We compare two of the BEST Shotgun Slugs we've tested

We have tested a lot of really impressive slugs. These two stand out, but how do they compare?

[@dELTA13579111315]

I checked out the store, and for anybody curious Goodell sells the slugs at $21.25 for 25 slugs for most of them, and he has a ton of varieties to choose from. Thanks for giving both companies a shoutout, it's good to know of them!

[@taofledermaus]

I've been clamoring for someone to sell just the slugs - even suggesting they sell them on Ebay. Ryan even had some molds custom made for him. It seems like every day I check, he's added something new to the site. He still has a lot of work to do.

[@davidjernigan8161]

@@taofledermaus I can imagine that a small business where you are the manufacturer, shipper, etc. the website may end up taking a back seat to production and shipping.

[@nikihealey5571]

@@taofledermaus Collaboration with a chemistry/physics KZbinr would be a leap for the Channel. I have many questions and suggestions on other KZbin channels to connect with

[@oaktreejw]

I’m sure if Ryan gets into this thread he will probably look into producing a slug similar to the gate keeper

[@carolinaadventures4713]

@@taofledermaus I replied on a post my son is station in Miramar and my brother runs the Elks Lodge in San Diego was going to see if you would let them come shoot one day have some guest shooters? I received spam posing to be you I reported.

[@HugoHugunin]

Gatekeeper vs armed intruder is a non-contest. A center mass shot is going to do a Ninja blender to heart, lungs, liver, major arteries and spinal column. As a former Trauma Tech, I feel comfortable saying that even a "badly placed" shot will likely be instantly fatal, or at the very least, totally incapacitating.

[@R.Sole88109]

What's the medical term for shit his pants too?. I think the Latin is Rapidass Evacuass😂

[@MESOHAWNYFAWYOU]

Fire one into a human crouching menacingly in your living room and guaranteed you'll want to move out instead of cleaning up the mess. Just sayin'.

[@Jeff.78]

A blast to the thigh is removing your leg, while the femoral paints the walls, briefly. Into the shoulder, depends, but I wouldn't be hopeful. This is probably the closet you can get from firing an HE round.

[@p_campbell]

Saw a trauma vic. that had a deer slug to the left pelvis ....... With this round I believe the leg would be torn off , or at least hanging by a bit of meat., Either way D.O.A

[@ScotlandsGold]

@@MESOHAWNYFAWYOU did you move or clean the mess?

[@nickross133]

I've always thought the Gatekeeper was the single most impressive slug you've shot. Awesome find OG.

[@Jeff.78]

Agreed. It does everything right and I'd be ok with the ridiculous price, if they were in stock.

[@robmanueb.]

Wax slugs are still my fav, the original and you can make them easily.

[@WapTek123]

well now i gotta reverse engineer the gatekeper

[@SharpiesERA]

It’s an absolute phenomenal slug. And they look incredibly cool. I hope the maker of these things made a very good buck off of them

[@hondolane3125]

The thing I still like best is that Brianna made a ring out of an expanded Gatekeeper.

[@Khan.WrathOf]

The Gatekeeper is BRUTAL. If there was ever a shotgun round designed to take down small to medium-sized dinosaurs, it'd probably be that one.

[@TheOriginalFaxon]

I would honestly say it depends on the dinosaur. Some of the armored ones you would need a .700 nitro loaded with a brass solid, to get enough energy on target and penetrate. A .50 BMG might honestly be a better choice at that point given a .700 nitro costs like $100 a shell while packing less muzzle energy. A specially designed hollow point .50 BMG round could easily be more devastating for a fraction of the price, probably being priced comparably to a pair of these gatekeeper slugs. For home defense shooting a man sized target though, I'd pick that gatekeeper slug all day

[@ScottLovenberg]

You have to shoot the tree next to small dinosaurs if you want there to be any meat on the kill. Same thing they used to have to do with muskets when hunting small game.

[@michiganengineer8621]

@@TheOriginalFaxon Maybe a .50 BMG designed to "bloom" like the Gatekeeper slug. THAT'S a scary thought actually!

