with me. It was almost 20 years ago, but I remember the conversation well.

[@phrike7588]

When artists make English versions of their songs, they usually have to change the lyrics substantially to fit the melody ..and often, like in this case, some things in the original just doesn't translate - something we often see in movie subtitles in foreign movies. Things like wordplay; "hast" is "have" but phonetically it's the same, "hasst" = hate, which probably were their intentions.

[@BlackMai85]

Till is playing with german words. That's the play with "du hasst mich" but there comes more "du hast mich ... gefragt" that's the declination of "you've asked me" Also the play with "bis der Tod uns scheidet" (until death separates us) and "bis zum tod der Scheide"(until death of the vagina) 🧐 He's a poet and everyone can interpret anything in the lyrics 🥰 But translation is hard. Cause of the play with the words.

[@woodydroneson]

If you listen to any Rammstein song with headphones on and listen out for individual parts each member does a fantastic job, but if you listen to what the keyboard player adds, he is a genious musically. Till on Vocals is amazing.

[@lozlax1121]

He's so calm because he knows they have the croud in the palms of their hands! Thank you for doing these Rammstein videos. The band are incredible ❤

[@sea-ferring]

I'm not even a Rammstein fan, but they are on my must see live show list.

[@seancollins3106]

I saw them last year. You don't have to be a fanboy/girl to love what's going on. It's an incredibly visceral experience! I brought my 15yr old and he had the time of his life!

[@alexthorpe6583]

I wouldn't say this is a typical Rammstein song, but it was their first breakout hit in 1997, and about the only one to get mainstream radio play in the US. I think the band has greatly improved their skill, their songwriting, their creativity over the years. For an intense experience, you can look at 'Deutschland', a rather disturbing look at German history, and it asks how can they be proud of their country, when they've got so much darkness in their past.

[@ksenss2513]

Also much better to look at the vocals.

[@PalleRasmussen]

What is a typical Rammstein song? I would posit there is none.

[@agrazaj223]

Popatrz w swoją historię to ci się włos zjeży!

[@hydrosan13]

I don't think any country or nation is sunshine and rainbows for all their history... what matters is you look at and acknowledge the dark parts so that they won't be repeated. This includes my own country of The United States of America.

[@smok069]

@@PalleRasmussenIf you want to hear the original Rammstein, then songs like Heirate Mich or Das Alte Leid, when you want to hear the futuristic Rammstein, then Eifersucht or Tier and if you want to hear the modern Rammstein, then Giftig or Adieu

[@billyc3035]

Now you're hooked. Their song Deutschland and especially the official music video for it are moving and just amazing.

[@Fanatic1704]

Till sings this song for 27 years! Every sound, every note is filled with perfection. Watch some live records and check this masterpiece!

[@ValkyrieLadyK]

Saw Rammstein live man years ago and they put on a great show with some of the most consistently impressive pyrotechnics I've ever seen.

[@ValkyrieLadyK]

They have a song called "Rammstein" that the singer often performs while he is on fire.

[@runforitscooby]

First thing I wondered is why the hell is she listening to Rammstein. Then I remembered why you are my favorite music reactor. You embrace, critique, and teach people not to judge music that they are not necessarily into. Du Hast for Rammstein is what Enter Sandman is to Metallica, or Closer by Nine Inch Nails- its the song that brought it to the masses which the purists of each band dislike.. This song is such a feast of techno, industrial, metal, and rock and visual aesthetics .

[@alethea507]

I love Rammstein and Du Hast, but this is not the song for a vocal coach reaction video. There are so many songs that have so much more vocally. Like you said, this is the hook song for worldwide popularity.

[@honeypotaka7252]

I'm Soo happy you're enjoying this! They had 50 different cameras stationed to capture this...wow!

[@seanryan9599]

This band are truly amazing. The industrial metal sound, the techno sound, the 80's electronica and prog rocky parts. Coupled with the Kraftwerk feel and look and awesome live show. Just wow. Can't wait to see them in London in December.

[@kamikazecdn]

Their song "Engel" live at MSG would be another good one to react to for both Till's voice and the show. For non-metal and non-Rammstein reactions, The White Buffalo would be someone worth checking out. His performance of "The Whistler" live at the Guitar Center would be a decent starting point to see the range of his voice.

[@ksenss2513]

They also make great music videos. Watch "Deutschland" from 2019 (also a bit more recent than Du hast) for great vocals, a massive video and make sure to get english subtitles, text ist important with this one. (even the automated subtitles turned to english do quite a good job in this case).

[@blued_moon4020]

Another beautiful song: Ohne Dich. One of my favorites. If you like Till singing more soft, this is one of their more ballad ones

[@whatdonormiesthink2331]

The duality of the song is what makes it amazing!

[@darinhusk366]

Till likes to burn the stage up. His annunciation is amazing, as is his voice. Thanks, and cheers!