[@Khan.WrathOf]

@@ScottLovenberg important fax. Thank you mystery internet man

[@BIG-DIPPER-56]

Yay, I'd feel confident in that arena ! !

[@frawdulent]

I remember watching the “gatekeeper” video back when you released it. My mouth was agape through the whole video from seeing the total destruction of that round. Thanks Jeff!

[@taofledermaus]

I was really surprised at those- I would have thought their reputation and performance would have been known long before we got ahold of them.

[@paulhendrixson1896]

I think we were lumped in with Oath and G2 when I built those. I designed the slug on the day Biden said no one needed an AR 15 and that a shotgun was all you needed.

[@MoldyStir-Fry]

The Gatekeeper will forever be the coolest slug ever in my opinion, but the Twister shredding that pork in 3 different directions was incredible to see!

[@samael978]

Hope more comparisons are coming, I can already tell this is gonna be good

[@giarcsavage]

those were very impressive, and that was one hell of a pork explosion!

[@goldenwheeledbanshee9160]

Pork rainbow 🌈

[@_nelson]

Yep pork explosion Imagine if that slug hit you That is one wicked slug

[@MrYogitron92]

"Porksplosion "

[@alystair]

The wild life must love em'!

[@issachocolate5116]

The twister made a PorkNado!

[@madmod]

I just got my first 12 guage. Needless to say, this channel has been an awesome source of both info and etertainment. Your videos prove the 12 guage is such a versatile beast and you guys are very fun to watch.

[@taofledermaus]

thank you!

[@ScottKenny1978]

I say that the 12ga is the "chef's knife" of firearms. Can do almost anything, depending on what you load it with.

[@supergeek1418]

I'm *DEFINITELY* looking forward to seeing what some of those other slugs are, and how they perform. Another excellent video. Thanks.

[@taofledermaus]

thanks!

[@adamhuckfeldt2895]

Best on KZbin. Keep it up gang

[@R.J.1]

Whoa. Neat stuff. Thanks for featuring these 2 rounds guys.

[@redneckhippiefreak]

Last time I was this early I was eaten by a Bird..

[@Angelsilhouette]

I'd love to see you compare those slugs with your old wax slugs. Maybe you could use multiple sizes of shot in your wax slugs to get it packed in extra tight.

[@goldenwheeledbanshee9160]

Enjoyed hell I loved watching this Jeff. My favorite slug is good ol wax or cut shell. Great shooting an great narration by you. 10/10 big man.

[@taofledermaus]

thanks!

[@andreawhalen4142]

@@taofledermaus Tactidrive was the best

[@robmanueb.]

Love to see an updated wax slug test.

[@ronin47-ThorstenFrank]

That was funny right now - I just checked YT if I´ve missed a video from ou guys and after refreshing I saw the new upload. Thank you.

[@Gregc63]

2 of my favorite rounds you've tested! The Gatekeeper has to be the most devastating round you've ever tested! Thanks for the years of great videos!

[@taofledermaus]

thanks Greg

[@pepepantuflas1]

Just scrolling online for a 9mm repeating rifle when I get a notification for this.

[@taofledermaus]

Don't buy the Chiappa M1-9

[@kiljoysvnzr0]

Excellent and entertaining video and didn't have to go out in the Central Valley heat. I am all for you doing another video where you compare, contrast and review similar slug types and their relative effectiveness. Perhaps you could do a "worst of the worst".

[@Jeff.78]

Just name them as "dishonorable mention".

[@JunkyardBashSteve]

My favorite slug hast to be that brass knob. Seeing it blow clean through the lead plate literally made my jaw drop.

[@jonathanboerema2872]

Thanks for showing me something else, I can't live without.

[@N3219T]

As you probably know, I love that Gatekeeper slug. But the Twister? WOW!!! Totally devastated that pork shoulder.

[@randallthomas5207]

When evaluating rounds for home defense, it might be helpful to test it on a mocked up drywall and 2X4 wall section.