[@stephanewantiez164]

The place for the audience in front of the stage is called the "Feuerzone" ^^'

[@jovana_r]

It's all real except for the lightning from the keyboards. I would recommend "Ich tu dir weh" live from Madison Square Garden, where apart from an insane stage performance you can also hear more of Till's singing. I'm really looking forward to more reactions of Rammstein! 🖤

[@peterl5804]

Love your analysis. Rammstein are unique.

[@SpaceMissile]

truly a one-of-a-kind band.

[@rcm944]

Your reaction is one of the most delightful things I have seen in a long time. It reminded me of an almost childlike wonderment, and that is meant as a compliment and was very contagious...keep doing what you're doing you're a blast to watch!

[@Touchpadse]

I wasn't at this specific concert but I've seen them a few times live and I can tell you for certain that this is all done live

[@EddieReischl]

I remember the first time I heard this the video was on MTV at the other guitarist in our band's house, and his ancestry is French Canadian, and he was asking me what the lyrics meant. I didn't know a lot of German at the time. "I can't really tell if he's singing "You Have Me" or "You Hate Me", he might mean both." "Oh yeah, that's perfect." he replied, and laughed. Later on, I saw the official song title. Turns out Till plays with words like that often, I've found Rammstein to be a good band to study the lyrics of for getting better at understanding German and a few of its nuances.

[@BATTLECATT00]

(I love the reaction this Vocalyst Coach reacts to these. She would be worth taking to a live concert like this. She would have fun, and would not be a boring person to bring along...) -All Heavy metal or rock or glam bands(bands out of ending 70's more common 80's and up, Rammstein is out of early 90's), audience participation is a tradition, namely on songs that are well known top list songs. Not only is it very highly common, but considered traditional....

[@bartvools2314]

Watching them live is an experience. They just blow you away. Saw them last year for the first time, about 20 years too late or so…. Can’t wait to see them again in Brussels this summer.

[@toyfreaks]

I always thought Rammstein was just another German industrial metal band. I had no idea a guy who looks like Herman Munster could sing like this! Thank you for getting me to listen to this.

[@retroz4]

The best moment I have found in a reaction video so far at 10:05 in this video! An honest reaction to a truly amazing moment by one of the best live shows to see! So glad to get to see you experience this!

[@TugaDev]

Saw this band a couple of years ago LIVE and i must say its a must. They have presence on stage and give a heck of a show!!

[@xFallN1x]

Caught them in late 90s at Hammerstein ball room I think , smaller venue , killer show full Pyro. One of the best shows I ever seen

[@scoobyblue5300]

Loving your reactions to my favourite band! If I could reccommend Ich Tu Dir Weh...live from Madison Square Garden...as your next jump into the Rammstein rabbit hole. It's probably the song which showcases Till Lindemann's full vocal range better than any other.

[@arnodobler1096]

Yes 🤘

[@theinvisibleneonrainbowzeb2567]

It's a good song and great performance but I don't think it is the best showcase of his voice. Epic performance of the song though!

[@scoobyblue5300]

@@theinvisibleneonrainbowzeb2567 Really???...What would you suggest then?

[@rockonileva]

You once said you like to watch the music videos to see a concept added to the experience. Rammstein's music videos are simply amazing. Zeit (from their latest album) is a great example, beautiful song (among the best by them), I simply love Till's performance on it, and the music video is simply stunning!

[@annabrady1546]

They are amazing to see live!! I saw them in Vegas on a more intimate stage. I had goosebumps throughout! The best show I've ever seen & still get excited telling about it but know words can never do justice. It was an incredible experience & yes they sound EXACTLY as recorded. Just incredible artist's in both sound & vision. I love that you liked them too! Def go if you ever have a chance, it will stay with you forever:)

[@nicci4724]

They are amazing live. I was at this concert. The keyboard player is in a faraday cage so no graphics. They do not talk during the concert. It's all music. All of it is live. They are pyrotechnic experts. Their name - look up Rammstein air base,.

[@Hellknight27]

Even if you weren't a fan of their music, you could enjoy their stage shows. They are second to none. Also, this is industrial metal, which is a sub-genre that includes an electronic element. In Rammstein's case it is called Neue Deutsche Härte (New German Hardness). Which was coined by the German press after Rammstein released their first album in 1995. This is also their most recognisable song, as it is easy to follow and acts as a gateway to the band.

[@RobinC63]

Rammstein is one of those groups where you don’t go to a concert, you to an experience. The pyros are live and what looks like grease they have on their bodies is actually fire retardant. Another term you may not have heard of when describing Rammstein is Industrial Metal. Really big in Germany.

[@johna1367]

I got see them live in 2012, top 5 craziest but absolutely freaking amazing concerts I've been too.

[@mikebunner3498]

From what I have read their contract states "No fire, NO Show!" And I believe that!!!!

[@Brute4rce1111]

Saw them live in LA a few months back. Absolutely amazing!

[@cherielima6100]

Yes, the pyrotechnics are real. Till has taken the time to become a pyrotechnition. He and the band are fabulous ❤

[@rogersjgregory]

Good to see that the keyboardist is getting his daily steps in.

[@philjones45]

Being their live is even more amazing, you feel the heat of the pyrotechnics, the power of the band. Most impressive is they don't stop to talk garbage. They perform each song as if it's a play in itself, and give everything their all. At the end they take a humble bow and say thank you. The best live concert I ever went to, think it was 2005.

[@kiksyame1481]

I was lucky to see them live last year, they probably used fuel of a smaller city's week over 2 hours. We were not cold (outside concert). Their effect are crazy, I got goosebumbs during Puppe.

[@TheAnon26]

Yeah, I saw them back in 2019. Not close to the stage, kinda in the middle. You still felt the heat waft over you. Insane. 😁

[@ileana8360]

At the beginning of their career they called it "dance metal" themselves. In Germany it is mostly categorized as "neue deutsche Härte". Edit: really loved how you pointed out that this song is not as monotone or "easy" as it appeaers. It would not be such a success for decades if it where.

[@ariell6489]

I love ur expression when Till breaks out the firework bazooka lol They have the best concerts EVER. Its an immersive experience.

I think that the only thing added to the video is the lightning from the keyboard. Every pyrotechnics is totally Live. That's one of Rammsteins trademarks. They have the "hottest" Live show on earth.

[@pipkin5287]

I really loved your analysis and just overall enjoyment of a band I absolutely adore. I hope you'll do more videos from them! Till is very known for writing lyrics with double entendres and multiple meanings, so listening to the songs are always a layered experience.

[@wickednymphet]

I love watching Till perform. He just looks so cool.

[@SaturnusDK]

The pyrotechnics of Rammstein shows is insane. I've been front of stage crew to several of their concerts. To avoid getting our hair burned from the intense heat right at the front of the stage we all had wet hair and wet caps on. Those that had long hair tuck it into the cap. You also had to wear a turtle neck to avoid the hairs on the back of your neck from searing. I tell you, you sweat more than doing a marathon, just being a crew to their shows. I can't even imagine how difficult it must be to actually be on the stage, and trying to perform under those conditions. Oh, and there's nothing "added" to the video. It's all live. All of it.

[@ahmedelkettani8626]

It's not chaotic because it's industrial, it's pulsating and very mechanical, yet extremely artistic, Rammstein are mighty good!

[@damnedyankee5]

I do NOT recommend listening to Rammstein while driving a band bus across the desert in the middle of the night WITHOUT setting your cruise control! Trust me! It was expensive! 😆

[@66048fishn-huntin]

Great review. They absolutely incorporate techno into their music. They are the perfect Industrial Metal band.

[@helmutkoohl8652]

i love to hear our neighbours performing in my motherlanguage,; rammstein makes it possible 😎it's pure, raw german power + a perfect show. so many milliones around the world can't be wrong.

[@mat8431]

Love to see you react to those, just FYI there's a song Till Lindemann featured in called "Le jardin des larmes" From Zaz and it really shows his range and I just love the contrast with his band(s) even in a non native language.

[@eagle1de227]

Thank you for this enlightening analysis of this Rammstein Song. After the vocal version of "mein Herz brennt" and the life concert version of "Du hast" the next level would be the music video to "Deutschland" (or maybe not so intense: "Angst")

[@chrisrode3208]

They have a song called mein teil. It’s an example of the epitome of Rammstein. My favorite song of theirs. I saw them with System of a Down. Rammstein’s show was amazing. Can’t even put it into words

[@kevinparent8843]

their firework is awesome ! one of a kind

[@dmwalker24]

A really great example of Till's vocals is 'Ich Tu Dir Weh', and if you're looking for not only a great song, but also the most amazing production I've ever seen in a music video, you should definitely check out 'Deutschland'.

[@Ishwolv]

I just like seeing someone who isn't really a big Rammstein fan listen to them and appreciate them instead of just being turned off because of how niche the band is.

[@Joyce_Boettcher]

If you are interested in Tils vocals, you should watch his life perfomance of „Ich tuh dir weh“ :)

[@cathyb1273]

I went to one of their concert in France and I confirm that all the fire effects are very real. It was in july in the south of France in an open roman arena and oh boy the atmosphere was hot... I was exhausted at the end 😁🤘 An wonderful souvenir.

[@dn8036]

you can find some of the best singers and musicians on the planet in Metal!

[@capstan50g]

I sure dig Til's bracing baritone. Their whole vibe somehow takes me back to 1920's Berlin. I wouldn't be surprised if they released an entire album of Kurt Weill songs. Great reaction, Bethany!

[@arnodobler1096]

Eine Kooperation mit Max Raabe & Palast Orchester wäre spannend. Ähnlich wie mit David Garret in "Alle Tage ist kein Sonntag" A cooperation with Max Raabe & Palast Orchester would be exciting. Similar to David Garret in "Alle Tage ist kein Sonntag".

[@stephanewantiez164]

you have great 1920's vibes in the "Radio" music video, I greatly recommend it (with translated subtitles on for sure)

[@capstan50g]

@@stephanewantiez164 Many thanks! I will check that out!