[@keithjurena9319]

Very few rounds are stopped by 2 sheets of dry wall. Always be sure of what is behind the target. That being said, most slug rounds will completely penetrate solid body shots.

[@taofledermaus]

Relying on chalk and paper to stop a slug is no substitute for marksmanship

[@ScottKenny1978]

The "box of truth" uses a whole series of drywall all separated by 2*4s. It's a pretty easy thing to put together.

[@mckenziekeith7434]

@@ScottKenny1978 I am pretty sure that there is no round that will stop a bad guy, but won't go through a sheetrock (aka drywall or gypsum board) interior wall.

[@ScottKenny1978]

@@mckenziekeith7434 right. But it might only go through 4 layers of sheetrock (Hornady Critical Defense 5.56, iirc), which means it will go through 2 inner walls and stop. I'd really like to see what the Gatekeeper slug does versus drywall. I expect it will blow through a lot of sheets, even if it does fully expand just from the drywall.

[@donaldslayton2769]

Been waiting for another video. Thanks Jeff and co

[@kawaiiarchive357]

I work as a mechanic and you can melt down lead tire weights to use for fishing. I would imagine you could apply the same to custom shotgun slugs.

[@mattkissmyasstyrants8676]

Absolutely.. many do. Wheel weights are actually harder than pure lead because of the antimony. They make what most refer to as Hard Cast bullets.

[@psykoklown874]

The Twisters in this video were made out of range scrap that was around 8 bhn. I forgot to add that they were originally powder coated and air cooled.

[@nikihealey5571]

Very interesting how the white gas seal sparked on impact. My best guess, If the impact force is high enough and enough heat/high pressure is created just about anything can combust. In this case it was a detonation with air and the gasses of the plastic seal (or the sill putty) created on impact. Thanks for another great video 👍

[@nikihealey5571]

Revision; A similar way for materials to combust in a Diesel engine

[@jonnyblade3234]

Would love to see how the plastisol gel blocks would react to these slugs

[@WeaponsEducation]

I have purchased 50 shells of the Gatekeeper after your first video. They are in my FN SLP, my SLP holds 8plus1. Now extinct. I told everyone the SLP would go extinct and it did.

[@oigliyj]

Nothing like seeing you guys expand some cavities in slow motion

[@nicholasmelzian3908]

Pause..

[@MassimoTava]

They have a only fans?

[@singleshot2218]

Very effective rounds. Lots of energy being unleashed in different media, so great home defense rounds. I cast my own, so they don’t cost so much. Take care and stay safe! God bless! 🙏🎚🇲🇾🇲🇾🇲🇾

[@pr0gram392]

That energy dump tho

[@bobjordan8283]

I always love your content very clear explanation of what you are doing and what goes right and what goes wrong without apologizing for not so perfect results! This one was a treat to see great job!!

[@aaronfrotten]

Thanks guys I always appreciate your content Been watching for years

[@taofledermaus]

thanks Aaron

[@salexxavier]

The Gatekeeper is, without doubt, the most impressive slug for home defense that I have ever seen. Directly after seeing your first video about them, I ordered them. I now have several boxes of them, and after testing them myself, I can state that what you guys show, is exactly what I have seen personally. The Gatekeeper is all I'll ever load in my bedside buddy, she's "The thing that goes BOOM! in the night!". No overpenetration. Insane level of stopping power. Seriously good home defense, and they are worth every penny - I just wish they were MORE available for everyone.

[@deadmanwalken7690]

Great video guys. Your Slomo videos are some of the best on KZbin. A lot of the other channels are just now using high speed cameras so you are way ahead of the game. Keep up the good work.

[@kixeusvent]

I don’t know about you, but I don’t want a home defense round that splatters the intruder across my entire house…

[@DUKWAK]

The Gatekeeper was my all time favorite. Thanks for the video!

[@jeffw1246]

Great news, going to check out those Twisters.

[@TheRealNessie]

Ive been looking for a new vid for days.. Im excited.

[@scrappydoo7887]

I love this channel. Excellent content, a friendly community and no invasive irrelevant ads or agendas. Excellent work as always 👍

[@taofledermaus]

thanks

[@bobiojimbo]

WHOA! The violent reaction of the ballistic gel when struck by that twister round...

[@greenbudkelly2820]

That Gatekeeper is "Wicked Pissah" as we say around here. Just fantastic. Anyone else think the segments are cut with a water jet?

[@clairecelestin8437]

I was always impressed by the Double Donut, specifically the little gummy worm that got cookie-cutter'd out of the gummy bear. That would have left a permanent cavity that would have drained out in seconds.

[@taofledermaus]

lol

[@SuperBadVideos]

Awesome video as usual guys 👍🏻🔥🤘🏻

[@Greeev]

I found the "gatekeeper" slugs for sale! Not loaded ammo, the slugs themselves, for $2.43/ea. They're produced by a company called "Maker Bullets" under the name "Rex". Although according to their website they are 435gr and not 460gr, I'm assuming the 435gr is without the gas seal/tail piece.

[@m17glock35]

Maker bullets has been waiting months for back ordered copper stock to come in for making these , some of it is just now starting to come in so they should have some ready very soon .

[@ckl9390]

When I checked their website (at least the one that googlebox led me to) the browser said it was broken. (Edit: I just remembered that it wasn't Maker's website that was broken, it was ARM's) Do you have a link to the website that worked for you? I would actually be trying to buy just the slugs because of import/export issues that may arise through an individual attempting to ship ammunition internationally. Just importing the copper projectile and loading on my end may be more feasible. On a side note, it may help that this one has a more neutral name "Rex" instead of "Gatekeeper", as something intended for "self defence" may have import issues. On the other hand I'm looking at these as an anti-bear round, or for other dangerous game, and having a neutral name or one that reflects being used for hunting or livestock protection would help at the border. Edit: I tried looking up the name and it led to their T-Rex line. Additional Edit: I found it. I'll drop their SKU for the product to make finding it easier 12ga-435gr-REX-SLUG all one word.

[@Leverguns50]

This is gonna be a whole lot of fun

[@alexdejong7569]

Stay cool out there Jeff! I remember both those slug tests and they were both crazy

[@eugeneallshouse5884]

My favorite is still the gate keeper..its a brutal slog n accurate...so far nothing compares..great video..thanks

[@RustyorBroken]

Are you the gate keeper? I am the key master.

[@SaltyNationalist]

HAVE MEEEERCY!!! THE WOUND TRACK ON BOTH WERE IMPRESSIVE... BUT THE 5 BUCK A ROUND SLUG?? HOLY JEEBUS!!😱😱 THAT WOULD PUT AN INTRUDER INTO AT LEAST TWO DIFFERENT AREA CODES..🤣🤣🤣🤣 Nice find Jeff..

[@StONEDiLESO]

I loved the contdnt. Id love to see some older stuff revisited. Like wax slugs, sabots slugs in smooth bore comparisons and other cool stuff

[@taofledermaus]

thanks!

[@middleagedbaldguy6774]

I've always wanted a shotgun slug that drops a hog and cleans it at the same time.

[@ViperX2SGaming]

Reminds me of the .357 defender, always thought that one was crazy

[@taofledermaus]

That is definitely a no-gimmick slug too. Not cheap but it's going wreck what it hits.

[@steveshoemaker6347]

Those Slug are truly AWESOME.....l remember these video's....But it is amazing to see them again Thanks Jeff.....Shoe🇺🇸

[@sandracreeth6510]

That video was really enjoyable,i love watching your videos

[@taofledermaus]

thanks Sandra

[@Erinnem]

Hey guys I’ve watched your videos for years they have all been great!!!!!!

[@taofledermaus]

thanks Erin

[@DT7967]

Thanks for the Goodell info. Just ordered two different types. Shipping was fair as well! American Reloading his 12 gauge hulls and free shipping but seems you'll have to order larger quantities but they also have lots of reloading items and ammo as well for pretty good prices

[@gtnaylor5870]

That was, like always, very interesting and informative. The Gatekeeper is awesome! I agree, if Jurassic Park ever needs shotgun loads, that's it.

[@shauncunningham2232]

Awesome videos, I think it's awesome that you give shout outs and give a basic walk thru on your loading process and logic. Couple questions for you if you have the time. 1. What is the best shape for penetration? 2. What is your preferred material (lead copper brass composite cast)?

[@jacoblaw23]

Maker makes some phenomenal projectiles. I use maker Rex sub sonics in my 300blk and they’re some devastating rds

[@taofledermaus]

They seem to make good stuff.

[@rayhall3010]

Thank you guys for so much information on ammo, for us the people that don't want to kill unless needed, retired military vet ,,

[@oaktreejw]

That was an awesome recap video. Perhaps you could do a revisit and compare these two great slugs head to head?

[@Aidan-fw1xr]

I know you usually only do shotgun ammo demos. However, by going through ARMs store I found that they make 9mm GATEKEEPER rounds. And I’m genuinely intrigued. Would it be too much to ask for a demo of other such ammo? Also, huge fan of this awesome channel and watching all the carnage just because.

[@taofledermaus]

I've been talking with Maker Bullets who is eager to promote their new stuff with us. ARM just loads other companies ammo .

[@86steelrain]

The energy transfer of that last round was insane, I thought the block was going to rip itself apart

[@crazynok5511]

I love this channel and those rounds .

[@taofledermaus]

thanks!

[@Smallathe]

Very Very cool Comparison. A super fun video! It's super hot in IL as well... burning hot. Looking forward to see these new slugs - they sure do look awesome.

[@taofledermaus]

Thanks Saar. I'm ready for winter for sure.

[@seanfoltz7645]

Good as I'm interested in seeing that odd spherical one in action. I got lucky and scored two boxes of the Gatekeeper shells as I've got a mag fed shotgun that holds 9+1. Yes, they're more expensive, but if I need more than those ten over the course of my lifetime, or in light of how lethal they are, even if I need all ten, well I figure the situation is above my paygrade anyway. For the Russian slug, my next firearm purchase is going to be one of those black powder Diablo shotgun pistols so I'll actually be investing in getting one of those molds so I can cast as many as I like - figure I might as well target shoot with what I'll be hunting with.

[@amphibiousone7972]

Great Video Guys THANKS 😊

[@paulessdot2]

WOW!! 😳 That gatekeeper slug is diabolical, fkkn love it 👌

[@ulfhedtyrsson]

Oddly enough, "Pork Explosion" was the name of my rural Alabama Baptist Square Dance Extreme Melodic Death Electrona band in the early 2000s...

[@michellewilt4479]

I remember both videos and they were definitely the most impressive slugs I've ever seen except for maybe the big 2 oz train wreck slug that Breanna handled better than anyone else. Since seeing the videos, I've been trying to find them (as money allows) to test for myself, but didn't know the company names. Thank you for giving them a shout out so that we can more easily find them when they're available.

[@MrRednhot]

I like that you say it is for home defense.... One thing is for sure that perpetrator is never ever coming back, if you put one to the chest. WOW

[@timmarbell255]

That twister is the best I have seen yet!

[@smileupondeath]

I was literally just wondering what the best slug you fired was earlier this afternoon 😂🤣😂…. Great video.. keep up the good work!

[@taofledermaus]

Thanks 👍

[@BenjySparky]

Jeff and OG y'all rock! Love the channel and content! I'm here for the algorithm! Peace

[@patrickw9520]

For the heat, a few canopies for shade, some misters, and a couple drums of water with a 12v dc pump. Y'all dont get humid like the south, so the mist actually provides good cooling. Use the finest atomizing sprayers, and you wont even feel the moisture in mid 20s% RH

[@adamspencer3620]

As always gentlemen,fantastic video

[@taofledermaus]

Glad you enjoyed it

[@christurley391]

Thanks for the video.

[@445supermag]

So its come to this, a clip show... Still watched and enjoyed the extra background info.

[@pastorlarry7470]

Awesome! All I can say is WOW! Just think being shot with one of those. It would shoot a leg or arm off. Or blow a body part out. On the guy that makes just the slug, there was one shaped like a ball. Have you guys shot it? Thanks for the video

[@taofledermaus]

I just got all those slugs in and will be shooting them all. Just could not get anything arranged to shoot this weekend.

[@pastorlarry7470]

@@taofledermaus thanks

[@eric81872]

Thank you for the video! ☺♥

[@petertimp5416]

For someone who has never shot a gun or makes their own ammunition…I find your work to Be very interesting and enjoyable, thanks.

[@taofledermaus]

Thank you. If you ever get a chance, try it!

[@wilsonrawlin8547]

Outstanding video and details. Gatekeeper is incredible performance and a true GUT BLASTER!! The clean up after the shot would be insane. The twister is on par IMO. Especially being available and able to create the ideal load for your defense or hunting needs. Watched again and see that the Twister is the one that exploded the pork shoulder thingy. IMO the twister slowed down just a little for HD is optimal due to fragmentation/energy dump/availability and you can load your own velocities.

[@TheGeekiestGuy]

Watching that ballistic gel dance is always a good time. I have a buddy that pours a lot of lead for fishing and I'm gonna show him that copper/brass ceramic coating. We might be able to trade off some work in exchange. Thanks for showing everything. Good luck on the heat. I hope you guys are doing well. Stay cool. 🤙🏾

[@taofledermaus]

See if he will pour you some slugs!

[@TheGeekiestGuy]

@@taofledermaus I taught him how to make silicone molds a few years back. I'll have to get my hands on a slug mold or two and I bet we can come up with something. I honestly appreciate the inspiration. It's been awhile since I felt compelled to do something new. Thanks, brother. 🤙🏾

[@PaulCarm]

Those are two wicked looking rounds.

[@guardianminifarm8005]

Great stuff. Thanks so much. Excited to know where to buy slugs for handloads.

[@taofledermaus]

It's going to be a good place. His selection is getting bigger by the day.

[@guardianminifarm8005]

@@taofledermaus Thank you again. Appreciate all the thought, time, energy & resources invested.

[@richarddixon7276]

Sorry I'm late , but glad I got here eventually . A bit of a change this but brilliant as always , Thanks Guys. Shoot Straight Stay Safe & Stay Well .

[@robertmullally8781]

Why have no major ammo manufacturer bought the rights to these? These would go like crazy. Hunting, where you cant use lead. Home defense... The next test I would like to see is accuracy out to 100 yards with a smooth bore and a fully rifled barrel. Great vid. guys.

[@markroper9269]

Good stuff!!

[@dennismain3228]

Ballistic jelly show what a slug does to a body...the best family defender. Thank you guys for help me maintain may sanity

[@taofledermaus]

Glad to help

[@davidrdanner4232]

Good video Jeff 👍

[@robinpage2730]

Please bring back the extreme penetrator shotgun slug. Those were awesome too! Is love to see a comparison between the Gatekeeper and the Extreme Penetrator slugs

[@Followme556]

The Russian Philips screwdriver slugs are by far the most impressive ones I've seen on this site.

[@kevinrivera1492]

Can't wait for the end of year wrap up with super odd fun things

[@taylorhickman84]

Just imagine the cleanup required after using one of those for home defense.

[@user-bt5gu3pe3d]

Bullet of Prince Shirinsky - Shikhmatov. Invented more than 100 years ago for bear hunting

[@l.a.3887]

Good video great slugs

[@demantoid418]

Sweet Thanks fellas

[@jeep_freek1640]

I've shot the Makers before. Still have a few boxes. Paul the owner of Maker is a cool guy. From what I was told Paul sells these to Texas law enforcement agencies. They were called T-Rex when we tested them with him. Very good for home defence.

[@jeep_freek1640]

He also made them in pistol and rifle calibers too.

[@COIcultist]

Pork Explosion, that had to be one of Greg's bands names?